TonB and the Gram-negative dilemma

TonB protein serves as an energy transducer to couple cytoplasmic membrane energy to high-affinity active transport of iron siderophores and vitamin B₁₂ across the outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria. The biochemical mechanism of the energy transduction remains to be determined, but important details are already known. TonB is targeted to and anchored in the cytoplasmic membrane by a single membrane-spanning domain and spans the periplasm to physically interact with outer-membrane receptors of the transport ligands. TonB-dependent energy transduction is modulated by ExbB protein, which stabilizes TonB, and possibly by several other proteins including ExbC, ExbD, and TolQ. TonB has a relatively short functional half-life that is accelerated when rates of active transport across the outer membrane are increased. A model that incorporates this information, as well as some tempered speculation, is presented.     

The Vibrio parahaemolyticus pvuA1 gene (formerly termed psuA) encodes a second ferric vibrioferrin receptor that requires tonB2

We previously reported that the Vibrio parahaemolyticus pvsABCDE and psuA-pvuABCDE operons are involved in the biosynthesis and transport of its own siderophore, vibrioferrin (VF). Of these, psuA and pvuA encode TonB-dependent outer-membrane proteins (OMPs). Although pvuA was characterized as the ferric vibrioferrin receptor gene, the role of the psuA product remains unknown. In this study, a growth assay of isogenic psuA, pvuA, and psuA-pvuA double-deletion mutants followed by complementation of the double-deletion mutant with psuA or pvuA was used to identify psuA as a gene encoding an OMP involved in the uptake of ferric VF. Thus, psuA and pvuA were renamed pvuA1 and pvuA2, respectively. Moreover, we clarified the TonB specificities of PvuA1 and PvuA2, because V. parahaemolyticus has three sets of the TonB systems. The triple deletion of pvuA1, tonB1, and tonB2, and the double deletion of pvuA2 and tonB2 resulted in the complete loss of growth promotion by VF. This finding indicates that the energy required for PvuA1 and PvuA2 to transport ferric VF across the outer membrane is provided by the TonB2 system and by both the TonB1 and TonB2 systems, respectively.     

Comprehensive analysis of transport proteins encoded within the genome of Bdellovibrio bacteriovorus

Bdellovibrio bacteriovorus is a bacterial parasite with an unusual lifestyle. It grows and reproduces in the periplasm of a host prey bacterium. The complete genome sequence of B. bacteriovorus has recently been reported. We have reanalyzed the transport proteins encoded within the B. bacteriovorus genome according to the current content of the Transporter Classification Database. A comprehensive analysis is given on the types and numbers of transport systems that B. bacteriovorus has. In this regard, the potential protein secretory capabilities of at least four types of inner-membrane secretion systems and five types of outer-membrane secretion systems are described. Surprisingly, B. bacteriovorus has a disproportionate percentage of cytoplasmic membrane channels and outer-membrane porins. It has far more TonB/ExbBD-type systems and MotAB-type systems for energizing outer-membrane transport and motility than does Escherichia coli. Analysis of probable substrate specificities of its transporters provides clues to its metabolic preferences. Interesting examples of gene fusions and of potentially overlapping genes are also noted. Our analyses provide a comprehensive, detailed appreciation of the transport capabilities of B. bacteriovorus. They should serve as a guide for functional experimental analyses.     

