Synergistic effects in mixed Escherichia coli biofilms: conjugative plasmid transfer drives biofilm expansion

Bacterial biofilms, often composed of multiple species and genetically distinct strains, develop under complex influences of cell-cell interactions. Although detailed knowledge about the mechanisms underlying formation of single-species laboratory biofilms has emerged, little is known about the pathways governing development of more complex heterogeneous communities. In this study, we established a laboratory model where biofilm-stimulating effects due to interactions between genetically diverse strains of Escherichia coli were monitored. Synergistic induction of biofilm formation resulting from the cocultivation of 403 undomesticated E. coli strains with a characterized E. coli K-12 strain was detected at a significant frequency. The survey suggests that different mechanisms underlie the observed stimulation, yet synergistic development of biofilm within the subset of E. coli isolates (n = 56) exhibiting the strongest effects was most often linked to conjugative transmission of natural plasmids carried by the E. coli isolates (70%). Thus, the capacity of an isolate to promote the biofilm through cocultivation was (i) transferable to the K-12 strain, (ii) was linked with the acquisition of conjugation genes present initially in the isolate, and (iii) was inhibited through the presence in the cocultured K-12 strain of a related conjugative plasmid, presumably due to surface exclusion functions. Synergistic effects of cocultivation of pairs of natural isolates were also observed, demonstrating that biofilm promotion in this system is not dependent on the laboratory strain and that the described model system could provide relevant insights on mechanisms of biofilm development in natural E. coli populations.     

Effect of Escherichia coli morphogene bolA on biofilms

Biofilm physiology is established under a low growth rate. The morphogene bolA is mostly expressed under stress conditions or in stationary phase, suggesting that bolA could be implicated in biofilm development. In order to verify this hypothesis, we tested the effect of bolA on biofilm formation. Overexpression of bolA induces biofilm development, while bolA deletion decreases biofilms.     

Synergistic activity and mode of action of flavonoids isolated from smaller galangal and amoxicillin combinations against amoxicillin-resistant Escherichia coli

Aim: The smaller galangal is extracted, purified and identified the bioactive compounds. The purpose of this research was to investigate whether these isolated compounds have antibacterial and synergistic activity against amoxicillin‐resistant Escherichia coli (AREC) when used singly and in combination with amoxicillin. The primarily mode of action is also studied. Method and Results: The galangin, kaempferide and kaempferide‐3‐O‐β‐d ‐glucoside were isolated. The minimum inhibitory concentrations(MIC) of amoxicillin and these flavonoids against AREC were between 500 and >1000 μg ml^?1. Synergistic activity was observed on combining amoxicillin with these flavonoids. The combinations of amoxicillin and these flavonoids exhibited a synergistic effect, reducing AREC cell numbers. Electron microscopy showed that these combinations damaged the ultrastructure of AREC cells. The results indicated that these combinations altered outer membrane permeability but not affecting cytoplasmic membrane. Enzyme assays showed that these flavonoids had an inhibitory activity against penicillinase. Conclusion: These results indicated that these flavonoids have the potential to reverse bacterial resistance to amoxicillin in AREC and may operate via three mechanisms: inhibition of peptidoglycan and ribosome synthesis, alteration of outer membrane permeability, and interaction with β‐lactamases. Significance and Impact of the Study: These findings offer the potential to develop a new generation of phytopharmaceuticals to treat AREC.     

A simple in vitro model for growth control of bacterial biofilms

The perfused biofilm fermenter was found to be unsuitable for the long-term culture and growth rate control of Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosab biofilms. In a simplified approach, biofilms of these organisms were grown within Sorbarod filter plugs which were perfused with culture medium. Pseudo-steady states were established which were stable over several days at which the growth rate of the biofilm was reproducible, measurable and significantly slower than in broth culture. Environmental scanning electron microscopy of dissected Sorbarods demonstrated an association of cells with the surfaces of individual cellulose fibres, and growth characteristic of biofilms. Relatively high cell numbers recovered from the Sorbarod model facilitated biochemical investigations of biofilm populations and cells released spontaneously from them.
SDS-PAGE demonstrated significant differences between the protein profiles of biofilm and eluted populations, which include, in Staph. aureus , the repression of a 48 kDa protein and increased expression of a 21 kDa protein relative to planktonic controls cultured at equivalent growth rates. The paper demonstrates the suitability of the approach for the culture of biofilm samples which are suitable for biochemical analysis.     

