Chromatin compaction at the mononucleosome level

Using a previously described FRET technique, we measured the distance between the ends of DNA fragments on which nucleosomes were reconstituted from recombinant and native histones. This distance was analyzed in its dependence on the DNA fragment length, concentration of mono- and divalent counterions, presence of linker histone H1, and histone modifications. We found that the linker DNA arms do not cross under all conditions studied but diverge slightly as they leave the histone core surface. Histone H1 leads to a global approach of the linker DNA arms, confirming the notion of a "stem structure". Increasing salt concentration also leads to an approach of the linker DNAs. To study the effect of acetylation, we compared chemically acetylated recombinant histones with histones prepared from HeLa cells, characterizing the sites of acetylation by mass spectroscopy. Nucleosomes from chemically acetylated histones have few modifications in the core domain and form nucleosomes normally. Acetylating all histones or selectively only H3 causes an opening of the nucleosome structure, indicated by the larger distances between the linker DNA ends. Selective acetylation of H4 distances the linker ends for short fragments but causes them to approach each other for fragments longer than 180 bp.     

Apoptotic DNA fragmentation is not related to the phosphorylation state of histone H1

Changes in chromatin structure, histone phosphorylation and cleavage of DNA into nucleosome-size fragments are characteristic features of apoptosis. Since H1 histones bind to the site of DNA cleavage between nucleosomal cores, the question arises as to whether the state of H1 phosphorylation influences the rate of internucleosomal cleavage. Here, we tested the relation between DNA fragmentation and H1 phosphorylation both in cultured cells and in vitro. In Jurkat cells, hyperosmotic mannitol concentration resulted in apoptosis, including nucleosomal fragmentation, whereas apoptosis induction by increased NaCl concentration was not accompanied by DNA fragmentation. However, both treatments induced dephosphorylation of H1 histones. In contrast, treatment of Raji cells with alkylphosphocholine led to induction of apoptosis with internucleosomal fragmentation, albeit without notable histone H1 dephosphorylation. These results demonstrate that dephosphorylation of H1 histones is neither a prerequisite for nor a consequence of internucleosomal cleavage. Moreover, we observed with an in vitro assay that the known enhancing effect of H1 histones on the activity of the apoptosis-induced endonuclease DFF40 is independent of the subtype or the phosphorylation state of the linker histone.     

Trajectory of nucleosomal linker DNA studied by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

While the structure of the nucleosome core is known in atomic detail, the precise geometry of the DNA beyond the core particle is still unknown. We have used fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) for determining the end-to-end distance of DNA fragments assembled with histones into nucleosomes. The DNA of a length of 150-220 bp was labeled with rhodamine-X on one end and fluorescein or Alexa 488 on the other. Assembling nucleosomes on these DNA fragments leads to a measurable energy transfer. The end-to-end distance computed from the FRET increases from 60 +/- 5 A at 150 bp to 75 +/- 5 A at 170 bp without measurable change above it. These distances are compatible with different geometries of the linker DNA, all having in common that no crossing can be observed up to 220 bp. Addition of H1 histone leads to an increase in energy transfer, indicating a compaction of the linker DNA toward the nucleosome.     

Histone H3 Tail Modifications Alter Structure and Dynamics of the H1 C-Terminal Domain Within Nucleosomes

The highly positively charged and intrinsically disordered H1 C-terminal domain (CTD) undergoes extensive condensation upon binding to nucleosomes, and stabilizes nucleosomes and higher-order chromatin structures but its interactions in chromatin are not well defined. Using single-molecule FRET we found that about half of the H1 CTDs in H1-nucleosome complexes exhibit well-defined FRET values indicative of distinct, static conformations, while the remainder of the population exhibits exchange between multiple defined FRET structures. Moreover, crosslinking studies indicate that the first 30 residues of the H1 CTD participate in relatively localized contacts with the first ∼25 bp of linker DNA, and that two separate regions in the CTD contribute to H1-dependent organization of linker DNA. Finally, we show that acetylation mimetics within the histone H3 tail markedly reduce the overall extent of H1 CTD condensation and significantly increase the fraction of H1 CTDs undergoing dynamic exchange between FRET states. Our results indicate the nucleosome-bound H1 CTD adopts loosely defined structures that exhibit significantly enhanced dynamics and decondensation upon epigenetic acetylation within the H3 tail.     

