Coupling Sequence-specific Recognition to DNA Modification

Enzymes that modify DNA are faced with significant challenges in specificity for both substrate binding and catalysis. We describe how single hydrogen bonds between M.HhaI, a DNA cytosine methyltransferase, and its DNA substrate regulate the positioning of a peptide loop which is ∼28 Å away. Stopped-flow fluorescence measurements of a tryptophan inserted into the loop provide real-time observations of conformational rearrangements. These long-range interactions that correlate with substrate binding and critically, enzyme turnover, will have broad application to enzyme specificity and drug design for this medically relevant class of enzymes.Sequence-specific modification of DNA is essential for nearly all forms of life and contributes to a myriad of biological processes including gene regulation, mismatch repair, host defense, DNA replication, and genetic imprinting. Methylation of cytosine and adenine bases is a key epigenetic process whereby phenotypic changes are inherited without altering the DNA sequence (1). The central role of the bacterial and mammalian S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet)²-dependent DNA methyltransferases in virulence regulation and tumorigenesis, respectively, have led these enzymes to be validated targets for antibiotic and cancer therapies (2, 3). However, AdoMet-dependent enzymes catalyze diverse reactions, and the design of potent and selective DNA methyltransferase inhibitors is particularly challenging (4, 5). The design of drugs that bind outside the active site is a particularly attractive means of inhibition for enzymes with common cofactors like AdoMet because off-target inhibition often leads to toxicity (6). Unfortunately, robust methods to identify and characterize such critical binding sites distal from the active site have not been developed.DNA methyltransferases bind to a particular DNA sequence, stabilize the target base into an extrahelical position within the enzyme active site, and transfer the methyl moiety from AdoMet to the DNA (7). During this process, dramatic changes in the DNA structure such as bending, base flipping, or the intercalation of residues into the recognition sequence are often accompanied by large scale protein rearrangements (8). Here we characterized a specific conformational rearrangement of M.HhaI, a model DNA cytosine C⁵ methyltransferase with a cognate recognition sequence of 5′-GCGC-3′. Many structures of M.HhaI are available at high resolution including an ensemble of complexes with either cognate or nonspecific DNA (9, 10). Reorganization of an essential catalytic loop (residues 80–100) is regulated by sequence-specific protein-DNA interactions that occur ∼28 Å away from the catalytic loop (Fig. 1). Our work quantifies the importance of such distal communication in sequence-specific DNA modification and provides plausible structural mechanisms.Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.Loop interactions in M.HhaI. A, two superimposed structures of M.HhaI are shown with the catalytic loop highlighted. Enzymes are in blue (open conformer) and red (closed conformer) with the cofactor in orange, the flipped cytosine in green, and position 1 of the DNA recognition sequence colored by atom along with Cys-81, Ile-86, and Arg-240. The large blue arrow shows the long-range structural communication between Arg-240 and the catalytic loop. B, close-up of the interactions between Arg-240, Ile-86, and position 1 of the recognition sequence. The flipped cytosine is in green. Removal of N² from the guanosine with an inosine base maintains near cognate loop motion while removal of O⁶ with a 2AP base has almost no loop motion.DNA-dependent positioning of the catalytic loop in M.HhaI was first observed crystallographically; cognate DNA stabilizes the loop-closed conformer, while nonspecific DNA leaves the loop in the open conformer (9, 10). Correct positioning of this loop is essential for catalysis because C81, the active site nucleophile that attacks the target cytosine base at the C⁶ position (supplemental Fig. S1), is ∼9.6 Å away in the loop-open conformer (Fig. 1A). Populating the closed conformer of the loop is essential for tight DNA binding and stabilizing the target cytosine that is flipped out of the DNA duplex (11–13). Using stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy to monitor the environment of tryptophan (Trp) residues inserted into the catalytic loop, we recently observed reorganization of this loop upon DNA binding in the absence of cofactor using the M.HhaI mutants W41F, W41F/K91W, and W41F/E94W (12). Loop positioning and the interconversion between the open and closed conformers, as determined from the intensities and rates of change in fluorescence signal are highly dependent on DNA sequence and confirm that cognate DNA stabilizes the loop-closed conformer whereas nonspecific DNA stabilizes the open conformer.In this study, W41F/K91W and W41F/E94W M.HhaI were preincubated with cognate (COG), non-cognate (NC), or nonspecific (NS) DNA and mixed with cofactor or cofactor product, AdoMet and S-adenosylhomocysteine (AdoHcy), respectively, in a stopped-flow apparatus. Differences in observed fluorescence intensity are indicative of shifts in the populations of the various loop conformers; no observable fluorescence change suggests no significant change in population and thus, essentially no loop positioning to the closed conformer. Non-cognate and cognate sequences are nearly identical but differ by a single base change, whereas the nonspecific DNA substrate has no similarity to the cognate sequence. As a methyltransferase searches for the cognate site within a genome, it must encounter both non-cognate and nonspecific DNA sequences and be able to distinguish these from the cognate sequence. We examine both binding, using the cofactor product AdoHcy, and catalysis, using the AdoMet cofactor of M.HhaI, with these various DNA substrates.     

