Qualitative changes accompany memory T cell generation: faster, more effective responses at lower doses of antigen

The generation of memory T cells is critically important for rapid clearance and neutralization of pathogens encountered previously by the immune system. We have studied the kinetics of response and Ag dose requirements for proliferation and cytokine secretion of CD4+ memory T cells to examine whether there are qualitative changes which might lead to improved immunity. TCR Tg CD4+ T cells were primed in vitro and transferred into T cell-deficient hosts. After 6 or more weeks, the persisting T cells were exclusively small resting cells with a memory phenotype: CD44high CD62L+/- CD25-. Memory CD4 T cells showed a similar pattern of response as naive cells to peptide analogues with similar Ag dose requirements for IL-2 secretion. However, memory cells (derived from both Th2 and Th1 effectors) displayed faster kinetics of cytokine secretion, cell division, and proliferation, enhanced proliferation in response to low doses of Ag or peptide analogues, and production of IL-4, IL-5, and IFN-gamma. These results suggest there is a much more efficient response of CD4 memory T cells to Ag re-exposure and that the expanded functional capacity of memory cells will promote a rapid development of effector functions, providing more rapid and effective immunity.     

Distinct roles of Cdc42 in thymopoiesis and effector and memory T cell differentiation

Cdc42 of the Rho GTPase family has been implicated in cell actin organization, proliferation, survival, and migration but its physiological role is likely cell-type specific. By a T cell-specific deletion of Cdc42 in mouse, we have recently shown that Cdc42 maintains naïve T cell homeostasis through promoting cell survival and suppressing T cell activation. Here we have further investigated the involvement of Cdc42 in multiple stages of T cell differentiation. We found that in Cdc42^−/− thymus, positive selection of CD4⁺CD8⁺ double-positive thymocytes was defective, CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ single-positive thymocytes were impaired in migration and showed an increase in cell apoptosis triggered by anti-CD3/-CD28 antibodies, and thymocytes were hyporesponsive to anti-CD3/-CD28-induced cell proliferation and hyperresponsive to anti-CD3/-CD28-stimulated MAP kinase activation. At the periphery, Cdc42-deficient naive T cells displayed an impaired actin polymerization and TCR clustering during the formation of mature immunological synapse, and showed an enhanced differentiation to Th1 and CD8⁺ effector and memory cells in vitro and in vivo. Finally, Cdc42^−/− mice exhibited exacerbated liver damage in an induced autoimmune disease model. Collectively, these data establish that Cdc42 is critically involved in thymopoiesis and plays a restrictive role in effector and memory T cell differentiation and autoimmunity.     

Dendritic cell-T cell interactions in the generation and maintenance of CD8 T cell memory

Dendritic cells (DCs) are the critical antigen-presenting cells involved in initiating CD8 T cell responses to microbial and viral pathogens. Hence the generation of memory T cells from naïve T cells is intricately intertwined with DCs at every level. This review broadly addresses DC-CD8 T cell interactions that result in the generation and maintenance of CD8 memory T cells.     

Discrete event modeling of CD4+ memory T cell generation

Studies of memory T cell differentiation are hampered by a lack of quantitative models to test hypotheses in silico before in vivo experimentation. We created a stochastic computer model of CD4+ memory T cell generation that can simulate and track 10(1)-10(8) individual lymphocytes over time. Parameters for the model were derived from experimental data using naive human CD4+ T cells stimulated in vitro. Using discrete event computer simulation, we identified two key variables that heavily influence effector burst size and the persistent memory pool size: the cell cycle dependent probability of apoptosis, and the postactivation mitosis at which memory T cells emerge. Multiple simulations were performed and varying critical parameters permitted estimates of how sensitive the model was to changes in all of the model parameters. We then compared two hypotheses of CD4+ memory T cell generation: maturation from activated naive to effector to memory cells (model I) vs direct progression from activated naive to memory cells (model II). We find that direct progression of naive to memory T cells does not explain published measurements of the memory cell mass unless postactivation expansion of the memory cell cohort occurs. We conclude that current models suggesting direct progression of activated naive cells to the persistent memory phenotype (model II) do not account for the experimentally measured size of the postactivation CD4+, Ag-specific, memory T cell cohort.     

