Induction of B lymphocyte tolerance by an oligovalent antigen. I. Influence of the read-out system.

A single intravenous injection of deaggregated preparations of lightly substituted dinitrophenylated human gamma globulin (DNP-HGG) induced DNP-specific tolerance in adult CBA mice, as judged by their failure to mount an IgM anti-DNP antibody-forming cell (AFC) response following challenge with the thymus-independent antigen, polymerized flagellin substituted with DNP (DNP-POL). Tolerance was also readily achieved in nude mice. Experiments using bovine serum albumin as the DNP carrier in both strains suggested that this was a less effective carrier for tolerance induction. The spleen cells from mice injected with DNP-HGG failed to respond to challenge with DNP-POL in vitro, but marked recovery of responsiveness occurred when the cells were challenged after adoptive transfer.These observations indicate that tolerance among antibody-forming cell precursors may selectively affect subpopulations. They further show that the choice of a read-out system used to analyze tolerance in B cells may critically influence the results.     

TNP-LPS induces an IgG anti-TNP immune response in mice.

The trinitrophenylated derivatives of lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS) elicit a specific anti-TNP, thymus-independent immune response in mice. After a single injection of antigen, anti-TNP antibodies of IgM and IgG isotypes are detected at the cellular and at the humoral levels, in athymic nude mice as well as in conventional (C57B1/6 × DBA/2)F₁ mice. The immune sera were resolved into IgM and IgG molecules by gel filtration; both fractions showed an anti-TNP activity, thus confirming the data obtained by the cellular analysis.     

Lymphotoxin-alpha-dependent spleen microenvironment supports the generation of memory B cells and is required for their subsequent antigen-induced activation

Lymphotoxin alpha-deficient (LTalpha-/-) mice show dramatically reduced IgG responses after either primary or secondary immunizations with sheep red blood cells (SRBC). When splenocytes from SRBC-primed wild-type donor mice were infused into irradiated naive wild-type recipient mice, they generated a robust memory IgG response, but not when infused into LTalpha-/- recipients, indicating that the microenvironment that develops in LTalpha-/- mice is incompetent to support the activation of this memory response. When irradiated wild-type mice were reconstituted with splenocytes from primed LTalpha-/- donors and then challenged with the same immunizing Ag, no memory response was observed, indicating further that memory cells could not be generated in the LTalpha-/- environment. To address which lymphocyte subsets were impaired in the LTalpha-/- mice, we performed reconstitution experiments using a hapten/carrier system and T cells and B cells from different primed donors. There was no detectable defect in either the generation or expression of memory T cells from LTalpha-/- donors. In contrast, B cells were not primed for memory in the microenvironment of LTalpha-/- mice. Additionally, primed wild-type memory B cells could not express a memory IgG response in the LTalpha-/- microenvironment. Thus, splenic white pulp structure, which depends on the expression of LTalpha for its development and maintenance, is needed to support the generation of memory B cells and to permit existing memory B cells to express an isotype switched memory Ig response following antigenic challenge.     

Expression of IgG memory response in vitro to thymus-dependent and thymus-independent antigens

A model is described in which expression of IgG secondary antihapten responses of large magnitude can be initiated in vitro without resorting to in vivo boosting prior to culture. The number of IgG plaque-forming cells (PFC) is frequently as much as 100-fold greater than that of IgM PFC. Spleen cells from mice primed with trinitrophenylated keyhole limpet hemocyanin (TNP-KLH) several months earlier are stimulated in vitro to produce an anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response 7–10 days later. The in vitro IgG response can be elicited with either a thymus-dependent antigen (TNP-KLH) or thymus-independent antigens (TNP-T₄ bacteriophage or DNP-dextran). The kinetics of the responses to these two forms of antigen differ in that the thymus-independent response peaks two days earlier. The IgG response to both forms of antigen requires the presence of 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) even though macrophages are not depleted prior to culture. In the absence of the reducing agent both thymus-dependent and thymus-independent IgG responses were diminished ≥90%. The magnitude of the response to thymus-independent antigens emphasizes the ability of these materials to elicit IgG expression in memory B cells provided optimal conditions for memory development and in vitro expression exist.     

