Cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition of class I H-2 antigens after DNA-mediated gene transfer

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) recognition sites on class I major histocompatibility complex molecules have been investigated by several laboratories by using cloned genes expressed on mouse L cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer. Recombinant genes, constructed by restriction endonuclease treatment of cloned H-2Dd and Ld genes and exchange of the N and C1 exons (exon shuffling) have provided an additional tool. These hybrid H-2 molecules expressed on L cells have been used as targets to achieve more precise localization of site(s) recognized by allospecific and virus-specific CTLs. CTL systems were chosen that limit recognition to either the Dd or Ld alloantigen or to virus and Dd or Ld complexes. Using this approach, we were able to map essential restricting site(s) to the N and/or C1 domains. Additional evidence is presented that the cytoplasmic tail of H-2 may be involved in interactions with some viral antigens and effect the formation of an immunogenic complex.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition of secreted HLA class I molecules

The cytolytic responses of DBA/2 mice against syngeneic transfected P815 mastocytoma cells expressing either membrane-associated (HLA-Cw3) or -secreted hybrid (HLA-Cw3 x H-2 Q10b) molecules were compared. In spite of the absence of serologically detectable hybrid molecules on their plasma membrane, cells secreting these molecules elicited a CTL response similar to that of cells expressing the membrane associated HLA-Cw3 molecules, in terms of both MHC-restriction and peptide specificity. Together with the observation that syngeneic mice were capable of rejecting the injected secreting cells, these results imply that secreted HLA class I molecules can function as minor histocompatibility Ag and suggest that processing of both the membrane-bound and the -secreted forms of a protein may follow common or overlapping pathways.     

Subunit interactions of class I histocompatibility antigens

The kinetics of dissociation of iodinated beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2m) from the papain-solubilized class I histocompatibility antigen HLA-B7 have been investigated. In the presence of unlabeled beta 2m, most of the HLA dissociates according to a single rate constant, whereas in the absence of unlabeled beta 2m, the system approaches an equilibrium dependent upon the initial HLA concentration. When iodinated beta 2m is incubated with unlabeled HLA-B7, the rate of incorporation of beta 2m into the complex is much less dependent on the concentration than is expected for a simple association/dissociation system; instead, the system behaves as if the "activity" (in a thermodynamic sense) of the HLA heavy-chain intermediate cannot surpass a critical concentration. The dissociation rate for each class I specificity is a function of temperature, ionic strength, pH, and the status of the heavy chain (papain solubilized vs. detergent solubilized). High temperature, high ionic strength, and extremes of pH promote dissociation. The intact molecule dissociates about 10 times more slowly than the papain-solubilized molecule. In contrast, the rate of dissociation of all papain-solubilized class I antigens tested falls within the range of about a factor of 2. The presence of the carbohydrate has no effect on the rate of dissociation. The possibility that HLA class I antigen dissociation may occur in vivo within acidic internal vesicles is discussed.     

Generation of major histocompatibility complex class I antigens

Presentation of antigenic peptides by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules on the surface of antigen-presenting cells is an effective extracellular representation of the intracellular antigen content. The intracellular proteasome-dependent proteolytic machinery is required for generating MHC class I-presented peptides. These peptides appear to be derived mainly from newly synthesized defective ribosomal products, ensuring a rapid cytotoxic T lymphocyte-mediated immune response against infectious pathogens. Here we discuss the generation of MHC class I antigens on the basis of the currently understood molecular, biochemical and cellular mechanisms.     

The role of T8 in the cytotoxic activity of cloned cytotoxic T lymphocyte lines specific for class II and class I major histocompatibility complex antigens

It is reported here that most cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), which recognize class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) loci, express the T cell differentiation antigen T8. However, a minority of T8+ CTL clones was found to recognize class II MHC antigens. To test the hypothesis that T8 is involved only in T cell recognition of class I MHC antigens, we studied the role of T8 in the cytotoxic activity of class II MHC-specific CTL. Monoclonal antibodies specific for T8 blocked the activity of most class I MHC-specific CTL clones but did not affect the activity of class II MHC-specific CTL clones. Moreover, a mild trypsin treatment of the clones, which removed and T8 determinant, affected the activity of class I MHC but not that of class II MHC-specific CTL clones. These findings indicate that the class II-specific MHC CTL clones described here did not require T8 for their cytolytic activity. The activity of one T8+ class I MHC-specific (HLA-B27) CTL clone (HG-61) against the B cell line JY, which was used to raise this CTL clone, was not blocked by trypsin treatment of this clone. However, the activity of CTL clone HG-61 against target cells different from JY but carrying the appropriate HLA specificity was blocked by anti-T8 antibodies and trypsin treatment. The implications of these findings for the hypothesis that T8 is involved only in the activity of CTL with a relatively low avidity for class I MHC antigens are discussed.     

