Functional consequences of Genetics variant in TMC1 and TMC2 within a United Arab Emirates family with Pre-lingual hearing loss

Hearing loss (HL) is the most prevalent sensory disorder whose etiology comes from environmental and/or genetic factors. Approximately 60 % of HL cases are due to mutations in genes responsible for maintaining a normal hearing function. Despite the monogenic inheritance of hereditary hearing loss (HHL), its diagnosis is challenging as both clinical and genetic heterogeneity characterizes it. Through the development of next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques, the number of identified mutations responsible for HHL has increased exponentially during the last decade. Mutations in the TMC1 have been reported in several patients with nonsyndromic hereditary hearing loss (NSHHL), more precisely in cases with an autosomal recessive inheritance pattern. In this study, we conducted whole-exome sequencing (WES) analysis of a United Arabs Emirates (UAE) family with autosomal recessive nonsyndromic hearing loss (ARNSHL). This analysis revealed segregation of the TMC1 missense mutation c.596A > T (p.Asn199Ile) with the disease. Bioinformatics analysis supported the pathogenic effect of this mutation and predicted its impact at the proteomics level. Molecular docking analysis of TMC2WT, TMC2R123K, TMC2Q205R, and TMC2R123K + Q205R. Finally, protein docking results suggest a role for TMC2 variants in the phenotypic variability observed within the investigated family.     

Exome Sequencing Reveals Novel and Recurrent Mutations with Clinical Significance in Inherited Retinal Dystrophies

This study aimed to identify the underlying molecular genetic cause in four Spanish families clinically diagnosed of Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP), comprising one autosomal dominant RP (adRP), two autosomal recessive RP (arRP) and one with two possible modes of inheritance: arRP or X-Linked RP (XLRP). We performed whole exome sequencing (WES) using NimbleGen SeqCap EZ Exome V3 sample preparation kit and SOLID 5500xl platform. All variants passing filter criteria were validated by Sanger sequencing to confirm familial segregation and the absence in local control population. This strategy allowed the detection of: (i) one novel heterozygous splice-site deletion in RHO, c.937-2_944del, (ii) one rare homozygous mutation in C2orf71, c.1795T>C; p.Cys599Arg, not previously associated with the disease, (iii) two heterozygous null mutations in ABCA4, c.2041C>T; p.R681* and c.6088C>T; p.R2030*, and (iv) one mutation, c.2405-2406delAG; p.Glu802Glyfs*31 in the ORF15 of RPGR. The molecular findings for RHO and C2orf71 confirmed the initial diagnosis of adRP and arRP, respectively, while patients with the two ABCA4 mutations, both previously associated with Stargardt disease, presented symptoms of RP with early macular involvement. Finally, the X-Linked inheritance was confirmed for the family with the RPGR mutation. This latter finding allowed the inclusion of carrier sisters in our preimplantational genetic diagnosis program.     

Spectrum of the GJB2 mutations in Belarussian patients with hearing loss. Findings of pilot genetic screening of hearing impairment in newborns

A total of 111 unrelated probands and their 8 sibs from Grodno oblast (Belarus) with bilateral isolated sensorineural hearing impairment were studied for the presence of mutations in the connexin 26 (GJB2) gene. Mutations were detected in 51 probands (46% of the sample). A significantly higher frequency of the GJB2 gene mutations was observed in familial cases of the disease with the autosomal recessive mode of inheritance (in 78% of families). Detected characteristics of the GJB2 gene mutation spectrum demonstrated that the using the algorithm, which was designed for Russian patients, is optimal for the molecular study of patients from Belarus. In the sample of patients with hearing loss, the highest (among other similar samples studied in the world) allele frequency of c.313_326del14 mutation (7% of all pathological GJB2 alleles) was registered; Polish origin of this deletion was suggested. It was demonstrated that detection of the GJB2 gene mutation on one patient’s chromosome only is insufficient to confirm a molecular genetic diagnosis of hearing loss of the DFNB1 genetic type (autosomal recessive hearing loss caused by the GJB2 gene mutations). Pilot screening for the GJB2 gene mutations in newborns from Grodno oblast was performed. The material from 235 children was studied during the screening; nine heterozygous carriers of the mutation were found. The c.35delG mutation was detected in a homozygous state in a single newborn (hearing loss of moderate severity was subsequently audiologically confirmed in this child).     

