Modeling the early stage of DNA sequence recognition within RecA nucleoprotein filaments

Homologous recombination is a fundamental process enabling the repair of double-strand breaks with a high degree of fidelity. In prokaryotes, it is carried out by RecA nucleofilaments formed on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). These filaments incorporate genomic sequences that are homologous to the ssDNA and exchange the homologous strands. Due to the highly dynamic character of this process and its rapid propagation along the filament, the sequence recognition and strand exchange mechanism remains unknown at the structural level. The recently published structure of the RecA/DNA filament active for recombination (Chen et al., Mechanism of homologous recombination from the RecA-ssDNA/dsDNA structure, Nature 2008, 453, 489) provides a starting point for new exploration of the system. Here, we investigate the possible geometries of association of the early encounter complex between RecA/ssDNA filament and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Due to the huge size of the system and its dense packing, we use a reduced representation for protein and DNA together with state-of-the-art molecular modeling methods, including systematic docking and virtual reality simulations. The results indicate that it is possible for the double-stranded DNA to access the RecA-bound ssDNA while initially retaining its Watson–Crick pairing. They emphasize the importance of RecA L2 loop mobility for both recognition and strand exchange.     

Probing the DNA sequence specificity of Escherichia coli RECA protein

Escherichia coli RecA protein catalyzes the central DNA strand-exchange step of homologous recombination, which is essential for the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks. In this reaction, RecA first polymerizes on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) to form a right-handed helical filament with one monomer per 3 nt of ssDNA. RecA generally binds to any sequence of ssDNA but has a preference for GT-rich sequences, as found in the recombination hot spot Chi (5′-GCTGGTGG-3′). When this sequence is located within an oligonucleotide, binding of RecA is phased relative to it, with a periodicity of three nucleotides. This implies that there are three separate nucleotide-binding sites within a RecA monomer that may exhibit preferences for the four different nucleotides. Here we have used a RecA coprotease assay to further probe the ssDNA sequence specificity of E.coli RecA protein. The extent of self-cleavage of a λ repressor fragment in the presence of RecA, ADP-AlF₄ and 64 different trinucleotide-repeating 15mer oligonucleotides was determined. The coprotease activity of RecA is strongly dependent on the ssDNA sequence, with TGG-repeating sequences giving by far the highest coprotease activity, and GC and AT-rich sequences the lowest. For selected trinucleotide-repeating sequences, the DNA-dependent ATPase and DNA-binding activities of RecA were also determined. The DNA-binding and coprotease activities of RecA have the same sequence dependence, which is essentially opposite to that of the ATPase activity of RecA. The implications with regard to the biological mechanism of RecA are discussed.     

Specific defects in double-stranded DNA unwinding and homologous pairing of a mutant RecA protein

The DNA molecules bound to RecA filaments are extended 1.5-fold relative to B-form DNA. This extended DNA structure may be important in the recognition of homology between single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). In this study, we show that the K286N mutation specifically impaired the dsDNA unwinding and homologous pairing activities of RecA, without an apparent effect on dsDNA binding itself. In contrast, the R243Q mutation caused defective dsDNA unwinding, due to the defective dsDNA binding of the C-terminal domain of RecA. These results provide new evidence that dsDNA unwinding is essential to homology recognition between ssDNA and dsDNA during homologous pairing.     

Hallmarks of homology recognition by RecA-like recombinases are exhibited by the unrelated Escherichia coli RecT protein

Homologous recombination is a fundamental process for genome maintenance and evolution. Various proteins capable of performing homology recognition and pairing of DNA strands have been isolated from many organisms. The RecA family of proteins exhibits a number of biochemical properties that are considered hallmarks of homology recognition. Here, we investigated whether the unrelated Escherichia coli RecT protein, which mediates homologous pairing and strand exchange, also exhibits such properties. We found that, like RecA and known RecA homologs: (i) RecT promotes the co-aggregation of ssDNA with duplex DNA, which is known to facilitate homologous contacts; (ii) RecT binding to ssDNA mediates unstacking of the bases, a key step in homology recognition; (iii) RecT mediates the formation of a three-strand synaptic intermediate where pairing is facilitated by local helix destabilization, and the preferential switching of A:T base pairs mediates recognition of homology; and (iv) RecT-mediated pairing occurs from both 3'- and 5'-single-stranded ends. Taken together, our results show that RecT shares fundamental homology-recognition properties with the RecA homologs, and provide new insights on an underlying universal mechanism of homologous recognition.     

