Interference with viral infection by RNA replicase deleted at the carboxy-terminal region

Escherichia coli cells harboring an altered Q beta RNA replicase which has amino acid substitutions of the glycine residue at position 357 in the conserved sequence Tyr356-Gly357-Asp358-Asp359 of the beta-subunit protein lost the replicase activity but interfered with proliferation of Q beta phage [Inokuchi and Hirashima (1987) J. Virol. 61, 3946-3949]. To examine the mechanism of the interference, we further analyzed various mutants lacking the carboxy-terminal region of the beta-subunit protein. The cells expressing the beta-subunit gene with up to 17% deletion from the carboxy-terminus of the protein prevented the proliferation of Q beta phage. However, in the case that the deletion extended beyond 25% from the carboxy-terminus, the cells showed no interference. In addition, when the interference took place, the phage coat protein synthesis was inhibited. These results indicate that the region between amino acids 440 and 487 of the beta-subunit protein is involved in the interference and suggest that the defective replicase inhibits the phage coat protein synthesis by competing with the ribosomes at the initiation site of the coat gene.     

Sequence of the viral replicase gene from foot-and-mouth disease virus C1-Santa Pau (C-S8)

The nucleotide sequence of the region including the viral replicase gene, the carboxy terminus of protein P18, and the 3'-extracistronic region of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) type C1-Santa Pau (C-S8) has been determined from previously cloned cDNA fragments [Villanueva et al., Gene 23 (1983) 185-194]. The comparison with the corresponding gene segments of FMDV of serotypes A or O shows base substitutions in 7.2-8.6% of residues in the replicase gene with no insertions or deletions. This is about fourfold lower variation than found for the region encoding capsid protein VP1 of the corresponding viruses. Intermediate variability (substitution at 16.1-23.6% positions) exists in the 3'-extracistronic region, including point mutations, insertions and deletions. The predicted amino acid sequence of the replicase gene indicates that 75.5-82.6% of mutations are silent and that 93.4% of amino acids are conserved in the four FMDV replicases. The frequency of certain types of silent mutations and of rare codon usage is significantly lower for the replicase gene than for the protein VP1 coding region.     

Q beta RNA bacteriophage: mapping cis-acting elements within an RNA genome

We have identified, for the first time, regions of cis-acting RNA elements within the bacteriophage Q beta replicase cistron by analyzing the infectivities of 76 replicase gene mutant phages in the presence of a helper replicase. Two separate classes of mutant Q beta phage genomes (35 different insertion mutants, each containing an insertion of 3 to 15 nucleotides within the replicase gene, and 41 deletion genomes, each having from 15 to 935 nucleotides deleted from different regions of the gene) were constructed, and their corresponding RNAs were tested for the ability to direct the formation of progeny virus particles. Each mutant phage was tested for plaque formation in an Escherichia coli (F+) host strain that supplied helper Q beta replicase in trans from a plasmid DNA. Of the 76 mutant genomes, 34% were able to direct virus production at or close to wild-type levels (with plaque yield ratios of greater than 0.5), another 36% also produced virus particles, but at much lower levels than those of wild-type virus (with plaque yield ratios of less than 0.05), and the remaining 30% produced no virus at all. From these data, we have been able to define regions within the Q beta replicase gene that contain functional cis-acting RNA elements and further correlate them with regions of RNA that are solely required to code for functional RNA polymerase.     

Reversion of Q beta RNA phage mutants by homologous RNA recombination.

Q beta phage RNAs with inactivating insertion (8-base) or deletion (17-base) mutations within their replicase genes were prepared from modified Q beta cDNAs and transfected into Escherichia coli spheroplasts containing Q beta replicase provided in trans by a resident plasmid. Replicase-defective (Rep-) Q beta phage produced by these spheroplasts were detected as normal-sized plaques on lawns of cells containing plasmid-derived Q beta replicase, but were unable to form plaques on cells lacking this plasmid. When individual Rep- phage were isolated and grown to high titer in cells containing plasmid-derived Q beta replicase, revertant (Rep+) Q beta phage were obtained at a frequency of ca. 10(-8). To investigate the mechanism of this reversion, a point mutation was placed into the plasmid-derived Q beta replicase gene by site-directed mutagenesis. Q beta mutants amplified on cells containing the resultant plasmid also yielded Rep+ revertants. Genomic RNA was isolated from several of the latter phage revertants and sequenced. Results showed that the original mutation (insertion or deletion) was no longer present in the phage revertants but that the marker mutation placed into the plasmid was now present in the genomic RNAs, indicating that recombination was one mechanism involved in the reversion of the Q beta mutants. Further experiments demonstrated that the 3' noncoding region of the plasmid-derived replicase gene was necessary for the reversion-recombination of the deletion mutant, whereas this region was not required for reversion or recombination of the insertion mutant. Results are discussed in terms of a template-switching model of RNA recombination involving Q beta replicase, the mutant phage genome, and plasmid-derived replicase mRNA.     

