Detection of localized caspase activity in early apoptotic cells by laser scanning cytometry

BACKGROUND: Caspase activation is a critical early step in the onset of apoptosis. Cell-permeable fluorogenic caspase substrates have proven valuable in detecting caspase activation by flow cytometry. Nevertheless, detection of early low-level caspase activation has been difficult using conventional area or peak fluorescence analysis by flow cytometry, despite the apparent presence of these cells as observed by microscopy. We describe a method utilizing maximum fluorescence pixel analysis by laser scanning cytometry (LSC) to detect early apoptotic cells. METHODS: The PhiPhiLux-G(1)D(2) caspase 3/7 substrate was used in combination with DNA dye exclusion and annexin V binding to identify several stages of apoptosis in EL4 murine thymoma cells by both traditional flow and LSC. LSC analysis of maximum pixel brightness in individual cells demonstrated an intermediate caspase-low subpopulation not detectable by flow or LSC integral analysis. LSC analysis of caspase activity was then carried out using the larger UMR-106 rat osteosarcoma cell line to determine if this apparent early caspase activity could be correlated with localized, punctate caspase activity observed by microscopy. RESULTS: The caspase-low subpopulation found in apoptotic EL4 cells was also observable in UMR-106 cells. Relocation to cells with low fluorescence due to caspase activity and subsequent examination by microscopy demonstrated that these latter cells indeed show punctate, highly localized caspase activation foci that might represent an early stage in caspase activation. CONCLUSIONS: Cells with low-level, localized caspase expression can be detected using maximum pixel analysis by LSC. This methodology allows an early step of apoptotic activation to be resolved for further analysis.     

Caspase activity is not sufficient to execute cell death

Molecular studies of the physiological cell death process have focused attention on the role of effector caspases as critical common elements of the lethal mechanism. Diverse death signals act afferently via distinct signaling pathways to activate these resident proenzyme molecules post-translationally. Whether this molecular convergence represents the mechanistic point of irreversible commitment to cell death has not been established. That a number of caspase substrates are proteins that serve important roles in cellular homeostasis has led to the view that the acquisition of this activity must be the determinative step in cell death. Observations that caspases serve in a regulatory role to catalyze the appearance of new activities involved in orderly cellular dissolution challenge this model of death as a simple process of proteolytic destruction. We found previously that caspase-dependent nuclear cyclin dependent kinase 2 (Cdk2) activity appears to be necessary for cell death. Employing direct cytofluorimetric analyses of intracellular caspase activity and colony forming assays, we now show that transient blockade of caspase-dependent Cdk2 activity confers long-lived sparing from death on cells otherwise triggered to die and fully replete with caspase activity. These data demonstrate that caspases, while necessary for apoptosis, are not sufficient to exert lethality. Caspase activation per se does not represent an irreversible point of commitment to physiological cell death.     

M1 muscarinic receptors block caspase activation by phosphoinositide 3-kinase- and MAPK/ERK-independent pathways

When PC12 cells are deprived of trophic support they undergo apoptosis. We have previously shown that survival of trophic factor-deprived PC12M1 cells can be promoted by activation of the G protein-coupled muscarinic receptors. The mechanism whereby muscarinic receptors inhibit apoptosis is poorly understood. In the present study we investigated this mechanism by examining the effect of muscarinic receptor activation on the serum deprivation-induced activity of key players in apoptosis, the caspases, in PC12M1 cells. The results showed that m1 muscarinic activation inhibits caspase activity induced by serum deprivation. This effect appeared to be caused by the prevention of activation of caspases such as caspase-2 and caspase-3, and not by the inhibition of existing activity. Muscarinic receptor activation also stimulated the mitogen-activated protein kinase/extracellular signaling-regulated kinase (MAPK/ERK) and phosphoinositide (PI) 3-kinase signaling pathways. The PI 3-kinase pathway inhibitors wortmannin and LY294002, as well as the MAPK/ERK pathway PD98059 inhibitor, did not however suppress the inhibitory effect of the muscarinic receptors on caspase activity. The results therefore suggested that the muscarinic survival effect is mediated by a pathway that leads to caspase inhibition by MAPK/ERK- and PI 3-kinase-independent signaling cascades.     

