A proposal for the use of advance directives in the treatment of incompetent mentally ill persons

[M]y question is how these patients while competent might be able to give their own informed consent to treatment, despite being both unwilling and incompetent to do so when treatment is to be begun, thereby reducing the need to relax the dangerousness criteria for involuntary commitment. It is uncontroversial that the dangerousness requirement would be too restrictive for all treatment of mental illness. When competent patients voluntarily seek and/or accept treatment for their mental illness, neither public policy nor medical practice restricts treatment to those patients judged to be dangerous. Instead, criteria should be and generally are comparable to those for the treatment of physical illness -- whether the patient is ill, in this case mentally ill, and likely to benefit from treatment. Through use of advance directives, it would be possible for mentally ill persons who are currently refusing treatment to give prior consent, while competent and with their disease in remission, to treatment at a later time when they are incompetent, have become noncompliant, and are refusing treatment. My proposal is certainly not entirely novel, since others have made similar proposals under the heading of Ulysses contracts and voluntary commitment contracts. Addressing briefly some of the criticisms of these earlier proposals will bring out one fundamental difference between them and my proposal here for a new use of advance directives -- whether the patient must then be incompetent when the contract or directive made earlier is later invoked -- a difference I shall argue strongly favors my proposal.     

Adaptation of children to a chronically ill or mentally handicapped sibling.

The presence of a chronically ill or mentally handicapped child in a family can be a stress for the child''s siblings, who often are ill informed about the nature and prognosis of the illness, may be uncertain what is expected of them in the caregiving role, may feel their own identities threatened, and may experience ostracism by their friends and misunderstanding at school. Although individual reactions vary widely, feelings of anger, guilt, resentment and shame are commonly reported. Excessive responsibility and concern about one''s identity may add to these feelings and culminate in psychologic problems in the sibling. The physician caring for the family must be alert for symptoms of emotional disturbance or social maladjustment among the siblings of chronically ill or mentally handicapped children and should be prepared to counsel the family or refer them to a counsellor experienced in this area. In general, the first step is to be sure that the sibling is fully informed about the condition and to encourage frank discussion between the parents and the handicapped child''s siblings.     

Area security unit in a psychiatric hospital.

Since 1974 a psychiatric hospital security unit, designed to serve the whole catchment area, has cared for mentally ill (mostly psychotic) patients with disturbed behaviour that cannot be managed in open wards. There are a few long-term dangerous patients but most stay only briefly. The admission of women to the unit was not followed by the expected reduction in violence. The unit has facilities for occupational therapy, physical recreation, work, and study, which are particularly important for those who are too dangerous to leave it. The unit''s calming influence depends as much on the supportive effect of the high staff ratio as on the use of tranquillisers. This type of unit is not suitable for patients with personality disturbances who "act out" or for mentally abnormal offenders; but it functions well as a crisis centre for the disturbed mentally ill, and there is an increasing demand for its services.     

Impact of an integrated service system on client outcomes by gender in a national sample of a mentally ill homeless population

Background: Homeless populations with concurrent mental illness have a complex array of service needs that are often addressed in a haphazard or uncoordinated manner. Information is lacking about the effectiveness of programs and public policy in women who are both homeless and mentally ill.Objective: This study assessed the impact of gender on the outcomes of a multisite public policy intervention that implemented components of an integrated service delivery system to address the needs of mentally ill homeless men and women.Methods: A secondary analysis was performed using longitudinal data obtained from homeless men and women in the Access to Community Care and Effective Services and Supports prospective study, which was conducted at 18 sites across the United States. Outcome data from baseline, 3, 12, and 18 months across 5 annual cohorts were analyzed to determine the impact of gender on 6 clinical outcomes, including days of housing, relationships, victimization, social support, alcohol use, and drug use, in homeless men and women with mental illness. The analysis plan included multilevel modeling of longitudinal data.Results: Data were analyzed from a total of 7229 participants, including 4502 men (62%)) (mean age, 38.2 years) and 2727 women (38%) (mean age, 37.2 years). After 18 months of follow-up, women had significantly better outcomes in terms of family relationships (estimated mean score increased 0.100), victimization (score decreased 0.164), and social support (score increased 0.363) than did men (aall, P < 0.001). Being accompanied by children was significantly associated with less change in drug use among women compared with men (P < 0.01). These outcomes were the same across all 18 program sites.Conclusion: Although the addition of services for the homeless in conjunction with clinical and support services offered by case managers had generally positive effects in this study's population, a gender-specific substance abuse treatment intervention should also be included in a comprehensive program for homeless women with mental illness.     