DNA and nucleosomes direct distinct folding of a linker histone H1 C-terminal domain

We previously documented condensation of the H1 CTD consistent with adoption of a defined structure upon nucleosome binding using a bulk FRET assay, supporting proposals that the CTD behaves as an intrinsically disordered domain. In the present study, by determining the distances between two different pairs of sites in the C-terminal domain of full length H1 by FRET, we confirm that nucleosome binding directs folding of the disordered H1 C-terminal domain and provide additional distance constraints for the condensed state. In contrast to nucleosomes, FRET observed upon H1 binding to naked DNA fragments includes both intra- and inter-molecular resonance energy transfer. By eliminating inter-molecular transfer, we find that CTD condensation induced upon H1-binding naked DNA is distinct from that induced by nucleosomes. Moreover, analysis of fluorescence quenching indicates that H1 residues at either end of the CTD experience distinct environments when bound to nucleosomes, and suggest that the penultimate residue in the CTD (K195) is juxtaposed between the two linker DNA helices, proposed to form a stem structure in the H1-bound nucleosome.     

Solution Scattering and FRET Studies on Nucleosomes Reveal DNA Unwrapping Effects of H3 and H4 Tail Removal

Using a combination of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements we have determined the role of the H3 and H4 histone tails, independently, in stabilizing the nucleosome DNA terminal ends from unwrapping from the nucleosome core. We have performed solution scattering experiments on recombinant wild-type, H3 and H4 tail-removed mutants and fit all scattering data with predictions from PDB models and compared these experiments to complementary DNA-end FRET experiments. Based on these combined SAXS and FRET studies, we find that while all nucleosomes exhibited DNA unwrapping, the extent of this unwrapping is increased for nucleosomes with the H3 tails removed but, surprisingly, decreased in nucleosomes with the H4 tails removed. Studies of salt concentration effects show a minimum amount of DNA unwrapping for all complexes around 50-100mM of monovalent ions. These data exhibit opposite roles for the positively-charged nucleosome tails, with the ability to decrease access (in the case of the H3 histone) or increase access (in the case of the H4 histone) to the DNA surrounding the nucleosome. In the range of salt concentrations studied (0-200mM KCl), the data point to the H4 tail-removed mutant at physiological (50-100mM) monovalent salt concentration as the mononucleosome with the least amount of DNA unwrapping.     

Opposing roles of H3- and H4-acetylation in the regulation of nucleosome structure—a FRET study

Using FRET in bulk and on single molecules, we assessed the structural role of histone acetylation in nucleosomes reconstituted on the 170 bp long Widom 601 sequence. We followed salt-induced nucleosome disassembly, using donor–acceptor pairs on the ends or in the internal part of the nucleosomal DNA, and on H2B histone for measuring H2A/H2B dimer exchange. This allowed us to distinguish the influence of acetylation on salt-induced DNA unwrapping at the entry–exit site from its effect on nucleosome core dissociation. The effect of lysine acetylation is not simply cumulative, but showed distinct histone-specificity. Both H3- and H4-acetylation enhance DNA unwrapping above physiological ionic strength; however, while H3-acetylation renders the nucleosome core more sensitive to salt-induced dissociation and to dimer exchange, H4-acetylation counteracts these effects. Thus, our data suggest, that H3- and H4-acetylation have partially opposing roles in regulating nucleosome architecture and that distinct aspects of nucleosome dynamics might be independently controlled by individual histones.     

Nucleosomal histone protein protects DNA from iron-mediated damage.

Iron promotes DNA damage by catalyzing hydroxyl radical formation. We examined the effect of chromatin structure on DNA susceptibility to oxidant damage. Oxygen radicals generated by H2O2, ascorbate and iron-ADP (1:2 ratio of Fe2+:ADP) extensively and randomly fragmented protein-free DNA, with double-strand breaks demonstrable even at 1 microM iron. In contrast, polynucleosomes from chicken erythrocytes were converted to nucleosome-sized fragments by iron-ADP even up to 250 microM iron. Cleavage occurred only in bare areas where DNA is unassociated with histone. In confirmation, reassembly of nucleosomes from calf thymus DNA and chicken erythrocyte histone also yielded nucleosomes resistant to fragmentation. Protection of DNA by histone was dependent on nucleosome assembly and did not simply reflect presence of scavenging protein. In contrast to this specific cleavage of internucleosomal linker DNA by iron-ADP, iron-EDTA cleaved polynucleosomes indiscriminately at all sites. The hydroxyl radical scavenger thiourea completely inhibited the random cleavage of polynucleosomes by iron-EDTA but inhibited the nonrandom cleavage of polynucleosomes by iron-ADP less completely, suggesting the possibility that the lower affinity iron-ADP chelate may allow association of free iron with DNA. Thus, oxygen radicals generated by iron-ADP indiscriminately cleaved naked DNA but cleaved chromatin preferentially at internucleosomal bare linker sites, perhaps because of nonrandom iron binding by DNA. These findings suggest that the DNA-damaging effects of iron may be nonrandom, site-directed and modified by histone protein.     