Determinants of precatalytic conformational transitions in the DNA cytosine methyltransferase M.HhaI

The DNA methyltransferase M.HhaI is an excellent model for understanding how recognition of a nucleic acid substrate is translated into site-specific modification. In this study, we utilize direct, real-time monitoring of the catalytic loop position via engineered tryptophan fluorescence reporters to dissect the conformational transitions that occur in both enzyme and DNA substrate prior to methylation of the target cytosine. Using nucleobase analogues in place of the target and orphan bases, the kinetics of the base flipping and catalytic loop closure rates were determined, revealing that base flipping precedes loop closure as the rate-determining step prior to methyl transfer. To determine the mechanism by which individual specific hydrogen bond contacts at the enzyme-DNA interface mediate these conformational transitions, nucleobase analogues lacking hydrogen bonding groups were incorporated into the recognition sequence to disrupt the major groove recognition elements. The consequences of binding, loop closure, and catalysis were determined for four contacts, revealing large differences in the contribution of individual hydrogen bonds to DNA recognition and conformational transitions on the path to catalysis. Our results describe how M.HhaI utilizes direct readout contacts to accelerate extrication of the target base that offer new insights into the evolutionary history of this important class of enzymes.     

Engineered extrahelical base destabilization enhances sequence discrimination of DNA methyltransferase M.HhaI

Improved sequence specificity of the DNA cytosine methyltransferase HhaI was achieved by disrupting interactions at a hydrophobic interface between the active site of the enzyme and a highly conserved flexible loop. Transient fluorescence experiments show that mutations disrupting this interface destabilize the positioning of the extrahelical, "flipped" cytosine base within the active site. The ternary crystal structure of the F124A M.HhaI bound to cognate DNA and the cofactor analogue S-adenosyl-l-homocysteine shows an increase in cavity volume between the flexible loop and the core of the enzyme. This cavity disrupts the interface between the loop and the active site, thereby destabilizing the extrahelical target base. The favored partitioning of the base-flipped enzyme-DNA complex back to the base-stacked intermediate results in the mutant enzyme discriminating better than the wild-type enzyme against non-cognate sites. Building upon the concepts of kinetic proofreading and our understanding of M.HhaI, we describe how a 16-fold specificity enhancement achieved with a double mutation at the loop/active site interface is acquired through destabilization of intermediates prior to methyltransfer rather than disruption of direct interactions between the enzyme and the substrate for M.HhaI.     

The role of Arg165 towards base flipping, base stabilization and catalysis in M.HhaI

Arg165 forms part of a previously identified base flipping motif in the bacterial DNA cytosine methyltransferase, M.HhaI. Replacement of Arg165 with Ala has no detectable effect on either DNA or AdoMet affinity, yet causes the base flipping and restacking transitions to be decreased approximately 16 and 190-fold respectively, thus confirming the importance of this motif. However, these kinetic changes cannot account for the mutant's observed 10(5)-fold decreased catalytic rate. The mutant enzyme/cognate DNA cocrystal structure (2.79 A resolution) shows the target cytosine to be positioned approximately 30 degrees into the major groove, which is consistent with a major groove pathway for nucleotide flipping. The pyrimidine-sugar chi angle is rotated to approximately +171 degrees, from a range of -95 degrees to -120 degrees in B DNA, and -77 degrees in the WT M.HhaI complex. Thus, Arg165 is important for maintaining the cytosine positioned for nucleophilic attack by Cys81. The cytosine sugar pucker is in the C2'-endo-C3'-exo (South conformation), in contrast to the previously reported C3'-endo (North conformation) described for the original 2.70 A resolution cocrystal structure of the WT M.HhaI/DNA complex. We determined a high resolution structure of the WT M.HhaI/DNA complex (1.96 A) to better determine the sugar pucker. This new structure is similar to the original, lower resolution WT M.HhaI complex, but shows that the sugar pucker is O4'-endo (East conformation), intermediate between the South and North conformers. In summary, Arg165 plays significant roles in base flipping, cytosine positioning, and catalysis. Furthermore, the previously proposed M.HhaI-mediated changes in sugar pucker may not be an important contributor to the base flipping mechanism. These results provide insights into the base flipping and catalytic mechanisms for bacterial and eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases.     

