Induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes. VII. Correlation between trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid administration, serum trinitrophenyl content, and level of tolerance

The induction of immunological tolerance with trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) was studied by a comparison of the concentration of trinitrophenyl (TNP) in the serum of tolerant mice (TolS) and the degree of unresponsiveness induced as the dose and time of tolerogen injection were varied. The concentration of TNP in TolS was greater with a larger dose of TNBS, as expected, and decreased with time after tolerogen injection in a biphasic manner. The rapid initial decline followed on Day 10 by a more gradual decrease in TNP concentration suggests that there were two classes of TNP conjugates produced by TNBS injection. The serum TNP concentration appeared to correlate to the in vivo response of TNBS-treated mice to thymic-dependent and thymic-independent antigenic challenge while little correlation was evident with the in vitro response.     

The induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes. II. Temporal and dose response relationships of tolerance induction in B lymphocytes of various differentiation states.

The induction of TNP-specific B lymphocyte tolerance by TNBS in sources representing various differentiation states was studied in an adoptive cell transfer system. An adoptive assay was utilized in which the delay of immunization with the T-independent antigen TNP-LPS resulted in an enhanced PFC response. TNBS induced tolerance in spleen cells which was independent of T cell activity, was dose dependent, and could be adoptively transferred. While bone marrow and spleen cells were susceptible to tolerogenesis after cell transfer, TNBS treatment of the donor induced unresponsiveness in splenocytes but not marrow cells. The tolerance dose response relationship and the effect of the temporal relationship between cell transfer and tolerogenesis were studied in B lymphocytes from various sources. Adult spleen cells were resistant to tolerance induction late in the adoptive response, and the tolerance induced by TNBS administration 1 hr after cell transfer was dose dependent. Athymic nude spleen cells and adult bone marrow cells displayed similar characteristics while fetal liver cells were somewhat more susceptible to the induction of unresponsiveness. Neonatal spleen cells were rendered tolerant at much lower doses and at any stage of the adoptive response. The hierarchy obtained in these studies in the order of decreasing resistance to tolerance induction is: adult normal and athymic nude spleen and adult bone marrow, fetal liver, and neonatal spleen. This variation in tolerogenesis appears to be due to the maturity of the cell types which may reflect differences in B lymphocyte sub-populations.     

Defective B cell tolerance induction in New Zealand black mice. I. Macrophage independence and comparison with other autoimmune strains

B cell unresponsiveness was examined in vitro by using spleen cells from autoimmune NZB, BXSB/Mp male, MRL/Mp-Ipr/Ipr (MRL/l), and control mice, and the tolerogen trinitrophenyl human gamma-globulin (TNP-HGG). The B cell subset responsive to TNP-Brucella abortus in each autoimmune and control strain that was tested was highly susceptible to tolerance induction with the use of high epitope density conjugates (TNP30HGG and TNP32HGG). When a tolerogen with a lower epitope density was used (TNP7HGG), several control strains were all rendered tolerant in a thymic-independent and hapten-specific manner. NZB B cells were resistant to all concentrations of TNP7HGG tested, whereas B cells from BXSB/Mp male and MRL/1 mice were resistant to low concentrations of this tolerogen. NZB mice were resistant in addition to tolerance induction with TNP9HGG, TNP10HGG, and TNP12.7HGG. Experiments were performed to determine whether splenic macrophages played a role in resistance to tolerance in NZB mice. The mixing of NZB and control DBA/2J T cell-depleted splenocytes revealed no modulatory effects by the accessory cells in culture. Moreover, B cells rigorously depleted of macrophages by double Sephadex G-10 column passage exhibited characteristic patterns of resistance or susceptibility in NZB and control strains, respectively. These findings support the conclusion that resistance to tolerance in NZB mice is determined at the B cell level and are consistent with the hypothesis that diverse immunoregulatory disturbances contribute in varying degrees to the development of systemic lupus erythematosus in different inbred strains of mice.     