Transport of iron across the outer membrane

Summary The TonB protein is involved in energy-coupled receptor-dependent transport processes across the outer membrane. The TonB protein is anchored in the cytoplasmic membrane but exposed to the periplasmic space. To fulfill its function, it has to couple the energy-providing metabolism in the cytoplasmic membrane with regulation of outer membrane receptor activity. Ferrichrome and albomycin transport, uptake of colicin M, and infection by the phages T1 and80 occur via the same receptor, the FhuA protein in the outer membrane. Therefore, this receptor is particularly suitable for the study of energy-coupled TonB-dependent transport across the outer membrane. Ferrichrome, albomycin and colicin M bind to the FhuA receptor but are not released into the periplasmic space of unenergized cells, ortonB mutants. In vivo interaction between FhuA and TonB is suggested by the restoration of activity of inactive FhuA proteins, bearing amino acid replacements in the TonB box, by TonB derivatives with single amino acid substitutions. Point mutations in thefhuA gene are suppressed by point mutations in thetonB gene. In addition, naturally occurring degradation of the TonB protein and its derivatives is preferentially prevented in vivo by FhuA and FhuA derivatives where functional interaction takes place. It is proposed that in the energized state, TonB induces a conformation in FhuA which leads to the release of the FhuA-bound compounds into the periplasmic space. Activation of FhuA by TonB depends on the ExbBD proteins in the cytoplasmic membrane. They can be partially replaced by the TolQR proteins which show strong sequence similarity to the ExbBD proteins. A physical interaction of these proteins with the TonB protein is suggested by TonB stabilization through ExbB and TolQR. We propose a permanent or reversible complex in the cytoplasmic membrane composed of the TonB protein and the ExbBD/TolQR proteins through which TonB is energized.     

Molecular and genetic characterization of the TonB2-cluster TtpC protein in pathogenic vibrios

TtpC is a fourth required protein in the TonB2 energy transduction system in Vibrio anguillarum. TtpC is necessary for iron transport mediated by the TonB2 system and is highly conserved in all pathogenic vibrio species studied to date as well as several marine organisms. We show here that the TtpC proteins from selected pathogenic vibrio species can function with the TonB2 system of V. anguillarum to allow iron transport mediated by a chimeric TonB2 system where the native ExbB2, ExbD2 and TonB2 function with an episomally expressed TtpC in trans from a different species. The discovery that inter-species complementation occurs can be used to identify the functional regions of the TtpC proteins and will lead to an investigation of the mechanism of interaction between the TtpC protein and other members of the TonB2 system.     

Substrate-induced exposure of an energy-coupling motif of a membrane transporter

BtuB is an outer membrane protein responsible for the uptake of vitamin B12 by Escherichia coli. It belongs to a family of bacterial transport proteins that derive energy for transport by coupling to the trans-periplasmic energy-coupling protein TonB. Using site-directed spin labeling and EPR we investigated the structure and substrate-induced changes in the TonB box, a highly conserved region in all TonB dependent transporters that may couple to TonB. In the absence of substrate, the line widths and collision parameters from EPR are consistent with this domain existing in a structured helical conformation that contacts the barrel of the transporter. Addition of substrate converts this segment into an extended structure that is highly dynamic, disordered and probably extended into the periplasm. This structural change demonstrates that the TonB box cycles between sequestered and accessible states in a substrate-dependent fashion. In a transport defective mutant of BtuB, this conformational cycle is disrupted and the TonB box appears to be extended even in the absence of substrate. These data suggest that the TonB box extends into the periplasm and interacts with TonB only in     

Analysis of residues determining specificity of Vibrio cholerae TonB1 for its receptors

