Thiamine and Cholinergic Transmission in the Electric Organ of Torpedo

The electric organ of Torpedo marmorata was found to contain as much as 120 +/- 24 nmol of thiamine per g of fresh tissue. The vitamin was distributed as nonesterified thiamine (32%), thiamine monophosphate (22%), thiamine diphosphate (8%), and an important proportion of thiamine triphosphate (38%). A high level of thiamine triphosphate was found in synaptosomes isolated from the electric organ. In contrast, the synaptic vesicles did not show any enrichment in thiamine, whereas they contained a marked peak of acetylcholine (ACh) and ATP. Thus thiamine seems to be very abundant in cholinergic nerve terminals; its localization is apparently extravesicular, either in the axoplasm or in association with plasma membrane. When calcium was reduced and magnesium increased in the external medium, the efficiency of transmission was diminished, owing to inhibition of ACh release; in a parallel manner the degree of thiamine phosphorylation was found to increase--this condition is known to modify the repartition of ACh between vesicular and extravesicular compartments. Electrical stimulation, which causes periodic variations of the level of ACh and ATP, also caused significant changes in thiamine esters. In addition, related changes of the vitamin and the transmitter were observed under other conditions, suggesting a functional link between the metabolism of thiamine and that of ACh in cholinergic nerve terminals.     

The Synthesis, Storage, and Release of Propionylcholine by the Electric Organ of Torpedo marmorata

Abstract: Little is known about the specificity of the mechanisms involved in the synthesis and release of acetylcholine for the acetyl moiety. To test this, blocks of tissue from the electric organ of Torpedo were incubated with either [1-¹⁴C]acetate or [1-¹⁴C]propionate, and the synthesis, storage, and release of [1-¹⁴C]acetylcholine and [¹⁴C]propionylcholine were compared. To obtain equivalent amounts of the two labeled choline esters, a 50-fold higher concentration of propionate than of acetate was needed. Following subcellular fractionation, similar proportions of [¹⁴C]acetylcholine and [¹⁴C]propionylcholine were recovered with synaptosomes and with synaptic vesicles. Furthermore, both labeled choline esters were protected to a similar extent from degradation during homogenization of tissue in physiological medium, indicating that the two choline esters were equally well incorporated into synaptic vesicles. Yet depolarization of tissue blocks by 50 m M KCI released much less [¹⁴C]propionylcholinc than [¹⁴C]acetylcholine. During field stimulation of the tissue blocks, the difference between the releasibility of the two choline esters was less marked, but acetylcholine was still released in preference to propionylcholine. Evidence for specificity of the release mechanism was also obtained when the release of the two choline esters in response to field stimulation was compared in tissue blocks preincubated with both [³H]choline and [¹⁴C]propionate.     

Large-Scale Purification of Torpedo Electric Organ Synaptosomes

Abstract: A procedure for the large-scale purification of Torpedo electric organ synaptosomes is described. The synaptosomal fraction obtained is very pure as judged from biochemical and morphological data. In addition, acetylcholine (ACh) release was demonstrated after KCl depolarization of synaptosomes in the presence of calcium. Two hundred grams of electric organ can be fractionated in a single run, allowing biochemical studies on presynaptic membrane constituents.     

Uptake of Acetate and Propionate by Isolated Nerve Endings from the Electric Organ of Torpedo marmorata and Their Incorporation into Choline Esters

Abstract: The uptake and incorporation into choline esters of acetate and propionate by electric organ synaptosomes were compared, with the aim of better understanding the basis for the selectivity of choline ester synthesis shown by this tissue for acetate. It was found that propionate uptake, like acetate uptake, was a temperature-dependent, saturable process. Both uptake mechanisms had similar affinities for their substrates, but the maximal velocity of propionate uptake was considerably lower than that of acetate uptake; and less of the accumulated propionate was used for choline ester synthesis than of the accumulated acetate. While acetate was a good inhibitor of propionate uptake, propionate was a very poor inhibitor of acetate uptake. This finding, in addition to the observation that the two uptakes were not affected in the same way by changes in pH, led to the suggestion that acetate uptake and propionate uptake reflect different processes. In both cases, however, the pH dependence of uptake indicated that these substrates cross the membrane as the charged species. Acetate uptake and acetylcholine synthesis remained closely associated under various experimental conditions, while propionate uptake could be dissociated from the synthesis of propionylcholine. Hence, it appears that acetate is taken up by a specific, high-velocity mechanism linked to acetylcholine synthesis, whereas propionate uptake may represent a less specific mechanism.     

