The ability of the epithelium of diencephalic origin to differentiate into cells of the ocular lens.

After the discovery that in adult salamanders following lentectomy a new, functional lens develops by transdifferentiation (cell-type conversion) of previously depigmented epithelial cells of the iris (Wolffian lens regeneration), this phenomenon has been intensively studied by various experimental approaches. During the last two decades it was shown that pleiomorphic aggregates of atypical lens cells (lentoids) differentiated in reaggregates of dissociated cells of the chick neural retina and in spread cell cultures of the pigmented epithelium of the iris and retina, of the neural retina and the pineal gland of the chick embryo. The neural retina of human fetuses and adults also displayed this capacity. We showed that lentoids developed at a low incidence in renal isografts of rat embryonic shields or isolated embryonic ectoderm and of lentectomized eyes of rat fetuses, as well as in organ cultures of rat embryonic shields in chemically defined media. The addition of transferrin significantly increased the incidence of differentiation of lentoids in explants. In both renal isografts and explants in vitro a continuous transformation of retinal epithelial cells into atypical lens cells was observed. In renal isografts lentoids were also observed to originate from the ependyma of the brain ventricle. All tissues having the capacity to convert into lens cells belong to the diencephalon in a broad sense. Evolutionary aspects of this feature are discussed.     

Expression of Neuronal Specificities in "Transdifferentiating" Cultures of Neural Retina

Cells dissociated from the neural retina of embryonic chick differentiate into lens and pigment cells, when cultured in vitro. Using 3.5-day-old and 8.5-day-old chick embryos, we examined whether neuronal specificities would be expressed in such transdifferentiating cultures of neural retinal cells. The synthesis of acetylcholine and γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) and the activity of choline acetyl transferase (CAT) was searched for in these cultures. The synthesis of an appreciable amount of these two putative neurotransmitters was detected in cultures of 3.5-day-old embryonic retinas by about 15 days. The activity of CAT was maximum in 7-day cultures of the 3.5-day-old materials and in 2-day cultures of the 8.5-day-old materials, and then decreased. Concomitant with the decrease of CAT-activity, δ-crystallin became detectable and increased thereafter. CAT-activity changed in parallel with the increase in the number of small neuroblast-like cells in cultures. The results demonstrate that the neuronal specificity identified by the appearance of acetylcholine and GABA and of the enzyme for the synthesis of acetylcholine is expressed in the early period of transdifferentiating cultures, which would later differentiate into lens and pigment cells. The possible mechanisms of the transition from neuronal to non-neuroretinal specificities of the transdifferentiating cultures are discussed.     

THE INFLUENCE OF GROWTH-INHIBITING AND GROWTH-PROMOTING MEDIUM CONDITIONS ON CRYSTALLIN ACCUMULATION IN TRANSDIFFERENTIATING CULTURES OF EMBRYONIC CHICK NEURAL RETINA

The effects of media containing undialysed serum (controls) or dialysed serum with or without ascorbic acid, were compared during the second half of the 41-day culture period in embryonic chick neural retina cultures, which had all been grown in control medium prior to 19 days. Conditions permitting greatest culture growth (controls) showed earlier and more extensive development of lentoids, greater accumulation of total crystallin and a higher proportion of δ relative to α+β crystallins. Conditions allowing least culture growth (dialysed serum) gave converse results throughout. Thus changes in culture growth rate apparently affect δ crystallin production more than α or β crystallin production. Insulin promotes growth in neural retina cultures, whether present throughout the culture period (in this case 31 days), or only from 18 days onwards. The frequency and survival of putative neuronal cell aggregates are both increased by insulin during the first 18 days of culture. Delta crystallin production during subsequent transdifferentiation is selectively promoted by insulin when present throughout, but this effect is largely obviated when insulin is present only from 18 days onwards. This anomaly could arise through percursor cell selection during the earlier phases of culture, since it is possible that some (not all) lentoids may be derived from aggregates of neuronal-like cells in neural retina cultures. Thus precursor cell selection as well as culture growth rate may influence the pattern of crystallin production during transdifferentiation.     