Suppression of memory CD8 T cell generation and function by tryptophan catabolism

Dendritic cell-derived indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) suppresses naive T cell proliferation and induces their apoptosis by catalyzing tryptophan, and hence is essential for the maintenance of peripheral tolerance. However, it is not known whether memory T cells are subject to the regulation by IDO-mediated tryptophan catabolism, as memory T cells respond more rapidly and vigorously than their naive counterparts and are resistant to conventional costimulatory blockade. In this study, we present the evidence that memory CD8+ T cells are susceptible to tryptophan catabolism mediated by IDO. We found that overexpression of IDO in vivo attenuated the generation of both central memory CD8+ T cells (T(CM)) and effector memory CD8+ T cells (T(EM)) while suppressing IDO activity promoted their generation. Moreover, IDO overexpression suppressed the effector function of T(CM) cells or T(CM) cell-mediated allograft rejection as well as their proliferation in vivo. Interestingly, T(CM) cells were resistant to apoptosis induced by tryptophan catabolism. However, IDO overexpression did not suppress the effector function of T(EM) cells or T(EM) cell-mediated allograft rejection, suggesting that T(EM) cells, unlike T(CM) cells, do not require tryptophan for their effector function once they are generated. This study provides insight into the mechanisms underlying the differential regulation of memory T cell responsiveness and has clinical implications for vaccination or tolerance induction.     

Viral FLIP impairs survival of activated T cells and generation of CD8+ T cell memory

Viral FLIPs (vFLIPs) interfere with apoptosis signaling by death-domain-containing receptors in the TNFR superfamily (death receptors). In this study, we show that T cell-specific transgenic expression of MC159-vFLIP from the human Molluscum contagiosum virus blocks CD95-induced apoptosis in thymocytes and peripheral T cells, but also impairs postactivation survival of in vitro activated primary T cells despite normal early activation parameters. MC159 vFLIP impairs T cell development to a lesser extent than does Fas-associated death domain protein deficiency or another viral FLIP, E8. In the periphery, vFLIP expression leads to a specific deficit of functional memory CD8(+) T cells. After immunization with a protein Ag, Ag-specific CD8(+) T cells initially proliferate, but quickly disappear and fail to produce Ag-specific memory CD8(+) T cells. Viral FLIP transgenic mice exhibit impaired CD8(+) T cell responses to lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus and Trypanosoma cruzi infections, and a specific defect in CD8(+) T cell recall responses to influenza virus was seen. These results suggest that vFLIP expression in T cells blocks signals necessary for the sustained survival of CD8(+) T cells and the generation of CD8(+) T cell memory. Through this mechanism, vFLIP proteins expressed by T cell tropic viruses may impair the CD8(+) T cell immune responses directed against them.     

Dynamics of memory T cell proliferation under conditions of heterologous immunity and bystander stimulation

By examining adoptively transferred CSFE-labeled lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-immune donor T cells in Thy-1 congenic hosts inoculated with viruses or with the cytokine inducer poly(I:C), strikingly different responses of bona fide memory T cells were found in response to different stimuli. Poly(I:C) (cytokine) stimulation caused a limited synchronized division of memory CD8 T cells specific to each of five LCMV epitopes, with no increase and sometimes a loss in number, and no change in their epitope hierarchy. Homologous LCMV infection caused more than seven divisions of T cells specific for each epitope, with dramatic increases in number and minor changes in hierarchy. Infections with the heterologous viruses Pichinde and vaccinia (VV) caused more than seven divisions and increases in number of T cells specific to some putatively cross-reactive but not other epitopes and resulted in substantial changes in the hierarchy of the LCMV-specific T cells. Hence, there can be memory T cell division without proliferation (i.e., increase in cell number) in the absence of Ag and division with proliferation in the presence of Ag from homologous or heterologous viruses. Heterologous protective immunity between viruses is not necessarily reciprocal, given that LCMV protects against VV but VV does not protect against LCMV. VV elicited proliferation of LCMV-induced CD8 and CD4 T cells, whereas LCMV did not elicit proliferation of VV-induced T cells. Thus, depending on the pathogen and the sequence of infection, a heterologous agent may selectively stimulate the memory pool in patterns consistent with heterologous immunity.     

