Both transmembrane domains of SecG contribute to signal sequence recognition by the Escherichia coli protein export machinery

A chimeric protein containing the uncleaved signal sequence of plasminogen activators inhibitor-2 (PAI2) fused to alkaline phosphatase (AP) interferes with Escherichia coli protein export and arrests growth. Suppressors of this toxicity include secG mutations that define the Thr-41-Leu-42-Phe-43 (TLF) domain of SecG. These mutations slow down the export of PAI2-AP. Another construct encoding a truncated PAI2 signal sequence (hB-AP) is also toxic. Most suppressors exert their effect on both chimeric proteins. We describe here five secG suppressors that only suppress the toxicity of hB-AP and selectively slow down its export. These mutations do not alter the TLF domain: three encode truncated SecG, whereas two introduce Arg residues in the transmembrane domains of SecG. The shortest truncated protein only contains 13 residues of SecG, suggesting that the mutation is equivalent to a null allele. Indeed, a secG disruption selectively suppresses the toxicity of hB-AP. However, the missense mutations are not null alleles. They allow SecG binding to SecYE, although with reduced affinity. Furthermore, these mutated SecG are functional, as they facilitate the export of endogenous proteins. Thus, SecG participates in signal sequence recognition, and both transmembrane domains of SecG contribute to ensure normal signal sequence recognition by the translocase.     

A novel class of secA alleles that exert a signal-sequence-dependent effect on protein export in Escherichia coli

The murine plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 (PAI2) signal sequence inefficiently promotes the export of E. coli alkaline phosphatase (AP). High-level expression of PAI2::AP chimeric proteins from the arabinose P(BAD) promoter is toxic and confers an Ara(S) phenotype. Most Ara(R) suppressors map to secA, as determined by sequencing 21 independent alleles. Mutations occur throughout the gene, including both nucleotide binding domains (NBDI and NBDII) and the putative signal sequence binding domain (SSBD). Using malE and phoA signal sequence mutants, we showed that the vast majority of these secA suppressors exhibit weak Sec phenotypes. Eight of these secA mutations were further characterized in detail. Phenotypically, these eight suppressors can be divided into three groups, each localized to one domain of SecA. Most mutations allow near-normal levels of wild-type preprotein export, but they enhance the secretion defect conferred by signal sequence mutations. Interestingly, one group exerts a selective effect on the export of PAI2::AP when compared to that of AP. In conclusion, this novel class of secA mutations, selected as suppressors of a toxic signal sequence, differs from the classical secA (prlD) mutations, selected as suppressors of defective signal sequences, although both types of mutations affect signal sequence recognition.     

Mutational analysis of transmembrane regions 3 and 4 of SecY, a central component of protein translocase

The SecYEG heterotrimeric membrane protein complex functions as a channel for protein translocation across the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane. SecY is the central subunit of the SecYEG complex and contains 10 transmembrane segments (TM1 to TM10). Previous mutation studies suggested that TM3 and TM4 are particularly important for SecY function. To further characterize TM3 and TM4, we introduced a series of cysteine-scanning mutations into these segments. With one exception (an unstable product), all the mutant proteins complemented the cold-sensitive growth defect of the secY39 mutant. A combination of this secY mutation and the secG deletion resulted in synthetic lethality, and the TM3 and TM4 SecY cysteine substitution mutations were examined for their ability to complement this lethality. Although they were all positive for complementation, some of the complemented cells exhibited significant retardation of protein export. The substitution-sensitive residues in TM3 can be aligned to one side of the alpha-helix, and those in TM4 revealed a tendency for residues closer to the cytosolic side of the membrane to be more severely affected. Disulfide cross-linking experiments identified a specific contact point for TM3 and SecG TM2 as well as for TM4 and SecG TM1. Thus, although TM3 and TM4 do not contain any single residue that is absolutely required, they include functionally important helix surfaces and specific contact points with SecG. These results are discussed in light of the structural information available for the SecY complex.     

