Methods for enhancing symbiotic nitrogen fixation

Biological nitrogen fixation of leguminous crops is becoming increasingly important in attempts to develop sustainable agricultural production. However, these crops are quite variable in their effectiveness in fixing nitrogen. By the use of the ¹⁵N isotope dilution method some species have been found to fix large proportions of their nitrogen, while others like common bean have been considered rather inefficient. Methods for increasing N₂ fixation are therefore of great importance in any legume work. Attempts to enhance nitrogen fixation of grain legumes has been mainly the domain of microbiologists who have selected rhizobial strains with superior effectiveness or competitive ability. Few projects have focused on the plant symbiont with the objective of improving N₂ fixation as done in the FAO/IAEA Co-ordinated Research Programme which is being reported in this volume. The objective of the present paper is to discuss some possibilities available for scientists interested in enhancing symbiotic nitrogen fixation in grain legumes. Examples will be presented on work performed using agronomic methods, as well as work on the plant and microbial symbionts. There are several methods available to scientists working on enhancement of N₂ fixation. No one approach is better than the others; rather work on the legume/Rhizobium symbiosis combining experience from various disciplines in inter-disciplinary research programmes should be pursued.     

Biological nitrogen fixation: Investments,expectations and actual contributions to agriculture

Inputs of biologically fixed N into agricultural systems may be derived from symbiotic relationships involving legumes and Rhizobium spp., partnerships between plants and Frankia spp. or cyanobacteria, or from non-symbiotic associations between free-living diazotrophs and plant roots. It is assumed that these N₂-fixing systems will satisfy a large portion of their own N requirements from atmospheric N₂, and that additional fixed N will be contributed to soil reserves for the benefit of other crops or forage species. This paper reviews the actual levels of N₂ fixation attained by legume and non-legume associations and assesses their role as a source of N in tropical and sub-tropical agriculture. We discuss factors influencing N₂ fixation and identify possible strategies for improving the amount of N₂ fixed.     

Mechanisms in plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria that enhance legume–rhizobial symbioses

Nitrogen fixation is an important biological process in terrestrial ecosystems and for global crop production. Legume nodulation and N₂ fixation have been improved using nodule-enhancing rhizobacteria (NER) under both regular and stressed conditions. The positive effect of NER on legume–rhizobia symbiosis can be facilitated by plant growth-promoting (PGP) mechanisms, some of which remain to be identified. NER that produce aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid deaminase and indole acetic acid enhance the legume–rhizobia symbiosis through (i) enhancing the nodule induction, (ii) improving the competitiveness of rhizobia for nodulation, (iii) prolonging functional nodules by suppressing nodule senescence and (iv) upregulating genes associated with legume–rhizobia symbiosis. The means by which these processes enhance the legume–rhizobia symbiosis is the focus of this review. A better understanding of the mechanisms by which PGP rhizobacteria operate, and how they can be altered, will provide opportunities to enhance legume–rhizobial interactions, to provide new advances in plant growth promotion and N₂ fixation.     

The regulation of symbiotic N2 fixation: a conceptual model of N feedback from the ecosystem to the gene expression level

Symbiotic nitrogen (N₂) fixation in legumes may give the host plant a distinct competitive advantage; at the same time it is mainly responsible for introducing N into terrestrial ecosystems which may ultimately benefit all organisms. Depending on environmental conditions, symbiotic N₂ fixation may be tuned to the plant's N demand or specifically inhibited (a disadvantage for plants which depend mainly on symbiotic N₂ fixation), or even prevented. Thus, the ecological range for symbiotic N₂ fixation can be narrower than that of the host plants. A shortage of mineral N is the only case in which adverse environmental conditions clearly favour symbiotic N₂ fixation. Variations in number or mass of nodules or nodule morphology are persistent features, that may represent one kind of regulation of N₂ fixation. In addition, varying O₂ permeability of nodules functions as a rapid and reversible control of N₂ fixation which may compensate partially or fully for poor nodulation. The plant's demand for symbiotically fixed N is thought to play a central role in modulating both nodulation and N₂ fixation activity; an N feedback mechanism is assumed. The control of symbiotic N₂ fixation operates through a series of ecophysiological triggers which are also influenced by complex interactions between legume plants and other organisms in the ecosystem. The proportion of legume biomass and the performance of symbiotic N₂ fixation in each individual legume are the main parameters which determine the amount of symbiotically fixed N introduced into a terrestrial ecosystem. The various triggers and N feedback mechanisms from the whole ecosystem to the gene expression level which regulate symbiotic N₂ fixation in terrestrial ecosystems are reviewed and discussed in terms of a conceptual model. Although the presented model is based primarily on our knowledge about the physiology of a few leguminous crop species and of ecosystem processes in managed, perennial grassland in temperate climatic conditions, it may stimulate thinking about functional relationships between symbiotic N₂ fixation and terrestrial ecosystems at various system levels.     