Latent virus influences the generation and maintenance of CD8+ T cell memory

The influence of latent virus on CD8+ T cell memory is poorly understood. HSV type 1 specifically establishes latency in trigeminal ganglia (TG) after corneal infection of mice. In latently infected TG, IL-15 deprivation reduced the following: 1) accumulation of HSV-specific CD8+ effector T cells (HSV-CD8(eff)), 2) accumulation of CD127(+) putative HSV-CD8 memory precursors, and 3) the size and functionality of the memory (HSV-CD8(mem)) population. Although compromised in IL-15(-/-) mice, the HSV-CD8(mem) pool persisted in latently infected tissue, but not in noninfected tissue of the same mice. Anti-IL-2 treatment also dramatically reduced the size of the HSV-CD8(eff) population in the TG, but did not influence the concomitant generation of the CD127+ putative HSV-CD8(mem) precursor population or the size or functionality of the HSV-CD8(mem) pool. Thus, the size of the memory pool appears to be determined by the size of the CD127+ CD8(mem) precursor population and not by the size of the overall CD8(eff) pool. HSV-CD8(mem) showed a higher basal rate of proliferation in latently infected than noninfected tissue, which was associated with a reduced population of CD4+FoxP3+ regulatory T cells. Thus, the generation, maintenance, and function of memory CD8+ T cells is markedly influenced by latent virus.     

T cell memory against colon carcinoma is long-lived in the absence of antigen.

Eradication of established colon carcinoma metastases is a major goal for adjuvant immunotherapy of this disease. This was accomplished in a murine model by targeting IL-2 to the tumor microenvironment with a recombinant Ab-IL-2 fusion protein (huKS1/4-IL-2). The generation of a long-lived protective immunity was demonstrated by a 10- to 14-fold increase in CTL precursor (pCTL) frequency and induction of genes encoding Th1 cytokines, followed by the generation of tumor-specific CD8+ T effector cells, some of which differentiated into long-lived T memory cells. The frequency of pCTL correlated with enhanced immune protection against tumor cell challenge, and long-lived T cell memory was maintained in syngeneic SCID mice in the absence of tumor Ag. Tumor cell challenge of these SCID mice, concomitant with a boost of two noncurative doses of huKS1/4-IL-2 fusion protein, resulted in the generation of primed CD8+ T effector cells with concurrent release of Th1 cytokines. These events culminated in the complete rejection of the tumor cell challenge and prevention of pulmonary metastases. Taken together, the data suggest that T cell memory against colon carcinoma can be maintained in the absence of Ag.     

p21CIP1/WAF1 controls proliferation of activated/memory T cells and affects homeostasis and memory T cell responses

