Prediction of mean skin temperature in warm environments

The data collected by the authors in four experimental series have been analysed together with data from the literature, to study the relationship between mean skin temperature and climatic parameters, subject metabolic rate and clothing insulation. The subjects involved in the various studies were young male subjects, unacclimatized to heat. The range of conditions examined involved mean skin temperatures between 33 degrees C and 38 degrees C, air temperatures (Ta) between 23 degrees C and 50 degrees C, ambient water vapour pressures (Pa) between 1 and 4.8 kPa, air velocities (Va) between 0.2 and 0.9 m.s-1, metabolic rates (M) between 50 and 270 W.m-2, and Clo values between 0.1 and 0.6. In 95% of the data, mean radiant temperature was within +/- 3 degrees C of air temperature. Based on 190 data averaged over individual values, the following equation was derived by a multiple linear regression technique: Tsk = 30.0 + 0.138 Ta + 0.254 Pa-0.57 Va + 1.28.10(-3) M-0.553 Clo. This equation was used to predict mean skin temperature from 629 individual data. The difference between observed and predicted values was within +/- 0.6 degrees C in 70% of the cases and within +/- 1 degrees C in 90% of the cases. It is concluded that the proposed formula may be used to predict mean skin temperature with satisfactory accuracy in nude to lightly clad subjects exposed to warm ambient conditions with no significant radiant heat load.     

Mean skin temperature in warm humid climates

Mean skin temperature (Tsk) was measured in 24 subjects during experiments in a climatic chamber. Three conditions of ambient temperature (Ta = 25.6 degrees, 28.9 degrees and 32.2 degrees C), and three of humidity (relative humidity = 50%, 70% and 90%) were studied. A relationship was established by a linear regression technique. It is valid in the 24 degree-34 degree C range, for air velocity = 0.2 m.s-1, clothing insulation = 0.077 degrees C.m2.w-1 (0.5 clo), metabolic rate = 64 w.m-2 (1.1 met) and radiant temperature = air temperature. In these conditions Tsk = 28.125 + 0.021 Pw + 0.210 Ta (Pw: ambient water vapour pressure in mb). It shows a small humidity influence. The influences of sex, transition from one condition to the next, and air velocity were also studied. Measurements in Africa confirmed the small influence of humidity. Ethnic life-style differences indicated that a high precision in Tsk determination is difficult to achieve.     

TLV in cold environments

1. 1. The risks encountered during cold exposure are general body cooling or local cooling of parts of th body.

2. 2. Measures of cold stress must account for the effects of climate, clothing and metabolic heat production on heat balance.

3. 3. The combinaed effect of air temperature, mean radiant temperature, humidity and air velocity determines the cooling power of the environment.

4. 4. The cooling power can be easily converted into a required insulation value (IREQ) for whole body heat balance.

5. 5. Extensive cooling of hands and feet may be a limiting factor, even when sufficient total insulation is provided. In addition the cooling effect of wind on unprotected skin must be considered.

6. 6. Recommendation regarding acceptable exposures can be expressed as lowest ambient temperatures and time limits as function of available protection and activity level, with due attention to both general and local effects.

A model of evaporation from the skin while wearing protective clothing

 A simple model was developed to describe the transport of water vapour from subjects working in hot environments while wearing chemical-protective clothing. The goal of the modelling was to obtain a better estimate of evaporative cooling of the subjects, as it was hypothesised that calculations of evaporative heat loss based on changes in dressed weight over-estimate the actual benefit experienced by the subjects. The model employed measured values of vapour pressure within the clothing ensemble to estimate the skin vapour pressure. The resistance of the clothing ensemble to water vapour transport was calculated from measurements of the physical properties of the materials in conjunction with estimates of the resistance of air layers between the clothing layers. The model predicts mean evaporation rates from the skin that are approximately 60% of those calculated from measured changes in dressed weight. Error analysis failed to account for the magnitude of this difference and possible explanations for the difference are advanced. A brief examination of the effect of wicking suggests that some of the difference results from a reduction of the resistance of the garment to water vapour due to wicking of liquid sweat through fabric layers. Received: 4 June 1997 / Accepted: 21 October 1997     

Simulation of sensible and latent heat losses from wet-skin surface and fur layer

A simulation model that simultaneously calculates heat and mass transfer from a wetted skin surface and fur layer of a cow is presented. The model predicts evaporative, convective and radiant heat losses for different levels of skin and fur wetness, air velocity, air temperature and relative humidity. In the model, fur layer (hair coat) properties such as fur thickness and hair density assumed are that of summer conditions. Evaporative cooling from wet-skin surface and hair coat is the dominant mode of heat mitigation mechanism in stressful hot environments and is further enhanced by increased air velocity. Evaporative cooling is, however, depressed by increased relative humidity because of deficit of water-vapor concentration between the skin surface and ambient air.     

