The relationship between dynamic balancing ability and posture-related modulation of the soleus H-reflex

Soleus H-reflex reveals down modulation with increased postural difficulty. Role of this posture-related reflex modulation is thought to shift movement control toward higher motor centers in order to facilitate more precise postural control. Present study hypothesized that the ability to modulate H-reflex is related to one’s ability to dynamically balance while in an unstable posture. This study examined the relationship between dynamic balancing ability and soleus H-reflex posture-related modulation. Thirty healthy adults participated. The soleus maximal H-reflex (Hmax), motor response (Mmax), and background EMG activity (bEMG) were obtained during three postural conditions: prone, open-legged standing, and closed-legged standing. Hmax/Mmax ratios were normalized via the corresponding bEMG in order to remove the effects of background muscle activity from the obtained H-reflex. Reflex modulation was calculated as the ratio of the normalized Hmax/Mmax ratios in one postural condition to another posture in a more difficult condition. Dynamic balancing ability was assessed by testing stability while standing on a wobble board. A significant negative correlation was observed between balancing scores and reflex modulation from open-legged standing to closed-legged standing. This suggests that the ability to modulate monosynaptic stretch reflex excitability in response to a changing posture is a significant factor for dynamic balancing.     

Enhanced stretch reflex excitability in the soleus muscle during passive standing posture in humans

The purpose of this study was to test whether the spinal reflex excitability of the soleus muscle is modulated as posture changes from a supine to a passive upright position. Eight healthy subjects (29.6 ± 5.4 yrs) participated in this study. Stretch and H-reflex responses were elicited while the subjects maintained passive standing (ST) and supine (SP) postures. The passive standing posture was accomplished by using a gait orthosis to which a custom-made device was mounted to elicit stretch reflex in the soleus muscle. This orthosis makes it possible to elicit stretch and H-reflexes without background muscle activity in the soleus muscle. The results revealed that the H-reflex amplitude in the ST was smaller than that in the SP condition, which is in good agreement with previous reports. On the other hand, the stretch reflex was significantly larger in the ST than in the SP condition. Since the experimental conditions of both the stretch and H-reflex measurements were exactly the same, the results were attributed to differences in the underlying neural mechanisms of the two reflex systems: different sensitivity of the presynaptic inhibition onto the spinal motoneuron pool and/or a change in the muscle spindle sensitivity.     

Similarities and Differences of the Soleus and Gastrocnemius H-reflexes during Varied Body Postures, Foot Positions, and Muscle Function: Multifactor Designs for Repeated Measures

Background  

Although the soleus (Sol), medial gastrocnemius (MG), and lateral gastrocnemius (LG) muscles differ in function, composition, and innervations, it is a common practice is to investigate them as single H-reflex recording. The purpose of this study was to compare H-reflex recordings between these three sections of the triceps surae muscle group of healthy participants while lying and standing during three different ankle positions.     

Vestibulospinal influences on lower limb motoneurons

Galvanic vestibular stimulation (GVS) is a research tool used to activate the vestibular system in human subjects. When a low-intensity stimulus (1-4 mA) is delivered percutaneously to the vestibular nerve, a transient electromyographic response is observed a short time later in lower limb muscles. Typically, galvanically evoked responses are present when the test muscle is actively engaged in controlling standing balance. However, there is evidence to suggest that GVS may be able to modulate the activity of lower limb muscles when subjects are not in a free-standing situation. The purpose of this review is to examine 2 studies from our laboratory that examined the effects of GVS on the lower limb motoneuron pool. For instance, a monopolar monaural galvanic stimulus modified the amplitude of the ipsilateral soleus H-reflex. Furthermore, bipolar binaural GVS significantly altered the onset of activation and the initial firing frequency of gastrocnemius motor units. The following paper examines the effects of GVS on muscles that are not being used to maintain balance. We propose that GVS is modulating motor output by influencing the activity of presynaptic inhibitory mechanisms that act on the motoneuron pool.     