Development of autoantibodies and lupus-like autoimmunity by 129/Sv x C57BL/6 p21(-/-) mice has established that cell cycle deregulation is one the defective pathways leading to break of tolerance. Memory T cell accumulation is thought to be related to tolerance loss in murine lupus models. We studied T cell memory responses in C57BL/6 p21(-/-) mice that develop lupus-like disease manifestations. p21 did not affect primary proliferation of naive T cells, and was required for cycling control, but not for apoptosis of activated/memory T cells. When we induced apoptosis by secondary TCR challenge, surviving memory T cells depended on p21 for proliferation control. Under conditions of secondary T cell stimulation that did not cause apoptosis, p21 was also needed for regulation of activated/memory T cell expansion. The requirement for p21 in the control of T cell proliferation of activated/memory T cells suggests that in addition to apoptosis, cycling regulation by p21 constitutes a new pathway for T cell homeostasis. Concurring with this view, we found accumulation in p21(-/-) mice of memory CD4(+) T cells that showed increased proliferative potential after TCR stimulation. Furthermore, OVA immunization of p21(-/-) mice generated hyperresponsive OVA-specific T cells. Overall, the data show that p21 controls the proliferation of only activated/memory T cells, and suggest that p21 forms part of the memory T cell homeostasis mechanism, contributing to maintenance of tolerance.     

The generation of memory B-cell subpopulations capable of proliferation and expansion of the pool: effect of time and antigen

The ability of antigen to induce proliferation of memory B lymphocytes, thus perpetuating and expanding the memory cell pool, has been examined using an antibody-forming cell (AFC) assay. This method provided confirmation of previous studies in which serum antibody titer was used as a relative measure of pool size and demonstrated directly that the number of antibody-forming cells is increased. Memory cell subpopulations were prepared by lg velocity sedimentation from recently immunized donors (2 weeks) and tested for their ability to proliferate, thus expanding the memory cell pool. Both large and small immature DNP-specific memory cells displayed antigen-dependent and antigen-independent proliferation while mature cells (8 weeks postpriming) were capable only of antigen-dependent proliferation. Chicken γ-globulin (CGG) specific memory cells were also evaluated in this system and were found to differ from DNP-specific cells in several ways. (A) DNP-specific AFC were found to be concentrated in the spleen while CGG-specific AFC were found predominantly in the bone marrow early after transfer and in the spleen upon delayed challenge. (B) The rate of maturation of CGG-specific memory cells capable of antigen-driven proliferation and pool expansion was delayed in comparison to DNP-specific memory cells. The relationship of these functionally defined subsets to previously described memory cell subpopulations is discussed.     

Population dynamics of naive and memory CD8 T cell responses after antigen stimulations in vivo

The extent to which the progeny of one primary memory CD8 T cell differs from the progeny of one naive CD8 T cell of the same specificity remains an unresolved question. To explore cell-autonomous functional differences between naive and memory CD8 T cells that are not influenced by differences in the priming environment, an experimental model has been developed in which physiological numbers of both populations of cells were cotransferred into naive hosts before Ag stimulation. Interestingly, naive CD8 T cells undergo greater expansion in numbers than do primary memory CD8 T cells after various infections or immunizations. The intrinsic ability of one naive CD8 T cell to give rise to more effector CD8 T cells than one memory CD8 T cell is independent of the number and quality of primary memory CD8 T cells present in vivo. The sustained proliferation of newly activated naive CD8 T cells contributed to their greater magnitude of expansion. Additionally, longitudinal analyses of primary and secondary CD8 T cell responses revealed that on a per-cell basis naive CD8 T cells generate higher numbers of long-lived memory cells than do primary memory CD8 T cells. This enhanced "memory generation potential" of responding naive CD8 T cells occurred despite the delayed contraction of secondary CD8 T cell responses. Taken together, the data in this study revealed previously unappreciated differences between naive and memory CD8 T cells and will help further define the functional potential for both cell types.     

OX40-mediated memory T cell generation is TNF receptor-associated factor 2 dependent

Tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated factor 2 (TRAF2), an adapter protein that associates with the cytoplasmic tail of OX40, may play a critical role in OX40-mediated signal transduction. To investigate the in vivo role of TRAF2 in OX40-mediated generation of Ag-specific memory T cells, we bred OVA-specific TCR transgenic mice to TRAF2 dominant-negative (TRAF2 DN) mice. Following Ag stimulation and OX40 engagement of TRAF2 DN T cells in vivo, the number of long-lived OVA-specific T cells and effector T cell function was dramatically reduced when compared with wild-type T cells. We also demonstrate that CTLA-4 is down-regulated following OX40 engagement in vivo and the OX40-specific TRAF2 DN defect was partially overcome by CTLA-4 blockade in vivo. The data provide evidence that TRAF2 is linked to OX40-mediated memory T cell expansion and survival, and point to the down-regulation of CTLA-4 as a possible control element to enhance early T cell expansion through OX40 signaling.     

