Methylation of the mouse hprt gene differs on the active and inactive X chromosomes.

It has been proposed that DNA methylation is involved in the mechanism of X inactivation, the process by which equivalence of levels of X-linked gene products is achieved in female (XX) and male (XY) mammals. In this study, Southern blots of female and male DNA digested with methylation-sensitive restriction endonucleases and hybridized to various portions of the cloned mouse hprt gene were compared, and sites within the mouse hprt gene were identified that are differentially methylated in female and male cells. The extent to which these sites are methylated when carried on the active and inactive X chromosomes was directly determined in a similar analysis of DNA from clonal cell lines established from a female embryo derived from a mating of two species of mouse, Mus musculus and Mus caroli. The results revealed two regions of differential methylation in the mouse hprt gene. One region, in the first intron of the gene, includes four sites that are completely unmethylated when carried on the active X and extensively methylated when carried on the inactive X. These same sites are extensively demethylated in hprt genes reactivated either spontaneously or after 5-azacytidine treatment. The second region includes several sites in the 3' 20kilobases of the gene extending from exon 3 to exon 9 that show the converse pattern; i.e., they are completely methylated when carried on the active X and completely unmethylated when carried on the inactive X. At least one of these sites does not become methylated after reactivation of the gene. The results of this study, together with the results of previous studies by others of the human hprt gene, indicate that these regions of differential methylation on the active and inactive X are conserved between mammalian species. Furthermore, the data described here are consistent with the idea that at least the sites in the 5' region of the gene play a role in the X inactivation phenomenon and regulation of expression of the mouse hprt gene.     

Differential methylation of the ornithine carbamoyl transferase gene on active and inactive mouse X chromosomes.

Ornithine carbamoyl transferase (Oct) is an X-linked gene which exhibits tissue-specific expression. To determine whether methylation of specific CpG sequences plays a role in dosage compensation or tissue-specific expression of the gene, 13 potentially methylatable sites were identified over a 30-kilobase (kb) region spanning from approximately 15 kb upstream to beyond exon II. Fragments of the Mus hortulanus Oct gene were used as probes to establish the degree of methylation at each site. By considering the methylation status in liver (expressing tissue) versus kidney (nonexpressing tissue) from male and female mice, the active and inactive genes could be investigated on active and inactive X-chromosome backgrounds. One MspI site, 12 kb 5' of the Oct-coding region, was cleaved by HpaII in liver DNA from males but not in kidney DNA from males and thus exhibited complete correlation with tissue-specific expression of the gene. Six other sites showed partial methylation, reflecting incomplete correlation with tissue-specific expression.     

The hypervariable DXS255 locus contains a LINE-1 repetitive element with a CpG island that is extensively methylated only on the active X chromosome.

The DXS255 locus at Xp11.22 is highly polymorphic due to a 26-bp variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) motif. In previous studies, one of the MspI sites flanking the VNTR manifested a correlation between methylation and X chromosome inactivation. Here we show, by DNA sequence analysis, that this MspI site is located within the CpG island at the 5' end of a LINE-1 element, which is 2.5 kb from the VNTR. The methylation status of the CpG island was assessed in Southern blotting experiments using the methylation-sensitive enzymes HpaII, HhaI, and BssHII. All these sites were completely methylated on active X chromosomes, consistent with previously reported findings of full methylation of LINE-1 elements throughout the genome. However, on inactive X chromosomes these sites were predominantly unmethylated, although patterns were found to be heterogeneous. The results suggest that LINE-1 elements on the inactive X chromosome are not suppressed by full methylation of their CpG islands. The differential methylation of the DXS255 CpG island provides the basis for a highly informative X inactivation analysis system.     

Analysis of methylation and distribution of CpG sequences on human active and inactive X chromosomes by in situ nick translation

In situ nick translation of fixed mitotic chromosomes after HpaII or MspI digestion allows us to detect different DNA methylation levels along chromosomes. We used this technique to analyse the methylation levels of CCGG sites in the active and inactive X chromosomes of female human cells. In addition, we analysed the distribution of these sites with respect to the banding pattern. Our data show that the inactive X, as a whole, is more methylated than the active one and that CCGG sequences are preferentially located on R-positive bands.     

