Cellular response to horizontally transferred DNA in Escherichia coli is tuned by DNA repair systems

We studied how DNA divergence between recombining DNAs and the mismatch repair system modulate the SOS response in Escherichia coli. The observed positive log-linear correlation between SOS induction and DNA divergence, and the negative correlation between SOS induction and frequency of recombination, suggest that the level of SOS induction precisely reflects the difficulty of RecA protein to initiate a productive strand exchange process. Our results suggest that the mismatch repair system could contribute to this SOS induction more by affecting the RecA-catalyzed homology search than by acting on mismatched recombination intermediates. The propensity of the recombination machinery to promote recombination between the blocks of sequences with the highest identity results in the increasing ratios of merodiploids (partial diploids) over genuine recombinants (homologous replacements) with increasing DNA divergence. We discuss the role of molecular mechanisms involved in the control of the recombination between diverged DNA sequences in the maintenance of genomic stability and genome evolution.     

Vitamin para-aminobenzoic acid inhibits development of SOS function in tif-1 mutants of Escherichia coli at nonpermissive temperatures

The development of "SOS" inducible functions in lysogenic and non-lysogenic strains of Escherichia coli tif-1 sfiA11 (lambda) at nonpermissive temperature of 42 degrees C was strongly suppressed by para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA). The rate of prophage lambda induction decreased 400 times, as compared to the control level; the efficiency of W-reactivation of UV-irradiated phage lambda decreased 37.5 to 16%. PABA also inhibited to some extent (1.5 times) the process of inducible recombination on the RecF pathway. The processes of spontaneous lambda induction and W-reactivation, as well as spontaneous recombination on RecBC and RecF pathways, were not influenced by PABA. The above data are in accordance with previous studies of PABA action when the manifestation of "SOS" functions was induced by chemical mutagens. The action of PABA has been tentatively interpreted on the basis of negative control of "SOS" repair pathway.     

Repair system for noncanonical purines in Escherichia coli

Exposure of Escherichia coli strains deficient in molybdopterin biosynthesis (moa) to the purine base N-6-hydroxylaminopurine (HAP) is mutagenic and toxic. We show that moa mutants exposed to HAP also exhibit elevated mutagenesis, a hyperrecombination phenotype, and increased SOS induction. The E. coli rdgB gene encodes a protein homologous to a deoxyribonucleotide triphosphate pyrophosphatase from Methanococcus jannaschii that shows a preference for purine base analogs. moa rdgB mutants are extremely sensitive to killing by HAP and exhibit increased mutagenesis, recombination, and SOS induction upon HAP exposure. Disruption of the endonuclease V gene, nfi, rescues the HAP sensitivity displayed by moa and moa rdgB mutants and reduces the level of recombination and SOS induction, but it increases the level of mutagenesis. Our results suggest that endonuclease V incision of DNA containing HAP leads to increased recombination and SOS induction and even cell death. Double-strand break repair mutants display an increase in HAP sensitivity, which can be reversed by an nfi mutation. This suggests that cell killing may result from an increase in double-strand breaks generated when replication forks encounter endonuclease V-nicked DNA. We propose a pathway for the removal of HAP from purine pools, from deoxynucleotide triphosphate pools, and from DNA, and we suggest a general model for excluding purine base analogs from DNA. The system for HAP removal consists of a molybdoenzyme, thought to detoxify HAP, a deoxyribonucleotide triphosphate pyrophosphatase that removes noncanonical deoxyribonucleotide triphosphates from replication precursor pools, and an endonuclease that initiates the removal of HAP from DNA.     

lon incompatibility associated with mutations causing SOS induction: null uvrD alleles induce an SOS response in Escherichia coli