Generation of immune memory by haptenated derivatives of thymus-independent antigens in C57BL/6 mice. I. The differentiation of memory B lymphocytes into antibody-secreting cells depends on the nature of the thymus-independent carrier used for memory induction and/or revelation

It has been previously reported that trinitrophenylated lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS), a thymus-independent (TI)-1 antigen, elicits an anamnestic response to TNP in C57BL/6 mice. The ability of these mice to mount a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was analyzed. Priming with DNP-Ficoll or DNP-Dextran, both TI-2 antigens, resulted in an increased frequency of TNP-binding B lymphocytes. Evidence is presented that memory cell-induction by DNP-Ficoll does not require functional T cells. The differentiation into antibody-forming cells (AFC) of memory cells generated by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll cannot be obtained by a challenge with either antigen. There was no indication that the lack of a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was related to suppressive T cells interfering with memory expression. Memory cells induced by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll can nevertheless be activated by TNP-LPS. In contrast to the restricted sensitivity of TNP-memory cells generated by TI-2 antigens, TNP-LPS-induced memory cells are indifferently susceptible to TI-1 or TI-2 antigenic stimulation. These results are discussed in terms of memory B-cell subpopulations.     

Influence of contact sensitivity to DNFB on the induction of carrier-determined tolerance to DNP.

Contact sensitivity to DNFB, induced by skin painting Balb/c mice with DNFB had no influence on the induction of carrier determined tolerance to DNP. In contrast, contact sensitivity to DNFB, elicited in complete Freund's adjuvant, prevented induction of tolerance to DNP. This effect was not due to the adjuvant alone and was hapten specific since contact sensitivity induced by OCBC in complete adjuvant had no influence on tolerance induction to DNP. In addition, in mice primed with DNFB in complete Freund's adjuvant, the tolerogen becomes immunogenic. It is suggested that the T-cell mediating tolerance to DNP-autologous IgG is different from the T-cell mediating contact sensitivity to DNP autologous carrier. DNFB in complete adjuvant may augment not only contact-sensitized T-cells, which mediate contact sensitivity, but also T-cells which have helper function in the antibody response to DNP.     

The role of T cells in IgG production; thymus-dependent antigens induce B cell memory in the absence of T cells.

B cell memory was shown to develop in congenitally athymic (nu/nu) mice after injection with small amounts of thymus-dependent antigens, in particular heterologous serum proteins, such as fown gamma-globulin (FGG) or DNP-bovine-serum albumin (DNP-BSA). Large doses of proteins (10 mg) tended to produce a specific B cell unresponsiveness, although there was still some evidence of B cell priming. The antigen did not have to be in a multivalent form to interact with B cell so as to induce immunologic memory or tolerance. In contrast to the induction of B cell memory, the production of IgG antibody in this system was found to be strongly T cell dependent. Thymus-independent antigens like LPS or POL with pronounced adjuvant effects on IgG production in normal or surgically thymectomized mice, could not replace T cells in allowing an IgG response against thymus-dependent antigens in congenitally athymic mice. However, the action of T cells once activated is likely to be non-antigen-specific, since it was shown that supernatants of antigen-activated-syngeneic T cells stimulated IgG production in cultures of primed B cell populations non-antigen-specifically.     

Universal vaccine carrier. Liposomes that provide T-dependent help to weak antigens

