A comparison of SCE test in human lymphocytes and Vicia faba: a hopeful technique using plants to detect mutagens and carcinogens

A comparison of the Vicia faba SCE with the human lymphocyte SCE test was made with regard to their capacity to detect mutagens. Twelve chemical agents that can induce sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in both Vicia faba root tip cells and human lymphocytes were used. The results indicate that the plant SCE technique is a sensitive test for screening various chemical agents including food preservatives, pesticides and essences which may have mutagenic activity. A new simplified procedure was introduced for differential staining of sister chromatids in Vicia faba.     

Author index

A technique using human lymphocytes together with an Ames-type microsomal (S9) activation system for testig indirect chemical mutagens has been developed and examined. The cytotoxic drug cyclophosphamide (CP), which only displays mutagenic properties after metabolic activation, was used as a test chemical and mutagenicity assessed in terms of sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) induction. Direct exposure of lymphocytes to CP and S9 mix produced increases in the yield of SCE for CP concentrations down to 10^?6 M. Exposure times of 30, 60 and 120 min commencing at the beginning of cell culture or after 48 h gave different ranges of detection and response with later treatment being more effective for SCE induction. Variations in relative proportions of the S9 mix culture medium constituents affected the lymphocytes' tolerance of toxic factors and modifiec the mutagen's effect. CP pre-incubated with S9 mix for 1 h before adding to the lymphocyte cultures also produced increases in SCE levels but the method was complicated and did not reduce toxicity. Direct addition of CP and S9 mix to the lymphocytes without prior pre-incubation showed maximum sensitivity, minimum toxocity and was a simpler, more reliable technique.     

Induction of sister-chromatid exchanges in Vicia faba by arsenic-contaminated drinking water

Arsenic-contaminated drinking water from various towns of Comarca Lagunera, Coahuila, Mexico, was tested for its ability to induce sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) in Vicia faba. 3-h treatments were applied and the differential staining technique of Tempelaar et al. (1982) was used. Atomic absorption spectrophotometry showed that the arsenic concentration in drinking water was 0.11-0.695 ppm, well over the maximum limit of 0.05 ppm (EPA, 1984). In all cases the SCE frequencies were significantly different from the controls. Some concentrations (0.2, 0.3, 0.5 and 1.0 ppm) of sodium arsenate (V) and potassium arsenite (III) were also applied to Vicia faba and all produced significant SCE frequencies, except 0.2 ppm of sodium arsenate.     

Analyses for in vitro growth conditions,cytokinetics, and sister chromatid exchanges in lymphocytes cultured from the Sprague-Dawley rat

Summary Peripheral blood samples from Sprague-Dawley rats gave successful lymphocyte growth in GIBCO: IA, RPMI 1640, and Eagle's minimum essential medium (MEM) culture media. Various growth conditions, cytokinetics, and sister chromatic exchange (SCE) induction were studied using reconstituted GIBCO 1A only. Neither methoxyflurane anesthesia of the rats before sampling nor washing of the cells with phosphate buffered saline affected the mitotic index. Cultures treated with [³H]thymidine showed the lymphocytes entering into DNA synthesis after approximately 24 h. The time at which BUdR (5-bromo-2′ deoxyuridine) was added, i.e. 0 vs. 24 h incubation, had minimal effect on the mitotic index of cultures harvested at 48 h. However, when harvest was extended to 72 h, mitotic activity was greater in the cultures treated with BUdR at 24 h. No significant differences in mitotic index and the number of average lymphocyte division were detected in cultures exposed to 0.3 to 0.5 μg/ml BUdR at 24 h and harvested at 72 h. Although SCE frequencies increased in the presence of BUdR, the baseline level of SCEs was estimated to be 5 to 6/cell. Average generation time of the lymphocytes dividing between 48 and 72 h was 16.5 h. Because of its simplicity of culture and the reproducible nature of its in vitro growth kinetics, the Sprague-Dawley rat lymphocyte is a suitable model for cytogenetic investigations.     