The investigation of control mechanisms of stepping rhythm in human in the air-stepping conditions during passive and voluntary leg movements

In unloading condition the degree of activation of the central stepping program was investigated during passive leg movements in healthy subjects, as well as the excitability of spinal motoneurons during passive and voluntary stepping movement. Passive stepping movements with characteristics maximally approximated to those during voluntary stepping were accomplished by experimenter. The comparison of the muscle activity bursts during voluntary and imposed movements was made. In addition to that the influence of artificially created loading onto the foot to the leg movement characteristics was analyzed. Spinal motoneuron excitability was estimated by means of evaluation of amplitude modulation of the soleus H-reflex. The changes of H-reflexes under the fixation of knee or hip joints were also studied. In majority of subjects the passive movements were accompanied by bursts of EMG activity of hip muscles (and sometimes of knee muscles), which timing during step cycle was coincided with burst timing of voluntary step cycle. In many cases the bursts of EMG activity during passive movements exceeded activity in homonymous muscles during voluntary stepping. The foot loading imitation exerted essential influence on distal parts of moving extremity during voluntary as well passive movements, that was expressed in the appearance of movements in the ankle joint and accompanied by emergence and increasing of phasic EMG activity of shank muscles. The excitability of motoneurons during passive movements was greater then during voluntary ones. The changes and modulation of H-reflex throughout the step cycle without restriction of joint mobility and during exclusion of hip joint mobility were similar. The knee joint fixation exerted the greater influence. It is supposed that imposed movements activate the same mechanisms of rhythm generation as a supraspinal commands during voluntary movements. In the conditions of passive movements the presynaptic inhibition depend on afferent influences from moving leg in the most degree then on central commands. It seems that afferent inputs from pressure receptors of foot in the condition of "air-stepping" actively interact with central program of stepping and, irrespective of type of the performing movements (voluntary or passive), form the final pattern activity.     

On the methods employed to record and measure the human soleus H-reflex

The aim of this study was to investigate if the magnitude of the soleus H-reflex is different depending on the method employed to measure its size (peak-to-peak amplitude vs. area). In this study, 13 healthy human subjects participated, while the soleus H-reflex was induced via conventional methods. In the first experiment, the soleus H-reflex was recorded via two monopolar electrodes and was evoked at least at eight different stimulation intensities in respect to the recovery curve of the H-reflex and at three different inter-stimulus intervals (ISIs) (8, 5, and 2 s). The ISI refers to the time delay between the single pulses delivered to the posterior tibial nerve within a single trial. In the second experiment, the effects of common peroneal nerve (CPN) stimulation at short (2-4 ms) and at long (60-120 ms) conditioning test (C-T) intervals on the soleus H-reflex elicited every 5 s were established. Control and conditioned reflexes were recorded via a single differential bipolar electrode. In both experiments, H-reflexes were quantified by measuring their size as peak-to-peak amplitude and as area under the full-wave rectified waveform. The reflex responses recorded through two monopolar electrodes across stimulation intensities and ISIs measured as peak-to-peak amplitude had larger values than measured as area. In contrast, the magnitude of the reflexes, conditioned by CPN stimulation at either short or long C-T intervals and recorded via a single differential electrode, were not significantly different when measured as peak-to-peak amplitude or as area. Our findings indicate that monopolar recordings yield different reflex sizes depending on the method employed to measure the reflex size, and that the H-reflex measured as area might detect better the homosynaptic reflex depression. The lack of observing such differences with bipolar recordings might be related to changes of the reflex shape at a given stimulus intensity due to inhibitory inputs. The implications of our findings are discussed in respect to human reflex studies.     

Influences of neck vibration on lower limb extensor muscles in man

The effects of neck vibration were studied in ten healthy subjects standing in unrestrained or restrained conditions. An involuntary slow and gradual displacement of the body axis associated with a subjective experience of forward tilt occurred during vibration of the dorsal surface of the neck. This effect was associated with a decreased tonic contration of the antigravitary lower limb musculature. The amplitude of the H-reflex from the soleus muscle, recorded at progressively increasing time interval after the onset of the vibratory stimulus, showed complex interactions: in particular, in unrestrained conditions an early inhibitory phase occurred at about 100 msec, followed by a short-lasting facilitatory phase between 150-300 msec and by a late long-lasting excitatory component which started 500-600 msec after the onset of vibratory stimulus. In restrained subjects, the late excitatory phase disappeared and was substituted by a delayed depression. In this instance, the short-lasting facilitatory phase appeared to be superimposed on a background of inhibition. The effects produced by the neck input on the H-reflex were attenuated during vibration of the dorsal muscolature at L4-L5. The mechanisms involved in the cervical control of posture and reflex movements following neck vibration are discussed.     

