Hybrid genes in the analysis of transformation conditions: II. Transient expression vs stable transformation—analysis of parameters influencing gene expression levels and transformation efficiency

Reports on direct gene transfer have dealt with either the obtention of stable transformants and transgenic plants, or described the use of reporter genes to analyse different aspects of gene expression in plant protoplasts and conditions for their use in transient gene expression assays.
In this paper we present comparisons between several transformation techniques, show species-specific differences in efficiencies of stable transformants and in the levels of transient gene expression, and report on the identification of major parameters responsible for DNA uptake as judged from transient chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) expression levels and from efficiencies of transformation based on kanamycin-resistance. The described procedures have been simplified, optimized and standardized and should allow routine use with a great variety of plant species.     

Microbial horizontal gene transfer and the DNA release from transgenic crop plants

Intraspecific and interspecific horizontal gene transfers among prokaryotes by mechanisms like conjugation, transduction and transformation are part of their life style. Experimental data and nucleotide sequence analyses show that these processes appear to occur in any prokaryotic habitat and have shaped microbial genomes throughout evolution over hundreds of million years. Here we summarize studies with a focus on the possibility of the transfer of free recombinant DNA released from transgenic plants to microorganisms by transformation. A list of 87 species capable of natural transformation is presented. We discuss monitoring techniques which allowed detection of the spread of intact DNA from plants during their growth, in the process of decay and by pollen dispersal including novel biomonitoring assays for measuring the transforming potential of DNA in the environment. Also, studies on the persistence of free DNA in soil habitats and the potential of bacteria to take up DNA in soil are summarized. On the other hand, the various barriers evolved in prokaryotes which suppress interspecific gene transfer and recombination will be addressed along with studies aiming to estimate the chance of a gene transfer from plant to microbe. The results suggest that, although such transfers could be possible in principle, each of the many steps involved from the release of intact DNA from a plant cell to integration into a prokaryotic genome has such a low probability that a successful transfer event be extremely rare. Further, interspecies transfer of chromosomal DNA is mostly negative for the recipient, and, if not, in the absence of a selective advantage the transformant will be lost. It is stressed that the nucleotide sequences introduced into transgenic plants are much less likely to be captured from the transgenic plants than directly from those organisms (often bacteria or viruses) from which they were originally derived.     

Direct DNA transfer using electric discharge particle acceleration (ACCELL™ technology)

Direct DNA transfer methods based on particle bombardment have revolutionized plant genetic engineering. Major agronomic crops previously considered recalcitrant to gene transfer have been engineered using variations of this technology. In many cases variety-independent and efficient transformation methods have been developed enabling application of molecular biology techniques to crop improvement. The focus of this article is the development and performance of electric discharge particle bombardment (ACCELL™) technology. Unique advantages of this methodology compared to alternative propulsion technologies are discussed in terms of the range of species and genotypes that have been engineered, and the high transformation frequencies for major agronomic crops that enabled the technology to move from the R&D phase to commercialization. Creation of transgenic soybeans, cotton, and rice will be used as examples to illustrate the development of variety-independent and efficient gene transfer methods for most of the major agronomic crops. To our knowledge, no other gene transfer method based on particle bombardment has resulted in variety-independent and practical generation of large numbers of independently-derived crop plants. ACCELL™ technology is currently being utilized for the routine transfer of valuable genes into elite germplasm of soybean, cotton, bean, rice, corn, peanut and woody species.     

Genetic transformation technology: Status and problems

Summary Transfer of genes from heterologous species provides the means of selectively introducing new traits into crop plants and expanding the gene pool beyond what has been available to traditional breeding systems. With the recent advances in genetic engineering of plants, it is now feasible to introduce into crop plants, genes that have previously been inaccessible to the conventional plant breeder, or which did not exist in the crop of interest. This holds a tremendous potential for the genetic enhancement of important food crops. However, the availability of efficient transformation methods to introduce foreign DNA can be a substantial barrier to the application of recombinant DNA methods in some crop plants. Despite significant advances over the past decades, development of efficient transformation methods can take many years of painstaking research. The major components for the development of transgenic plants include the development of reliable tissue culture regeneration systems, preparation of gene constructs and efficient transformation techniques for the introduction of genes into the crop plants, recovery and multiplication of transgenic plants, molecular and genetic characterization of transgenic plants for stable and efficient gene expression, transfer of genes to elite cultivars by conventional breeding methods if required, and the evaluation of transgenic plants for their effectiveness in alleviating the biotic and abiotic stresses without being an environmental biohazard. Amongst these, protocols for the introduction of genes, including the efficient regeneration of shoots in tissue cultures, and transformation methods can be major bottlenecks to the application of genetic transformation technology. Some of the key constraints in transformation procedures and possible solutions for safe development and deployment of transgenic plants for crop improvement are discussed.     

