Molecular analysis of N6-methyladenine patterns in Tetrahymena thermophila nuclear DNA.

We have cloned two DNA fragments containing 5'-GATC-3' sites at which the adenine is methylated in the macronucleus of the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. Using these cloned fragments as molecular probes, we analyzed the maintenance of methylation patterns at two partially and two uniformly methylated sites. Our results suggest that a semiconservative copying model for maintenance of methylation is not sufficient to account for the methylation patterns we found during somatic growth of Tetrahymena. Although we detected hemimethylated molecules in macronuclear DNA, they were present in both replicating and nonreplicating DNA. In addition, we observed that a complex methylation pattern including partially methylated sites was maintained during vegetative growth. This required the activity of a methylase capable of recognizing and modifying sites specified by something other than hemimethylation. We suggest that a eucaryotic maintenance methylase may be capable of discriminating between potential methylation sites to ensure the inheritance of methylation patterns.     

Smchd1-dependent and -independent pathways determine developmental dynamics of CpG island methylation on the inactive x chromosome

X chromosome inactivation involves multiple levels of chromatin modification, established progressively and in a stepwise manner during early development. The chromosomal protein Smchd1 was recently shown to play an important role in DNA methylation of CpG islands (CGIs), a late step in the X inactivation?pathway that is required for long-term maintenance of gene silencing. Here we show that inactive X chromosome (Xi) CGI methylation can occur via either Smchd1-dependent or -independent pathways. Smchd1-dependent CGI methylation, the primary pathway, is acquired gradually over an extended period, whereas Smchd1-independent CGI methylation occurs rapidly after the onset of X inactivation. The de novo methyltransferase Dnmt3b is required for methylation of both classes of CGI, whereas Dnmt3a and Dnmt3L are dispensable. Xi CGIs methylated by these distinct pathways differ with respect to their sequence characteristics and immediate chromosomal environment. We discuss the implications of these results for understanding CGI methylation during development.     

Effects of DNA binding proteins on DNA methylation in vitro

The inheritance of DNA methylation patterns may play an important role in the stability of the differentiated state. We have therefore studied the inhibitory effects of DNA binding proteins on DNA methylation in vitro. Mouse L1210 cells grown in the presence of 5-azacytidine acquire hemimethylated sites in their DNA. Purified hemimethylated DNA accepted methyl groups from S-adenosyl-L-methionine in the presence of a crude maintenance methylase more readily than purified DNA isolated from cells not exposed to 5-azacytidine. On the other hand, chromatin fractions isolated from cells grown in the presence or absence of 5-azacytidine were poor substrates for the maintenance methylase irrespective of the number of hemimethylated sites present in the DNA. Inhibition of DNA methylation was shown to be associated primarily with chromatin proteins bound to DNA, and trypsinization of nuclei increased their methyl accepting abilities. Methyl acceptance was increased by salt extraction of chromosomal proteins. These data suggest that association of histones with DNA may play a role in the modulation of methylation patterns.     

Methylation of HpaII and HhaI sites near the polymorphic CAG repeat in the human androgen-receptor gene correlates with X chromosome inactivation.

The human androgen-receptor gene (HUMARA; GenBank) contains a highly polymorphic trinucleotide repeat in the first exon. We have found that the methylation of HpaII and HhaI sites less than 100 bp away from this polymorphic short tandem repeat (STR) correlates with X inactivation. The close proximity of the restriction-enzyme sites to the STR allows the development of a PCR assay that distinguishes between the maternal and paternal alleles and identifies their methylation status. The accuracy of this assay was tested on (a) DNA from hamster/human hybrid cell lines containing either an active or inactive human X chromosome; (b) DNA from normal males and females; and (c) DNA from females showing nonrandom patterns of X inactivation. Data obtained using this assay correlated substantially with those obtained using the PGK, HPRT, and M27 beta probes, which detect X inactivation patterns by Southern blot analysis. In order to demonstrate one application of this assay, we examined X inactivation patterns in the B lymphocytes of potential and obligate carriers of X-linked agammaglobulinemia.     