Induction of SCEs and DNA fragmentation in bovine peripheral lymphocytes by in vitro exposure to tolylfluanid-based fungicide

The potential for genotoxic and cytotoxic effects of tolylfluanid-based fungicide (50% active agent) was evaluated using sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and proliferation indices (PI) in cultured bovine peripheral lymphocytes. For the detection of possible genetic damage, DNA fragmentation assay was also applied. Bovine lymphocytes cultured for 72 h were treated with the fungicide at the final concentrations of 1.75, 3.5, 8.75, and 17.5 μg/mL for the last 24 and 48 h of culture without S9 metabolic activation, and during the last 2 h of culture with S9 metabolic activation. In the SCE assays no evidence for genotoxic activity of the fungicide was found in treatments of 24 h without and 2 h with S9. After the 24 h exposure to tolylfluanid, a weak decrease in the PI was observed. With the prolonged exposure time (48 h), dose dependence in the increase of SCE frequencies was observed. Moreover, after 48 h exposure slight fragmentation of DNA at the concentrations of 3.5 and 8.75 μg/mL was demonstrated. SCE quantification is the most widely used approach for the assessment of genotoxic/cytogenetic effects of chemical compounds. Positive results in the assay at 48 h exposure indicated a potential of the fungicide to increase frequency of chromosomal damage (replication injuries) that is the confirmation of early effect of exposure.     

Are SCE frequencies indicative of adaptive response of plant cells?

Low-dose pretreatments with maleic hydrazide, mitomycin C, and N-methyl-N-nitrosourea or sublethal heat shock were tested with regard to their effect on sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) induction by high doses of the same mutagens administered 2 h later to root-tip meristems of Vicia faba. Consecutive treatments resulted in either additive or, in a minority of experiments, in below-additive SCE frequencies. A model is proposed to explain the conflicting data reported on adaptation to SCE and aberration induction.     

Studies on the utilization of a plant SCE test in detecting potential mutagenic agents

In this paper a modified procedure for sister-chromatid differentiation in plant cells is reported. Using this procedure some chemicals were tested for SCE induction in Vicia faba, Hordeum vulgare and Secale cereale. The chemicals tested were ethanol, chromium oxide, sodium saccharin, fluorouracil, ascorbic acid (vitamin c), omethoate and phenol. The experimental results showed that most of them induced SCE increases in mouse spleen cells, human lymphocytes and plant cells. The increase of SCEs per cell in plant cells is in agreement with that found in human lymphocytes or in mouse spleen cells. In our opinion, the utilization of SCE in plants is a simple and inexpensive technique for detecting potential mutagenic agents in the environment.     

乙酸铜对蚕豆根尖细胞致畸效应

采用蚕豆根尖细胞的微核试验和染色体畸变试验方法,以不同浓度的乙酸铜为诱变剂,选择不同的处理时间,测定蚕豆根尖细胞的有丝分裂指数、微核率和染色体畸变率。结果表明：乙酸铜能诱发较高频率的微核率,处理6h、12h时微核率均随着乙酸铜浓度的升高而增加,具有明显的剂量效应;处理24h时在实验浓度范围内,其微核率随乙酸铜浓度的升高而增加,但高于一定浓度后反而呈下降趋势。不同浓度的乙酸铜在不同处理时间均使蚕豆根尖细胞有丝分裂指数增大。乙酸铜还能诱导蚕豆根尖细胞产生较高频率的染色体畸变,且产生多种类型的染色体畸变。因此,乙酸铜对蚕豆根尖细胞具有明显的致畸效应。     

Erythrocytes modulate the baseline frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges and the kinetics of lymphocyte division in culture