Next generation sequencing reveals novel homozygous frameshift in PUS7 and splice acceptor variants in AASS gene leading to intellectual disability,developmental delay,dysmorphic feature and microcephaly

Intellectual developmental disorder with abnormal behavior, microcephaly and short stature (IDDABS), (OMIM# 618342) is an autosomal recessive condition described as developmental delay, poor or absent speech, intellectual disability, short stature, mild to progressive microcephaly, delayed psychomotor development, hyperactivity, seizure, along with mild to swear aggressive behavior. Homozygous frameshift mutation in Pseudouridine Synthase 7, Putative; (PUS7) OMIM# 616,261 NM_019042.3 and splice acceptor variants in Alpha-Aminoadipic Semialdehyde Synthase; (AASS) OMIM# 605,113 NM_005763.3 was funded. Whole exome sequencing (WES) technique was used as tool to identify the molecular diagnostic test. Different bioinformatics analysis done for WES data and we identified two novel mutations one as frameshift mutation c.606_607delGA, p.Ser282CysfsTer9 in the PUS7 gene and splice acceptor variants c.1767–1 G > A in the AASS gene has been reported. The pattern of family segregation maintained the pathogenicity of this variation associated with abnormal behavior, intellectual developmental disorder, microcephaly along with short stature IDDABS. Further, the WES data was validated in the family having other affected individuals and healthy controls (n = 100) was done using Sanger sequencing. Finally, our results further explained the role of WES in the disease diagnosis and elucidated that the mutation in PUS7 and AASS genes may lead an important role for the development of IDDABS in Saudi family.     

Haplotype analysis of oculopharyngeal muscular dystrophy (OPMD) locus in Yakutia

Oculopharyngeal muscular dystrophy (OPMD) is a hereditary neuromuscular disease with autosomal dominant and rarely with autosomal recessive inheritance types. This study included 50 patients with a clinical diagnosis of OPMD, 23 asymptomatic carriers of the mutation from 45 unrelated families, and 56 healthy relatives, as well as population samples of four ethnic groups of Yakutia: Yakuts, Evens, Evenks, Yukaghirs. It was found that the cause of OPMD development in all investigated families is the same increase in GCN repeats to 14 copies in the PABPN1 gene. The molecular structure of the (GCN)₁₄ mutant allele is (GCG)₁₀(GCA)₃GCG. The genetic variability of ten SNPs at the OPMD locus was studied in patient families and population samples. The haplotypes of OPMD were determined by a segregation analysis technique and using the EM algorithm in the groups of patients, mutation carriers, and population samples. Only one haplotype of four SNPs (ATCG) linked with the (GCN)₁₄ mutant allele was found in Yakuts and Russian patients and OPMD mutation carriers. Probably, this indicates the accumulation of mutations as a result of the founder effect.     

A case of Usher syndrome type IIA caused by a rare USH2A homozygous frameshift variant with maternal uniparental disomy (UPD) in a Chinese family

Usher syndrome encompasses a group of genetically and clinically heterogeneous autosomal recessive disorders with hearing deficiencies and retinitis pigmentosa. The mechanisms underlying the Usher syndrome are highly variable. In the present study, a Chinese family with Usher syndrome was recruited. Whole exome sequencing (WES), Sanger sequencing, homozygosity mapping, short tandem repeat (STR) analysis and segregation analysis were performed. Functional domains of the pathogenic variant for USH2A were analysed. We identified a homozygous frameshift variant c.99_100insT (p.Arg34Serfs*41) in the USH2A gene in the proband that showed discordant segregation in the father. Further homozygosity mapping and STR analysis identified an unusual homozygous variant of proband that originated from maternal uniparental disomy (UPD). The p.Arg34Serfs*41 variant produced a predicted truncated protein that removes all functional domains of USH2A. The variant was not included in the 1000 Human Genomes Project database, ExAC database, HGMD or gnomAD database, but was included in the ClinVar databases as pathogenic. Although USH2A is an autosomal recessive disease, the effects of UPD should be informed in genetic counselling since the recurrence risk of an affected child is greatly reduced when the disease is due to the UPD mechanism. To test potential patients, WES, combined with STR analysis and homozygosity mapping, provides an accurate and useful strategy for genetic diagnosis. In summary, our discoveries can help further the understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of Usher syndrome type IIA to advance the prevention, diagnosis and therapy for this disorder.     