Predicting urban outdoor thermal comfort by the Universal Thermal Climate Index UTCI—a case study in Southern Brazil

Recognising that modifications to the physical attributes of urban space are able to promote improved thermal outdoor conditions and thus positively influence the use of open spaces, a survey to define optimal thermal comfort ranges for passers-by in pedestrian streets was conducted in Curitiba, Brazil. We applied general additive models to study the impact of temperature, humidity, and wind, as well as long-wave and short-wave radiant heat fluxes as summarised by the recently developed Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI) on the choice of clothing insulation by fitting LOESS smoothers to observations from 944 males and 710 females aged from 13 to 91 years. We further analysed votes of thermal sensation compared to predictions of UTCI. The results showed that females chose less insulating clothing in warm conditions compared to males and that observed values of clothing insulation depended on temperature, but also on season and potentially on solar radiation. The overall pattern of clothing choice was well reflected by UTCI, which also provided for good predictions of thermal sensation votes depending on the meteorological conditions. Analysing subgroups indicated that the goodness-of-fit of the UTCI was independent of gender and age, and with only limited influence of season and body composition as assessed by body mass index. This suggests that UTCI can serve as a suitable planning tool for urban thermal comfort in sub-tropical regions.     

A computer model of human thermoregulation for a wide range of environmental conditions: the passive system.

A dynamic model predicting human thermal responses in cold, cool, neutral, warm, and hot environments is presented in a two-part study. This, the first paper, is concerned with aspects of the passive system: 1) modeling the human body, 2) modeling heat-transport mechanisms within the body and at its periphery, and 3) the numerical procedure. A paper in preparation will describe the active system and compare the model predictions with experimental data and the predictions by other models. Here, emphasis is given to a detailed modeling of the heat exchange with the environment: local variations of surface convection, directional radiation exchange, evaporation and moisture collection at the skin, and the nonuniformity of clothing ensembles. Other thermal effects are also modeled: the impact of activity level on work efficacy and the change of the effective radiant body area with posture. A stable and accurate hybrid numerical scheme was used to solve the set of differential equations. Predictions of the passive system model are compared with available analytic solutions for cylinders and spheres and show good agreement and stable numerical behavior even for large time steps.     

Preferred temperature of the elderly after cold and heat exposures determined by individual self-selection of air temperature

1. 1. The purpose of the study was to investigate the preferred temperature of the elderly after cold and heat exposures.

2. 2. Eight elderly and 9 young females wearing the same type of clothing were exposed to cold (10°C), moderate (25°C) or hot (35°C) environments for 30 min in the exposure room.

3. 3. Then they moved to the self-control room in which the temperature was set at 25°C, and the room temperature increased or decreased continuously by 0.4°C every minute.

4. 4. The subjects were instructed to operate the switch when they felt uncomfortably warm or cool during a 90-min period.

5. 5. In operating the switch, the changing in room temperature shifted to the opposite direction.

6. 6. The ambient temperature was recorded continuously and analyzed as the preferred temperature, which was defined as the midpoint temperature of the crest and trough of temperature records.

7. 7. The preferred temperatures after the cold exposure were significantly higher than those of other exposure conditions in the elderly.

8. 8. On the other hand, in the young, there was no significant difference in the preferred temperature among the exposure conditions.

9. 9. Although the effect of exposure to cold or hot environments decreased in the latter parts of self-control, the elderly still preferred the higher temperature after cold exposure.

Thermal interaction between animal and microclimate: a comprehensive model

An equation based on heat transfer theory is developed to predict the rate of heat loss from a homeothermic vertebrate to the environment, specified by the air temperature, humidity, windspeed and radiation receipt. The analysis incorporates the animal's thermoregulatory responses--sweating ability, vasomotor action, and regulation of body-core temperature, metabolic and respiratory rate. The loss of heat and water vapour from cattle is used as an illustration, and particular attention is given to their heat balance in hot environments. The predicted rates of heat loss from cattle indoors at various air temperatures and humidities are consistent with experiments. Outdoors, intercepted solar radiation can reduce substantially heat loss through the body tissue when the air temperature is low. In contrast, at high air temperatures the heat dissipation may not be sensitive to the radiation load, although body-core temperature is. Increased rates of air movement can aggravate strain at low air temperatures, but mitigate strain in a hot environment.     

