The generation of Mutator transposable element subfamilies in maize

The mobile DNAs of the Mutator system of maize (Zea mays) are exceptional both in structure and diversity. So far, six subfamilies of Mu elements have been discovered; all Mu elements share highly conserved terminal inverted repeats (TIRs), but each sub-family is defined by internal sequences that are apparently unrelated to the internal sequences of any other Mu subfamily. The Mu1/Mu2 subfamily of elements was created by the acquisition of a portion of a standard maize gene (termed MRS-A) within two Mu TIRs. Beside the unusually long (185–359 bp) and diverse TIRs found on all of these elements, other direct and inverted repeats are often found either within the central portion of a Mu element or within a TIR.Our computer analyses have shown that sequence duplications (mostly short direct repeats interrupted by a few base pairs) are common in non-autonomous members of the Mutator, Ac/Ds, and Spm(En) systems. These duplications are often tightly associated with the element-internal end of the TIRs. Comparisons of Mu element sequences have indicated that they share more terminal components than previously reported; all subfamilies have at least the most terminal 215 bp, at one end or the other, of the 359-bp Mu5 TIR. These data suggest that many Mu element subfamilies were generated from a parental element that had termini like those of Mu5. With the Mu5 TIRs as a standard, it was possible to determine that elements like Mu4 could have had their unusual TIRs created through a three-step process involving (1) addition of sequences to interrupt one TIR, (2) formation of a stem-loop structure by one strand of the element, and (3) a subsequent DNA repair/gene conversion event that duplicated the insertion(s) within the other TIR. A similar repair/conversion extending from a TIR stem into loop DNA could explain the additional inverted repeat sequences added to the internal ends of the Mu4 and Mu7 TIRs. This same basic mechanism was found to be capable of generating new Mu element subfamilies. After endonucleolytic attack of the loop within the stem-loop structure, repair/conversion of the gap could occur as an intermolecular event to generate novel internal sequences and, therefore, a new Mu element subfamily. Evidence supporting and expanding this model of new Mu element subfamily creation was identified in the sequence of MRS-A.     

Mu transposable elements are structurally diverse and distributed throughout the genusZea

Summary The Robertson's Mutator stock of maize exhibits a high mutation rate due to the transposition of theMu family of transposable elements. All characterizedMu elements contain similar 200-bp terminal inverted repeats, yet the internal sequences of the elements may be completely unrelated. Non-Mutator stocks of maize have a 20–100-fold lower mutation rate relative to Mutator stocks, yet they contain multiple sequences that hybridize to theMu terminal inverted repeats. Most of these sequences do not cohybridize to internal regions of previously clonedMu elements. We have cloned two such sequences from the maize line B37, a non-Mutator inbred line. These sequences, termedMu4 andMu5, have an organization characteristic of transposable elements and possess 200-bpMu terminal inverted repeats that flank internal DNA, which is unrelated to other clonedMu elements.Mu4 andMu5 are both flanked by 9-bp direct repeats as has been observed for otherMu elements. However, we have no direct evidence that they have recently transposed because they have not been found in known genes. Although the internal regions ofMu4 andMu5 are not related by sequence similarity, both elements share an unusual structural feature: the terminal inverted repeats extend more than 100 bp internally fromMu-similar termini. The distribution of these elements in maize lines and related species suggests thatMu elements are an ancient component of the maize genome. Moreover, the structure of theMu termini and the fact thatMu termini are found flanking different internal sequences leads us to speculate thatMu termini once may have been capable of transposing as independent entities.     

Concomitant regulation of Mu1 transposition and Mutator activity in maize

Summary The mutagenic activity of the maize transposable element system Mutator can be lost by outcrossing to standard, non-Mutator lines or by repetitive intercrossing of genetically diverse Mutator lines. Lines losing Mutator mutagenic activity in either manner retain high copy numbers (10–15 per diploid genome) of the Mutator-associated Mu transposable elements. Frequent transposition of Mu1-related elements is observed only in active Mutator lines, however. The loss of Mutator activity on intercrossing is correlated with an increase in the copy number of Mu1-like elements to 40–50 per diploid genome, implying a self-encoded or self-activated negative regulator of Mu1 transposition. The outcross loss of Mutator activity is only weakly correlated with a low Mu element copy number and may be due to the loss of a positive regulatory factor encoded by a subset of Mu1-like elements. Transposition of Mu elements in active Mutator lines generates multiple new genomic positions for about half the elements each plant generation. The appearance of Mu1-like elements in these new positions is not accompanied by equally high germinal reversion frequencies, suggesting that Mu1 may commonly transpose via a DNA replicative process.     