COMPARISON OF NEURONAL AND LENS PHENOTYPE EXPRESSION IN THE TRANSDIFFERENTIATING CULTURES OF NUERAL RETINA WITH DIFFERENT CULTURE MEDIA*

The effects of three different culture media (Eagle's MEM, F-12 and L-15) on the transdifferentiation of 8-day chick embryonic neural retina into lens cells, were examined with respect to the expression of two phenotypes. One type referred to neuronal specificity (as represented by the level of cholineacetyl-transferase, CAT, activity) and the other to lens specificity (as represented by content of α-and δ-crystallin). In 7-day cell cultures before the visible differentiation of lentoid bodies, CAT activity was detected in all media. But, its level was about 9 times higher in cultures with L-15 than in those with MEM and 3 times higher than in F-12. In 26-day cultures, CAT activity was practically undetectable. The production of α-and δ-crystallin was detected in cultures at 26 days. There were quantitative differences in the crystallin content with different media, and it was highest in cultures with L-15. The results indicate that conditions most favourable to the maintenance of the neuronal specificity in cell cultures of neural retina, can also support the most extensive transdifferentiation. The possibility of direct transdifferentiation of once neuronally specified cells into lens cells in cultures with L-15 has been suggested to explain the present results.     

Basic fibroblast growth factor induces retinal pigment epithelium to generate neural retina in vitro.

During embryogenesis, the cells of the eye primordium are initially capable of giving rise to either neural retina or pigmented epithelium (PE), but become restricted to one of these potential cell fates. However, following surgical removal of the retina in embryonic chicks and larval amphibians, new neural retina is generated by the transdifferentiation, or phenotypic switching, of PE cells into neuronal progenitors. A recent study has shown that basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) stimulates this process in chicks in vivo. To characterize further the mechanisms by which this factor regulates the phenotype of retinal tissues, we added bFGF to enzymatically dissociated chick embryo PE. We found that bFGF stimulated proliferation and caused several morphological changes in the PE, including the loss of pigmentation; however, no transdifferentiation to neuronal phenotypes was observed. By contrast, when small sheets of PE were cultured as aggregates on a shaker device, preventing flattening and spreading on the substratum, we found that a large number of retinal progenitor cells were generated from the PE treated with bFGF. These results indicate that bFGF promotes retinal regeneration in vitro, as well as in ovo, and suggest that the ability of chick PE to undergo transdifferentiation to neuronal progenitors appears to be dependent on the physical configuration of the cells.     

Pathways of Differentiation in Chick Embryo Neuroretinal Cultures

Markers of neuronal cell differentiation (GABA accumulation, choline acetyltransferase activity) are shown to increase initially and then decline sharply in monolayer cultures of 9 day embryo neuroretinal (NR) cells. A glial marker (glutamine synthetase, GSase) is precociously inducible by hydrocortisone (HC) in dense'monolayer' NR cultures (containing aggregates of neuronal cells overlying the glial sheet) as well as in chick embryo retinal explants. The induced level of GSase activity is not maintained in the continued presence of HC, but rather declines by 20 days in vitro. Choline acetyltransferase (CAT) activity is higher in HC-treated cultures than in controls only during the period when induced GSase activity is detectable. Furthermore, the subsequent transdifferentiation of lens cells (monitored as δ crystallin content) in these cultures is delayed by 10 days and much reduced in extent when HC is present throughout the culture period.
We suggest a simple model to account for these results, on the basis of recent evidence that lens cells are derived mainly from the retinal epithelial cells (immature Müller glia) of 9-day embryonic NR, and that transdifferentiation results from a change in cell determination during the early stages of'monolayer' culture. In outline, our model proposes that early dedetermination of the retinal glia is associated with a decline of neuronal cell markers (dedifferentiation) followed eventually by loss of the neuronal cells. Hydrocortisone, by inducing transient glial cell differentiation (GSase activity), both prolongs the expression of a neuronal marker (CAT) and also reduces later transdifferentiation into lens.     

AGE-DEPENDENT CHANGE IN THE TRANSDIFFERENTIATION ABILITY OF CHICK NEURAL RETINA IN CELL CULTURE*

We examined how the transdifferentiation ability of neural retinal cells into lens and/or pigment cells in call culture is changed with the development of the donor. Cells dissociated from neural retinas of chick embryos ranging from 3-day-old to the stage immediately before hatching and of 3-day-old chicks were cultured for about 60 days. The results clearly indicated that the transdifferentiation ability decreased with age. The latest developmental stage at which the differentiation of lens cells took place was in 18-day-old embryos. A gradual decrease in this ability was shown by the comparison of crystallin content in cultures prepared from embryos at different stages. The differentiation of pigment cells was recognized in cultures of neural retinas earlier than in 15-day-old embryos. Such loss of the ability of neural retinal cells to transdifferentiate into pigment cells earlier than into lens cells can be partially attributed to inhibitory factors accumulated in medium conditioned with many neuronal cells present in cultures.     