Calorimetric analysis of binding of two consecutive DNA strands to RecA protein illuminates mechanism for recognition of homology

RecA protein recognises two complementary DNA strands for homologous recombination. To gain insight into the molecular mechanism, the thermodynamic parameters of the DNA binding have been characterised by isothermal calorimetry. Specifically, conformational changes of protein and DNA were searched for by measuring variations in enthalpy change (DeltaH) with temperature (heat capacity change, DeltaC(p)). In the presence of the ATP analogue ATPgammaS, the DeltaH for the binding of the first DNA strand depends upon temperature (large DeltaC(p)) and the type of buffer, in a way that is consistent with the organisation of disordered parts and the protonation of RecA upon complex formation. In contrast, the binding of the second DNA strand occurs without any pronounced DeltaC(p), indicating the absence of further reorganisation of the RecA-DNA filament. In agreement with these findings, a significant change in the CD spectrum of RecA was observed only upon the binding of the first DNA strand. In the absence of nucleotide cofactor, the DeltaH of DNA binding is almost independent of temperature, indicating a requirement for ATP in the reorganisation of RecA. When the second DNA strand is complementary to the first, the DeltaH is larger than that for non-complementary DNA strand, but less than the DeltaH of the annealing of the complementary DNA without RecA. This small DeltaH could reflect a weak binding that may facilitate the dissociation of only partly complementary DNA and thus speed the search for complementary DNA. The DeltaH of binding DNA sequences displaying strong base-base stacking is small for both the first and second binding DNA strand, suggesting that the second is also stretched upon interaction with RecA. These results support the proposal that the RecA protein restructures DNA, preparing it for the recognition of a complementary second DNA strand, and that the recognition is due mainly to direct base-base contacts between DNA strands.     

Mechanism of homology recognition in DNA recombination from dual-molecule experiments

In E. coli homologous recombination, a filament of RecA protein formed on DNA searches and pairs a homologous sequence within a second DNA molecule with remarkable speed and fidelity. Here, we directly probe the strength of the two-molecule interactions involved in homology search and recognition using dual-molecule manipulation, combining magnetic and optical tweezers. We find that the filament's secondary DNA-binding site interacts with a single strand of the incoming double-stranded DNA during homology sampling. Recognition requires opening of the helix and is strongly promoted by unwinding torsional stress. Recognition is achieved upon binding of both strands of the incoming dsDNA to each of two ssDNA-binding sites in the filament. The data indicate a physical picture for homology recognition in which the fidelity of the search process is governed by the distance between the DNA-binding sites.     

RecA蛋白介导的三链核酸结构形成及其序列提取

人工合成的单链DNA分子经PCR扩增形成双链DNA分子。将RecA蛋白与生物素标记的寡聚核酸探针序列在ATPγS存在的情况下共同哺育,使RecA蛋白包裹寡聚核酸探针,然后加入含同源序列的上述双链DNA分子经适当环境哺育形成了稳定的局部三链核酸结构。通过加入链亲和素包裹的磁珠吸附生物素化的探针,这样同源双链DNA分子与寡聚核酸探针形成的局部三链核酸结构也被吸附在磁珠上。使用磁分离装置提取这一结构,逐步降低盐离子浓度以洗脱双链DNA分子。将洗脱液中残留的蛋白质去除,经PCR扩增可获得目的DNA序列。同时使用同源探针和非同源探针在其它序列中提取目的DNA序列,结果显示目的DNA序列只被同源探针提取。实验结果显示了这一三链核酸结构形成的序列特异性,并且其稳定性随盐离子浓度降低而下降。提示在这一结构中同源的寡聚核酸单链与双链DNA分子形成了氢键结合,同时提示使用文中描述的方法可以提取特异的序列,用以克隆相应的基因。     

Nucleotide sequence and LexA regulation of the Escherichia coli recN gene.