The uvrD gene in Escherichia coli encodes a 720-amino-acid 3'-5' DNA helicase which, although nonessential for viability, is required for methyl-directed mismatch repair and nucleotide excision repair and furthermore is believed to participate in recombination and DNA replication. We have shown in this study that null mutations in uvrD are incompatible with lon, the incompatibility being a consequence of the chronic induction of SOS in uvrD strains and the resultant accumulation of the cell septation inhibitor SulA (which is a normal target for degradation by Lon protease). uvrD-lon incompatibility was suppressed by sulA, lexA3(Ind(-)), or recA (Def) mutations. Other mutations, such as priA, dam, polA, and dnaQ (mutD) mutations, which lead to persistent SOS induction, were also lon incompatible. SOS induction was not observed in uvrC and mutH (or mutS) mutants defective, respectively, in excision repair and mismatch repair. Nor was uvrD-mediated SOS induction abolished by mutations in genes that affect mismatch repair (mutH), excision repair (uvrC), or recombination (recB and recF). These data suggest that SOS induction in uvrD mutants is not a consequence of defects in these three pathways. We propose that the UvrD helicase participates in DNA replication to unwind secondary structures on the lagging strand immediately behind the progressing replication fork, and that it is the absence of this function which contributes to SOS induction in uvrD strains.     

5-Azacytidine: survival and induction of the SOS response in Escherichia coli K-12

Survival and induction of the SOS system by 5-azacytidine, an analog of cytidine, were studied in Escherichia coli K-12. This compound did not produce any effect on the viability of dcm and dam dcm mutants. Furthermore, recA430 and lexA1 strains (both mutations interfere with LexA repressor cleavage but not recombination proficiency) were more resistant than the wild-type strain of E. coli K-12. In contrast, recBC and recA13 mutants were more sensitive to 5-azacytidine than the wild type. Transient exposure of E. coli to 5-azacytidine for 60 min induced both recA-dependent inhibition of cell division and induction of lambda prophage in Dcm+ strains but not in Dcm- mutants. Expression of both functions was dependent on recBC exonuclease. On the other hand, 5-azacytidine was unable to trigger the induction of umuCD and mucB genes and no amplification of RecA protein synthesis in either Dcm+ or Dcm- strains was observed. These last results are in agreement with previously reported data suggesting that there is a discrimination in the expression of the several SOS functions and that some SOS genes may be induced without amplification of RecA protein synthesis.     

A system for detection of genetic and epigenetic alterations in Escherichia coli induced by DNA-damaging agents

In order to compare the genetic and epigenetic effects of genotoxic agents, we have constructed Escherichia coli K12 strains that allow the detection of mutagenesis, SOS induction (epigenetic effect) and genetic recombination in the same genetic background. The epigenetic effect was detected in a similar way to any genetic alteration, i.e. by counting altered clones (colonies), using a gene fusion system that responds to a temporary epigenetic effect by a stable, heritable switch. The gene fusion consists of the E. coli gal operon and a partially deleted prophage lambda, resulting in the gal operon coming under the control of the cI and cro genes. It allows the detection of SOS induction and forward mutagenesis in the cI gene. Even a temporary inactivation of the CI repressor in this particular system leads to a stable epigenetic switch transmitted to the cellular progeny, which can be detected as Gal+ (red) colonies. The genetic (mutational inactivation of gene cI) and epigenetic (proteolytic inactivation of the product of gene cI) mechanisms leading to gal expression can be distinguished. Genetic recombination between two heteroallelic lacZ genes, one located in the bacterial chromosome, the other on an F'lac plasmid, can be detected as Lac+ colonies. Radiation and several chemical mutagens show very different capacities in generating mutants, inductants and recombinants; therefore, a dose range of any physical or chemical agent generates a set of relative values for the generation of mutants, inductants and recombinants that are characteristic of the agent.     

Identification of the Escherichia coli recN gene product as a major SOS protein.

