'Signature sets', minimal fragment sets for identifying protein disulfide structures with cyanylation-based mass mapping methodology

Our cyanylation (CN)-based methodology for determining disulfide structure of cystinyl proteins overcomes the limitations of conventional proteolytic methods. However, the CN-based method has the potential drawback that occasionally some CN-induced cleavage fragments may not be detected. We show that CN-based methods can overcome the failure to detect fragments by demonstrating the existence of small 'signature sets' of fragments. The link between signature sets and the robustness of CN-based methodology is validated by two case studies.     

Probing the folding pathways of long R(3) insulin-like growth factor-I (LR(3)IGF-I) and IGF-I via capture and identification of disulfide intermediates by cyanylation methodology and mass spectrometry

This report describes an integrated investigation of the refolding and reductive unfolding of insulin-like growth factor (IGF-I) and its variant, long R(3) IGF-I (LR(3)IGF-I), which has a Glu(3) to Arg(3) substitution and a hydrophobic 13-amino acid N-terminal extension. The refolding performed in glutathione redox buffer was quenched at different time points by adjusting the pH to 2.0-3.0 with a 1 N HCl solution of 1-cyano-4-dimethylaminopyridinium tetrafluoroborate, which trapped intermediates via cyanylation of free sulfhydryl groups. The disulfide structure of the intermediates was determined by chemical cleavage followed by mass mapping with mass spectrometry. Six refolding intermediates of IGF-I and three refolding intermediates of LR(3)IGF-I were isolated and characterized. Folding pathways of IGF-I and LR(3)IGF-I are proposed based on the time-dependent distribution and disulfide structure of the corresponding trapped intermediates. Similarities and differences in the refolding behavior of IGF-I and LR(3)IGF-I are discussed.     

Disulfide exchange folding of insulin-like growth factor I.

The disulfide exchange folding properties of insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) have been analyzed in a redox buffer containing reduced (10 mM) and oxidized (1 mM) glutathione. Under these conditions, the 3 disulfide bridges of the 70 amino acid peptide were not quantitatively formed. Instead, five major forms of IGF-I were detected, and these components were concluded to be in equilibrium as their relative amounts were similar starting from either reduced, native, or a mismatched variant of IGF-I containing two non-native disulfides. The different components in the mixtures were trapped by thiol alkylation using vinylpyridine and subsequently isolated by reverse-phase HPLC. The purified variants were further characterized using plasma desorption mass spectrometry and peptide mapping. Two of the five different forms were identified as native and mismatched IGF-I. One form was a variant with only one disulfide bond, and the other two major components had two disulfides formed. In a separate experiment, early refolding intermediates were trapped by pyridylethylation after only 90 s of refolding in the glutathione buffer, starting from reduced IGF-I. The intermediates were identical to the components observed at equilibrium, but at different relative concentrations. On the basis of the disulfide bond patterns of the different components in the equilibrium mixtures, we conclude that the disulfide between cysteines-47 and -52 in IGF-I is an unfavorable high-energy bond that may exist in the native molecule in a strained configuration.     

Trapping of intermediates during the refolding of recombinant human epidermal growth factor (hEGF) by cyanylation, and subsequent structural elucidation by mass spectrometry.

Human epidermal growth factor (hEGF) contains 53 amino acids and three disulfide bonds. The unfolded, reduced hEGF is allowed to refold under mildly alkaline conditions. The folding is quenched at different time points by adjusting the pH to 3.0 with an acetic acid solution of 1-cyano-4-dimethylamino-pyridinium (CDAP) which traps folding intermediates via cyanylation of free sulfhydryl groups. The mixture of cyanylated intermediates is separated by reversed-phase HPLC; the fractions collected are identified by mass spectrometry. The disulfide structures of the intermediates are then determined by specific chemical cleavage and mass-mapping by MALDI-MS, a novel approach developed in our laboratory. The procedure of quenching and trapping of disulfide intermediates in acidic solution minimizes sulfhydryl-disulfide exchange, and therefore provides a good measure of folding kinetics and preservation of intermediate species. Our cyanylation methodology for disulfide mapping is simpler, faster, and more sensitive than the more conventional approach. Among 18 folding intermediates isolated and identified at different time points, disulfide structures of seven well-populated intermediates, including two non-native isomers with scrambled disulfide structures, one 2-disulfide intermediate, and four 1-disulfide intermediates, have been characterized; most of them possess non-native disulfide structures.     