The nucleotide sequence of a 2224 bp region of the Escherichia coli chromosome that carries the LexA regulated recN gene has been determined. A region of 1701 nucleotides encoding a polypeptide of 567 amino acids with a predicted molecular weight of 63,599 was identified as the most probable sequence for the recN structural gene. The proposed initiation codon is preceded by a reasonable Shine-Dalgarno sequence and a promoter region containing two 16 bp sequences, separated by 6 bp, that match the consensus sequence (SOS box) for binding LexA protein. DNA fragments containing this putative promoter region are shown to bind LexA in vitro and to have LexA-regulated promoter activity in vivo. The amino acid sequence of RecN predicted from the DNA contains a region that is homologous to highly conserved sequences found in several DNA repair enzymes and other proteins that bind ATP. A sequence of 9 amino acids was found to be homologous to a region of the RecA protein of E. coli postulated to have a role in DNA/nucleotide binding.     

Recombination-Independent Recognition of DNA Homology for Repeat-Induced Point Mutation (RIP) Is Modulated by the Underlying Nucleotide Sequence

Haploid germline nuclei of many filamentous fungi have the capacity to detect homologous nucleotide sequences present on the same or different chromosomes. Once recognized, such sequences can undergo cytosine methylation or cytosine-to-thymine mutation specifically over the extent of shared homology. In Neurospora crassa this process is known as Repeat-Induced Point mutation (RIP). Previously, we showed that RIP did not require MEI-3, the only RecA homolog in Neurospora, and that it could detect homologous trinucleotides interspersed with a matching periodicity of 11 or 12 base-pairs along participating chromosomal segments. This pattern was consistent with a mechanism of homology recognition that involved direct interactions between co-aligned double-stranded (ds) DNA molecules, where sequence-specific dsDNA/dsDNA contacts could be established using no more than one triplet per turn. In the present study we have further explored the DNA sequence requirements for RIP. In our previous work, interspersed homologies were always examined in the context of a relatively long adjoining region of perfect homology. Using a new repeat system lacking this strong interaction, we now show that interspersed homologies with overall sequence identity of only 36% can be efficiently detected by RIP in the absence of any perfect homology. Furthermore, in this new system, where the total amount of homology is near the critical threshold required for RIP, the nucleotide composition of participating DNA molecules is identified as an important factor. Our results specifically pinpoint the triplet 5''-GAC-3'' as a particularly efficient unit of homology recognition. Finally, we present experimental evidence that the process of homology sensing can be uncoupled from the downstream mutation. Taken together, our results advance the notion that sequence information can be compared directly between double-stranded DNA molecules during RIP and, potentially, in other processes where homologous pairing of intact DNA molecules is observed.     

Geometry of the DNA strands within the RecA nucleofilament: role in homologous recombination

Homologous recombination consists of exchanging DNA strands of identical or almost identical sequence. This process is important for both DNA repair and DNA segregation. In prokaryotes, it involves the formation of long helical filaments of the RecA protein on DNA. These filaments incorporate double-stranded DNA from the cell's genetic material, recognize sequence homology and promote strand exchange between the two DNA segments. DNA processing by these nucleofilaments is characterized by large amplitude deformations of the double helix, which is stretched by 50% and unwound by 40% with respect to B-DNA. In this article, information concerning the structure and interactions of the RecA, DNA and ATP molecules involved in DNA strand exchange is gathered and analyzed to present a view of their possible arrangement within the filament, their behavior during strand exchange and during ATP hydrolysis, the mechanism of RecA-promoted DNA deformation and the role of DNA deformation in the process of homologous recombination. In particular, the unusual characteristics of DNA within the RecA filament are compared to the DNA deformations locally induced by architectural proteins which bind in the DNA minor groove. The possible role and location of two flexible loops of RecA are discussed.     