A novel mutation in <Emphasis Type="Italic">RDH5</Emphasis> gene causes retinitis pigmentosa in consanguineous Pakistani family

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is the most frequent genetically and clinically heterogeneous inherited retinal degeneration. To date, more than 80 genes have been identified that cause autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive and X linked RP. However, locus and allelic heterogeneity of RP has not been fully captured yet. This heterogeneity and lack of an accurate genotype phenotype correlation makes molecular dissection of the disease more difficult. The present study was designed to characterize the underlying pathogenic variants of RP in Pakistan. For this purpose, a large consanguineous family with RP phenotype showing autosomal recessive mode of inheritance was selected after a complete ophthalmological examination. Next generation sequencing was used for the identification of molecular determinant followed by Sanger-sequencing for confirmation. After sequence analysis a novel homozygous missense mutation, (c.602 C?>?T) in exon 4 of the RDH5 gene (MIM: 601617) was identified. This mutation resulted in substitution of phenyl alanine for serine at amino acid 201 (p.Ser201Phe) of the RDH5 gene. The same mutation was not detected in the 200 ethnically-matched control samples by Sanger sequencing. The identified mutant allele segregated in homozygous fashion in all the affected individuals of pedigree. Identification of this mutation reveals the allelic heterogeneity of RDH5 in patients with RP phenotype. The findings of this study demonstrate the clinical significance of next generation sequencing to understand the molecular basis of diseases and would help to reveal new proteins and their function in visual cycle will pave the way for early diagnosis, genetic counseling and better therapeutic inventions.     

Coinheritance of chromosomes 3 and 11 in the patients with autosomal recessive polycythemia from Chuvachia

Inheritance of chromosomes 3 and 11 in the families with Chuvash autosomal recessive polycythemia and in control group with no disease symptoms was examined using polymorphic dinucleotide markers D3S1597 and D3S1263, mapped to region 3p25, and D11S4111, D11S4127, and D11S1356, mapped to region 11q23. All patients were homozygous for the C598T mutation in the VHL gene (3p25). The analysis showed that in 75% of the cases, chromosome 3 carrying C598T mutation was coinherited with certain chromosome 11, which differed from 50%, expected upon independent inheritance of each chromosome. In case of chromosome 3 without C598T mutation, this pattern was observed neither in healthy sibs form the families with autosomal recessive polycythemia (44%), nor in the control group (43%). These results suggest that in case of the C598T mutation in the VHL gene, chromosomal loci 3p25 and 11q23 are inherited not independently, compared to the inheritance of these loci in the absence of the mutation in healthy sibs from the affected families (chi2 = 16.14; P < 0.001), and also in the control family sample (chi2 = 17.91; P < 0.001).     

Floating-Harbor syndrome in two sisters: autosomal recessive inheritance or germinal mosaicism?

We describe the clinical histories and physical findings most compatible with the diagnosis of Floating-Harbor syndrome in two sisters. The genetic basis of the Floating-Harbor syndrome is still unclear, and family data are in favour of autosomal recessive inheritance although germinal mosaicism for an autosomal dominant gene mutation cannot be fully excluded.     

An unusual FGFR1 mutation (fibroblast growth factor receptor 1 mutation) in a girl with non-syndromic trigonocephaly

Non-syndromic trigonocephaly is a heterogeneous entity; in most cases the origin is unknown. Rare cases with autosomal dominant and recessive inheritance exist. Here the mutational screening of ten patients in the FGFR1, 2, and 3 genes and the TWIST gene causative of autosomal dominant craniosynostosis syndromes was reported. In one girl an unusual FGFR1 mutation was found.     

Whole Exome Sequencing Identifies Recessive PKHD1 Mutations in a Chinese Twin Family with Caroli Disease

Background

Mutations in PKHD1 cause autosomal recessive Caroli disease, which is a rare congenital disorder involving cystic dilatation of the intrahepatic bile ducts. However, the mutational spectrum of PKHD1 and the phenotype-genotype correlations have not yet been fully established.