Partial cleavage of RasGAP by caspases is required for cell survival in mild stress conditions

Tight control of apoptosis is required for proper development and maintenance of homeostasis in multicellular organisms. Cells can protect themselves from potentially lethal stimuli by expressing antiapoptotic factors, such as inhibitors of apoptosis, FLICE (caspase 8)-inhibitory proteins, and members of the Bcl2 family. Here, we describe a mechanism that allows cells to survive once executioner caspases have been activated. This mechanism relies on the partial cleavage of RasGAP by caspase 3 into an amino-terminal fragment called fragment N. Generation of this fragment leads to the activation of the antiapoptotic Akt kinase, preventing further amplification of caspase activity. Partial cleavage of RasGAP is required for cell survival under stress conditions because cells expressing an uncleavable RasGAP mutant cannot activate Akt, cannot prevent amplification of caspase 3 activity, and eventually undergo apoptosis. Executioner caspases therefore control the extent of their own activation by a feedback regulatory mechanism initiated by the partial cleavage of RasGAP that is crucial for cell survival under adverse conditions.     

Caspase-6 is the direct activator of caspase-8 in the cytochrome c-induced apoptosis pathway: absolute requirement for removal of caspase-6 prodomain

Caspase activation resulting from cytochrome c release from the mitochondria is an essential component of the mechanism of apoptosis initiated by a range of factors. The activation of Bid by caspase-8 in this pathway promotes further cytochrome c release, thereby completing a positive feedback loop of caspase activation. Although the identity of the caspases necessary for caspase-8 activation in this pathway are known, it is still unclear which protease directly cleaves caspase-8. In order to identify the factor responsible we undertook a biochemical purification of caspase-8 cleaving activity in cytosolic extracts to which cytochrome c had been added. Here we report that caspase-6 is the only soluble protease in cytochrome c activated Jurkat cell extracts that has significant caspase-8 cleaving activity. Furthermore the caspase-6 that we purified was sufficient to induce Bid dependent cytochrome c releasing activity in cell extracts. Inhibition of caspase-6 activity in cells significantly inhibited caspase-8 cleavage and apoptosis, therefore establishing caspase-6 as a major activator of caspase-8 in vivo and confirming that this pathway can have a critical role in promotion of apoptosis. We also show that caspase-6 is inactive until the short prodomain is removed. We suggest that the requirement for two distinct cleavage steps to activate an effector caspase may represent an effective mechanism for restriction of spontaneous caspase activation and aberrant entry into apoptosis.     

Unique sequence of a high molecular weight myosin light chain kinase is involved in interaction with actin cytoskeleton

Resolution of neutrophil mediated inflammation is achieved, in part, through induction of neutrophil apoptosis. This constitutively expressed programme can be delayed by inflammatory mediators and induced by ligation of the Fas receptor. However, functional activation of the neutrophil results in resistance to Fas signalled death. We evaluated the effects of Fas antibody engagement on caspase activation and mitochondrial permeability, and the impact of co-stimulation by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) on these events. Fas engagement by an agonistic anti-Fas antibody resulted in enhanced caspase 3 and 8 activity and increased mitochondrial permeability. Studies with pharmacological inhibitors of caspase activity showed that activation of caspase 8 occurred before, and activation of caspase 3 occurred after mitochondrial disruption. The mitochondrial stabilising agent bongkrekic acid also inhibited caspase activation and apoptosis. LPS, GM-CSF and increased glutathione stabilised the mitochondria and inhibited caspase 3. Caspase 8 activity was also inhibited by co-stimulation through a mechanism independent of mitochondrial stabilisation. Glutathione directly inhibited caspase 3 and 8 activity. We conclude inhibition of Fas antibody induced apoptosis by inflammatory proteins is associated with augmented mitochondrial stability and reduced caspase 3 activity that may be glutathione mediated.     

FLIP(L) induces caspase 8 activity in the absence of interdomain caspase 8 cleavage and alters substrate specificity

Caspase 8 is an initiator caspase that is activated by death receptors to initiate the extrinsic pathway of apoptosis. Caspase 8 activation involves dimerization and subsequent interdomain autoprocessing of caspase 8 zymogens, and recently published work has established that elimination of the autoprocessing site of caspase 8 abrogates its pro-apoptotic function while leaving its proliferative function intact. The observation that the developmental abnormalities of caspase 8-deficient mice are shared by mice lacking the dimerization adapter FADD (Fas-associated death domain) or the caspase paralogue FLIP(L) [FLICE (FADD-like interleukin 1β-converting enzyme)-inhibitory protein, long form] has led to the hypothesis that FADD-dependent formation of heterodimers between caspase 8 and FLIP(L) could mediate the developmental role of caspase 8. In the present study, using an inducible dimerization system we demonstrate that cleavage of the catalytic domain of caspase 8 is crucial for its activity in the context of activation by homodimerization. However, we find that use of FLIP(L) as a partner for caspase 8 in dimerization-induced activation rescues the requirement for intersubunit linker proteolysis in both protomers. Moreover, before processing, caspase 8 in complex with FLIP(L) does not generate a fully active enzyme, but an attenuated species able to process only selected natural substrates. Based on these results we propose a mechanism of caspase 8 activation by dimerization in the presence of FLIP(L), as well as a mechanism of caspase 8 functional divergence in apoptotic and non-apoptotic pathways.     