The SalGI restriction endonuclease. Enzyme specificity.

We have analysed the kinetics of DNA cleavage in the reaction between the SalGI restriction endonuclease and plasmid pMB9. This reaction is subject to competitive inhibition by DNA sequences outside the SalGI recognition site; we have determined the Km and Vmax. for the reaction of this enzyme at its recognition site and the KI for its interaction at other DNA sequences. We conclude that the specificity of DNA cleavage by the enzyme is only partly determined by the discrimination it shows for binding at its recognition sequence compared with binding to other DNA sequences.     

Numerical investigation of sequence dependence in homologous recognition: evidence for homology traps

During the initial phase of RecA-mediated recombination, known as the search for homology, a single-stranded DNA coated by RecA protein and a homologous double-stranded DNA have to perfectly align and pair. We designed a model for the homology search between short molecules, and performed Monte Carlo Metropolis computer simulations of the process. The central features of our model are 1), the assumption that duplex DNA longitudinal thermal fluctuations are instrumental in the binding; and 2), the explicit consideration of the nucleotide sequence. According to our results, recognition undergoes a first slow nucleation step over a few basepairs, followed by a quick extension of the pairing to adjacent bases. The formation of the three-stranded complex tends to be curbed by heterologies but also by another possible obstacle: the presence of partially homologous stretches, such as mono- or polynucleotide repeats. Actually, repeated sequences are observed to trap the molecules in unproductive configurations. We investigate the dependence of the phenomenon on various energy parameters. This mechanism of homology trapping could have a strong biological relevance in the light of the genomic instability experimentally known to be triggered by repeated sequences.     

The RecA binding locus of RecBCD is a general domain for recruitment of DNA strand exchange proteins

RecBCD enzyme facilitates loading of RecA protein onto ssDNA produced by its helicase/nuclease activity. This process is essential for RecBCD-mediated homologous recombination. Here, we establish that the C-terminal nuclease domain of the RecB subunit (RecBnuc) forms stable complexes with RecA. Interestingly, RecBnuc also interacts with and loads noncognate DNA strand exchange proteins. Interaction is with a conserved element of the RecA-fold, but because the binding to noncognate proteins decreases in a phylogenetically consistent way, species-specific interactions are also present. RecBnuc does not impede activities of RecA that are important to DNA strand exchange, consistent with its role in targeting of RecA. Modeling predicts the interaction interface for the RecA-RecBCD complex. Because a similar interface is involved in the binding of human Rad51 to the conserved BRC repeat of BRCA2 protein, the RecB-domain may be one of several structural domains that interact with and recruit DNA strand exchange proteins to DNA.     

DNA binding, coprotease, and strand exchange activities of mycobacterial RecA proteins: implications for functional diversity among RecA nucleoprotein filaments

One of the fundamental questions concerning homologous recombination is how RecA or its homologues recognize several DNA sequences with high affinity and catalyze all the diverse biological activities. In this study, we show that the extent of single-stranded DNA binding and strand exchange (SE) promoted by mycobacterial RecA proteins with DNA substrates having various degrees of GC content was comparable with that observed for Escherichia coli RecA. However, the rate and extent of SE promoted by these recombinases showed a strong negative correlation with increasing amounts of sequence divergence embedded at random across the length of the donor strand. Conversely, a positive correlation was seen between SE efficiency and the degree of sequence divergence in the recipient duplex DNA. The extent of heteroduplex formation was not significantly affected when both the pairing partners contained various degrees of sequence divergence, although there was a moderate decrease in the case of mycobacterial RecA proteins with substrates containing larger amounts of sequence divergence. Whereas a high GC content had no discernible effect on E. coli RecA coprotease activity, a negative correlation was apparent between mycobacterial RecA proteins and GC content. We further show clear differences in the extent of SE promoted by E. coli and mycobacterial RecA proteins in the presence of a wide range of ATP:ADP ratios. Taken together, our findings disclose the existence of functional diversity among E. coli and mycobacterial RecA nucleoprotein filaments, and the milieu of sequence divergence (i.e., in the donor or recipient) exerts differential effects on heteroduplex formation, which has implications for the emergence of new genetic variants.     

