Cancer screening practices among primary care physicians serving Chinese Americans in San Francisco

Previous research has reported a lack of regular cancer screening among Chinese Americans. The overall objectives of this study were to use a mail survey of primary care physicians who served Chinese Americans in San Francisco to investigate: a) the attitudes, beliefs, and practices regarding breast, cervical, and colon cancer screening and b) factors influencing the use of these cancer screening tests. The sampling frame for our mail survey consisted of: a) primary care physicians affiliated with the Chinese Community Health Plan and b) primary care physicians with a Chinese surname listed in the Yellow Pages of the 1995 San Francisco Telephone Directory. A 5-minute, self-administered questionnaire was developed and mailed to 80 physicians, and 51 primary care physicians completed the survey. A majority reported performing regular clinical breast examinations (84%) and teaching their patients to do self-breast examinations (84%). However, the rate of performing Pap smears was only 61% and the rate of ordering annual mammograms for patients aged 50 and older was 63%. The rates of ordering annual fecal occult blood testing and sigmoidoscopy at regular intervals of three to five years among patients aged 50 and older were 69% and 20%, respectively. Barriers (patient-specific, provider-specific, and practice logistics) to using cancer screening tests were identified. The data presented in this study provide a basis for developing interventions to increase performance of regular cancer screening among primary care physicians serving Chinese Americans. Cancer screening rates may be improved by targeting the barriers to screening identified among these physicians. Strategies to help physicians overcome these barriers are discussed.     

Attitudes of Washington State physicians toward health care reform.

Attitudes of Washington State physicians about health care reform and about specific elements of managed competition and single-payer proposals were evaluated. Opinions about President Clinton''s reform plan were also assessed. Washington physicians (n = 1,000) were surveyed from October to November 1993, and responses were collected through January 1994; responses were anonymous. The response rate was 80%. Practice characteristics of respondents did not differ from other physicians in the state. Of physicians responding, 80% favored substantial change in the current system, 43% favored managed competition, and 40% preferred a single-payer system. Of physicians responding, 64% thought President Clinton''s proposal would not adequately address current problems. Reduced administrative burden, a central element of single-payer plans, was identified by 89% of respondents as likely to improve the current system. Other elements of reform plans enjoyed less support. More procedure-oriented specialists than primary care physicians favored leaving the current system unchanged (28% versus 8%, P < .001). While physicians favor health care reform, there is no consensus on any single plan. It seems unlikely that physicians will be able to speak with a single voice during the current debates on health care reform.     

Diagnosis and management of hypertension: the stated practices of family physicians.

Hypertension is an important and common problem in family practice, but there is no general agreement on the systolic and diastolic pressures at which it should be diagnosed and treated. Responses from 273 family physicians surveyed by mail in Metropolitan Toronto showed a wide variation in the pressures used as cut-off points. The probability that in a given patient hypertension would be diagnosed or treated at different systolic and diastolic pressures varied considerably among the physicians, the variation increasing with the age of the patient. There was also wide variation in opinion among the surveyed physicians about how often patients should be screened for hypertension; depending on the patient''s age, up to 35% of the physicians stated that the blood pressure should be measured at every visit. Only one third reported using any one or more methods to ensure that patients with hypertension were not lost to follow-up. The family physicians with an academic appointment used higher cut-off points for diagnosis and treatment, and they screened and scheduled follow-up visits less frequently than those without an academic appointment.     

Effectiveness of a quality-improvement program in improving management of primary care practices

Background:

The European Practice Assessment program provides feedback and outreach visits to primary care practices to facilitate quality improvement in five domains (infrastructure, people, information, finance, and quality and safety). We examined the effectiveness of this program in improving management in primary care practices in Germany, with a focus on the domain of quality and safety.

Methods:

In a before–after study, 102 primary care practices completed a practice assessment using the European Practice Assessment instrument at baseline and three years later (intervention group). A comparative group of 102 practices was included that completed their first assessment using this instrument at the time of the intervention group’s second assessment. Mean scores were based on the proportion of indicators for which a positive response was achieved by all of the practices, on a scale of 0 to 100.

