Effect of freezing and freeze-drying on the viability and storage of Lilium longiflorum L. and Zea mays L. pollen

The freeze-preservation of pollen is dependent on the interaction of several factors such as freezing rate, thawing rate, freeze-drying temperature and duration, storage temperature and environment and rehydration rates. Changes in any of these variables affects the others directly or indirectly.Rapid freezing of pollen at rates of approximately 200 °C/min maintains the highest degree of viable pollen in combination with rapid thawing rates of 218 °C/min. Rapid cooling and slow rewarming resulted in a substantial loss of pollen viability. This might indicate that intracellular ice crystals formed during rapid cooling perhaps grow into larger ice masses during slow rewarming or storage at temperatures above ?50 °C.The germinability of pollen freeze-dried at temperatures below ?50 °C was also prolonged over that of the controls. Germination values for unfrozen pollen stored for 30 days at 0–5 °C averaged 50% for lily and 20% for corn. Freeze-dried pollen stored for 30 days at the same temperature yielded considerably higher viability percentages for both lily and corn pollen. Drying time is an important factor, perhaps indicating that residual moisture is critical. Freeze-dried pollen can be stored at higher temperatures than frozen and control pollen. Freeze-dried material stored for five months at 0–5 °C, upon slow rehydration yielded intact grains which has average germination percentages of 25 for lily and 15 for corn. The same pollen upon rapid rehydration showed rupturing of 20–40% of the cells and practically no germination.     

Hemolysis in several animal species after rapid freezing of blood

The effect of various freezing rates on the extent of hemolysis in human, bovine and ovine erythrocytes, which are known to have different cell volumes, water contents and permeabilities, was investigated. Blood in stainless steel capillary tubes was frozen at various rates by abrupt immersion of the capillaries into cooling baths at temperatures ranging from ?20° to ?130°C. Minimum lysis values were obtained at freezing temperatures of ?40°, ?50° and ?70°C with, respectively, human, bovine and ovine blood. The smallest, highly permeable sheep erythrocytes were the least damaged at the highest freezing rates; the largest human cells with the highest water content, suffered the greatest damage; intermediate values were obtained with ox blood. At the lower freezing rates, the largest, human cells were the least damaged; the highest hemolysis values were obtained with the smallest, highly permeable sheep erythrocytes; ox blood again gave intermediate values. These results are in agreement with current views that, (1) very rapid freezing results in the formation of damaging intracellular ice; (2) injury associated with slow freezing is related to the extent of dehydration or to the increase in electrolyte concentration which accompanies ice formation; (3) minimum hemolysis is obtained under those freezing conditions in which osmotic dehydration has been sufficient to prevent the formation of intracellular ice, but has left enough water in the cells to prevent the damaging effects of dehydration and high electrolyte concentrations.     

PVP contrasted with dextran and a multifactor theory of cryoprotection

Washed human erythrocytes were suspended in 0, 5, 10, 15, and 20% PVP in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS). Fifty lambda samples were frozen in alcohol baths at temperatures ranging from ?10 ° to ?80 °C. The specimens were frozen either for 1 or 16 min, rapidly thawed, and resuspended in PBS or PBS plus PVP. Percent hemolysis was determined colorimetrically. Results indicate that there is a high degree of latent damage when red cells are frozen in the presence of PVP. This damage is evident from the large increase in hemolysis when freeze-thawed, intact red cells are resuspended in the PBS. Under some circumstances 16 min freezing is significantly less damaging than 1 min freezing. This indicates a partial recovery from the freezing stress during subzero storage of the red cells.The general cryoprotective properties of PVP were described in terms of: (1) latent damage; (2) storage damage; (3) optimal cooling and rewarming rates (as a function of freezing bath temperature); (4) optimum PVP concentration; and (5) post-thaw cryoprotection. The data were compared with that from a similar study using dextran-40. This comparison indicated six similarities and ten differences in the cryoprotective properties of dextran and PVP. The remarkable differences between dextran and PVP was counted as an important common characteristics of macromolecular cryoprotective agents. That is, their cryoproteetive properties cannot be reduced to one or a few physical characteristics held in common. Nine other common characteristics were listed. Several of these, which include latent damage and recovery from latent damage, cannot be explained by current theories of cryoprotection. A multifactor theory was proposed to account for these ten common features of macromolecular cryoprotective agents.     