Germinal and somatic products of Mu1 excision from the Bronze-1 gene of Zea mays

Summary Germinal and somatic excision products of Mu1 from the insertion allele bz::mu1 were selectively amplified from maize cob tissue. The sequence of these footprints often included deletions at the target site, suggesting that substantial exonucleolytic degradation occurs upon excision of the element. In addition to deletions of target site sequences, single base insertions were also found. The isolation of an excision product including a 4 by inverted duplication of the target site provides evidence that the double-stranded chromosomal break generated by Mu excision may be terminated by a covalently closed hairpin structure. The majority of excision products, however, do not include inverted duplications of target site sequences, suggesting that such structures are the result of occasional repair activities, rather than an essential step in the mechanism of Mu excision. The sequence of the Mu insertion sites of the bz::mu1 and bz::mu2 alleles is also presented.     

Identification of the Maize Gravitropism Gene lazy plant1 by a Transposon-Tagging Genome Resequencing Strategy

Since their initial discovery, transposons have been widely used as mutagens for forward and reverse genetic screens in a range of organisms. The problems of high copy number and sequence divergence among related transposons have often limited the efficiency at which tagged genes can be identified. A method was developed to identity the locations of Mutator (Mu) transposons in the Zea mays genome using a simple enrichment method combined with genome resequencing to identify transposon junction fragments. The sequencing library was prepared from genomic DNA by digesting with a restriction enzyme that cuts within a perfectly conserved motif of the Mu terminal inverted repeats (TIR). Paired-end reads containing Mu TIR sequences were computationally identified and chromosomal sequences flanking the transposon were mapped to the maize reference genome. This method has been used to identify Mu insertions in a number of alleles and to isolate the previously unidentified lazy plant1 (la1) gene. The la1 gene is required for the negatively gravitropic response of shoots and mutant plants lack the ability to sense gravity. Using bioinformatic and fluorescence microscopy approaches, we show that the la1 gene encodes a cell membrane and nuclear localized protein. Our Mu-Taq method is readily adaptable to identify the genomic locations of any insertion of a known sequence in any organism using any sequencing platform.     

A nuclear protein that binds specifically to several maize transposons is not essential for Ds1 excision

Specific binding of plant nuclear proteins to GGTAAA-like motifs in the terminal regions of the transposable elements Ac and Mu1 has been detected in several laboratories. However, the role of these proteins in transposition remains unknown. To test the hypothesis that this binding activity is necessary for transposition, we identified and mutagenized all the binding motifs within the Ds1 element. This analysis enabled us to define more precisely the requirements for binding of the host protein. We then tested the ability of the mutated elements to excise from the maize streak virus (MSV) genome. We found that mutated Ds1 elements that do not bind the host proteins, as determined by gel-shift competition assay, are still capable of undergoing excision in maize, although for one of the maize lines the rate of excision was reduced. Excision of mutated Ds1 elements generated typical excision footprints. These data indicate that binding of host protein(s) to the GGTAAA-like motifs is not essential for Ds1 excision; however, it may contribute to the efficiency of the process. Received: 30 September 1999 / Accepted: 17 January 2000     

Molecular characterization of Mutator systems in maize embryogenic callus cultures indicates Mu element activity in vitro