Results:

We found significant improvements in all domains between the first and second assessments in the intervention group. In the domain of quality and safety, improvements in scores (mean scores were based on the proportion of indicators for which a positive response was achieved by all of the practices, on a scale of 0 to 100) were observed in the following dimensions: complaint management (from a mean score of 51.2 at first assessment to 80.7 at second assessment); analysis of critical incidents (from 79.1 to 89.6); and quality development, quality policy (from 40.7 to 55.6). Overall scores at the time of the second assessment were significantly higher in the intervention group than in the comparative group.

Interpretation:

Primary care practices that completed the European Practice Assessment instrument twice over a three-year period showed improvements in practice management. Our findings show the value of the quality-improvement cycle in the context of practice assessment and the use of established organizational standards for practice management with the Europeaen Practice Assessment.A variety of quality-improvement initiatives in health care management have been implemented in most health care systems.^1,2 Countries such as Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States have a long tradition in, and established standards for, quality management in primary care. In Canada, such initiatives in primary care are in their infancy, despite support by the federal Primary Health Care Transition Fund since 2000.³ In Ontario, a comprehensive book was recently issued that provides recommendations on practice management and clinical indicators for improving quality in primary care settings in the province.⁴ The indicators were adopted and refined from the Royal New Zealand College of General Practitioners, the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners’ National Expert Committee on Standards for General Practices, the TOPAS–Europe Association European Practice Assessment, the United Kingdom’s Quality and Outcomes Framework and the Canadian Institute for Health Information.In Germany, similar developments took place. In 2005, the German government stipulated that health care providers implement a system of annual assessment of quality management.⁵ One of the systems available to practices is the European Practice Assessment (www.epa-qm.de), a validated instrument based on quality indicators for assessing practice management.⁶ The five key domains of the European Practice Assessment instrument and their respective dimensions are described in Figure 1.Open in a separate windowFigure 1:The domains and dimensions (and number of indicators) of the European Practice Assessment instrument used to measure the quality of practice management in primary care practices. For an example of how the pentagon shape is used to provide feedback to individual practices, see Appendix 1 (available at www.cmaj.ca/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1503/cmaj.110412/-/DC1). GP = general practitioner.The European Practice Assessment is used to help general practices both assess and improve their quality of practice management set against predefined criteria with embedded quality indicators. The improvement process is ongoing (e.g., through plan–do–study–act cycles⁷): each step is reviewed and redesigned with a view to improving the quality of the end product, thereby fostering continuous improvement.⁸ The multifaceted strategy has three essential components: assessment and feedback using validated instruments based on quality indicators; external support through an outreach educational visit by a trained visitor (physician or nurse) to support the practice in improving areas of management identified by the practice;⁹ and formal accreditation by an external organization.Three requirements have to be fulfilled by practices to receive accreditation: achieve a positive response for more than 50% of the indicators; meet predefined safety indicators (e.g., the vaccination status of staff regarding hepatitis B vaccination is recorded and medical equipment is checked regularly according to national regulations); and highlight areas for continuous quality improvement.Accreditation is one method for assessing and benchmarking the performance of general practice care across a broad range of clinical and organizational domains. It describes a formal process of self-assessment and external and independent peer review to encourage best management practice and can result in recommendations for continuous improvement of safety and quality in the practice.⁸ Practice accreditation can be used for different purposes: quality control, regulation, quality improvement, providing data on performance, and marketing.⁸ In Germany, it is used for quality improvement, leading to a certificate.We conducted a study to determine whether improvements in practice management occurred in general practices that completed the European Practice Assessment twice over three years, compared with general practices that completed the European Practice Assessment once. We focused our analysis on the domain of quality and safety, expecting an association between practice organization and quality improvement.^10,11 We hypothesized that the initial use of the European Practice Assessment and reassessment with it three years later would result in improved scores in the dimensions and indicators within the domain of quality and safety.     

