Leaf and canopy responses to elevated CO2 in a pine forest under free-air CO2 enrichment

Physiological responses to elevated CO₂ at the leaf and canopy-level were studied in an intact pine (Pinus taeda) forest ecosystem exposed to elevated CO₂ using a free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) technique. Normalized canopy water-use of trees exposed to elevated CO₂ over an 8-day exposure period was similar to that of trees exposed to current ambient CO₂ under sunny conditions. During a portion of the exposure period when sky conditions were cloudy, CO₂-exposed trees showed minor (7%) but significant reductions in relative sap flux density compared to trees under ambient CO₂ conditions. Short-term (minutes) direct stomatal responses to elevated CO₂ were also relatively weak (5% reduction in stomatal aperture in response to high CO₂ concentrations). We observed no evidence of adjustment in stomatal conductance in foliage grown under elevated CO₂ for nearly 80 days compared to foliage grown under current ambient CO₂, so intrinsic leaf water-use efficiency at elevated CO₂ was enhanced primarily by direct responses of photosynthesis to CO₂. We did not detect statistical differences in parameters from photosynthetic responses to intercellular CO₂ (A _net-C _i curves) for Pinus taeda foliage grown under elevated CO₂ (550 mol mol^–1) for 50–80 days compared to those for foliage grown under current ambient CO₂ from similar-sized reference trees nearby. In both cases, leaf net photosynthetic rate at 550 mol mol^–1 CO₂ was enhanced by approximately 65% compared to the rate at ambient CO₂ (350 mol mol^–1). A similar level of enhancement under elevated CO₂ was observed for daily photosynthesis under field conditions on a sunny day. While enhancement of photosynthesis by elevated CO₂ during the study period appears to be primarily attributable to direct photosynthetic responses to CO₂ in the pine forest, longer-term CO₂ responses and feedbacks remain to be evaluated.     

The effect of free air carbon dioxide enrichment (FACE) and soil nitrogen availability on the photosynthetic capacity of wheat

A simple system for free air carbon dioxide enrichment (FACE) was recently developed and it is here briefly described. Such a MiniFACE system allowed the elevation of CO₂ concentration of small field plots avoiding the occurrence of large spatial and temporal fluctuations. A CO₂ enrichment field experiment was conducted in Italy in the season 1993–1994 with wheat (cv. Super-dwarf Mercia). A randomized experimental design was used with the treatment combination CO₂ × soil N, replicated twice. Gas exchange measurements showed that photosynthetic capacity was significantly decreased in plants exposed to elevated CO₂ and grown under nitrogen deficiency. Photosynthetic acclimation was, in this case, due to the occurrence of reduced rates of rubP saturated and rubP regeneration limited photosynthesis. Gas exchange measurements did not instead reveal any significant effect of elevated CO₂ on the photosynthetic capacity of leaves of plants well fertilized with nitrogen, in spite of a transitory negative effect on rubP regeneration limited photosynthesis that was detected to occur in the central part of a day with high irradiance. It is concluded that the levels of nitrogen fertilization will play a substantial role in modulating CO₂ fertilization effects on growth and yields of wheat crops under the scenario of future climate change.     

The effects of nitrogen fertilisation and elevated CO2 on the lipid biosynthesis and carbon isotopic discrimination in birch seedlings (Betula pendula)

The effects of nitrogen (N) fertilisation and elevated [CO₂] on lipid biosynthesis and carbon isotope discrimination in birch (Betula pendula Roth.) transplants were evaluated using seedlings grown with and without N fertiliser, and under two concentrations of atmospheric CO₂ (ambient and ambient+250 μmol mol^-1) in solar dome systems. N fertilisation decreased n-fatty acid chain length (18:0/16:0) and the ratios of α-linolenate (18:2)/linoleate (18:1), whereas elevated [CO₂] showed little effect on n-fatty acid chain length, but decreased the unsaturation (18:2+18:1)/18:0. Both N fertilisation and elevated [CO₂] increased the quantity of leaf wax n-alkanes, whilst reducing that of n-alkanols by 20–50%, but had no simple response in fatty acid concentrations. ¹³C enrichment by 1–2.5‰ under N fertilisation was observed, and can be attributed to both reduced leaf conductance and increased photosynthetic consumption of CO₂. Individual n-alkyl lipids of different chain length show consistent pattern of δ¹³C values within each homologue, but are in general 5–8‰ more depleted in ¹³C than the bulk tissues. Niether nitrogen fertilisation and elevated CO₂ influenced the relationship between carbon isotope discrimination of the bulk tissue and the individual lipids. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effects of elevated CO2 and nitrogen on growth ofPoa pratensis (L.)