The relationship between environmental temperature and clothing insulation across a year

People adapt to thermal environments, such as the changing seasons, predominantly by controlling the amount of clothing insulation, usually in the form of the clothing that they wear. The aim of this study was to determine the actual daily clothing insulation on sedentary human subjects across the seasons. Thirteen females and seven males participated in experiments from January to December in a thermal chamber. Adjacent months were grouped in pairs to give six environmental conditions: (1) January/February = 5°C; (2) March/April = 14°C; (3) May/June = 25°C; (4) July/August = 29°C; (5) September/October = 23°C; (6) November/December = 8°C. Humidity(45 ± 5%) and air velocity(0.14 ± 0.01 m/s) were constant across all six experimental conditions. Participants put on their own clothing that allowed them to achieve thermal comfort for each air temperature, and sat for 60 min (1Met). The clothing insulation (clo) required by these participants had a significant relationship with air temperature: insulation was reduced as air temperature increased. The range of clothing insulation for each condition was 1.87–3.14 clo at 5°C(Jan/Feb), 1.62–2.63 clo at 14°C(Mar/Apr), 0.87–1.59 clo at 25°C(May/Jun), 0.4–1.01 clo at 29°C(Jul/Aug), 0.92–1.81 clo at 23°C (Sept/Oct), and 2.12–3.09 clo at 8°C(Nov/Dec) for females, and 1.84–2.90 clo at 5°C, 1.52–1.98 clo at 14°C, 1.04–1.23 clo at 25°C, 0.51–1.30 clo at 29°C, 0.82–1.45 clo at 23°C and 1.96–3.53 clo at 8°C for males. The hypothesis was that thermal insulation of free living clothing worn by sedentary Korean people would vary across seasons. For Korean people, a comfortable air temperature with clothing insulation of 1 clo was approximately 27°C. This is greater than the typical comfort temperature for 1 clo. It was also found that women clearly increased their clothing insulation level of their clothing as winter approached but did not decrease it by the same amount when spring came.     

Modelling occupants’ personal characteristics for thermal comfort prediction

Based on results from a field survey campaign conducted in Switzerand, we show that occupants’ variations in clothing choices, which are relatively unconstrained, are best described by the daily mean outdoor temperature and that major clothing adjustments occur rarely during the day. We then develop an ordinal logistic model of the probability distribution of discretised clothing levels, which results in a concise and informative expression of occupants’ clothing choices. Results from both cross-validation and independent verification suggest that this model formulation may be used with confidence. Furthermore, the form of the model is readily generalisable, given the requisite calibration data, to environments where dress codes are more specific. We also observe that, for these building occupants, the prevailing metabolic activity levels are mostly constant for the whole range of surveyed environmental conditions, as their activities are relatively constrained by the tasks in hand. Occupants may compensate for this constraint, however, through the consumption of cold and hot drinks, with corresponding impacts on metabolic heat production. Indeed, cold drink consumption was found to be highly correlated with indoor thermal conditions, whilst hot drink consumption is best described by a seasonal variable. These variables can be used for predictive purposes using binary logistic models.     

The UTCI-clothing model

The Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI) was conceived as a thermal index covering the whole climate range from heat to cold. This would be impossible without considering clothing as the interface between the person (here, the physiological model of thermoregulation) and the environment. It was decided to develop a clothing model for this application in which the following three factors were considered: (1) typical dressing behaviour in different temperatures, as observed in the field, resulting in a model of the distribution of clothing over the different body segments in relation to the ambient temperature, (2) the changes in clothing insulation and vapour resistance caused by wind and body movement, and (3) the change in wind speed in relation to the height above ground. The outcome was a clothing model that defines in detail the effective clothing insulation and vapour resistance for each of the thermo-physiological model’s body segments over a wide range of climatic conditions. This paper details this model’s conception and documents its definitions.     