SecG function and phospholipid metabolism in Escherichia coli

SecG is an auxiliary protein in the Sec-dependent protein export pathway of Escherichia coli. Although the precise function of SecG is unknown, it stimulates translocation activity and has been postulated to enhance the membrane insertion-deinsertion cycle of SecA. Deletion of secG was initially reported to result in a severe export defect and cold sensitivity. Later results demonstrated that both of these phenotypes were strain dependent, and it was proposed that an additional mutation was required for manifestation of the cold-sensitive phenotype. The results presented here demonstrate that the cold-sensitive secG deletion strain also contains a mutation in glpR that causes constitutive expression of the glp regulon. Introduction of both the glpR mutation and the secG deletion into a wild-type strain background produced a cold-sensitive phenotype, confirming the hypothesis that a second mutation (glpR) contributes to the cold-sensitive phenotype of secG deletion strains. It was speculated that the glpR mutation causes an intracellular depletion of glycerol-3-phosphate due to constitutive synthesis of GlpD and subsequent channeling of glycerol-3-phosphate into metabolic pathways. In support of this hypothesis, it was demonstrated that addition of glycerol-3-phosphate to the growth medium ameliorated the cold sensitivity, as did introduction of a glpD mutation. This depletion of glycerol-3-phosphate is predicted to limit phospholipid biosynthesis, causing an imbalance in the levels of membrane phospholipids. It is hypothesized that this state of phospholipid imbalance imparts a dependence on SecG for proper function or stabilization of the translocation apparatus.     

Escherichia coli SecG Is Required for Residual Export Mediated by Mutant Signal Sequences and for SecY-SecE Complex Stability

Protein export to the bacterial periplasm is achieved by SecYEG, an inner membrane heterotrimer. SecY and SecE are encoded by essential genes, while SecG is not essential for growth under standard laboratory conditions. Using a quantitative and sensitive export assay, we show that SecG plays a critical role for the residual export mediated by mutant signal sequences; the magnitude of this effect is not proportional to the strength of the export defect. In contrast, export mediated by wild-type signal sequences is only barely retarded in the absence of SecG. When probed with mutant signal sequences, secG loss of function mutations display a phenotype opposite to that of prlA mutations in secY. The analysis of secG and prlA single and double mutant strains shows that the increased export conferred by several prlA alleles is enhanced in the absence of SecG. Several combinations of prlA alleles with a secG deletion cannot be easily constructed. This synthetic phenotype is conditional, indicating that cells can adapt to the presence of both alleles. The biochemical basis of this phenomenon is linked to the stability of the SecYE dimer in solubilized membranes. With prlA alleles that can be normally introduced in a secG deletion strain, SecG has only a limited effect on the stability of the SecYE dimer. With the other prlA alleles, the SecYE dimer can often be detected only in the presence of SecG. A possible role for the maintenance of SecG during evolution is proposed.     

Functional identification of the product of the Bacillus subtilis yvaL gene as a SecG homologue

Protein export in Escherichia coli is mediated by translocase, a multisubunit membrane protein complex with SecA as the peripheral subunit and the SecY, SecE, and SecG proteins as the integral membrane domain. In the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis, SecA, SecY, and SecE have been identified through genetic analysis. Sequence comparison of the Bacillus chromosome identified a potential homologue of SecG, termed YvaL. A chromosomal disruption of the yvaL gene results in mild cold sensitivity and causes a beta-lactamase secretion defect. The cold sensitivity is exacerbated by overexpression of the secretory protein alpha-amylase, whereas growth and beta-lactamase secretion are restored by coexpression of yvaL or the E. coli secG gene. These results indicate that the yvaL gene codes for a protein that is functionally homologous to SecG.     

Functional activity of eukaryotic signal sequences in Escherichia coli: the ovalbumin family of serine protease inhibitors

It is widely assumed that the functional activity of signal sequences has been conserved throughout evolution, at least between Gram-negative bacteria and eukaryotes. The ovalbumin family of serine protease inhibitors (serpins) provides a unique tool to test this assumption, since individual members can be secreted (ovalbumin), cytosolic (leukocyte elastase inhibitor, LEI), or targeted to both compartments (plasminogen activator inhibitor 2, PAI-2). The facultative secretion of PAI-2 is mediated by a signal sequence proposed to be inefficient by design. We show here that the same internal domain that promotes an inefficient translocation of murine PAI-2 in mammalian cells is a weak signal sequence in Escherichia coli. In contrast, the ovalbumin signal sequence is much more efficient, whereas the corresponding sequence elements from LEI, maspin and PI-10 are entirely devoid of signal sequence activity in E.coli. Mutations that improve the activity of the PAI-2 signal sequence and that convert the N-terminal regions of maspin and PI-10 into efficient signal sequences have been characterized. Taken together, these results indicate that several structural features contribute to the weak activity of the PAI-2 signal sequence and provide new insights into the plasticity of the "hydrophobic core" of signal sequences. High-level expression of two chimeric proteins containing the PAI-2 signal sequence is toxic, and the reduced viability is accompanied by a rapid decrease in the membrane proton motive force, in ATP levels and in translation. In unc- cells, which lack the F0F1 ATP-synthase, the chimeric proteins retain their toxicity and their expression only affected the proton motive force. Thus, the properties of these toxic signal sequences offer a new tool to dissect the interactions of signal sequences with the protein export machinery.     