Ecological roles of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in two wild legume plants

Two wild legume plants,Glycine soja andCassia mimosoides var.nomame, and a cultivated plant, soybean (Glycine max), were employed for a study of triple symbiosis with an inoculum ofScutellispora heterogama harvested from natural soils and an inoculum of their own rhizobial cells. The dry weight, colonization of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus, nodule formation and N₂-fixation activity were estimated as the parameters of triple symbiosis. The two wild legume plants showed greater growth with colonization of arbuscular mycorrhizae than with nodulation, whereas the cultivated legume showed more nodulation than colonization of arbuscular mycorrhizae. Moreover,S. heterogama appeared to stimulate the triple symbiosis for the wild legume plants. The results suggested that spores ofS. heterogama are important in disturbed soils in Korea.     

Synthesis,release, and transmission of alfalfa signals to rhizobial symbionts

In addition to the flavonoids exuded by many legumes as signals to their rhizobial symbionts, alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) releases two betaines, trigonelline and stachydrine, that induce nodulation (nod) genes inRhizobium meliloti. Experiments with¹⁴C-phenylalanine in the presence and absence of phenylalanine ammonia-lyase inhibitors show that exudation of flavonoidnod-gene inducers from alfalfa roots is linked closely to their concurrent synthesis. In contrast, flavonoid and betainenod-gene inducers are already present on mature seeds before they are released during germination. Alfalfa seeds and roots release structurally differentnod-gene-inducing signals in the absence of rhizobia. WhenR. meliloti is added to roots, medicarpin, a classical isoflavonoid phytoalexin normally elicited by pathogens, and anod-gene-inducing compound, formononetin-7-O-(6-O-malonylglycoside), are exuded. Carbon flow through the phenylpropanoid pathway and into the flavonoid pathway via chalcone synthase is controlled by complexcis-acting sequences andtrans-acting factors which are not completely understood. Even less information is available on molecular regulation of the two other biosynthetic pathways that produce trigonelline and stachydrine. Presumably the three separate pathways for producingnod-gene inducers in some way protect the plant against fluctuations in the production or transmission of the two classes of signals. Factors influencing transmission of alfalfanod-gene inducers through soil are poorly defined, but solubility differences between hydrophobic flavonoids and hydrophilic betaines suggest that the diffusional traits of these molecules are not similar. Knowledge derived from studies of how legumes regulate rhizobial symbionts with natural plant products offers a basis for defining new fundamental concepts of rhizosphere ecology.     

Identification and cloning of nodulation genes from the stem-nodulating bacterium ORS571

Summary After random Tn5 mutagenesis of the stem-nodulating Sesbania rostrata symbiont strain ORS571, Nif^-, Fix^- and Nod^- mutants were isolated. The Nif^- mutants had lost both free-living and symbiotic N₂ fixation capacity. The Fix^- mutants normally fixed N₂ in the free-living state but induced ineffective nodules on S. rostrata. They were defective in functions exclusively required for symbiotic N₂ fixation. A further analysis of the Nod^- mutants allowed the identification of two nod loci. A Tn5 insertion in nod locus 1 completely abolished both root and stem nodulation capacity. Root hair curling, which is an initial event in S. rostrata root nodulation, was no longer observed. A 400 bp region showing weak homology to the nodC gene of Rhizobium meliloti was located 1.5 kb away from this nod Tn5 insertion. A Tn5 insertion in nod locus 2 caused the loss of stem and root nodulation capacity but root hair curling still occurred. The physical maps of a 20.5 kb DNA region of nod locus 1 and of a 40 kb DNA region of nod locus 2 showed no overlaps. The two nod loci are not closely linked to nif locus 1, containing the structural genes for the nitrogenase complex (Elmerich et al. 1982).     