Identification of Actin in Highly Purified Synaptic Vesicles from the Electric Organ of Torpedo marmorata

Abstract: Evidence has been obtained that actin is a major constituent of highly purified synaptic vesicles isolated from the electric organ of Torpedo marmorata . The mobility of a prominent spot in the polypeptide pattern of vesicles in high-resolution two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis is very similar to the mobility of the main component in the actin preparation purified from the whole electric organ by affinity chromatography on immobilized pancreatic deoxyribonuclease I. The comparison of tryptic peptide maps obtained from the putative vesicle actin and authentic actin from the electric organ, both purified by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and labeled in situ with ¹²⁵I, showed about 88% homology, thereby supporting the conclusion that the vesicle actin is indeed an actin isoform.     

Ganglioside Composition of Synaptic Vesicles from Torpedo Electric Organ

We have studied the ganglioside content and pattern of synaptic vesicles isolated from the electric organs of two species of Torpedinidae, Torpedo californica and Torpedo marmorata. The ganglioside concentrations were high relative to protein content (77 and 58 micrograms of N-acetylneuraminic acid/mg of protein, respectively), owing to the low protein-to-lipid ratio; however, they were also appreciable in relation to phospholipid (15.6 and 10.0 micrograms of N-acetylneuraminic acid/mg of phospholipid). The fact that a membrane fraction that separated from synaptic vesicles of T. californica on a controlled-pore glass-bead column and constituted the main potential source of contamination in this preparation had a lower ganglioside content and a different TLC pattern than synaptic vesicles indicated the relatively high purity of the latter. Most of the gangliosides from synaptic vesicles of both species migrated on TLC in the vicinity of standards with three or more sialic acids. Synaptosomes from T. marmorata had a higher lipid N-acetylneuraminic acid/phospholipid ratio and a different TLC pattern than synaptic vesicles. Considering these results and other data appearing recently in the literature, we suggest that reexamination of synaptic vesicles from mammalian brain for the possible presence of gangliosides is warranted.     

Continuous Determination by a Chemiluminescent Method of Acetylcholine Release and Compartmentation in Torpedo Electric Organ Synaptosomes

Abstract: The detection of acetylcholine (ACh) with a chemiluminescent procedure enables one to follow continuously the release of transmitter from stimulated synaptosomes and to study the compartmentation of ACh in resting and active nerve terminals. A compartment of ACh liberated almost entirely by a single freezing and thawing could be directly measured and compared with a compartment of ACh resistant to several cycles of freezing and thawing but liberated by a detergent (60–70% of the total). It is the compartment liberated by freezing and thawing that is reduced when synaptosomes are stimulated. Up to half the total synaptosomal ACh content is readily releasable provided the calcium entry is maintained, or if a strong releasing agent such as the venom of Glycera convoluta is used. In addition, it is shown that synaptosomes contain only negligible amounts of choline, and that the proportion of the two ACh compartments is not influenced by changing extracellular calcium just before their determination.     

Cetiedil, a Drug That Inhibits Acetylcholine Release in Torpedo Electric Organ

The effects of cetiedil, a vasodilatator substance with reported anticholinergic properties, were examined on cholinergic presynaptic functions at the nerve electroplaque junction of Torpedo marmorata using either synaptosomes or slices of intact tissue. Cetiedil abolished the calcium-dependent release of acetylcholine (ACh) triggered by depolarization or by addition of A23187 ionophore, a finding localizing the site of action downstream from the calcium entry step. In addition, a direct effect on the release process itself was indicated by the observation that cetiedil blocks the release of ACh mediated by a recently isolated presynaptic membrane protein, the mediatophore, reconstituted into ACh-containing proteoliposomes. In all three preparations, ACh release was inhibited by cetiedil with a Ki of 5-8 microM. Under the conditions used in these release experiments, the synthesis of ACh and its compartmentation within the nerve terminals were not modified. However, the drug was able to reduce high-affinity choline uptake and vesicular ACh incorporation when it was given together with the radioactive precursor, a result showing that cetiedil has a broad inhibitory action on cholinergic uptake processes.     