Summary Active Mutator lines of maize (Zea mays L.) are characterized by their ability to generate new mutants at a high rate and by somatic instability at Mutator-induced mutant alleles. Mutagenically active lines with fewer than ten Mu elements per diploid genome have not been observed. Alteration of Mutator activity has been shown to correlate with the state of modification of Hinfl restiction sites that lie within inverted terminal repeats of Mu elements. To determine whether active Mutator systems can be established and maintained in culture, copy number and modification state of Mu elements were investigated in embryogenic callus lines derived from F₁S of crosses of active Mutator stock with the inbred lines A188 and H99. All callus lines studied maintain high Mu-element copy numbers, and more than half show a continued lack of modification at the Mu element Hinfl sites; thus, parameters associated with mutagenic activity in planta are present in some, but not all, callus lines. Mutator activity was then tested directly by restriction fragment analysis of subclonal populations from A188/Mu ² and H99/Mu ² embryonic cultures. Novel Mu-homologous restriction fragments occurred in 38% of the subpopulations which contained unmodified Mu elements, but not in control cultures containing modified, genetically inactive Mu elements. We conclude that Mu elements from active Mutator parents can remain transpositionally active in embryogenic cell culture. Active Mutator cell lines may be useful for the production of mutations in vitro.     

Mu Transposon Insertion Sites and Meiotic Recombination Events Co-Localize with Epigenetic Marks for Open Chromatin across the Maize Genome

The Mu transposon system of maize is highly active, with each of the ∼50–100 copies transposing on average once each generation. The approximately one dozen distinct Mu transposons contain highly similar ∼215 bp terminal inverted repeats (TIRs) and generate 9-bp target site duplications (TSDs) upon insertion. Using a novel genome walking strategy that uses these conserved TIRs as primer binding sites, Mu insertion sites were amplified from Mu stocks and sequenced via 454 technology. 94% of ∼965,000 reads carried Mu TIRs, demonstrating the specificity of this strategy. Among these TIRs, 21 novel Mu TIRs were discovered, revealing additional complexity of the Mu transposon system. The distribution of >40,000 non-redundant Mu insertion sites was strikingly non-uniform, such that rates increased in proportion to distance from the centromere. An identified putative Mu transposase binding consensus site does not explain this non-uniformity. An integrated genetic map containing more than 10,000 genetic markers was constructed and aligned to the sequence of the maize reference genome. Recombination rates (cM/Mb) are also strikingly non-uniform, with rates increasing in proportion to distance from the centromere. Mu insertion site frequencies are strongly correlated with recombination rates. Gene density does not fully explain the chromosomal distribution of Mu insertion and recombination sites, because pronounced preferences for the distal portion of chromosome are still observed even after accounting for gene density. The similarity of the distributions of Mu insertions and meiotic recombination sites suggests that common features, such as chromatin structure, are involved in site selection for both Mu insertion and meiotic recombination. The finding that Mu insertions and meiotic recombination sites both concentrate in genomic regions marked with epigenetic marks of open chromatin provides support for the hypothesis that open chromatin enhances rates of both Mu insertion and meiotic recombination.     

Reactivation of the Mutator transposable element system following gamma irradiation of seed

Summary The bz2-mu1 allele contains a 1.4 kb Mu element insertion in the open reading frame of the bronze-2 locus. This insertion suppresses gene activity. In an active Mutator line, however, the bz2-mu1 allele shows high somatic instability resulting in numerous purple spots of full gene activity against a beige background in the aleurone tissue of the kernel; restoration of gene activity results from excision of the Mu element. In contrast, in plants with an inactive Mutator system, uniformly bronze kernels are found, and the Mu element at bz2-mu1 is stabilized. Accompanying a loss of somatic instability, this Mu element, as well as the Mu elements elsewhere in the genome, have an increased level of DNA modification. Spontaneous reactivation of somatic instability in inactive Mutator lines rarely occurs; however, reactivation can be induced with gamma irradiation. Reactivated plants regain both the spotted kernel phenotype indicative of element excision from the bz2-mu1 reporter allele and diagnostic restriction sites within the Mu elements indicative of a hypomethylated state. The reactivated plants transmit these characters to their progeny. These data support the hypothesis that genomic shock can elicit cryptic transposable element activities in maize. Possible mechanisms for inactivation and reactivation of the Mutator transposable element system are also discussed.     

Characterization of the maize Mutator transposable element MURA transposase as a DNA-binding protein.