The myth of plant transformation

Technology development is innovative to many aspects of basic and applied plant transgenic science. Plant genetic engineering has opened new avenues to modify crops, and provided new solutions to solve specific needs. Development of procedures in cell biology to regenerate plants from single cells or organized tissue, and the discovery of novel techniques to transfer genes to plant cells provided the prerequisite for the practical use of genetic engineering in crop modification and improvement. Plant transformation technology has become an adaptable platform for cultivar improvement as well as for studying gene function in plants. This success represents the climax of years of efforts in tissue culture improvement, in transformation techniques and in genetic engineering. Plant transformation vectors and methodologies have been improved to increase the efficiency of transformation and to achieve stable expression of transgenes in plants. This review provides a comprehensive discussion of important issues related to plant transformation as well as advances made in transformation techniques during three decades.     

Plant transformation technology

Plant transformation has its roots in the research on Agrobacterium that was being undertaken in the early 1980s. The last two decades have seen significant developments in plant transformation technology, such that a large number of transgenic crop plants have now been released for commercial production. Advances in the technology have been due to development of a range of Agrobacterium-mediated and direct DNA delivery techniques, along with appropriate tissue culture techniques for regenerating whole plants from plant cells or tissues in a large number of species. In addition, parallel developments in molecular biology have greatly extended the range of investigations to which plant transformation technology can be applied. Research in plant transformation is concentrating now not so much on the introduction of DNA into plant cells, but rather more on the problems associated with stable integration and reliable expression of the DNA once it has been integrated.     

Genomic stability in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis> transgenic plants obtained by floral dip

The occurrence of DNA modification is an undesired phenomenon accompanying plant cell transformation. The event has been correlated with the stress imposed by the presently utilised transformation procedures, all depending on plant differentiation from in vitro cell culture, but other causes have not been excluded. In this work, transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana plants have been produced by an approach that does not require cell dedifferentiation, being based on in planta Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer by flower infiltration, which is followed by recovery and selection of transgenic progeny. Genomic DNA changes in transgenic and control plants have been investigated by AFLP and RAMP analysis. Results show no statistically relevant genomic modifications in transgenic plants, as compared with control untreated plants. Variations were observed in callus-derived A. thaliana plants, thus supporting the conclusion that somaclonal variation is essentially correlated with the stress imposed by the in vitro cell culture, rather than with the integration of a foreign gene.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhizobia species</Emphasis>: A Boon for “Plant Genetic Engineering”

Since past three decades new discoveries in plant genetic engineering have shown remarkable potentials for crop improvement. Agrobacterium Ti plasmid based DNA transfer is no longer the only efficient way of introducing agronomically important genes into plants. Recent studies have explored a novel plant genetic engineering tool, Rhizobia sp., as an alternative to Agrobacterium, thereby expanding the choice of bacterial species in agricultural plant biotechnology. Rhizobia sp. serve as an open license source with no major restrictions in plant biotechnology and help broaden the spectrum for plant biotechnologists with respect to the use of gene transfer vehicles in plants. New efficient transgenic plants can be produced by transferring genes of interest using binary vector carrying Rhizobia sp. Studies focusing on the interactions of Rhizobia sp. with their hosts, for stable and transient transformation and expression of genes, could help in the development of an adequate gene transfer vehicle. Along with being biologically beneficial, it may also bring a new means for fast economic development of transgenic plants, thus giving rise to a new era in plant biotechnology, viz. “Rhizobia mediated transformation technology.”     