Hemolysis of human red blood cells by freezing and thawing in solutions containing sucrose: relationship with posthypertonic hemolysis and solute movements

Human red blood cells were frozen at temperatures down to ?9 °C in solutions containing sucrose, and the hemolysis on thawing was measured. This was compared with the hemolysis caused by exposing the cells to high concentrations of sucrose and then resuspending them in more dilute solutions at 4 °C. The effects of the hypertonic solutions of sucrose on potassium, sodium, and sucrose movements were also investigated. It was found that sucrose does not prevent damage to the cells by very hypertonic solutions (whether during freezing and thawing or at 4 °C) but it does reduce hemolysis of cells previously exposed to these solutions if present in the resuspension (or thawing) solution. Evidence is presented that the damaging effects of the hypertonic solutions of sucrose occurring during freezing are associated with changes in cell membrane permeability but that posthypertonic hemolysis is not primarily associated with a “loading” of the cells with extracellular solutes in the hypertonic phase. It is concluded that sucrose may reduce hemolysis of red blood cells by slow freezing and thawing by reducing colloid osmotic swelling of cells with abnormally permeable membranes.     

Survival of frozen mouse embryos after rapid thawing from -196 degrees C.

The effect of the rate of rewarming on the survival of 8-cell mouse embryos and blastocysts was examined. The samples were slowly cooled (0.3--0.6 degrees C/min) in 1.5 M-DMSO to temperatures between -10 and -80 degrees C before direct transfer to liquid nitrogen (-196 degrees C). Embryos survived rapid thawing (275--500 degrees C/min) only when slow cooling was terminated at relatively high subzero temperatures (-10 to -50 degrees C). The highest levels of survival in vitro of rapidly thawed 8-cell embryos were obtained after transfer to -196 degrees C from -35 and -40 degrees C (72 to 88%) and of rapidly thawed blastocysts after transfer from -25 to -50 degrees C (69 to 74%). By contrast, for embryos to survive slow thawing (8 to 20 degrees C/min) slow cooling to lower subzero temperatures (-60 degrees C and below) was required before transfer to -196 degrees C. The results indicate that embryos transferred to -196 degrees C from high subzero temperatures contain sufficient intracellular ice to damage them during slow warming but to permit survival after rapid warming. Survival of embryos after rapid dilution of DMSO at room temperature was similar to that after slow (stepwise) dilution at 0 degrees C. There was no difference between the viability of rapidly and slowly thawed embryos after transfer to pseudopregnant foster mothers. It is concluded that the behaviour of mammalian embryos subjected to the stresses of freezing and thawing is similar to that of other mammalian cells. A simpler and quicker method for the preservation of mouse embryos is described.     

Hemolysis of human red blood cells by freezing and thawing in solutions containing polyvinylpyrrolidone: relationship with postthypertonic hemolysis and solute movements

An investigation was made into the effects of the presence of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) on changes in human red blood cells suspended in hypertonic solutions, on posthypertonic hemolysis, and on freezing at temperatures down to ?12 °C.PVP is very effective at reducing hemolysis when the red blood cells are frozen at temperatures down to ?12 °C. However, the membranes of the cells recovered on thawing have become very permeable to sodium and potassium ions and there is a much increased hemolysis if the cells are resuspended in an isotonic solution of sodium chloride.The presence of PVP does not affect the dehydration of the cells or the development of a change in membrane permeability when the cells are shrunken in hypertonic solutions at 0 °C. Neither does its presence in the hypertonic solution reduce the extent of posthypertonic hemolysis at 4 °C (as measured by the hemolysis on resuspension in an isotonic solution of sodium chloride), but it is more effective than sucrose at reducing hemolysis when present in the resuspension solution. It is concluded that the PVP is able to prevent swelling and hemolysis of cells which are very permeable to cations by opposing the colloid osmotic pressure due to the hemoglobin. However, this does not explain how PVP is able to protect cells against freezing damage at high cooling rates, and a mechanism by which it might do this is discussed.     

