Disorganization is a completely dominant gain-of-function mouse mutation causing sporadic developmental defects.

Disorganization (Ds) is an exceptional mutation because of its diverse and profound developmental effects. Although other mouse mutations produce similar congenital defects, extreme pleiotropism, random occurrence, developmental independence of multiple defects, and type of anomaly make Ds unique. Examples of developmental defects include cranioschisis, rachischisis, thoracoschisis, exencephaly, hamartomas, and anomalies of appendages, digestive, genital and urinary tracts, sense organs, limbs and girdles, tail and pharynx. No other mutation in the mouse has such broad effects. Ds is therefore an important model for studying not only the genetic control of lineage determination and pattern formation, but also the occurrence of sporadic congenital defects. To characterize the effects of gene dosage, we examined the viability and phenotype of Ds homozygotes and the phenotype of +/+/Ds trisomic fetuses. Occurrence of homozygotes was tested by intercrossing Ds/+ heterozygotes, typing genetic markers that flank Ds, and examining homozygotes for morphological abnormalities. Not only were Ds homozygotes found in their expected frequency, homozygotes were not more severely affected than heterozygotes. Trisomies provide a direct test for determining whether Ds is a gain-of-function mutation. Trisomic fetuses were derived by crossing Ds/Ds homozygous mice to hybrid mice that were heterozygous for two related Robertsonian translocations. Two trisomic fetuses had developmental defects characteristic of Ds mice. Together these results demonstrate that Ds is a completely dominant, gain-of-function mutation.     

Tgfbr2 is required for development of the skull vault

Transforming growth factor β (TGFβ) is known to play important roles in multiple developmental processes. One of the main functions is in skeletal development. Our previous studies demonstrated that loss of Tgfbr2 in Prx1Cre-expressing limb mesenchyme results in defects in the long bones and joints of mice. Here we show that loss of Tgfbr2 also results in defects in the development of the skull vault indicating Tgfbr2 has a critical role in intramembranous bone formation as well as endochondral bone formation. Mutant mice did not survive after birth and demonstrated an open skull. The first signs of skull defects were observed at E14.5 day. Prx1Cre⁺/Tgfbr2^f/f embryos showed significantly reduced cell proliferation in the developing mesenchyme of the skull by E14.5 day without any detectable alteration in apoptosis suggesting that reduced cell proliferation in Prx1Cre⁺/Tgfbr2^f/f embryos was at least partially responsible for the defects observed. Immunofluorescent staining showed a significant reduction in the expression of Runx2/Cbfa1 and Osterix/Sp7 in Prx1Cre⁺/Tgfbr2^f/f embryos suggesting that osteoblast differentiation was also altered in Prx1Cre⁺/Tgfbr2^f/f embryos. To distinguish between the effects of losing Tgfbr2 on mesenchymal proliferation versus osteoblast differentiation, osteoprogenitor cells from the skulls of Tgfbr2^f/f embryos were cultured under conditions of high cell density and Tgfbr2 was deleted from the cells using Adeno-Cre virus. RT-PCR analysis showed that the mRNA level of Runx2 and Osterix as well as Dlx5 and Msx2 were down-regulated in Tgfbr2-deleted cultures compared to control cultures indicating that Tgfbr2 regulates osteoblast differentiation independent of regulating proliferation. Together, these results suggest that Tgfbr2 is required for normal development of the skull.     

Two-hit model for sporadic congenital anomalies in mice with the disorganization mutation.

Congenital anomalies have complex etiologies involving both genetic and nongenetic components. Many are sporadic, without obvious evidence for heritability. An important model for these anomalies is a mutation in laboratory mice that is called "disorganization" (Ds), which functions as a variable autosomal dominant and leads to a wide variety of congenital anomalies involving many developmental processes and systems. Variable expressivity, asymmetrical manifestations, and low penetrance suggest that somatic events determine the location and nature of these anomalies. A statistical analysis suggests that occurrence of anomalies in mice with the Ds mutation follows a Poisson distribution. These results suggest that congenital anomalies in mice with the Ds mutation occur independently of each other. We propose that Ds causes a heritable predisposition to congenital anomalies and that Ds and appropriate somatic events combine to compromise normal development. We also propose that some sporadic, nonheritable congenital anomalies involve somatic mutations at Ds-like loci. Ds may therefore serve not only as a model for developmental anomalies in cell fate and pattern formation but also for complex developmental traits showing variable expressivity, low penetrance, and sporadic occurrence in mice and humans.     