Prevalence of Mental Illness among Homeless People in Hong Kong

MetholodogyThis study examined the prevalence and correlates of mental illness in homeless people in Hong Kong and explored the barriers preventing their access to health care. Ninety-seven Cantonese-speaking Chinese who were homeless during the study period were selected at random from the records of the three organisations serving the homeless population. The response rate was 69%. Seventeen subjects could not give valid consent due to their poor mental state, so their responses were excluded from the data analysis. A psychiatrist administered the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis-I disorders (SCID-I) and the Mini -Mental State Examination. Consensus diagnoses for subjects who could not complete the SCID-I were established by three independent psychiatrists.FindingsThe point prevalence of mental illness was 56%. Seventy-one percent of the subjects had a lifetime history of mental illness, 30% had a mood disorder, 25% had an alcohol use disorder, 25% had a substance use disorder, 10% had a psychotic disorder, 10% had an anxiety disorder and 6% had dementia. Forty-one percent of the subjects with mental illness had undergone a previous psychiatric assessment. Only 13% of the subjects with mental illness were receiving psychiatric care at the time of interview. The prevalence of psychotic disorders, dementia and the rate of under treatment are hugely underestimated, as a significant proportion (18%) of the subjects initially selected were too ill to give consent to join the study.ConclusionThe low treatment rate and the presence of this severely ill and unreached group of homeless people reflect the fact that the current mode of service delivery is failing to support the most severely ill homeless individuals.     

Mentally abnormal prisoners on remand: I—Rejected or accepted by the NHS?

Increasing numbers of mentally abnormal offenders are sentenced to prison. The decision to treat or imprison them is influenced by the attitudes of consultant psychiatrists and their staff. The process whereby those decisions were made and the willingness of consultants to offer treatment were investigated. A retrospective survey of all (362) mentally abnormal men remanded to Winchester prison for psychiatric reports over the five years 1979-83 showed that one in five were rejected for treatment by the NHS consultant psychiatrist responsible for their care. Those with mental handicaps, organic brain damage, or a chronic psychotic illness rendering them unable to cope independently in the community were the most likely to be rejected. They posed the least threat to the community in terms of their criminal behaviour yet were more likely to be sentenced to imprisonment. Such subjects were commonly described by consultants as too disturbed or potentially dangerous to be admitted to hospital or as criminals and unsuitable for treatment. Consultants in mental hospitals were most likely and those in district general hospitals and academic units least likely to accept prisoners.The fact that many mentally ill and mentally handicapped patients can receive adequate care and treatment only on reception into prison raises serious questions about the adequacy of current management policies and the range of facilities provided by regional health authorities.     

Prevention of suicide.

We reviewed the epidemiologic features of suicide in Canada and evaluated suicide prevention programs. Three groups were found to be at increased risk for suicide: men aged 70 years or more, women aged 65 to 69 and men aged 20 to 24. The other groups, in decreasing order of risk, were the mentally ill, people who have attempted suicide, those with a life-threatening illness, native people, people with a family history of suicide and prisoners. Studies that evaluated suicide prevention programs showed that none significantly reduced the incidence of suicide; however, the studies were found to be methodologically inadequate or used noncomparable systems of data collection. On the basis of our findings we recommend that primary care physicians routinely evaluate suicide risk among patients in high-risk groups and that intervention include counselling, follow-up and, if necessary, referral to a psychiatrist. Close follow-up is recommended for newly discharged psychiatric patients and those who recently attempted suicide.     

Development of a culture specific (Nigeria) screening scale of somatic complaints indicating psychiatric disturbance

In a pre-study it was seen that somatization complaints formed the basis of the distress of the mentally ill in Nigeria and there was need for somatic complaints to be employed in evolving a psychodiagnostic system which would lead to a better understanding of mental illness in Nigeria. In pursuit of this goal, some 65 somatic complaints were drawn from protocols of patients treated at the Psychiatric Hospital, Enugu, from 1978–1981. These complaints were administered in form of questions to 179 psychiatric patients and 349 students (normals) of the Institute of Management and Technology, Enugu. Forty-six of the 65 complaints distinguished male normals from the psychiatric patients and 30 items of the 65 distinguished the female normals from the female psychiatric patients at the 0.05 level or better. In a further step each subject was rated. A positive response to each of the discriminant items was scored as one point. The mean, standard deviation and cumulative frequency percentage of both groups were calculated. These values are recommended for use in discriminating normals from the mentally ill in Nigeria. This study is seen as a first step leading towards a much wider study involving somatizations in a psychodiagnostic endeavor, as well as throwing more light into the problem of classification of psychiatric disorders in Nigeria.     