Direct identification of disulfide bond linkages in human insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) by chemical synthesis

The primary structure of human IGF-I, except for the disulfide bond system, has been reported by Rinderknecht and Humbel. IGF-I afforded the corresponding characteristic peptide fragment on V8 protease digestion, which contained Cys6, Cys47, Cys48, and Cys52. Two possible fragments, Type I with Cys6-Cys47 and Cys48-Cys52, and Type II with Cys6-Cys48 and Cys47-Cys52, were synthesized. The disulfide bond system of IGF-I was unequivocally determined to be the Type II form along with Cys18-Cys61. Interestingly, the Type I system was included in the disulfide bond isomer produced as the main by-product in the refolding step on IGF-I synthesis by the recombinant DNA method.     

Algorithm-assisted elucidation of disulfide structure: application of the negative signature mass algorithm to mass-mapping the disulfide structure of the 12-cysteine transforming growth factor beta type II receptor extracellular domain

The power of an algorithm-driven method for interpreting disulfide mass-mapping data is demonstrated in the context of determining the disulfide structure of the extracellular domain of the transforming growth factor beta type II receptor, a 14-kDa cystinyl protein containing 12 cysteines in the form of six disulfide bonds. The disulfide mass-mapping methodology is based on partial reduction and cyanylation-induced cleavage of the cystinyl protein. Because the multiplicity of possible disulfide structures that must be considered grows rapidly with the number of cysteines, as does the difficulty in physically isolating each of the partially reduced and cyanylated isoforms of the analyte, manual data interpretation for disulfide mapping a cystinyl protein containing more than eight cysteines becomes unmanageable. Recently, we introduced the concept of a "negative signature mass algorithm" (NSMA) to determine the disulfide structure of a cystinyl protein by processing an input of its amino acid sequence and mass spectral data from analysis of its associated cyanylation-induced cleavage products. Here, we present experimental results to validate the NSMA concept. A key advantage of the NSMA, in addition to convenience and automation, is its capacity to interpret mass spectra from mixtures of cyanylation-induced cleavage fragments without separating the partially reduced isoforms of the cystinyl protein and without knowledge of the extent of partial reduction.     

A major kinetic trap for the oxidative folding of human epidermal growth factor

The folding pathway of human epidermal growth factor (EGF) has been characterized by structural and kinetic analysis of the acid-trapped folding intermediates. Oxidative folding of the fully reduced EGF proceeds through 1-disulfide intermediates and accumulates rapidly as a single stable 2-disulfide intermediate (designated as EGF-II), which represents up to more than 85% of the total protein along the folding pathway. Among the five 1-disulfide intermediates that have been structurally characterized, only one is native, and nearly all of them are bridges by neighboring cysteines. Extensive accumulation of EGF-II indicates that it accounts for the major kinetic trap of EGF folding. EGF-II contains two of the three native disulfide bonds of EGF, Cys(14)-Cys(31) and Cys(33)-Cys(42). However, formation of the third native disulfide (Cys(6)-Cys(20)) for EGF-II is slow and does not occur directly. Kinetic analysis reveals that an important route for EGF-II to reach the native structure is via rearrangement pathway through 3-disulfide scrambled isomers. The pathway of EGF-II to attain the native structure differs from that of three major 2-disulfide intermediates of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI). The dissimilarities of folding mechanism(s) between EGF, BPTI, and hirudin are discussed in this paper.     