Targeting of >1.5 Mb of Human DNA into the Mouse X Chromosome Reveals Presence of cis-Acting Regulators of Epigenetic Silencing

Regulatory sequences can influence the expression of flanking genes over long distances, and X chromosome inactivation is a classic example of cis-acting epigenetic gene regulation. Knock-ins directed to the Mus musculus Hprt locus offer a unique opportunity to analyze the spread of silencing into different human DNA sequences in the identical genomic environment. X chromosome inactivation of four knock-in constructs, including bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) integrations of over 195 kb, was demonstrated by both the lack of expression from the inactive X chromosome in females with nonrandom X chromosome inactivation and promoter DNA methylation of the human transgene in females. We further utilized promoter DNA methylation to assess the inactivation status of 74 human reporter constructs comprising >1.5 Mb of DNA. Of the 47 genes examined, only the PHB gene showed female DNA hypomethylation approaching the level seen in males, and escape from X chromosome inactivation was verified by demonstration of expression from the inactive X chromosome. Integration of PHB resulted in lower DNA methylation of the flanking HPRT promoter in females, suggesting the action of a dominant cis-acting escape element. Female-specific DNA hypermethylation of CpG islands not associated with promoters implies a widespread imposition of DNA methylation during X chromosome inactivation; yet transgenes demonstrated differential capacities to accumulate DNA methylation when integrated into the identical location on the inactive X chromosome, suggesting additional cis-acting sequence effects. As only one of the human transgenes analyzed escaped X chromosome inactivation, we conclude that elements permitting ongoing expression from the inactive X are rare in the human genome.     

Overall DNA methylation and chromatin structure of normal and abnormal X chromosomes

DNA methylation patterns were studied at the chromosome level in normal and abnormal X chromosomes using an anti-5-methylcytosine antibody. In man, except for the late-replicating X of female cells, the labeled chromosome structures correspond to R- and T-bands and heterochromatin. Depending on the cell type, the species, and cell culture conditions, the late-replicating X in female cells appears to be more or less undermethylated. Under normal conditions, the only structures that remain methylated on the X chromosomes correspond to pseudoautosomal regions, which harbor active genes. Thus, active genes are usually hypomethylated but are located in methylated chromatin. Structural rearrangements of the X chromosome, such as t(X;X)(pter;pter), induce a Turner syndrome-like phenotype that is inconsistent with the resulting triple-X constitution. This suggests a position effect controlling gene inactivation. The derivative chromosomes are always late replicating, and their duplicated short arms, which harbor pseudoautosomal regions, replicate later than the normal late-replicating X chromosomes. The compaction or condensation of this segment is unusual, with a halo of chromatin surrounding a hypocondensed chromosome core. The chromosome core is hypomethylated, but the surrounding chromatin is slightly labeled. Thus, unusual DNA methylation and chromatin condensation are associated with the observed position effect. This strengthens the hypothesis that DNA methylation at the chromosome level is associated with both chromatin structure and gene expression.     

CpG methylation of an X-linked transgene is determined by somatic events postfertilization and not germline imprinting

The process of X-inactivation in mammals requires at least two events, the initiation of inactivation and the maintenance of the inactive state. One possible mechanism of control is by methylation of DNA at CpG dinucleotides to maintain the inactive state. Furthermore, the paternal X-chromosome is frequently inactivated in the extraembryonic membranes. The relationship between the parental origin of the chromosome, nonrandom inactivation and DNA methylation is not clear. In this paper, we report on the CpG methylation of an X-linked transgene, CAT-32. The levels of methylation in embryonic, extraembryonic and germline cells indicates that the modifications of the transgene are broadly similar to those reported for endogenous X-linked genes. Interestingly, the methylation of CAT-32 transgene in extraembryonic tissues displays patterns that could be linked to the germline origin of each allele. Hence, the maternally derived copy of CAT-32 was relatively undermethylated when compared to the paternal one. The changes in DNA methylation were attributed to de novo methylation occurring after fertilization, most probably during differentiation of extraembryonic tissues. In order to determine whether or not the patterns of DNA methylation reflected the germline origin of the X-chromosome, we constructed triploid embryos specifically to introduce two maternal X-chromosomes in the same embryo. In some of these triploid conceptuses, methylation patterns characteristic of the paternally derived transgene were observed. This observation indicates that the methylation patterns are not necessarily dependent on the parental origin of the X-chromosome, but could be changed by somatic events after fertilization. One of the more likely mechanisms is methylation of the transgene following inactivation of the X-chromosome in extraembryonic tissues.     