Somatosensory graviception inhibits the soleus H-reflex in standing man - a parabolic flight experiment-

The purpose of this study was to investigate how gravity level affects the excitability of the soleus muscle (SOL) motoneuron pool to la afferent input while erect posture is maintained in humans. Three healthy male subjects participated in an experiment whereby three different gravity conditions (micro gravity (MG), normal gravity (NG), and hyper gravity) were imposed using a parabolic flight procedure. The SOL H-reflex was evoked every 2 seconds while the subjects kept an erect posture. The background electromyographic activity (BGA) of the SOL was almost absent during MG. The SOL H-reflex amplitude was significantly larger during MG than during NG. These results suggest that the somatosensory systems detecting a load at the lower limbs and/or vertebral column play a role in reducing the excitability of the SOL motoneuron pool to la afferent inputs by presynaptic inhibition.     

On the methods employed to record and measure the human soleus H-reflex

The aim of this study was to investigate if the magnitude of the soleus H-reflex is different depending on the method employed to measure its size (peak-to-peak amplitude vs. area). In this study, 13 healthy human subjects participated, while the soleus H-reflex was induced via conventional methods. In the first experiment, the soleus H-reflex was recorded via two monopolar electrodes and was evoked at least at eight different stimulation intensities in respect to the recovery curve of the H-reflex and at three different inter-stimulus intervals (ISIs) (8, 5, and 2?s). The ISI refers to the time delay between the single pulses delivered to the posterior tibial nerve within a single trial. In the second experiment, the effects of common peroneal nerve (CPN) stimulation at short (2–4?ms) and at long (60–120?ms) conditioning test (C-T) intervals on the soleus H-reflex elicited every 5?s were established. Control and conditioned reflexes were recorded via a single differential bipolar electrode. In both experiments, H-reflexes were quantified by measuring their size as peak-to-peak amplitude and as area under the full-wave rectified waveform. The reflex responses recorded through two monopolar electrodes across stimulation intensities and ISIs measured as peak-to-peak amplitude had larger values than measured as area. In contrast, the magnitude of the reflexes, conditioned by CPN stimulation at either short or long C-T intervals and recorded via a single differential electrode, were not significantly different when measured as peak-to-peak amplitude or as area. Our findings indicate that monopolar recordings yield different reflex sizes depending on the method employed to measure the reflex size, and that the H-reflex measured as area might detect better the homosynaptic reflex depression. The lack of observing such differences with bipolar recordings might be related to changes of the reflex shape at a given stimulus intensity due to inhibitory inputs. The implications of our findings are discussed in respect to human reflex studies.     

Effects of repeated ankle plantar-flexions on H-reflex and body sway during standing

The study investigated relations between effects of repeated ankle plantar-flexion movements exercise on the soleus Hoffmann (H) reflex and on postural body sway when maintaining upright stance. Ten young volunteers performed five sets of ankle plantar-flexions of both lower limbs. Assessment of the feet centre-of-pressure (COP) displacement and H-reflex tests were carried out in quiet stance before, during and after the exercise. H-max and M-max responses were obtained in 8 subjects and reported as the peak-to-peak amplitudes of the right soleus muscle electromyographic waves. Mean dispersion of COP along the antero-posterior direction increased significantly during the exercise; whilst the overall H-reflex response indicated a reduction without a concomitant modification in the M-max response. H-reflex responses, however, varied between participants during the first sets of exercise, showing two main trends of modulation: either depression or early facilitation followed by reduction of the H-reflex amplitude. The extent of reflex modulation in standing position was correlated to the concentric work performed during the exercise (r = 0.85; p < 0.01), but not to the antero-posterior COP dispersion. These results suggest that during a repeated ankle plantar-flexions exercise, modulation of the H-reflex measured in upright stance differs across individuals and is not related to changes of postural sway.     