Secondary structure of coliphage Q beta RNA. Analysis by electron microscopy

The secondary structure of genomic RNA from the coliphage Q beta has been examined by electron microscopy in the presence of varying concentrations of spermidine using the Kleinschmidt spreading technique. The size and position of structural features that cover 70% of the viral genome have been mapped. The structural features that are visualized by electron microscopy in Q beta RNA are large. They range in size from 170 to 1600 nucleotides. A loop containing approximately 450 nucleotides is located at the 5' end of the RNA. It includes the initiation region for the viral maturation protein. A large hairpin containing approximately 1600 nucleotides is located in the center of the molecule. It is multibranched and includes most of the viral coat gene, the readthrough region of the A1 gene, and approximately one third of the viral replicase gene. Within the central hairpin, the initiation region for the viral replicase gene pairs with a region within the distal third of the viral coat gene. This structure may participate in the regulation of translational initiation of the viral replicase gene. Two structural variants of the central hairpin were observed. One of them brings the internal S and M viral replicase binding regions into juxtaposition. These observations suggest that the central hairpin may also participate in the regulation of translation of the viral coat gene. The secondary structures that are observed in Q beta RNA differ significantly from structures that we described previously in the genomic RNA of coliphage MS2 but are similar to structures we observed by electron microscopy in the related group B coliphage SP.     

Analysis of the complete nucleotide sequence of the group IV RNA coliphage SP.

We report the nucleotide sequence of the Group IV RNA bacteriophage SP. The entire sequence is 4276 nucleotides long. Four cistrons have been identified by comparison with the related Group III phage Q beta. The maturation protein contains 449 amino acids, the coat protein contains 131 amino acids, the read-through protein contains 330 amino acids and the replicase beta-subunit contains 575 amino acids. SP is 59 nucleotides longer than Q beta. We have analyzed both sequence and structural conservation between SP and Q beta and shown that the sequences for the coat and central region of the replicase are strongly conserved between the two genomes. We also show that the S and M replicase binding sites of Q beta are strongly conserved in SP. Interestingly, the base composition of SP and Q beta differ significantly from one another, and most of the differences can be accounted for by a strong preponderance of U in the third position of each codon of Q beta relative to SP. We also compare conserved hairpins associated with potential coat protein and replicase binding sites.     

Interference with viral infection by defective RNA replicase.

RNA-dependent RNA and DNA polymerases have a conserved segment, Tyr-X-Asp-Asp (G. Karmer and P. Argos, Nucleic Acids Res. 12:7269-7282, 1984). To investigate the function of this segment, we changed the Gly residue at position 357 in the conserved sequence Tyr-356-Gly-357-Asp-358-Asp-359 of the replicase of RNA coliphage Q beta to Ala, Ser, Pro, Met, or Val and examined the replicase activity in vivo. Cells carrying the variant plasmids lost the replicase activity and severely inhibited the proliferation of phage Q beta (group III) and related phage SP (group IV) by suppressing phage RNA synthesis. In contrast, substitution of the Gly residue at 390 showed only a slight inhibitory effect, although replicase activity was also lost. These results suggest that the cells harboring an altered replicase at the conserved segment can interfere specifically with the wild-type phage and different but related phage infections.     

Localization of the Q beta replicase recognition site in MDV-1 RNA

Fragments of MDV-1 RNA (a small, naturally occurring template for Q beta replicase) that were missing nucleotides at either their 5' end or their 3' end were still able to form a complex with Q beta replicase. By assaying the binding ability of fragments of different length, it was established that the binding site for Q beta replicase is determined by nucleotide sequences that are located near the middle of MDV-1 RNA. Fragments missing nucleotides at their 5' end were able to serve as templates for the synthesis of complementary strands, but fragments missing nucleotides at their 3' end were inactive, indicating that the 3'-terminal region of the template is required for the initiation of RNA synthesis. The nucleotide sequences of both the 3' terminus and the central binding region of MDV-1 (+) RNA are almost identical to sequences at the 3' terminus and at an internal region of Q beta (-) RNA.     

Structural consensus of RNA templates replicated by Q beta replicase.