B Cell Tolerance

The mechanisms of B cell tolerance were studied in an attempt to learn whether B cells rendered tolerant are present in the immune system in a potentially responsive form. The author tested the in vitro anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) antibody-forming cell (anti-TNP AFC) response to TNP-immunogens and polyclonal B cell activators (PBA) of spleen cells taken from mice injected with a tolerogen, TNP-carboxymethylcellulose (TNP-CMC). Spleen cells from mice injected 5 days previously with 10 μg of TNP-CMC did not respond to TNP-sheep red blood cells (TNP-SRBC), T-dependent (TD) antigen or TNP-Ficoll, T-independent (TI) antigen. However, the same spleen cells responded to PBA, lipopolysaccharide (LPS) of Salmonella enteritidis and purified protein derivative (PPD) of BCG. The results indicate that B cells specific for TNP are present in a potentially responsive form. Spleen cells from mice injected with 500 μg of TNP-CMC did not respond to either TNP-immunogens or PBA. The state of unresponsiveness to PBA lasted for 12 days after the tolerogen injection. Responsiveness to PBA reappeared within the short period of 2 days, whereas unresponsiveness to TNP-immunogens lasted much longer. Unresponsiveness to PBA was relieved considerably by treating tolerant spleen cells with the proteolytic enzyme trypsin before in vitro stimulation. These results indicate that B cells rendered refractory are present in the immune system in a potentially responsive form.     

Comparison of the ease of tolerance induction in thymus and bone marrow of three strains of mice

Three strains of mice which vary in their susceptibility to induction of immune tolerance with human gamma-globulin were studied to evaluate the cellular basis for their sensitivity to induction of the unresponsive state. Tolerance induction in BALB/c mice was difficult to establish, while tolerance induction was easily achieved in C57BL/6 and CBF₁ (BALB/c × C57BL/6) mice. The degree of unresponsiveness obtained with various tolerogen doses in intact C57BL/6 and CBF₁ mice was reflected in the sensitivity of their thymocytes to the production of the unresponsive state. In the BALB/c mouse strain slight immune suppression observed at low tolerogen doses was correlated with bone marrow cell unresponsiveness while significant levels of tolerance observed at a high tolerogen dose was due to suppression of thymus cells. It was apparent that CBF₁ mice had inherited both thymus cells and bone marrow cells which exhibited the sensitivity to induction of immune tolerance characteristic of those same cells of their C57BL/6 parent.     

Trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid effects in two amphibian model systems

The induction of hapten-specific tolerance was investigated in two amphibia, Notophthalmus viridescens and Xenopus laevis. Responses to trinitrophenylated (TNP)-Ficoll and TNP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS), as well as to horse erythrocytes (HRBC) were examined in both species, following an intraperitoneal injection of 2,4,6-trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS). The less evolutionarily advanced newt, Notophthalmus, failed to respond to all three immunogens after TNBS administration. While Xenopus became completely tolerant upon challenge with TNP-Ficoll and partially tolerant with TNP-LPS, full capacity to respond to HRBC was retained. Therefore, specific tolerance was induced in Xenopus, but not in Notophthalmus. The tolerance with TNP-Ficoll in the toad, Xenopus, was short lived and return to responsiveness appeared to be related inversely to levels of TNP protein in the sera of TNBS-treated animals. The thymic dependence of this tolerance could not be determined, because adult thymectomy (ATx) abrogated the response to TNP-Ficoll in control nontolerized animals. Responses to TNP-LPS and HRBC were unaffected by ATx. These data, in conjunction with TNBS-induced differential tolerance to the TNP moiety, suggest carrier-dependent hapten-specific B-cell heterogeneity in the toad which differs in certain ways from that recently described for murine systems.     

Role of self carriers in the immune response and tolerance. III. B cell tolerance induced by hapten-modified-self involves both active T cell-mediated suppression and direct blockade.

The induction of B cell unresponsiveness with hapten-modified syngeneic murine lymphoid cells (hapten-modified self, HMS) can be achieved in vivo and in vitro. Tolerance in vivo in mice required a latent period of 3 to 4 days. Moreover, B cell unresponsiveness could not be induced by HMS in athymic nude mice, although their nu/+ littermates were rendered hyporesponsive by HMS. Pretreatment of normal mice with cyclophosphamide (cyclo) prevented their susceptibility to tolerance induction by haptenated lymphoid cells. Nude mice became sensitive to HMS-induced suppression if they were first reconstituted with spleen cells from normal (but not cyclo-treated) donors.Interestingly, labeling of H-2 antigens was not necessary for tolerance induction by HMS since haptenated teratoma cells (lacking H-2) were tolerogenic in normal recipients.In contrast, suppression of the in vitro response to haptenated flagellin occurred equally well with nude, nu/+ and anti-Ly 2 + C-treated spleen cells. These data suggest that cyclo-sensitive modified self-reactive (T) cells may regulate the immune response and mediate tolerance to HMS in vivo. However, the in vitro “blockade” of B cell reactivity may be directly mediated on hapten-specific PFC precursors.     