Static otolithic drive alters presynaptic inhibition in soleus motor pool

The vestibular system has both direct and indirect connections to the soleus motor pool via the vestibulospinal and reticulospinal tracts. The exact nature of how this vestibular information is integrated within the spinal cord is largely unknown. The purpose of this study was to identify whether changes in static otolithic drive altered the amount of presynaptic inhibition in the soleus H-reflex pathway. Changes in static otolithic drive were investigated in sixteen healthy participants using a tilt table. Two presynaptic pathways (common peroneal and femoral) to the soleus H-reflex were tested in three weight conditions (supine, non-weight bearing, and weight bearing). The dependent variable was the peak-to-peak amplitude of the soleus H-reflex. Inhibition to the soleus motor pool through the common peroneal nerve pathway differed significantly during weight conditions and tilt. During tilt and non-weight bearing there was greater inhibition of the soleus H-reflex compared to supine, however, this effect was reversed during tilt and weight bearing. Facilitation from the femoral nerve pathway was reduced by tilt compared to supine, but this reduction was unaffected by weight condition. This supports a role of the vestibular system as providing complex, task-dependent presynaptic input to motoneurons in the lower limbs.     

Post-tetanic potentiation of reciprocal Ia inhibition in human lower limb.

The purpose of this study was to investigate how reciprocal Ia inhibition is changed during muscle fatigue of lower limb muscle, induced with a voluntary contraction or height frequency electrical stimulation. Reciprocal Ia inhibition from ankle flexors to extensors has been investigated in 12 healthy subjects. Hoffmann reflex (H-reflex) in the soleus muscle was used to monitor changes in the amount of reciprocal Ia inhibition from common peroneal nerve as demonstrated during voluntary dorsi or planterflexion and 50 Hz electrical stimulation induced dorsi or planterflexion. The test soleus H-reflex was kept at 20-25% of maximum directly evoked motor response (M response) and the strength of the conditioning common peroneal nerve stimulation was kept at 1.0 x motor threshold. At rest, weak la inhibition was demonstrated in 12 subjects, maximal inhibition from the common peroneal nerve was 28.8%. During voluntary dorsiflexion and 50 Hz electrical stimulation induced dorsiflexion, there absolute amounts of inhibition increased as compared to at rest, and decreased or disappeared during voluntary planterflexion and 50 Hz electrical stimulation induced planterflexion as compared to at rest. During voluntary or electrical stimulation induced agonist muscle fatigue, the inhibition of the soleus H-reflex from the common peroneal nerve was greater during voluntary dorsiflexion (maximal, 11.1%) and 50 Hz (maximal, 6.7%) electrical stimulation induced dorsiflexion than at rest. The inhibition was decreased or disappeared during voluntary planterflexion 50 Hz electrical stimulation induced planterflexion. It was concluded that the results were considered to support the hypothesis that alpha-motoneurones and la inhibitory intemeurones link to antagonist motoneurones in reciprocal inhibition. The diminished reciprocal Ia inhibition of voluntary contraction during muscle fatigue as compared to electrical stimulation, is discussed in relation to its possible contribution to ankle stability.     

Effects of vibration intensity on lower limb joint moments during standing

Muscle activity and joint moment of the lower limbs can provide different information about the stimulation of controlled whole-body vibration (CWBV) on human body. Previous studies investigated the immediate effects of the intensity of CWBV on enhancing lower-limb muscle activity. However, no study has examined the possible influence of CWBV intensity on joint loading. It remains unexplored how CWBV intensity impacts joint loading. This study was carried out (1) to quantify the effects of CWBV intensity in terms of vibration frequency and amplitude on the lower limb joint moments and (2) to examine the relationship between leg joint moments and vibration intensity characterized by the platform’s acceleration, that is determined by frequency and amplitude, during standing among young adults. Thirty healthy young adults participated in this study. Each participant experienced nine vibration intensity levels dependent upon the frequency (10, 20, and 30 Hz) and amplitude (1, 2, and 3 mm) while standing on a side-alternating vibration platform. Their body kinematics and vertical reaction forces between the feet and platform were collected. Inverse dynamics was employed to calculate the resultant moment for the ankle, knee, and hip joints in the sagittal plane. Our results revealed that the root-mean-square moment significantly increases with increasing vibration frequency or amplitude for all three joints. Further, all joint moments are strongly and positively correlated with the platform acceleration.     