The baseline sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies of human plasma lymphocyte cultures (PLC), but not pig PLC, were nearly twice as high as those of whole-blood cultures (WBC). Addition of human red blood cells (RBCs) to human PLC decreased the SCE frequency in proportion to the RBC-leukocyte co-incubation interval. When the period of RBC-leukocyte co-incubation was equivalent to the total length of the culture period (72 h), the SCE frequency was similar to that observed in WBC. Shorter co-incubation periods yielded SCE frequencies intermediate between those of PLC and WBC. Regardless of the species, cell proliferation was slower in PLC than in WBC. Experiments where RBCs were added to PLC showed that the time sequence of RBC incorporation also affects the cell-cycle progression of human and pig lymphocytes. When either human or pig RBCs were added immediately after PLC stimulation, the cell-cycle kinetics was similar to that of WBC. Shorter co-incubation periods made cell-cycle progression intermediate between PLC and WBC values. Thus, PBCs modulate the baseline frequency of SCEs in human PLC and the cell-cycle progression of both human and pig lymphocytes in a time-dependent manner. Two possible hypotheses for the heightened frequency of SCEs of human lymphocytes in RBC-free cultures were assessed. The loss of RBC-to-lymphocyte cellular contact in PLC did not influence the SCE frequencies of lymphocytes. Finally, the increase of SCEs in human PLC could not be related to differences in the generation time of lymphocytes in culture.     

Sister-chromatid exchange in highly purified human CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes.

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies were determined in human peripheral blood CD₄⁺ and CD₈⁺ T lymphocyte subpopulations which were rapidly and highly purified from pooled T lymphocytes by immunological methods. The purified lymphocytes were stimulated with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) for 4 days. CD₄⁺ lymphocytes showed significantly higher SCE frequencies than autologous CD₈⁺ lymphocytes when measured simultaneously after identical bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) incubation times. Differences in SCE frequencies between CD₄⁺ and CD₈⁺ lymphocytes were also detected when mitomycin C (MMC) was added to the cultures. Higher SCE frequencies in CD₄⁺ lymphocytes were associated with lower proliferating rate indices (PRI) as compared to autologous CD₈⁺ lymphocytes. Abnormalities in CD₄⁺ T lymphocyte function and number in peripheral blood have been observed in several diseases characterized by immunological disorders. Thus, our data may suggest a link between some immunological disturbances and abnormal SCE frequencies in T lymphocyte subsets.     

Differences in the induction of SCEs between human whole blood cultures and purified lymphocyte cultures and the effect of an S9 mix

Studies for SCE induction are frequently performed on human blood cultures. Either whole blood cultures (WBC) or purified lymphocyte cultures (PLC) are employed. However, it has been shown that fundamental differences with respect to metabolic activity exist between these two systems. In order to further characterize the whole blood culture and the purified lymphocyte culture, differently acting substances were studied comparatively with and without an Aroclor-1254-induced S9 mix. Treatment with ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), a direct mutagen, produced distinct SCE induction in both systems. Cyclophosphamide (CP) and benzo[a]pyrene (BP), two indirect mutagens, also led to a significant increase of SCEs both in WBC and PLC without S9 mix. Only with CP was this effect more pronounced after addition of S9 mix. Sodium selenite (Na2SeO3), which induced SCEs in WBC, did not show this effect in the PLC. After S9 mix was added to purified lymphocytes, an increase of SCEs by sodium selenite was observed as in WBC. H2O2, a radical former, led to SCE induction in purified lymphocytes but not in the whole blood culture. By adding S9 mix, a distinct reduction of the SCEs induced by H2O2 was established. These results show that human lymphocytes can metabolize indirect mutagens and that it should be kept in mind when using S9 mix that, besides mixed-function oxygenases, it also contains enzymes which influence the SCE-inducing effects of substances.     

The effects of post-treatments with caffeine during S and G2 on the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations induced by thiotepa in root tips of Vicia faba and in human lymphocytes in vitro

The effects of post-treatments with caffeine on the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations induced by the trifunctional alkylating agent thiotepa were studied in human lymphocytes and in root tips of Vicia faba. In lymphocytes the frequency of aberrations induced in G0 or G1 was most strongly increased when the caffeine post-treatments were given during G2. In Vicia faba, on the other hand, the frequency of aberrations induced in early interphase was unaffected by post-treatments with caffeine during G2, but strongly increased when the root tips were exposed to caffeine during the S phase.     