Modulation of class I and class II histocompatibility antigens on human T cell lines by IFN-gamma

IFN-gamma is an immunomodulatory agent which is known to induce or enhance the expression of class II histocompatibility Ag (Ia Ag) on many lymphoid cells and cell lines of diverse origin. However, we have observed that IFN-gamma did not induce the expression of Ia Ag on Ia- human T cell lines. Neither did IFN-gamma enhance the expression of Ia Ag on Ia+ T cells. However, IFN-gamma was able to enhance the expression of class I histocompatibility Ag (HLA-A,B,C Ag) on a number of the T cell lines tested. Experiments with 125I-labeled IFN-gamma showed a relatively small degree of specific binding to these T cell lines. More extensive studies on two of the T cell lines demonstrated 1000 and 2600 IFN-gamma binding receptor sites/cell and binding affinities of 4.0 X 10(-10) M and 7.3 X 10(-10) M. Thus, although IFN-gamma can bind to human T cell lines and enhance class I histocompatibility Ag on these cells, IFN-gamma alone does not appear to regulate expression of class II histocompatibility Ag on T cell lines.     

Specificity, phenotype, and precursor frequency of primary cytolytic T lymphocytes specific for class II major histocompatibility antigens

Most cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) recognize class I rather than class II MHC determinants, and relatively little is known about those CTL that do recognize class II MHC determinants. The present study was undertaken to document the specificity, phenotype, and precursor frequency of primary class II allospecific CTL. It was found that class II-allospecific CTL could be consistently generated in vitro from unprimed spleen or thymus populations in the presence of exogenously added helper factors. The class II MHC specificity of both the precursor and CTL effectors activated in primary cultures by Ia-disparate stimulator cells was documented both by blocking experiments with anti-Ia mAb and by the use of L cell transfectants. The mechanism by which primary allospecific CTL effectors lysed their targets appeared to involve direct cell-cell contact, because they failed to lyse bystander target cells. The frequency in unprimed spleen populations of precursor CTL specific for class II alloantigens was examined by limiting dilution analysis and was found to be as high as 1/15,000 splenocytes and approximately 10% of the frequency reported for primary class I allospecific CTL. Finally, the Lyt phenotype of primary class II allospecific CTL precursors and effectors was determined. It was found that anti-class II CTL derive from at least two distinct precursor subpopulations that are either L3T4+Lyt-2- or L3T4-Lyt-2+, and that the Lyt phenotype expressed by the CTL effectors are concordant with that of their precursors. No correlation was found between the I subregion gene products recognized by CTL effectors and the Lyt phenotype they expressed in that both I-A- and I-E-specific CTL were both L3T4+Lyt-2- and L3T4-Lyt-2+.     

Response against single minor histocompatibility antigens. I. Functional and immunogenetic analysis of cloned cytolytic T cells

A clonal approach was used to investigate the cellular basis of a T cell response to single minor histocompatibility antigens (miHA). This analysis was performed by functional and immunogenetic characterization of a large number of clones derived from short-term mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations generated against the miHA, H-1.3. Forty-nine clones isolated from such MLC were specifically cytolytic for H-1.3-bearing, H-2Db-compatible target cells. Thirty-seven of the 49 cytolytic clones were driven to proliferate when stimulated by spleen cells bearing the H-1.3 alloantigen in the absence of added T cell-derived growth factor(s) (GF). The remaining 12 clones proliferated only when GF was added. A strong positive correlation was observed between antigen-induced proliferation and the production of interleukin 2 (IL 2) activity. A similar correlation was observed when comparing the ability of both antigen and concanavalin A to induce IL 2 activity from the clones. These data suggest that i) antigen-driven or helper T cell-independent cytolytic T cells (HITc) are frequent components of an MLC response to a single miHA, and ii) the ability of HITc to undergo antigen-driven proliferation is related to their ability to produce antigen-induced GF.     