Incorporation of Acetate into Acetylcholine, Acetylcarnitine, and Amino Acids in the Torpedo Electric Organ

The metabolism of acetate was investigated in the nerve-electroplaque system of Torpedo marmorata. In intact fragments of electric organ, radiolabeled acetate was incorporated into acetylcholine (ACh), acetylcarnitine (ACar), and three amino acids: aspartate, glutamate, and glutamine. These compounds were identified by TLC, high-voltage electrophoresis, column chromatography, and enzymic tests. The system responsible for acetate transport and incorporation into ACh displayed a higher affinity but a lower Vmax than that involved in the synthesis of ACar and amino acids. Choline, when added to the medium, increased the rate of acetate incorporation into ACh but decreased (at concentrations greater than 10(-5) M) that into ACar and amino acids. Monofluoroacetate slightly depressed ACh and ACar synthesis from external acetate but inhibited much more the synthesis of amino acids. During repetitive nerve stimulation, the level of the newly synthetized [14C]ACh was found to oscillate together with that of endogenous ACh, but the level of neither [14C]ACar nor the 14C-labeled amino acids exhibited any significant change as a function of time. This means that there is probably no periodic transfer of acetyl groups between ACh and the investigated metabolites in the course of activity. Acetate metabolism was also tested in the electric lobe (which contains the cell bodies of the neurons innervating the electric organ) and in Torpedo synaptosomes (which are nerve terminals isolated from the same neurons). Radioactive pyruvate and glutamine were also assayed in some experiments for comparison with acetate. These observations are discussed in connection with ACh metabolism under resting and active conditions in tissues where acetate is the preferred precursor of the neurotransmitter.     

Purification and Characterization of a Peptidyl Dipeptidase Resembling Angiotensin Converting Enzyme from the Electric Organ of Torpedo marmorata

The electric organ of Torpedo marmorata contains a membrane-bound, captopril-sensitive metallopeptidase that resembles mammalian angiotensin converting enzyme (peptidyl dipeptidase A; EC 3.4.15.1). The Torpedo enzyme has now been purified to apparent homogeneity from electric organ by a procedure involving affinity chromatography using the selective inhibitor lisinopril immobilised to Sepharose via a 28-A spacer arm. The purified protein, like the mammalian enzyme, acted as a peptidyl dipeptidase in cleaving dipeptides from the C-terminus of a variety of peptide substrates, including angiotensin I, bradykinin, [Met5]enkephalin, [Leu5]enkephalin, and the model substrate hippuryl (benzoylglycyl; BzGly)-His-Leu. The hydrolysis of BzGly-His-Leu was activated by Cl-. Enzyme activity was inhibited by classical angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors, including captopril, enalaprilat (MK422), and lisinopril (MK521). Torpedo angiotensin converting enzyme, like its mammalian counterpart, was also able to act as an endopeptidase in hydrolysing the amidated neuropeptide substance P. Hydrolysis of substance P occurred primarily at the Phe8-Gly9 bond with release of the C-terminal tripeptide, Gly-Leu-MetNH2, and this hydrolysis was blocked by selective inhibitors. The Torpedo enzyme was recognised by a polyclonal antibody to pig kidney angiotensin converting enzyme on immunoelectrophoretic (Western) blot analysis. Thus, on the basis of substrate specificity, inhibitor sensitivity, and immunological criteria, the Torpedo enzyme closely resembles mammalian angiotensin converting enzyme. However, the Torpedo enzyme appears somewhat larger (Mr = 190,000) than the pig kidney enzyme (Mr = 180,000) on sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The endogenous peptide substrate(s) for Torpedo electric organ angiotensin converting enzyme and the physiological role of the enzyme in this tissue remain to be evaluated.     

Inactive Monomeric Acetyleholinesterase in the Low-Salt-Soluble Extract of the Electric Organ from Torpedo marmorata

Proteolytic fragmentation of [3H]diisopropylfluorophosphate-labelled catalytic subunits of different molecular forms of acetylcholinesterase demonstrates that all forms extracted from the electric organ from Torpedo marmorata are true acetylcholinesterases. This is supported by immunochemical results showing that the radiolabelled polypeptides are readily recognized by specific anti-acetylcholinesterase antibodies. Although distinct structural differences exist, all forms contain a similar peptide carrying the serine hydroxyl of the esteratic subsite. Dimeric, detergent-soluble acetylcholinesterase is present in the low-salt-soluble extract (Mr of the catalytic subunit 66,000) together with a monomeric form (apparent Mr 76,000). This monomeric polypeptide is hydrophilic, enzymatically inactive, and might represent a precursor of the asymmetric forms of acetylcholinesterase.     

