Temperature-mediated dynamics of planktonic food chains: the effect of an invertebrate carnivore

1. This study involves an examination of two- and three-trophic-level food chains at two temperatures (18 and 25 °C) in order to determine how the addition of a carnivore to a predator–prey system can alter the dynamics of populations and how this effect may be temperature mediated. The system consisted of phytoplankton, Daphnia pulex and the flatworm Mesostoma ehrenbergii .
2. Although the plant–herbivore system is inherently unstable at 25 °C, the addition of the carnivore led to a further destabilization of the Daphnia –algal dynamics at the higher temperature. No destabilization effect of the carnivore was noted at 18 °C. At the lower temperature, all populations persisted and the carnivore induced changes only in the age structure of the Daphnia populations rather than in overall biomass.
3. The differential effects of the carnivore at two temperatures can be attributed to shifts in the life history, physiological rates and the reproductive strategy employed by Mesostoma .
4. Previous theoretical work has predicted that the addition of a third trophic level to an unstable predator–prey system should stabilize dynamics. Our results indicate that the effect of a carnivore on plant–herbivore dynamics can be significantly affected by ambient temperature.     

Temperature-mediated dynamics of planktonic food chains: the effect of an invertebrate carnivore

1. This study involves an examination of two- and three-trophic-level food chains at two temperatures (18 and 25 °C) in order to determine how the addition of a carnivore to a predator–prey system can alter the dynamics of populations and how this effect may be temperature mediated. The system consisted of phytoplankton, Daphnia pulex and the flatworm Mesostoma ehrenbergii .
2. Although the plant–herbivore system is inherently unstable at 25 °C, the addition of the carnivore led to a further destabilization of the Daphnia –algal dynamics at the higher temperature. No destabilization effect of the carnivore was noted at 18 °C. At the lower temperature, all populations persisted and the carnivore induced changes only in the age structure of the Daphnia populations rather than in overall biomass.
3. The differential effects of the carnivore at two temperatures can be attributed to shifts in the life history, physiological rates and the reproductive strategy employed by Mesostoma .
4. Previous theoretical work has predicted that the addition of a third trophic level to an unstable predator–prey system should stabilize dynamics. Our results indicate that the effect of a carnivore on plant–herbivore dynamics can be significantly affected by ambient temperature.     

Predation risk perception and food scarcity induce alterations of life-cycle traits of the mosquito Culex pipiens

Abstract.  1. Predators may affect prey populations by direct consumption, and by inducing defensive reactions of prey to the predation risk. Food scarcity frequently has effects on the inducible defences of prey, but no consistent pattern of food–predation risk interaction is known.
2. In this study the combined effect of food shortage and predation-risk perception in larvae of the mosquito Culex pipiens was investigated. Water exposed to the aquatic predator bug Notonecta glauca was used as a source of predation intimidation. Mosquito larvae were reared in three different media containing either no predator cues or the cues of N. glauca that had been fed on either C. pipiens larvae or on Daphnia magna . Food was provided in favourable or limited amount for these set-ups.
3. The results showed that chemical cues from the predators fed with prey's conspecifics caused a decreased survival, delayed pre-imaginal development, and reduction in body size of emerged mosquitoes, whereas chemical cues from predators fed with D. magna caused only delayed development. Food scarcity significantly exacerbates the negative effect of the predator cues on pre-imaginal development of C. pipiens . Effects of the cues on larval development and body size of imagoes are significantly stronger for females than for males.
4. The present study suggests that when food is limited, predators can affect population dynamics of prey not only by direct predation, but also by inducing lethal and sublethal effects due to perception of risk imposed by chemical cues. To understand the effects of predators on mosquito population dynamics, environmental parameters such as food deficiency should be considered.     

Unsuitability of Cnesterodon decemmaculatus (Jenyns, 1842) for mosquito control in Uruguay: evidence from food‐preference experiments

We analyzed the feeding preference of Cnesterodon decemmaculatus, a small‐bodied poecilid native from the Rio de la Plata and proximate Atlantic Basins in South America. This species has a wide distribution in Uruguayan water bodies but its effectiveness as a predator of mosquito larvae has not been tested. In laboratory trials, five aquatic invertebrates were offered simultaneously as potential prey to fish: Daphnia pulex (Cladocera), copepods, two different instars of mosquito larvae (Culex pipiens), and the 4^th instar of Chironomidae larvae. Preference was measured by the Chesson's electivity index (α). In order to determine differences in prey preference according to fish size, individuals ranging from 9.5 mm to 35.3 mm were classified in three different body size classes: small, medium, and large. Small fish showed preference for copepods, while medium‐sized fish preferred the smallest mosquito larvae instars and Chironomidae larvae. We conclude that C. decemmaculatus is a zooplankton facultative‐feeder fish that prefers large‐bodied zooplankton but is a weak predator of mosquito larvae. Thus, the introduction of C. decemmaculatus as a biological‐control agent in natural environments is not an effective strategy.     