Enhancing legume N2 fixation through plant and soil management

Atmospheric N₂ fixed symbiotically by associations between Rhizobium spp. and legumes represents a renewable source of N for agriculture. Contribution of legume N₂ fixation to the N-economy of any ecosystem is mediated by: (i) legume reliance upon N₂ fixation for growth, and (ii) the total amount of legume-N accumulated. Strategies that change the numbers of effective rhizobia present in soil, reduce the inhibitory effects of soil nitrate, or influence legume biomass all have potential to alter net inputs of fixed N. A range of management options can be applied to legumes growing in farming systems to manipulate N₂ fixation and improve the N benefits to agriculture and agroforestry.     

Soil moisture and potassium affect the performance of symbiotic nitrogen fixation in faba bean and common bean

Potassium (K) is reported to improve plant's resistance against environmental stress. A frequently experienced stress for plants in the tropics is water shortage. It is not known if sufficient K supply would help plants to partially overcome the effects of water stress, especially that of symbiotic nitrogen fixation which is often rather low in the tropics when compared to that of temperate regions. Thus, the impact of three levels of fertilizer potassium (0.1, 0.8 and 3.0 mM K) on symbiotic nitrogen fixation was evaluated with two legumes under high (field capacity to 25% depletion) and low (less than 50% of field capacity) water regimes. Plants were grown in single pots in silica sand under controlled conditions with 1.5 mM N (¹⁵N enriched NH₄NO₃). The species were faba bean (Vicia faba L.), a temperate, amide producing legume and common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.), a tropical, ureide producing species. In both species, 0.1 mM K was insufficient for nodulation at both moisture regimes, although plant growth was observed. The supply of 0.8 or 3.0 mM K allowed nodulation and subsequent nitrogen fixation which appeared to be adequate for respective plant growth. High potassium supply had a positive effect on nitrogen fixation, on shoot and root growth and on water potential in both water regimes. Where nodulation occurred, variations caused by either K or water supply had no consequences on the percentage of nitrogen derived from the symbiosis. The present data indicate that K can apparently alleviate water shortage to a certain extent. Moreover it is shown that the symbiotic system in both faba bean and common bean is less tolerant to limiting K supply than plants themselves. However, as long as nodulation occurs, N assimilation from the symbiotic source is not selectively affected by K as opposed to N assimilation from fertilizer.     

On the efficiency of legume supernodulating mutants

The supernodulating mutants of legumes lack the internal regulation of the number of symbiotic root nodules that harbour N₂-fixing nodule bacteria. On one hand, these mutants represent an efficient tool for dramatic increase in the degree of rhizobial symbiosis development. The trait of released nodulation is often associated with the desirable resistance of nodule initiation and functioning to the inhibition by ambient nitrate. On the other hand, the more intense and stable atmospheric nitrogen fixation of supernodulated plants is devalued by plant growth depression that results from the disproportion between the photosynthetic capacity of the shoot and the catabolic demands of symbiotic nodules. The deleterious effects of excessive nodulation can be neutralised or alleviated by a breeding strategy aimed at creating an ideotype of N₂-fixing legume. The growth depression can be diminished by the reduction in the nodule number typical for supernodulators, that is, 6–10-fold of the wild type, to the level found permissive for the particular crop. This shift should be accompanied with breeding aimed at the increased photosynthetic capacity of the shoot. Forage varieties of legumes represent a reserve of high photosynthetic and shoot growth capacity, thanks to a long-term breeding history for green biomass accumulation. Moreover, the deleterious effects of supernodulation are less perceived after introgression into the background of forage varieties in view of different criteria in their evaluation, such as nitrogen accumulation and biomass production per crop area unit. The growth of supernodulators can be further corrected by breeding for auxiliary traits such as long-vine shoot architecture, a longer vegetation period and late flowering. The same strategy is applicable to the compensation for inherent pleiotropic changes in plant development, which are often associated with primarily symbiotic mutations. Supporting evidence for the efficiency of the described approach has already been reported.     