A signal sequence is not required for protein export in prlA mutants of Escherichia coli.

The prlA/secY gene, which codes for an integral membrane protein component of the Escherichia coli protein export machinery, is the locus of the strongest suppressors of signal sequence mutations. We demonstrate that two exported proteins of E.coli, maltose-binding protein and alkaline phosphatase, each lacking its entire signal sequence, are exported to the periplasm in several prlA mutants. The export efficiency can be substantial; in a strain carrying the prlA4 allele, 30% of signal-sequenceless alkaline phosphatase is exported to the periplasm. Other components of the E.coli export machinery, including SecA, are required for this export. SecB is required for the export of signal-sequenceless alkaline phosphatase even though the normal export of alkaline phosphatase does not require this chaperonin. Our findings indicate that signal sequences confer speed and efficiency upon the export process, but that they are not always essential for export. Entry into the export pathway may involve components that so overlap in function that the absence of a signal sequence can be compensated for, or there may exist one or more means of entry that do not require signal sequences at all.     

Altered translation initiation factor 2 in the cold-sensitive ssyG mutant affects protein export in Escherichia coli.

The Escherichia coli gene secY (pr1A) codes for an integral membrane protein that plays an essential role in protein export. We previously isolated cold-sensitive mutations (ssy) as extragenic suppressors of temperature-sensitive secY24 mutation. Now we show that the ssyG class of mutations are within infB coding for the translation initiation factor IF2. The mutants produce altered forms of IF2 with a cold-sensitive in vitro activity to form a translation initiation complex. The mutation suppresses not only secY24 but also other secretion-defective mutations such as secA51 and rp10215. The beta-galactosidase enzyme activity of the MalE-LacZ 72-47 hybrid protein is strikingly reduced in the ssyG mutant at the permissive high temperature, while the hybrid protein itself is normally synthesized. This effect, which was observed only for the hybrid protein with a functional signal sequence, may result from some alteration in the cellular localization of the protein. These results suggest that IF2 or the translation initiation step can modulate protein export reactions. The isolation of cold-sensitive ssyG mutations in infB provides genetic evidence that IF2 is indeed essential for normal growth of E. coli cells.     

Two SecG molecules present in a single protein translocation machinery are functional even after crosslinking

SecG, a membrane component of the protein translocation apparatus of Escherichia coli, undergoes membrane topology inversion, which is coupled to the membrane insertion and deinsertion cycle of SecA. Eighteen SecG derivatives possessing a single cysteine residue at various positions were constructed and expressed in a secG null mutant. All the SecG-Cys derivatives retained the SecG function, and stimulated protein translocation both in vivo and in vitro. Inverted membrane vesicles containing a SecG-Cys derivative were labeled with a membrane-permeable or -impermeable sulfhydryl reagent before or after solubilization with a detergent. The accessibility of these reagents to the cysteine residue of each derivative determined the topological arrangement of SecG in the membrane. Derivatives having the cysteine residue in the periplasmic region each existed as a homodimer crosslinked through disulfide bonds, indicating that two SecG molecules closely co-exist in a single translocation machinery. The crosslinking did not abolish the SecG function and the crosslinked SecG dimer underwent topology inversion upon protein translocation.     