B cell tolerance. I. Analysis of hapten-specific unresponsiveness induced in vitro in adult and neonatal murine spleen cell populations.

The cellular mechanisms and tolerogen dose requirements of hapten-specific unresponsiveness induced in vitro by using 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl human gamma-globulin (TNP17HgG) were analyzed in adult and neonatal murine splenocytes. Tolerance induction in both cell populations was found to be independent of non-B cell effects including BAtheta-positive cells, Ly 2.2-positive cells, adding or reducing the number of macrophages, and large excesses of HgG. The tolerance induced was specific and not "infectious", further excluding a role for suppressor T cells. Neonatal splenic B cells were rendered tolerant by doses of TNP17HgG 1000-fold less than those required to produce similar tolerance in splenic B cells from adults. These findings support the concept of functional clonal abortion as a mechanism for producing tolerance to self antigens.     

The use of haptenated-immunoglobulin molecules to induce tolerance in B cells from neonatal mice

The role of the Fc region of trinitrophenylated (TNP)-immunoglobulins (Ig) in their ability to induce tolerance in immature B cells was examined. With the use of B cells from neonatal mice, tolerogens that could or could not bind to Fc receptors were assessed for their ability to induce tolerance. This was accomplished by tolerizing spleen cells in bulk culture and assessing the degree of tolerance by challenging the cells with the thymus-independent antigen TNP-Brucella abortus (TNP-BA) in limiting dilution cultures. It was found that by using tolerogens containing 10 to 11 haptens per Ig molecule, immature B cells were very susceptible to tolerance induction. Mature B cells were not as susceptible. This increased susceptibility was independent of the Fc portion of the tolerogen, because TNP11-HGG and a TNP10-F(ab')2 induced equivalent degrees of unresponsiveness. When the TNP density was lowered to approximately five haptens per Ig molecule, those Ig molecules that contained Fc portions were superior tolerogens with the use of B cells from 6-day-old mice. Thus, a TNP4-HGG, TNP7-mouse IgG1, and TNP6-mouse IgG2a were more effective tolerogens than either TNP5-F(ab')2 or TNP6-mouse IgG3. These results confirm previous findings that immature B cells are inherently more susceptible to tolerance induction than mature B cells. They also suggest that very lightly haptenated Ig molecules may depend on Fc receptor-binding for effective tolerance induction. Finally, by means of a cytofluorograph, the surface IgD (sIgD) and sIgM phenotypes of splenic B cells from neonates of increasing age were determined. When comparing the phenotype of maturing cells with their tolerance susceptibilities, a correlation between the appearance of sIgD and the acquisition of resistance to tolerance was observed.     

Tolerance and contact sensitivity to DNFB in mice. VII. Functional demonstration of cell-associated tolerogen in lymph node cell populations containing specific suppressor cells.

Adoptive tolerance to contact sensitivity to DNFB is mediated by suppressor T cells. These cells are induced by iv injection of the hapten DNB-SO₃. Experiments were carried out to investigate the question of simultaneous transfer of tolerogen (DNB-SO₃ or its conjugation product DNP) with the suppressor cells. The results showed that tolerant lymph node cells pretreated in vitro with anti-TNP serum before transfer were unable to induce unresponsiveness to DNFB. Tolerant cells treated with either anti-TNP serum which had been passed over a TNP-affinity column or with polyvalent anti-immunoglobul in serum were not inhibited. These results functionally demonstrate that LN cell populations containing DNFB suppressor cells have accessible hapten (e.g., DNP) associated with their membrane, which is necessary for induction of adoptive tolerance. The hapten (tolerogen) appears to be bound directly to the cell surface rather than as an immune complex.     

Membrane defects of the tolerant B cell. I. Failure of antigen-induced capping.

In order to study the membrane function of tolerant B antigen-binding cells, tolerance to the trinitrophenyl (TNP) determinant was induced in mice by injecting the reactive form of the hapten, trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS). By appropriate transfer experiments, Fidler and Golub (J. Immunol.112, 1891, 1974) had previously shown that this form of tolerance is a B-cell property, induced and expressed in the absence of T cells. Hapten inhibition demonstrated the TNP-specificity of receptors on TNP-donkey erythrocyte(TNP-D)-binding cells in tolerant and nontolerant mice. About 88% of these cells were B cells by immunofluorescence, and the remainder were T cells. In the tolerant mice, challenge with TNP-sheep erythrocytes failed to expand the TNP-binding population, but sheep erythrocyte binders and anti-sheep plaque-forming cells expanded normally. Despite little or no change in TNP-binding cell numbers after tolerance induction, the TNP-binding cells of tolerant animals could not cap their receptors, in contrast to the sheep erythrocyte-binding cells from the same animals which capped normally. Although there is no anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response when tolerogen and immunogen are given simultaneously, capping failure is not evident until 2–4 days after tolerogen exposure. By Day 7, substantial recovery of immune responsiveness had occurred, yet even 12 months after a single dose of tolerogen there was no restoration of capping. Thus despite the association of both capping failure and unresponsiveness with tolerogen exposure, these lymphocyte functional defects appeared not to be causally related.     