Sequence specificity of cytosine methylation in the DNA of the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cell line

We have determined the DNA renaturation kinetics for those DNA sequences of the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells in which enzymatic cytosine methylation occurred immediately after strand synthesis and for those in which methylation was delayed after strand synthesis. DNA sequences showing immediate or delayed methylation were found to be distributed throughout all repetition classes of the DNA of these cells, with a slight concentration of immediate methylation in moderately repetitive sequences and with delayed methylation being slightly over-represented in the highly repetitive fraction. However, DNA sequences showing both classes of methylation were represented equally in unique DNA sequences. We interpret these data to mean that the methylase acting near the replication forks (the 'immediate' methylase) is a relatively inefficient enzyme, missing some 20% of hemimethylated sites produced by DNA replication in these cells. We suggest that the methylase performing maintenance methylation at sites remote from the replication forks (the 'delayed' methylase) is simply a back-up enzyme for the first and that it has no true sequence specificity. The implications of this for the function(s) of DNA methylation in mammalian cells are discussed.     

Differential methylation of the hypervariable locus DXS255 on active and inactive X chromosomes correlates with the expression of a human X-linked gene

Consistent differences in methylation of particular cytosine residues in the DNA of active and inactive X chromosomes can be used for rapid, direct analysis of X-inactivation patterns in different female tissues. We have studied methylation of the highly polymorphic DXS255 locus in tissues from patients with deficiency of the E1 alpha subunit of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex in whom the results can be correlated directly with total enzyme activity, levels of immunoreactive protein, and patterns of cell mosaicism. The results confirm that methylation of the DXS255 locus correlates with X-chromosome expression. In patients and normal controls, the pattern of X inactivation varied widely from tissue to tissue and often deviated markedly from a 50:50 proportion. These deviations are likely to reflect small numbers of tissue-specific stem cells at the time of random X inactivation and cannot be taken alone as evidence for selection or "nonrandom" inactivation.     

Epigenetic programming of differential gene expression in development and evolution

This review covers data on changing patterns of DNA methylation and the regulation of gene expression in mouse embryonic development. Global demethylation occurs from the eight-cell stage to the blastocyst stage in pre-implantation embryos, and global de novo methylation begins at implantation. We have used X-chromosome inactivation in female embryos as a model system to study specific CpG sites in the X-linked Pgk-1 and Gópd housekeeping genes and in the imprinted regulatory Xist gene to elucidate the role of methylation in the initiation and maintenance of differential gene activity. Methyl-ation of the X-linked housekeeping genes occurs very close in time to their inactivation, thus raising the question as to whether methylation could be causal to inactivation, as well as being involved in its maintenance. A methylation difference between sperm and eggs in the promoter region of the Xist gene, located at the X-chromosome inactivation centre, is correlated with imprinted preferential inactivation of the paternal X chromosome in extra-embryonic tissues. Based on our data, a picture of the inheritance of methylation imprints and speculation on the significance of the Xist imprint in development is presented. On a more general level, an hypothesis of evolution by “adaptive epige-netic/genetic inheritance” is considered. This proposes modification of germ line DNA in response to a change in environment and mutation at the site of modification (e.g., of methylated cytosine to thymine). Epigenetic inheritance could function to shift patterns of gene expression to buffer the evolving system against changes in environment. If the altered patterns of gene activity and inactivity persist, the modifications may become “fixed” as mutations; alternatively, previously silenced gene networks might be recruited into function, thus appearing as if they are “acquired characteristics.” An extension of this hypothesis is “foreign gene acquisition and sorting” (selection or silencing of gene function according to use). “Kidnapping” and sorting of foreign genes in this way could explain the observation that increased complexity in evolution is associated with more “junk” DNA. Adaptive epigenetic/genetic inheritance challenges the “central dogma” that information is unidirectional from the DNA to protein and the idea that Darwinian random mutation and selection are the sole mechanisms of evolution. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Methylation profile of genes on the human X chromosome

X chromosome inactivation occurs in female mammals for the purpose of equalisation of dosage of X linked genes between the two sexes. In eutherian mammals, one of the two copies of the X chromosome present in female individuals is silenced. Epigenetic modifications of both DNA and histones have been implicated to play a crucial role in this inactivation phenomenon. In this work, we have employed a novel method published earlier by us, to assess the DNA methylation levels of genes on the inactive X chromosome in the human system. We have used genomic DNA from cells with the following karyotype namely, 47,XXX and 45,X to compare methylation levels from the active and inactive X. We report differential methylation of genes from the active and the inactive X chromosome with higher number of methylated genes being present on the inactive X chromosome. Our work has also led to identification of motifs that show a significant similarity to microRNA sequences which are enriched in methylated regions specific to the inactive X.     