Differential phosphorylation of murine class I major histocompatibility antigens

Recent studies have shown that the H-2K and H-2D transplantation antigens are expressed differentially in different tissues of mouse. Our previous investigations also established that in thioglycolate-stimulated peritoneal macrophages the H-2D^k antigen exists in distinct cell surface and intracellular forms. These two forms are glycosylated differently. In this report, we have found that (1) H-2D^k antigen is phosphorylated whereas H-2K^k antigen is not, and (2) only the cell surface form of H-2D^k antigen is phosphorylated in thioglycolate-stimulated macrophages derived from C3H/Heha mice. This differential phosphorylation of H-2 antigens will provide a model system for further studies on the molecular mechanism and function of phosphrrylation of H-2 antigens.     

Defining cytolytic T lymphocyte recognition of chemically modified self. I. Response to trinitrophenyl-H-2Kk

We used purified class I antigen incorporated into liposomes to examine the response of secondary cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) to chemically modified self. By generating the secondary response in the presence of T cell helper factor, the level of CTL response was limited by CTL recognition of added antigen rather than by helper cell generation of lymphokines. We found a strong secondary response against chemically modified self when spleen cells from trinitrophenyl (TNP)-primed C3H/HeJ mice were stimulated with a) TNP-modified liposomes containing H-2Kk, b) liposomes containing H-2Kk purified from TNP-modified RDM-4 (H-2k) cells, or c) liposomes containing the limited trypsin proteolysis product of H-2Kk that had been directly modified with TNP. In contrast, we were not able to generate a significant CTL response with unmodified H-2Kk incorporated into vesicles along with TNP-modified membrane components lacking H-2Kk. These results suggest that TNP-modified H-2Kk is a major antigenic site recognized by CTL from C3H/HeJ mice after priming against TNP-modified self.     

Recognition of influenza-infected cells by cytolytic T lymphocyte clones: determinant selection by class I restriction elements

The fine specificity of virus recognition by influenza A/PR8/34(H1N1)-specific cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones was analyzed with the use of a panel of syngeneic target cells infected with five heterologous influenza A strain viruses. Forty-five H-2 D-end-restricted CTL clones from B10.A(5R) responders (Dd,Ld) demonstrated 14 different patterns of recognition. Many of these clonotypes were able to distinguish between closely related viruses of the same subtype. Such discriminatory capacity, however, was often accompanied by cross-reactivity against a distantly related viral subtype. This supports the contention that virus-specific CTL see different structures than do virus-specific antibodies. A similar analysis of the fine specificity of 60 Db-restricted clones from C57BL/6 responders was performed. The vast majority of this response was composed of clonotypes not observed in the B10.A(5R) response. In addition, the hierarchy of relatedness between the virus strain used for immunization and the various heterologous viruses was different in C57BL/6 and B10.A(5R). In contrast, the D-end-restricted response of Balb/c (Dd,Ld) demonstrated clonotypes similar to those found in B10.A(5R). These data suggest that determinant recognition in an anti-viral CTL response is a function of the H-2 restricting elements, and this is discussed in the context of determinant selection by class I molecules.     

Mechanism of cytolytic T lymphocyte killing of a low class I-expressing tumor

Many tumors have been shown to express minimal levels of class I MHC Ag, which makes them more resistant to recognition and lysis by cytolytic T lymphocytes. Line 1, a BALB/c spontaneous lung carcinoma, normally expresses very low levels of class I Ag, but expression can be increased 50-fold by treatment with agents such as DMSO or IFN-gamma. Because class I Ag serve as restricting elements for cytolytic T cell recognition of tumor Ag, we wished to determine if cytotoxic T lymphocytes could play a role in the immune response to this type of class I low, but inducible, tumor. After immunization in vivo and restimulation of splenic cells in vitro we were able to generate T cell clones that lysed line 1 cells induced to express high levels of class I, but did not lyse uninduced, low class I expressing line 1 cells in short term (6-h) 51Cr release assays. Paradoxically, incubation of the T cells with uninduced class I low line 1 cells for a few days resulted in complete destruction of the tumor cells. We demonstrate that the T cells, stimulated by the tumor cells, produce IFN-gamma, which in turn induces class I expression on the line 1 cells making them susceptible to lysis by the T cell clone. This suggests that a positive feedback reaction can occur in generating a response to this and perhaps other inducible tumor cell lines.     