A canine thermal model for simulating temperature responses of military working dogs

Military working dogs (MWDs) are often required to operate in dangerous or extreme environments, to include hot and humid climate conditions. These scenarios can put MWD at significant risk of heat injury. To address this concern, a two-compartment (core, skin) rational thermophysiological model was developed to predict the temperature of a MWD during rest, exercise, and recovery. The Canine Thermal Model (CTM) uses inputs of MWD mass and length to determine a basal metabolic rate and body surface area. These calculations are used along with time series inputs of environmental conditions (air temperature, relative humidity, solar radiation and wind velocity) and level of metabolic intensity (MET) to predict MWD thermoregulatory responses. Default initial values of core and skin temperatures are set at neutral values representative of an average MWD; however, these can be adjusted to match known or expected individual temperatures. The rational principles of the CTM describe the heat exchange from the metabolic energy of the core compartment to the skin compartment by passive conduction as well as the application of an active control for skin blood flow and to tongue and lingual tissues. The CTM also mathematically describes heat loss directly to the environment via respiration, including panting. Thermal insulation properties of MWD fur are also used to influence heat loss from skin and gain from the environment. This paper describes the CTM in detail, outlining the equations used to calculate avenues of heat transfer (convective, conductive, radiative and evaporative), overall heat storage, and predicted responses of the MWD. Additionally, this paper outlines examples of how the CTM can be used to predict recovery from exertional heat strain, plan work/rest cycles, and estimate work duration to avoid overheating.     

Estimation of thermal sensation using PMV and SET under high air movement conditions

1. 1. Our previous experimental results showed the thermal sensation vote was much less than the values of PMV and SET^* at air velocities above 0.5 m/s.

2. 2. The method to modify SET^* is presented from the results of subjective experiments taking account of decrease in clo value of summer clothing and decrease in skin wettedness due to increased air velocity.

3. 3. Thermal resistance under increased air movement on a standard summer clothing ensemble was measured. Basic thermal insulation of the summer ensemble was reduced by 25% at air velocity of 1.0 m/s.

4. 4. Thirty-two subjects were exposed at operative temperatures of 27 and 30°C under 1 m/s air movement in order to determine the amount of skin diffusion. Measured evaporation heat loss from skin surface was much smaller at air velocity of 1 m/s than that predicted by SET^*.

5. 5. Estimated thermal sensation vote using modified SET^* agreed well with our previous experimental results under different air velocities for the same clothing.

Prediction of air temperature for thermal comfort of people in outdoor environments

Current thermal comfort indices do not take into account the effects of wind and body movement on the thermal resistance and vapor resistance of clothing. This may cause public health problem, e.g. cold-related mortality. Based on the energy balance equation and heat exchanges between a clothed body and the outdoor environment, a mathematical model was developed to determine the air temperature at which an average adult, wearing a specific outdoor clothing and engaging in a given activity, attains thermal comfort under outdoor environment condition. The results indicated low clothing insulation, less physical activity and high wind speed lead to high air temperature prediction for thermal comfort. More accurate air temperature prediction is able to prevent wearers from hypothermia under cold conditions.     

Thermoregulatory and subjective responses of clothed men in the cold during continuous and intermittent exercise

Thermoregulatory and thermal subjective responses were studied in ten male, clothed subjects during continuous (C) and intermittent (I) exercise at the same average level of oxygen consumption. The subjects performed both I and C twice, dressed in two different three-layer cold-protective clothing ensembles of two thermal insulation levels [total clothing insulation = 2.59 clo (L) and 3.20 clo (H)]. Experiments were carried out at an ambient temperature of -10 degrees C. Rectal temperatures increased similarly in both types of exercise. Mean skin temperature (Tsk) was lower in I compared to C with both levels of clothing insulation. Over the last 0.5 h of the experiment Tsk was approximately 1.3 degrees C lower in I than in C for clothing L. The skin evaporation rate was higher in clothing H than L but did not differ between I and C. Subjective ratings for thermal sensations of the whole body (BTS) and hands were close to neutral in I and around slightly warm in C. The BTS was lower in I than in C and was lower in L compared to H. It was concluded that, at equal average energy expenditure, thermal responses to intermittent and continuous exercise in the cold differ in clothed subjects, principally as a result of different patterns of heat exchange.     