The recA+ lexA+-dependent induction of four Escherichia coli SOS proteins was readily observed by two-dimensional gel analysis. In addition to the 38-kilodalton (kDa) RecA protein, which was induced in the greatest amounts and was readily identified, three other proteins of 115, 62, and 12 kDa were seen. The 115-kDa protein is the product of the uvrA gene, which is required for nucleotide excision repair and has previously been shown to be induced in the SOS response. The 62-kDa protein, which was induced to high intracellular levels, is the product of recN, a gene required for recBC-independent recombination. The recA and recN genes were partially derepressed in a recBC sbcB genetic background, a phenomenon which might account for the recombination proficiency of such strains. The 12-kDa protein has yet to be identified.     

RecJ nuclease is required for SOS induction after introduction of a double-strand break in a RecA loading deficient recB mutant of Escherichia coli

The SOS response is an important mechanism which allows Escherichia coli cells to maintain genome integrity. Two key proteins in SOS regulation are LexA (repressor) and RecA (coprotease). The signal for SOS induction is generated at the level of a RecA filament. Depending on the type of DNA damage, a RecA filament is produced by specific activities (helicase, nuclease and RecA loading) of either RecBCD, RecF or a hybrid recombination pathway. It was recently demonstrated that RecA loading activity is essential for the induction of the SOS response after UV-irradiation. In this paper we studied the genetic requirements for SOS induction after introduction of a double-strand break (DSB) by the I-SceI endonuclease in a RecA loading deficient recB mutant (recB1080). We monitored SOS induction by assaying beta-galactosidase activity and compared induction of the response between strains having one or more inactivated mechanisms of RecA loading and their derivatives. We found that simultaneous inactivation of both RecA loading functions (in recB1080 recO double mutant) partially impairs SOS induction after introduction of a DSB. However, we found that the RecJ nuclease is essential for SOS induction after the introduction of a DSB in the recB1080 mutant. This result indicates that RecJ is needed to prepare ssDNA for subsequent loading of RecA protein. It implies that an additional type of RecA loading could exist in the cell.     

Effect of induction of SOS response on expression of pBR322 genes and on plasmid copy number

Several lines of evidence are presented that indicate that the level of tetracycline resistance of Esherichia coli strains harboring plasmid pBR322 varies according to whether the SOS system of the host bacteria has been induced. These include use of strains in which the SOS system is expressed constitutively (lexA def.), is thermoinducible (recA441) or noninducible (lexA ind-), or is highly repressed (multiple copies of lexA+). Similar induction was observed with the product of another plasmid gene, beta-lactamase. The amounts of extractable plasmid DNA were also increased by SOS induction, and we propose that the SOS-induced increases in levels of tetracycline resistance and beta-lactamase activity are due to an increased plasmid copy number.     

Genetic evidence for the requirement of RecA loading activity in SOS induction after UV irradiation in Escherichia coli

The SOS response in Escherichia coli results in the coordinately induced expression of more than 40 genes which occurs when cells are treated with DNA-damaging agents. This response is dependent on RecA (coprotease), LexA (repressor), and the presence of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). A prerequisite for SOS induction is the formation of a RecA-ssDNA filament. Depending on the DNA substrate, the RecA-ssDNA filament is produced by either RecBCD, RecFOR, or a hybrid recombination mechanism with specific enzyme activities, including helicase, exonuclease, and RecA loading. In this study we examined the role of RecA loading activity in SOS induction after UV irradiation. We performed a genetic analysis of SOS induction in strains with a mutation which eliminates RecA loading activity in the RecBCD enzyme (recB1080 allele). We found that RecA loading activity is essential for SOS induction. In the recB1080 mutant RecQ helicase is not important, whereas RecJ nuclease slightly decreases SOS induction after UV irradiation. In addition, we found that the recB1080 mutant exhibited constitutive expression of the SOS regulon. Surprisingly, this constitutive SOS expression was dependent on the RecJ protein but not on RecFOR, implying that there is a different mechanism of RecA loading for constitutive SOS expression.     

