Identification and characterization of sulfolobus solfataricus P2 proteome using multidimensional liquid phase protein separations

We have identified and characterized the proteome of Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 using multidimensional liquid phase protein separations. Multidimensional liquid phase chromatography was performed using ion exchange chromatography in the first dimension, followed by reverse-phase chromatography using 500 microm i.d. poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) monoliths in the second dimension to separate soluble protein lysates from S. solfataricus. The 2DLC protein separations from S. solfataricus protein lysates enabled the generation of a 2D liquid phase map analogous to the traditional 2DE map. Following separation of the proteins in the second dimension, fractions were collected, digested in solution using trypsin and analyzed using mass spectrometry. These approaches offer significant reductions in labor intensity and the overall time taken to analyze the proteome in comparison to 2DE, taking advantage of automation and fraction collection associated with this approach. Furthermore, following proteomic analysis using 2DLC, the data obtained was compared to previous 2DE and shotgun proteomic studies of a soluble protein lysate from S. solfataricus. In comparison to 2DE, the results show an overall increase in proteome coverage. Moreover, 2DLC showed increased coverage of a number of protein subsets including acidic, basic, low abundance and small molecular weight proteins in comparison to 2DE. In comparison to shotgun studies, an increase in proteome coverage was also observed. Furthermore, 187 unique proteins were identified using 2DLC, demonstrating this methodology as an alternative approach for proteomic studies or in combination with 2DE and shotgun workflows for global proteomics.     

Improvements in proteomic metrics of low abundance proteins through proteome equalization using ProteoMiner prior to MudPIT

Ideally, shotgun proteomics would facilitate the identification of an entire proteome with 100% protein sequence coverage. In reality, the large dynamic range and complexity of cellular proteomes results in oversampling of abundant proteins, while peptides from low abundance proteins are undersampled or remain undetected. We tested the proteome equalization technology, ProteoMiner, in conjunction with Multidimensional Protein Identification Technology (MudPIT) to determine how the equalization of protein dynamic range could improve shotgun proteomics methods for the analysis of cellular proteomes. Our results suggest low abundance protein identifications were improved by two mechanisms: (1) depletion of high abundance proteins freed ion trap sampling space usually occupied by high abundance peptides and (2) enrichment of low abundance proteins increased the probability of sampling their corresponding more abundant peptides. Both mechanisms also contributed to dramatic increases in the quantity of peptides identified and the quality of MS/MS spectra acquired due to increases in precursor intensity of peptides from low abundance proteins. From our large data set of identified proteins, we categorized the dominant physicochemical factors that facilitate proteome equalization with a hexapeptide library. These results illustrate that equalization of the dynamic range of the cellular proteome is a promising methodology to improve low abundance protein identification confidence, reproducibility, and sequence coverage in shotgun proteomics experiments, opening a new avenue of research for improving proteome coverage.     

Spectral index for assessment of differential protein expression in shotgun proteomics

Detecting differentially expressed proteins is a key goal of proteomics. We describe a label-free method, the spectral index, for analyzing relative protein abundance in large-scale data sets derived from biological samples by shotgun proteomics. The spectral index is comprised of two biochemically plausible features: relative protein abundance (assessed by spectral counts) and the number of samples within a group with detectable peptides. We combined the spectral index with permutation analysis to establish confidence intervals for assessing differential protein expression in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid from cystic fibrosis and control subjects. Significant differences in protein abundance determined by the spectral index agreed well with independent biochemical measurements. When used to analyze simulated data sets, the spectral index outperformed four other statistical tests (Student's t-test, G-test, Bayesian t-test, and Significance Analysis of Microarrays) by correctly identifying the largest number of differentially expressed proteins. Correspondence analysis and functional annotation analysis indicated that the spectral index improves the identification of enriched proteins corresponding to clinical phenotypes. The spectral index is easily implemented and statistically robust, and its results are readily interpreted graphically. Therefore, it should be useful for biomarker discovery and comparisons of protein expression between normal and disease states.     