植物遗传转化表达载体研究进展

植物遗传转化表达载体是植物转基因研究中非常重要的一个环节,外源基因在转基因植物中的高效表达是转基因研究成功的关键。综述了植物遗传转化表达载体近年来的研究进展情况,着重介绍了在转基因植物中实现外源基因高效表达的多种途径和策略,旨在提高转基因植物中外源基因的表达水平和生物安全性,并展望了今后植物转基因研究及商业化发展方向。     

Agrobacterium-mediated horizontal gene transfer: Mechanism,biotechnological application,potential risk and forestalling strategy

The extraordinary capacity of Agrobacterium to transfer its genetic material to host cell makes it evolve from phytopathogen to a powerful transgenic vector. Agrobacterium-mediated stable transformation is widely used as the preferred method to create transgenic plants for molecular plant biology research and crop breeding. Recent years, both mechanism and application of Agrobacterium-mediated horizontal gene transfer have made significant progresses, especially Agrobacterium-mediated transient transformation was developed for plant biotechnology industry to produce recombinant proteins. Agrobacterium strains are almost used and saved not only by each of microbiology and molecular plant labs, but also by many of plant biotechnology manufacturers. Agrobacterium is able to transfer its genetic material to a broad range of hosts, including plant and non-plant hosts. As a consequence, the concern of environmental risk associated with the accidental release of genetically modified Agrobacterium arises. In this article, we outline the recent progress in the molecular mechanism of Agrobacterium-meditated gene transfer, focus on the application of Agrobacterium-mediated horizontal gene transfer, and review the potential risk associated with Agrobacterium-meditated gene transfer. Based on the comparison between the infecting process of Agrobacterium as a pathogen and the transgenic process of Agrobacterium as a transgenic vector, we realize that chemotaxis is the distinct difference between these two biological processes and thus discuss the possible role of chemotaxis in forestalling the potential risk of Agrobacterium-meditated horizontal gene transfer to non-target plant species.     

Genetic transformation of wheat: progress during the 1990s into the Millennium

Wheat transformation technology has progressed rapidly during the past decade. Initially, procedures developed for protoplast isolation and culture, electroporation- and polyethylene glycol (PEG)-induced DNA transfer enabled foreign genes to be introduced into wheat cells. The development of biolistic (microprojectile) bombardment procedures led to a more efficient approach for direct gene transfer. More recently, Agrobacterium-mediated gene delivery procedures, initially developed for the transformation of rice, have also been used to generate transgenic wheat plants. This review summarises the considerable progress in wheat transformation achieved during the last decade. An increase in food production is essential in order to sustain the increasing world population. This could be achieved by the development of higher yielding varieties with improved nutritional quality and tolerance to biotic and abiotic stresses. Although conventional breeding will continue to play a major role in increasing crop yield, laboratory-based techniques, such as genetic transformation to introduce novel genes into crop plants, will be essential in complementing existing breeding technologies. A decade ago, cereals were considered recalcitrant to transformation. Since then, a significant research effort has been focused on cereals because of their agronomic status, leading to improved genetic transformation procedures (Bommineni and Jauhar 1997). Initially, the genetic transformation of cereals relied on the introduction of DNA into protoplasts and the subsequent production of callus from which fertile plants were regenerated. More recently, major advances have been accomplished in the regeneration of fertile plants from a range of source tissues, providing an essential foundation for the generation of transgenic plants. This review summarises procedures, vectors and target tissues used for transformation, high-lights the limitations of current approaches and discusses future trends. The citation of references is limited, where possible, to the most relevant or recent reports.     

在杂交作物分子育种中利用普通核雄性不育的几个可能途径

由一对隐性基因控制的普通核雄性不育性遗传方式能够满足对植物最佳雄性不育系选育的要求,是水稻等作物杂种优势利用的极好遗传工具。如果能解决其不育系繁殖问题,将优于现有的其他杂种优势利用方式。克隆出普通核雄性不育性的可育基因,通过叶绿体转化,将核雄性不育性可育基因向普通核雄性不育株细胞质转移,创造普通核雄性不育株的保持系;通过种子成熟后表达的启动子;和以位点特异性重组技术为基础的基因开关以及化学诱导启动子的利用,都可能繁殖出100％不育株率的普通核雄性不育系,创造普通核雄性不育性利用的新途径,对植物杂种优势利用产业有十分重要的意义。     