Q beta replicase replicates a variety of enzyme-specific small RNAs in addition to the phage genomic RNA. The sequence analysis has revealed that all these RNAs are potentially capable of forming a consensus secondary structure element. It represents a stalk which is formed by the 5'-GGG ... and ... CCCA-3' complementary stretches at the termini of the replicating RNA molecules and adjacent 5'- and 3'-hairpins, which may form a stacking with the stalk. The structure found is rather similar to the analogous structure in the tRNA molecule. The genomic RNA of the Q beta phage and other related phages can also form a similar structural element.     

Mutational analysis of apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enzyme (APOBEC1). structure-function relationships of RNA editing and dimerization

APOBEC1 is the catalytic subunit of an enzyme complex that mediates apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA editing. It dimerizes in vitro and requires complementation factor(s) for its editing activity. We have performed a systematic analysis of the structure-functional relationship of APOBEC1 by targeted mutagenesis of various sequence motifs within the protein. Using in vitro RNA editing assay, we found that basic amino acid clusters at the amino-terminal region R15R16R17 and R33K34, are essential for apoB mRNA editing. Mutation of R15R16R17 to K15K16K17 and mutation of R33K34 simultaneously to A33A34 almost completely abolished in vitro editing activity. The carboxy-terminal region of APOBEC1 contains a leucine-rich motif. Deletion analysis of this region indicates that residues 181 to 210 are important for in vitro apoB mRNA editing. Single amino acid substitutions demonstrate that L182, I185, and L189 are important residues required for normal editing function. Furthermore, the double mutant P190A/P191A also lost >90% of editing activity which suggests that a beta turn in this region of the molecule may be essential for proper functioning of APOBEC1. It was suggested that dimerization of APOBEC1 creates an active structure for deamination of apoB mRNA. When we examined the dimerization potential of truncated APOBEC1s using both amino and carboxy termini deletion mutants, we found that amino-terminal deletions up to residue A117 did not impair dimerization activity whereas carboxy-terminal deletions showed diminished dimerization. The systematic and extensive mutagenesis experiments in this study provide information on the role of various sequence motifs identified in APOBEC1 in enzyme catalysis and dimerization.     

Accommodation of single amino acid insertions by the native state of staphylococcal nuclease

Single alanine and glycine insertions were introduced at 20 randomly selected positions in staphylococcal nuclease. The resulting changes in catalytic activity and in stability to guanidine hydrochloride denaturation indicate that the native state structure is frequently able to accommodate the extra residue without great difficulty, even insertions within secondary structural elements such as alpha helices and beta sheets. On average, an inserted residue reduces the free energy of denaturation (delta GH2O) by an amount roughly comparable to an alanine or glycine substitution for one of the residues flanking the site of insertion. Several positions outside of the enzyme active site were found where insertions, but not substitutions, lead to structural changes that modify catalytic activity and the circular dichroism spectrum. Amino acid insertions represent a virtually unexplored class of genetic mutation that may prove complementary to amino acid substitutions for engineering proteins with altered functional and structural properties.     

Autocatalytic replication of a recombinant RNA

We demonstrate that a heterologous RNA sequence can be copied in vitro by Q beta replicase when it is inserted into a naturally occurring Q beta replicase template. A recombinant RNA was constructed by inserting decaadenylic acid between nucleotides 63 and 64 of MDV-1 (+) RNA, using phage T4 RNA ligase. The insert was located away from regions of the template known to be required for the binding of the replicase and for the initiation of product strand synthesis. To minimize the disruption of template structure, we inserted the heterologous sequence into a hairpin loop on the exterior of the molecule. Q beta replicase copied this recombinant RNA in vitro, and the complementary product strands served as templates for the synthesis of additional copies of the original recombinant RNA. The reaction was therefore autocatalytic and the amount of recombinant RNA increased exponentially. A 300-fold amplification of the recombinant RNA occurred within nine minutes. Insertion of biologically significant RNAs into the MDV-1 RNA sequence should allow them to be replicated autocatalytically.     