The autonomous MuDR element of the Mutator (Mu) transposable element family of maize encodes at least two proteins, MURA and MURB. Based on amino acid sequence similarity, previous studies have reported that MURA is likely to be a transposase. The functional characterization of MURA has been hindered by the instability of its cDNA, mudrA, in Escherichia coli. In this study, we report the first successful stabilization and expression of MURA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Gel mobility shift assays demonstrate that MURA is a DNA-binding protein that specifically binds to sequences within the highly conserved Mu element terminal inverted repeats (TIRs). DNase I and 1,10-phenanthroline-copper footprinting of MURA-Mu1 TIR complexes indicate that MURA binds to a conserved approximately 32-bp region in the TIR of Mu1. In addition, MURA can bind to the same region in the TIRs of all tested actively transposing Mu elements but binds poorly to the diverged Mu TIRs of inactive elements. Previous studies have reported a correlation between Mu transposon inactivation and methylation of the Mu element TIRs. Gel mobility shift assays demonstrate that MURA can interact differentially with unmethylated, hemimethylated, and homomethylated TIR substrates. The significance of MURA's interaction with the TIRs of Mu elements is discussed in the context of what is known about the regulation and mechanisms of Mutator activities in maize.     

A novel nuclear factor, SREB, binds to a cis-acting element, SRE, required for inducible expression of the Aspergillus oryzae Taka-amylase A gene in A. nidulans

The Taka-amylase A gene (taaG2) of Aspergillus oryzae is inducibly expressed in A. nidulans upon exposure to inducing carbon sources, such as starch and maltose. In order to identify nuclear factor(s) possibly involved in the induction of the taaG2 gene, gel mobility shift assays and DNase I footprinting analyses were carried out, and revealed a novel nuclear factor in A. nidulans extracts, which specifically bound to two sites in the taaG2 promoter region, −204 to −189 and −182 to −168, which share the common sequence GGAAATT. The nuclear factor was detected in nuclei from both induced and uninduced mycelia. Mutational analysis within and around the binding sequences demonstrated that only the upstream binding sequence, designated SRE (starch responsive element), was required for the inducible expression of the taaG2 gene, and thus we designated the nuclear factor SREB (SRE binding factor). The downstream binding site contained an inverted SRE (ISRE) and played no role in the induction of taaG2 expression. SREB was shown by gel retardation assays to have higher affinity for SRE than for ISRE. Received: 26 January 1999 / Accepted: 10 November 1999     

Binding sites for maize nuclear proteins in the subterminal regions of the transposable elementActivator

Genetic data suggest that transposition of the maize elementActivator (Ac) is modulated by host factors. Using gel retardation and DNase I protection assays we identified maize proteins which bind to seven subterminal sites in both ends ofAc. Four DNase I-protected sites contain a GGTAAA sequence, the other three include either GATAAA or GTTAAA. The specificity of the maize protein binding toAc was verified by using a synthetic fragment containing four GGTAAA motifs as probe and competitor in gel retardation assays. All seven binding sites are located within regions requiredin cis for transposition. A maize protein binding site with the same sequence has previously been identified in the terminal inverted repeats of the maizeMutator element. Thus, the protein, that recognizes this sequence is a good candidate for a regulatory host factor forAc transposition.     

Covalent DNA modification and the regulation of Mutator element transposition in maize

Summary Analyses of the multiple genomic Mu transposable elements in active Mutator lines with several C-methylation sensitive restriction enzymes indicate that Mu elements are undermodified compared with total maize nuclear DNA. Intercrossing of diverse Mutator lines leads to a discrete hypermodification of the Mu elements in a particular plant concurrent with a loss of mutagenic and transpositional potential. The modification events observed appear to be methylation of cytosine at the 5 position in the sequences 5-CG-3 and 5-CNG-3. Some potential C-methylation sites in Mu elements show a higher degree of methylation than others. Once established, the modified Mu state, like the loss of Mutator activity, is stable on outcrossing. Crosses between active Mutator lines with unmodified Mu elements and Mutator-loss lines with modified Mu elements show partial maternal dominance for the modification event. Mutator activity may also be lost thorugh outcrossing in a mechanism not associated with any detected modification events.     