Violence and psychosis. II--Effect of psychiatric diagnosis on conviction and sentencing of offenders.

An examination of the records of all sick and violent men remanded to a large English prison suggested a tendency among police to consider men to be exceptionally dangerous simply because of their mental illness. On further study, however, there was no evidence that the mentally ill were more vulnerable to detention without subsequent conviction than their normal peers. Remand was rarely followed by help for the mentally abnormal men studied; this is disturbing as requests for psychiatric help constitute an important reason for custodial remand. Less than a third of the men with active symptoms went to hospital, although some of the less disturbed received supervision (including probation) orders, occasionally with treatment. As there is evidence that most of the few mentally abnormal offenders who subsequently receive treatment benefit from it, psychiatrists should do more for offender patients.     

Productivity cost due to maternal ill health in sri lanka

Background

The global impact of maternal ill health on economic productivity is estimated to be over 15 billion USD per year. Global data on productivity cost associated with maternal ill health are limited to estimations based on secondary data. Purpose of our study was to determine the productivity cost due to maternal ill health during pregnancy in Sri Lanka.

Methods and Findings

We studied 466 pregnant women, aged 24 to 36 weeks, residing in Anuradhapura, Sri Lanka. A two stage cluster sampling procedure was used in a cross sectional design and all pregnant women were interviewed at clinic centers, using the culturally adapted Immpact tool kit for productivity cost assessment. Of the 466 pregnant women studied, 421 (90.3%) reported at least one ill health condition during the pregnancy period, and 353 (83.8%) of them had conditions affecting their daily life. Total incapacitation requiring another person to carry out all their routine activities was reported by 122 (26.1%) of the women. In this study sample, during the last episode of ill health, total number of days lost due to absenteeism was 3,356 (32.9% of total loss) and the days lost due to presenteeism was 6,832.8 (67.1% of the total loss). Of the 353 women with ill health conditions affecting their daily life, 280 (60%) had coping strategies to recover loss of productivity. Of the coping strategies used to recover productivity loss during maternal ill health, 76.8% (n = 215) was an intra-household adaptation, and 22.8% (n = 64) was through social networks. Loss of productivity was 28.9 days per episode of maternal ill health. The mean productivity cost due to last episode of ill health in this sample was Rs.8,444.26 (95% CI-Rs.6888.74-Rs.9999.78).

Conclusions

Maternal ill health has a major impact on household productivity and economy. The major impact is due to, generally ignored minor ailments during pregnancy.     

Thoughts on malaria in pregnancy with consideration of some factors which influence remedial strategies

There is evidence that pregnancy enhances the clinical severity of malaria, especially of P. falciparum infections. In pregnant women with little or no prior experience of the disease, P. falciparum causes severe clinical illness, substantial malaria mortality, increased rates of abortion and stillbirth and low birthweight of offspring; moreover, in such women, the clinical consequences seen unmodified by maternal parity. However, in pregnant women resident in highly endemic areas who have acquired considerable immunity through prolonged prior contact with malaria, parity appears to influence susceptibility to an important degree. Women who are pregnant for the first time are most affected, showing increased prevalence and density of parasitaemia, increased frequency of clinical illness (but not mortality) and significantly increased frequency of delivery of low birthweight children. In contrast, in multigravid women these clinical features are much less obvious and rarely attain statistical significance. The differences in susceptibility to malaria of pregnant women associated with parity and previous immunological experience require that protective strategies must be planned with full knowledge of the local epidemiology of malaria and be specifically targeted to the women who require them. Furthermore, the effectiveness of each strategy requires careful monitoring to permit such modifications as may be required by change in the immune status of the resident population.     

Quelle information donner �� une femme souffrant de troubles psychotiques ou de troubles bipolaires avant la naissance d��un enfant ?