Methods

Whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed on one twin sample with Caroli disease from a Chinese family from Shandong province. Routine Sanger sequencing was used to validate the WES and to carry out segregation studies. We also described the PKHD1 mutation associated with the genotype-phenotype of this twin.

Results

A combination of WES and Sanger sequencing revealed the genetic defect to be a novel compound heterozygous genotype in PKHD1, including the missense mutation c.2507 T>C, predicted to cause a valine to alanine substitution at codon 836 (c.2507T>C, p.Val836Ala), and the nonsense mutation c.2341C>T, which is predicted to result in an arginine to stop codon at codon 781 (c.2341C>T, p.Arg781*). This compound heterozygous genotype co-segregates with the Caroli disease-affected pedigree members, but is absent in 200 normal chromosomes.

Conclusions

Our findings indicate exome sequencing can be useful in the diagnosis of Caroli disease patients and associate a compound heterozygous genotype in PKHD1 with Caroli disease, which further increases our understanding of the mutation spectrum of PKHD1 in association with Caroli disease.     

Detection of New Paternal Dystrophin Gene Mutations in Isolated Cases of Dystrophinopathy in Females

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is one of the most common lethal monogenic disorders and is caused by dystrophin deficiency. The disease is transmitted as an X-linked recessive trait; however, recent biochemical and clinical studies have shown that many girls and women with a primary myopathy have an underlying dystrophinopathy, despite a negative family history for Duchenne dystrophy. These isolated female dystrophinopathy patients carried ambiguous diagnoses with presumed autosomal recessive inheritance (limbgirdle muscular dystrophy) prior to biochemical detection of dystrophin abnormalities in their muscle biopsy. It has been assumed that these female dystrophinopathy patients are heterozygous carriers who show preferential inactivation of the X chromosome harboring the normal dystrophin gene, although this has been shown for only a few X:autosome translocations and for two cases of discordant monozygotic twin female carriers. Here we study X-inactivation patterns of 13 female dystrophinopathy patients—10 isolated cases and 3 cases with a positive family history for Duchenne dystrophy in males. We show that all cases have skewed X-inactivation patterns in peripheral blood DNA. Of the nine isolated cases informative in our assay, eight showed inheritance of the dystrophin gene mutation from the paternal germ line. Only a single case showed maternal inheritance. The 10-fold higher incidence of paternal transmission of dystrophin gene mutations in these cases is at 30-fold variance with Bayesian predictions and gene mutation rates. Thus, our results suggest some mechanistic interaction between new dystrophin gene mutations, paternal inheritance, and skewed X inactivation. Our results provide both empirical risk data and a molecular diagnostic test method, which permit genetic counseling and prenatal diagnosis of this new category of patients.     

Autosomal Recessive Transmission of MYBPC3 Mutation Results in Malignant Phenotype of Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy

Background

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) due to mutations in genes encoding sarcomere proteins is most commonly inherited as an autosomal dominant trait. Since nearly 50% of HCM cases occur in the absence of a family history, a recessive inheritance pattern may be involved.

Methods

A pedigree was identified with suspected autosomal recessive transmission of HCM. Twenty-six HCM-related genes were comprehensively screened for mutations in the proband with targeted second generation sequencing, and the identified mutation was confirmed with bi-directional Sanger sequencing in all family members and 376 healthy controls.

Results

A novel missense mutation (c.1469G>T, p.Gly490Val) in exon 17 of MYBPC3 was identified. Two siblings with HCM were homozygous for this mutation, whereas other family members were either heterozygous or wild type. Clinical evaluation showed that both homozygotes manifested a typical HCM presentation, but none of others, including 5 adult heterozygous mutation carriers up to 71 years of age, had any clinical evidence of HCM.

Conclusions

Our data identified a MYBPC3 mutation in HCM, which appeared autosomal recessively inherited in this family. The absence of a family history of clinical HCM may be due to not only a de novo mutation, but also recessive mutations that failed to produce a clinical phenotype in heterozygous family members. Therefore, consideration of recessive mutations leading to HCM is essential for risk stratification and genetic counseling.     