The growth responses of a grass,Poa pratensis, to elevated CO₂ and nitrogen were investigated. Light-saturated photosynthetic rate per unit leaf area increased with exposure to elevated CO₂, while dry weight did not respond to increased CO₂. Patterns of biomass allocation within plants, including leaf area, leaf area ratio, specific leaf area, and root to shoot ratios, were not altered by elevated CO₂, but changed considerably with N treatment Shoot and whole-plant tissue N concentrations were significantly diluted by elevated CO₂ (Tukey test, P < 0.05). Total N content did not differ significantly among CO₂ treatments. The absence of a concomitant increase in N uptake under elevated CO₂ may have caused a dilution in plant tissue [N], probably negating the positive effects of increased photosynthesis on biomass accumulation.     

Interactive effects of elevated CO2 and precipitation change on leaf nitrogen of dominant Stipa L. species

Nitrogen (N) serves as an important mineral element affecting plant productivity and nutritional quality. However, few studies have addressed the interactive effects of elevated CO₂ and precipitation change on leaf N of dominant grassland genera such as Stipa L. This has restricted our understanding of the responses of grassland to climate change. We simulated the interactive effects of elevated CO₂ concentration and varied precipitation on leaf N concentration (N_mass) of four Stipa species (Stipa baicalensis, Stipa bungeana, Stipa grandis, and Stipa breviflora; the most dominant species in arid and semiarid grassland) using open-top chambers (OTCs). The relationship between the N_mass of these four Stipa species and precipitation well fits a logarithmic function. The sensitivity of these four species to precipitation change was ranked as follows: S. bungeana > S. breviflora > S. baicalensis > S. grandis. The N_mass of S. bungeana was the most sensitive to precipitation change, while S. grandis was the least sensitive among these Stipa species. Elevated CO₂ exacerbated the effect of precipitation on N_mass. N_mass decreased under elevated CO₂ due to growth dilution and a direct negative effect on N assimilation. Elevated CO₂ reduced N_mass only in a certain precipitation range for S. baicalensis (163–343 mm), S. bungeana (164–355 mm), S. grandis (148–286 mm), and S. breviflora (130–316 mm); severe drought or excessive rainfall would be expected to result in a reduced impact of elevated CO₂. Elevated CO₂ affected the N_mass of S. grandis only in a narrow precipitation range. The effect of elevated CO₂ reached a maximum when the amount of precipitation was 253, 260, 217, and 222 mm for S. baicalensis, S. bungeana, S. grandis, and S. breviflora, respectively. The N_mass of S. grandis was the least sensitive to elevated CO₂. The N_mass of S. breviflora was more sensitive to elevated CO₂ under a drought condition compared with the other Stipa species.     

The impact of salt stress on the water status of barley plants is partially mitigated by elevated CO2

With the changing climate, plants will be facing increasingly harsh environmental conditions marked by elevated salinity in the soils and elevated concentrations of CO₂ in the atmosphere. These two factors have opposite effects on water status in plants. Therefore, our objective was to determine the interaction between these two factors and to determine whether elevated [CO₂] might alleviate the adverse effects of salt stress on water status in two barley cultivars, Alpha and Iranis, by studying their relative water content and their water potential and its components, transpiration rate, hydraulic conductance, and water use efficiency. Both cultivars maintained their water status under salt stress, increasing water use efficiency and conserving a high relative water content by (1) reducing water potential via passive dehydration and active osmotic adjustment and (2) decreasing transpiration through stomatal closure and reducing hydraulic conductance. Iranis showed a greater capacity to achieve osmotic adjustment than Alpha. Under the combined conditions of salt-stress and elevated [CO₂], both cultivars (1) achieved osmotic adjustment to a greater extent than at ambient [CO₂], likely due to elevated rates of photosynthesis, and (2) decreased passive dehydration by stomatal closure, thereby maintaining a greater turgor potential, relative water content, and water use efficiency. Therefore, we found an interaction between salt stress and elevated [CO₂] with regard to water status in plants and found that elevated [CO₂] is associated with improved water status of salt-stressed barley plants.     