Energy Metabolism and Quantal Acetylcholine Release: Effects of Botulinum Toxin, l-Fluoro-2,4-Dinitrobenzene, and Diamide in the Torpedo Electric Organ

In the Torpedo electric organ, a modified nerve-muscle system, type A botulinum toxin blocked the release of acetylcholine (ACh) quanta, both neurally evoked and spontaneous. At the same time, the toxin increased the release of a class of small miniature potentials (the subminiature potentials), reduced the ATP and more the creatine phosphate content of the tissue, and impaired the activity of creatine kinase (CK). Thus, we compared this pattern of changes with those provoked by 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (FDNB), an efficient inhibitor of CK. As expected, FDNB rapidly inactivated CK, which resulted in a profound depletion of ATP whereas the stores of creatine phosphate were preserved. In addition, FDNB caused conspicuous morphological alterations of nerve endings and ACh depletion. This agent also suppressed evoked and spontaneous quantal release whereas the occurrence of subminature potentials was markedly increased. Diamide, a penetrating thiol oxidizing substance, provoked first a transient rise in quantal ACh release and then blockade of transmission with, again, production of a large number of subminiature potentials. Creatine phosphate was depleted in the tissue by diamide, the ATP content reduced, and CK activity partly inhibited. The morphology of nerve terminals did not show obvious changes with either diamide or botulinum toxin at the stage of transmission failure. Although the three poisons acted by different mechanisms, this resulted in a rather similar pattern of physiological changes: failure of quantal release and enhancement of subquantal release. These results and experiments on synaptosomes indicated that CK inhibition was probably a crucial mechanism for FDNB but not for diamide or botulinum intoxication.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Origin of the Bicarbonate Stimulation of Torpedo Electric Organ Synaptic Vesicle ATPase

Abstract: The origin of the stimulation by bicarbonate of the ATPase found in cholinergic synaptic vesicles isolated from Torpedo californica electric organ was studied. Given in descending order of potency, the anions formate, malonate, acetate, thiosulfate, cyanate, biphosphite, biselenite, and bisulfite also stimulate to lesser extents. The anion channel blockers 4-acetamido-4'-isothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid (SITS) and 4,4'-diisothiocyanostil-bene-2,2'-disulfonic acid (DIDS) inactivated the ATPase at micromolar concentrations, but there was no indication that the reagents acted to block an anion channel. The LineweaverBurk plot of the basal ATPase activity was biphasic, indicating high- and low–affinity states with K_ms of 0.0098 ' 0.0013 and 1.2 ' 0.1 mM for V _maxs of 52 ' 2 and 82 ' 9 nmol/min/mg protein, respectively. It became nearly linear in the presence of bicarbonate, indicating conversion of all of the ATPase to one high affinity-high velocity state with a K _m of 0.054 ' 0.009 mM and a V _max of 232 ' 0.051 nmol/min/mg protein. The pH activity profile for basal ATPase was bell-shaped and optimal between pH 6 and 8. The bicarbonate stimulation was maximal at about pH 7. The ATPase could be solubilized in 1.6% Lubrol WX with full retention of the bicarbonate stimulation. Although ouabain and oligomycin act at high concentrations to inhibit bicarbonate stimulation of the ATPase, there is no contamination by the Na⁺-K⁺ ATPase, mitochondrial ATPase, or other common ATPases. The study suggests that bicarbonate acts to stimulate the ATPase by acting directly on it at an allosteric site on the outside of the synaptic vesicle.     

Development of the electromotor system in Torpedo marmorata: Cationic staining of the electric organ

Summary The electric organs of embryonic Torpedo marmorala have been reacted with three cationic stains to evaluate the appearance and distribution of anionic sites. Ruthenium red, alcian blue and lysozyme were used at different pHs and found to react in a time-related manner to anionic components within the interelectrocyte space. The basal lamina covering the ventral electrocyte surface possesses the greatest number of anionic sites whereas growth cone, presynaptic terminal and glial membranes displayed almost no staining. Since this lamina serves as the exclusive substrate for ingrowing neuntes during synaptogenesis, the results are consistent with the idea that charge distribution on the membrane surface may provide a necessary cue for neurite motility, extension and eventual synaptogenesis.     