Interference with tolerance induction of primed B cells by the Fc fragment of immunoglobulin

The capacity to interfere with tolerance induction in primed B cells was examined. Previous work had shown that TNP-specific splenic B cells from mice primed and boosted with TNP-KLH are highly susceptible to in vitro tolerization upon a brief exposure to TNP on a carrier unrelated to KLH. In the present work it was found that tolerance induction in these primed B cells could be partially disrupted by addition of the Fc fragment of immunoglobulin, a B-cell mitogen, and adjuvant, during exposure of the B cells to tolerogen. Addition of Fc fragments prepared by papain digestion of human IgG interfered with tolerization routinely in approximately 30-60% of the spleen cells susceptible to tolerogen. Addition of whole IgG or Fab fragments had no effect on tolerance induction. As little as 5 micrograms/ml of the Fc fragment preparation significantly interfered with tolerization and 32-64 micrograms/ml was optimal. Disruption of tolerization was most effective when the Fc fragment was added to the spleen cells either 4 hr prior to tolerogen or simultaneously with tolerogen; addition of the Fc fragment 4 hr after exposure to tolerogen was significantly less effective. Disruption of tolerization by the Fc fragment was not through polyclonal activation of B cells, as antigen was required for generation of significant numbers of PFC to TNP. Also, disruption was not through expansion of low avidity clones of B cells insusceptible to tolerogen, as the avidity of the antibody produced with and without Fc fragments present was approximately the same. These results show that the Fc fragment of IgG can partially interfere with tolerization of primed B cells. The manner in which Fc fragments may function to prevent tolerization through its lymphoid cell stimulatory capacities is discussed.     

T cell tolerization in vitro: modulation of helper and suppressor cell activities

This paper analyzes the conditions for in vitro tolerization of purified whole T cell populations and the consequences on helper and suppressor T cell functions. Highly purified splenic T cells from adult DBA/2 mice were incubated in vitro for 24 hr with high doses of trinitrophenyl coupled to human gamma-globulins (TNP-HGG). A profound inhibition of the TNP-specific helper function of these T lymphocytes was observed in a cooperative culture with normal purified splenic B cells and TNP-SRBC as antigen. This state of specific unresponsiveness was maintained after trypsin treatment of the cells, at the end of the 24-hr incubation with the tolerogen. We checked that this procedure removed the vast majority of F23.1 T cell receptor determinants from the cells. This result indicates that T cell receptors for antigen were not merely blocked by the tolerogen. In addition, B cells preincubated with tolerized T cells for 24 hr remained as responsive to TNP as B cells mixed with normal T cells in similar conditions. This demonstrates that the decreased response is not the result of secondary B cell tolerization. In addition, anti-Ia monoclonal antibodies were shown to block the induction of tolerance. We also showed that tolerized T cells significantly decreased the anti-TNP response of normal T and B cells in vitro, whereas the anti-SRBC response in the same cultures was unaffected. When tolerized T cells were separated into Lyt-2- and Lyt-2+ cells, it was found that tolerized Lyt-2- cells had lost about 75% of their helper activity and that Lyt-2+ cells suppressed 70% of the response of a normal T and B cell culture. Thus, in vitro induction of T cell tolerance results in a specific T cell unresponsiveness which is due to both helper T cell inactivation and induction of specific suppressor T cells.     