The design of a thymus-dependent synthetic vaccine that will provide a universal T cell epitope for B cell epitopes is described in this study. Simultaneous incorporation into liposomes of both a peptide recognized by Th lymphocytes and a lipophilic hapten and the IgG antibody responses to this hapten were assessed in outbred mice. DNP-aminocaproyl phosphatidylethanolamine (DNP-CapPE) is a well characterized T-independent hapten Ag. HA2 peptide derived from the hemagglutinin protein of influenza virus contains amino acid sequences recognized by Th and T cytotoxic lymphocytes. In addition, HA2 contains a sequence of hydrophobic amino acids near the carboxyl terminus, allowing its incorporation into liposomes. Results of immunization show that (i), when DNP-CapPE is carried by liposomes without the HA2 peptide, an IgM antibody response is induced, (ii) liposomes carrying both HA2 and DNP-CapPE elicit an IgG antibody response to DNP in a dose-dependent fashion for both HA2 and DNP, (iii) the liposomes must be processed intracellularly in order to elicit a response, (iv) the system leads to a memory response for DNP, and (v) all of the IgG subclasses are elicited. These data suggest that liposomes containing the HA2 peptide exhibit a T-dependent carrier effect for a T-independent Ag. The significance of these findings is discussed in conjunction with the characteristics of the liposome model used.     

IgM rheumatoid factors in mice injected with bacterial lipopolysaccharides.

Bacterial lipopolysaccharides (LPS) induced the formation of IgM rheumatoid factors (RF) in several strains of mice including athymic C57BL/6 nude mice, but not in the LPS-resistant C3H/HeJ mice. The RF induced by LPS reacted not only with murine IgG but also with IgG from cows, goats, guinea pigs, and humans. The kinetics of this RF response to injection of LPS were similar to those of antibody response against DNA and a hapten, dinitrophenyl (DNP), and to those of total IgM production. In addition, the RF activity of individual serum samples correlated significantly with levels of anti-DNA and anti-DNP antibodies and of IgM. Therefore, it is concluded that the induction of RF results from polyclonal antibody synthesis by B cells stimulated with LPS. This observation suggests that LPS or LPS-like substances may help to generate RF in patients with rheumatoid arthritis or with some infectious diseases.     

Carboxymethyl cellulose, a nonimmunogenic hapten carrier with tolerogenic properties.

This communication reports on the tolerogenic properties of carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) as a nonimmunogenic carrier for 2.4 dinitrophenyl (DNP) and the benzylpenicilloyl determinant (BPO). Either normal or primed mice, given an optimal dose of 250 micrograms per animal of DNP CMC, when challenged with an immunogenic form of the hapten as early as 30 min or as late as 21 days thereafter were completely and specifically unresponsive to it. Experimental evidence suggests that this unresponsiveness is not due to suppressor cells. Furthermore, DNP CMC induces tolerance in vivo but fails to do so in vitro under conditions at which other tolerogenic carbohydrate hapten conjugates such as DNP-dextran do. This together with comparative studies of tolerance induction kinetics by DNP CMC and DNP-dextran in vivo led us to conclude that molecular properties other than the epitope density must be attributed to CMC's tolerogenic potential. CMC may also be used as a tolerogenic carrier for BPO with respect to IgE antibody production. Thus, normal or primed mice injected with the BPO CMC conjugate were found specifically unresponsive to a challenge with an immunogenic form of penicillin.     

Immunopotentiation by SGP and Quil A. II. Identification of responding cell populations

The adjuvants SGP (a starch-acrylamide polymer) and Quil A (purified saponin) were shown to markedly augment antibody responses to T-independent (TI) antigens, suggesting that their adjuvant effects may be at least partially mediated through B cells. The ability of both adjuvants to augment primary responses to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-Ficoll (TI-2 antigen) in athymic nude mice further suggested these adjuvants affect B cells. SGP, however, did not induce a response to the T-dependent (TD) antigen dinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (DNP-KLH) in athymic nude mice, indicating it was unable to replace the requirement for T-helper cells for responses to TD antigens. Responses to TNP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were augmented by SGP in CBA/N X Balb/c immune defective (xid) mice. However, SGP was unable to induce a response to TNP-Ficoll in xid mice. The SGP and Quil A augmented responses to TNP-Ficoll were completely inhibited by the mitotic inhibitor, Velban, indicating that SGP and Quil A increased the plaque-forming cell (PFC) response primarily by stimulating cell proliferation, and not by recruitment of antigen-reactive cells. The effects of the adjuvants on secondary responses were investigated using adoptive transfer experiments. SGP and A1(OH)3 both increased the induction of hapten-specific memory B cells in mice primed with DNP-KLH. SGP, Quil A, and A1(OH)3 also increased priming of carrier specific T cells. Priming of memory B cells with DNP-KLH and either A1(OH)3 or SGP was prevented when T cells were depleted with anti-lymphocyte serum (ALS) at the time of antigen priming, indicating that the augmentation of memory B-cell priming by SGP and A1(OH)3 was dependent on the presence of functional T cells. SGP and Quil A were both unable to augment memory cell induction to the TI antigen, TNP-Ficoll, even though both adjuvants markedly augmented primary IgM and IgG responses to this antigen. Based on these results, it is suggested that SGP and Quil A can mediate their adjuvant effects primarily by a direct or indirect effect on B cells although the adjuvants may also affect T cells to some extent.     