Effect of in vivo histone hyperacetylation on the state of chromatin fibers.

We evaluated the contribution of in vivo histone acetylation to the folding of chromatin into its higher-order structures. We have compared high-order folding patterns of hyperacetylated vs. unmodified chromatin in living green monkey kidney cells (CV1 line) using intercalator chloroquine diphospate to induce alterations in the twist of internucleosomal linker DNA. We have shown that histone hyperacetylation induced by antibiotic Trichostatin A significantly alters intercalator-mediated chromatin folding pattern.     

Characterization of the interaction between HMGB1 and H3—a possible means of positioning HMGB1 in chromatin

High mobility group protein B1 (HMGB1) binds to the internucleosomal linker DNA in chromatin and abuts the nucleosome. Bending and untwisting of the linker DNA results in transmission of strain to the nucleosome core, disrupting histone/DNA contacts. An interaction between H3 and HMGB1 has been reported. Here we confirm and characterize the interaction of HMGB1 with H3, which lies close to the DNA entry/exit points around the nucleosome dyad, and may be responsible for positioning of HMGB1 on the linker DNA. We show that the interaction is between the N-terminal unstructured tail of H3 and the C-terminal unstructured acidic tail of HMGB1, which are presumably displaced from DNA and the HMG boxes, respectively, in the HMGB1-nucleosome complex. We have characterized the interaction by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and show that it is extensive for both peptides, and appears not to result in the acquisition of significant secondary structure by either partner.     

Salt-dependent compaction of di- and trinucleosomes studied by small-angle neutron scattering

Using small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), we have measured the salt-dependent static structure factor of di- and trinucleosomes from chicken erythrocytes and from COS-7 cells. We also determined the sedimentation coefficients of these dinucleosomes and dinucleosomes reconstituted on a 416-bp DNA containing two nucleosome positioning sequences of the 5S rDNA of Lytechinus variegatus at low and high salt concentrations. The internucleosomal distance d was calculated by simulation as well as Fourier back-transformation of the SANS curves and by hydrodynamic simulation of sedimentation coefficients. Nucleosome dimers from chicken erythrocyte chromatin show a decrease in d from approximately 220 A at 5 mM NaCl to 150 A at 100 mM NaCl. For dinucleosomes from COS-7 chromatin, d decreases from 180 A at 5 mM to 140 A at 100 mM NaCl concentration. Our measurements on trinucleosomes are compatible with a compaction through two different mechanisms, depending on the salt concentration. Between 0 and 20 mM NaCl, the internucleosomal distance between adjacent nucleosomes remains constant, whereas the angle of the DNA strands entering and leaving the central nucleosome decreases. Above 20 mM NaCl, the adjacent nucleosomes approach each other, similar to the compaction of dinucleosomes. The internucleosomal distance of 140-150 A at 100 mM NaCl is in agreement with distances measured by scanning force microscopy and electron microscopy on long chromatin filaments.     

The histone H1 C-terminal domain binds to the apoptotic nuclease, DNA fragmentation factor (DFF40/CAD) and stimulates DNA cleavage

The apoptotic nuclease, DNA fragmentation factor (DFF40/CAD), is primarily responsible for internucleosomal DNA cleavage during the terminal stages of programmed cell death. Previously, we demonstrated that histone H1 greatly stimulates naked DNA cleavage by this nuclease. Here, we investigate the mechanism of this stimulation with native and recombinant mouse and human histone H1 species. Using a series of truncation mutants of recombinant histone H1-0, we demonstrate that the H1 C-terminal domain (CTD) is responsible for activation of DFF40/CAD. We show further that the intact histone H1-0 CTD and certain synthetic CTD fragments bind to DFF40/CAD and confer upon it an increased ability to bind to DNA. Interestingly, we find that each of the six somatic cell histone H1 isoforms, whose CTDs differ significantly in primary sequence but not amino acid composition, equally activate DFF40/CAD. We conclude that the interactions identified here between the histone H1 CTD and DFF40/CAD target and activate linker DNA cleavage during the terminal stages of apoptosis.     

Effect of in vivo Histone Hyperacetylation on the State of Chromatin Fibers

Abstract

We evaluated the contribution of in vivo histone acetylation to the folding of chromatin into its higher-order structures. We have compared high-order folding patterns of hyperacetylat- ed vs. unmodified chromatin in living green monkey kidney cells (CV1 line) using intercalator chloroquine diphospate to induce alterations in the twist of internucleosomal linker DNA. We have shown that histone hyperacetylation induced by antibiotic Trichostatin A significantly alters intercalator-mediated chromatin folding pattern.     