The pattern of DNA methylation in the delta-crystallin genes in transdifferentiating neural retina cultures

Terminally differentiated lens fibre cells are formed in the vertebrate lens throughout life. Lens fibre cells may also be obtained by an in vitro process termed transdifferentiation, from certain tissues of different developmental origin from lens, such as embryo neural retina. delta-Crystallin is the major protein in the chick embryo lens fibre cells, and also in transdifferentiated lens cells obtained from cultured embryonic neural retina. Lens crystallin proteins and mRNA are present at low levels in the intact embryonic neural retina but are no longer detectable in the early stages of neural retina cell culture. However, levels rise steeply in the later stages and crystallins become the major products in terminally transdifferentiating neural retina cultures. We have used this system to test the hypothesis that the patterns of DNA methylation in particular genes are correlated with gene expression. A number of developmentally regulated genes have been found to be undermethylated in tissues where they are expressed, and methylated in tissues where they are not. However this correspondence does not always hold true. Eight-day-old embryonic neural retina was cultured for the period of time during which crystallin gene expression increases 100-fold. DNA methylation in the delta-crystallin gene region was analysed at several stages of cell culture by using the restriction endonucleases HpaII and MspI which cleave at the sequence CCGG. The former enzyme cannot cleave internally methylated cytosine (CmCGG) while the latter cannot cleave externally methylated cytosine (mCCGG). We detect no change in the methylation of CCGG sites within the delta-crystallin gene regions during transdifferentiation. Since dramatic changes in delta-crystallin gene expression occur during this process we conclude that large scale alterations in the pattern of DNA methylation are not a necessary accompaniment to changes in gene activity.     

Transdifferentiation of putative neuronal cells of neural retina into lens: A demonstration by chick-quail chimeric cultures

Summary To elucidate the cell-type origin of lens cells, which differentiate in stationary cultures of neural retina, chimeric cultures between chick and quail cells were made to recombine xenoplastically the different cell fractions separated from 8- to 9-day cultures of 3.5-day-old embryonic neural retinal cells by means of centrifugation in Percoll. Extensive lentoidogenesis occurred in the recombination of the N2-fraction (consisting mostly of small round cells) with the E-fraction (containing a number of flattened epithelial cells). Taking advantage of the difference in electrophoretic mobility of chick and quail -crystallin, it was shown that this lens-specific protein, synthesized in the chimeric cultures, was mostly of the species-specificity of N2. Microscopic observations of histological sections of cell sheets of quail N2- and chick E-fraction chimeric cultures revealed that most cells with -crystallin, as identified by means of immunohistological detection, are provided with a nuclear marker characteristic of quail. By determining the level of activity of choline acetyltransferase and by examining the stainability with a fluorescent dye (Merocyanine-540), it was suggested that cells in the N2-fraction are primitive neuroblast-like cells. Thus, we can conclude that putative neuronal cells in early cultures of avian embryonic neural retina can transdifferentiate into lens cells.     

Possible demonstration of multipotential nature of embryonic neural retina by clonal cell culture.

The possible multipotential nature of the neural retina of early chick embryos was examined by the technique of clonal cell culture. Cultures were prepared from cells dissociated from freshly excised neural retinas of 3.5-day-old chick embryos or from cells harvested from primary highdensity cultures. The following four colony types were obtained: colonies differentiating into “lentoid bodies”; colonies with pigment cells; colonies with both “lentoid bodies” and pigment cells; and colonies comprised entirely of unidentifiable cells. Neuronal differentiation occurred frequently in the early stages of culture (up to about 10 days). In some of these neuronal colonies, “lentoid bodies” and, rarely, both “lentoid bodies” and pigment cells differentiated after a further culture period of up to 30 days. Secondary colonies established from primary colonies after 9–10 days demonstrated that these original colonies fell into four different categories: those giving rise to secondary colonies containing only “lentoid bodies,” those giving rise to pigmented colonies only, those developing both lentoid and pigmented colonies, and finally those which gave rise to secondary colonies of all three types, lentoid, pigmented, and mixed colonies. When primary pigmented colonies were recloned at about 30 days after inoculation, the differentiated pigment cells transdifferentiated into lens. Whether multispecific colonies were really of clonal origin or not is discussed. The possible presence of a multipotent progenitor cell able to give rise to multispecific clones in the neural retina of 3.5-day-old chick embryos is suggested. A sequence of differentiation starting from multipotent neural retinal cells to be terminated with lens through the differentiation of neuronal and pigment cells is hypothetically proposed.     