Opposite roles of Kindlin orthologs in cell survival and proliferation

ObjectiveIt is unclear why adhesion‐dependent cells such as epithelium undergo anoikis without anchorage, while adhesion‐independent blood cells thrive in suspension. The adhesive machinery of these cells is similar, with the exception of Kindlin orthologs, Kindlin 2 (K2) and Kindlin 3 (K3). Here we address how Kindlins control cell survival and proliferation in anchorage‐dependent and independent cells.Material and MethodsTo demonstrate the opposite roles of Kindlin''s in cell survival we utilized in vivo and in vitro models and K3 and K2 knockdown and knockin cells. We used human lymphocytes from the K3 deficient patients in tumour model, K3 knockout and knockin macrophages and K2 knockout and knockin MEF cells for experiments in under conditions of adhesion and in suspension.ResultsDepletion of K3 promotes cell proliferation and survival of anchorage‐independent cells regardless of cell attachment. In contrast, the absence of K2 in anchorage‐dependent cells accelerates apoptosis and limits proliferation. K3 deficiency promotes human lymphoma growth and survival in vivo. Kindlins'' interaction with paxillin, is critical for their differential roles in cell anchorage. While disruption of K2‐paxillin binding leads to increased apoptosis, the lack of K3‐paxillin binding has an opposite effect in adhesion‐independent cells.ConclusionKindlin ortologs and their interaction to cytoskeletal protein paxillin define the mechanisms of anchorage dependence. Our study identifies the key elements of the cell adhesion machinery in cell survival and tumour metastasis, proposing possible targets for tumour treatment.

Cell anchorage is critical for tissue morphogenesis and protection against dysplasia and cancer metastasis. Only transformed and circulating haematopoietic cells thrive without anchorage. The adhesive machinery of anchorage‐dependent and ‐independent cells is similar, with the exception of Kindlin orthologs, Kindlin 2 (K2) and Kindlin 3 (K3). Our study reveals paradoxically opposite roles of K2 and K3 in cell survival despite their identical functions in cell adhesion. K3 deficiency promotes human lymphoma growth and survival. K3 deficiency protects anchorage‐independent cells from apoptosis and promotes their proliferation, while K2 deficiency triggers apoptosis and diminishes proliferation in anchorage‐dependent cells. We further demonstrate that Kindlins'' effects on proliferation rely upon the interaction between Kindlin and paxillin in both, anchorage‐dependent and ‐independent cells.     

An IFN-gamma-IL-18 signaling loop accelerates memory CD8+ T cell proliferation

Rapid proliferation is one of the important features of memory CD8(+) T cells, ensuring rapid clearance of reinfection. Although several cytokines such as IL-15 and IL-7 regulate relatively slow homeostatic proliferation of memory T cells during the maintenance phase, it is unknown how memory T cells can proliferate more quickly than na?ve T cells upon antigen stimulation. To examine antigen-specific CD8(+) T cell proliferation in recall responses in vivo, we targeted a model antigen, ovalbumin(OVA), to DEC-205(+) dendritic cells (DCs) with a CD40 maturation stimulus. This led to the induction of functional memory CD8(+) T cells, which showed rapid proliferation and multiple cytokine production (IFN-gamma, IL-2, TNF-alpha) during the secondary challenge to DC-targeted antigen. Upon antigen-presentation, IL-18, an IFN-gamma-inducing factor, accumulated at the DC:T cell synapse. Surprisingly, IFN-gamma receptors were required to augment IL-18 production from DCs. Mice genetically deficient for IL-18 or IFN-gamma-receptor 1 also showed delayed expansion of memory CD8(+) T cells in vivo. These results indicate that a positive regulatory loop involving IFN-gamma and IL-18 signaling contributes to the accelerated memory CD8(+) T cell proliferation during a recall response to antigen presented by DCs.     