Stimulation of the in vivo dinitrophenyl antibody response to the DNP conjugate of L-glutamic acid60-L-alanine30-L-Tyrosine10 (GAT) polymer by a synthetic adjuvant, muramyl dipeptide (MDP): target cells for adjuvant activity and isotypic pattern of MDP-stimulated response

Specific anti-dinitrophenyl (DNP) response to DNP-conjugated L-glutamine60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (DNP-GAT) was obtained in GAT-responder mice by using synthetic N-acetylmuramyl-L-alanyl-D-isoglutamine (MDP) as adjuvant. Significant levels of anti-DNP antibodies were observed during a secondary response to DNP-GAT, when both antigen and MDP were used for priming. In this system, MDP was able to prime the carrier-specific T cells but not the hapten specific B cells. The study of the isotypic pattern of the anti-DNP response shows that MDP stimulates only the appearance of specific anti-DNP IgG1 plaque-forming cells. Anti-DNP plaque-forming cells were stimulated in animals primed with DNP-GAT in Freund's complete adjuvant or in Maalox-pertussis and used as control IgG1, IgG2a, and IgG2b.     

Effect of Adjuvants on the Antibody Response to a Hapten on a Thymus-independent Carrier

IT has been demonstrated in mice that levan (polyfructose), an antigen which interacts only with B lymphocytes¹, can function as a carrier and produce a thymus-independent response to dinitrophenol (DNP)². Using this conjugate, antibody-production against the hapten is totally unaffected in thymectomized animals and is abolished in mice tolerant to levan. The DNP-levan conjugate produces only 19S antibody against DNP.     

Antigen-initiated B lymphocyte differentiation. V. Electrophoretic separation of different subpopulations of AFC progenitors for unprimed IgM and memory IgG responses to the NIP determinant.

Spleen cells from CBA mice were separated by continuous, free-buffer film cell electrophoresis, and the capacity of cells in different fractions to mount an adoptive immune response specific for the NIP hapten determined. Experimental conditions were such that AFC progenitor B cells were measured, rather than helper or suppressor T cells. The IgM response of unprimed animals (a virgin or antigen inexperienced population) and the IgG response of long-term hapten-primed animals (a B memory cell population) were compared. The results indicated physical and biological heterogeneity in splenic B cells, with AFC progenitors for unprimed IgM and memory IgG responses being extensively separated.AFC progenitors for a primary IgM response in normal, germ-free and athymic mouse spleen, and bone marrow, separated into three distinct populations. Two of these were of much higher mobility than the typical splenic B cells and separated in the T cell zone. These cells produced a relatively early peak response of AFC after stimulation.AFC progenitors for a secondary IgG response were predominantly typical low-mobility B cells. Three regions of activity were separated, one overlapping part of the IgM progenitors. The slowest migrating activity peaks corresponded to the mobility of some recirculating B cells. These cells produced a more delayed AFC response after stimulation.AFC from the spleens of immunised mice separated as a single, broad, mediummobility peak distinct from most B cells and AFC progenitors. IgM and IgG (memory) AFC had similar electrophoretic characteristics.     