Quantitative analysis of fluorescent caspase substrate cleavage in intact cells and identification of novel inhibitors of apoptosis

Caspase activation and proteolytic cleavage of specific target proteins represents an integral step in the pathway leading to the apoptotic death of cells. Analysis of caspase activity in intact cells, however, has been generally limited to the measurement of end-point biochemical and morphological markers of apoptosis. In an effort to develop a strategy with which to monitor caspase activity, early in the cell death cascade and in real-time, we have generated cell lines that overexpress recombinant GFP-based caspase substrates that display a quantifiable change in their spectral properties when cleaved by group II caspases. Specifically, tandem GFP substrates linked by a caspase-sensitive cleavage site show diminished fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), as a consequence of cleavage, due to physical separation of the GFP moieties in apoptotic cells. We have evaluated the influence of different caspase-sensitive linkers on both FRET efficiency and cleavage by caspase-3. We also demonstrate that caspase activity as well as inhibition by pharmacological agents can be monitored, with minimal manipulation, in intact adherent cells seeded in a 96-well cell culture dish. Finally, we have adapted this technology to a high throughput screening platform to identify novel small molecule and cell permeable inhibitors of apoptosis. Based on a biochemical analysis of the compounds identified it is clear that this assay can be used to detect drugs which inhibit caspases directly as well as those which target upstream components of the caspase cascade.     

Rapid nucleolytic degradation of the small cytoplasmic Y RNAs during apoptosis.

We have investigated the fate of the RNA components of small ribonucleoprotein particles in apoptotic cells. We show that the cytoplasmic Ro ribonucleoprotein-associated Y RNAs are specifically and rapidly degraded during apoptosis via a caspase-dependent mechanism. This is the first study describing the selective degradation of a specific class of small structural RNA molecules in apoptotic cells. Cleavage and subsequent truncation of Y RNAs was observed upon exposure of cells to a variety of apoptotic stimuli and were found to be inhibited by Bcl-2, zinc, and several caspase inhibitors. These results indicate that apoptotic degradation of Y RNAs is dependent on caspase activation, which suggests that the nucleolytic activity responsible for hY RNA degradation is activated downstream of the caspase cascade. The Y RNA degradation products remain bound by the Ro60 protein and in part also by the La protein, the only two proteins known to be stably associated with intact Ro ribonucleoprotein particles. The size of the Y RNA degradation products is consistent with the protection from degradation of the most highly conserved region of the Y RNAs by the bound Ro60 and La proteins. Our results indicate that the rapid abrogation of the yet unknown function of Y RNAs might be an early step in the systemic deactivation of the dying cell.     

Baculovirus inhibitor of apoptosis functions at or upstream of the apoptotic suppressor P35 to prevent programmed cell death.

Members of the inhibitor of apoptosis (iap) gene family prevent programmed cell death induced by multiple signals in diverse organisms, suggesting that they act at a conserved step in the apoptotic pathway. To investigate the molecular mechanism of iap function, we expressed epitope-tagged Op-iap, the prototype viral iap from Orgyia pseudotsugata nuclear polyhedrosis virus, by using novel baculovirus recombinants and stably transfected insect cell lines. Epitope-tagged Op-iap blocked both virus- and UV radiation-induced apoptosis. With or without apoptotic stimuli, Op-IAP protein (31 kDa) cofractionated with cellular membranes and the cytosol, suggesting a cytoplasmic site of action. To identify the step(s) at which Op-iap blocks apoptosis, we monitored the effect of Op-iap expression on in vivo activation of the insect CED-3/ICE death proteases (caspases). Op-iap prevented in vivo caspase-mediated cleavage of the baculovirus substrate inhibitor P35 and blocked caspase activity upon viral infection or UV irradiation. However, unlike the stoichiometric inhibitor P35, Op-IAP failed to affect activated caspase as determined by in vitro protease assays. These findings provide the first biochemical evidence that Op-iap blocks activation of the host caspase or inhibits its activity by a mechanism distinct from P35. Moreover, as suggested by the capacity of Op-iap to block apoptosis induced by diverse signals, including virus infection and UV radiation, iap functions at a central point at or upstream from steps involving the death proteases.     