Time-resolved fluorescence of 2-aminopurine as a probe of base flipping in M.HhaI-DNA complexes

DNA base flipping is an important mechanism in molecular enzymology, but its study is limited by the lack of an accessible and reliable diagnostic technique. A series of crystalline complexes of a DNA methyltransferase, M.HhaI, and its cognate DNA, in which a fluorescent nucleobase analogue, 2-aminopurine (AP), occupies defined positions with respect the target flipped base, have been prepared and their structures determined at higher than 2 Å resolution. From time-resolved fluorescence measurements of these single crystals, we have established that the fluorescence decay function of AP shows a pronounced, characteristic response to base flipping: the loss of the very short (~100 ps) decay component and the large increase in the amplitude of the long (~10 ns) component. When AP is positioned at sites other than the target site, this response is not seen. Most significantly, we have shown that the same clear response is apparent when M.HhaI complexes with DNA in solution, giving an unambiguous signal of base flipping. Analysis of the AP fluorescence decay function reveals conformational heterogeneity in the DNA–enzyme complexes that cannot be discerned from the present X-ray structures.     

Dynamic modes of the flipped-out cytosine during HhaI methyltransferase-DNA interactions in solution.

Flipping of a nucleotide out of a B-DNA helix into the active site of an enzyme has been observed for the HhaI and HaeIII cytosine-5 methyltransferases (M.HhaI and M.HaeIII) and for numerous DNA repair enzymes. Here we studied the base flipping motions in the binary M. HhaI-DNA and the ternary M.HhaI-DNA-cofactor systems in solution. Two 5-fluorocytosines were introduced into the DNA in the places of the target cytosine and, as an internal control, a cytosine positioned two nucleotides upstream of the recognition sequence 5'-GCGC-3'. The 19F NMR spectra combined with gel mobility data show that interaction with the enzyme induces partition of the target base among three states, i.e. stacked in the B-DNA, an ensemble of flipped-out forms and the flipped-out form locked in the enzyme active site. Addition of the cofactor analogue S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine greatly enhances the trapping of the target cytosine in the catalytic site. Distinct dynamic modes of the target cytosine have thus been identified along the reaction pathway, which includes novel base-flipping intermediates that were not observed in previous X-ray structures. The new data indicate that flipping of the target base out of the DNA helix is not dependent on binding of the cytosine in the catalytic pocket of M.HhaI, and suggest an active role of the enzyme in the opening of the DNA duplex.     

Conformational transitions as determinants of specificity for the DNA methyltransferase EcoRI

Changes in DNA bending and base flipping in a previously characterized specificity-enhanced M.EcoRI DNA adenine methyltransferase mutant suggest a close relationship between precatalytic conformational transitions and specificity (Allan, B. W., Garcia, R., Maegley, K., Mort, J., Wong, D., Lindstrom, W., Beechem, J. M., and Reich, N. O. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 19269-19275). The direct measurement of the kinetic rate constants for DNA bending, intercalation, and base flipping with cognate and noncognate substrates (GAATTT, GGATTC) of wild type M.EcoRI using fluorescence resonance energy transfer and 2-aminopurine fluorescence studies reveals that DNA bending precedes both intercalation and base flipping, and base flipping precedes intercalation. Destabilization of these intermediates provides a molecular basis for understanding how conformational transitions contribute to specificity. The 3500- and 23,000-fold decreases in sequence specificity for noncognate sites GAATTT and GGATTC are accounted for largely by an approximately 2500-fold increase in the reverse rate constants for intercalation and base flipping, respectively. Thus, a predominant contribution to specificity is a partitioning of enzyme intermediates away from the Michaelis complex prior to catalysis. Our results provide a basis for understanding enzyme specificity and, in particular, sequence-specific DNA modification. Because many DNA methyltransferases and DNA repair enzymes induce similar DNA distortions, these results are likely to be broadly relevant.     