Implications of an elevated sister-chromatid exchange frequency in rat lymphocytes cultured in the absence of erythrocytes

One important variable in complex culture systems such as whole blood is the interaction of the cell types present. To investigate the effects of erythrocytes (RBCs) and monocytes on the sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency, Ficoll-Hypaque-separated Fischer-344 rat leukocytes were added to 1.9 ml of culture medium containing either 4 micrograms phytohemagglutinin or 4-8 micrograms concanavalin A/ml. Bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU;2 microM) was added at 24 h, and the cultures were harvested at 54 or 72 h. SCE frequencies in the mononuclear leukocyte cultures were consistently about 1.5- to 2-fold higher than in the whole-blood cultures. The titration of rat or human RBCs (0.05-2.5 X 10(9)) into purified rat leukocyte cultures reduced the SCE frequency to that of whole-blood cultures. Monocyte depletion decreased the elevated SCE frequency by approximately 50%. Scintillation counting of [14C]BrdU uptake in isolated RBCs revealed that less than 8% of the total amount of BrdU was sequestered. Also, BrdU induced a concentration-dependent increase in SCE in purified leukocytes, but the absolute increase was no greater than in whole-blood lymphocytes. Thus, BrdU had a minor role in the elevated SCE frequency in purified lymphocytes. Neither anti-oxidant enzymes such as catalase and superoxide dismutase nor the hydroxyl radical scavenger, dimethyl sulfoxide, decreased the SCE frequency. Although purified human lymphocytes had a small, but significant increase in SCE compared to whole blood, the magnitude of the dichotomous response between man and rat may represent a fundamental species difference.     

Cytogenetic effect of the thiocarbamate herbicides butylate, molinate and vernolate in the mouse bone marrow micronucleus test

Three thiocarbamate herbicides, butylate (S-ethyl-diisobutylthiocarbamate), vernolate (S-propyl dipropylthiocarbamate) and molinate (S-ethyl-N,N-hexamethylenethiocarbamate) were assayed for cytogenetic effect in the mouse bone marrow micronucleus test. Butylate was inactive in bone marrow, vernolate caused a marginal increase in the incidence of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes only at a high toxic dose level. Molinate, the N,N-hexamethylene derivative was, however, strongly active in the bone marrow, causing a high frequency of micronucleated erythrocytes, even at subtoxic concentrations.     

氯苯胁迫对蚕豆幼苗生长和细胞分裂的影响

研究了1,2,4-三氯苯(TCB)对蚕豆幼苗生长、根尖细胞分裂及染色体畸变的影响．结果表明,随TCB浓度增加和处理时间延长,蚕豆幼苗根长的生长及根尖细胞有丝分裂指数降低甚至停止．TCB诱发蚕豆根尖细胞有丝分裂过程中染色体数目畸变和结构畸变．50-100μg.g^-1TCB胁迫12-24h,蚕豆根尖染色体的主要损伤形式为c-有丝分裂、染色体桥和不均匀排列,其出现百分率达1．0％--10.3％．300μg.g^-1TCB胁迫12-96h,蚕豆根尖细胞中染色体粘连(S)、S+染色体断裂(S+B)、S+染色体环(S+R)、S+染色体不均匀排列(S+A)及S+染色体桥(S+Be)出现的百分率达47．9％--88.9％,各种类型染色体断裂出现的百分率仅为18．1％--29．6％,说明蚕豆根尖细胞染色体畸变分析可作为TCB土壤污染监测的敏感生物监测指标．     

Sister-chromatid exchange in highly purified human CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies were determined in human peripheral blood CD₄⁺ and CD₈⁺ T lymphocyte subpopulations which were rapidly and highly purified from pooled T lymphocytes by immunological methods. The purified lymphocytes were stimulated with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) for 4 days. CD₄⁺ lymphocytes showed significantly higher SCE frequencies than autologous CD₈⁺ lymphocytes when measured simultaneously after identical bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) incubation times. Differences in SCE frequencies between CD₄⁺ and CD₈⁺ lymphocytes were also detected when mitomycin C (MMC) was added to the cultures. Higher SCE frequencies in CD₄⁺ lymphocytes were associated with lower proliferating rate indices (PRI) as compared to autologous CD₈⁺ lymphocytes. Abnormalities in CD₄⁺ T lymphocyte function and number in peripheral blood have been observed in several diseases characterized by immunological disorders. Thus, our data may suggest a link between some immunological disturbances and abnormal SCE frequencies in T lymphocyte subsets.     