What information should be provided to a female patient suffering from a psychotic disorder or a bipolar disorder prior to the birth of her child? Pregnancy is a time of intense psychological reshuffles that may weaken parents-to-be. The couple or the mother-to-be will seek the support of their loved ones. In this particular time, the involvement of professionals may be necessary when difficulties arise for the couple in relation to the psychological adjustment required by a child??s arrival. In case of a pregnancy contemplated in women affected by a mental illness, information related to potential risks carried by treatments and also by the impact of the pregnancy itself, the eventuality of the inability, for a more or less long period of time, to look after the child as well as the occurrence of possible distortions of the interactions in this context must be discussed in each parental project. This consists of a reflection on the benefits/risks by the patient, if possible her partner, also involving the referring psychiatrist, the general practitioner, the obstetricians and the paediatricians. This information is not always easy for the referring psychiatric to deliver. A tight cooperation between the Department of General Psychiatry and the Departments of Infant-Juvenile Psychiatry is important from a perspective of prevention, as it is required to deal with the perinatal/prenatal issues which arise out of the formation of a quality bond between mentally ill parents and a baby, that is sometimes difficult to set in place by the professionals involved and also by the patients themselves at the time of the birth. Thus, Cico was set up at the Saint Anne Hospital, non sectored, dealing with child psychiatric and adult psychiatric approaches. It allows patients to reflect on their desire for a child and provides information on the course of pregnancy to patients. It also assesses the capacity of the patient to form a bond with the child.     

Women's physical and psychological condition independently predict their preference for apparent health in faces

Physical condition (e.g., health, fertility) influences female mate preferences in many species, with females in good condition preferring "higher quality" (e.g., healthier) mates. In humans, condition may comprise both physical (e.g., health and fertility) and psychological factors (e.g., stress, anxiety, and depression). We found that women with low waist-to-hip ratios (indicating health and fertility) or who scored low on anxiety, depression, and stress measures expressed greater attraction to composite male (but not female) faces with color and texture cues associated with apparent health than did women with relatively high waist-to-hip ratios or who scored relatively high on the anxiety, depression, and stress measures. These effects of physical and psychological condition were independent and were not mediated by women's perceptions of their own attractiveness. Our findings indicate that women's physical and psychological conditions both contribute to individual differences in face preferences.     

Ought We to Sentence People to Psychiatric Treatment?

In principle, there seem to be three main ways in which society can react when people commit crimes under influence of mental illness.
(1) The standard model. We excuse them. If they are dangerous they are detained in the interest of safety of the rest of the citizens.
(2) The Swedish model. We hold them responsible for their criminal offence, we convict them, but we do not sentence them to jail. Instead, we sentence them to psychiatric treatment.
(3) My model. We sentence them to jail, but offer them (voluntary) psychiatric treatment.
The advantages of my model are obvious. We get a clear delineation of roles. We allow the psychiatrist to be just a doctor, not a warden. We liberate psychiatry of the objective of deciding whether people who were mentally ill when they committed criminal offences 'could have acted otherwise'— a hopeless task. We allow that psychiatrists live up to their professional ethical code (the Hawaii Declaration). We treat psychically ill persons as 'normal', we allow them to repent their crimes, which renders easier their recovery.
However, two objections to my model come to mind. First of all, is it not unfair to sentence people to jail who could not help doing what they did? And, secondly, the question of fairness set to one side, is it not inhumane to sentence mentally ill persons to jail? Is it not inhumane to the mentally ill persons themselves, and does it not mean that they will be a burden to other prisoners?
In my paper I show that, if our system of criminal punishment takes a civilised form, neither of these objections carries any weight.     

Ought we to sentence people to psychiatric treatment?

In principle, there seem to be three main ways in which society can react when people commit crimes under influence of mental illness. (1) The standard model. We excuse them. If they are dangerous they are detained in the interest of safety of the rest of the citizens. (2) The Swedish model. We hold them responsible for their criminal offence, we convict them, but we do not sentence them to jail. Instead, we sentence them to psychiatric treatment. (3) My model. We sentence them to jail, but offer them (voluntary) psychiatric treatment. The advantages of my model are obvious. We get a clear delineation of roles. We allow the psychiatrist to be just a doctor, not a warden. We liberate psychiatry of the objective of deciding whether people who were mentally ill when they committed criminal offences 'could have acted otherwise' -- a hopeless task. We allow that psychiatrists live up to their professional ethical code (The Hawaii Declaration). We treat psychically ill persons as 'normal', we allow them to repent their crimes, which renders easier their recovery. However, two objections to my model come to mind. First of all, is it not unfair to sentence people to jail who could not help doing what they did? And, secondly, the question of fairness set to one side, is it not inhumane to sentence mentally ill persons to jail? Is it not inhumane to the mentally ill persons themselves, and does it not mean that they will be a burden to other prisoners? In my paper I show that, if our system of criminal punishment takes a civilised form, neither of these objections carries any weight.     