SecY variants that interfere with Escherichia coli protein export in the presence of normal secY

As an approach for studying how SecY, an integral membrane protein translocation factor of Escherichia coli, interacts with other protein molecules, we isolated a dominant negative mutation, secY-d1, of the gene carried on a plasmid. The mutant plasmid severely inhibited export of maltose-binding protein and less severely of OmpA, when introduced into sec+ cells. It inhibited growth of secY and secE mutant cells, but not of secA and secD mutant cells or wild-type cells. The mutation deletes three amino acids that should be located at the interface of cytoplasmic domain 5 and transmembrane segment 9. We also found that some SecY-PhoA fusion proteins that lacked carboxy-terminal portions of SecY but retain a region from periplasmic domain 3 to transmembrane segment 7 were inhibitory to protein export. We suggest that these SecY variants are severely defective in catalytic function of SecY, which requires cytoplasmic domain 5 and its carboxy-terminal side, but retain the ability to associate with other molecules of the protein export machinery, which requires the central portion of SecY; they probably exert the 'dominant negative' effects by competing with normal SecY for the formation of active Sec complex. These observations should provide a basis for further genetic analysis of the Sec protein complex in the membrane.     

Influence of tat mutations on the ribose-binding protein translocation in Escherichia coli

Proteins are exported across the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane either as unfolded precursors via the Sec machinery or in folded conformation via the Tat system. The ribose-binding protein (RBP) of Escherichia coli is a Sec-pathway substrate. Intriguingly, it exhibits fast folding kinetics and its export is independent of SecB, a general chaperone protein dedicated for protein secretion. In this study, we found that the quantity of RBP was significantly reduced in the periplasm of tat mutants, which was restored by in trans expression of the tatABC genes. Pulse-chase experiments showed that significant amount of wild-type RBP was processed in a secY mutant in the presence of azide (SecA inhibitor), whereas the processing of a slow folding RBP derivative was almost completely blocked under the same conditions. These results would suggest that under the Sec-defective conditions the export of a portion of folded RBP could be rescued by the Tat system.     

PrlA and PrlG suppressors reduce the requirement for signal sequence recognition.

Selection for suppressors of defects in the signal sequence of secretory proteins has led most commonly to identification of prlA alleles and less often to identification of prlG alleles. These genes, secY/prlA and secE/prlG, encode integral membrane components of the protein translocation system of Escherichia coli. We demonstrate that an outer membrane protein, LamB, that lacks a signal sequence can be exported with reasonable efficiency in both prlA and prlG suppressor strains. Although the signal sequence is not absolutely required for export of LamB, the level of export in the absence of prl suppressor alleles is exceedingly low. Such strains are phenotypically LamB-, and functional LamB can be detected only by using sensitive infectious-center assays. Suppression of the LamB signal sequence deletion is dependent on normal components of the export pathway, indicating that suppression is not occurring through a bypass mechanism. Our results indicate that the majority of the known prlA suppressors function by an identical mechanism and, further, that the prlG suppressors work in a similar fashion. We propose that both PrlA and PrlG suppressors lack a proofreading activity that normally rejects defective precursors from the export pathway.     

Targeting of signal sequenceless proteins for export in Escherichia coli with altered protein translocase.

Most extracytoplasmic proteins are synthesized with an N-terminal signal sequence that targets them to the export apparatus. Escherichia coli prlA mutants (altered in the secY gene) are able to export cell envelope proteins lacking any signal sequence. In order to understand how such proteins are targeted for export, we isolated mutations in a signal sequenceless version of alkaline phosphatase that block its export in a prlA mutant. The mutations introduce basic amino acyl residues near the N-terminus of alkaline phosphatase. These changes do not disrupt an N-terminal export signal in this protein since the first 25 amino acids can be removed without affecting its export competence. These findings suggest that signal sequenceless alkaline phosphatase does not contain a discrete domain that targets it for export and may be targeted simply because it remains unfolded in the cytoplasm. We propose that basic amino acids near the N-terminus of a signal sequenceless protein affect its insertion into the translocation apparatus after it has been targeted for export. These findings allow the formulation of a model for the entry of proteins into the membrane-embedded export machinery.     