In gram-negative organisms, high-affinity transport of iron substrates requires energy transduction to specific outer membrane receptors by the TonB-ExbB-ExbD complex. Vibrio cholerae encodes two TonB proteins, one of which, TonB1, recognizes only a subset of V. cholerae TonB-dependent receptors and does not facilitate transport through Escherichia coli receptors. To investigate the receptor specificity exhibited by V. cholerae TonB1, chimeras were created between V. cholerae TonB1 and E. coli TonB. The activities of the chimeric TonB proteins in iron utilization assays demonstrated that the C-terminal one-third of either TonB confers the receptor specificities associated with the full-length TonB. Single-amino-acid substitutions near the C terminus of V. cholerae TonB1 were identified that allowed TonB1 to recognize E. coli receptors and at least one V. cholerae TonB2-dependent receptor. This indicates that the very C-terminal end of V. cholerae TonB1 determines receptor specificity. The regions of the TonB-dependent receptors involved in specificity for a particular TonB protein were investigated in experiments involving domain switching between V. cholerae and E. coli receptors exhibiting different TonB specificities. Switching the conserved TonB box heptapeptides at the N termini of these receptors did not alter their TonB specificities. However, replacing the amino acid immediately preceding the TonB box in E. coli receptors with an aromatic residue allowed these receptors to use V. cholerae TonB1. Further, site-directed mutagenesis of the TonB box -1 residue in a V. cholerae TonB2-dependent receptor demonstrated that a large hydrophobic amino acid in this position promotes recognition of V. cholerae TonB1. These data suggest that the TonB box -1 position controls productive interactions with V. cholerae TonB1.     

Molecular modeling of the bacterial outer membrane receptor energizer,ExbBD/TonB,based on homology with the flagellar motor,MotAB

The MotA/MotB proteins serve as the motor that drives bacterial flagellar rotation in response to the proton motive force (pmf). They have been shown to comprise a transmembrane proton pathway. The ExbB/ExbD/TonB protein complex serves to energize transport of iron siderophores and vitamin B12 across the outer membrane of the Gram-negative bacterial cell using the pmf. These two protein complexes have the same topology and are homologous. Based on molecular data for the MotA/MotB proteins, we propose simple three-dimensional channel structures for both MotA/MotB and ExbB/ExbD/TonB using modeling methods. Features of the derived channels are discussed, and two possible proton transfer pathways for the ExbBD/TonB system are proposed. These analyses provide a guide for molecular studies aimed at elucidating the mechanism by which chemiosmotic energy can be transferred either between two adjacent membranes to energize outer membrane transport or to the bacterial flagellum to generate torque.     

Ton-dependent colicins and microcins: modular design and evolution

Ton-dependent colicins and microcins are actively taken up into sensitive cells at the expense of energy which is provided by the proton motive force of the cytoplasmic membrane. The Ton system consisting of the proteins TonB, ExbB and ExbD is required for colicin and microcin import. Colicins as well as the outer membrane transport proteins contain proximal to the N-terminus a short sequence, called TonB box, which interacts with TonB and in which point mutants impair uptake. No TonB box is found in microcins. Colicins are composed of functional modules which during evolution have been interchanged resulting in new colicins. The modules define sites of interaction with the outer membrane transport genes, TonB, the immunity proteins, and the activity regions. Six TonB-dependent microcins with different primary structures are processed and exported by highly homologous proteins. Three of these microcins are modified in an unknown way and they have in common specificity for catecholate siderophore receptors.     

Molecular modeling of the bacterial outer membrane receptor energizer, ExbBD/TonB, based on homology with the flagellar motor, MotAB

The MotA/MotB proteins serve as the motor that drives bacterial flagellar rotation in response to the proton motive force (pmf). They have been shown to comprise a transmembrane proton pathway. The ExbB/ExbD/TonB protein complex serves to energize transport of iron siderophores and vitamin B₁₂ across the outer membrane of the Gram-negative bacterial cell using the pmf. These two protein complexes have the same topology and are homologous. Based on molecular data for the MotA/MotB proteins, we propose simple three-dimensional channel structures for both MotA/MotB and ExbB/ExbD/TonB using modeling methods. Features of the derived channels are discussed, and two possible proton transfer pathways for the ExbBD/TonB system are proposed. These analyses provide a guide for molecular studies aimed at elucidating the mechanism by which chemiosmotic energy can be transferred either between two adjacent membranes to energize outer membrane transport or to the bacterial flagellum to generate torque.     