Characterization of the rat liver membrane proteome using peptide immobilized pH gradient isoelectric focusing

Membrane proteins are of particular interest in proteomics because of their potential therapeutic utility. Past proteomic approaches used to investigate membrane proteins have only been partially successful at providing a comprehensive analysis due to the inherently hydrophobic nature and low abundance for some of these proteins. Recently, these difficulties have been improved by analyzing membrane protein enriched samples using shotgun proteomics. In addition, the recent application of methanol-assisted trypsin digestion of membrane proteins has been shown to be a method to improve membrane protein identifications. In this study, a comparison of different concentrations of methanol was assessed for assisting membrane protein digestion with trypsin prior to analysis using a gel-based shotgun proteomics approach called peptide immobilized pH gradient isoelectric focusing (IPG-IEF). We demonstrate the use of peptide IEF on pH 3-10 IPG strips as the first dimension of two-dimensional shotgun proteomics for protein identifications from the membrane fraction of rat liver. Tryptic digestion of proteins was carried out in varying concentrations of methanol in 10 mM ammonium bicarbonate: 0% (v/v), 40% (v/v), and 60% (v/v). A total of 800 proteins were identified from 60% (v/v) methanol, which increased the protein identifications by 17% and 14% compared to 0% (v/v) methanol and 40% (v/v) methanol assisted digestion, respectively. In total, 1549 nonredundant proteins were identified from all three concentrations of methanol including 690 (42%) integral membrane proteins of which 626 of these proteins contained at least one transmembrane domain. Peptide IPG-IEF separation of peptides was successful as the peptides were separated into discrete pI regions with high resolution. The results from this study prove utility of 60% (v/v) methanol assisted digestion in conjunction with peptide IPG-IEF as an optimal shotgun proteomics technique for the separation and identification of previously unreported membrane proteins.     

A combination of immobilised pH gradients improves membrane proteomics

Membrane protein analyses have been notoriously difficult due to hydrophobicity and the general low abundance of these proteins compared to their soluble cytosolic counterparts. Shotgun proteomics has become the preferred method for analyses of membrane proteins, in particular the recent development of peptide immobilized pH gradient isoelectric focusing (IPG-IEF) as the first dimension of two-dimensional shotgun proteomics. Recently, peptide IPG-IEF has been shown to be a valuable shotgun proteomics technique through the use of acidic narrow range IPG strips, which demonstrated that small acidic p I increments are rich in peptides. In this study, we assess the utility of both broad range (BR) (p I 3-10) and narrow range (NR) (p I 3.4-4.9) IPG strips for rat liver membrane protein analyses. Furthermore, the use of these IPG strips was evaluated using label-free quantitation to demonstrate that the identification of a subset of proteins can be improved using NR IPG strips. NR IPG strips provided 2603 protein assignments on average (with 826 integral membrane proteins (IMPs)) compared to BR IPG strips, which provided 2021 protein assignments on average (with 712 IMPs). Nonredundant protein analysis demonstrated that in total from all experiments, 4195 proteins (with 1301 IMPs) could be identified with 1428 of these proteins unique to NR IPG strips with only 636 from BR IPG strips. With the use of label-free quantitation methods, 1659 proteins were used for quantitative comparison of which 319 demonstrated statistically significant increases in normalized spectral abundance factors (NSAF) in NR IPG strips compared to 364 in BR IPG strips. In particular, a selection of six highly hydrophobic transmembrane proteins was observed to increase in NSAF using NR IPG strips. These results provide evidence for the use of alternative pH gradients in combination to improve the shotgun proteomic analysis of the membrane proteome.     

Selection of thiol- and disulfide-containing proteins of Escherichia coli on activated thiol-Sepharose

Activated thiol-Sepharose (ATS) facilitates selection of thiol-containing proteins. In control- and menadione-treated Escherichia coli, batch selection performed under denaturing conditions revealed distinct two-dimensional electrophoresis (2DE) patterns. Using shotgun proteomics, 183 thiol-containing proteins were identified in control ATS-selected extracts and 126 were identified in menadione-treated E. coli, with 85 proteins being common to both. More than 90% of identified proteins contained one or more cysteines. Blocking with N-ethyl maleimide followed by reduction facilitated ATS-based selection of disulfide-containing proteins. In total, 62 proteins were unique to control cells and 164 were identified in menadione-treated E. coli cells, with 29 proteins being common to both. Proteins from menadione-treated cells were excised from 2DE gels, digested with trypsin, and identified by peptide mass fingerprinting. This revealed 19 unique proteins, 14 of which were identified by shotgun proteomics. Outer membrane proteins A, C, W, and X and 30S ribosomal protein S1 were found in 2DE but not by shotgun proteomics. Foldases, ribosomal proteins, aminoacyl transfer RNA (tRNA) synthetases, and metabolic and antioxidant enzymes were prominent among identified proteins, and many had previously been found to respond to, and be targets for, oxidative stress in E. coli. ATS provides a convenient and rapid way to select thiol-containing proteins.     