Use of two-step cooling procedures to examine factors influencing cell survival following freezing and thawing

The two-step cooling procedure has been used to investigate factors involved in cell injury. Chinese hamster fibroblasts frozen in dimethylsulphoxide (5%, $\text{v}\text{v}$) were studied. Survival was measured using a cell colony assay and simultaneous observations of cellular shrinkage and the localization of intracellular ice were done by an ultrastructural examination of freeze-substituted samples.Correlations were obtained between survival and shrinkage at the holding temperature. However, cells shrunken at ?25 °C for 10 min (the optimal conditions for survival on rapid thawing from ?196 °C) contain intracellular ice nuclei at ?196 °C detectable by recrystallization. These ice nuclei only form below ?80 °C and prevent recovery on slow or interrupted thawing but not on rapid thawing. Cells shrunken at ?35 °C for 10 min (just above the temperature at which intracellular ice forms in the majority of rapidly cooled cells) can tolerate even slow thawing from ?196 °C, suggesting that they contain very few or no ice nuclei even in liquid nitrogen. Damage may correlate with the total amount of ice formed per cell rather than the size of individual crystals, and we suggest that injury occurs during rewarming and is osmotic in nature.     

Cryopreservation of mouse oocytes using a medium with low sodium content: effect of plunge temperature

The effect of various combinations of plunge temperature and thawing protocol on the survival and viability of mouse oocytes was examined. The oocytes were frozen either in a standard freezing medium (ETFM, embryo transfer freezing medium) or in a low-sodium, choline-based freezing medium (CJ2), with 1.5 M 1,2-propanediol and 0.1 M sucrose, and using a conventional slow cooling method. The criteria used to assess survival were morphological state after thawing (intact or lysed), ability to become fertilized, and ability to develop to the two-cell, morula, and blastocyst stage in vitro. Oocytes frozen in CJ2 and plunged into liquid nitrogen (LN(2)) from -10, -20, or -33 degrees C remained intact and developed to the blastocyst stage at significantly higher rates than oocytes frozen in ETFM. For oocytes plunged into LN(2) from -33 degrees C, very rapid thawing (10 s in 30 degrees C water) was more detrimental than rapid or slow thawing (holding in air at room temperature for 10 or 30 s, respectively, prior to submersion in water at 30 degrees C for 10 s). By contrast, oocytes plunged into LN(2) from -10 or -20 degrees C survived better when thawing was very rapid or rapid than when thawing was slow. With the current protocol CJ2 was very effective over a wide range of plunge temperatures (-20 to -33 degrees C), although the optimal thawing protocol depended on the particular plunge temperature. Over 90% of oocytes surviving after slow cooling in CJ2 to -33 degrees C could be plunged to -196 degrees C with little or no further damage.     

Survival of tissue culture cells frozen by a two-step procedure to -196 degrees C. I. Holding temperature and time.

A two-step freezing procedure has been examined in order to separate some of the causes of damage following freezing and thawing. Different holding temperatures and times have been studied during the freezing of Chinese hamster tissue culture cells in dimethyl sulphoxide (5%, $\text{v}\text{v}$). Damage following rapid cooling to, time at, and thawing from different holding temperatures was found to increase at lower holding temperatures and at longer times. Damage on subsequent cooling from the holding temperature to ?196 °C and thawing was found to diminish at lower holding temperatures and longer times. The net result was that optimal survival from ?196 °C was obtained after 10 min at ?25 °C. Protection against the second step of cooling to ?196 °C was acquired at the holding temperature itself and was absent at ?15 °C without freezing.It seems that this technique will allow the different phases of freezing injury to be separated. These phases may include thermal shock to the holding temperature, hypertonic damage at the holding temperature and dilution shock on thawing from ?196 °C.     