Cellular events in tolerance IX: Maintenance of immunological tolerance in the presence of normal B-cell precursors and in the absence of demonstrable suppression

The cellular events involved in immunological tolerance to fluoresceinated sheep gammaglobulin (FL-SGG) were analyzed at the level of hapten-specific B cells. One single iv injection of FL-SGG induced tolerance as measured by challenge with thymus-dependent (FL-KLH) or thymus-independent (FL-Ficoll) antigens in vivo or thymus-independent (FL-LPS) antigen in vitro. As noted earlier, unresponsiveness was maintained until 6–8 weeks after tolerance induction. Limiting-dilution precursor analysis demonstrated a reduction in B-cell precursors on Day 7 after tolerogen treatment; precursor frequencies returned to control levels by 3–4 weeks. This recovery of precursors in the presence of stable tolerance was not due to suppressor activity. Rather, results show that tolerant hapten-specific B cells are clonally anergic and display a reduced burst size in response to antigen. Hence, unresponsiveness is maintained in the presence of apparently normal precursor levels by an intrinsic defect in antigen-specific B cells.     

Establishment of unresponsiveness in primed B lymphocytes in vivo

As an approach to examine the influence of the state of cellular activation on the ability to tolerize B cells, the induction of unresponsiveness in human gamma-globulin-(HGG) primed B lymphocytes was studied in an adoptive transfer system. In contrast to transferred normal spleen cells, spleen cells from HGG-primed mice are not readily rendered unresponsive when exposed to the tolerogen, deaggregated HGG (DHGG), in irradiated recipients. A kinetic study showed that unfractionated primed spleen cells do not respond to an antigenic challenge given between 6 and 10 days after cell transfer and injection of DHGG, indicating that they are transiently depressed. In contrast, isolated primed B cells are tolerized when transferred to recipients and treated with DHGG in the absence of T cells. Furthermore, primed B cells exposed to tolerogen in the recipients do not recover the ability to respond to HGG either after a secondary challenge with AHGG given up to 14 days after transfer, or after 2 consecutive challenges given on days 14 and 24 after transfer. The presence of primed T cells at the time of tolerization interferes with the induction of unresponsiveness in these primed B cells. These studies suggest that the presence of primed T cells is responsible for the inability to tolerize unfractionated primed spleen cells populations and that primed B cells themselves are not intrinsically resistant to the induction of unresponsiveness.     

Tolerance induced by TNP-derivatized syngeneic erythrocytes: evidence for cooperation between hapten-specific T and hapten-specific B lymphocytes in the immune response.

Tolerance to the DNP haptenic determinant was induced with a single i.v. injection of trinitrophenylated syngeneic red blood cells. The tolerant state lasted 1 month and was stable on transfer to irradiated thymectomized syngeneic recipients. Suppressor activity was found soon after injection of tolerogen but was lost before the termination of tolerance. The unresponsive state could be reversed by adding normal thymus cells to tolerant spleen cells but not by normal bone marrow cells. LPS when given with immunogen restored the normal immune response in tolerant mice. Thus the injection of TNP-MRBC induced partial immune unresponsiveness which was characterized by the induction of T cell suppressor activity and by a hapten-specific helper T cells tolerance. Finally, these studies suggest a cooperative interaction between DNP-specific T lymphocytes and DNP-specific B lymphocytes in the immune response to DNP-BGG.     

Cellular events in tolerance. V. Detection, isolation and fate of lymphoid cells which bind fluoresccinated antigen in vivo.

The binding of tolerogen to specific receptors of lymphocytes and the subsequent fate of such cells was directly studied in Lewis rats injected with fluorescein-labeled sheep gamma globulin (F-SGG). This tolerogen produced unresponsiveness both in SGG-specific T cells (carrier tolerance) and F-specific antibody-forming cell precursors. The former (T-cell tolerance) was still significant more than 60 days after tolerogen whereas tolerance in the latter (B-cell tolerance) had waned by that time.Cells which have bound the tolerogen (antigen-binding cells, ABC) in vivo were detectable by direct immunofluorescence of washed spleen cell suspensions from rats injected with F-SGG up to 7 days previously. These cells were isolated using antifluorescein affinity columns, and shown to contain immunocompetent precursors for F- and SGG specific responses.The frequency of such ABC was between 30 and 80 per 10⁵ spleen, lymph node or bone marrow cells; no ABC were detected in the thymus. Both Ig positive and Ig negative cells were found to be ABC; Ig negative ABC usually showed a “capped” fluorescent pattern whereas Ig positive ABC generally were “spotted.”By 10 days after injection, ABC were not detectable in the spleen, lymph nodes, thymus or bone marrow of tolerant rats. Furthermore, reinjection of F-SGG after this time did not label any cells. This suggests that antigen-binding cells are not present at this time or that such cells, if available, lack receptors. In contrast, rats previously injected with a lower non-tolerogenic dose of F-SGG or an immunogenic form (F-SGG on bentonite) possessed cells at these later times which could be labeled with F-SGG. Thus, ABC remain detectable following immunogen or a subtolerogeic dose of F-SGG, but disappear in tolerant rats.By approximately 40 days after initial high dose tolerogen injection (when B cell tolerance has started to wane), cells capable of binding a second dose of F-SGG again became detectable. It is suggested that high doses of F-SGG are bound by specific lymphocytes (identifiable as ABC) and that these cells either fail to regenerate new receptors or die. As tolerance begins to wane, either new receptors or new cells are generated.     