A simple in vitro model for growth control of bacterial biofilms

The perfused biofilm fermenter was found to be unsuitable for the long-term culture and growth rate control of Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms. In a simplified approach, biofilms of these organisms were grown within Sorbarod filter plugs which were perfused with culture medium. Pseudo-steady states were established which were stable over several days at which the growth rate of the biofilm was reproducible, measurable and significantly slower than in broth culture. Environmental scanning electron microscopy of dissected Sorbarods demonstrated an association of cells with the surfaces of individual cellulose fibres, and growth characteristic of biofilms. Relatively high cell numbers recovered from the Sorbarod model facilitated biochemical investigations of biofilm populations and cells released spontaneously from them. SDS-PAGE demonstrated significant differences between the protein profiles of biofilm and eluted populations, which include, in Staph. aureus, the repression of a 48 kDa protein and increased expression of a 21 kDa protein relative to planktonic controls cultured at equivalent growth rates. The paper demonstrates the suitability of the approach for the culture of biofilm samples which are suitable for biochemical analysis.     

Influence of flow rate variation on the development of Escherichia coli biofilms

This work investigates the effect of flow rate variation on mass transfer and on the development of Escherichia coli biofilms on a flow cell reactor under turbulent flow conditions. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) was used to assess the applicability of this reactor for the simulation of industrial and biomedical biofilms and the numerical results were validated by streak photography. Two flow rates of 374 and 242 L h^?1 (corresponding to Reynolds numbers of 6,720 and 4,350) were tested and wall shear stresses between 0.183 and 0.511 Pa were predicted in the flow cell reactor. External mass transfer coefficients of 1.38 × 10^?5 and 9.64 × 10^?6 m s^?1 were obtained for the higher and lower flow rates, respectively. Biofilm formation was favored at the lowest flow rate because shear stress effects were more important than mass transfer limitations. This flow cell reactor generates wall shear stresses that are similar to those found in some industrial and biomedical settings, thus it is likely that the results obtained on this work can be used in the development of biofilm control strategies in both scenarios.     

Novel phage-based bio-processing of pathogenic Escherichia coli and its biofilms

To explore new approaches of phage-based bio-process of specifically pathogenic Escherichia coli bacteria in food products within a short period. One hundred and forty highly lytic designed coliphages were used. Escherichia coli naturally contaminated and Enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli experimentally inoculated samples of lettuce, cabbage, meat, and egg were used. In addition, experimentally produced biofilms of E. coli were tested. A phage concentration of 10³ PFU/ml was used for food products immersion, and for spraying of food products, 10⁵ PFU/ml of a phage cocktail was used by applying a 20-s optimal dipping time in a phage cocktail. Food samples were cut into pieces and were either sprayed with or held in a bag immersed in lambda buffer containing a cocktail of 140 phages. Phage bio-processing was successful in eliminating completely E. coli in all processed samples after 48 h storage at 4°C. Partial elimination of E. coli was observed in earlier storage periods (7 and 18 h) at 24° and 37°C. Moreover, E. coli biofilms were reduced >3 log cycles upon using the current phage bio-processing. The use of a phage cocktail of 140 highly lytic designed phages proved highly effective in suppressing E. coli contaminating food products. Proper decontamination/prevention methods of pathogenic E. coli achieved in this study can replace the current chemically less effective decontamination methods.     

Effect of Phosphorus on survival of Escherichia coli in drinking water biofilms

The effect of phosphorus addition on survival of Escherichia coli in an experimental drinking water distribution system was investigated. Higher phosphorus concentrations prolonged the survival of culturable E. coli in water and biofilms. Although phosphorus addition did not affect viable but not culturable (VBNC) E. coli in biofilms, these structures could act as a reservoir of VBNC forms of E. coli in drinking water distribution systems.     

Possible involvement of the division cycle in dispersal of Escherichia coli from biofilms.

Growth rate control of adherent, sessile populations was achieved by the controlled perfusion of membrane-associated bacterial biofilms by the method of Gilbert et al. (P. Gilbert, D. G. Allison, D. J. Evans, P. S. Handley, and M. R. W. Brown, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55:1308-1311, 1989). Changes in cell surface hydrophobicity were evaluated with respect to growth rate for such sessile Escherichia coli cells and compared with those of suspended (planktonic) populations grown in a chemostat. Newly formed daughter cells shed at the various growth rates from the biofilm during its growth and development were also included in the study. Surface hydrophobicity decreased with growth rate similarly for both planktonic and sessile E. coli; no significant differences were noted between the two. Daughter cells dislodged from the biofilm, however, were significantly more hydrophilic than those remaining, indicating that hydrophobicity changed during the division cycle. Our data support the hypothesis that dispersal of cells from adhesive biofilms and recolonization of new surfaces reflect cell-cycle-mediated events.     