A comparison of the relative activities of 8 radiosensitizers in the SOS chromotest

Misonidazole, and RSU 1069 and 6 of its analogues are all reported to show increased cytotoxicity towards hypoxic cells compared to oxic cells. DNA is considered to be the target through which these drugs exert their cytotoxic activity. Therefore we monitored induction of the SOS response in uvrABC excinuclease proficient and deficient strains of E. coli, under oxic and hypoxic conditions, as an indirect method of assessing the activity of these drugs towards DNA in a biological system. This was done using the SOS chromotest which utilizes E. coli strains which possess a sfiA::lacZ fusion allowing induction of the SOS response to be monitored by assaying beta-galactosidase activity. All of the drugs tested here show some induction of the SOS response in both uvrABC excinuclease proficient and deficient strains. Data shown here suggests that the uvrABC excinuclease is important in the production of a SOS induction signal from RSU 1069-induced DNA lesions and that RSU 1069 may act as a crosslinking agent. The data also shows that SOS induction activity and toxicity do not necessarily correlate and that production of a SOS induction signal may occur via a different pathway for RSU 1069 than for its analogues.     

Stimulation of recombination between homologous sequences on carcinogen-treated plasmid DNA and chromosomal DNA by induction of the SOS response in Escherichia coli K12

Summary Previous studies have shown that transformation of Escherichia coli by plasmid DNA modified in vitro by carcinogens leads to RecA-dependant recombination between homologous plasmid and chromosomal DNA sequences. The mechanism of this recombination has now been studied using recombination-deficient mutants, and the influence of induction of the SOS response on the level of recombination investigated. Plasmid pNO1523, containing the str ⁺ operon (Sm^s), has been modified in vitro by either irradiation with UV light, or by reaction with (±) trans-benzo(a)pyrene-7,8-dihydrodiol-9,10-epoxide (BPDE) and used to transform streptomycin-resistant hosts. The formation of Amp^r transformants which also carry streptomycin resistance was used as a measure of the level of recombination between plasmid and chromosomal DNA. Transformation of recB and recC mutants produced no change in the level of recombination while in the recF mutant a significant decrease was observed compared to the wild type host. Thermal induction of the SOS response in tif-1 and tif-1 umuC mutants followed by transformation led to a four-fold increase in recombination in both cases. The results suggest that the streptomycin-resistant transformants arise exclusively via a recombinational pathway which is largely dependant on the recF gene product, and that this pathway is influenced by induction of the SOS response. These results are discussed in terms of the mechanism of this recombination.     

Suppression of Escherichia coli recF mutations by recA-linked srfA mutations.

Suppressors of recF (srfA) were found by selection for resistance to mitomycin C and UV irradiation in a recB21 recC22 sbcB15 recF143 strain. srfA mutations map in recA and are dominant to srfA+. They suppress both the DNA repair and the recombination deficiencies due to recF mutations. Therefore, RecA protein which is altered by the srfA mutation can allow genetic recombination to proceed in the absence of recB, recC, and recF functions. recF is also required for induction of the SOS response after UV damage. We propose that recF+ normally functions to allow the expression of two recA activities, one that is required for the RecF pathway of recombination and another that is required for SOS induction. The two RecA activities are different and are separable by mutation since srfA mutations permit recombination to proceed but have not caused a dramatic increase in SOS induction in recF mutants. According to this hypothesis, one role for recF in DNA repair and recombination is to modulate RecA activities to allow RecA to participate in these recF-dependent processes.     