Hyperacetylation of core histones does not cause unfolding of nucleosomes. Neutron scatter data accords with disc shape of the nucleosome

Recent studies report that the frictional resistance of partially acetylated core particles increases when the number of acetyl groups/particle exceeds 10 (Bode, J., Gomez-Lira, M. M. & Schr?ter, H. (1983) Eur. J. Biochem. 130, 437-445). This was attributed to an opening of the core particle though other explanations, e.g. unwinding of the DNA ends were also suggested. Another possible explanation is that release of the core histone N-terminal domains by acetylation increased the frictional resistance of the particle. Neutron scatter studies have been performed on core particles acetylated to different levels up to 2.4 acetates/H4 molecule. Up to this level of acetylation the neutron scatter data show no evidence for unfolding of the core particle. The fundamental scatter functions for the envelope shape and internal structure are identical to those obtained previously for bulk core particles. The structure that gave the best fit to these fundamental scatter functions was a flat disc of diameter 11-11.5 nm and of thickness 5.5-6 nm with 1.7 +/- 0.2 turns of DNA coiled with a pitch of 3.0 nm around a core of the histone octamer. The data analysis emphasizes the changes in pair distance distribution functions at relatively low contrasts, particularly when the protein is contrast matched and DNA dominates the scatter. Under these conditions there is no evidence for the unwinding of long DNA ends in the hyperacetylated core particles. The distance distribution functions go to zero between 11.5 and 12 nm which gives the maximum chord length in a particle of dimension, 11 nm X 5.5 nm. The distance distribution function for the histone octamer contains 85% of the vectors within the 7.0-nm diameter of the histone core. 15% of the histone vectors lie between 7.0 and 12.0 nm, and these are attributed to the N-terminal domains of the core histones which extend out from the central histone core. Histone vectors extending beyond 7.0 nm are necessary to account for the measured radius of gyration of the histone core of 3.3 nm. A similar value of 3.2 nm is calculated for the recent ellipsoidal shape of 11.0 X 6.5 X 6.5 nm from the crystal structure of the octamer. However, the nucleosome model based on this structure is globular, roughly 11 nm in diameter, which does not accord with the flat disc shape core particle obtained from detailed neutron scatter data nor with the cross-section radii of gyration of the histone and DNA found previously for extended chromatin in solution.     

H3 and H4 histone tails play a central role in the interactions of recombinant NCPs

Using small-angle x-ray scattering, we probe the effect of histone tails on both internucleosomal interactions and nucleosome conformation. To get insight into the specific role of H3 and H4 histone tails, perfectly monodisperse recombinant nucleosome core particles were reconstituted, either intact or deprived of both H3 and H4 histone tails (gH3gH4). The main result is that H3 and H4 histone tails are necessary to induce attractive interactions between NCPs. A pair potential model was used to describe interactions between NCPs. At all salt concentrations, interactions between gH3gH4 NCPs are best described by repulsive interactions exclusively. For intact NCPs, an additional attractive term, with a 5–10 kT magnitude and 20 Å range, is required to account for interparticle interactions above 50 mM monovalent salt. Regarding conformation, intact NCPs in solution are similar to NCPs in 3D crystals. gH3gH4 NCPs instead give rise to slightly different small-angle x-ray scattering curves that can be understood as a more opened conformation of the particle, where DNA ends are slightly detached from the core.     

Core histone acetylation is regulated by linker histone stoichiometry in vivo

We investigated the relationship between linker histone stoichiometry and the acetylation of core histones in vivo. Exponentially growing cell lines induced to overproduce either of two H1 variants, H1(0) or H1c, displayed significantly reduced rates of incorporation of [(3)H]acetate into all four core histones. Pulse-chase experiments indicated that the rates of histone deacetylation were similar in all cell lines. These effects were also observed in nuclei isolated from these cells upon labeling with [(3)H]acetyl-CoA. Nuclear extracts prepared from control and H1-overexpressing cell lines displayed similar levels of histone acetylation activity on chromatin templates prepared from control cells. In contrast, extracts prepared from control cells were significantly less active on chromatin templates prepared from H1-overexpressing cells than on templates prepared from control cells. Reduced levels of acetylation in H1-overproducing cell lines do not appear to depend on higher order chromatin structure, because it persists even after digestion of the chromatin with micrococcal nuclease. The results suggest that alterations in chromatin structure, resulting from changes in linker histone stoichiometry may modulate the levels or rates of core histone acetylation in vivo.