Diving beetles (Dytiscidae) as predators of mosquito larvae (Culicidae) in field experiments and in laboratory tests of prey preference

Field experiments were performed in artificial ponds to evaluate how the density of predatory diving beetles (Dytiscidae) would affect the population levels of mosquito larvae (Culicidae). Mosquitoes colonizing the ponds were predominantly species of the genus Culex. In 2000, most of the dytiscids colonizing the ponds were small (Hydroporus spp.), and these predators had no impact on the size of larval mosquito populations, not even in ponds with added dytiscids. In 2001, larger beetles (Ilybius, Rhantus, and Agabus spp.) were more common, and there were significantly fewer mosquito larvae in ponds with the highest numbers of dytiscids. There was a negative correlation between numbers of diving beetles in the ponds and the mean body length of mosquito larvae. In neither year could dytiscid densities be maintained above a certain level owing to emigration. In laboratory tests, there were marked differences between three common dytiscid species in regard to preferences for Daphnia and Culex species as prey: Colymbetes paykulli Erichson chose mosquito larvae more often, whereas both Ilybius ater (De Geer) and I. fuliginosus (Fabricius) preferred Daphnia spp. All of the tested dytiscids consumed large numbers of prey. Since some dytiscid species can efficiently decrease populations of mosquito larvae, they are probably important in the natural control of these dipterans.     

Pelagic flatworm predation on daphniids in a subtropical reservoir: different effects on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Daphnia galeata</Emphasis> and on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ceriodaphnia quadrangula</Emphasis>

Following a reduction in fish populations in 2004–2005, a new, single annual pulse of pelagic flatworms was observed in early summer during 2006–2009 in Liuxihe, a freshwater reservoir in South China. As soon as these worms appear, Daphnia galeata retreats into dormancy, one month earlier (July) in the presence of flatworms than previously observed (August) with fish, while the population of the related Ceriodaphnia quadrangula tends to increase. We show, through in situ lake sampling, in large enclosures and by laboratory observations, that Ceriodaphnia, although perhaps competitively inferior in its ability to acquire algal food, has a higher tolerance to flatworm toxins. As a result, Ceriodaphnia manages to coexist with and proliferate in the presence of the flatworm. Observations in the laboratory suggest that flatworm population autoregulates by being sensitive to their own toxins and that Ceriodaphnia, even if prey to the worms, likely incurs more benefit than cost from their presence.     

Surplus Killing by Predatory Larvae of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Corethrella appendiculata</Emphasis>: Prepupal Timing and Site-Specific Attack on Mosquito Prey

Surplus or ‘wasteful’ killing of uneaten prey has been documented in the fourth larval instar of various species of the mosquito genus Toxorhynchites that occur in treeholes and other phytotelmata. Here we document surplus killing by the predatory midge Corethrella appendiculata, which in Florida cohabits treeholes and artificial containers with larvae of Toxorhynchites rutilus. Provided with a surfeit of larval mosquito prey, surplus killing was observed only in the fourth instar of C. appendiculata, peaking in intensity in the final 24 h prior to pupation, as observed for Toxorhynchites spp. Attack sites identified from videotaped encounters with mosquito prey were divided among head, thorax, abdomen, and siphon. Consumed mosquito larvae (n = 70) were attacked primarily on the head (46%) or siphon (34%), but surplus-killed prey (n = 30) were attacked predominantly on the thorax (83%). Despite its independent evolution among different insect species in aquatic container habitats, the functional significance of prepupal surplus killing remains unclear.     