Requirements for ATP binding and hydrolysis in RecA function in Escherichia coli

RecA is essential for recombination, DNA repair and SOS induction in Escherichia coli . ATP hydrolysis is known to be important for RecA's roles in recombination and DNA repair. In vitro reactions modelling SOS induction minimally require ssDNA and non-hydrolyzable ATP analogues. This predicts that ATP hydrolysis will not be required for SOS induction in vivo . The requirement of ATP binding and hydrolysis for SOS induction in vivo is tested here through the study of recA4159 (K72A) and recA2201 (K72R). RecA4159 is thought to have reduced affinity for ATP. RecA2201 binds, but does not hydrolyse ATP. Neither mutant was able to induce SOS expression after UV irradiation. RecA2201, unlike RecA4159, could form filaments on DNA and storage structures as measured with RecA–GFP. RecA2201 was able to form hybrid filaments and storage structures and was either recessive or dominant to RecA⁺, depending on the ratio of the two proteins. RecA4159 was unable to enter RecA⁺ filaments on DNA or storage structures and was recessive to RecA⁺. It is concluded that ATP hydrolysis is essential for SOS induction. It is proposed that ATP binding is essential for storage structure formation and ability to interact with other RecA proteins in a filament.     

A novel assay for illegitimate recombination in Escherichia coli: Stimulation of λbio transducing phage formation by ultra-violet light and its independence from RecA function

We developed a novel assay system for illegitimate recombination, in which the frequency of the formation of λ Spi⁻ phages formed during prophage induction was measured with an E. coli P2 lysogen as the indicator bacteria. Since almost all of the λ Spi⁻ phages thus detected contain attR, they have essentially the same structures as λbio transducing phages, indicating that this assay system enables us to detect specialized transducing phages that produce heterogenote transductants, thus ignoring the occurrences of docL and docR particles which carry only one cohesive end. The following results on the formation of specialized transducing phages have been obtained by this assay system to date. (1) Irradiation with UV light greatly enhanced the formation of λ Spi⁻ phages. (2) Treatments with other DNA-damaging agents also enhanced the formation of λ Spi⁻ phages. (3) Illegitimate recombination during prophage induction does not require the RecA function, indicating that enhancement of λ Spi⁻ phage formation is not controlled by the SOS regulatory system. (4) Preliminary results suggested that DNA gyrase is involved in the formation of λ Spi⁻ phage during prophage induction. Since the above results were consistent with most of the previous observations on the illegitimate recombination in other systems, the Spi⁻ assay system can provide important clues to the mechanism of illegitimate recombination.     

Survival and induction of SOS in Escherichia coli treated with cisplatin, UV-irradiation, or mitomycin C are dependent on the function of the RecBC and RecFOR pathways of homologous recombination

Resistance of tumors to drugs such as cisplatin and mitomycin C (MMC) is an important factor limiting their usefulness in cancer chemotherapy. The antitumor effects of these drugs are due to the formation of bifunctional adducts in DNA, with cisplatin causing predominantly intrastrand-crosslinks and MMC causing interstrand-crosslinks. The SOS chromotest was used to study the cellular mechanisms that process DNA damage in Escherichia coli exposed to cisplatin, ultraviolet irradiation (UV) and MMC and subsequently facilitate the production of a molecular signal for induction of the SOS response. Strains used in the SOS chromotest have a fusion of lacZ with the sfiA (sulA) gene so that the amount of SOS inducing signal, which is modulated by the ability of the cell to repair DNA, is measured by assaying beta-galactosidase activity. SOS induction in a strain proficient in homologous recombination (HR) was compared with that in isogenic strains deficient in HR due to a blocked RecBC pathway caused by a recB mutation or a blocked RecFOR pathway caused by a recO mutation. The effect of cisplatin treatment in a uvrA mutant strain blocked at the first step of NER was compared with that in an isogenic strain proficient in NER. Cellular resistance was measured as percent colony forming units (cfu) for cells treated with increasing doses of cisplatin, MMC and UV relative to that in untreated control cultures. The importance of both HR pathways for resistance to these treatments was demonstrated by decreased survival in mutants with the recB mutant being more sensitive than the recO mutant. SOS induction levels were elevated in the sensitive recB strain relative to the HR proficient strain possibly due to stalled and/or distorted replication forks at crosslinks in DNA. In contrast, induction of SOS was dependent on RecFOR activity that is thought to act at daughter strand gaps in newly synthesized DNA to mediate production of the signal for SOS induction. Proficiency in NER was necessary for both survival and high levels of SOS induction in cisplatin treated cells.     