Interactive effects of atmospheric CO2 enrichment,salinity and flooding on growth of C3 (Elymus athericus) and C4 (Spartina anglica) salt marsh species

The growth response of Dutch salt marsh species (C₃ and C₄) to atmospheric CO₂ enrichment was investigated. Tillers of the C₃ speciesElymus athericus were grown in combinations of 380 and 720 11^-1 CO₂ and low (O) and high (300 mM NaCl) soil salinity. CO₂ enrichment increased dry matter production and leaf area development while both parameters were reduced at high salinity. The relative growth response to CO₂ enrichment was higher under saline conditions. Growth increase at elevated CO₂ was higher after 34 than 71 days. A lower response to CO₂ enrichment after 71 days was associated with a decreased specific leaf area (SLA). In two other experiments the effect of CO₂ (380 and 720 11^-1) on growth of the C₄ speciesSpartina anglica was studied. In the first experiment total plant dry weight was reduced by 20% at elevated CO₂. SLA also decreased at high CO₂. The effect of elevated CO₂ was also studied in combination with soil salinity (50 and 400 mM NaCl) and flooding. Again plant weight was reduced (10%) at elevated CO₂, except under the combined treatment high salinity/non-flooded. But these effects were not significant. High salinity reduced total plant weight while flooding had no effect. Causes of the salinity-dependent effect of CO₂ enrichment on growth and consequences of elevated CO₂ for competition between C₃ and C₄ species are discussed.     

Hemiparasite abundance in an alpine treeline ecotone increases in response to atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Populations of the annual hemiparasites Melampyrum pratense L. and Melampyrum sylvaticum L. were studied at the treeline in the Swiss Alps after 3 years of in situ CO₂ enrichment. The total density of Melampyrum doubled to an average of 44 individuals per square meter at elevated CO₂ compared to ambient CO₂. In response to elevated CO₂, the height of the more abundant and more evenly distributed M. pratense increased by 20%, the number of seeds per fruit by 21%, and the total seed dry mass per fruit by 27%, but the individual seed size did not change. These results suggest that rising atmospheric CO₂ may stimulate the reproductive output and increase the abundance of Melampyrum in the alpine treeline ecotone. Because hemiparasites can have important effects on community dynamics and ecosystem processes, notably the N cycle, changing Melampyrum abundance may potentially influence the functioning of alpine ecosystems in a future CO₂-rich atmosphere.     

Effects of CO2 and nutrient enrichment on tissue quality of two California annuals

The effects of CO₂ enrichment and soil nutrient status on tissue quality were investigated and related to the potential effect on growth and decomposition. Two California annuals, Avena fatua and Plantago erecta, were grown at ambient and ambient plus 35 Pa atmospheric CO₂ in nutrient unamended and amended serpentine soil. Elevated CO₂ led to significantly increased Avena shoot nitrogen concentrations in the nutrient amended treatment. It also led to decreased lignin concentrations in Avena roots in both nutrient treatments, and in Plantago shoots and roots with nutrient addition. Concentrations of total nonstructural carbohydrate (TNC) and carbon did not change with elevated CO₂ in either species. As a consequence of increased biomass accumulation, increased CO₂ led to larger total pools of TNC, lignin, total carbon, and total nitrogen in Avena with nutrient additions. Doubling CO₂ had no significant effect on Plantago. Given the limited changes in the compounds related to decomposibility and plant growth, effects of increased atmospheric CO₂ mediated through tissue composition on Avena and Plantago are likely to be minor and depend on site fertility. This study suggests that other factors such as litter moisture, whether or not litter is on the ground, and biomass allocation among roots and shoots, are likely to be more important in this California grassland ecosystem. CO₂ could influence those directly as well as indirectly.     