Expression of Cre Recombinase in the developing mouse limb bud driven by a Prxl enhancer

We have used a Prx1 limb enhancer to drive expression of Cre Recombinase in transgenic mice. This regulatory element leads to Cre expression throughout the early limb bud mesenchyme and in a subset of craniofacial mesenchyme. Crossing a murine line carrying this transgene to a reporter mouse harboring a floxed Cre-reporter cassette revealed that recombinase activity is first observed in the earliest limb bud at 9.5 dpc. By early to mid bud stages at 10.5 dpc recombination is essentially complete in all mesenchymal cells in the limb. Expression of the Cre recombinase was never detected in the limb bud ectoderm. The use of Prx1-Cre mice should facilitate analysis of gene function in the developing limb.     

A spontaneous mutation in contactin 1 in the mouse

Mutations in the gene encoding the immunoglobulin-superfamily member cell adhesion molecule contactin1 (CNTN1) cause lethal congenital myopathy in human patients and neurodevelopmental phenotypes in knockout mice. Whether the mutant mice provide an accurate model of the human disease is unclear; resolving this will require additional functional tests of the neuromuscular system and examination of Cntn1 mutations on different genetic backgrounds that may influence the phenotype. Toward these ends, we have analyzed a new, spontaneous mutation in the mouse Cntn1 gene that arose in a BALB/c genetic background. The overt phenotype is very similar to the knockout of Cntn1, with affected animals having reduced body weight, a failure to thrive, locomotor abnormalities, and a lifespan of 2-3 weeks. Mice homozygous for the new allele have CNTN1 protein undetectable by western blotting, suggesting that it is a null or very severe hypomorph. In an analysis of neuromuscular function, neuromuscular junctions had normal morphology, consistent with previous studies in knockout mice, and the muscles were able to generate appropriate force when normalized for their reduced size in late stage animals. Therefore, the Cntn1 mutant mice do not show evidence for a myopathy, but instead the phenotype is likely to be caused by dysfunction in the nervous system. Given the similarity of CNTN1 to other Ig-superfamily proteins such as DSCAMs, we also characterized the expression and localization of Cntn1 in the retinas of mutant mice for developmental defects. Despite widespread expression, no anomalies in retinal anatomy were detected histologically or using a battery of cell-type specific antibodies. We therefore conclude that the phenotype of the Cntn1 mice arises from dysfunction in the brain, spinal cord or peripheral nervous system, and is similar in either a BALB/c or B6;129;Black Swiss background, raising a possible discordance between the mouse and human phenotypes resulting from Cntn1 mutations.     

Gestational ethanol exposure disrupts the expression of FGF8 and Sonic hedgehog during limb patterning

BACKGROUND: Ethanol is known to induce a wide variety of gestational anomalies, including skeletal malformations. Gestational ethanol exposure in mice has been shown to induce postaxial digit loss (ectrodactyly). How ethanol induces limb malformations is not understood. To better understand how ethanol effects limb development, we have utilized a transgenic line of mice that expresses beta-galactosidase in the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) of the limbs throughout gestation. METHODS: Pregnant female mice were injected with 2.9, 3.4, or 3.9 gm/kg ethanol at E9.3 and E9.5; embryos were isolated at E11.25, stained for beta-galactosidase activity, and evaluated for AER defects. Based upon the pattern of defects seen, expression of FGF8 in the AER and Sonic hedgehog in the postaxial mesoderm was evaluated by in situ hybridization. RESULTS: Two distinct phenotypes were seen in response to ethanol that were dose dependent. At 2.9 gm/kg ethanol, the most prevalent phenotype was a mislocalization of the AER to regions both dorsal and ventral to the midline. A higher dosage of 3.4 gm/kg ethanol did not increase the mislocalization phenotype, but resulted in a higher frequency of postaxial loss of the AER and associated mesenchymal tissue. The highest dosage utilized (3.9 gm/kg) resulted in a high frequency of both preaxial and postaxial loss of the AER. Through in situ hybridization, we found that ethanol exposure resulted in a concomitant reduction in FGF8 expression in the AER and Sonic hedgehog expression from the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA). CONCLUSIONS: We propose a model where ethanol disrupts the AER/ZPA positive feedback loop to induce postaxial malformations. Preaxial malformations seen at higher ethanol dosage suggest FGF8 as a critical target of ethanol in producing limb defects.     