Intermittent wetting clothing as a cooling strategy for body heat strain alleviation of vulnerable populations during a severe heatwave incident

Many documented studies have demonstrated the human mortality rate increases during severe heatwaves. There remains a need for further explore ecologically valid cooling strategies to alleviate body heat strain during extreme heatwaves. The main aim of this work was to explore whether intermittent wetting clothing can be served as an ecologically valid cooling strategy to mitigate heat stress on inactive vulnerable populations not having access to air-conditioning during a severe heatwave. Ten young male subjects underwent two 90-min separate trials: a dry clothing trial (i.e., CON) and a wetted clothing cooling trial (i.e., WEC). A set of light summer wear was chosen and intermittently wetted by tap water at intervals of every 30 min. Physiological and perceptual responses of subjects were examined and compared. All trials were performed in a chamber with an air temperature of 43 ± 0.5 °C, RH= 57 ± 5% and an air velocity of 0.15 ± 0.05 m/s (WBGT=37.35 °C). Results demonstrated that WEC, compared with CON, could significantly reduce both the mean skin temperature and the core temperature throughout the 5–90th min and 25–90th min of the trial, respectively (p < 0.05). Besides, WEC could also remarkable reduce local skin temperatures at those body sites covered by wet clothing (p < 0.05). In comparison, no significant difference was found between WEC and CON on perceptual responses. Further, it was also found from PHS simulations that conditions with a partial water vapour pressure ≤ 3.1–3.5 kPa would not induce pronounced core temperature rises at 43 °C. Finally, it may be concluded that intermittent wetting clothing could be served as an ecologically valid cooling strategy to reduce thermophysiological strain of vulnerable populations while seating during humid heatwaves and thereby improve their health and safety.     

Thermal equilibrium of goats

The effects of air temperature and relative humidity on thermal equilibrium of goats in a tropical region was evaluated. Nine non-pregnant Anglo Nubian nanny goats were used in the study. An indirect calorimeter was designed and developed to measure oxygen consumption, carbon dioxide production, methane production and water vapour pressure of the air exhaled from goats. Physiological parameters: rectal temperature, skin temperature, hair-coat temperature, expired air temperature and respiratory rate and volume as well as environmental parameters: air temperature, relative humidity and mean radiant temperature were measured. The results show that respiratory and volume rates and latent heat loss did not change significantly for air temperature between 22 and 26 °C. In this temperature range, metabolic heat was lost mainly by convection and long-wave radiation. For temperature greater than 30 °C, the goats maintained thermal equilibrium mainly by evaporative heat loss. At the higher air temperature, the respiratory and ventilation rates as well as body temperatures were significantly elevated. It can be concluded that for Anglo Nubian goats, the upper limit of air temperature for comfort is around 26 °C when the goats are protected from direct solar radiation.     

Indoor climate and air quality

 In industrialized countries about 90% of the time is spent indoors. The ambient parameters affecting indoor thermal comfort are air temperature and humidity, air velocity, and radiant heat exchange within an enclosure. In assessing the thermal environment, one needs to consider all ambient parameters, the insulating properties of the occupants’ clothing, and the activity level of the occupants by means of heat balance models of the human body. Apart from thermal parameters, air quality (measured and perceived) is also of importance for well-being and health in indoor environments. Pollutant levels are influenced by both outdoor concentrations and by indoor emissions. Indoor levels can thus be lower (e.g. in the case of ozone and SO₂) or higher (e.g. for CO₂ and formaldehyde) than outdoor levels. Emissions from cooking play an important role, especially in developing countries. The humidity of the ambient air has a wide range of effects on the energy and water balance of the body as well as on elasticity, air quality perception, build-up of electrostatic charge and the formation or mould. However, its effect on the indoor climate is often overestimated. While air-handling systems are commonly used for achieving comfortable indoor climates, their use has also been linked to a variety of problems, some of which have received attention within the context of ”sick building syndrome”. Received: 27 October 1997 / Accepted 26 November 1997     

Phenotypic flexibility in the metabolic response of the limpet Cellana tramoserica to thermally different microhabitats

Temperature determines all physiological responses by limiting cellular reaction rates. Daily temperature variation differs between microhabitats, which means that subpopulations of the same species may respond differently to temperature. The aim of this study is to determine how physiological responses to temperature of the limpet Cellana tramoserica differ between limpets from variable and from stable thermal environments. Oxygen consumption and anaerobic and aerobic metabolic capacities were measured over a range of temperatures in limpets from thermally stable and variable field sites in summer and winter, and in laboratory acclimation treatments. Limpets from both variable and stable sites, showed acclimatisation of anaerobic and aerobic potentials. Limpets from stable environments, but not from variable environments, showed increased oxygen consumption in winter. Comparison of field and laboratory data showed that temperature was the signal for acclimatisation. The physiological response of C. tramoserica to temperature depends on season and microhabitat. Care must therefore be taken when conducting interspecies comparisons of response to temperature to address the confounding effects of phenotypic plasticity. Differences in physiological response to temperature in phenotypically flexible species like C. tramoserica may simply reflect individual reactions to immediate environmental conditions.