The right end of MudI(Ap,lac)

Stable derivatives of the bacteriophage MudI(Ap,lac) were used to generate operon fusions in S. typhimurium which exhibit a sectoring phenotype with respect to lacZ expression. The Lac^- to Lac⁺ conversion was shown to be the result of small deletions involving the right end of the MudI element. DNA sequence analysis of several different fusions revealed that this end of MudI(Ap,lac) contains an assymetric inverted repeat of the attR site found in the wild-type Mu phage. A model is presented which explains how such a structure was formed in the construction of MudI(Ap,lac). In addition, this model explains the observed deletion formation and the Lac^- to Lac⁺ conversion in the sectoring fusions.This paper is dedicated to our padrinos, John and Marge Ingraham, whose love of truth has served us as constant inspiration     

Genetic studies on the loss of mu mutator activity in maize

Mutator activity of the Mu mutator system of maize can be lost by either outcrossing or inbreeding Mu stocks. The nature of these two kinds of Mu-loss phenomena was analyzed by testing the results of crossing Mu-loss stocks by active Mu lines. Outcross- Mu-loss stocks are capable of supporting Mu activity if crossed by an active mutator line. Inbred-Mu-loss stocks, however, inactivate the active Mu system contributed by a Mu line. Also, inbred- Mu-loss lines do not regain Mu activity after at least three generations of outcrossing to non-Mu stocks. These results suggest that, once the Mu system is inactivated by inbreeding, it remains inactivated for at least three generations of outcrossing. Further, once the system responsible for inactivation is established, it will, in turn, inactivate an active Mu system contributed by crossing with Mu plants. The outcross-Mu-loss does not seem to involve such an inactivation system. These results are interpreted in the light of recent evidence that Mu inactivation results from the modification of Mu 1 transposable elements involved in the Mu phenotype.     

Genetic analyses of putative two-element systems regulating somatic mutability in Mutator-induced aleurone mutants of maize

The Mutator transposable element system (Mu) of maize has been responsible for the induction of numerous mutable aleurone mutants of maize. Unlike similar mutants induced by other transposable element systems, the mutability of Mu-induced mutants did not seem initially to be regulated by an independent autonomous or regulator element. However, in a continuing study of two Mu-induced a1 mutable mutants (a1-Mum2) and a1-Mum3, lines have been obtained that give evidence of an independently segregating regulator of somatic mutability. Data from several generations of crossing are presented indicating that intense somatic mutability in many of these stocks is under the control of an independent regulator. However, testing of other lines, which initially gave evidence of the presence of an independent regulator, were negative. Some of these latter lines could be expected to have Mutator elements that were modified (methylated) at sites recognized by certain restriction endonucleases. Modification of Mu elements, which is known to affect the expression of somatic mutability, might, at times, be responsible for producing conditions that mimic the segregation of an independent regulator. Lines with stable derivatives of the a1-Mum2 and a1-Mum3 can recover intense somatic mutability by crossing with germinally active Mutator stocks. Thus, active Mutator lines contain regulator elements and evidence is presented suggesting that such lines have multiple copies of these elements. Most a1- Mum2 and a1-Mum3 stocks segregating for a regulator do not have germinal Mutator activity. Thus the presence of one or a few putative regulator elements does not necessarily account for the high level of germinal activity in most Mutator stocks.     

Reevaluation of the role of auxin binding site II

Binding of 1-naphthylacetic acid (1-NAA) was assayed in microsomal membranes from Zea mays coleoptiles and from hypocotyls of Cucurbita pepo. Auxin binding site II was differentiated from site I binding by using phenylacetic acid (PAA) to saturate site I binding capacity. The amount of type-II binding sites, per gram original fresh weight, was 34 pmol with Zea and 6.4 pmol with Cucurbita. When maize membranes were separated by dextran gradient centrifugation, auxin binding site II migrated coincident with tonoplast marker enzymes. The physiologically active auxin 4-chloroindoleacetic acid (4-Cl-IAA) competed very poorly with 1-NAA binding to both site I and site II. This result suggests that sites I and II are not involved in the regulation of growth. When comparing isolated outer epidermis with intact coleoptile of Zea, similar amounts and ratios of site I and site II binding activities were observed.