Retinitis pigmentosa: distribution of inheritance patterns in a VA blind rehabilitation center population

Objectives: This purpose of this study was to characterize retinitis pigmentosa (RP) patients at the Southeastern Blind Rehabilitation Center (SBRC) by inheritance pattern, and compare the results with similar studies. Study Design: Records of all RP patients who were in the blind rehabilitation program at the SBRC between 1989 and 1993 were reviewed (n=50). Patients were included in the study who could be personally contacted and whose records were complete (n=43). Pedigrees were obtained through review of records and patient interviews. Results: The analysis showed 24 patients (55.8%) were simplex (no family history of RP), 8 patients (18.6%) were autosomal dominant, 4 patients (9.3%) were probable autosomal dominant, 4 patients (9.3%) were autosomal recessive, 2 patients (4.7%) were probable autosomal recessive and 1 patient (2.3%) was X-linked recessive. Conclusions: Unique trends were apparent in the distribution of inheritance patterns. Clinicians should be aware of the large number of simplex patients found in this and the majority of similar studies.     

Exome Sequencing Identifies a Founder Frameshift Mutation in an Alternative Exon of USH1C as the Cause of Autosomal Recessive Retinitis Pigmentosa with Late-Onset Hearing Loss

We used a combined approach of homozygosity mapping and whole exome sequencing (WES) to search for the genetic cause of autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa (arRP) in families of Yemenite Jewish origin. Homozygosity mapping of two arRP Yemenite Jewish families revealed a few homozygous regions. A subsequent WES analysis of the two index cases revealed a shared homozygous novel nucleotide deletion (c.1220delG) leading to a frameshift (p.Gly407Glufs*56) in an alternative exon (#15) of USH1C. Screening of additional Yemenite Jewish patients revealed a total of 16 homozygous RP patients (with a carrier frequency of 0.008 in controls). Funduscopic and electroretinography findings were within the spectrum of typical RP. While other USH1C mutations usually cause Usher type I (including RP, vestibular dysfunction and congenital deafness), audiometric screening of 10 patients who are homozygous for c.1220delG revealed that patients under 40 years of age had normal hearing while older patients showed mild to severe high tone sensorineural hearing loss. This is the first report of a mutation in a known USH1 gene that causes late onset rather than congenital sensorineural hearing loss. The c.1220delG mutation of USH1C accounts for 23% of RP among Yemenite Jewish patients in our cohort.     

Exome sequencing and metabolomic analysis of a chronic kidney disease and hearing loss patient family revealed RMND1 mutation induced sphingolipid metabolism defects

Mitochondrial disorders (MIDs) shows overlapping clinical presentations owing to the genetic and metabolic defects of mitochondria. However, specific relationship between inherited mutations in nuclear encoded mitochondrial proteins and their functional impacts in terms of metabolic defects in patients is not yet well explored. Therefore, using high throughput whole exome sequencing (WES), we screened a chronic kidney disease (CKD) and sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) patient, and her family members to ascertain the mode of inheritance of the mutation, and healthy population controls to establish its rare frequency. The impact of mutation on biophysical characteristics of the protein was further studied by mapping it in 3D structure. Furthermore, LC-MS tandem mass spectrophotometry based untargeted metabolomic profiling was done to study the fluctuations in plasma metabolites relevant to disease causative mutations and kidney damage. We identified a very rare homozygous c.631G > A (p.Val211Met) pathogenic mutation in RMND1 gene in the proband, which is inherited in an autosomal recessive fashion. This gene is involved in the mitochondrial translational pathways and contribute in mitochondrial energy metabolism. The p.Val211Met mutation is found to disturb the structural orientation (RMSD is −2.95 Å) and stability (ΔΔG is −0.552 Kcal/mol) of the RMND1 protein. Plasma metabolomics analysis revealed the aberrant accumulation of metabolites connected to lipid and amino acid metabolism pathways. Of these metabolites, pathway networking has discovered ceramide, a metabolite of sphingolipids, which plays a role in different signaling cascades including mitochondrial membrane biosynthesis, is highly elevated in this patient. This study suggests that genetic defects in RMND1 gene alters the mitochondrial energy metabolism leading to the accumulation of ceramide, and subsequently promote dysregulated apoptosis and tissue necrosis in kidneys.     