Disulfide folding pathways of cystine knot proteins. Tying the knot within the circular backbone of the cyclotides

The plant cyclotides are a fascinating family of circular proteins that contain a cyclic cystine knot motif. The knotted topology and cyclic nature of the cyclotides pose interesting questions about folding mechanisms and how the knotted arrangement of disulfide bonds is formed. In the current study we have examined the oxidative refolding and reductive unfolding of the prototypic cyclotide, kalata B1. A stable two-disulfide intermediate accumulated during oxidative refolding but not in reductive unfolding. Mass spectrometry and NMR spectroscopy were used to show that the intermediate contained a native-like structure with two native disulfide bonds topologically similar to the intermediate isolated for the related cystine knot protein EETI-II (Le-Nguyen, D., Heitz, A., Chiche, L., El Hajji, M., and Castro B. (1993) Protein Sci. 2, 165-174). However, the folding intermediate observed for kalata B1 is not the immediate precursor of the three-disulfide native peptide and does not accumulate in the reductive unfolding process, in contrast to the intermediate observed for EETI-II. These alternative pathways of linear and cyclic cystine knot proteins appear to be related to the constraints imposed by the cyclic backbone of kalata B1 and the different ring size of the cystine knot. The three-dimensional structure of a synthetic version of the two-disulfide intermediate of kalata B1 in which Ala residues replace the reduced Cys residues provides a structural insight into why the two-disulfide intermediate is a kinetic trap on the folding pathway.     

The folding of hirudin adopts a mechanism of trial and error.

Reduced and denatured hirudin (65 amino acids and 3 disulfides) refolds in vitro to become an active molecule. The folding process adopts a mechanism of "trial and error" without predominant pathways. Throughout the entire folding process, the 6 cysteines were about equally involved in the disulfide shuffling. Among the first 20% of 3-disulfide species accumulated during the early phase of refolding, two-thirds were inactive and were reshuffled in the presence of thiol catalyst to regain correct disulfide pairing. When refolding was performed in the presence of strong denaturant (guanidinium chloride) without thiol catalyst, 8% of the active hirudin was obtained. This figure is close to the probability (6.7%) that would be expected from the random disulfide pairing of a molecule containing 6 sulfhydryl groups.     

Pulsed hydrogen exchange and electrospray charge-state distribution as complementary probes of protein structure in kinetic experiments: implications for ubiquitin folding

The possible involvement of "hidden" kinetic intermediates in the apparent two-state folding of some proteins is currently a matter of debate. This study uses time-resolved electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry with on-line pulsed hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) for monitoring the refolding of acid/methanol-denatured ubiquitin. It is demonstrated that the ESI charge-state distribution (CSD) and the extent of HDX represent nonredundant probes of the protein structure in solution. When considered in isolation, the data provided by both of these probes are consistent with a two-state behavior, involving only denatured ubiquitin D and refolded protein F. However, a careful comparison of the CSD and HDX kinetics reveals the presence of an additional species, exhibiting a CSD like the folded protein but showing non-native HDX characteristics. This kinetic intermediate, D*, is in rapid equilibrium with D, such that the overall reaction is consistent with the mechanism D <--> D* --> F. The results of this work suggest that the occurrence of transient intermediates may be more widespread than commonly thought, especially in cases where a cursory analysis indicates two-state behavior.     

Putative disulfide-forming pathway of porcine insulin precursor during its refolding in vitro

Although the structure of insulin has been well studied, the formation pathway of the three disulfide bridges during the refolding of insulin precursor is ambiguous. Here, we reported the in vitro disulfide-forming pathway of a recombinant porcine insulin precursor (PIP). In redox buffer containing L-arginine, the yield of native PIP from fully reduced/denatured PIP can reach 85%. The refolding process was quenched at different time points, and three distinct intermediates, including one with one disulfide linkage and two with two disulfide bridges, have been captured and characterized. An intra-A disulfide bridge was found in the former but not in the latter. The two intermediates with two disulfide bridges contain the common A20-B19 disulfide linkage and another inter-AB one. Based on the time-dependent formation and distribution of disulfide pairs in the trapped intermediates, two different forming pathways of disulfide bonds in the refolding process of PIP in vitro have been proposed. The first one involves the rapid formation of the intra-A disulfide bond, followed by the slower formation of one of the inter-AB disulfide bonds and then the pairing of the remaining cysteines to complete the refolding of PIP. The second pathway begins first with the formation of the A20-B19 disulfide bridge, followed immediately by another inter-AB one, possibly nonnative. The nonnative two-disulfide intermediates may then slowly rearrange between CysA6, CysA7, CysA11, and CysB7, until the native disulfide bond A6-A11 or A7-B7 is formed to complete the refolding of PIP. The proposed refolding behavior of PIP is compared with that of IGF-I and discussed.     