The Commitment Process for Psychiatric Patients: Changing Status in the Western States

Recent changes in commitment legislation for the mentally ill have had an important impact on the role of physicians in treating these patients. New commitment laws emphasize civil rights at the expense of right-to-treatment concepts, sometimes causing neglect of severely psychotic persons. Only four western states have a high rating of conformity with a model commitment statute.     

Amenorrhoea after Discontinuing Combined Oestrogen-Progestogen Oral Contraceptives

Out of 210 women seen at the Middlesex Hospital with secondary amenorrhoea the 63 who developed it after stopping oral contraceptives were fully investigated. Five had organic disease sufficient to account for the amenorrhoea (one had severe diabetes, one a pituitary tumour, and three premature ovarian failure); two patients had galactorrhoea (one of whom also had the pituitary tumour); two had anorexia nervosa.Of the 63 women 40 (63%) had suffered from amenorrhoea or prolonged or irregular menstrual cycles before taking the pill, and this suggested that combined oestrogen-progestogen oral contraceptives should be used with caution for women with irregular menstruation.Nineteen patients wished to become pregnant and 12 have so far done so after treatment with clomiphene or gonadotrophins.In another study 204 women recorded when their first menstrual cycle occurred after stopping the pill. Seventy-four had a cycle longer than five weeks but only five exceeded three months, and only one of the five had more than six months'' amenorrhoea. These results confirm that the incidence of amenorrhoea after stopping oral contraceptives is low.     

The outcome of targeting community mental health services: evidence from the West Lambeth schizophrenia cohort.

OBJECTIVES--To report outcome of targeting community mental health services to people with schizophrenia in an inner London district who had been shown, one year after discharge, to have high levels of psychotic symptomatology and social disability but very low levels of supported housing and structured day activity. DESIGN--Repeat interview survey of symptoms, disability, and receipt of care four years after index discharge. SETTING--Inner London health district with considerable social deprivation and a mental hospital in the process of closure. SUBJECTS--51 patients originally aged 20-65 years who satisfied the research diagnostic criteria for schizophrenia. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Contact with services during the three months before interview, levels of symptoms (from present state examination), global social disability rating. RESULTS--65% (33/51) of the study group had been readmitted at least once in the three years between surveys. Recent contacts with community psychiatric nurses and rates of hospital admission increased (8 at one year v 24 at four years, p < 0.01; 5 v 13, p < 0.06). Conversely, fewer patients were in contact with social workers (17 v 7, p < 0.03). Proportions in supported housing, day care, or sheltered work did not change. Unemployment rates remained very high. A considerable reduction (almost a halving) in psychiatric symptoms was observed, but there was no significant change in mean levels of social disability. CONCLUSIONS--The policy of targeting the long term mentally ill resulted in significant increases in professional psychiatric input to the cohort but failed to improve access to social workers or suitable accommodation. Improvements in social functioning did not follow from reductions in the proportions of patients with psychotic mental states. Social interventions are likely to be crucial to achieving the Health of the Nation target of improving social functioning for the seriously mentally ill, as improving mental state seems in itself to be insufficient.     

Suicide and attempted suicide among South Asians in England: who is at risk?

Evidence from both large-scale and small-scale studies suggests differences and similarities in patterns of suicide and attempted suicide between South Asians and the total population in England. Among South Asians, the excess of females among both suicides and attempted suicides is even more marked; the traditional view of a strong family structure among Asians is confirmed, although cultural conflict between generations is apparent. The technique of suicide by burning among Asians appears to be waning. Asians who attempt or complete suicide are more likely to be suffering from stress, but less likely to have been diagnosed as mentally ill. Their psychological problems appear to have been frequently overlooked by general practitioners, or not presented to them. Differences in religion, with Hindus producing higher rates than Muslims, and demographic, geographical, financial and cultural differences, contribute to the need for disaggregation and up-to-date research.