Synergistic effect of migrating Ascaris larvae and Escherichia coli in piglets

The effect of intestinal flora on the establishment, development and pathogenicity of Ascaris suum larvae in piglets (Large White breed) was investigated. The infected piglets with Ascaris and Escherichia coli showed signs of pneumonia, cough with respiratory difficulties initially even though these moderated with time. They lost appetite and showed signs of unthriftiness with loss of weight. The packed cell volume was normal but the differential leucocyte counts of the pigs infected with Ascaris larvae and bacteria had high neutrophils, unlike the very high lymphocyte count observed in piglets with ascarids only. The piglets had generalized serous atrophy of body fat. The pericardial and perirenal fats were gelatinous. There was a firm and nodular grey and red hepatization with abscess pockets in the intermediate and anterior one third of the diaphragmatic lobes of the lungs. The liver contained greyish-white and depressed focus immediately dorsal to the area of attachment to the gall bladder with multifocal areas. There was no significant gross lesion in the control animals. Cultural and microscopic examinations of some internal organs of the infected animals showed that bacteria were carried to the lungs by the migrating Ascaris larvae. The combined synergistic effect of Ascaris larvae and E. coli was also investigated and it was concluded that the two agents (A. suum larvae and E. coli) worked together synergistically.     

Exposure of conjugative plasmid carrying Escherichia coli biofilms to male-specific bacteriophages

Escherichia coli carrying a natural conjugative F-plasmid generates F-pili mating pairs, which is important for early biofilm formation. In this study, we investigated the effect of male-specific filamentous single stranded DNA bacteriophage (f1) and RNA bacteriophage (MS2) on the formation of biofilms by E. coli carrying a natural conjugative F-plasmid. We showed that the early biofilm formation was completely inhibited by addition of the f1 phage, but not the MS2 phage. This suggests that the tip of F-pili is the specific attachment site for mating pairs formation and the side of F-pili has a non-obligatory role during biofilm formation. The inhibitory effect of the f1 phage was dependent on the time of addition during the biofilm formation. No inhibitory effect was observed when the f1 phages were added to the mature biofilms. This resistant mechanism of the mature biofilms could be attributed to the biofilm-specific phenotypes representing that the F-pili mating pairs were already formed and then the curli production commenced during the biofilm maturation. The pre-formed mating pairs seemed to resist the f1 phages. Altogether, our results indicate a close relationship between the presence of conjugative plasmid and male-specific bacteriophages within sessile biofilm communities, as well as the possibility of using the male-specific bacteriophages to control biofilm formation.     

Escherichia coli biofilms formed under low-shear modeled microgravity in a ground-based system

Bacterial biofilms cause chronic diseases that are difficult to control. Since biofilm formation in space is well documented and planktonic cells become more resistant and virulent under modeled microgravity, it is important to determine the effect of this gravity condition on biofilms. Inclusion of glass microcarrier beads of appropriate dimensions and density with medium and inoculum, in vessels specially designed to permit ground-based investigations into aspects of low-shear modeled microgravity (LSMMG), facilitated these studies. Mathematical modeling of microcarrier behavior based on experimental conditions demonstrated that they satisfied the criteria for LSMMG conditions. Experimental observations confirmed that the microcarrier trajectory in the LSMMG vessel concurred with the predicted model. At 24 h, the LSMMG Escherichia coli biofilms were thicker than their normal-gravity counterparts and exhibited increased resistance to the general stressors salt and ethanol and to two antibiotics (penicillin and chloramphenicol). Biofilms of a mutant of E. coli, deficient in sigma(s), were impaired in developing LSMMG-conferred resistance to the general stressors but not to the antibiotics, indicating two separate pathways of LSMMG-conferred resistance.     

Increased transfer of a multidrug resistance plasmid in Escherichia coli biofilms at the air-liquid interface

Although biofilms represent a common bacterial lifestyle in clinically and environmentally important habitats, there is scant information on the extent of gene transfer in these spatially structured populations. The objective of this study was to gain insight into factors that affect transfer of the promiscuous multidrug resistance plasmid pB10 in Escherichia coli biofilms. Biofilms were grown in different experimental settings, and plasmid transfer was monitored using laser scanning confocal microscopy and plate counting. In closed flow cells, plasmid transfer in surface-attached submerged biofilms was negligible. In contrast, a high plasmid transfer efficiency was observed in a biofilm floating at the air-liquid interface in an open flow cell with low flow rates. A vertical flow cell and a batch culture biofilm reactor were then used to detect plasmid transfer at different depths away from the air-liquid interface. Extensive plasmid transfer occurred only in a narrow zone near that interface. The much lower transfer frequencies in the lower zones coincided with rapidly decreasing oxygen concentrations. However, when an E. coli csrA mutant was used as the recipient, a thick biofilm was obtained at all depths, and plasmid transfer occurred at similar frequencies throughout. These results and data from separate aerobic and anaerobic matings suggest that oxygen can affect IncP-1 plasmid transfer efficiency, not only directly but also indirectly, through influencing population densities and therefore colocalization of donors and recipients. In conclusion, the air-liquid interface can be a hot spot for plasmid-mediated gene transfer due to high densities of juxtaposed donor and recipient cells.