Nod factor-independent ‘crack-entry’ symbiosis in dalbergoid legume Arachis hypogaea

Dalbergoids are typified by crack-entry symbiosis which is evidenced to be Nod Factor (NF)-independent in several Aeschynomene legumes. Natural symbionts of the dalbergoid legume Arachis hypogaea are always NF-producing, prompting us to check whether symbiosis in this legume could also be NF-independent. For this, we followed the symbiosis with two NF-containing bradyrhizobial strains – SEMIA6144, a natural symbiont of Arachis and ORS285, a versatile nodulator of Aeschynomene legumes, along with their corresponding nodulation (nod) mutants. Additionally, we investigated NF-deficient bradyrhizobia like BTAi1, a natural symbiont of Aeschynomene indica and the WBOS strains that were natural endophytes of Oryza sativa, collected from an Arachis-Oryza intercropped field. While SEMIA6144ΔnodC was non-nodulating, both ORS285 and ORS285ΔnodB could induce functional nodulation, although with lower efficiency than SEMIA6144. On the other hand, all the NF-deficient strains – BTAi1, WBOS2 and WBOS4 showed comparable nodulation with ORS285 indicating Arachis to harbour an NF-independent mechanism of symbiosis. Intriguingly, symbiosis in Arachis, irrespective of whether it was NF-dependent or independent, was always associated with the curling or branching of the rosette root hairs at the lateral root bases. Thus, despite being predominantly described as an NF-dependent legume, Arachis does retain a vestigial, less-efficient form of NF-independent symbiosis.     

Toward More Productive,Efficient, and Competitive Nitrogen-Fixing Symbiotic Bacteria

The prospects of developing strains of legume nodule bacteria that provide higher productivity of leguminous plants are described. The generic, biochemical, physiological, regulatory, and economic constraints that govern the ability of private and public efforts to construct better inoculants for legume nodulation are discussed. Success in constructing better inoculants requires a two-pronged approach. First, strains need to be improved in order to compete successfully with indigenous strains for root nodulation of legumes. Several loci have been identified to date that affect competitiveness for strain nodule occupancy. Usually mutations in these loci affect the ability of a strain to form nodules rapidly and efficiently. Other loci, such as those that confer antibiotic production, can be added to strains to enhance nodulation competitiveness when co-inoculated with antibiotic-sensitive strains. Second, the inoculum strains must be improved with respect to symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Efforts to enhance the symbiotic productivity of legume nodule bacteria either by mutation or genetic engineering are also described. The best characterized example of these is the hydrogenase system. Due to nitrogenase-dependent catalysis of proton reduction, diazotrophs evolve large amounts of H₂. An approach to maximize the efficiency of symbiotic N₂ fixation, and therefore of legume productivity, is to construct strains of Rhizobium with the ability to oxidize this otherwise wasted H₂. The electrons produced by H₂ oxidation are funneled through energy-conserving electron transport chains. Our knowledge of the genetics and biochemistry of H₂ oxidation in Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Rhizobium leguminosarum has developed rapidly in recent years. At least 20 genes are needed for these bacteria to manufacture and efficiently express a nickel-containing H₂-uptake hydrogenase. These genes include those encoding regulatory elements, posttranslational processing enzymes, nickel-sensing and nickel-metabolism proteins, and electron transport components for integrating the electrons from H₂ oxidation into the respiratory chain. Some of the components for oxidizing H₂ in the symbiotic N₂ fixing bacteria are distinct from the analogous components in (nonsymbiotic) H₂ oxidizing bacteria.     