Freezing damage of bovine erythrocytes: Simulation using glycerol concentration changes at subzero temperatures

When a cell is frozen and thawed, it is exposed to (i) lowered temperature, (ii) increased solute concentration during freezing, and (iii) decreased solute concentration during thawing. Without actually freezing the cells, an attempt has been made to simulate physical-chemical changes to which bovine erythrocytes are exposed when frozen and thawed in glycerol solutions. Experimentally, the study consisted of suspending erythrocytes in 1, 2, or 3 glycerol at 20 °C for various times and then exposing them to each of several dilution sequences. The dilution sequences were: (i) transfer from the initial glycerol concentration at 20 °C into the same concentration at −5 °C, (ii) transfer into an increased glycerol concentration at 20 °C, (iii) transfer into an increased followed by a decreased glycerol concentration at 20 °C, (iv) transfer into an increased glycerol concentration at −5 °C, and (v) transfer into an increased followed by a decreased glycerol concentration at −5 °C. This last sequence is analogous to the exposure that cells undergo at subzero temperatures to increased solute concentration during freezing and decreased solute concentration during thawing. This dilution sequence yielded a survival pattern very similar to that obtained when bovine erythrocytes are frozen and thawed, and thus does appear to mimic freezing damage. It is concluded that a major factor in freezing damage is the extent to which a cell must shrink or swell to achieve osmotic equilibrium at subzero temperatures in partially frozen or thawed solutions.     

Freezing injury to erythrocytes. II. Morphological alterations of cell membranes.

Morphological alterations of human red blood cell membranes were examined with the cells containing different concentrations of glycerol being subjected to rapid rates of cooling, approximately 10⁴ and 10⁵ °C/min, and subsequent rewarming. Small membrane defects, similar to holes, were observed in specimens frozen with and without 10% glycerol. Various degrees of roughness were found on the surface of the cells at all freezing rates tested. The membrane alterations were reduced with increasing glycerol concentration, although roughness also appeared on the surface of the cells in 30% glycerol suspensions, frozen rapidly, and rewarmed to ?80 or ?60 °C. The cell membrane surface texture correlated with the growth of intra- and extracellular ice particles. There was also a positive correlation between these alterations and post-thaw hemolysis. It is concluded, therefore, that morphological alterations appearing on the erythrocyte membranes may be a manifestation of freezing damage.     

Viability and Morphology of rat heart cells after freezing and thawing of the whole heart

Intact adult rat hearts were cooled in the presence of 10% DMSO according to an external cooling program which approximated the optimal external three-step cooling program for the isolated adult heart cells: 20 min at ?20 °C, 0.2 °C/min from ?20 to ?25, ?30, or ?50 °C, and rapid cooling to ?196 °C. Following rapid thawing, cells were isolated after perfusion with a 0.1% collagenase solution. Only cells which originated from the free wall of the right ventricle could be isolated, even after cooling to ?20 °C. Most cells from hearts cooled to ?196 °C did not survive. When the third cooling step was omitted and the end temperature of the second cooling step was ?30 °C, 38% of the cells excluded trypan blue, 29% were morphologically intact, and 30% showed spontaneous contractions after thawing, expressed as percentages of the control, A much lower survival was found after cooling to ?50 °C.Histological and electron microscopical study of the heart immediately after thawing revealed no differences between hearts cooled to ?20, ?30, or ?196 °C. Also no marked differences were observed between the morphological integrity after freezing and thawing of the atrium, the left and right ventricle walls, and the ventricular septum. The survival data suggest the presence of nonmorphologically detectable alterations in cells frozen to ?196 °C, compared to cells frozen to ?30 °C. The morphological investigations indicate no essential differences in resistance of atrial and ventricular cells to the freezing process.Experiments involving neonatal rat hearts cooled to ?196 °C, according to the method which gave optimal preservation of the isolated cells, revealed that after thawing cells are present from which growing and contracting cultures can be derived. It appears that cells in the neonatal rat heart are more resistant to freezing to ?196 °C than cells in the adult rat heart.     

Survival of tissue culture cells frozen by a two-step procedure to -196 degrees C. II. Warming rate and concentration of dimethyl sulphoxide.