Molecular analysis of TMC1 gene in the Korean patients with nonsyndromic hearing loss

Hereditary nonsyndromic hearing loss (NSHL) is a highly heterogeneous disorder in humans. Mutations of the transmembrane channel-like (TMC1) gene have been identified as the genetic cause for both autosomal recessive (DFNB7/11) and autosomal dominant (DFNA36) nonsyndromic hearing loss. To evaluate the spectrum and frequency of mutation(s) caused by TMC1 gene in the Korean population, we have performed sequencing analysis of the PCR products amplified from genomic DNA of each proband in 193 unrelated families showing 30 autosomal dominant and 163 autosomal recessive inheritance patterns. As a result, we identified eight different novel sequence variations for the first time in this study, respectively. However, none of these showed co-segregation of phenotype in the families. Therefore, our study suggests that the TMC1 gene is not the cause of nonsyndromic hearing loss in the Korean population.     

Autosomal recessive inheritance of goiter in Dutch goats

The inheritance of congenital goiter due to a thyroglobulin synthesis defect in a strain of Dutch goats has been studied by Mendelian and biochemical methods. Mendelian analysis of 301 matings, resulting in 591 kids, showed an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance. A restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) in the thyroglobulin gene also was used to confirm the recessive mode of inheritance of the defect. In a pedigree consisting of 27 goats, spanning four generations, the genotype determined by RFLP study was in accordance with the observed phenotype and the autosomal inheritance of the defect. Although phenotypically no differences were detected between normal and heterozygous animals, the use of RFLPs allowed the diagnosis of the three genotypes.     

A Recessive Founder Mutation in Regulator of Telomere Elongation Helicase 1, RTEL1, Underlies Severe Immunodeficiency and Features of Hoyeraal Hreidarsson Syndrome

Dyskeratosis congenita (DC) is a heterogeneous inherited bone marrow failure and cancer predisposition syndrome in which germline mutations in telomere biology genes account for approximately one-half of known families. Hoyeraal Hreidarsson syndrome (HH) is a clinically severe variant of DC in which patients also have cerebellar hypoplasia and may present with severe immunodeficiency and enteropathy. We discovered a germline autosomal recessive mutation in RTEL1, a helicase with critical telomeric functions, in two unrelated families of Ashkenazi Jewish (AJ) ancestry. The affected individuals in these families are homozygous for the same mutation, R1264H, which affects three isoforms of RTEL1. Each parent was a heterozygous carrier of one mutant allele. Patient-derived cell lines revealed evidence of telomere dysfunction, including significantly decreased telomere length, telomere length heterogeneity, and the presence of extra-chromosomal circular telomeric DNA. In addition, RTEL1 mutant cells exhibited enhanced sensitivity to the interstrand cross-linking agent mitomycin C. The molecular data and the patterns of inheritance are consistent with a hypomorphic mutation in RTEL1 as the underlying basis of the clinical and cellular phenotypes. This study further implicates RTEL1 in the etiology of DC/HH and immunodeficiency, and identifies the first known homozygous autosomal recessive disease-associated mutation in RTEL1.     

Whole exome sequencing,in silico and functional studies confirm the association of the GJB2 mutation p.Cys169Tyr with deafness and suggest a role for the TMEM59 gene in the hearing process

The development of next generation sequencing techniques has facilitated the detection of mutations at an unprecedented rate. These efficient tools have been particularly beneficial for extremely heterogeneous disorders such as autosomal recessive non-syndromic hearing loss, the most common form of genetic deafness. GJB2 mutations are the most common cause of hereditary hearing loss. Amongst them the NM_004004.5: c.506G > A (p.Cys169Tyr) mutation has been associated with varying severity of hearing loss with unclear segregation patterns. In this study, we report a large consanguineous Emirati family with severe to profound hearing loss fully segregating the GJB2 missense mutation p.Cys169Tyr. Whole exome sequencing (WES), in silico, splicing and expression analyses ruled out the implication of any other variants and confirmed the implication of the p.Cys169Tyr mutation in this deafness family. We also show preliminary murine expression analysis that suggests a link between the TMEM59 gene and the hearing process. The present study improves our understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of hearing loss. It also emphasizes the significance of combining next generation sequencing approaches and segregation analyses especially in the diagnosis of disorders characterized by complex genetic heterogeneity.