Comparison of factor IX methylation on human active and inactive X chromosomes: implications for X inactivation and transcription of tissue-specific genes.

Maintenance of dosage compensation for housekeeping genes on the human X chromosome is mediated through differential methylation of clustered CpG nucleotides associated with these genes. To determine if methylation has a role in maintaining inactivity of X-linked genes which show tissue-specific expression, we examined the locus for blood clotting Factor IX. The analysis encompassed 91% of the HpaII and HhaI sites in the 41-kb region that includes the presumed promoter region, 5 kb of 5'- and 4 kb of 3'-flanking sequences. Although there are sex differences in methylation of the locus in leukocytes, the methylation pattern in liver, where the gene is expressed, is essentially the same for loci on the active and inactive X chromosome. The lack of differences in methylation of active and inactive genes makes it unlikely that methylation within the locus has a role in expression of the Factor IX gene. These findings, along with the absence of clustered CpG dinucleotides within the Factor IX locus, suggest that functional differences in DNA methylation related to X chromosome dosage compensation may be limited to CpG clusters. In any event, dosage compensation seems to be maintained regionally, rather than locus by locus.     

N6-methyldeoxyadenosine residues at specific sites decrease the activity of the E1A promoter of adenovirus type 12 DNA

The activity of eukaryotic promoters is highly sensitive to site-specific modifications by DNA methylations. We have used the E1A promoter of adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) DNA to investigate the effects of methylations at different promoter sites on its activity. The chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene has served as an activity indicator. Activity of the E1A promoter is lost or markedly decreased by deoxycytidine methylation of two HpaII (5'-C-C-G-G-3') or seven HhaI (5'-G-C-G-C-3') sites upstream from the 3' located T-A-T-A signal. There are two T-A-T-A signals in the E1A promoter of adenovirus type 12 DNA, one T-A-T-T-A-T sequence starting at nucleotide 276 (5' located), a second T-A-T-T-T-A-A sequence starting at nucleotide 414 (3' located). Deoxycytidine methylations at two AluI (5'-A-G-C-T-3') sites downstream from the 5' located T-A-T-A signal have no effect on promoter activity. When one EcoRI (5'-G-A-A-T-T-C-3') or one TaqI (5'-T-C-G-A-3') sequence at 281 base-pairs upstream or 61 base-pairs downstream from the 5' located E1A T-A-T-A signal, respectively, is deoxyadenosine methylated, the promoter becomes inactive. Deoxyadenosine methylation at one MboI (5'-G-A-T-C-3') site, which is located 127 nucleotides downstream from the 5' located T-A-T-A signal, fails to decrease E1A promoter activity. There is no conspicuous anatomical relation of any of these sites to the two presumptive enhancer sequences in the E1A promoter. We conclude that 5-deoxymethylcytidine or N6-methyldeoxyadenosine residues have to be introduced at highly specific promoter sites to inactivate the promoter. These sites are probably different for different promoters.     

Methylation patterns at the hypervariable X-chromosome locus DXS255 (M27 beta): correlation with X-inactivation status.

Methylation patterns surrounding a hypervariable X-chromosome locus, DXS255, have been analyzed with the restriction enzyme MspI and its methylation-sensitive isoschizomer HpaII. HpaII sites flanking the hypervariable region were found to be methylated on 41 active X chromosomes and unmethylated on 11 inactive X chromosomes present in a range of male, female, and hybrid cells and tissues. This differential methylation pattern coupled with the previously described high level (greater than 90%) of heterozygosity at the DXS255 locus can therefore be applied to determine the inactivation status of X chromosomes in females heterozygous for X-linked disease and in tumor clonality studies.     

Methylation of HpaII and HhaI sites near the polymorphic CAG repeat in the human androgen-receptor gene correlates with X chromosome inactivation.