Quality of plasma cholesterol measurements in primary care.

Three surveys were made of the quality of plasma cholesterol measurements performed with a commercial desktop analyser (BCL Reflotron) in primary care. Each survey included three specimens, and results were received from 37, 61, and 69 participants. Although many participants obtained satisfactory results, 8.6% of the results differed by 1.0 mmol/l or more from the target values, and the overall between instrument dispersion of results was 1.3 times that between hospital laboratories. It was found that common sources of error were poor technique and the use of outdated reagent strips. Users of such instruments outside the laboratory need help and advice with training, and guidelines for this are provided. The main recommendations are that users should establish contact with a local clinical chemistry laboratory for training and support and should participate in external quality assessment schemes.     

Early detection of depression by primary care physicians.

The overall prevalence of depression is from 3.5% to 27%. The burden of suffering is high and includes death through suicide. In most cases treatment is effective, but important episodes of depression are being missed. To determine whether a brief, systematic assessment for the early detection of depression should be part of the periodic health examination we searched MEDLINE and the Science Citation Index for randomized controlled trials that evaluated the effectiveness of early detection of depression with a questionnaire. Seven instruments met our quality criteria; the Beck Depression Inventory, the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale, the Zung Self-Assessment Depression Scale, the General Health Questionnaire, the Hopkins Symptom Checklist, the Mental Health Inventory and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale. The four randomized controlled trials failed to provide adequate evidence of the benefit of routine screening. Early detection is difficult because of depression''s natural history, the role of symptoms, the cultural diversity of Canada and how detection instruments have been developed. Depression deserves careful attention from primary care physicians; however, further research and development is required before the widespread routine use of any detection test can be recommended.     

Educational package on hypertension for primary care physicians.

The usefulness of an educational package on hypertension that provides clinically important, up-to-date medical information and office "aids" to primary care physicians was tested in a randomized controlled trial. Fifty-six physicians completed a pretest multiple-choice questionnaire and were allocated at random either to a group that received the educational package (the "study group") or to a control group. There was a highly significant correlation between the pretest scores and the number of years since graduation (r = -0.55, p less than 0.0001), which indicated that younger physicians are more likely than older physicians to have an up-to-date knowledge of the management of hypertension. The increase in knowledge in the study group (17.5%) was significantly greater than that in the control group (2.7%). Furthermore, although the post-test scores in the control group were still significantly correlated with the number of years since graduation, those in the study group were not. It was concluded that although the older physicians knew less than their younger colleagues about hypertension, the use of the educational package significantly increased knowledge, and the increase was not limited by the physician''s age.     

Reduced atherosclerosis in MyD88-null mice links elevated serum cholesterol levels to activation of innate immunity signaling pathways

Atherosclerosis, the leading cause of death in developed countries, has been linked to hypercholesterolemia for decades. More recently, atherosclerotic lesion progression has been shown to depend on persistent, chronic inflammation in the artery wall. Although several studies have implicated infectious agents in this process, the role of infection in atherosclerosis remains controversial. Because the involvement of monocytes and macrophages in the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis is well established, we investigated the possibility that macrophage innate immunity signaling pathways normally activated by pathogens might also be activated in response to hyperlipidemia. We examined atherosclerotic lesion development in uninfected, hyperlipidemic mice lacking expression of either lipopolysaccharide (LPS) receptor CD14 or myeloid differentiation protein-88 (MyD88), which transduces cell signaling events downstream of the Toll-like receptors (TLRs), as well as receptors for interleukin-1 (IL-1) and IL-18. Whereas the MyD88-deficient mice evinced a marked reduction in early atherosclerosis, mice deficient in CD14 had no decrease in early lesion development. Inactivation of the MyD88 pathway led to a reduction in atherosclerosis through a decrease in macrophage recruitment to the artery wall that was associated with reduced chemokine levels. These findings link elevated serum lipid levels to a proinflammatory signaling cascade that is also engaged by microbial pathogens.     