Identification of a prx1 limb enhancer

Mice with a loss of function of prx1, a paired-related homeobox gene formerly called Mhox, showed craniofacial defects, limb shortening, and incompletely penetrant spina bifida. To investigate the mechanisms that regulate prx1 expression, we analyzed a 2.4-kb prx1 genomic flanking region in transgenic mice. This region of the prx1 gene contains an enhancer element that directs expression of a LacZ reporter gene in limb bud mesenchyme and a subset of craniofacial mesenchyme. Deletional analysis in transgenic founders identified a necessary 530-bp core element. Comparison of this core element with human Prx1 sequence showed two highly conserved cassettes that also contained a prx recognition element. Moreover, transgene expression was diminished in posterior handplate of prx1; prx2 double mutant mice. Our data reveal that the prx1 limb enhancer is proximally located within the prx1 gene and suggest that prx1 may have an autoregulatory function in limb mesenchyme.     

Dynamin-related protein 1 heterozygote knockout mice do not have synaptic and mitochondrial deficiencies

The objective of this study was to elucidate the effect of partial reduction of the mitochondrial fission protein, dynamin-related protein 1 (Drp1) on mitochondrial activity and synaptic viability. Recent knockout studies of Drp1 revealed that homozygote Drp1 knockout mice are embryonic lethal due to reduced mitochondrial fission, and that this reduced fission leads to developmental defects in the brain. In contrast, heterozygote Drp1 knockout mice appear to be normal in terms of lifespan, fertility, and viability, and phenotypically these animals are not different from wild-type mice. However, the effects of partial Drp1 reduction on mitochondrial function and synaptic activity are not well understood. In the present study, we sought to characterize synaptic, dendritic and mitochondrial proteins, and mitochondrial function and GTPase enzymatic activity, in Drp1 heterozygote knockout mice. Interestingly, we found no significant changes in synaptic, dendritic, and mitochondrial proteins in the Drp1 heterozygote knockout mice compared to the wild-type mice. Further, mitochondrial function and GTPase enzymatic activity appeared to be normal. However, H(2)O(2) and lipid peroxidation levels were significantly reduced in the Drp1 heterozygote knockout mice compared to the wild-type mice. These findings suggest that partial Drp1 reduction does not affect mitochondrial and synaptic viability and may have therapeutic use in treating patients with Alzheimer's disease and Huntington's disease.     

Prx1 and Prx2 are upstream regulators of sonic hedgehog and control cell proliferation during mandibular arch morphogenesis

The aristaless-related homeobox genes Prx1 and Prx2 are required for correct skeletogenesis in many structures. Mice that lack both Prx1 and Prx2 functions display reduction or absence of skeletal elements in the skull, face, limbs and vertebral column. A striking phenotype is found in the lower jaw, which shows loss of midline structures, and the presence of a single, medially located incisor. We investigated development of the mandibular arch of Prx1(-/-)Prx2(-/-) mutants to obtain insight into the molecular basis of the lower jaw abnormalities. We observed in mutant embryos a local decrease in proliferation of mandibular arch mesenchyme in a medial area. Interestingly, in the oral epithelium adjacent to this mesenchyme, sonic hedgehog (Shh) expression was strongly reduced, indicative of a function for Prx genes in indirect regulation of SHH: Wild-type embryos that were exposed to the hedgehog-pathway inhibitor, jervine, partially phenocopied the lower jaw defects of Prx1(-/-)Prx2(-/-) mutants. In addition, this treatment led to loss of the mandibular incisors. We present a model that describes how loss of Shh expression in Prx1(-/-)Prx2(-/-) mutants leads to abnormal morphogenesis of the mandibular arch.     