The hypervariable DXS255 locus contains a LINE-1 repetitive element with a CpG island that is extensively methylated only on the active X chromosome.

The DXS255 locus at Xp11.22 is highly polymorphic due to a 26-bp variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) motif. In previous studies, one of the MspI sites flanking the VNTR manifested a correlation between methylation and X chromosome inactivation. Here we show, by DNA sequence analysis, that this MspI site is located within the CpG island at the 5' end of a LINE-1 element, which is 2.5 kb from the VNTR. The methylation status of the CpG island was assessed in Southern blotting experiments using the methylation-sensitive enzymes HpaII, HhaI, and BssHII. All these sites were completely methylated on active X chromosomes, consistent with previously reported findings of full methylation of LINE-1 elements throughout the genome. However, on inactive X chromosomes these sites were predominantly unmethylated, although patterns were found to be heterogeneous. The results suggest that LINE-1 elements on the inactive X chromosome are not suppressed by full methylation of their CpG islands. The differential methylation of the DXS255 CpG island provides the basis for a highly informative X inactivation analysis system.     

Insights into X chromosome inactivation from studies of species variation, DNA methylation and replication, and vice versa

I am indebted to Mary Lyon as her X-inactivation hypothesis stimulated my mentor, Barton Childs, and in turn, myself, to think about the consequences of X-inactivation in heterozygous females. I often reread her original papers setting forth the single active X hypothesis, and still marvel at the concise and compelling exposition of the hypothesis and the logical predictions which seemed prophetic at my first reading, and have survived the test of time. My contribution to this Festschrift reviews evidence derived from studies of DNA methylation, species variation and DNA replication that reveals an important role for methylated CpG islands and suggests a role for late DNA replication in propagating X inactivation from one cell to its progeny. These studies also show that X inactivation is a powerful research tool for identifying the factors which program and maintain developmental processes.     

Sequence specificity of cytosine methylation in the DNA of the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cell line

We have determined the DNA renaturation kinetics for those DNA sequences of the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells in which enzymatic cytosine methylation occurred immediately after strand synthesis and for those in which methylation was delayed after strand synthesis. DNA sequences showing immediate or delayed methylation were found to be distributed throughout all repetition classes of the DNA of these cells, with a slight concentration of immediate methylation in moderately repetitive sequences and with delayed methylation being slightly over-represented in the highly repetitive fraction. However, DNA sequences showing both classes of methylation were represented equally in unique DNA sequences. We interpret these data to mean that the methylase acting near the replication forks (the ‘immediate’ methylase) is a relatively inefficient enzyme, missing some 20% of hemimethylated sites produced by DNA replication in these cells. We suggest that the methylase performing maintenance methylation at sites remote from the replication forks (the ‘delayed’ methylase) is simply a back-up enzyme for the first and that it has no true sequence specificity. The implications of this for the function(s) of DNA methylation in mammalian cells are discussed.     

X chromosome inactivation patterns correlate with fetal-placental anatomy in monozygotic twin pairs: implications for immune relatedness and concordance for autoimmunity.

BACKGROUND: Monozygotic (MZ) twinning is a poorly understood phenomenon that may result in subtle biologic differences between twins, despite their identical inheritance. These differences may in part account for discordant expression of disease in MZ twin pairs. Due to their stochastic nature, differences in X chromosome inactivation patterns are one source of such variation in female MZ twins. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We investigated X chromosome inactivation patterns in the blood of 41 MZ twin pairs based on methylation of the androgen receptor gene using a Hpa II-PCR assay. Twenty-six female MZ twin pairs with autoimmune disease (rheumatoid arthritis or multiple sclerosis) were studied. In addition, we studied 15 newborn female MZ twin pairs who were characterized at birth with respect to the anatomy of chorionic membranes (dichorionic versus monochorionic). RESULTS: We found a strong correlation between dichorionic fetal anatomy and differences in X chromosome inactivation patterns between members of an MZ twin pair. In contrast, all monochorionic twin pairs had closely correlated patterns of X chromosome inactivation. X chromosome inactivation patterns did not distinguish between MZ twin pairs who were concordant or discordant for autoimmune disease. CONCLUSIONS: The highly similar patterns of X chromosome inactivation among monochorionic twin pairs may result from their shared placental blood supply during intrauterine life. Alternatively, these patterns may indicate that X chromosome inactivation occurs before the twinning event in this anatomic subgroup of MZ twins. The data further suggest that these factors do not make a major contribution to the high discordance rates for autoimmune disease in MZ twin pairs.