Novel structure of the recA locus of Mycobacterium tuberculosis implies processing of the gene product.

A fragment of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DNA containing recA-like sequences was identified by hybridization with the Escherichia coli recA gene and cloned. Although no expression was detected from its own promoter in E. coli, expression from a vector promoter partially complemented E. coli recA mutants for recombination, DNA repair, and mutagenesis, but not for induction of phage lambda. This clone produced a protein which cross-reacts with antisera raised against the E. coli RecA protein and was approximately the same size. However, the nucleotide sequence of the cloned fragment revealed the presence of an open reading frame for a protein about twice the size of other RecA proteins and the cloned product detected by Western blotting (immunoblotting). The predicted M. tuberculosis RecA protein sequence was homologous with RecA sequences from other bacteria, but this homology was not dispersed; rather it was localized to the first 254 and the last 96 amino acids, with the intervening 440 amino acids being unrelated. Furthermore, the junctions of homology were in register with the uninterrupted sequence of the E. coli RecA protein. Identical restriction fragments were found in the genomic DNAs of M. tuberculosis H37Rv and H37Ra and of M. bovis BCG. It is concluded that the ancestral recA gene of these species diversified via an insertional mutation of at least 1,320 bp of DNA. Possible processing mechanisms for synthesizing a normal-size RecA protein from this elongated sequence are discussed.     

FBH1 Helicase Disrupts RAD51 Filaments in Vitro and Modulates Homologous Recombination in Mammalian Cells

Efficient repair of DNA double strand breaks and interstrand cross-links requires the homologous recombination (HR) pathway, a potentially error-free process that utilizes a homologous sequence as a repair template. A key player in HR is RAD51, the eukaryotic ortholog of bacterial RecA protein. RAD51 can polymerize on DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament that facilitates both the search for the homologous DNA sequences and the subsequent DNA strand invasion required to initiate HR. Because of its pivotal role in HR, RAD51 is subject to numerous positive and negative regulatory influences. Using a combination of molecular genetic, biochemical, and single-molecule biophysical techniques, we provide mechanistic insight into the mode of action of the FBH1 helicase as a regulator of RAD51-dependent HR in mammalian cells. We show that FBH1 binds directly to RAD51 and is able to disrupt RAD51 filaments on DNA through its ssDNA translocase function. Consistent with this, a mutant mouse embryonic stem cell line with a deletion in the FBH1 helicase domain fails to limit RAD51 chromatin association and shows hyper-recombination. Our data are consistent with FBH1 restraining RAD51 DNA binding under unperturbed growth conditions to prevent unwanted or unscheduled DNA recombination.     

A chimeric Rec-A protein that implicates non-Watson-Crick interactions in homologous pairing.

The helical filament formed by RecA protein on single-stranded DNA plays an important role in homologous recombination and pairs with a complementary single strand or homologous duplex DNA. The RecA nucleoprotein filament also recognizes an identical single strand. The chimeric protein, RecAc38, forms a nucleoprotein filament that recognizes a complementary strand but is defective in recognition of duplex DNA, and is associated with phenotypic defects in repair and recombination. As described here, RecAc38 nucleoprotein filament is also defective in recognition of an identical strand, either when the filament has within it a single strand or duplex DNA. A model that postulates three DNA binding sites rationalizes these observations and suggests that the third binding site mediates non-Watson-Crick interactions that are instrumental in recognition of homology in duplex DNA.     