The human androgen-receptor gene (HUMARA; GenBank) contains a highly polymorphic trinucleotide repeat in the first exon. We have found that the methylation of HpaII and HhaI sites less than 100 bp away from this polymorphic short tandem repeat (STR) correlates with X inactivation. The close proximity of the restriction-enzyme sites to the STR allows the development of a PCR assay that distinguishes between the maternal and paternal alleles and identifies their methylation status. The accuracy of this assay was tested on (a) DNA from hamster/human hybrid cell lines containing either an active or inactive human X chromosome; (b) DNA from normal males and females; and (c) DNA from females showing nonrandom patterns of X inactivation. Data obtained using this assay correlated substantially with those obtained using the PGK, HPRT, and M27 beta probes, which detect X inactivation patterns by Southern blot analysis. In order to demonstrate one application of this assay, we examined X inactivation patterns in the B lymphocytes of potential and obligate carriers of X-linked agammaglobulinemia.     

Methylation of adenovirus genes in transformed cells and in vitro: influence on the regulation of gene expression?

An inverse correlation has been described between the levels of DNA methylation in specific segments of adenovirus DNA integrated into the genomes of transformed and tumor cells and the extent to which these segments are expressed as messenger RNA. In the adenovirus type 2 (Ad2)-transformed hamster cell lines HE2 and HE3, the virus-specific DNA binding protein (DBP) is not expressed, and the DNA in the DBP gene is completely methylated in all 5'-CCGG-3' sites. At least part of the late promoter/leader sequence of the DBP gene is present in cell lines HE2 and HE3. In line HE1, on the other hand, the DBP is expressed, and the DNA in the DBP gene is unmethylated at the 5'-CCGG-3' (HpaII) sites. The late promotor/leader sequence of the DBP gene is expressed in cytoplasmic RNA isolated from line HE1. The effect of DNA methylation has also been tested in vitro in a microinjection system using Xenopus laevis oocytes. Unmethylated DNA fragments of Ad2 (E2a region) have been found to serve as active templates. When the same fragments are methylated at the 5'-CCGG-3' sites by the HpaII DNA-methyltransferase, viral RNA synthesis is inhibited upon microinjection into oocyte nuclei. These results provide direct evidence for the notion that DNA methylated at highly specific sites is somehow involved in the regulation of gene expression.     

DNA methylation changes in human testicular cancer

We previously reported an X/Y imbalance with a relative excess of X- and a relative deficiency of Y-chromosomal DNA in three out of nine testicular tumors of germ cell origin. To study the implications of those changes the methylation status of DNA from seven of the tumors was explored by HpaII/MspI analysis. The 5' regions of the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) and the phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) gene loci exhibited main patterns suggestive of active X chromosomes in the tumors. However, a minority of the HPRT loci of one teratocarcinoma with an increased dosage of the X chromosome, as well as one additional teratocarcinoma, revealed patterns analogous to inactive X chromosomes in females. Using probes from several chromosomes it was subsequently found that the teratocarcinoma tumors (3/3) were characterized by generalized hypermethylation. On the contrary, the seminomas showed variable hypomethylation (4/5) or virtually complete demethylation (1/5). The seminoma with the most extensive hypomethylation was disseminated (stage III), whereas the other seminomas were local (stage I). These findings suggest that DNA methylation may play a role in the developmental pathways leading to different histologic types of testicular tumors of germ cell origin. The HPRT results imply that the consequences of extra X chromosomes--a frequent finding in testicular tumors--may be modulated by mechanisms, such as DNA methylation, that control gene activity.     

The distribution of genes on human chromosomes as studied by in situ nick translation.