Carbon-based secondary metabolites and internal nitrogen pools in Populus nigra under Free Air CO2 Enrichment (FACE) and nitrogen fertilisation

The goal of this study was to investigate whether increased nitrogen use efficiency found in Populus nigra L. (Jean Pourtet) under elevated CO₂ would correlate with changes in the production of carbon-based secondary compounds (CBSCs). Using Free-Air CO₂ Enrichment (FACE) technology, a poplar plantation was exposed to either ambient (about 370 μmol mol⁻¹ CO₂) or elevated (about 550 μmol mol⁻¹ CO₂) [CO₂] for 5 years. After three growing seasons, the plantation was coppiced and half of the experimental plots were fertilized with nitrogen. CBSCs, total nitrogen and lignin-bound nitrogen were quantified in secondary sprouts in seasons of active growth and dormancy during 2 years after coppicing. Neither elevated CO₂ nor nitrogen fertilisation alone or in combination influenced lignin concentrations in wood. Soluble phenolics and soluble proteins in wood decreased slightly in response to elevated CO₂. Higher nitrogen supply stimulated formation of CBSCs and increased protein concentrations. Lignin-bound nitrogen in wood ranged from 0.37–1.01 mg N g⁻¹ dry mass accounting for 17–26% of total nitrogen in wood, thus, forming a sizeable nitrogen fraction resistant to chemical degradation. The concentration of this nitrogen fraction was significantly decreased by elevated CO₂, increased in response to nitrogen fertilisation and showed a significant CO₂ × fertilisation interaction. Seasonal changes markedly affected the internal nitrogen pools. Soluble proteins in wood were 52–143% higher in the dormant than in the growth season. Positive correlations existed between the biosynthesis of proteins and CBSCs. The limited responses to elevated CO₂ and nitrogen fertilisation indicate that growth and defence are well orchestrated in P. nigra and that changes in the balance of both resources—nitrogen and C—have only marginal effects on wood chemistry. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

The effect of long term CO2 enrichment on the growth,biomass partitioning and mineral nutrition of Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr.)

Sitka spruce [Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr.] seedlings were grown for 3 years in an outside control plot or in ambient (355 mol mol^-1) or elevated (ambient + 350 mol mol^-1) atmospheric CO₂ environments, within open top chambers (OTCs) at the Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Edinburgh. Sequential harvests were carried out at the end of each growing season and throughout the 1991 growing season, five in all. Plants grown in elevated CO₂ had, (i) 35 and 10% larger root/shoot ratios at the end of the first and third season, respectively, (ii) significantly higher summer leader extension relative growth rates, which declined more rapidly in early autumn than ambient grown plants, (iii) after three growing seasons a significantly increased mean annual relative growth rate, (iv) consistently lower foliar nutrient concentrations, and (v) after two growing seasons smaller total projected needle areas. Plants grown inside OTCs were taller, heavier and had a smaller root/shoot ratio than those grown outside the chambers. There was no effect of CO₂ concentration on Sitka spruce leaf characteristics, although leaf area ratio, specific leaf area and leaf weight ratio all fell throughout the course of the 3 year experiment.     

Effect of CO2 enrichment and nitrogen availability on resource acquisition and resource allocation in a grass,Bromus mollis

Summary The effects of CO₂ enrichment on the growth, biomass partitioning, photosynthetic rates, and leaf nitrogen concentration of a grass, Bromus mollis (C₃), were investigated at a favorable and a low level of nitrogen availability. Despite increases in root: shoot ratios, leaf nitrogen concentrations were decreased under CO₂ enrichment at both nitrogen levels. For the low-nitrogen treatment, this resulted in lower photosynthetic rates measured at 650 l/l for the CO₂-enriched plants, compared to photosynthetic rates measured at 350 l/l for the non-enriched plants. At higher nitrogen availability, photosynthetic rates of plants grown and measured at 650 l/l were greater than photosynthetic rates of the non-enriched plants measured at 350 l/l. Water use efficiency, however, was increased in enriched plants at both nitrogen levels. CO₂ enrichment stimulated vegetative growth at both high and low nitrogen during most of the vegetative growth phase but, at the end of the experiment, total biomass of the high and low CO₂ treatments did not differ for plants grown at low nitrogen availability. While not statistically significant, CO₂ tended to stimulate seed production at high nitrogen and to decrease it at low nitrogen.     