Phorbol Esters Induce Neurotransmitter Release in Cholinergic Synaptosomes from Torpedo Electric Organ

The effect of phorbol esters and so the involvement of Ca2+/phospholipid-dependent protein kinase (protein kinase C;PKC) in the release of acetylcholine (ACh) was studied using Torpedo electric organ synaptosomes. 12-O-Tetradecanoylphorbol 13-acetate (TPA), a known activator of PKC, induced neurotransmitter release in a concentration-dependent manner and increased the potassium-evoked release of ACh. The effect of TPA was shown to be independent of the extrasynaptosomal calcium concentration. TPA-induced ACh release was reversed by H-7, an inhibitor of PKC activity. This drug showed no effect on potassium-evoked ACh release. Botulinum toxin, a strong blocker of potassium-induced ACh release in that synaptosomal preparation, showed no inhibitory effect on the TPA-induced ACh release. Our results suggest that activation of PKC potentiates the release of an ACh pool that is not releasable by potassium depolarization, independently of the extracellular calcium concentration.     

Muscarinic Acetylcholine Receptors in Torpedo Electric Organ: Effect of Guanine Nucleotides

Abstract: The effect of guanine nucleotides on the binding properties of presynaptic muscarinic receptors has been studied in a membrane preparation from the electric organ of Torpedo marmorata by measuring the competitive displacement of the radiolabelled antagonist, [³H]quinuclidinyl benzilate, by nonradioactive muscarinic ligands. The binding of the antagonists, atropine, scopolamine and pirenzepine was to a single class of sites [slope factors (pseudo Hill coefficients) close to 1] and was unaffected by 0.1 m M GTP. The binding of the N -methylated antagonists, N -methylatropine and N -methyl-scopolamine was more complex (slope factors <1) but also insensitive ( N- methylatropine) to 0.1 m M GTP. Agonist binding was complex and could be resolved into two binding sites with relatively high and low affinities. The proportion of high-affinity sites varied with the nature of the agonist (15–80%). Agonist binding was depressed by 0.1 m M GTP, and the order of sensitivity was oxotremorine-M > carbamoylcholine > muscarine > acetylcholine > arecoline > oxotremorine. The binding of pilocarpine, a partial agonist, was unaffected by GTP. With carbamoylcholine as a test ligand the GTP effect on agonist binding was half-maximal at 12 μM. GDP and guanylylimidodiphosphate produced comparable inhibition of carbamoylcholine binding, but GMP and cyclic GMP were ineffective, as were various adenine nucleotides. Analysis of agonist binding in terms of a two-site model indicates that the predominant effect of guanine nucleotides is to reduce the number of sites of higher affinity.     

AH5183 and Cetiedil: Two Potent Inhibitors of Acetylcholine Uptake into Isolated Synaptic Vesicles from Torpedo marmorata

Synaptic vesicles purified on a sucrose-KCl sedimentation gradient were tested for their ability to accumulate [1-14C]acetylcholine ([1-14C]ACh) in the absence and in the presence of AH5183 and cetiedil. Kinetic studies of ACh transport showed that it was time dependent and saturable as a function of ACh concentration, with a KT of 1.2 mM. The protein-modifying agents N-ethylmaleimide and 4-chloro-7-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole were powerful inhibitors of ACh uptake. In agreement with other studies, AH5183 was found to be a potent inhibitor of ACh uptake by synaptic vesicles. Inhibition was of the mixed noncompetitive type, and the inhibition constant was 45.2 +/- 3.4 nM. Cetiedil, a drug that resembles ACh, was previously shown on intact nerve endings to inhibit the translocation of newly synthesized ACh into the synaptic vesicle compartment, and we demonstrate here that cetiedil is indeed an efficient blocker of ACh uptake by isolated synaptic vesicles. It acted as a competitive inhibitor, with a Ki of 118.5 +/- 9.5 nM. Neither ATP-dependent calcium uptake nor Mg2+-ATPase activity was affected by the drugs, a finding showing their specificity toward the ACh uptake process. The binding of L-[3H]AH5183 to intact vesicles was characterized in the absence or the presence of ACh or cetiedil. Saturation experiments showed a total binding capacity of approximately 126 pmol/mg of vesicular protein and a dissociation constant of 19.9 +/- 4.1 nM under control conditions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Acetylcholine, ATP, and Proteoglycan Are Common to Synaptic Vesicles Isolated from the Electric Organs of Electric Eel and Electric Catfish as Well as from Rat Diaphragm