ExbB acts as a chaperone-like protein to stabilize TonB in the cytoplasm

The TonB protein is required to transduce energy from the cytoplasmic membrane to outer membrane transport proteins of Gram-negative bacteria. Two accessory proteins, ExbB and ExbD, are required for TonB function and it has been suggested that TonB and ExbBD form a complex in the membrane. In this paper we demonstrate that there are two spatially distinct, functional interactions between ExbBD and TonB. First, there is an interaction between ExbBD and the N-terminal signal-like peptide of TonB, probabiy the formation of a stable complex in the membrane. Second, ExbB interacts with TonB in the cytoplasm. This interaction involves the domain of TonB that is normally periplasmic. Thus, this is a transient interaction which occurs during the synthesis and/or localization of TonB, implying a chaperone-like role for ExbB. The transmembrane topology of ExbB was shown to be consistent with this role.     

Molecular characterization of the TonB2 protein from the fish pathogen Vibrio anguillarum

In the fish pathogen Vibrio anguillarum the TonB2 protein is essential for the uptake of the indigenous siderophore anguibactin. Here we describe deletion mutants and alanine replacements affecting the final six amino acids of TonB2. Deletions of more than two amino acids of the TonB2 C-terminus abolished ferric-anguibactin transport, whereas replacement of the last three residues resulted in a protein with wild-type transport properties. We have solved the high-resolution solution structure of the TonB2 C-terminal domain by NMR spectroscopy. The core of this domain (residues 121-206) has an alphabetabetaalphabeta structure, whereas residues 76-120 are flexible and extended. This overall folding topology is similar to the Escherichia coli TonB C-terminal domain, albeit with two differences: the beta4 strand found at the C-terminus of TonB is absent in TonB2, and loop 3 is extended by 9 A (0.9 nm) in TonB2. By examining several mutants, we determined that a complete loop 3 is not essential for TonB2 activity. Our results indicate that the beta4 strand of E. coli TonB is not required for activity of the TonB system across Gram-negative bacterial species. We have also determined, through NMR chemical-shift-perturbation experiments, that the E. coli TonB binds in vitro to the TonB box from the TonB2-dependent outer membrane transporter FatA; moreover, it can substitute in vivo for TonB2 during ferric-anguibactin transport in V. anguillarum. Unexpectedly, TonB2 did not bind in vitro to the FatA TonB-box region, suggesting that additional factors may be required to promote this interaction. Overall our results indicate that TonB2 is a representative of a different class of TonB proteins.     

His(20) provides the sole functionally significant side chain in the essential TonB transmembrane domain

The cytoplasmic membrane protein TonB couples the protonmotive force of the cytoplasmic membrane to active transport across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. The uncleaved amino-terminal signal anchor transmembrane domain (TMD; residues 12 to 32) of TonB and the integral cytoplasmic membrane proteins ExbB and ExbD are essential to this process, with important interactions occurring among the several TMDs of all three proteins. Here, we show that, of all the residues in the TonB TMD, only His(20) is essential for TonB activity. When alanyl residues replaced all TMD residues except Ser(16) and His(20), the resultant "all-Ala Ser(16) His(20)" TMD TonB retained 90% of wild-type iron transport activity. Ser(16)Ala in the context of a wild-type TonB TMD was fully active. In contrast, His(20)Ala in the wild-type TMD was entirely inactive. In more mechanistically informative assays, the all-Ala Ser(16) His(20) TMD TonB unexpectedly failed to support formation of disulfide-linked dimers by TonB derivatives bearing Cys substitutions for the aromatic residues in the carboxy terminus. We hypothesize that, because ExbB/D apparently cannot efficiently down-regulate conformational changes at the TonB carboxy terminus through the all-Ala Ser(16) His(20) TMD, the TonB carboxy terminus might fold so rapidly that disulfide-linked dimers cannot be efficiently trapped. In formaldehyde cross-linking experiments, the all-Ala Ser(16) His(20) TMD also supported large numbers of apparently nonspecific contacts with unknown proteins. The all-Ala Ser(16) His(20) TMD TonB retained its dependence on ExbB/D. Together, these results suggest that a role for ExbB/D might be to control rapid and nonspecific folding that the unregulated TonB carboxy terminus otherwise undergoes. Such a model helps to reconcile the crystal/nuclear magnetic resonance structures of the TonB carboxy terminus with conformational changes and mutant phenotypes observed at the TonB carboxy terminus in vivo.     