CO2-induced growth enhancements of co-occurring tree species decline at different rates

To elucidate how enriched CO₂ atmospheres, soil fertility, and light availability interact to influence the long-term growth of tree seedlings, six co-occurring members of temperate forest communities including ash (Fraxinus americana L.), gray birch (Betula populifolia), red maple (Acer rubrum), yellow birch (Betula alleghaniensis), striped maple (Acer pensylvanicum), and red oak (Quercus rubra L.) were raised in a glasshouse for three years in a complete factorial design. After three years of growth, plants growing in elevated CO₂ atmospheres were generally larger than those in ambient CO₂ atmospheres, however, magnitudes of CO₂-induced growth enhancements were contingent on the availability of nitrogen and light, as well as species identity. For all species, magnitudes of CO₂-induced growth enhancements after one year of growth were greater than after three years of growth, though species' growth enhancements over the three years declined at different rates. These results suggest that CO₂-induced enhancements in forest productivity may not be sustained for long periods of time. Additionally, species' differential growth responses to elevated CO₂ may indirectly influence forest productivity via long-term species compositional changes in forests.     

Acclimation response of spring wheat in a free-air CO2 enrichment (FACE) atmosphere with variable soil nitrogen regimes. 2. Net assimilation and stomatal conductance of leaves

Atmospheric CO₂ concentration continues to rise. It is important, therefore, to determine what acclimatory changes will occur within the photosynthetic apparatus of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv. Yecora Rojo) grown in a future high-CO₂ world at ample and limited soil N contents. Wheat was grown in an open field exposed to the CO₂ concentration of ambient air [370 μmol (CO₂) mol⁻¹; Control] and air enriched to ∼200 μmol (CO₂) mol⁻¹ above ambient using a Free-Air CO₂ Enrichment (FACE) apparatus (main plot). A High (35 g m⁻²) or Low (7 and 1.5 g m⁻² for 1996 and 1997, respectfully) level of N was applied to each half of the main CO₂ treatment plots (split-plot). Under High-N, FACE reduced stomatal conductance (g _s) by 30% at mid-morning (2 h prior to solar noon), 36% at midday (solar noon) and 27% at mid-afternoon (2.5 h after solar noon), whereas under Low-N, g _s was reduced by as much as 31% at mid-morning, 44% at midday and 28% at mid-afternoon compared with Control. But, no significant CO₂ × N interaction effects occurred. Across seasons and growth stages, daily accumulation of carbon (A′) was 27% greater in FACE than Control. High-N increased A′ by 18% compared with Low-N. In contrast to results for g _s, however, significant CO₂ × N interaction effects occurred because FACE increased A′ by 30% at High-N, but by only 23% at Low-N. FACE enhanced the seasonal accumulation of carbon (A′′) by 29% during 1996 (moderate N-stress), but by only 21% during 1997 (severe N-stress). These results support the premise that in a future high-CO₂ world an acclimatory (down-regulation) response in the photosynthetic apparatus of field-grown wheat is anticipated. They also demonstrate, however, that the stimulatory effect of a rise in atmospheric CO₂ on carbon gain in wheat can be maintained if nutrients such as nitrogen are in ample supply. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Above- and belowground response of Populus grandidentata to elevated atmospheric CO2 and soil N availability

Soil N availability may play an important role in regulating the long-term responses of plants to rising atmospheric CO₂ partial pressure. To further examine the linkage between above- and belowground C and N cycles at elevated CO₂, we grew clonally propagated cuttings of Populus grandidentata in the field at ambient and twice ambient CO₂ in open bottom root boxes filled with organic matter poor native soil. Nitrogen was added to all root boxes at a rate equivalent to net N mineralization in local dry oak forests. Nitrogen added during August was enriched with ¹⁵N to trace the flux of N within the plant-soil system. Above-and belowground growth, CO₂ assimilation, and leaf N content were measured non-destructively over 142 d. After final destructive harvest, roots, stems, and leaves were analyzed for total N and ¹⁵N. There was no CO₂ treatment effect on leaf area, root length, or net assimilation prior to the completion of N addition. Following the N addition, leaf N content increased in both CO₂ treatments, but net assimilation showed a sustained increase only in elevated CO₂ grown plants. Root relative extension rate was greater at elevated CO₂, both before and after the N addition. Although final root biomass was greater at elevated CO₂, there was no CO₂ effect on plant N uptake or allocation. While low soil N availability severely inhibited CO₂ responses, high CO₂ grown plants were more responsive to N. This differential behavior must be considered in light of the temporal and spatial heterogeneity of soil resources, particularly N which often limits plant growth in temperate forests.