Prey preferences of aquatic insects: potential implications for the regulation of wetland mosquitoes

Wetlands are potential sites for mosquito breeding and are thus important in the context of public health. The use of chemical and microbial controls is constrained in wetlands in view of their potential impact on the diverse biota. Biological control using generalist aquatic insects can be effective, provided a preference for mosquito larvae is exhibited. The mosquito prey preferences of water bugs and larvae of odonate species were evaluated using chironomid larvae, fish fingerlings and tadpoles as alternative prey. Manly's selectivity (α_i) values with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were estimated to judge prey preference patterns. Multivariate analysis of variance (manova) and standardized canonical coefficients were used to test the effects of density on prey selectivity. The α_i values indicated a significant preference (P < 0.05) in all of the insect predators tested for mosquito larvae over the alternative prey as a density‐dependent function. On a comparative scale, chironomid larvae had the highest impact as alternative prey. In a multiple‐prey experiment, predators showed a similar pattern of preference for mosquito larvae over alternative prey, reflecting a significant (P < 0.05) niche overlap. The results suggest that, in a laboratory setting, these insect predators can effectively reduce mosquito density in the presence of multiple alternative prey.     

Importance of consumptive and non-consumptive prey mortality in a coupled predator–prey system

1. Laboratory experiments were completed to identify the mechanisms by which the predatory flatworm, Dugesia tigrina , imposes mortality on its Aedes aegypti and Daphnia magna prey. Feeding trials were completed in glass microcosms which contained one of three – nine densities of small or large individuals of each prey species.
2. Mortality by Dugesia on small and large Aedes followed a type II functional response, whereas the mortality of Daphnia resembled a type III functional response. Prey mortality imposed by Dugesia consisted of consumptive and non-consumptive elements. Non-consumptive mortality occurred when prey individuals trapped in mucus trails subsequently died but were not ingested.
3. Additional experiments were conducted to quantify consumptive (capture followed by ingestion) and non-consumptive mortality (death not followed by ingestion).
4. Consumptive mortality followed a type II functional response for small and large individuals of both prey species, whereas non-consumptive mortality increased with prey density, although the relationships differed with prey species and size. The non-consumptive mortality of large Daphnia increased at an accelerating rate with prey density and exceeded consumptive mortality at intermediate prey abundances. In contrast, non-consumptive mortality of small Aedes and small Daphnia was lower than consumptive mortality and either increased with prey density at a decelerating (small Aedes ) or accelerating (small Daphnia ) rate.
5. These results suggest that the importance of consumptive and non-consumptive mortality to total prey mortality needs to be considered when modelling predator–prey dynamics.     

Opportunistic foraging by heteropteran mosquito predators

Tropical aquatic environments host a large number of predatory insects including heteropteran water bugs Anisops bouvieri Kirkaldy, 1704 (Heteroptera: Notonectidae), Diplonychus (=Sphaerodema) rusticus Fabricius, 1781 (Heteroptera: Belostomatidae), and Diplonychus (=Sphaerodema) annulatus Fabricius, 1781 (Heteroptera: Belostomatidae) feeding on a range of organisms. In tropical and subtropical wetlands, ponds, and temporary pools these predators play a role in regulation of dipteran populations, particularly mosquitoes and chironomids. Their relative abilities to control mosquitoes depend in part on predator preference for mosquitoes in relation to other natural prey, and the predators’ propensities to switch to mosquitoes as mosquito density increases. The prey electivity and switching dynamics of these predatory water bugs were evaluated in the laboratory under various prey densities, using two instars (II and IV) of chironomid and mosquito larvae as prey. Studies of electivity at relatively high densities (20 prey L⁻¹) in small (5 L) vessels demonstrated that all predators showed opportunistic foraging as the mosquito:chironomid ratio changed, with some evidence that mosquito larvae were positively selected over chironomids. In particular, Anisops showed strong electivity for mosquitoes when presented with any ratio of large mosquito and chironomid prey in the high density experiment, although the preference was not expressed in lower density (2.5 prey L⁻¹) treatments executed in 40 L vessels. In these lower density treatments, D. rusticus demonstrated higher electivity for mosquitoes when the mosquito:chironomid ratio was high, consistent with non-significant trends observed in the higher density experiment. The positive electivity of D. rusticus for mosquitoes was reinforced in an experiment executed over 16 days at varying prey ratios, in which D. rusticus mosquito electivity was high and consistent while D. annulatus showed slight avoidance of mosquito larvae, and Anisops remained largely opportunistic in foraging on prey in proportion with availability. Anisops and D. rusticus are potentially good biocontrol agents for mosquito larvae, in that they preferentially consume mosquitoes under many circumstances but can readily forage on other prey when mosquito density is low.     