Biochemical characterization of activation-associated bovine class I major histocompatibility complex antigens

Utilizing a 'sandwich' ELISA assay we have been able to demonstrate that mAb W6/32, B1G6 and IL-A19 are reactive with three different monomorphic determinants on bovine class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Sequential immunoprecipitations performed with the mAb revealed that class I molecules on PBM comprise a single population with respect to reactivity with the mAb in that the beta 2m-associated proteins bear all three epitopes. By contrast, TCGF-driven lymphoblasts and cells transformed by Theileria parva (Tp) additionally express molecules of Mr 45000 bound to beta 2m which are recognized by mAb B1G6 and IL-A19 but not by W6/32. These two subclasses of molecules were further distinguished on the basis that, when tunicamycin was added to cultures in the preparation of cells for analysis, mAb W6/32 precipitated class I heavy chains of Mr 39000 while the extra molecules detected only by mAb B1G6 and IL-A19 were of Mr 37000 and 39000. On thymocytes, the mAb W6/32-non-reactive class I molecules are present in low amounts and are expressed by cells in the medulla area, unlike BoT1 (analogous to human CD1) molecules which are expressed by the cortical cells. Our studies also revealed that the supposed beta 2m-specific mAb B1G6 does not recognize the beta 2m-associated molecules (BoT1) precipitated by mAb TH97A and thus the specificity of mAb B1G6 in cattle is for an epitope on bovine beta 2m which is strongly influenced by the nature of the heavy chain with which the beta 2m is associated.     

Construction of novel class I histocompatibility antigens by interspecies exon shuffling

Human and mouse class I histocompatibility antigens share considerable structural homology at both the protein and DNA sequence level. This homology has allowed the production of hybrid class I molecules by the reciprocal exchange of DNA sequences corresponding to equivalent domains of HLA-B7 and either H-2Ld or H-2Dd. It is shown that these genes give rise to protein products that are stably expressed on the surface of murine L cells after DNA-mediated gene transfer. These proteins express only those monoclonal antibody-defined H-2 determinants that are expected based on their genetic construction. The molecules have allowed the localization of a number of polymorphic and monomorphic HLA-specific epitopes. In all but one case, expression of an epitope on a domain does not appear to be influenced by the replacement of adjacent human domains with their murine equivalents, suggesting a considerable degree of structural independence of the domains. Cells expressing the hybrid molecules have also been tested as targets for a panel of HLA-B7-specific cytotoxic T cell clones. The results show that the polymorphic determinants recognized by these clones map to the alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of the HLA-B7 molecule. No evidence for an influence of species-related amino acid sequence differences in the third extracellular domain on T cell recognition was seen. The results are discussed in light of the proposed domain structure of the class I proteins and the potential use of such molecules for further functional studies.     

Biochemical characterization of activation-associated bovine class I major histocompatibility complex antigens

Summary. Utilizing a 'sandwich' ELISA assay we have been able to demonstrate that mAb W6/32, B1G6 and IL-A19 are reactive with three different monomorphic determinants on bovine class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Sequential immunoprecipitations performed with the mAb revealed that class I molecules on PBM comprise a single population with respect to reactivity with the mAb in that the β2m-associated proteins bear all three epitopes. By contrast, TCGF-driven lymphoblasts and cells transformed by Theileria parva (Tp) additionally express molecules of Mr 45000 bound to β2m which are recognized by mAb B1G6 and IL-A19 but not by W6/32. These two subclasses of molecules were further distinguished on the basis that, when tunicamycin was added to cultures in the preparation of cells for analysis, mAb W6/32 precipitated class I heavy chains of Mr 39000 while the extra molecules detected only by mAb B1G6 and IL-A19 were of Mr 37000 and 39000. On thymocytes, the mAb W6/32-non-reactive class I molecules are present in low amounts and are expressed by cells in the medulla area, unlike BoT1 (analogous to human CD1) molecules which are expressed by the cortical cells. Our studies also revealed that the supposed β2m-specific mAb B1G6 does not recognize the β2m-associated molecules (BoT1) precipitated by mAb TH97A and thus the specificity of mAb B1G6 in cattle is for an epitope on bovine β2m which is strongly influenced by the nature of the heavy chain with which the β2m is associated.     