Mutational analysis of the sequence and structural requirements in brome mosaic virus RNA for minus strand promoter activity

An RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (replicase) activity that specifically copies brome mosaic virus (BMV) RNAs in vitro can be prepared from BMV-infected barley leaves. The signals directing complementary (minus) strand synthesis reside within the 3' 134-nucleotide-long tRNA-like structure that is common to each of the virion RNAs. By studying the influence of minus strand synthesis of numerous mutations introduced throughout this region of the RNA, we have mapped in detail the sequence and structural elements necessary for minus strand promoter activity. Sequence alterations (either substitutions or small, structurally discrete deletions) in most parts of the tRNA-like structure resulted in decreased minus strand synthesis. This suggests that BMV replicase is a large enzyme, possibly composed of several subunits. The lowest activities, 5 to 8% of wild type, were observed for mutants with substitutions at three separate loci, identifying one structural and two sequence-specific elements essential for optimal promoter activity. (1) Destabilization of the pseudoknot structure in the aminoacyl acceptor stem resulted in low promoter activity, demonstrating the importance of a tRNA-like conformation. (2) Substitution of the C residue adjacent to the 3' terminus resulted in low promoter activity, probably by interfering with strand initiation. (3) The low activities resulting from substitutions and a small deletion in arm C suggest this region of the RNA to be a major feature involved in replicase binding. In particular, nucleotides within the loop of arm C appear to be involved in a sequence-specific interaction with the replicase.     

On the nature of spontaneous RNA synthesis by Q beta replicase.

Numerous RNA species of different length and nucleotide sequence grow spontaneously in vitro in Q beta replicase reactions where no RNA templates are added deliberately. Here, we show that this spontaneous RNA synthesis by Q beta replicase is template directed. The immediate source of template RNA can be the laboratory air, but there are ways to eliminate, or at least substantially reduce, the harmful effects of spontaneous synthesis. Solitary RNA molecules were detected in a thin layer of agarose gel containing Q beta replicase, where they grew to form colonies that became visible upon staining with ethidium bromide. This result provides a powerful tool for RNA cloning and selection in vitro. We also show that replicating RNAs similar to those growing spontaneously are incorporated into Q beta phage particles and can propagate in vivo for a number of phage generations. These RNAs are the smallest known molecular parasites, and in many aspects they resemble both the defective interfering genomes of animal and plant viruses and plant virus satellite RNAs.     

The serine protease and RNA-stimulated nucleoside triphosphatase and RNA helicase functional domains of dengue virus type 2 NS3 converge within a region of 20 amino acids

NS3 protein of dengue virus type 2 has a serine protease domain within the N-terminal 180 residues. NS2B is required for NS3 to form an active protease involved in processing of the viral polyprotein precursor. The region carboxy terminal to the protease domain has conserved motifs present in several viral RNA-stimulated nucleoside triphosphatase (NTPase)/RNA helicases. To define the functional domains of protease and NTPase/RNA helicase activities of NS3, full-length and amino-terminal deletion mutants of NS3 were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. Deletion of 160 N-terminal residues of NS3 (as in NS3del.2) had no detrimental effect on the basal and RNA-stimulated NTPase as well as RNA helicase activities. However, mutagenesis of the conserved P-loop motif of the RNA helicase domain (K199E) resulted in loss of ATPase activity. The RNA-stimulated NTPase activity was significantly affected by deletion of 20 amino acid residues from the N terminus or by substitutions of the cluster of basic residues, 184RKRK-->QNGN, of NS3del.2, although both mutant proteins retained the conserved RNA helicase motifs. Furthermore, the minimal NS3 protease domain, required for cleavage of the 2B-3 site, was precisely defined to be 167 residues, using the in vitro processing of NS2B-NS3 precursors. Our results reveal that the functional domains required for serine protease and RNA-stimulated NTPase activities map within the region between amino acid residues 160 and 180 of NS3 protein and that a novel motif, the cluster of basic residues 184RKRK, plays an important role for the RNA-stimulated NTPase activity.     

Functional circularity of legitimate Qbeta replicase templates

Qβ replicase (RNA-directed RNA polymerase of bacteriophage Qβ) exponentially amplifies certain RNAs in vitro. Previous studies have shown that Qβ replicase can initiate and elongate on a variety of RNAs; however, only a minute fraction of them are recognized as ‘legitimate’ templates. Guanosine 5′-triphosphate (GTP)-dependent initiation on a legitimate template generates a stable replicative complex capable of elongation in the presence of aurintricarboxylic acid, a powerful inhibitor of RNA-protein interactions. On the contrary, initiation on an illegitimate template is GTP independent and does not result in the aurintricarboxylic-acid-resistant replicative complex. This article demonstrates that the 3′ and 5′ termini of a legitimate template cooperate during and after the initiation step. Breach of the cooperation by dividing the template into fragments or by introducing point mutations at the 5′ terminus reduces the rate and the yield of initiation, increases the GTP requirement, decreases the overall rate of template copying, and destabilizes the postinitiation replicative complex. These results revive the old idea of a functional circularity of legitimate Qβ replicase templates and complement the increasing body of evidence that functional circularity may be a common property of RNA templates directing the synthesis of either RNA or protein molecules.