Advances in shotgun proteomics and the analysis of membrane proteomes

The emergence of shotgun proteomics has facilitated the numerous biological discoveries made by proteomic studies. However, comprehensive proteomic analysis remains challenging and shotgun proteomics is a continually changing field. This review details the recent developments in shotgun proteomics and describes emerging technologies that will influence shotgun proteomics going forward. In addition, proteomic studies of integral membrane proteins remain challenging due to the hydrophobic nature in integral membrane proteins and their general low abundance levels. However, there have been many strategies developed for enriching, isolating and separating membrane proteins for proteomic analysis that have moved this field forward. In summary, while shotgun proteomics is a widely used and mature technology, the continued pace of improvements in mass spectrometry and proteomic technology and methods indicate that future studies will have an even greater impact on biological discovery.     

Liquid chromatography MALDI MS/MS for membrane proteome analysis

Membrane proteins play critical roles in many biological functions and are often the molecular targets for drug discovery. However, their analysis presents a special challenge largely due to their highly hydrophobic nature. We present a surfactant-aided shotgun proteomics approach for membrane proteome analysis. In this approach, membrane proteins were solubilized and digested in the presence of SDS followed by newly developed auto-offline liquid chromatography/matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (LC/MALDI) tandem MS analysis. Because of high tolerance of MALDI to SDS, one-dimensional (1D) LC separation can be combined with MALDI for direct analysis of protein digests containing SDS, without the need for extensive sample cleanup. In addition, the heated droplet interface used in LC/MALDI can work with high flow LC separations, allowing a relatively large amount of protein digest to be used for 1D LC/MALDI which facilitates the detection of low abundance proteins. The proteome identification results obtained by LC/MALDI are compared to the gel electrophoresis/MS method as well as the shotgun proteomics method using 2D LC/electrospray ionization MS. It is demonstrated that, while LC/MALDI provides more extensive proteome coverage compared to the other two methods, these three methods are complementary to each other and a combination of these methods should provide a more comprehensive membrane proteome analysis.     

Significance analysis of spectral count data in label-free shotgun proteomics

Spectral counting has become a commonly used approach for measuring protein abundance in label-free shotgun proteomics. At the same time, the development of data analysis methods has lagged behind. Currently most studies utilizing spectral counts rely on simple data transforms and posthoc corrections of conventional signal-to-noise ratio statistics. However, these adjustments can neither handle the bias toward high abundance proteins nor deal with the drawbacks due to the limited number of replicates. We present a novel statistical framework (QSpec) for the significance analysis of differential expression with extensions to a variety of experimental design factors and adjustments for protein properties. Using synthetic and real experimental data sets, we show that the proposed method outperforms conventional statistical methods that search for differential expression for individual proteins. We illustrate the flexibility of the model by analyzing a data set with a complicated experimental design involving cellular localization and time course.     

Mass spectrometry-based targeted quantitative proteomics: achieving sensitive and reproducible detection of proteins

Traditional shotgun proteomics used to detect a mixture of hundreds to thousands of proteins through mass spectrometric analysis, has been the standard approach in research to profile protein content in a biological sample which could lead to the discovery of new (and all) protein candidates with diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic values. In practice, this approach requires significant resources and time, and does not necessarily represent the goal of the researcher who would rather study a subset of such discovered proteins (including their variations or posttranslational modifications) under different biological conditions. In this context, targeted proteomics is playing an increasingly important role in the accurate measurement of protein targets in biological samples in the hope of elucidating the molecular mechanism of cellular function via the understanding of intricate protein networks and pathways. One such (targeted) approach, selected reaction monitoring (or multiple reaction monitoring) mass spectrometry (MRM-MS), offers the capability of measuring multiple proteins with higher sensitivity and throughput than shotgun proteomics. Developing and validating MRM-MS-based assays, however, is an extensive and iterative process, requiring a coordinated and collaborative effort by the scientific community through the sharing of publicly accessible data and datasets, bioinformatic tools, standard operating procedures, and well characterized reagents.     