Cholinergic synaptic vesicles were isolated from the electric organs of the electric eel (Electrophorus electricus) and the electric catfish (Malapterurus electricus) as well as from the diaphragm of the rat by density gradient centrifugation followed by column chromatography on Sephacryl-1000. This was verified by both biochemical and electron microscopic criteria. Differences in size between synaptic vesicles from the various tissue sources were reflected by their elution pattern from the Sephacryl column. Specific activities of acetylcholine (ACh; in nmol/mg of protein) of chromatography-purified vesicle fractions were 36 (electric eel), 2 (electric catfish), and 1 (rat diaphragm). Synaptic vesicles from all three sources contained ATP in addition to ACh (molar ratios of ACh/ATP, 9-12) as well as binding activity for an antibody raised against Torpedo cholinergic synaptic vesicle proteoglycan. Synaptic vesicles from rat diaphragm contained binding activity for the monoclonal antibody asv 48 raised against a rat brain 65-kilodalton synaptic vesicle protein. Antibody asv 48 binding was absent from electric eel and electric catfish synaptic vesicles. These antibody binding results, which were obtained by a dot blot assay on isolated vesicles, directly correspond to the immunocytochemical results demonstrating fluorescein isothiocyanate staining in the respective nerve terminals. Our results imply that ACh, ATP, and proteoglycan are common molecular constituents of motor nerve terminal-derived synaptic vesicles from Torpedo to rat. In addition to ACh, both ATP and proteoglycan may play a specific role in the process of cholinergic signal transmission.     

A Kinetic Study of Stimulus-Induced Vesicle Recycling in Electromotor Nerve Terminals Using Labile and Stable Vesicle Markers

The kinetics of recovery, by recycling electromotor synaptic vesicles, of the biophysical parameters of the reserve population has been studied in perfused blocks of electric organ of Torpedo marmorata prestimulated in vivo, followed by density gradient separation of the extracted vesicles in a zonal rotor using labile (acetylcholine and ATP) and stable (proteoglycan) vesicle markers. Stimulation in vivo at 0.15 Hz for 3.3 h depleted tissue acetylcholine much less than stimulation at 1 Hz for 1 h but nevertheless generated a much larger pool of recycled vesicles that recovered more slowly. At the lower rate of stimulation, recovery of the biophysical characteristics of the reserve population by the recycled vesicles, identified by their content of newly synthesized transmitter, was essentially complete by 8 h. The stable proteoglycan marker was immunochemically assayed and was bimodally distributed in the vesicle-containing portion of the density gradient even in experiments with unstimulated or recovered tissue. The second peak corresponded with that of newly synthesized transmitter and was thus identified as containing the recycled vesicles. Its normalized acetylcholine/proteoglycan ratio was lower than that of the first peak, which is consistent with earlier findings that recycled vesicles, before recovery, are only partially loaded with transmitter. However, as expected, the proportion of total vesicular proteoglycan and acetylcholine associated with the recycled vesicle fraction was very much lower in preparations derived from unstimulated or recovered tissue than in those from recently stimulated tissue.     

The Kinetics of Acetylcholine Turnover in a Resting Cholinergic Nerve Terminal and the Magnitude of the Cytoplasmic Compartment

Abstract: The magnitude of the cytosolic pool of acetylcholine in the cholinergic electromotor nerve terminals of Torpedo marmorata has been calculated to be 22 ± 3% of the total by comparing the isotopic ratio of acetylcholine with that of choline when slices of electric organ were incubated with 10 μM deuterated choline. The calculation is based on a two-compartment model that assumes the presence, in unstimulated tissue, of a vesicular pool of acetylcholine that does not exchange, under resting conditions, with a second cytosolic pool; the latter, by contrast, is subject to 'futile recycling' and comes into isotopic equilibrium with the tissue choline pool.