Determinants of sequence-specific DNA methylation: target recognition and catalysis are coupled in M.HhaI

Sequence specificity studies of the wild-type bacterial DNA cytosine C5 methyltransferase HhaI were carried out with cognate (5'GCGC3') and noncognate DNA substrates containing single base pair changes at the first and the fourth position (underlined). Specificity for noncognate site methylation at the level of kcat/KDDNA is decreased 9000-80000-fold relative to the cognate site, manifested through changes in methylation, or a prior step, and changes in KDDNA. Analysis of a new high-resolution enzyme-DNA cocrystal structure provides a partial mechanistic understanding of this discrimination. To probe the significance of conformational transitions occurring prior to catalysis in determining specificity, we analyzed the double mutant (H127A/T132A). These amino acid substitutions disrupt the interface between the flexible loop (residues 80-99), which interacts with the DNA minor groove, and the active site. The mutant's methylation of the cognate site is essentially unchanged, yet its methylation of noncognate sites is decreased up to 460-fold relative to the wild-type enzyme. We suggest that a significant contribution to M.HhaI's specificity involves the stabilization of reaction intermediates prior to methyl transfer, mediated by DNA minor groove-protein flexible loop interactions.     

Direct observation of cytosine flipping and covalent catalysis in a DNA methyltransferase

Methylation of the five position of cytosine in DNA plays important roles in epigenetic regulation in diverse organisms including humans. The transfer of methyl groups from the cofactor S-adenosyl-L-methionine is carried out by methyltransferase enzymes. Using the paradigm bacterial methyltransferase M.HhaI we demonstrate, in a chemically unperturbed system, the first direct real-time analysis of the key mechanistic events-the flipping of the target cytosine base and its covalent activation; these changes were followed by monitoring the hyperchromicity in the DNA and the loss of the cytosine chromophore in the target nucleotide, respectively. Combined with studies of M.HhaI variants containing redesigned tryptophan fluorophores, we find that the target base flipping and the closure of the mobile catalytic loop occur simultaneously, and the rate of this concerted motion inversely correlates with the stability of the target base pair. Subsequently, the covalent activation of the target cytosine is closely followed by but is not coincident with the methyl group transfer from the bound cofactor. These findings provide new insights into the temporal mechanism of this physiologically important reaction and pave the way to in-depth studies of other base-flipping systems.     

Differential stabilization of reaction intermediates: specificity checkpoints for M.EcoRI revealed by transient fluorescence and fluorescence lifetime studies

M.EcoRI, a bacterial sequence-specific S-adenosyl-L-methionine-dependent DNA methyltransferase, relies on a complex conformational mechanism to achieve its remarkable specificity, including DNA bending, base flipping and intercalation into the DNA. Using transient fluorescence and fluorescence lifetime studies with cognate and noncognate DNA, we have characterized several reaction intermediates involving the WT enzyme. Similar studies with a bending-impaired, enhanced-specificity M.EcoRI mutant show minimal differences with the cognate DNA, but significant differences with noncognate DNA. These results provide a plausible explanation of the way in which destabilization of reaction intermediates can lead to changes in substrate specificity.     

The mechanism of target base attack in DNA cytosine carbon 5 methylation

We measured the tritium exchange reaction on cytosine C(5) in the presence of AdoMet analogues to investigate the catalytic mechanism of the bacterial DNA cytosine methyltransferase M.HhaI. Poly(dG-dC) and poly(dI-dC) substrates were used to investigate the function of the active site loop (residues 80-99), stability of the extrahelical base, base flipping mechanism, and processivity on DNA substrates. On the basis of several experimental approaches, we show that methyl transfer is the rate-limiting pre-steady-state step. Further, we show that the active site loop opening contributes to the rate-limiting step during multiple cycles of catalysis. Target base activation and nucleophilic attack by cysteine 81 are fast and readily reversible. Thus, the reaction intermediates involving the activated target base and the extrahelical base are in equilibrium and accumulate prior to the slow methyl transfer step. The stability of the activated target base depends on the active site loop closure, which is dependent on the hydrogen bond between isoleucine 86 and the guanine 5' to the target cytosine. These interactions prevent the premature release of the extrahelical base and uncontrolled solvent access; the latter modulates the exchange reaction and, by implication, the mutagenic deamination reaction. The processive catalysis by M.HhaI is also regulated by the interaction between isoleucine 86 and the DNA substrate. Nucleophilic attack by cysteine 81 is partially rate limiting when the target base is not fully stabilized in the extrahelical position, as observed during the reaction with the Gln(237)Trp mutant or in the cytosine C(5) exchange reaction in the absence of the cofactor.     