Serum cholesterol and triglyceride measurements in Canadian physicians.

In a study of serum cholesterol and triglyceride concentrations in male physicians, blood was drawn after fasting from 2071 registrants at 17 Canadian medical meetings from 1968 to 1973. Eight regional medical laboratories participated in the study. About two thirds of the samples were analysed in one of two laboratories to diminish method variations. When chylomicronemia, hyperglycemia or extremely high triglyceride values were detected, suggesting nonfasting, the data were discarded. The mean serum cholesterol value for the total study population was 233.9 plus or minus 1.22 mg/dl and the mean serum triglyceride value, 150.5 plus or minus 2.48 mg/dl. The mean values and the prevalence of elevated values (cholesterol larger than or equal to 250 mg/dl; triglyceride larger than or equal to 150 mg/dl) were related to age. Of the total study population 34.7% had elevated cholesterol values and 36.2% had elevated triglyceride values; only the cholesterol value was elevated in 17.5%, only the triglyceride value in 19.6% and both values were elevated in 16.8%. Although this was not a random sampling of Canadian physicians or of Canadian men, our findings of elevated serum lipid values were similar to those in French Canadian civic workers, American executives and Scandinavians, and somewhat higher than those in the Albany, New York and Framingham populations, but distinctly higher than those reported by a recent Nutrition Canada survey.     

Subnormal follicular-phase serum progesterone levels and elevated follicular-phase serum estradiol levels in young women with insulin-dependent diabetes

In a search for possible hormonal reasons for the loss of protection from myocardial infarction seen in diabetic women, serum levels of estradiol, progesterone, and luteinizing hormone were compared throughout a menstrual cycle (17 points) in eight healthy nonsmoking women and five otherwise healthy nonsmoking insulin-dependent diabetic women. The total length of the menstrual cycle and the lengths of the follicular and luteal phases did not differ between the groups. During the periovulatory and luteal phases, there was no significant intergroup difference with respect to any of the three hormones. During the follicular phase, in both groups, there was a plateau in serum progesterone concentration, with the level approximately 42% lower in the diabetic group (12.0 +/- 6.6 ng/dl versus 20.7 +/- 5.7; P less than 0.0001). Follicular-phase serum estradiol showed a rising curve in both groups; day-by-day comparison (days -10 to -3 before the luteinizing hormone peak) showed consistently higher levels in the diabetic group (mean, 108 pg/ml versus 95 pg/ml; P less than 0.001). The follicular-phase serum estradiol to progesterone ratio was nearly twice as high in the diabetic group as in the normal group (8.9 versus 4.6), a difference that was highly significant. The finding of elevated serum estradiol and subnormal serum progesterone concentrations during the follicular phase is so far unique to women with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. The possibility that this pronounced abnormality in diabetic women may be related to coronary disease merits testing in suitable in vivo and in vitro models of atherogenesis.     

Factors influencing the serum levels of cholesterol and beta-lipoproteins in starving rabbits]

The influence of starvation on the lipid metabolism was studied on male rabbits under usual conditions and in the presence of pyroxidine deficiency (4-deoxypyridoxine administration) and of thiamine (oxythiamine administration), and also in administration of neurotropic preparations (phenamine, seduxen). Starvation for 7 to 10 days led to increase of cholesterol and beta-lipoproteins level in the serum. Pyridoxine deficiency and phenamine administration caused a greater increase of cholesterol and especially or beta-lipoproteins. On the other hand, thiamine deficiency and seduxen administration limited an increase of cholesterol and beta-lipoproteins during hungry stress. Administration of aerovit for prophylactic purpose promoted a decrease of the metabolic shifts. The amount of cholesterol increased in the liver of hungry animals, especially after the phenamine administration and in the presence of pyridoxine deficiency; aerovit administration prevented increased cholesterol accumulation in the liver. The differences in the cholesterol level in the serum and and the liver can be explained by the changes of its biosynthesis during hungry stress.