在杂交作物分子育种中利用普通核雄性不育的几个可能途径

由一对隐性基因控制的普通核雄性不育性遗传方式能够满足对植物最佳雄性不育系选育的要求,是水稻等作物杂种优势利用的极好遗传工具。如果能解决其不育系繁殖问题,将优于现有的其他杂种优势利用方式。克隆出普通核雄性不育性的可育基因,通过叶绿体转化,将核雄性不育性可育基因向普通核雄性不育株细胞质转移,创造普通核雄性不育株的保持系;通过种子成熟后表达的启动子;和以位点特异性重组技术为基础的基因开关以及化学诱导启动子的利用,都可能繁殖出100%不育株率的普通核雄性不育系,创造普通核雄性不育性利用的新途径,对植物杂种优势利用产业有十分重要的意义。     

转转基因植物对根际土壤生态系统的影响

随着全世界转基因植物种植的普及,转基因植物对生态环境的影响也受到人们的广泛关注。本文针对转基因植物对土壤生态系统带来的潜在风险做了较全面的探讨,概述了转基因植物在土壤中的残留、外源基因的水平转移及其表达产物对土壤生物、土壤理化性质的影响,为今后更安全利用转基因植物提供借鉴。     

植物的遗传转化及其应用(英文)

近年来,植物遗传转化研究有了长足的发展。已经达到能够通过简单的遗传控制手段研究具有新表现型的植物,甚至达到进入商业化的程度。这些手段包括植物生物学的主要研究技术以及植物组织培养和树种改良的一些实用方法。尽管采用农瘤杆菌和鸟枪法等技术的植物遗传转化系统已经得到了广泛的应用,但是在如何开发具有能够得到控制表达的转基因高产植物方面,在如何使所得到的转基因植物远离遗传危害等方面,目前的转化系统遇到了极大的技术挑战。已经提出了各种各样的方法用于将新基因稳定地导入120多种不同植物的核基因组。本文将讨论这些遗传转化系统所需的生物学要求和实际应用方面的需求、基因转化和转基因表达的研究策略、遗传转化植物的鉴定以及转基因植物与大众的认可。本文将分为七个部分加以讨论:一、导言;二 、基因转化到细胞里的方法;三、植物遗传转化策略;四、植物遗传转化的鉴定;五、植物遗传转化的实际应用;六、转基因植物与环境;七、未来植物遗传转化的需求与发展方向。     

Strategies for developing marker-free transgenic plants

The development of marker-free transgenic plants has responded to public concerns over the safety of biotechnology crops. It seems that continued work in this area will soon remove the question of unwanted marker genes from the debate concerning the public acceptability of transgenic crop plants. Selectable marker genes are co-introduced with genes of interest to identify those cells that have integrated the DNA into their genome. Despite the large number of different selection systems, marker genes that confer resistance to the antibiotics, hygromycin (hpt) and kanamycin (nptII) or herbicide phosphinothricin (bar), have been used in most transgenic research and crop development techniques. The techniques that remove marker gene are under development and will eventually facilitate more precise and subtle engineering of the plant genome, with widespread applications in both fundamental research and biotechnology. In addition to allaying public concerns, the absence of resistance genes in transgenic plants could reduce the costs of developing biotechnology crops and lessen the need for time-consuming safety evaluations, thereby speeding up the commercial production of biotechnology crops. Many research results and various techniques have been developed to produce marker-free transgenic plants. This review describes the strategies for eliminating selectable marker genes to generate marker-free transgenic plants, focusing on the three significant marker-free technologies, co-transformation, site-specific recombinase-mediated excision, and non-selected transformation.     