Contribution of the 6-120 disulfide bond of alpha-lactalbumin to the stabilities of its native and molten globule states.

The unfolding and refolding of a derivative of alpha-lactalbumin, in which the disulfide bond between Cys6 and Cys120 is selectively reduced and S-carboxymethylated, are investigated by equilibrium and kinetic circular dichroism measurements. The native conformation of this derivative is known to be essentially identical to that of intact alpha-lactalbumin. The equilibrium unfolding of the derivative involves a stable intermediate, which is also similar to the molten globule state of the disulfide intact protein. The results of stopped-flow circular dichroism experiments show that the same intermediate is formed rapidly as a transient intermediate in kinetic refolding. The conformational stabilities for the native and intermediate states have been estimated and compared with the stabilities for the corresponding states of intact alpha-lactalbumin. The stabilization of the native state by the disulfide has been interpreted in terms of a decrease in chain entropy in the unfolded state and elimination of the strain imposed on the disulfide bond in the native state. The molten globule state is also stabilized by the disulfide bond, although the degree of stabilization of the molten globule state is smaller than of the native state. The results suggest that, in the molten globule state, some ordered structures are present within the loop moiety formed by the 6-120 disulfide.     

Partially Unfolded Forms of the Prion Protein Populated under Misfolding-promoting Conditions: CHARACTERIZATION BY HYDROGEN EXCHANGE MASS SPECTROMETRY AND NMR*

The susceptibility of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) to convert to an alternative misfolded conformation (PrP^Sc), which is the key event in the pathogenesis of prion diseases, is indicative of a conformationally flexible native (N) state. In the present study, hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) in conjunction with mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy were used for the structural and energetic characterization of the N state of the full-length mouse prion protein, moPrP(23–231), under conditions that favor misfolding. The kinetics of HDX of 34 backbone amide hydrogens in the N state were determined at pH 4. In contrast to the results of previous HDX studies on the human and Syrian hamster prion proteins at a higher pH, various segments of moPrP were found to undergo different extents of subglobal unfolding events at pH 4, a pH at which the protein is known to be primed to misfold to a β-rich conformation. No residual structure around the disulfide bond was observed for the unfolded state at pH 4. The N state of the prion protein was observed to be at equilibrium with at least two partially unfolded forms (PUFs). These PUFs, which are accessed by stochastic fluctuations of the N state, have altered surface area exposure relative to the N state. One of these PUFs resembles a conformation previously implicated to be an initial intermediate in the conversion of monomeric protein into misfolded oligomer at pH 4.     

Accessing the reproducibility and specificity of pepsin and other aspartic proteases

The aspartic protease pepsin is less specific than other endoproteinases. Because aspartic proteases like pepsin are active at low pH, they are utilized in hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX MS) experiments for digestion under hydrogen exchange quench conditions. We investigated the reproducibility, both qualitatively and quantitatively, of online and offline pepsin digestion to understand the compliment of reproducible pepsin fragments that can be expected during a typical pepsin digestion. The collection of reproducible peptides was identified from > 30 replicate digestions of the same protein and it was found that the number of reproducible peptides produced during pepsin digestion becomes constant above 5–6 replicate digestions. We also investigated a new aspartic protease from the stomach of the rice field eel (Monopterus albus Zuiew) and compared digestion efficiency and specificity to porcine pepsin and aspergillopepsin. Unique cleavage specificity was found for rice field eel pepsin at arginine, asparagine, and glycine. Different peptides produced by the various proteases can enhance protein sequence coverage and improve the spatial resolution of HDX MS data. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Mass spectrometry in structural biology.     