Formation of nucleoprotein RecA filament on single-stranded DNA. Analysis by stepwise increase in ligand complexity

RecA protein plays a pivotal role in homologous recombination in Escherichia coli. RecA polymerizes on single-stranded (ss) DNA forming a nucleoprotein filament. Then double-stranded (ds) DNA is bound and searched for segments homologous to the ssDNA. Finally, homologous strands are exchanged, a new DNA duplex is formed, and ssDNA is displaced. We report a quantitative analysis of RecA interactions with ss d(pN)n of various structures and lengths using these oligonucleotides as inhibitors of RecA filamentation on d(pT)20. DNA recognition appears to be mediated by weak interactions between its structural elements and RecA monomers within a filament. Orthophosphate and dNMP are minimal inhibitors of RecA filamentation (I50 = 12-20 mM). An increase in homo-d(pN)2-40 length by one unit improves their affinity for RecA (f factor) approximately twofold through electrostatic contacts of RecA with internucleoside phosphate DNA moieties (f approximately = 1.56) and specific interactions with T or C bases (f approximately = 1.32); interactions with adenine bases are negligible. RecA affinity for d(pN)n containing normal or modified nucleobases depends on the nature of the base, features of the DNA structure. The affinity considerably increases if exocyclic hydrogen bond acceptor moieties are present in the bases. We analyze possible reasons underlying RecA preferences for DNA sequence and length and propose a model for recognition of ssDNA by RecA.     

Stimulation of D-loop formation by polypurine/polypyrimidine sequences

Most of the approaches used to correct gene mutations in mammalian cells involve the targeting of short nucleotide molecules to homologous chromosomal sequences and the replacement of resident sequences via homologous recombination and mismatch repair. The limited efficiency and inconsistent reproducibility of these techniques are major constraints to their use in gene therapy. One of the main problems is that it is impossible to obtain reproducible results when the targeted gene loci differ. We investigated the effects of flanking sequences on homologous recombination by means of an in vitro assay of the efficiency of oligonucleotide targeting to its homologous sequence on a large duplex molecule in a reaction catalysed by the Escherichia coli RecA protein. We demonstrated that polypurine·polypyrimidine tracts (PPTs) in duplex DNA strongly stimulate the formation of D-loops with short oligodeoxynucleotides. This result was reproduced with various PPT sequences and oligonucleotides. The stimulatory effect was observed at loci as far as 4000 bp from the PPT. The formation of complexes between the oligonucleotide and the duplex molecule depended on the extent of sequence similarity between the two DNAs and the presence of the RecA protein. The stimulatory effect was inhibited by excess RecA and restored by adding heterologous DNA. We suggest that PPT sequences induce conformational changes in duplex DNA, leading to the aggregation of molecules, facilitating homology searches. We com pared, in vivo, the efficiency of the oligonucleotide-mediated correction of a URA3 chromosomal mutation for sequences with and without a PPT sequence in the vicinity. Consistent with our in vitro results, the efficiency of correction was eight times higher in the presence of the PPT sequence.     

Regulation of DNA strand exchange in homologous recombination

Homologous recombination, the exchange of DNA strands between homologous DNA molecules, is involved in repair of many structural diverse DNA lesions. This versatility stems from multiple ways in which homologous DNA strands can be rearranged. At the core of homologous recombination are recombinase proteins such as RecA and RAD51 that mediate homology recognition and DNA strand exchange through formation of a dynamic nucleoprotein filament. Four stages in the life cycle of nucleoprotein filaments are filament nucleation, filament growth, homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange, and filament dissociation. Progression through this cycle requires a sequence of recombinase-DNA and recombinase protein-protein interactions coupled to ATP binding and hydrolysis. The function of recombinases is controlled by accessory proteins that allow coordination of strand exchange with other steps of homologous recombination and that tailor to the needs of specific aberrant DNA structures undergoing recombination. Accessory proteins are also able to reverse filament formation thereby guarding against inappropriate DNA rearrangements. The dynamic instability of the recombinase-DNA interactions allows both positive and negative action of accessory proteins thereby ensuring that genome maintenance by homologous recombination is not only flexible and versatile, but also accurate.