Regulation of T15 idiotype dominance. II. Genes unlinked to the Igh locus regulate T15 dominance of the secondary adoptive transfer response to phosphocholine

We have studied the idiotype and fine specificity of the secondary immune response to phosphocholine (PC) in C57BL (B10, B10.D2, and B.C8) and BALB (BALB/c, BAB-14, and C.B20) congenic strains of mice. In vivo IgM responses of mice from these two genetic backgrounds differed in their T15 idiotypic representation. BALB strains expressed the T15 idiotype on greater than 90% of their IgM, PC-specific plaque-forming cells (PFC), whereas C57BL strains expressed the T15 idiotype on approximately 50% of their IgM PFC. All strains examined expressed greater than 75% PC-inhibitable, VHPC idiotype-positive, IgM PFC. The IgG3 and IgA memory responses were similar to the IgM memory response; BALB strains produced a higher proportion of T15+ PFC than C57BL strains; however, the majority of IgG3 and IgA PFC in all strains were VHPC+, and PC-inhibitable. In contrast, the IgG1 memory response was not dominated by T15+, VHPC+, PC-inhibitable PFC in any of the strains tested. The IgG1 PFC required nitrophenylphosphocholine (NPPC) for efficient inhibition. The IgG2 memory response generally mimicked the IgG1 response with respect to idiotype and specificity. These data demonstrate that the representation of the T15 idiotype in the anti-PC immune response is determined by genes outside both the MHC and Igh genetic loci. Control of T15 expression in secondary IgM, IgG3, and IgA anti-PC responses was examined by using a cell-mixing protocol with primed T and B cells from BALB/c and B10.D2 mice. T15 representation in these responses was determined by the genotype of the B cell, not by the genotype of the helper T cell. Similarly, the B cell genotype was responsible for the idiotypic profile of a primary, in vitro, T-dependent, anti-PC response.     

Suppressor T-cell activity in MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr mice: differential effects on primary and memory antibody responses of MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr and MRL/Mp-+/+ spleen cells to thymus dependent and thymus independent antigens in vitro

We have previously shown that suppressor-T-cell (TS) activity in the spleens of autoimmune MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr (MRL/l) mice is increased after 2 months of age. The TS suppress the in vitro primary IgM response to the thymus-dependent (TD) antigen sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) of B and T cells from young congenic MRL/Mp-+/+ (MRL/n) mice which lack the lymphoproliferation (lpr) gene. The TS are nylon wool nonadherent, Thy 1.2 positive, and radiation sensitive. The studies presented here were done to further characterize the TS and to attempt to determine the mechanism of action of these cells. We found that increased TS activity was also present in the proliferating lymph nodes of old MRL/l mice but not in lymph nodes of young MRL/l or MRL/n mice. The splenic TS equally suppressed the primary IgM SRBC response of both young MRL/l and MRL/n B and T cells, indicating that MRL/l SRBC-specific B and T cells are not resistant to suppression. The IgM response of MRL/n B and T cells to the T-independent (TI) antigen trinitrophenyl conjugated to Brucella abortus (TNP-BA) was not suppressed by the TS, although the IgM response to TNP was suppressed when TNP was coupled to the TD carrier SRBC. The results of kinetics studies of TS expression showed that when the TS were added on Day 0 of culture the SRBC response was suppressed as early as Day 2 of culture; however, when the TS were added on Days 1, 2, or 3 of culture, the suppression was reduced. The TS suppressed the in vitro memory IgG response of spleen cells from MRL/n mice which had been primed with SRBC; the memory IgG responses of spleen cells from MRL/l mice were variably suppressed. Taken together, these results suggest that the TS suppress TH function in early events of antibody production and that some activated B or T cells may be resistant to the effects of the TS. Increased TS activity was not present in the spleens of aged New Zealand Black X NZ White (NZB/W) F1 mice. Possible reasons for the presence of increased TS activity in MRL/l mice and its relation to autoimmune disease is discussed.     