Proliferating cell nuclear antigen as the cell cycle sensor for an HLA-derived peptide blocking T cell proliferation

Synthetic peptides corresponding to structural regions of HLA molecules are novel immunosuppressive agents. A peptide corresponding to residues 65-79 of the alpha-chain of HLA-DQA03011 (DQ65-79) blocks cell cycle progression from early G1 to the G1 restriction point, which inhibits cyclin-dependent kinase-2 activity and phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein. A yeast two-hybrid screen identified proliferating cell nuclear Ag (PCNA) as a cellular ligand for this peptide, whose interaction with PCNA was further confirmed by in vitro biochemistry. Electron microscopy demonstrates that the DQ65-79 peptide enters the cell and colocalizes with PCNA in the T cell nucleus in vivo. Binding of the DQ65-79 peptide to PCNA did not block polymerase delta (pol delta)-dependent DNA replication in vitro. These findings support a key role for PCNA as a sensor of cell cycle progression and reveal an unanticipated function for conserved regions of HLA molecules.     

Manipulating the rate of memory CD8+ T cell generation after acute infection

Infection with Listeria monocytogenes elicits expansion in numbers of Ag-specific CD8+ T cells, which then undergo programmed contraction. The remaining cells undergo further phenotypic and functional changes with time, eventually attaining the qualities of memory CD8+ T cells. In this study, we show that L. monocytogenes-specific CD8+ T cell populations primed in antibiotic-pretreated mice undergo brief effector phase, but rapidly develop phenotypic (CD127(high), CD43(low)) and functional (granzyme B(low), IL-2-producing) characteristics of memory CD8+ T cells. These early memory CD8+ T cells were capable of substantial secondary expansion in response to booster challenge at day 7 postinfection, resulting in significantly elevated numbers of secondary effector and memory CD8+ T cells and enhanced protective immunity compared with control-infected mice. Although early expansion in numbers is similar after L. monocytogenes infection of antibiotic-pretreated and control mice, the absence of sustained proliferation coupled with decreased killer cell lectin-like receptor G-1 up-regulation on responding CD8+ T cells may explain the rapid effector to memory CD8+ T cell transition. In addition, antibiotic treatment 2 days post-L. monocytogenes challenge accelerated the generation of CD8+ T cells with memory phenotype and function, and this accelerated memory generation was reversed in the presence of CpG-induced inflammation. Together, these data show that the rate at which Ag-specific CD8+ T cell populations acquire memory characteristics after infection is not fixed, but rather can be manipulated by limiting inflammation that will in turn modulate the timing and extent to which CD8+ T cells proliferate and up-regulate killer cell lectin-like receptor G-1 expression.     

Functional heterogeneity of memory CD4 T cell responses in different conditions of antigen exposure and persistence

Memory CD4 T cell responses are functionally and phenotypically heterogeneous. In the present study, memory CD4 T cell responses were analyzed in different models of Ag-specific immune responses differing on Ag exposure and/or persistence. Ag-specific CD4 T cell responses for tetanus toxoid, HSV, EBV, CMV, and HIV-1 were compared. Three distinct patterns of T cell response were observed. A dominant single IL-2 CD4 T cell response was associated with the model in which the Ag can be cleared. Polyfunctional (single IL-2 plus IL-2/IFN-gamma plus single IFN-gamma) CD4 T cell responses were associated with Ag persistence and low Ag levels. A dominant single IFN-gamma CD4 T cell response was associated with the model of Ag persistence and high Ag levels. The results obtained supported the hypothesis that the different patterns observed were substantially influenced by different conditions of Ag exposure and persistence.