Intracellular folding pathway of the cystine knot-containing glycoprotein hormone alpha-subunit

Three of the five disulfide bonds in the glycoprotein hormone alpha-subunit (GPH-alpha) form a cystine knot motif that stabilizes a three-loop antiparallel structure. Previously, we described a mutant (alpha(k)) that contained only the three knot disulfide bonds and demonstrated that the cystine knot was necessary and sufficient for efficient GPH-alpha folding and secretion. In this study, we used alpha(k) as a model to study the intracellular GPH-alpha folding pathway. Cystine knot formation proceeded through a 1-disulfide intermediate that contained the 28-82 disulfide bond. Formation of disulfide bond 10-60, then disulfide bond 32-84, followed the formation of 28-82. Whether the two non-cystine knot bonds 7-31 and 59-87 could form independent of the knot was also tested. Disulfide bond 7-31 formed rapidly, whereas 59-87 did not form when all cysteine residues of the cystine knot were converted to alanine, suggesting that 7-31 forms early in the folding pathway and that 59-87 forms during or after cystine knot formation. Finally, loop 2 of GPH-alpha has been shown to be very flexible, suggesting that loop 2 does not actively drive GPH-alpha folding. To test this, we replaced residues 36-55 in the flexible loop 2 with an artificially flexible glycine chain. Consistent with our hypothesis, folding and secretion were unaffected when loop 2 was replaced with the glycine chain. Based on these findings, we describe a model for the intracellular folding pathway of GPH-alpha and discuss how these findings may provide insight into the folding mechanisms of other cystine knot-containing proteins.     

Fully oxidized scrambled isomers are essential and predominant folding intermediates of cardiotoxin-III

Scrambled isomers (X-isomers) are fully oxidized, non-native isomers of disulfide proteins. They have been shown to represent important intermediates along the pathway of oxidative folding of numerous disulfide proteins. A simple method to assess whether X-isomers present as folding intermediate is to conduct oxidative folding of fully reduced protein in the alkaline buffer alone without any supplementing thiol catalyst or redox agent. Cardiotoxin-III (CTX-III) contains 60 amino acids and four disulfide bonds. The mechanism of oxidative folding of CTX-III has been systematically characterized here by analysis of the acid trapped folding intermediates. Folding of CTX-III was shown to proceed sequentially through 1-disulfide, 2-disulfide, 3-disulfide and 4-disulfide (scrambled) isomers as folding intermediates to reach the native structure. When folding of CTX-III was performed in the buffer alone, more than 97% of the protein was trapped as 4-disulfide X-isomers, unable to convert to the native structure due to the absence of thiol catalyst. In the presence of thiol catalyst (GSH) or redox agents (GSH/GSSG), the recovery of native CTX-III was 80-85%. These results demonstrate that X-isomers play an essential and predominant role in the oxidative folding of CTX-III.     

Quantitative evaluation of refolding conditions for a disulfide-bond-containing protein using a concise ¹⁸O-labeling technique

A concise method was developed for quantifying native disulfide‐bond formation in proteins using isotopically labeled internal standards, which were easily prepared with proteolytic ¹⁸O‐labeling. As the method has much higher throughput to estimate the amounts of fragments possessing native disulfide arrangements by matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry (MALDI‐TOF‐MS) than the conventional high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analyses, it allows many different experimental conditions to be assessed in a short time. The method was applied to refolding experiments of a recombinant neuregulin 1‐β1 EGF‐like motif (NRG1‐β1), and the optimum conditions for preparing native NRG1‐β1 were obtained by quantitative comparisons. Protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) was most effective at the reduced/oxidized glutathione ratio of 2:1 for refolding the denatured sample NRG1‐β1 with the native disulfide bonds.     