We have studied the distribution of potentially active genes on human chromosomes, using two methods: DNAse I hypersensitivity and restriction enzyme--nick translation with enzymes sensitive to methylation of CpG doublets. DNAse hypersensitivity is known to be associated with potentially active genes, and, when the reaction is detected by "in situ" nick translation, produces an R-banding pattern. Digestion of chromosomes with HpaII or CfoI, both of which should preferentially cut unmethylated sequences in the CpG islands associated with the majority of genes, also produces R-banding patterns. Deviations are attributable to overdigestion of the chromosomes, leading to extraction of DNA and loss of the specific sites that were to be detected. Contrary to the results of a number of previous workers, we have failed to demonstrate any differences between the DNAse I hypersensitivity or the degree of methylation of the active and inactive X chromosomes in metaphases from females.     

Albumin and alpha-fetoprotein gene transcription in rat hepatoma cell lines is correlated with specific DNA hypomethylation and altered chromatin structure in the 5'' region.

We examined DNA methylation and DNase I hypersensitivity of the alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) and albumin gene region in hepatoma cell lines which showed drastic differences in the level of expression of these genes. We assayed for methylation of the CCGG sequences by using the restriction enzyme isoschizomers HpaII and MspI. We found two methylation sites located in the 5' region of the AFP gene and one in exon 1 of the albumin gene for which hypomethylation is correlated with gene expression. Another such site, located about 4,000 base pairs upstream from the AFP gene, seems to be correlated with the tissue specificity of the cells. DNase I-hypersensitive sites were mapped by using the indirect end-labeling technique with cloned genomic DNA probes. Three tissue-specific DNase I-hypersensitive sites were mapped in the 5' flanking region of the AFP gene when this gene was transcribed. Similarly, three tissue-specific DNase I-hypersensitive sites were detected upstream from the albumin gene in producing cell lines. In both cases, the most distal sites were maintained after cessation of gene activity and appear to be correlated with the potential expression of the gene. Interestingly, specific methylation sites are localized in the same DNA region as DNase I hypersensitive sites. This suggests that specific alterations of chromatin structure and changes in methylation pattern occur in specific critical regulatory regions upstream from the albumin and AFP genes in rat hepatoma cell lines.     

Methylation and expression of the human thyroglobulin gene

The DNA methylation pattern at the 5'end of the human thyroglobulin gene has been determined in different tissues. Out of the four HpaII/MspI sites (5'-CCGG-3') present in this region, three were found to be non-methylated in thyroid DNA, while full methylation was observed in liver, salivary gland and sperm DNA. This demethylation therefore correlates with expression of the thyroglobulin gene. However, all four sites were found to be non-methylated in placental DNA, regardless of the activity of the gene.     

Developmental regulation of cytosine methylation in the nuclear ribosomal RNA genes of Pisum sativum

Prominent features of the cytosine methylation pattern of the Pisum sativum nuclear ribosomal RNA genes have been defined. Cytosine methylation within the C-C-G-G sequence was studied using the restriction enzymes HpaII and MspI and gel blot hybridizations of the restriction digests. The extent to which particular features of the methylation pattern change during seedling development has also been determined. Total cellular DNA, purified from defined sections of pea seedlings grown under different lighting conditions, was analyzed with DNA hybridization probes derived from different portions of a cloned member of the nuclear rRNA gene family. By use of an indirect end-labeling technique, a map of 23 cleavable HpaII and/or MspI sites in genomic rDNA was constructed. The map covers about 90% of the rDNA repeat including the entire non-transcribed spacer region and most of the rRNA coding sequences. One notable feature of the map is that the most prominent HpaII site, located about 800 base-pairs upstream from the 5' end of the mature 18 S rRNA, is cleaved only in one of the two most abundant rDNA length variants (the short variant). With a gel blot assay specific for cleavage at this site, we estimated the HpaII sensitivity of DNA preparations from several stages of pea seedling development. We find that, while methylation is generally low in young seedlings, DNA obtained from the apical buds of pea seedlings is highly methylated. Further, the methylation level of rDNA within the pea bud decreases as the buds are allowed to develop under continuous white light. Our data, taken together with published studies on pea seedling development, indicate that cytosine methylation levels may be related to the regulated expression of the nuclear rRNA genes in pea.