Superfluous Transgene Integration in Plants

Referee: Dr. Paul Hooykass, Institut of Molecular Plant Sciences, Leiden University, Clusius Laboratory, Wassenaarseweg 64, 2333, Al Leiden, Netherlands Recent reports suggest the transfer of superfluous DNA sequences to plant genomes during transformation processes. This review investigates the evidence from the published literature for the prevalence of this phenomenon and highlights methods to limit or prevent DNA transfer and subsequent potentially detrimental evolutionary consequences. Evidence for superfluous foreign DNA transfer using both Agrobacterium-mediated transformation and direct DNA transfer methods such as microprojectile bombardment and PEG-mediated transformation of protoplasts is reported. In the case of Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, the lack of information on the integration of sequences from outside of the T-DNA borders has been due to the general belief by researchers that T-DNA processing is precise. This assumption was based on analysis of T-DNA in tumors and as a result the majority of T-DNA integration events have been identified exclusively using DNA probes, which are homologous only to DNA from within the T-DNA borders. Where direct gene transfer protocols are employed, any part of the transforming plasmid and indeed accompanying carrier DNA may become integrated into the plant genome. The main body of evidence proving that superfluous vector DNA sequences are present in plant genomes transformed using direct transfer methods is confined to the identification of plasmid concatamers integrated into plant genomes. The limited amount of recorded evidence pertaining to superfluous vector DNA integration in transgenic plants and transformed tissues makes it impossible to draw definitive conclusions as to the factors involved in promoting this phenomenon. However, there are methods available for removing superfluous sequences from transgenic plants. These have been developed for the removal of selectable marker genes, whose presence in transgenic plants has been a source of much controversy, but can equally be applied to other DNA sequences. Suggestions have been made in the review that might limit or prevent the integration of superfluous vector sequences during transformation procedures; however, these are not proven and further research is required.     

Features of development and reproduction of transgenic flax

Primary transformants carrying a genetic construct with the chimeric gfp-tua6 gene were obtained using biolistic transformation of hypocotyl explants of flax variety Vasilek. Viable modified plants were used as a basis for the production of inbred lines with confirmed inheritance of introduced genetic construct in three generations. The characteristics of phenological growth stages, plant height, number of bolls and meiosis were studied for transgenic plants. A comparison of transformed lines based on reproduction years revealed a significant decrease of seed production in one line. Meiotic analysis of this line at metaphase I and anaphase I stages was conducted. The percentage of cells with impaired meiosis was highest in transgenic plants of the line with the lowest seed production. Thus, the nonspecific incorporation of genetic construct into the flax genome using biolistic transformation impairs meiosis to a different extent and it is the main reason for unequal reproducibility of transgenic flax. The production of stably reproducing transgenic lines requires systematic analysis of meiosis.     

基于RNAi技术的转基因植物研究进展

RNA干扰（RNA interference,RNAi）是指由双链RNA（double-stranded RNA,dsRNA）诱发同源mRNA高效特异性降解的现象,在真核生物中普遍存在且进化保守。RNAi技术作为21世纪初的重大科学成就,目前被广泛应用于疾病防治、基因功能研究、植物改良育种等领域。RNAi技术常与转基因技术结合用于植物改良育种,通过不同的载体设计或作用途径来研发满足生产需要的农业生物技术产品。为了明确现阶段基于RNAi技术的转基因植物育种技术进展,综述了RNAi现象的发现和作用机制、转基因载体设计、小RNA（small RNA,sRNA）的递送方式等方面的研究进展,并阐述了基于RNAi技术的转基因植物的研究实例和商业化情况,以期为相关研究提供参考,从而发挥RNAi技术的最大应用价值,使之服务于新时代的农业发展。     

Transgenic plants for phytoremediation

Phytoremediation is a green, sustainable and promising solution to problems of environmental contamination. It entails the use of plants for uptake, sequestration, detoxification or volatilization of inorganic and organic pollutants from soils, water, sediments and possibly air. Phytoremediation was born from the observation that plants possessed physiological properties useful for environmental remediation. This was shortly followed by the application of breeding techniques and artificial selection to genetically improve some of the more promising and interesting species. Now, after nearly 20 years of research, transgenic plants for phytoremediation have been produced, but none have reached commercial existence. Three main approaches have been developed: (1) transformation with genes from other organisms (mammals, bacteria, etc.); (2) transformation with genes from other plant species; and (3) overexpression of genes from the same plant species. Many encouraging results have been reported, even though in some instances results have been contrary to expectations. This review will illustrate the main examples with a critical discussion of what we have learnt from them.