Early intermediates in the PDI-assisted folding of ribonuclease A

The oxidative refolding of ribonuclease A has been investigated in several experimental conditions using a variety of redox systems. All these studies agree that the formation of disulfide bonds during the process occurs through a nonrandom mechanism with a preferential coupling of certain cysteine residues. We have previously demonstrated that in the presence of glutathione the refolding process occurs through the reiteration of two sequential reactions: a mixed disulfide with glutathione is produced first which evolves to form an intramolecular S-S bond. In the same experimental conditions, protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) was shown to catalyze formation and reduction of mixed disulfides with glutathione as well as formation of intramolecular S-S bonds. This paper reports the structural characterization of the one-disulfide intermediate population during the oxidative refolding of Ribonuclease A under the presence of PDI and glutathione with the aim of defining the role of the enzyme at the early stages of the reaction. The one-disulfide intermediate population occurring at the early stages of both the uncatalyzed and the PDI-catalyzed refolding was purified and structurally characterized by proteolytic digestion followed by MALDI-MS and LC/ESIMS analyses. In the uncatalyzed refolding, a total of 12 disulfide bonds out of the 28 theoretical possible cysteine couplings was observed, confirming a nonrandom distribution of native and nonnative disulfide bonds. Under the presence of PDI, only two additional nonnative disulfides were detected. Semiquantitative LC/ESIMS analysis of the distribution of the S-S bridged peptides showed that the most abundant species were equally populated in both the uncatalyzed and the catalyzed process. This paper shows the first structural characterization of the one-disulfide intermediate population formed transiently during the refolding of ribonuclease A in quasi-physiological conditions that mimic those present in the ER lumen. At the early stages of the process, three of the four native disulfides are detected, whereas the Cys26-Cys84 pairing is absent. Most of the nonnative disulfide bonds identified are formed by nearest-neighboring cysteines. The presence of PDI does not significantly alter the distribution of S-S bonds, suggesting that the ensemble of single-disulfide species is formed under thermodynamic control.     

Determination of the disulfide bond pairings in human tissue factor pathway inhibitor purified fromEscherichia coli

The disulfide bond assignments of human alanyl tissue factor pathway inhibitor purified fromEscherichia coli have been determined. This inhibitor of the extrinsic blood coagulation pathway possesses three Kunitz-type inhibitor domains, each containing three disulfide bonds. The disulfide bond pairings in domains 1 and 3 were determined by amino acid sequencing and mass spectrometry of peptides derived from a thermolysin digest. However, thermolysin digestion did not cleave any peptide bonds within domain 2. The disulfide bond pairings in domain 2 were determined by isolating it from the thermolysin treatment and subsequently cleaving it with pepsin and trypsin into peptides which yielded the three disulfide bond pairings in this domain. These results demonstrate that the disulfide pairings in each of the three domains of human tissue factor pathway inhibitor purified fromEscherichia coli are homologous to each other and also to those in bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor.     

Oxidative folding of human lysozyme: effects of the loss of two disulfide bonds and the introduction of a calcium-binding site

Mutant human lysozymes (HLZ) lacking two disulfide bonds were constructed to study the importance of each disulfide bond on oxidative refolding. To avoid destabilization, a calcium-binding site was introduced. Five of the six species of two-disulfide mutants could be obtained with enzymatic activity. Based on the information obtained from refolding and unfolding experiments, the order of importance in oxidative refolding was found to be as follows: SS2(Cys30-Cys116) > SS1(Cys6-Cys128) SS3(Cys65-Cys81) > SS4(Cys77-Cys95). Without SS2, these mutants refolded with low efficiency or did not refold at all. The bond SS2 is located in the interface of B-and D-helices, and a small hydrophobic cluster is formed near SS2. This cluster may play an important role in the folding process and stabilization, and SS2 may act as a stabilizer through its polypeptide linkage. The bond SS2 is the most important disulfide bond for oxidative folding of lysozymes.