Determination of Chick Neuro-retinal Cells in Culture: Serum Factors Acting between 12 and 20 Days of Culture Influence the Extent of Subsequent Lens Cell Formation

Embryonic chick neuroretinal cells transdifferentiate into lens cells during culture in media containing foetal calf serum (F). This process is largely inhibited if horse serum plus supplementary glucose (Hg) is substituted for F. This paper explores the effect of medium changeover (from F to Hg or vice versa ) on the subsequent appearance of lens-specific δ-crystallin. If cultures are changed from Hg to F up to 12 days of culture, δ-production at 40 days is similar to that for controls maintained in F throughout. Changeovers between 14 and 17 days progressively inhibit subsequent δ production, and after 19 days in Hg, lens transdifferentiation cannot be induced by F. Conversely, if cultures are maintained in F for up to 17 days, a changeover to Hg blocks transdifferentiation, whereas similar transfers performed after 19 days give increased δ production. These results suggest that some retinal cells which will eventually form lens in vitro become so determined between the 12th and 20th days of culture. A mixture of 50% Hg and 50% F medium (FHg) does not support δ production even after 60 days, but in the absence of supplementary glucose (FH), δ appears in considerable amounts by 30 days.     

Pathways of differentiation in chick embryo neuroretinal cultures

Markers of neuronal cell differentiation (GABA accumulation, choline acetyltransferase activity) are shown to increase initially and then decline sharply in monolayer cultures of 9 day embryo neuroretinal (NR) cells. A glial marker (glutamine synthetase, GSase) is precociously inducible by hydrocortisone (HC) in dens "monolayer' NR cultures (containing aggregates of neuronal cells overlying the glian sheet) as well as in chick embryo retinal explants. The induced level of GSase activity is not maintained in the continued presence of HC, but rather declines by 20 days in vitro. Choline acetyltransferase (CAT) activity is higher in HC-treated cultures than in controls only during the period when induced GSase activity is detectable. Furthermore, the subsequent transdifferentiation of lens cells (monitored as delta crystalline content) in these cultures is delayed by 10 days and much reduced in extent when HC is present throughout the culture period. We suggest a simple model to account for these results, on the basis of recent evidence that lens cells are derived mainly from the retinal epithelial cells (immature Müller glia) of 9-day embryonic NR, and that transdifferentiation results from a change in cell determination during the early stages of "monolayers' culture. In outline, our model proposes that early determination of the retinal glia is associated with a decline of neuronal cell markers (dedifferentiation) followed eventually by loss of the neuronal cells. Hydrocortisone, by inducing transient glial cell differentiation (GSase activity), both prolongs the expression of a neuronal marker (CAT) and also reduces later transdifferentiation into lens.     

Can Once Neuronally Differentiated Cells of Neural Retina Be Lentoidogenic in Cell Culture?*

Cells dissociated from neural retina of 3.5-day-old chick embryos transdifferentiated extensively into lens cells under the conditions of a cell culture for 3 to 4 weeks. In early satges of cell culture by about 10 days, cultures consisted of small round cells often with cytoplasmic processes(N-cells) and flattened epithelial cells (E-cells). Only N-cells were stained with a fluorescent dye Merocyanine 540. When cells harvested from early cultures were separated into two fractions by centrifugation in Percoll gradient, the specific activity of choline acetyltransferase was much higher in the fraction consisting mainly of N-cells than in other fraction mainly of E-cells. Continuous daily observations as well as cinematographic observations of living cultures indicate that lentoid bodies were often formed in the locations where clusters of N-cells had been found in early stages of culturing. The possibility of transdifferentiation of N-cell clusters into lentoid bodies is discussed.     