Rhythmic arm swing enhances long latency facilitatory effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation on soleus motoneuron pool excitability

The purpose of this study was to investigate whether rhythmic arm swing modulates the long latency effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on soleus motoneuron pool excitability. Ten healthy humans rhythmically swung the left arm back and forth in a sitting position. The soleus H-reflex was evoked when the arm was in the backward swing phase. Conditioning TMS was delivered over the motor cortex 8?ms before the soleus H-reflex was evoked. The soleus H-reflex amplitude in both legs was depressed by the rhythmic arm swing. In contrast, rhythmic arm swing enhanced the facilitatory effect of conditioning TMS over the motor cortex contralateral to the arm swing side on the soleus H-reflex ipsilateral to the arm swing side. This finding indicates that rhythmic arm swing enhances some polysynaptic facilitatory pathways from the motor cortex contralateral to the arm swing side to the soleus motoneuron pool ipsilateral to the arm swing side.     

Rhythmic arm swing enhances long latency facilitatory effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation on soleus motoneuron pool excitability

The purpose of this study was to investigate whether rhythmic arm swing modulates the long latency effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on soleus motoneuron pool excitability. Ten healthy humans rhythmically swung the left arm back and forth in a sitting position. The soleus H-reflex was evoked when the arm was in the backward swing phase. Conditioning TMS was delivered over the motor cortex 8 ms before the soleus H-reflex was evoked. The soleus H-reflex amplitude in both legs was depressed by the rhythmic arm swing. In contrast, rhythmic arm swing enhanced the facilitatory effect of conditioning TMS over the motor cortex contralateral to the arm swing side on the soleus H-reflex ipsilateral to the arm swing side. This finding indicates that rhythmic arm swing enhances some polysynaptic facilitatory pathways from the motor cortex contralateral to the arm swing side to the soleus motoneuron pool ipsilateral to the arm swing side.     

Changes in H reflex and V wave following short-term endurance and strength training

This study examined the effects of 3 wk of either endurance or strength training on plasticity of the neural mechanisms involved in the soleus H reflex and V wave. Twenty-five sedentary healthy subjects were randomized into an endurance group (n = 13) or strength group (n = 12). Evoked V-wave, H-reflex, and M-wave recruitment curves, maximal voluntary contraction (MVC), and time-to-task-failure (isometric contraction at 40% MVC) of the plantar flexors were recorded before and after training. Following strength training, MVC of the plantar flexors increased by 14.4 ± 5.2% in the strength group (P < 0.001), whereas time-to-task-failure was prolonged in the endurance group (22.7 ± 17.1%; P < 0.05). The V wave-to-maximal M wave (V/M(max)) ratio increased significantly (55.1 ± 28.3%; P < 0.001) following strength training, but the maximal H wave-to-maximal M wave (H(max)/M(max)) ratio remained unchanged. Conversely, in the endurance group the V/M(max) ratio was not altered, whereas the H(max)/M(max) ratio increased by 30.8 ± 21.7% (P < 0.05). The endurance training group also displayed a reduction in the H-reflex excitability threshold while the H-reflex amplitude on the ascending limb of the recruitment curve increased. Strength training only elicited a significant decrease in H-reflex excitability threshold, while H-reflex amplitudes over the ascending limb remained unchanged. These observations indicate that the H-reflex pathway is strongly involved in the enhanced endurance resistance that occurs following endurance training. On the contrary, the improvements in MVC following strength training are likely attributed to increased descending drive and/or modulation in afferents other than Ia afferents.     