Enhancing crop legume N2 fixation through selection and breeding

Legume N₂ fixation is variable, but nonetheless is a valuable process in world agriculture. There is great potential to increase the contribution by the crop legumes to the world's supply of soil.N. This will be achieved by (i) increasing the area of legumes sown by farmers; (ii) improved management of the crops in order that the major determinants of productivity, e.g. land area, water availability, are converted to harvested product with maximum efficiency; and (iii) genetic modification of the commonly-grown species to ensure high dependence of the legume crop on N₂ fixation at all levels of productivity. Currently-used methods for measuring N₂ fixation and for assessing heritability and repeatability of N₂ fixation in breeding and selection programs are reviewed. Results from research programs to define genetic variation in N₂ fixation and to enhance N₂ fixation through selection and breeding are presented with particular emphasis on common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) and soybean (Glycine max).     

Roles of flavonoids in symbiotic and defense functions in legume roots

The roles of flavonoids in roots of legumes in the symbiotic relationships with nitrogen-fixing bacteria and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi are compared with defense functions, using examples from three legume genera,Lotus, Medicago, andGlycine. Pathways leading to proanthocyanidins and isoflavonoids are emphasized. The localization of flavonoids in nodules involved in nitrogen fixation and in the apoplastic compartment of mycorrhizal associations is briefly described, with emphasis on the need for more information concerning their precise localization. Also emphasized are the limits of our knowledge about the regulatory genes of the flavonoid pathway involved in both exogenous and endogenous regulation of these complex interrelationships.     

A mutant-based analysis of the establishment of Nod-independent symbiosis in the legume Aeschynomene evenia

Intensive research on nitrogen-fixing symbiosis in two model legumes has uncovered the molecular mechanisms, whereby rhizobial Nod factors activate a plant symbiotic signaling pathway that controls infection and nodule organogenesis. In contrast, the so-called Nod-independent symbiosis found between Aeschynomene evenia and photosynthetic bradyrhizobia, which does not involve Nod factor recognition nor infection thread formation, is less well known. To gain knowledge on how Nod-independent symbiosis is established, we conducted a phenotypic and molecular characterization of A. evenia lines carrying mutations in different nodulation genes. Besides investigating the effect of the mutations on rhizobial symbiosis, we examined their consequences on mycorrhizal symbiosis and in nonsymbiotic conditions. Analyzing allelic mutant series for AePOLLUX, Ca²⁺/calmodulin dependent kinase, AeCYCLOPS, nodulation signaling pathway 2 (AeNSP2), and nodule inception demonstrated that these genes intervene at several stages of intercellular infection and during bacterial accommodation. We provide evidence that AeNSP2 has an additional nitrogen-dependent regulatory function in the formation of axillary root hairs at lateral root bases, which are rhizobia-colonized infection sites. Our investigation of the recently discovered symbiotic actor cysteine-rich receptor-like kinase specified that it is not involved in mycorrhization; however, it is essential for both symbiotic signaling and early infection during nodulation. These findings provide important insights on the modus operandi of Nod-independent symbiosis and contribute to the general understanding of how rhizobial–legume symbioses are established by complementing the information acquired in model legumes.

Characterization of Aeschynomene evenia mutants altered in nodulation provides information on alternative mechanisms of rhizobium–legume symbiosis     

Recent development and new insight of diversification and symbiosis specificity of legume rhizobia: mechanism and application

Currently, symbiotic rhizobia (sl., rhizobium) refer to the soil bacteria in α- and β-Proteobacteria that can induce root and/or stem nodules on some legumes and a few of nonlegumes. In the nodules, rhizobia convert the inert dinitrogen gas (N₂) into ammonia (NH₃) and supply them as nitrogen nutrient to the host plant. In general, this symbiotic association presents specificity between rhizobial and leguminous species, and most of the rhizobia use lipochitooligosaccharides, so called Nod factor (NF), for cooperating with their host plant to initiate the formation of nodule primordium and to inhibit the plant immunity. Besides NF, effectors secreted by type III secretion system (T3SS), exopolysaccharides and many microbe-associated molecular patterns in the rhizobia also play important roles in nodulation and immunity response between rhizobia and legumes. However, the promiscuous hosts like Glycine max and Sophora flavescens can nodulate with various rhizobial species harbouring diverse symbiosis genes in different soils, meaning that the nodulation specificity/efficiency might be mainly determined by the host plants and regulated by the soil conditions in a certain cases. Based on previous studies on rhizobial application, we propose a ‘1+n−N’ model to promote the function of symbiotic nitrogen fixation (SNF) in agricultural practice, where ‘1’ refers to appreciate rhizobium; ‘+n’ means the addition of multiple trace elements and PGPR bacteria; and ‘−N’ implies the reduction of chemical nitrogen fertilizer. Finally, open questions in the SNF field are raised to future think deeply and researches.     