Biochemical and immunological studies of lentoid formation in cultures of embryonic chick neural retina and day-old chick lens epithelium

During long-term cell culture of 8-day embryonic chick neural retina, lentoid bodies containing lens crystallins are developed. Although very low levels of crystallin can be detected in the embryonic neural retina, gross synthesis of each major crystallin class (α, anodal β, cathodal β, and δ) begins only after 12–16 days in culture. This occurs at least 10 days before lentoid bodies can be distinguished by eye. The concentration of each crystallin class was determined during lentoid development in cultures of both neural retina and lens epithelium. The proportions of crystallins in lentoid-containing cultures do not resemble those of embryonic lens fibres. Comparisons between two chick strains (N and Hy-1) differing in their growth rates revealed several differences in the crystallin compositions of lentoid bodies. These differences imply independent quantitative regulation for most or all of the crystallins.     

Isolation and cell-free translation of chick lens crystallin mRNA during normal development and transdifferentiation of neural retina

Messenger RNA has been isolated from day-old chick lens. Size characterization and heterologous cell-free translation demonstrate that the predominant species of mRNA present code for α-, β- and δ-crystallins. Total polysomal RNA and polysomal RNA which did not bind to oligo (dT)-cellulose translate in the cell-free system to give a crystallin profile qualitatively similar to that of poly(A)⁺ mRNA. RNA from postribosomal supernatant which binds to oligo(dT)-cellulose also translates to give crystallins, but the products are enriched for β-crystallins. Messenger RNAs isolated from 15-day embryo lens fiber and lens epithelium cells give products on translation which reflect the different protein compositions of these two cell types, as do mRNAs isolated from chick lenses at various developmental stages. Messenger RNAs were isolated from freshly excised 8-day embryo neural retina and from this tissue undergoing transdifferentiation into lens cells in cell culture. Cell-free translation demonstrates no detectable crystallin mRNAs in the freshly excised material, but by 42 days in cell culture, crystallin mRNAs are the most prominent species.     

Progenitor cells from embryonic chick dorsal root ganglia differentiate in vitro to neurons: biochemical and electrophysiological evidence.

We have analyzed the appearance of neurons and glial cells in chick dorsal root ganglia during development. Neurons were identified by the presence of polysialogangliosides recognized by tetanus toxin (GD1b, GT1) or by the monoclonal antibody Q211 directed against polysialogangliosides containing four, five and six sialic acid residues. Glial cells were identified by the presence of 04 antigen. A population of undifferentiated cells, i.e., cells which express neither neuronal nor glial cell surface antigens, present in dorsal root ganglia until embryonic day 7, was separated from the neuronal and glial population. This cell population contains neuronal progenitor cells which differentiate to neurons within 1 day in culture. This differentiation process is characterized by the appearance of neuronal morphology, of neuron-specific gangliosides and by the appearance of voltage-dependent sodium and calcium channels.     

Astroglial cells provide a template for the positioning of developing cerebellar neurons in vitro

Indirect immunocytochemical staining with antisera raised against purified glial filament protein and a neurofilament polypeptide was used to study cell interactions between astrocytes and neurons dissociated from embryonic and early postnatal cerebellum. Staining with antibodies raised against purified glial filament protein revealed that greater than 99% of all processes present in cerebellar cultures during the 1st wk in vitro were glial in origin. After 1 wk in culture, unstained processes that were presumably neuronal were observed. Stained astroglial processes formed a dense network that served as a template for cerebellar neurons, identified by indirect immunocytochemical localization of tetanus toxin. More than 90% of neurons from postnatal days 1 or 7 were positioned within one cell diameter of a glial process. In contrast, less than 40% of the neurons dissociated from early embryonic cerebellum were located adjacent to a glial process. Staining with antibodies raised against purified glial filament protein also revealed differences in astroglial morphology that were under developmental regulation. Astroglial cells from embryonic cerebellum were fewer in number and had thick, unbranched processes. Those from postnatal day 1 were more slender, branched, and stellate. Those from postnatal day 7 were highly branched and stellate. Some veil-like astroglial processes were also observed in cells from postnatal animals. These morphological changes were also observed when cells from embryonic day 13 were maintained for a week in vitro. No specific staining of embryonic or postnatal cerebellum cells was observed with antibodies raised against purified neurofilament polypeptides.