The Drosophila DIAP1 protein is required to prevent accumulation of a continuously generated,processed form of the apical caspase DRONC

Although loss of the inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) protein DIAP1 has been shown to result in caspase activation and spontaneous cell death in Drosophila cells and embryos, the point at which DIAP1 normally functions to inhibit caspase activation is unknown. Depletion of the DIAP1 protein in Drosophila S2 cells or the Sf-IAP protein in Spodoptera frugiperda Sf21 cells by RNA interference (RNAi) or cycloheximide treatment resulted in rapid and widespread caspase-dependent apoptosis. Co-silencing of dronc or dark largely suppressed this apoptosis, indicating that DIAP1 is normally required to inhibit an activity dependent on these proteins. Silencing of dronc also inhibited DRICE processing following stimulation of apoptosis, demonstrating that DRONC functions as an apical caspase in S2 cells. Silencing of diap1 or treatment with UV light induced DRONC processing, which occurred in two steps. The first step appeared to occur continuously even in the absence of an apoptotic signal and to be dependent on DARK, because full-length DRONC accumulated when dark was silenced in non-apoptotic cells. In addition, treatment with the proteasome inhibitor MG132 resulted in accumulation of this initially processed form of DRONC, but not full-length DRONC, in non-apoptotic cells. The second step in DRONC processing was observed only in apoptotic cells. These results indicate that the initial step in DRONC processing occurs continuously via a DARK-dependent mechanism in Drosophila cells and that DIAP1 is required to prevent excess accumulation of this first form of processed DRONC, presumably through its ability to act as a ubiquitin-protein ligase.     

IAP suppression of apoptosis involves distinct mechanisms: the TAK1/JNK1 signaling cascade and caspase inhibition

The antiapoptotic properties of the inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) family of proteins have been linked to caspase inhibition. We have previously described an alternative mechanism of XIAP inhibition of apoptosis that depends on the selective activation of JNK1. Here we report that two other members of the IAP family, NAIP and ML-IAP, both activate JNK1. Expression of catalytically inactive JNK1 blocks NAIP and ML-IAP protection against ICE- and TNF-alpha-induced apoptosis, indicating that JNK1 activation is necessary for the antiapoptotic effect of these proteins. The MAP3 kinase, TAK1, appears to be an essential component of this antiapoptotic pathway since IAP-mediated activation of JNK1, as well as protection against TNF-alpha- and ICE-induced apoptosis, is inhibited when catalytically inactive TAK1 is expressed. In addition, XIAP, NAIP, and JNK1 bind to TAK1. Importantly, expression of catalytically inactive TAK1 did not affect XIAP inhibition of caspase activity. These data suggest that XIAP's antiapoptotic activity is achieved by two separate mechanisms: one requiring TAK1-dependent JNK1 activation and the second involving caspase inhibition.     

Cellular FLIP (long form) regulates CD8+ T cell activation through caspase-8-dependent NF-kappa B activation

Cellular FLIP long form (c-FLIP(L)) was originally identified as an inhibitor of Fas (CD95/Apo-1). Subsequently, additional functions of c-FLIP(L) were identified through its association with receptor-interacting protein (RIP)1 and TNFR-associated factor 2 to activate NF-kappaB, as well as by its association with and activation of caspase-8. T cells from c-FLIP(L)-transgenic (Tg) mice manifest hyperproliferation upon activation, although it was not clear which of the various functions of c-FLIP(L) was involved. We have further explored the effect of c-FLIP(L) on CD8(+) effector T cell function and its mechanism of action. c-FLIP(L)-Tg CD8(+) T cells have increased proliferation and IL-2 responsiveness to cognate Ags as well as to low-affinity Ag variants, due to increased CD25 expression. They also have a T cytotoxic 2 cytokine phenotype. c-FLIP(L)-Tg CD8(+) T cells manifest greater caspase activity and NF-kappaB activity upon activation. Both augmented proliferation and CD25 expression are blocked by caspase inhibition. c-FLIP(L) itself is a substrate of the caspase activity in effector T cells, being cleaved to a p43(FLIP) form. p43(FLIP) more efficiently recruits RIP1 than full-length c-FLIP(L) to activate NF-kappaB. c-FLIP(L) and RIP1 also coimmunoprecipitate with active caspase-8 in effector CD8(+) T cells. Thus, one mechanism by which c-FLIP(L) influences effector T cell function is through its activation of caspase-8, which in turn cleaves c-FLIP(L) to allow RIP1 recruitment and NF-kappaB activation. This provides a partial explanation of why caspase activity is required to initiate proliferation of resting T cells.     