Effect of habitat complexity on the predation of Buenoa fuscipennis (Heteroptera: Notonectidae) on mosquito immature stages and alternative prey

Notonectids are well‐known predators in aquatic habitats, where mosquito larvae, chironomids, and cladocerans constitute their main diet. Our purpose was to assess the effect of structural complexity on the predatory ability of Buenoa fuscipennis, a common predator in aquatic habitats of Buenos Aires city (Argentina). Buenoa fuscipennis showed type 2 functional responses in both the presence and absence of prey refuge and no differences in attack rate or handling time between refuge treatments. Regarding mosquito size classes, B. fuscipennis exhibited a significantly higher preference for 2^nd instar larvae and no predation on pupae. In the presence of mosquito larvae and alternative prey, B. fuscipennis preferred mosquitoes over chironomid larvae and adult cladocerans over mosquito larvae. No switching behavior was detected in our experiments. Habitat structure only slightly affected the predator´s consumption rates on mosquito larvae. Overall, preference for prey did not vary with the presence of refuge, except for the preference for mosquitoes over chironomid larvae, which was significantly decreased in the presence of refuge as a consequence of reduced predation on mosquito larvae. The results suggest that B. fuscipennis could efficiently control mosquitoes in structurally simple habitats where chironomids are the most abundant alternative prey but not in temporary pools where cladocerans are abundant.     

Predation on Mosquito Larvae by Mesocyclops thermocyclopoides (Copepoda: Cyclopoida) in the Presence of Alternate Prey

The cyclopoid copepod Mesocyclops thermocyclopoides, a dominant invertebrate predator in many shallow ponds and temporary water bodies in northern India, feeds on cladocerans, rotifers, ciliates and when present, on mosquito larvae also. We studied in the laboratory the prey consumption rates of the copepod on first and fourth instar larvae of two species of mosquito (Anopheles stephensi and Culex quinquefasciatus) in relation to their density. We also studied its prey selectivity with mosquito larvae in the presence of an alternate prey (the cladocerans‐either Moina macrocopa or Ceriodaphnia cornuta) in different proportions. With either mosquito species, the copepod actively selected Instar‐I larvae, avoiding the Instar‐IV larvae, and with either instar, selected Anopheles stephensi over Culex quinquefasciatus. When prey choice included the cladoceran as an alternate prey, the copepod selected the cladoceran only when the other prey was Instar‐IV mosquito larvae. Our results point to the potential and promise of M. thermocyclopoides as a biological agent for controlling larval populations of vectorially important mosquito species.     

Non-consumptive effects of larval Salamandra on crustacean prey: can eggs detect predators?

Predators affect prey populations not only by prey consumption but also in nonconsumptive ways including modifying prey behavior. I tested the effects of fire salamander larvae (Salamandra infraimmaculata) on populations of co-occurring crustacean species in artificial outdoor pools. I also tested whether these effects were due entirely to prey consumption by Salamandra larvae or alternatively to some nonconsumptive effect. The soil (containing crustacean eggs) added to the artificial pools was collected from a dried-out temporary pool that is inhabited by Salamandra during the early part of the hydroperiod. I randomly assigned the pools to one of three treatments: control, free Salamandra, or caged Salamandra. Free salamander larvae could roam the entire pool and prey upon crustaceans. Caged salamander larvae were placed within a cage with having 250-μm mesh windows. They could not prey upon the crustaceans but could, for example, influence them by chemical cues. Densities of the three dominant crustacean species (Arctodiaptomus similis, Ceriodaphnia quadrangula and Cyzicus sp.) were drastically reduced in both salamander treatments compared to the control. Crustacean densities, however, were not significantly different between the two salamander treatments. One plausible explanation is that crustacean eggs can detect the presence of this predator via chemical cues and delay hatching. Received: 4 March 1996 / Accepted, 23 October 1996     

Behavioral linkage of pelagic prey and littoral predators: microhabitat selection by Daphnia induced by damselfly larvae