The development of asymmetry: the sidedness of drug-induced limb abnormalities is reversed in situs inversus mice

We are studying the development of handedness, in particular the relationships between handed structures with bilateral symmetry, for example the limbs, and those with lateral asymmetry, such as the heart, lungs and gut. Asymmetric (unilateral) developmental limb abnormalities can be induced by chemical treatment of mouse embryos, either in utero by acetazolamide, or in culture by misonidazole. We have examined these effects in mice homozygous for the iv gene. The development of bilateral symmetry in iv/iv mice is normal, but the control of asymmetry appears to be random, that is 50% develop normally (situs solitus), 50% with laterally inverted viscera (situs inversus). We find that the handedness of induced asymmetric limb defects is highly correlated with embryonic visceral situs. Right limb defects are induced in situs solitus embryos, left-sided defects in situs inversus. This suggests that the mechanism of induction of asymmetric defects is not related to any intrinsic difference between the development of left and right limbs, but is connected to visceral asymmetry. In addition, the high correlation of limb defects with situs was observed in culture as well as in utero suggesting that the maternal environment plays no role in the development of asymmetry.     

Differential susceptibility of midbrain and spinal cord patterning to floor plate defects in the talpid2 mutant

The chick talpid2 mutant displays polydactylous digits attributed to defects of the Hedgehog (HH) signaling pathway. We examined the talpid2 neural tube and show that patterning defects in the spinal cord and the midbrain are distinct from each other and from the limb. Unlike the Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) source in the limb, the SHH-rich floor plate (FP) is reduced in the talpid2 midbrain. This is accompanied by a severe depletion of medial cell populations that encounter high concentrations of SHH, an expansion of lateral cell populations that experience low concentrations of SHH and a broad deregulation of HH's principal effectors (PTC1, GLI1, GLI2, GLI3). Together with the failure of SHH misexpression to rescue the talpid2 phenotype, these results suggest that talpid2 is likely to have a tissue-autonomous, bidirectional (positive and negative) role in HH signaling that cannot be attributed to the altered expression of several newly cloned HH pathway genes (SUFU, DZIP1, DISP1, BTRC). Strikingly, FP defects in the spinal cord are accompanied by relatively normal patterning in the talpid2 mutant. We propose that this differential FP dependence may be due to the prolonged apposition of the notochord to the spinal cord, but not the midbrain during development.     

Advances in the Molecular Genetics of Non-syndromic Syndactyly

Syndactyly, webbing of adjacent digits with or without bony fusion, is one of the most common hereditary limb malformations. It occurs either as an isolated abnormality or as a component of more than 300 syndromic anomalies. There are currently nine types of phenotypically diverse nonsyndromic syndactyly. Non-syndromic syndactyly is usually inherited as an autosomal dominant trait, although the more severe presenting types and subtypes may show autosomal recessive or X-linked pattern of inheritance. The phenotype appears to be not only caused by a main gene, but also dependant on genetic background and subsequent signaling pathways involved in limb formation. So far, the principal genes identified to be involved in congenital syndactyly are mainly involved in the zone of polarizing activity and sonic hedgehog pathway. This review summarizes the recent progress made in the molecular genetics, including known genes and loci responsible for non-syndromic syndactyly, and the signaling pathways those genetic factors involved in, as well as clinical features and animal models. We hope our review will contribute to the understanding of underlying pathogenesis of this complicated disorder and have implication on genetic counseling.     