Effects of homosynaptic depression on spectral properties of H-reflex recordings

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of homosynaptic depression (HD) on spectral properties of the soleus (SOL) H-reflex. Paired stimulations, separated by 100?ms, were used to elicit an unconditioned and conditioned H-reflex in the SOL muscle of 20 participants during quiet standing. Wavelet and principal component analyses were used to analyze features of the time-varying spectral properties of the unconditioned and conditioned H-reflex. The effects of HD on spectral properties of the H-reflex signal were quantified by comparing extracted principal component scores. The analysis extracted two principal components: one associated with the intensity of the spectra and one associated with its frequency. The scores for both principal components were smaller for the conditioned H-reflex. HD decreases the spectral intensity and changes the spectral frequency of H-reflexes. These results suggest that HD changes the recruitment pattern of the motor units evoked during H-reflex stimulations, in that it not only decreases the intensity, but also changes the types of motor units that contribute to the H-reflex signal.     

Movement behavior of high-heeled walking: how does the nervous system control the ankle joint during an unstable walking condition?

The human locomotor system is flexible and enables humans to move without falling even under less than optimal conditions. Walking with high-heeled shoes constitutes an unstable condition and here we ask how the nervous system controls the ankle joint in this situation? We investigated the movement behavior of high-heeled and barefooted walking in eleven female subjects. The movement variability was quantified by calculation of approximate entropy (ApEn) in the ankle joint angle and the standard deviation (SD) of the stride time intervals. Electromyography (EMG) of the soleus (SO) and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles and the soleus Hoffmann (H-) reflex were measured at 4.0 km/h on a motor driven treadmill to reveal the underlying motor strategies in each walking condition. The ApEn of the ankle joint angle was significantly higher (p<0.01) during high-heeled (0.38±0.08) than during barefooted walking (0.28±0.07). During high-heeled walking, coactivation between the SO and TA muscles increased towards heel strike and the H-reflex was significantly increased in terminal swing by 40% (p<0.01). These observations show that high-heeled walking is characterized by a more complex and less predictable pattern than barefooted walking. Increased coactivation about the ankle joint together with increased excitability of the SO H-reflex in terminal swing phase indicates that the motor strategy was changed during high-heeled walking. Although, the participants were young, healthy and accustomed to high-heeled walking the results demonstrate that that walking on high-heels needs to be controlled differently from barefooted walking. We suggest that the higher variability reflects an adjusted neural strategy of the nervous system to control the ankle joint during high-heeled walking.     

Influence of stimulus intensity on the soleus H-reflex amplitude and modulation during locomotion

Diverging results have been reported regarding the modulation and amplitude of the soleus H-reflex measured during human walking and running. A possible explanation to this could be the use of too high stimulus strength in some studies while not in others. During activities like walking and running it is necessary to use a small M-wave to control the effective stimulus strength during all phases of the movement. This implies that the descending part of the H-reflex recruitment curve is being used, which may lead to an unwanted suppression of the H-reflex due to limitations imbedded within the H-reflex methodology itself.Accordingly, the purpose of the present study was to study the effect on the soleus H-reflex during walking and running using stimulus intensities normally considered too high (up to 45% Mmax).Using M-waves of 25–45% Mmax as opposed to 5–25% Mmax showed a significant suppression of the peak H-reflex during the stance phase of walking, while no changes were observed during running. No differences were observed regarding modulation pattern. So a possible use of too high stimulus intensity cannot explain the differences mentioned. The surprising result in running may be explained by the much higher voluntary muscle activity, which implies the existence of a V-wave influencing the H-reflex amplitude in positive direction.     

Responses of Hoffman-reflex in human soleus to gravity and/or fluid shift

Responses of Hoffman (H)-reflex in human soleus to changes in the levels of gravity, activities of skeletal muscles, and/or fluid distribution of lower limbs during the parabolic flight of a jet airplane and/or using a tilting table were studied. The time interval between the electrical stimulation and the appearance of either M- or H-wave and the amplitude of M-wave were not influenced by the changes in gravity and fluid distribution levels. However, the H-wave amplitude was increased when the subjects were exposed to microgravity (microgravity-G). Hypergravity at 1.5- or 2-G had no effect on the H-wave amplitude. The H-reflex had no relation with the changes of electromyogram activities of skeletal muscles and fluid volume in lower limbs. Further, the H-wave amplitude was even decreased insignificantly when the distribution of lower limb fluid was reduced at head-down position on the table. It is suggested that an acute exposure to microgravity-G increases the excitability of soleus motor pool, but the mechanism is still unclear.