Heat shock inhibits caspase‐1 activity while also preventing its inflammasome‐mediated activation by anthrax lethal toxin

Anthrax lethal toxin (LT) rapidly kills macrophages from certain mouse strains in a mechanism dependent on the breakdown of unknown protein(s) by the proteasome, formation of the Nalp1b (NLRP1b) inflammasome and subsequent activation of caspase‐1. We report that heat‐shocking LT‐sensitive macrophages rapidly protects them against cytolysis by inhibiting caspase‐1 activation without upstream effects on LT endocytosis or cleavage of the toxin's known cytosolic substrates (mitogen‐activated protein kinases). Heat shock protection against LT occurred through a mechanism independent of de novo protein synthesis, HSP90 activity, p38 activation or proteasome inhibition and was downstream of mitogen‐activated protein kinase cleavage and degradation of an unknown substrate by the proteasome. The heat shock inhibition of LT‐mediated caspase‐1 activation was not specific to the Nalp1b (NLRP1b) inflammasome, as heat shock also inhibited Nalp3 (NLRP3) inflammasome‐mediated caspase‐1 activation in macrophages. We found that heat shock induced pro‐caspase‐1 association with a large cellular complex that could prevent its activation. Additionally, while heat‐shocking recombinant caspase‐1 did not affect its activity in vitro, lysates from heat‐shocked cells completely inhibited recombinant active caspase‐1 activity. Our results suggest that heat shock inhibition of active caspase‐1 can occur independently of an inflammasome platform, through a titratable factor present within intact, functioning heat‐shocked cells.     

Presenilin-directed inhibitors of gamma-secretase trigger caspase 3 activation in presenilin-expressing and presenilin-deficient cells

The amyloid beta peptide (Abeta) is generated by subsequent cleavages by beta- and gamma-secretases. Therefore, these two enzymes are putative therapeutic targets to prevent Abeta production, and hopefully to slow down or even stop the Alzheimer's disease (AD) neurodegenerative process. Several studies have revealed that gamma-secretase hydrolyses other important substrates besides beta-amyloid precursor protein (betaAPP) thus adding another level of complexity to designing fully AD-specific interfering drugs. Here we demonstrate that three distinct presenilin-directed gamma-secretase inhibitors as well as JLK compounds indirectly potentiate caspase 3 activity, the effector caspase of the apoptotic cascade. Thus, inhibitors were shown to drastically stimulate caspase 3 activity in wild-type mice blastocyst-derived and fibroblast cells. Interestingly, some of these inhibitors known to interact with presenilins also trigger caspase activation in presenilin-deficient cells. However, inhibitors do not affect recombinant caspase 3 activity, indicating that the effect on this enzyme was indirect. Furthermore, we established that caspase 3 activation was not due to an effect of gamma-secretase inhibitors on calpains, a family of proteolytic enzymes able to modulate caspase 3 activity. Altogether, our data demonstrate that presenilin-directed gamma-secretase inhibitors affect caspase 3 activity in a presenilin-independent manner. Therefore, as presenilin-dependent gamma-secretase activity is not specific for betaAPP and because its inhibitors clearly affect other vital cell functions, care should be taken in considering 'gamma-secretase' inhibitors as putative therapeutic tools to interfere with AD pathology.     

Eukaryotic Translation Initiation Factor 4G Is Targeted for Proteolytic Cleavage by Caspase 3 during Inhibition of Translation in Apoptotic Cells

Although much is known about the multiple mechanisms which induce apoptosis, comparatively little is understood concerning the execution phase of apoptosis and the mechanism(s) of cell killing. Several reports have demonstrated that cellular translation is shut off during apoptosis; however, details of the mechanism of translation inhibition are lacking. Translation initiation factor 4G (eIF4G) is a crucial protein required for binding cellular mRNA to ribosomes and is known to be cleaved as the central part of the mechanism of host translation shutoff exerted by several animal viruses. Treatment of HeLa cells with the apoptosis inducers cisplatin and etoposide resulted in cleavage of eIF4G, and the extent of its cleavage correlated with the onset and extent of observed inhibition of cellular translation. The eIF4G-specific cleavage activity could be measured in cell lysates in vitro and was inhibited by the caspase inhibitor Ac-DEVD-CHO at nanomolar concentrations. A combination of in vivo and in vitro inhibitor studies suggest the involvement of one or more caspases in the activation and execution of eIF4G cleavage. Furthermore recombinant human caspase 3 was expressed in bacteria, and when incubated with HeLa cell lysates, was shown to produce the same eIF4G cleavage products as those observed in apoptotic cells. In addition, purified caspase 3 caused cleavage of purified eIF4G, demonstrating that eIF4G could serve as a substrate for caspase 3. Taken together, these data suggest that cellular translation is specifically inhibited during apoptosis by a mechanism involving cleavage of eIF4G, an event dependent on caspase activity.