Six1 and Six4 homeoproteins are required for Pax3 and Mrf expression during myogenesis in the mouse embryo

In mammals, Six5, Six4 and Six1 genes are co-expressed during mouse myogenesis. Six4 and Six5 single knockout (KO) mice have no developmental defects, while Six1 KO mice die at birth and show multiple organ developmental defects. We have generated Six1Six4 double KO mice and show an aggravation of the phenotype previously reported for the single Six1 KO. Six1Six4 double KO mice are characterized by severe craniofacial and rib defects, and general muscle hypoplasia. At the limb bud level, Six1 and Six4 homeogenes control early steps of myogenic cell delamination and migration from the somite through the control of Pax3 gene expression. Impaired in their migratory pathway, cells of the somitic ventrolateral dermomyotome are rerouted, lose their identity and die by apoptosis. At the interlimb level, epaxial Met expression is abolished, while it is preserved in Pax3-deficient embryos. Within the myotome, absence of Six1 and Six4 impairs the expression of the myogenic regulatory factors myogenin and Myod1, and Mrf4 expression becomes undetectable. Myf5 expression is correctly initiated but becomes restricted to the caudal region of each somite. Early syndetomal expression of scleraxis is reduced in the Six1Six4 embryo, while the myotomal expression of Fgfr4 and Fgf8 but not Fgf4 and Fgf6 is maintained. These results highlight the different roles played by Six proteins during skeletal myogenesis.     

Transgenic isolation of skeletal muscle and kidney defects in laminin beta2 mutant mice: implications for Pierson syndrome

Pierson syndrome is a recently defined disease usually lethal within the first postnatal months and caused by mutations in the gene encoding laminin beta2 (LAMB2). The hallmarks of Pierson syndrome are congenital nephrotic syndrome accompanied by ocular abnormalities, including microcoria (small pupils), with muscular and neurological developmental defects also present. Lamb2(-/-) mice are a model for Pierson syndrome; they exhibit defects in the kidney glomerular barrier, in the development and organization of the neuromuscular junction, and in the retina. Lamb2(-/-) mice fail to thrive and die very small at 3 weeks of age, but to what extent the kidney and neuromuscular defects each contribute to this severe phenotype has been obscure, though highly relevant to understanding Pierson syndrome. To investigate this, we generated transgenic mouse lines expressing rat laminin beta2 either in muscle or in glomerular epithelial cells (podocytes) and crossed them onto the Lamb2(-/-) background. Rat beta2 was confined in skeletal muscle to synapses and myotendinous junctions, and in kidney to the glomerular basement membrane. In transgenic Lamb2(-/-) mice, beta2 deposition in only glomeruli prevented proteinuria but did not ameliorate the severe phenotype. By contrast, beta2 expression in only muscle restored synaptic architecture and led to greatly improved health, but the mice died from kidney disease at 1 month. Rescue of both glomeruli and synapses was associated with normal weight gain, fertility and lifespan. We conclude that muscle defects in Lamb2(-/-) mice are responsible for the severe failure to thrive phenotype, and that renal replacement therapy alone will be an inadequate treatment for Pierson syndrome.     

The role of a single formin isoform in the limb and renal phenotypes of limb deformity.

BACKGROUND: Mutations of the murine limb deformity (ld) locus are responsible for a pleiotropic phenotype of completely penetrant limb malformations and incompletely penetrant renal agenesis and/or dysgenesis. The ld locus encodes a complex family of mRNA and protein isoforms. MATERIALS AND METHODS: To examine the role of one of the more prominent of these isoforms, isoform IV, we specifically eliminated it by gene targeting. RESULTS: Unlike other mutant ld mice, homozygous mice bearing this isoform IV disruption display incompletely penetrant renal agenesis, but have perfectly normal limbs. Whole mount in situ hybridization demonstrated that this targeted disruption was specific for isoform IV and did not interfere with the expression of other ld isoforms. The isoform IV-disrupted allele of ld does not complement the renal agenesis phenotype of other ld alleles, in a manner consistent with its penetrance, and like the isoform IV-deficient mice, these compound heterozygotes have normal limbs. Sequence analysis of formin isoform IV in other ld mutant alleles did not detect any amino acid changes relative to the strain of origin of the mutant allele. CONCLUSIONS: Thus, the disruption of isoform IV is sufficient for the renal agenesis phenotype, but not the limb phenotype of ld mutant mice. Structural mutations in this isoform are only one of several genetic mechanisms leading to the renal phenotype, since amino acid changes in this isoform were not detected. These results demonstrate that this gene is limb deformity, and that variable isoform expression may play a role in generating the pleiotropic ld phenotype.