uvrD mutations enhance tandem repeat deletion in the Escherichia coli chromosome via SOS induction of the RecF recombination pathway

It has previously been shown that recombination between tandem repeats is not significantly affected by a recA mutation in Escherichia coli . Here, we describe the activation of a RecA-dependent recombination pathway in a hyper-recombination mutant. In order to analyse how tandem repeat deletion may proceed, we searched for mutants that affect this process. Three hyper-recombination clones were characterized and shown to be mutated in the uvrD gene. Two of the mutations were identified as opal mutations at codons 130 and 438. A uvrD  ::Tn 5 mutation was used to investigate the mechanism of deletion formation in these mutants. The uvrD -mediated stimulation of deletion was abolished by a lexAind3 mutation or by inactivation of either the recA , recF , recQ or ruvA genes. We conclude that (i) this stimulation requires SOS induction and (ii) tandem repeat recombination in uvrD mutants occurs via the RecF pathway. In uvrD ⁺ cells, constitutive expression of SOS genes is not sufficient to stimulate deletion formation. This suggests that the RecF recombination pathway activated by SOS induction is antagonized by the UvrD protein. Paradoxically, we observed that the overproduction of UvrD from a plasmid also stimulates tandem repeat deletion. However, this stimulation is RecA independent, as is deletion in a wild-type strain. We propose that the presence of an excess of the UvrD helicase favours replication slippage. This work suggests that the UvrD helicase controls a balance between different routes of tandem repeat deletion.     

Influence of dam and mismatch repair system on mutagenic and SOS-inducing activity of methyl methanesulfonate in Escherichia coli

In contrast to earlier reports (Mohn et al., 1980; Glickman, 1982), we show that E. coli dam- cells are able to mutate following MMS treatment. Since the mutagenicity of MMS has been regarded as largely dependent on induction of the SOS functions, E. coli strains bearing the recA::lacZ or umuC::lacZ fusions were used to determine the ability of MMS to induce the SOS functions in the various dam+ and dam- strains. The mutagenicity of MMS was also tested in several of these strains. The results show that (i) there is no direct correlation between SOS-inducing ability and mutagenicity potency of MMS; and (ii) most of the premutagenic lesions induced by MMS are removed from DNA of dam+ or dam- cells by the mismatch repair system. The role of strand breaks in repair of mismatches induced by alkylating agents is discussed.     

Differential Suppression of Pria2::Kan Phenotypes in Escherichia Coli K-12 by Mutations in Pria, Lexa, and Dnac

First identified as an essential component of the X174 in vitro DNA replication system, PriA has ATPase, helicase, translocase, and primosome-assembly activities. priA1::kan strains of Escherichia coli are sensitive to UV irradiation, deficient in homologous recombination following transduction, and filamentous. priA2::kan strains have eightfold higher levels of uninduced SOS expression than wild type. We show that (1) priA1::kan strains have eightfold higher levels of uninduced SOS expression, (2) priA2::kan strains are UV(S) and Rec(-), (3) lexA3 suppresses the high basal levels of SOS expression of a priA2::kan strain, and (4) plasmid-encoded priA300 (K230R), a mutant allele retaining only the primosome-assembly activity of priA(+), restores both UV(R) and Rec(+) phenotypes to a priA2::kan strain. Finally, we have isolated 17 independent UV(R) Rec(+) revertants of priA2::kan strains that carry extragenic suppressors. All 17 map in the C-terminal half of the dnaC gene. DnaC loads the DnaB helicase onto DNA as a prelude for primosome assembly and DNA replication. We conclude that priA's primosome-assembly activity is essential for DNA repair and recombination and that the dnaC suppressor mutations allow these processes to occur in the absence of priA.