The effects of shared peptides on protein quantitation in label-free proteomics by LC/MS/MS

Assessment of differential protein abundance from the observed properties of detected peptides is an essential part of protein profiling based on shotgun proteomics. However, the abundance observed for shared peptides may be due to contributions from multiple proteins that are affected differently by a given treatment. Excluding shared peptides eliminates this ambiguity but may significantly decrease the number of proteins for which abundance estimates can be obtained. Peptide sharing within a family of biologically related proteins does not cause ambiguity if family members have a common response to treatment. On the basis of this concept, we have developed an approach for including shared peptides in the analysis of differential protein abundance in protein profiling. Data from a recent proteomics study of lung tissue from mice exposed to lipopolysaccharide, cigarette smoke, and a combination of these agents are used to illustrate our method. Starting from data where about half of the implicated database protein involved shared peptides, 82% of the affected proteins were grouped into families, based on FASTA annotation, with closure on peptide sharing. In many cases, a common abundance relative to control was sufficient to explain ion-current peak areas for peptides, both unique and shared, that identified biologically related proteins in a peptide-sharing closure group. On the basis of these results, we propose that peptide-sharing closure groups provide a way to include abundance data for shared peptides in quantitative protein profiling by high-throughput mass spectrometry.     

Statistical analysis of membrane proteome expression changes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We have devised an approach for analyzing shotgun proteomics datasets based on the normalized spectral abundance factor that can be used for quantitative proteomics analysis. Three biological replicates of samples enriched for plasma membranes were isolated from S. cerevisiae grown in 14N-rich media and 15N-minimal media and analyzed via quantitative multidimensional protein identification technology. The natural log transformation of NSAF values from S. cerevisiae cells grown in 14N YPD media and 15N-minimal media had a normal distribution. The t-test analysis demonstrated 221 of 1316 proteins were significantly overexpressed in one or the other growth conditions with a p value <0.05. Notably, amino acid transporters were among the 14 membrane proteins that were significantly upregulated in cells grown in minimal media, and we functionally validated these increases in protein expression with radioisotope uptake assays for selected proteins.     

EBprot: Statistical analysis of labeling‐based quantitative proteomics data

Labeling‐based proteomics is a powerful method for detection of differentially expressed proteins (DEPs). The current data analysis platform typically relies on protein‐level ratios, which is obtained by summarizing peptide‐level ratios for each protein. In shotgun proteomics, however, some proteins are quantified with more peptides than others, and this reproducibility information is not incorporated into the differential expression (DE) analysis. Here, we propose a novel probabilistic framework EBprot that directly models the peptide‐protein hierarchy and rewards the proteins with reproducible evidence of DE over multiple peptides. To evaluate its performance with known DE states, we conducted a simulation study to show that the peptide‐level analysis of EBprot provides better receiver‐operating characteristic and more accurate estimation of the false discovery rates than the methods based on protein‐level ratios. We also demonstrate superior classification performance of peptide‐level EBprot analysis in a spike‐in dataset. To illustrate the wide applicability of EBprot in different experimental designs, we applied EBprot to a dataset for lung cancer subtype analysis with biological replicates and another dataset for time course phosphoproteome analysis of EGF‐stimulated HeLa cells with multiplexed labeling. Through these examples, we show that the peptide‐level analysis of EBprot is a robust alternative to the existing statistical methods for the DE analysis of labeling‐based quantitative datasets. The software suite is freely available on the Sourceforge website http://ebprot.sourceforge.net/ . All MS data have been deposited in the ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD001426 ( http://proteomecentral.proteomexchange.org/dataset/PXD001426/ ).     

Sequential protein extraction as an efficient method for improved proteome coverage in larvae of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)

Understanding diet‐ and environmentally induced physiological changes in fish larvae is a major goal for the aquaculture industry. Proteomic analysis of whole fish larvae comprising multiple tissues offers considerable potential but is challenging due to the very large dynamic range of protein abundance. To extend the coverage of the larval phase of the Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) proteome, we applied a two‐step sequential extraction (SE) method, based on differential protein solubility, using a nondenaturing buffer containing 150 mM NaCl followed by a denaturing buffer containing 7 M urea and 2 M thiourea. Extracts prepared using SE and one‐step direct extraction were characterized via label‐free shotgun proteomics using nanoLC‐MS/MS (LTQ‐Orbitrap). SE partitioned the proteins into two fractions of approximately equal amounts, but with very distinct protein composition, leading to identification of ～40% more proteins than direct extraction. This fractionation strategy enabled the most detailed characterization of the salmon larval proteome to date and provides a platform for greater understanding of physiological changes in whole fish larvae. The MS data are available via the ProteomeXchange Consortium PRIDE partner repository, dataset PXD003366.     