Modeling the effects of prl mutations on the Escherichia coli SecY complex

The apparatus responsible for translocation of proteins across bacterial membranes is the conserved SecY complex, consisting of SecY, SecE, and SecG. Prior genetic analysis provided insight into the mechanisms of protein export, as well as the interactions between the component proteins. In particular, the prl suppressor alleles of secE and secY, which allow export of secretory proteins with defective signal sequences, have proven particularly useful. Here, we report the isolation of novel mutations in secE and secY, as well as the phenotypic effects of combinations of prl mutations. These new alleles, as well as previously characterized prl mutations, were analyzed in light of the recently published crystal structure of the archaeal SecY complex. Our results support and expand a model of Prl suppressor activity that proposes that all of the prlA and prlG alleles either destabilize the closed state of the channel or stabilize the open form. These mutants thus allow channel opening to occur without the triggering event of signal sequence binding that is required in a wild-type complex.     

Temperature-sensitive sec mutants of Escherichia coli: inhibition of protein export at the permissive temperature.

Phenotypes of secY and secA temperature-sensitive mutants at permissive (low) temperature have been examined. The secY24 mutant was found to be extremely susceptible to export inhibition by a basal-level synthesis of the MalE-LacZ 72-47 hybrid protein or to overproduction of a normal secretory protein such as maltose-binding protein or beta-lactamase. Comparison of this phenotype of secY24 with those of the secY100 and secA51 mutants under similar conditions suggested that MalE-LacZ protein and overproduced secretory protein do not nonspecifically enhance the partial secretion defect but act synergistically with secY24 to inhibit protein export.     

Nearest neighbor analysis of the SecYEG complex. 1. Identification of a SecY-SecG interface

Integral membrane components SecY, SecE, and SecG of protein translocase form a complex in the Escherichia coli plasma membrane. To characterize subunit interactions of the SecYEG complex, a series of SecY variants having a single cysteine in its cytoplasmic (C1-C6) or periplasmic (P1-P5) domain were subjected to site-specific cross-linking experiments using bifunctional agents with thiol-amine reactivity. Experiments using inverted membrane vesicles revealed specific cross-linkings between a cysteine residue placed in the C2 or C3 domain of SecY and the cytosolic lysine (Lys26) near the first transmembrane segment of SecG. These SecY Cys residues also formed a disulfide bond with an engineered cytosolic cysteine at position 28 of SecG. Thus, the C2-C3 region of SecY is in the proximity of the N-terminal half of the SecG cytoplasmic loop. Experiments using spheroplasts revealed the physical proximity of P2 (SecY) and the C-terminal periplasmic region of SecG. In addition, mutations in secG were isolated as suppressors against a cold-sensitive mutation (secY104) affecting the TM4-C3 boundary of SecY. These results collectively suggest that a C2-TM3-P2-TM4-C3 region of SecY serves as an interface with SecG.     

Genetic analysis of an essential cytoplasmic domain of Escherichia coli SecY based on resistance to Syd, a SecY-interacting protein

We previously described a dominant negative secY ^-d 1 allele in Escherichia coli, whose product interferes with protein export, presumably by sequestering SecE, the stabilizing partner of SecY. Syd is the product of a multicopy suppressor of the secY ^-d 1 phenotype, and its overproduction preferentially stabilizes the wild-type SecY protein. In contrast, overproduction of Syd is toxic to the secY24 mutant, which shows a partial defect in SecY-SecE interaction. We isolated Syd-resistant revertants from the secY24 mutant. Pseudo-reversions mapped to sites at or near the secY24 mutation site (Gly240→Asp). The secY249 mutation (Ala249→Val) intragenically suppressed Syd sensitivity, but not the temperature-sensitive Sec phenotype of the secY24 mutation. The SecY249 mutant protein shows a reduced capacity to be stabilized by Syd, suggesting that the mutation weakens the SecY-Syd interaction. The other two mutations changed residue 240 (the site of the secY24 alteration) to Asn (secY245) or Ala (secY241) and restored the ability of the cell to export protein. Although the secY245 mutant retained some sensitivity?to Syd overproduction, the secY241 mutant was completely Syd-resistant. Furthermore, the secY241 mutation seemed to represent a “hyper reversion” with respect to the SecY-SecE interaction. Protein export in this mutant was no longer sensitive to SecY^-d1. When the secY ^-d 1 mutation was combined intragenically with secY241, the resulting double mutant gene (secY ^-d 1–241) showed an increased ability to interfere with protein export. On the basis of our model for SecY^-d1, these results suggest that the secY241 alteration enhances SecY-SecE interaction. These results indicate that residue 240 of SecY is crucial for the interaction between the cytosolic domains of SecY and SecE required for the establishment of the translocase complex.