Facultative nitrogen fixation by legumes in the central Congo basin is downregulated during late successional stages

The contribution of the legume community to the nitrogen cycle during natural forest regeneration remains poorly understood. We systematically assessed the changes in abundance and nodulation status of all legumes, across taxa and plant types, in a forest succession gradient in the Equateur Province of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Our results clearly show that symbiotic N₂ fixation is downregulated during late successional stages.     

Rhizobial Factors Required for Stem Nodule Maturation and Maintenance in Sesbania rostrata-Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571 Symbiosis

The molecular and physiological mechanisms behind the maturation and maintenance of N₂-fixing nodules during development of symbiosis between rhizobia and legumes still remain unclear, although the early events of symbiosis are relatively well understood. Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571 is a microsymbiont of the tropical legume Sesbania rostrata, forming N₂-fixing nodules not only on the roots but also on the stems. In this study, 10,080 transposon-inserted mutants of A. caulinodans ORS571 were individually inoculated onto the stems of S. rostrata, and those mutants that induced ineffective stem nodules, as displayed by halted development at various stages, were selected. From repeated observations on stem nodulation, 108 Tn5 mutants were selected and categorized into seven nodulation types based on size and N₂ fixation activity. Tn5 insertions of some mutants were found in the well-known nodulation, nitrogen fixation, and symbiosis-related genes, such as nod, nif, and fix, respectively, lipopolysaccharide synthesis-related genes, C₄ metabolism-related genes, and so on. However, other genes have not been reported to have roles in legume-rhizobium symbiosis. The list of newly identified symbiosis-related genes will present clues to aid in understanding the maturation and maintenance mechanisms of nodules.     

Low concentrations of nitrate and ammonium stimulate nodulation and N2 fixation while inhibiting specific nodulation (nodule DW g−1 root dry weight) and specific N2 fixation (N2 fixed g−1 root dry weight) in soybean

Nitrate N is a major inhibitor of the soybean/Bradyrhizobium symbiosis in legumes and although this inhibition has been studied for many years, as yet no consensus has been reached on the specific and quantitative interactions between nitrate and ammonium supply and N₂ fixation. The effect of nitrate and ammonium supply on plant growth, nodulation and N₂ fixation capacity during the full growth cycle was investigated in both greenhouse and growth chamber experiments with three soybean genotypes. The results show that a high concentration of mineral N (10 mM), either as nitrate or ammonium or ammonium nitrate significantly suppressed nodule number, nodule dry weight and total N₂ fixed per plant of nodulated soybeans. However, lower mineral N concentrations, either 1 mM or 3.75 mM significantly enhanced nodule number, nodule dry weight and total N₂ fixed per plant, while specific nodulation (nodule dry weight g^–1 root DW, SNOD) and specific N₂ fixation (total N₂ fixed g^–1 root DW, SNF) were significantly reduced, particularly at the early vegetative growth stage V4, compared to the treatment with N₂ fixation as the only N source, in both growth chamber and greenhouse experiments. Therefore, we suggest that SNOD or SNF might be better indicators to express the suppressing effect of mineral N addition on nodule performance and N₂ fixed. Our studies also showed that ammonium alone was the more efficient N source than either ammonium nitrate or nitrate for soybean, as it resulted in higher biomass accumulation, nodule dry weight, total N accumulation and total N₂ fixed by 23, 20, 18 and 44%, respectively, compared to NO₃ ^– as the N source.