Potentiation of antibody responses by specific IgM: specificity and thymus dependency

Modulation of antibody responses induced by IgM directed against the immunogen was investigated. When IgM directed against ox erythrocytes (ORBC) was given together with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-ORBC, the subsequent antibody response to the carrier, ORBC, as well as the response to the hapten, TNP, was potentiated. In contrast, IgG with carrier specificity inhibited both responses. The hapten-specific potentiation was found in both direct and indirect plaques, and was antigen-dose dependent, i.e., no potentiation was found with the lowest antigen doses. The response to 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP)-labeled proteins was potentiated by a monoclonal IgM with specificity for the hapten. The effects were observed both in primary and secondary responses. One strict requirement for IgM potentiation to occur was observed. The determinant against which potentiation was achieved had to be physically linked to the determinant against which the IgM was directed, be it hapten or carrier determinants. Thus, irrelevant IgM-antigen complexes were incapable of potentiating the responses. Similar specificity requirements were found for IgG induced suppression of antibody responses. Experiments with nude mice and their euthymic littermates showed that IgM potentiation of antibody production is T-cell dependent. Furthermore, passive transfer of carrier-primed spleen cells together with antigen challenge suggests that IgM potentiation of secondary antibody responses is dependent on specific carrier-primed immune T cells.     

Clonal anergy of memory B cells in epitope-specific regulation.

Immunization of carrier (keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)) primed mice with the hapten-carrier TNP-KLH induces specific suppression for the IgG anti-TNP-response without interfering with the response to epitopes on the carrier molecule. To examine the status of hapten-specific memory B cells from suppressed mice, highly enriched populations of TNP-specific memory B cells were purified from the spleen of TNP-KLH (control) or KLH/TNP-KLH (suppressed) immunized mice and tested in vitro for their ability to respond to TD or TI (TNP-KLH, TNP-LPS) antigenic challenge in presence of a KLH-specific Th cell line. Similar numbers of TNP-specific B cells with the characteristics of memory B cells were obtained from control and suppressed mice. TNP-specific B cells from suppressed mice could be triggered to IgG production by TNP-LPS but had an impaired ability to differentiate into IgG-secreting cells in response to TNP-KLH. This impaired IgG response to TNP-KLH was not due to an active suppression by a subset of TNP-specific B cells, or to an impedence of memory cells to a class switching but to an intrinsic memory B cell defect. TNP-specific B cells from suppressed mice were as efficient as memory B cells from control mice to present TNP-KLH to KLH-specific Th cells and to proliferate in response to T cell help. Our data support the view that the effector mechanism of epitope specific regulation does not interfere with the development of hapten-specific memory B cells but that these cells have an intrinsic defect that prevents their differentiation into active IgG antibody secreting cells in response to a T-dependent antigenic challenge.     

Further studies on amplification of cell-associated immunological memory by secondary antigenic stimulus.

Using the hapten-carrier system in which the dinitrophenyl group (DNP) served as a B cell reactive hapten and bovine serum albumin (BSA) or human gammaglobulin (HGG) as a T cell reactive carrier, changes in the hapten-specific memory (B cell-associated memory) and the carrier-specific memory (T cell-associated memory) after a secondary antigenic stimulus were analyzed in mice. Since an immunological adjuvant was indispensable in the induction of the primary increase in memory, antigen used for the primary antigenic stimulus was injected together with the capsular polysaccharide of Klebsiella pneumoniae (CPS-K) which has already been shown to exhibit a potent adjuvant effect. With the cell-transfer technique, it was found that the cell-associated hapten-specific memory for anti-DNP antibody response to DNP-BSA was truly amplified by the secondary injection of DNP-HGG into mice primed with DNP-HGG, and that the cell-associated carrier-specific memory as judged by the helper effect on anti-DNP response to DNP-BSA was also truly amplified by the secondary injection of BSA into mice primed with BSA. However, when memory was assessed in actively immunized mice, the secondary injection of BSA into mice primed with DNP-BSA and HGG decreased anti-DNP responsiveness to the tertiary injection of DNP-BSA, whereas the secondary injection of DNP-HGG secondarily increased anti-DNP responsiveness. In mice primed with DNP-BSA the titers of serum antibodies to BSA increased after the secondary injection of DNP-BSA or BSA. From these results it has been concluded that, like B cell-associated memory, T cell-associated memory is also amplified by a secondary antigenic stimulus, although its expression is inhibited in actively immunized mice through negative control by their antibodies.