Chinese hamster tissue culture cells in dimethyl sulphoxide (5%) required a lower holding temperature (?35 °C) for optimal survival on slow warming from ?196 °C using a two-step cooling schedule, compared with that required (?25 °C) when warming was rapid. A lower concentration of dimethyl sulphoxide (1%) did not affect the “protection” against damage on cooling from the holding temperature to ?196 °C and thawing. The results suggest that protective agents allow cells to be cooled initially to the holding temperature and minimize damage at the holding temperature. Damage following subsequent cooling and thawing may thus occur mainly as dilution shock on rewarming. This can be minimized by allowing the cells to shrink at the holding temperature.     

Interaction of rate of latent heat removal during freezing and rates of subsequent cooling and warming on survival of the blood protozoan, Babesia rodhaini

Babesia rodhaini parasites in murine blood containing 1.5 m DMSO were frozen at two rates, as judged by the duration of the “freezing plateau”, then cooled to ?196 °C and rewarmed at two rates to detect interactions between the duration of the plateau and rates of subsequent cooling and rewarming. Infectivity tests showed that fast and slow freezing (plateau times of about 1 sec and 30 sec, respectively) had similar effects on parasite survival when cooling was at 130 °C/min and warming was at 800 °C/min. However, when either the cooling rate was increased to 3500 °C/min or the warming rate was decreased to 2.3 °C/min, fast freezing decreased parasite survival more than did slow freezing. It is suggested that fast freezing accentuated the damaging effects of fast cooling and slow warming by increasing intracellular ice formation.     

Membrane leakage of solutes after thermal shock or freezing

Washed human erythrocytes were cooled at different rates from +37 °C to 0 °C in hypertonic solutions of either NaCl (1.2 m) or of a mixture of sucrose (40% $\text{w}\text{v}$) with NaCl (2.53% $\text{w}\text{v}$). Thermal shock hemolysis was measured and the surviving cells were examined for their mass and cell water content and also for net movements of sodium, potassium, and ¹⁴C-sucrose. The results were compared with those obtained from cells in sucrose (40% $\text{w}\text{v}$) initially, cooled at different rates to ?196 °C and rapidly thawed.The cells cooled to 0 °C in NaCl (1.2 m) showed maximal hemolysis at the fastest cooling rate studied (39 °C/min). In addition in the surviving cells this cooling rate induced the greatest uptake of ¹⁴C-sucrose and increase in cell water and cell mass and also entry of sodium and loss of cell potassium. A different dependence on cooling rate was seen with the cells cooled from +37 °C to 0 °C in sucrose (40% $\text{w}\text{v}$) with NaCl (2.53% $\text{w}\text{v}$). In this solution, survival decreased both at slow and fast cooling rates correlating with the greatest uptake of cell sucrose and increase in cell water. There was extensive loss of cell potassium and uptake of sodium at all cooling rates, the cation concentrations across the cell membrane approaching unity.The cells frozen to ?196 °C at different cooling rates in sucrose (40% $\text{w}\text{v}$) initially, also showed sucrose and water entry on thawing together with a loss of cell potassium and an uptake of cell sodium. More sucrose entered the cells cooled slowly (1.8 ° C/min) than those cooled rapidly (318 ° C/min).These results show that cooling to 0 °C in hypertonic solutions (thermal shock) and freezing to ?196 °C both induce membrane leaks to sucrose as well as to sodium and potassium. These leaks are not induced by the hypertonic solutions themselves but are due to the effects of the added stress of the temperature reduction on the membranes modified by the hypertonic solutions. The effects of cooling rate are explicable in terms of the different times of exposure to the hypertonic solutions. These results indicate that the damage observed after thermal shock or slow freezing is of a similar nature.     

Biological activity of Friend spleen focus-forming virus after cold storage

Two stocks of Friend spleen focus-forming virus (SFFV) were prepared, one in saline and the other in Eagle's medium with 2% fetal calf serum, and the effects of different freezing, storage and thawing temperatures were determined for the recovery of infectious virus from each diluent. Once frozen, virus maintained its titer at ?70 and at ?170 °C for up to 13 weeks, while it lost titer at ?13 °C more rapidly if it had been prepared in saline than in medium. However, during the freezing process lower ambient temperatures (?70 and ?170 °C) gave lower virus yields than a higher temperature (?13 °C) did. Similarly, rapid thawing (in a 37 °C water bath) was less efficient than slow thawing (in 4 or 20 °C air) for the recovery of infectious SFFV, This study illustrates the importance, for efficient recovery of leukemogenic activity from stored murine leukemia virus stocks, of the temperature used for freezing or thawing, as well as for storage.     