Intrathymic T cell repertoire after prenatal trinitrobenzene-sulfonic acid-treatment

It is still a matter of debate, whether tolerance toward self-non-MHC antigens is due to intrathymic deletion or to regulatory processes in the periphery. To further pursue this question, responsiveness toward TNP and an anti-TNP monoclonal antibody (Sp6) carrying a recurrent idiotype was evaluated in prenatally trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS)-treated mice. In prenatally untreated as well as in TNBS-treated mice, thymocytes proliferating in the absence of nominal antigen were double negative (L3T4-/Lyt2-), but antigen-specific thymocytes were single positive (L3T4+/Lyt2- or L3T4-/Lyt2+). TNBS-treated mice differed from controls inasmuch as in their first week of life T cells proliferating in response to TNP were found in the thymus and detected at increased frequencies in the spleen. The frequency of TNP-specific thymocytes and spleen cells declined rapidly, finally reaching in the spleen a level of 20-30% of controls. Furthermore, after antigenic stimulation, the frequency of thymocytes and spleen cells proliferating in response to TNP was found to be increased in control mice, but TNP-specific T cell were no more recovered in the thymus or the spleen of tolerized mice. The same accounted for thymic and splenic T cells proliferating in response to Sp6. They were expanded in control mice after antigenic stimulation, but were undetectable in TNBS-treated mice. Thus, T cells with specificity for an internal (Sp6) and an external (TNP) antigen, provided the latter was present during ontogeny, were detected in the thymus of control and, transiently, in the thymus of tolerized mice. But, the fate of antigen-specific thymocytes was different in prenatally untreated and TNBS-treated mice. The data are interpreted in the sense that tolerance toward non-MHC antigens may be acquired subsequently to tolerance toward self-MHC antigens and possibly after imprinting of antigen specificity.     

Specific suppression of the immune response by HGG tolerant spleen cells. I. Parameters affecting the level of suppression.

After adoptive transfer, the spleen cells from mice made tolerant to human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells. However, this suppressive activity in the spleen cells of tolerant mice is only present for a brief period after treatment with tolerogen. Spleen cells from animals injected 10 days earlier with tolerogen reduce the immune response of an equal number of normal spleen cells by 75%. Spleen cells from mice made tolerant 40 days previously are, however, no longer suppressive, even though they remain completely unresponsive. These data suggest that active suppression of antigen-reactive cells is not the mechanism responsible for maintaining tolerance to HGG, but rather is only transiently associated with the tolerant state. Further evidence in favor of the separation of the tolerant state from suppressive activity is that complete suppression of the normal spleen cell response requires either a high ratio of tolerant to immune competent cells or a delay in the antigenic challenge of the reconstituted recipients. By contrast, such manipulations are not required to demonstrate the complete unresponsiveness of the tolerant cells after adoptive transfer.     

Antigen-induced in vitro inhibition of immune responsiveness

Addition of the dinitrophenyl derivative of the copolymer of d-glutamic acid and d-lysine (DNP-d-GL) or dinitrophenyl bovine γ-globulin (DNP-BGG) to spleen cell cultures specifically inhibited their capacity to produce an anti-DNP plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to the T-independent antigen dinitrophenylated polyacrylamide beads (DNP-PAA) or to the T-dependent antigen TNP-burro erythrocytes. The degree of unresponsiveness was dependent upon the tolerogen concentration and the duration over which the tolerogen was present in the culture. Treatment with rabbit anti-mouse brain antiserum and complement did not alter the induction of unresponsiveness suggesting a state of B-cell tolerance. Culture of spleen cells for 4 days in the absence of antigen led to the appearance of nonspecific suppressor activity which was demonstrable by its effect on the response of fresh spleen cells to antigen. Preculture in the presence of the immunogen DNP-PAA induced both nonspecific and specific suppressor activities. Induction of specific suppressor activity was not prevented by the presence of the tolerogen DNP-D-GL in the culture. The suppressor activity resided in an adherent T-cell population and did not appear to require macrophages for its induction.