The two TonB systems of Vibrio cholerae: redundant and specific functions

The two TonB systems in Vibrio cholerae were found to have unique as well as common functions. Both systems can mediate transport of haemin and the siderophores vibriobactin and ferrichrome. However, TonB1 specifically mediates utilization of the siderophore schizokinen, whereas TonB2 is required for utilization of enterobactin by V. cholerae. Although either TonB system was sufficient for the use of haemin as an iron source, in vitro competition between TonB1 and TonB2 system mutants indicates a preferential role for TonB1 in haemin utilization. This was most pronounced in conditions of high osmolarity, in which TonB1 system mutants were unable to grow with haemin as the sole iron source. Sequence analysis predicted that the two TonB proteins differ in both amino acid sequence and protein size. An internal deletion in TonB1 was constructed in order to generate a protein of approximately the same size as TonB2. A strain expressing the TonB1 deletion protein, and no other TonB, used haemin as the iron source in low-osmolarity medium, but could not use haemin in high osmolarity. This is the same phenotype as a strain expressing only TonB2 and suggests that TonB1, but not TonB2, can span the increased periplasmic space in high osmolarity and thus mediate haemin transport. Mouse colonization assays indicated a role for both TonB systems, and mutations in either system resulted in reduced ability to compete with the wild type in vivo.     

Mechanics of force propagation in TonB-dependent outer membrane transport

For the uptake of scarce yet essential organometallic compounds, outer membrane transporters of Gram-negative bacteria work in concert with an energy-generating inner membrane complex, thus spanning the periplasmic space to drive active transport. Here, we examine the interaction of TonB, an inner membrane protein, with an outer membrane transporter based upon a recent crystal structure of a TonB-transporter complex to characterize two largely unknown steps of the transport cycle: how energy is transmitted from TonB to the transporter and how energy transduction initiates transport. Simulations of TonB in complex with BtuB reveal that force applied to TonB is transmitted to BtuB without disruption of the very small connection between the two, supporting a mechanical mode of coupling. Based on the results of different pulling simulations, we propose that the force transduction instigates a partial unfolding of the pore-occluding luminal domain of the transporter, a potential step in the transport cycle. Furthermore, analysis of the electrostatic potentials and salt bridge interactions between the two proteins during the simulations hints at involvement of electrostatic forces in long-range interaction and binding of TonB and BtuB.     

The ttpC gene is contained in two of three TonB systems in the human pathogen Vibrio vulnificus, but only one is active in iron transport and virulence

The TonB system of proteins is required for the energy-dependent active transport of iron-bound substrates across the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria. We have identified three TonB systems within the human pathogen Vibrio vulnificus. The TonB1 system contains the TonB1, ExbD1, and ExbB1 proteins, whereas both the TtpC2-TonB2 and TtpC3-TonB3 systems contain an additional fourth protein, TtpC. Here we report that TtpC3, although highly related to TtpC2, is inactive in iron transport, whereas TtpC2 is essential for the function of the TtpC2-TonB2 system in V. vulnificus. This protein, together with TonB2, is absolutely required for both the uptake of endogenously produced iron-bound siderophores as well as siderophores produced from other organisms. Through complementation we show that V. vulnificus is capable of using different TtpC2 proteins from other Vibrio species to drive the uptake of multiple siderophores. We have also determined that aerobactin, a common bacterial siderophore involved in virulence of enteric bacteria, can only be brought into the cell using the TtpC2-TonB2 system, indicating an important evolutionary adaptation of TtpC2 and TonB2. Furthermore, in the absence of TonB1, TtpC2 is essential for a fully virulent phenotype as demonstrated using 50% lethal dose (LD(50)) experiments in mice.     