Specificity in protein-DNA interactions: energetic recognition by the (cytosine-C5)-methyltransferase from HhaI

Sequence-specific interactions between proteins and DNA are essential for a variety of biological functions. The (cytosine-C5)-methyltransferase from HhaI (M.HhaI) specifically modifies the second base in GCGC sequences, employing a base flipping mechanism to access the target base being chemically modified. The mechanism of sequence-specific recognition of M.HhaI is not evident based on crystallographic structures, leading to the suggestion that recognition is linked to the flipping event itself, a process that may be referred to as energetic recognition. Using computational methods, it is shown that the free energy barriers to flipping are significantly higher in non-cognate versus the cognate sequence, supporting the energetic recognition mechanism. Energetic recognition is imparted by two protein "selectivity filters" that function via a "web" of protein-DNA interactions in short-lived, high energy states present along the base flipping pathway. Other sequence-specific DNA binding proteins whose function involves significant distortion of DNA's conformation may use a similar recognition mechanism.     

Role of base flipping in specific recognition of damaged DNA by repair enzymes

DNA repair enzymes induce base flipping in the process of damage recognition. Endonuclease V initiates the repair of cis, syn thymine dimers (TD) produced in DNA by UV radiation. The enzyme is known to flip the base opposite the damage into a non-specific binding pocket inside the protein. Uracil DNA glycosylase removes a uracil base from G.U mismatches in DNA by initially flipping it into a highly specific pocket in the enzyme. The contribution of base flipping to specific recognition has been studied by molecular dynamics simulations on the closed and open states of undamaged and damaged models of DNA. Analysis of the distributions of bending and opening angles indicates that enhanced base flipping originates in increased flexibility of the damaged DNA and the lowering of the energy difference between the closed and open states. The increased flexibility of the damaged DNA gives rise to a DNA more susceptible to distortions induced by the enzyme, which lowers the barrier for base flipping. The free energy profile of the base-flipping process was constructed using a potential of mean force representation. The barrier for TD-containing DNA is 2.5 kcal mol(-1) lower than that in the undamaged DNA, while the barrier for uracil flipping is 11.6 kcal mol(-1) lower than the barrier for flipping a cytosine base in the undamaged DNA. The final barriers for base flipping are approximately 10 kcal mol(-1), making the rate of base flipping similar to the rate of linear scanning of proteins on DNA. These results suggest that damage recognition based on lowering the barrier for base flipping can provide a general mechanism for other DNA-repair enzymes.     

M.HhaI binds tightly to substrates containing mismatches at the target base.

The (cytosine-5) DNA methyltransferase M.HhaI causes its target cytosine base to be flipped completely out of the DNA helix upon binding. We have investigated the effects of replacing the target cytosine by other, mismatched bases, including adenine, guanine, thymine and uracil. We find that M.HhaI binds more tightly to such mismatched substrates and can even transfer a methyl group to uracil if a G:U mismatch is present. Other mismatched substrates in which the orphan guanine is changed exhibit similar behavior. Overall, the affinity of DNA binding correlates inversely with the stability of the target base pair, while the nature of the target base appears irrelevant for complex formation. The presence of a cofactor analog. S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine, greatly enhances the selectivity of the methyltransferase for cytosine at the target site. We propose that the DNA methyltransferases have evolved from mismatch binding proteins and that base flipping was, and still is, a key element in many DNA-enzyme interactions.     

Water-assisted dual mode cofactor recognition by HhaI DNA methyltransferase.