Dissociation of alloantigen recognition from self major histocompatibility complex-restricted recognition of cytolytic T lymphocytes by monoclonal antireceptor antibodies

Two monoclonal antibodies (mAb) directed to the dual reactive cytolytic T lymphocyte clone OH8 (Db + H-Y and H-2d) were established. Analysis by cell surface staining and immunoprecipitation of radiolabeled surface molecules of OH8 followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis revealed that both mAb recognized an identical heterodimeric, clonotypic structure on OH8 cells, i.e., T cell receptor. However, although the MR3-2 mAb inhibited the lysis of either Db + H-Y or H-2d targets by OH8, the MR3-6 mAb inhibited the lysis of H-2d target cells, but not that of Db + H-Y target cells. Modulation of T cell receptor by either MR3-2 or MR3-6 mAb rendered the OH8 cytolytic T lymphocyte incapable of killing both Db + H-Y and H-2d target cells. These findings suggest that different epitopes of OH8 T cell receptor were involved for the recognition of self + antigen and alloantigen.     

The requirements for antigen multivalency in class I antigen recognition and triggering of primed precursor cytolytic T lymphocytes

In vitro generation of a secondary cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response to Class I alloantigen requires two signals: recognition of the Class I antigen by precursor CTL (Signal 1), and subsequent interaction with lymphokine(s) (Signal 2). Previous work using subcellular antigen stimulation has demonstrated that the required lymphokine(s) is produced as a result of adherent cell uptake, processing, and Ia-restricted presentation of alloantigen to helper T cells. This pathway could be bypassed by addition to the cultures of supernatant from Con A-stimulated rat spleen cells. When an optimal level of lymphokine(s) is provided by addition of Con A supernatant, the magnitude of the CTL response obtained is dependent on the effectiveness of alloantigen recognition and triggering of the primed precursor CTL (pCTL). By using this approach, we examined the cellular and molecular requirements for generation of Signal 1. Previous results had indicated that pCTL were able to directly recognize subcellular antigen, and that cellular presentation of the antigen to pCTL was not required. Further evidence for this was provided by the finding that pulsing of the responder population for short times with liposomes containing purified H-2Kk resulted in effective stimulation of the response. Exposure of cells to antigen for 1 to 2 hr at 4 degrees C generated responses of comparable magnitude to those obtained when antigen was continuously present in the cultures. Experiments were also done to directly examine the ability of alloantigen-pulsed splenic adherent cells (SAC) to deliver Signal 1. Although the antigen-pulsed SAC were very effective in presenting to helper T cells to result in factor production, they were found to be very ineffective in providing Signal 1 to the pCTL. Having obtained strong evidence for triggering of pCTL occurring via direct recognition of the subcellular alloantigen, we then examined the role of antigen multivalency in recognition and triggering. Purified H-2Kk was prepared in a variety of forms of differing multivalency, ranging from monovalent papain cleavage product to large, highly multivalent liposomes and plasma membranes. The magnitude of the CTL responses obtained was found to be critically dependent on the multivalency of the antigen preparation. Examination of the antigen dose-response curves and maximal responses obtained suggests that valency of the antigen may be important both in determining the avidity of interaction between the pCTL and the antigen-bearing structure, and in determining the extent to which localized receptor cross-linking occurs on the cell surface to result in triggering.     

Invasive equine trophoblast expresses conventional class I major histocompatibility complex antigens

Monoclonal antibodies and alloantisera were used in an indirect immunohistochemical assay to determine the expression of class I and class II Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) antigens by equine placental cells and the endometrial tissues at the fetal-maternal interface. MHC class I antigens were expressed at high density on the surface of the trophoblast cells of the chorionic girdle at days 32-36, just prior to their invasion of the endometrium. The mature gonadotrophin-secreting cells of the endometrial cups, which are derived from the chorionic girdle cells, had greatly reduced levels of MHC class I antigen expression while no MHC class I antigens were detectable on the non-invasive trophoblast cells of the allantochorion, except in small isolated patches. MHC class I antigens immunoprecipitated from chorionic girdle cells with either monoclonal antibodies or alloantisera had a relative molecular mass of 44,000, which was identical to that of MHC class I antigens precipitated from lymphocytes with the same reagents. MHC class II antigens were not detected on any trophoblast cells, although they were expressed at high levels by the endometrial glandular and lumenal epithelium immediately bordering the endometrial cups. MHC class I antigens were also expressed at high levels by endometrial tissues in the area of the cups. The high level of MHC class I antigen expression by endometrial glands within and bordering the cups was in sharp contrast to the greatly reduced class I antigen expression by the mature endometrial cup cells themselves.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)