Large scale protein profiling by combination of protein fractionation and multidimensional protein identification technology (MudPIT)

In the past decade, shotgun proteomic analysis has been utilized extensively to answer complex biological questions. New challenges arise in large scale proteomic profiling when dealing with complex biological mixtures such as the mammalian cell lysate. In this study, we explored the approach of protein separation prior to the shotgun multidimensional protein identification technology (MudPIT) analysis. We fractionated the mammalian cancer cell lysate using the PF 2D ProteomeLab system and analyzed the distribution of molecular weight, isoelectric point, and cellular localization of the eluted proteins. As a result, we were able to reduce sample complexity by protein fractionation and increase the possibility of detecting proteins with lower abundance in the complex protein mixture.     

Strategic shotgun proteomics approach for efficient construction of an expression map of targeted protein families in hepatoma cell lines

An expression map of the most abundant proteins in human hepatoma HepG2 cells was established by a combination of complementary shotgun proteomics approaches. Two-dimensional liquid chromatography (LC)-nano electrospray ionization (ESI) tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) as well as one-dimensional LC-matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization MS/MS were evaluated and shown that additional separation introduced at the peptide level was not as efficient as simple prefractionation of protein extracts in extending the range and total number of proteins identified. Direct LC-nanoESI MS/MS analyses of peptides from total solubilized fraction and the excised gel bands from one-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis fractionated insolubilized fraction afforded the best combination in efficient construction of a nonredundant cell map. Compiling data from multiple variations of rapid shotgun proteomics analyses is nonetheless useful to increase sequence coverage and confidence of hits especially for those proteins identified primarily by a single or two peptide matches. While the returned hit score in general reflects the abundance of the respective proteins, it is not a reliable index for differential expression. Using another closely related hepatoma Hep3B as a comparative basis, 16 proteins with more than two-fold difference in expression level as defined by spot intensity in two-dimensional gel electrophoresis analysis were identified which notably include members of the heat shock protein (Hsp) and heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein (hnRPN) families. The observed higher expression level of hnRNP A2/B1 and Hsp90 in Hep3B led to a search for reported functional roles mediated in concert by both these multifunctional cellular chaperones. In agreement with the proposed model for telomerase and telomere bound proteins in promoting their interactions, data was obtained which demonstrated that the expression proteomics data could be correlated with longer telomeric length in tumorigenic Hep3B. This biological significance constitutes the basis for further delineation of the dynamic interactions and modifications of the two protein families and demonstrated how proteomic and biological investigation could be mutually substantiated in a productive cycle of hypothesis and pattern driven research.     

Comparison of alternative analytical techniques for the characterisation of the human serum proteome in HUPO Plasma Proteome Project

Based on the same HUPO reference specimen (C1-serum) with the six proteins of highest abundance depleted by immunoaffinity chromatography, we have compared five proteomics approaches, which were (1) intact protein fractionation by anion-exchange chromatography followed by 2-DE-MALDI-TOF-MS/MS for protein identification (2-DE strategy); (2) intact protein fractionation by 2-D HPLC followed by tryptic digestion of each fraction and microcapillary RP-HPLC/microESI-MS/MS identification (protein 2-D HPLC fractionation strategy); (3) protein digestion followed by automated online microcapillary 2-D HPLC (strong cation-exchange chromatography (SCX)-RPC) with IT microESI-MS/MS; (online shotgun strategy); (4) same as (3) with the SCX step performed offline (offline shotgun strategy) and (5) same as (4) with the SCX fractions reanalysed by optimised nanoRP-HPLC-nanoESI-MS/MS (offline shotgun-nanospray strategy). All five approaches yielded complementary sets of protein identifications. The total number of unique proteins identified by each of these five approaches was (1) 78, (2) 179, (3) 131, (4) 224 and (5) 330 respectively. In all, 560 unique proteins were identified. One hundred and sixty-five proteins were identified through two or more peptides, which could be considered a high-confidence identification. Only 37 proteins were identified by all five approaches. The 2-DE approach yielded more information on the pI-altered isoforms of some serum proteins and the relative abundance of identified proteins. The protein prefractionation strategy slightly improved the capacity to detect proteins of lower abundance. Optimising the separation at the peptide level and improving the detection sensitivity of ESI-MS/MS were more effective than fractionation of intact proteins in increasing the total number of proteins identified. Overall, electrophoresis and chromatography, coupled respectively with MALDI-TOF/TOF-MS and ESI-MS/MS, identified complementary sets of serum proteins.