A comparative study of the effects of freezing and frozen storage on intact and demembranated bull spermatozoa

The damage caused to bull sperm by freezing and thawing them without cryoprotectants was assessed in both intact and membrane-extracted cells. Preparations of membrane-extracted cells were produced by treating the sperm with 0.1% Triton X-100 and motility was restored with exogenously applied ATP and Mg²⁺. Motile demembranated sperm showed no detectable reduction in motility after freezing and thawing. In contrast, when intact cells where subjected to freezing and thawing they lost all motility. These damaged cells were also restored to motility when exogenous ATP and Mg²⁺ were added to the sperm mixture. Apparently freezing and thawing sperm cells causes damage to the plasma membrane which permits ATP and Mg²⁺ to freely enter or leave the cells, but does not damage the components of the sperm cell which generate motility.The effects of storage temperature on frozen demembranated sperm were also explored. Sperm held at ?20 °C showed marked structural changes and progressively decreased motility after prolonged storage. When sperm were frozen at ?20 °C the mitochondrial structures were completely lost after 48 to 72 hr and ATP caused the disintegration of the flagellum rather than initiating motility. Sperm which were frozen at ?76 °C retained motility after short periods of storage, but showed a significant decline in motility when thawed after 8 days. Demembranated sperm which were kept frozen at ?196 °C showed no significant loss of motility when thawed after 1 year of storage.     

The mechanism of cryohemolysis: by direct observation with the cryomicroscope and the electron microscope.

Blood films (3–8 μm thick) supported between two glass coverslips were frozen to ?20 °C. In the extracellular areas, ice cavities of the order of 0.2 μm separated by bands of dense plasma were evident when examined with the electron microscope; intracellular ice was not observed with the light microscope. Electron microscopy also showed the presence of intracellular ice particles of the order of 0.2–0.7 μm, these appeared as fine reticulations when observed with the light microscope. Upon gradual rewarming the following changes were observed: recrystallization in the extracellular matrix (?18 to ?8 °C), intracellular recrystallization (?13 to ?10 °C), transfer of water from erythrocytes to extracellular areas (?9 to ?7 °C), and melting and hemolysis (?6 to ?2 °C).Freezing of blood at ?3 °C and subsequent thawing did not cause hemolysis of the red cells. In blood frozen at ?3 °C and cooled to ?20 °C or frozen by abrupt exposure to 20 °C the erythrocytes hemolyzed in 7/16–11/16 of a second, whereas in blood frozen at ?3 °C and cooled to ?10 °C the cells hemolyzed in 5–15 sec even though the mode if lysis (i.e., uniform seepage of hemoglobin from the surface of the cell) was similar in all cases. This indicates that the presence of intracellular ice does not seem to play a major role in the injury to the erythrocytes. The mechanism of cryoinjury demonstrated by hemolysis has been discussed.     

Protein-bound SH groups in frozen-thawed egg cells of the sea urchin

Unfertilized egg cells of the sea urchin St. intermedius could survive slow freezing to ?15 °C for a short period of time, but at the same freezing temperature extracellular freezing became fatal within a few hours. Such freezing injury resulted in “black” or “white” cytolysis in frozen-thawed cells. “Black” cytolysis took place in the process of both freezing and thawing, while “white” cytolysis occurred only on thawing. Rapid rewarming consistently produced “white” cytolysis in extracellularly frozen cells. The observed behavior of the injured cells during freeze-thawing appeared favorable for the explanation of freezing injury by the SH-SS hypothesis. Protein-bound SH groups were quantitatively determined in both whole cell and cortex with plasma membrane before and after freeze-thawing. However, no significant change in the SH value was observed between freeze-thaw cytolysed materials and unfrozen ones.