Analysis of chromosome aberrations and sister-chromatid exchanges in human lymphocytes exposed in vitro to Hydergine.

Hydergine (dihydroergotoxine mesylate, Sandoz) was examined for its capability to induce chromosome damage and sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in human lymphocyte in vitro. For the chromosome-aberration study, cultures set up from 6 individuals were divided into 5 groups: negative control, positive control (caffeine, 0.5 mg/ml), and Hydergine (0.1, 0.25 and 0.5 micrograms/ml). For the SCE examination, which used 8 individuals, 4 cultures were made per person in the following way: negative control, positive control (mitomycin C, 0.1 microgram/ml), and Hydergine (0.1 and 0.5 micrograms/ml). Lymphocytes were cultivated for 72 h, being exposed to the respective treatments during the final 24 h. The results showed that Hydergine induced no chromosome damage in human lymphocytes in vitro.     

Promutagen activation by Vicia faba: an assay based on the induction of sister-chromatid exchanges in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Plant activation of promutagens was studied using Vicia faba S10 (in vitro activation) and the extracts prepared from promutagen-treated roots of Vicia faba (in vivo activation). The induction of sister-chromatid exchanges in Chinese hamster ovary cells was used as an endpoint to evaluate the cytogenetic effects of promutagens activated by Vicia faba. Cyclophosphamide and ethyl alcohol were activated both by Vicia S10 and by the Vicia extracts, and their activation resulted in an increase in SCEs. Benzo[a]pyrene, 2-aminofluorene, and maleic hydrazide were not activated. Aniline was activated, but without effect on the induction of SCEs. The activation capacity in vitro and in vivo of Vicia faba was not very pronounced, except for the activation of ethyl alcohol, when compared with that of rat-liver S9, and showed differences in activation for the 6 chemical agents tested.     

Increased frequency of sister-chromatid exchange and chromatid breaks in lymphocytes after treatment of human volunteers with therapeutic doses of paracetamol

Paracetamol was given to 10 healthy human volunteers in 3 doses of 1 g each during a period of 8 h. Blood samples for lymphocyte cultures were taken before and 24 h after paracetamol administration. A small but significant increase was found in the frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) after intake of paracetamol (0.187 +/- 0.030 per chromosome before and 0.208 +/- 0.024 per chromosome after). After exposure the mean frequency of chromatid breaks per 100 cells was significantly increased (2.16 +/- 1.33 versus 0.33 +/- 0.50 before exposure). Exposure of human lymphocytes in vitro showed that concentrations of paracetamol above 0.1 mM induced inhibition of replicative DNA synthesis. Increased SCE was found in lymphocytes exposed to 1-10 mM paracetamol for 2 h. Furthermore, 0.75-1.5 mM paracetamol exposure for 24 h increased the frequency of chromatid and chromosome breaks in the lymphocytes. The paracetamol-induced SCE and chromosome aberrations may be secondary effects of paracetamol-induced inhibition of DNA synthesis or due to covalent binding of paracetamol metabolite(s) to DNA.     

Susceptibility to genotoxic effects of niclosamide in human peripheral lymphocytes exposed in vitro and in vivo

Niclosamide added in 2-h pulses to lymphocyte cultures induced a small clastogenic effect in one blood donor, while in two other blood donors it inhibited mitosis. In the presence of the 'S9' metabolic activation system, the antihelminthic drug exhibited a dose-related increase in clastogenicity in 2 of 4 blood samples. A weak dose-related increase in S.C.E. was observed only in the lymphocytes from one of these blood samples. From 5 patients treated with niclosamide, 3 showed an increase in chromosomal aberrations after treatment; in none of them was an induction of S.C.E. observed. These results suggest differences in lymphocyte susceptibility to the genotoxic effects of therapeutic drugs and also underline the need for evaluating chromosomal aberrations as well as SCE in any study of genotoxic substances.