Energetically competent binary recognition of the cofactor S-adenosyl-L-methionine (AdoMet) and the product S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine (AdoHcy) by the DNA (cytosine C-5) methyltransferase (M.HhaI) is demonstrated herein. Titration calorimetry reveals a dual mode, involving a primary dominant exothermic reaction followed by a weaker endothermic one, for the recognition of AdoMet and AdoHcy by M.HhaI. Conservation of the bimodal recognition in W41I and W41Y mutants of M.HhaI excludes the cation-pi interaction between the methylsulfonium group of AdoMet and the pi face of the Trp(41) indole ring from a role in its origin. Small magnitude of temperature-independent heat capacity changes upon AdoMet or AdoHcy binding by M.HhaI preclude appreciable conformational alterations in the reacting species. Coupled osmotic-calorimetric analyses of AdoMet and AdoHcy binding by M.HhaI indicate that a net uptake of nearly eight and 10 water molecules, respectively, assists their primary recognition. A change in water activity at constant temperature and pH is sufficient to engender and conserve enthalpy-entropy compensation, consistent with a true osmotic effect. The results implicate solvent reorganization in providing the major contribution to the origin of this isoequilibrium phenomenon in AdoMet and AdoHcy recognition by M.HhaI. The observations provide unequivocal evidence for the binding of AdoMet as well as AdoHcy to M.HhaI in solution state. Isotope partitioning analysis and preincubation studies favor a random mechanism for M.HhaI-catalyzed reaction. Taken together, the results clearly resolve the issue of cofactor recognition by free M.HhaI, specifically in the absence of DNA, leading to the formation of an energetically and catalytically competent binary complex.     

2-Aminopurine as a fluorescent probe for DNA base flipping by methyltransferases.

DNA base flipping, which was first observed for the C5-cytosine DNA methyltransferase M. Hha I, results in a complete removal of the stacking interactions between the target base and its neighbouring bases. We have investigated whether duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing the fluorescent base analogue 2-aminopurine can be used to sense DNA base flipping. Using M. Hha I as a paradigm for a base flipping enzyme, we find that the fluorescence intensity of duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine at the target site is dramatically enhanced (54-fold) in the presence of M. Hha I. Duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine adjacent to the target cytosine show little fluorescence increase upon addition of M. Hha I. These results clearly demonstrate that duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine at the target site can serve as fluorescence probes for base flipping. Another enzyme hypothesized to use a base flipping mechanism is the N6-adenine DNA methyltransferase M. Taq I. Addition of M. Taq I to duplex oligodeoxynucleotides bearing 2-aminopurine at the target position, also results in a strongly enhanced fluorescence (13-fold), whereas addition to duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine at the 3'- or 5'-neighbouring position leads only to small fluorescence increases. These results give the first experimental evidence that the adenine-specific DNA methyltransferase M. Taq I also flips its target base.     

The coupling of tight DNA binding and base flipping: identification of a conserved structural motif in base flipping enzymes

Val(121) is positioned immediately above the extrahelical cytosine in HhaI DNA C(5)-cytosine methyltransferase, and replacement with alanine dramatically interferes with base flipping and catalysis. DNA binding and k(cat) are decreased 10(5)-fold for the Val(121) --> Ala mutant that has a normal circular dichroism spectrum and AdoMet affinity. The magnitude of this loss of function is comparable with removal of the essential catalytic Cys(81). Surprisingly, DNA binding is completely recovered (increase of 10(5)-fold) with a DNA substrate lacking the target cytosine base (abasic). Thus, interfering with the base flipping transition results in a dramatic loss of binding energy. Our data support an induced fit mechanism in which tight DNA binding is coupled to both base flipping and protein loop rearrangement. The importance of the proximal protein segment (His(127)-Thr(132)) in maintaining this critical interaction between Val(121) and the flipped cytosine was probed with single site alanine substitutions. None of these mutants are significantly altered in secondary structure, AdoMet or DNA affinity, k(methylation), k(inactivation), or k(cat). Although Val(121) plays a critical role in both extrahelical base stabilization and catalysis, its position and mobility are not influenced by individual residues in the adjacent peptide region. Structural comparisons with other DNA methyltransferases and DNA repair enzymes that stabilize extrahelical nucleotides reveal a motif that includes a positively charged or polar side chain and a hydrophobic residue positioned adjacent to the target DNA base and either the 5'- or 3'-phosphate.     