Insight from TonB hybrid proteins into the mechanism of iron transport through the outer membrane

We created hybrid proteins to study the functions of TonB. We first fused the portion of Escherichia coli tonB that encodes the C-terminal 69 amino acids (amino acids 170 to 239) of TonB downstream from E. coli malE (MalE-TonB69C). Production of MalE-TonB69C in tonB(+) bacteria inhibited siderophore transport. After overexpression and purification of the fusion protein on an amylose column, we proteolytically released the TonB C terminus and characterized it. Fluorescence spectra positioned its sole tryptophan (W213) in a weakly polar site in the protein interior, shielded from quenchers. Affinity chromatography showed the binding of the TonB C-domain to other proteins: immobilized TonB-dependent (FepA and colicin B) and TonB-independent (FepADelta3-17, OmpA, and lysozyme) proteins adsorbed MalE-TonB69C, revealing a general affinity of the C terminus for other proteins. Additional constructions fused full-length TonB upstream or downstream of green fluorescent protein (GFP). TonB-GFP constructs had partial functionality but no fluorescence; GFP-TonB fusion proteins were functional and fluorescent. The activity of the latter constructs, which localized GFP in the cytoplasm and TonB in the cell envelope, indicate that the TonB N terminus remains in the inner membrane during its biological function. Finally, sequence analyses revealed homology in the TonB C terminus to E. coli YcfS, a proline-rich protein that contains the lysin (LysM) peptidoglycan-binding motif. LysM structural mimicry occurs in two positions of the dimeric TonB C-domain, and experiments confirmed that it physically binds to the murein sacculus. Together, these findings infer that the TonB N terminus remains associated with the inner membrane, while the downstream region bridges the cell envelope from the affinity of the C terminus for peptidoglycan. This architecture suggests a membrane surveillance model of action, in which TonB finds occupied receptor proteins by surveying the underside of peptidoglycan-associated outer membrane proteins.     

FhuA barrel-cork hybrids are active transporters and receptors

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli FhuA reveals a beta-barrel domain that is closed by a globular cork domain. It has been assumed that the proton motive force of the cytoplasmic membrane through the interaction of the TonB protein with the TonB box of the cork opens the FhuA channel. Yet, deletion of the cork results in an FhuA derivative, FhuADelta5-160, that still displays TonB-dependent substrate transport and phage receptor activity. To investigate this unexpected finding further, we constructed FhuADelta5-160 derivatives of FhuA proteins from Salmonella paratyphi B, Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, and Pantoea agglomerans. The FhuADelta5-160 proteins inserted correctly into the outer membrane, and with the exception of the P. agglomerans protein, transported ferrichrome and albomycin. FhuA hybrids consisting of the beta-barrel of one strain and the cork of another strain were active and showed higher TonB-dependent ferrichrome transport rates than the corkless derivatives. Exceptions were the E. coli beta-barrel/Salmonella serovar Typhimurium cork hybrid protein and the Salmonella serovar Typhimurium beta-barrel/P. agglomerans cork hybrid protein, both of which were less active than the beta-barrels alone. Each of the FhuA mutant proteins displayed activity for each of their ligands, except for phage T5, only when coupled to TonB. The hybrid FhuA proteins displayed a similar activity with the E. coli TonB protein as with their cognate TonB proteins. Sensitivity to phages T1, T5, and phi80, rifamycin CGP 4832, and colicin M was determined by the beta-barrel, whereas sensitivity to phage ES18 and microcin J25 required both the beta-barrel and cork domains. These results demonstrate that the beta-barrel domain of FhuA confers activity and specificity and responds to TonB and that the cork domains of various FhuA proteins can be interchanged and contribute to the activities of the FhuA hybrids.