Only recently ecologists started treating the previously separately considered benthic, littoral and pelagic zones of lake ecosystems as closely connected compartments. Here we study a link between organisms belonging to a different compartment – namely the pelagic and the littoral – through behavior in a series of laboratory experiments. Waterfleas of the genus Daphnia are inhabitants of the pelagic zone and suffer a high predation pressure from syntopic vertebrate predators (mainly fish). Presumably to escape this predation, they sometimes migrate in the day to the littoral to seek refuge within macrophytes and return to the pelagic at night. Zygopterans from the genus Ischnura do commonly co-occur in ponds with Daphnia and are known as opportunistic predators of Daphnia . In two initial experiments in microcosms in the lab we showed that Ischnura larvae are littoral predators strongly associated with macrophytes. Although we found that predation rates of individual Ischnura larvae on Daphnia are approximately 1.5 fold lower in macrophytes compared to open water, total predation from Ischnura on Daphnia per unit area is tenfold higher within macrophytes than in open water, making the open water a safer place for Daphnia with regard to Ischnura predation. In a third microcosm experiment we monitored horizontal distribution of Daphnia in the absence, presence and odor only of Ischnura larvae. After 2 hours, on average 10% less Daphnia remained within the vegetation when Ischnura larvae or only their odor were present compared to when Ischnura or their odor were absent. We interpret this as a behavioral anti-predation response of Daphnia to the presence of Ischnura larvae that seems primarily chemically mediated. The observed horizontal migration of the pelagic prey driven by the littoral predator may couple both lake compartments and may interact with the predator–prey relationships within the pelagic.     

Predation by odonates depresses mosquito abundance in water-filled tree holes in Panama

In the lowland moist forest of Barro Colorado Island (BCI), Panama, larvae of four common species of odonates, a mosquito, and a tadpole are the major predators in water-filled tree holes. Mosquito larvae are their most common prey. Holes colonized naturally by predators and prey had lower densities of mosquitoes if odonates were present than if they were absent. Using artificial tree holes placed in the field, we tested the effects of odonates on their mosquito prey while controlling for the quantity and species of predator, hole volume, and nutrient input. In large and small holes with low nutrient input, odonates depressed the number of mosquitoes present and the number that survived to pupation. Increasing nutrient input (and consequently, mosquito abundance) to abnormally high levels dampened the effect of predation when odonates were relatively small. However, the predators grew faster with higher nutrients, and large larvae in all three genera reduced the number of mosquitoes surviving to pupation, even though the abundance of mosquito larvae remained high. Size-selective predation by the odonates is a likely explanation for this result; large mosquito larvae were less abundant in the predator treatment than in the controls. Because species assemblages were similar between natural and artificial tree holes, our results suggest that odonates are keystone species in tree holes on BCI, where they are the most common large predators. Received: 4 November 1996 / Accepted: 11 April 1997     

The effects of group size on per capita ingestion in flatworms

1. We evaluated the effect of group size on the per capita ingestion rates of three species of flatworm, two of which actively group with conspecifics (Dugesia tigrina, D, dorotocephala) and employ mucus to capture prey, and a third species (Mesostoma ehrenbergii) that does not actively group but does use mucus to capture prey. 2. As flatworm group size increased, daily per capita ingestion first increased and then decreased for D. tigrina and D. dorotocephala. In the case of D. tigrina this pattern was observed even at low predator densities. Ingestion rates of M. ehrenbergii were largely unaffected by group size. 3. Results suggest that the observed changes in per capita ingestion rates with changes in group size previously reported for D. tigrina are related to their tendency for active grouping and are not directly a consequence of prey capture technique or experimental design. 4. We argue that freshwater triclads in general, and D. tigrina in particular, represent an ideal model system for the development and testing of group foraging theory.     

Behavior of juvenile pink salmon (Oncorhynchus gorbuscha Walbaum) toward novel prey: influence of ontogeny and experience

Synopsis The behavior of individual, juvenile pink salmon toward novel prey (Artemia salina) under laboratory conditions is described. Two aspects of predatory behavior, namely latency time to initial prey-capture attempt and prey-capture success, are quantified in relation to chronological age and feeding experience. Initially, mean latency time declined slightly with increasing age up to Day 19 (post-emergence from gravel), but increased sharply to an asymptote with further aging. Mean percentage capture success gradually increased from 7.88% on Day 1 to 92.9% on Day 45. Prior feeding experience on the prey resulted in a decline (to a stable level) in mean latency time in experienced fish compared to control fish. Mean percentage capture success was not significantly altered by prior feeding experience on the prey.