Substitution of active site tyrosines with tryptophan alters the free energy for nucleotide flipping by human alkyladenine DNA glycosylase

Human alkyladenine DNA glycosylase (AAG) locates and excises a wide variety of structurally diverse alkylated and oxidized purine lesions from DNA to initiate the base excision repair pathway. Recognition of a base lesion requires flipping of the damaged nucleotide into a relatively open active site pocket between two conserved tyrosine residues, Y127 and Y159. We have mutated each of these amino acids to tryptophan and measured the kinetic effects on the nucleotide flipping and base excision steps. The Y127W and Y159W mutant proteins have robust glycosylase activity toward DNA containing 1,N(6)-ethenoadenine (εA), within 4-fold of that of the wild-type enzyme, raising the possibility that tryptophan fluorescence could be used to probe the DNA binding and nucleotide flipping steps. Stopped-flow fluorescence was used to compare the time-dependent changes in tryptophan fluorescence and εA fluorescence. For both mutants, the tryptophan fluorescence exhibited two-step binding with essentially identical rate constants as were observed for the εA fluorescence changes. These results provide evidence that AAG forms an initial recognition complex in which the active site pocket is perturbed and the stacking of the damaged base is disrupted. Upon complete nucleotide flipping, there is further quenching of the tryptophan fluorescence with coincident quenching of the εA fluorescence. Although these mutations do not have large effects on the rate constant for excision of εA, there are dramatic effects on the rate constants for nucleotide flipping that result in 40-100-fold decreases in the flipping equilibrium relative to wild-type. Most of this effect is due to an increased rate of unflipping, but surprisingly the Y159W mutation causes a 5-fold increase in the rate constant for flipping. The large effect on the equilibrium for nucleotide flipping explains the greater deleterious effects that these mutations have on the glycosylase activity toward base lesions that are in more stable base pairs.     

Frameshift Deletion by Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 DNA Polymerase Dpo4 T239W Is Selective for Purines and Involves Normal Conformational Change Followed by Slow Phosphodiester Bond Formation

The human DNA polymerase κ homolog Sulfolobus solfataricus DNA polymerase IV (Dpo4) produces “−1” frameshift deletions while copying unmodified DNA and, more frequently, when bypassing DNA adducts. As judged by steady-state kinetics and mass spectrometry, bypass of purine template bases to produce these deletions occurred rarely but with 10-fold higher frequency than with pyrimidines. The DNA adduct 1,N²-etheno-2′-deoxyguanosine, with a larger stacking surface than canonical purines, showed the highest frequency of formation of −1 frameshift deletions. Dpo4 T239W, a mutant we had previously shown to produce fluorescence changes attributed to conformational change following dNTP binding opposite cognate bases (Beckman, J. W., Wang, Q., and Guengerich, F. P. (2008) J. Biol. Chem. 283, 36711–36723), reported similar conformational changes when the incoming dNTP complemented the base following a templating purine base or bulky adduct (i.e. the “+1” base). However, in all mispairing cases, phosphodiester bond formation was inefficient. The frequency of −1 frameshift events and the associated conformational changes were not dependent on the context of the remainder of the sequence. Collectively, our results support a mechanism for −1 frameshift deletions by Dpo4 that involves formation of active complexes via a favorable conformational change that skips the templating base, without causing slippage or flipping out of the base, to incorporate a complementary residue opposite the +1 base, in a mechanism previously termed “dNTP-stabilized incorporation.” The driving force is attributed to be the stacking potential between the templating base and the incoming dNTP base.     

HhaI DNA methyltransferase uses the protruding Gln237 for active flipping of its target cytosine

Access to a nucleotide by its rotation out of the DNA helix (base flipping) is used by numerous DNA modification and repair enzymes. Despite extensive studies of the paradigm HhaI methyltransferase, initial events leading to base flipping remained elusive. Here we demonstrate that the replacement of the target C:G pair with the 2-aminopurine:T pair in the DNA or shortening of the side chain of Gln237 in the protein severely perturb base flipping, but retain specific DNA binding. Kinetic analyses and molecular modeling suggest that a steric interaction between the protruding side chain of Gln237 and the target cytosine in B-DNA reduces the energy barrier for flipping by 3 kcal/mol. Subsequent stabilization of an open state by further 4 kcal/mol is achieved through specific hydrogen bonding of the side chain to the orphan guanine. Gln237 thus plays a key role in actively opening the target C:G pair by a "push-and-bind" mechanism.