Corneal Dystrophy Mutations Drive Pathogenesis by Targeting TGFBIp Stability and Solubility in a Latent Amyloid-forming Domain

Numerous mutations in the corneal protein TGFBIp lead to opaque extracellular deposits and corneal dystrophies (CDs). Here we elucidate the molecular origins underlying TGFBIp's mutation-induced increase in aggregation propensity through comprehensive biophysical and bioinformatic analyses of mutations associated with every major subtype of TGFBIp-linked CDs including lattice corneal dystrophy (LCD) and three subtypes of granular corneal dystrophy (GCD 1–3). LCD mutations at buried positions in the C-terminal Fas1–4 domain lead to decreased stability. GCD variants show biophysical profiles distinct from those of LCD mutations. GCD 1 and 3 mutations reduce solubility rather than stability. Half of the 50 positions within Fas1–4 most sensitive to mutation are associated with at least one known disease-causing mutation, including 10 of the top 11 positions. Thus, TGFBIp aggregation is driven by mutations that despite their physico-chemical diversity target either the stability or solubility of Fas1–4 in predictable ways, suggesting straightforward general therapeutic strategies.     

The stability of myocilin olfactomedin domain variants provides new insight into glaucoma as a protein misfolding disorder

Myocilin variants, localized to the olfactomedin (OLF) domain, are linked to early-onset, inherited forms of open-angle glaucoma. Disease-causing myocilin variants accumulate within trabecular meshwork cells instead of being secreted to the trabecular extracellular matrix of the eye. We hypothesize that, like in other diseases of protein misfolding, aggregation and downstream pathogenesis originate from the compromised thermal stability of mutant myocilins. In an expansion of our pilot study of four mutants, we compare 21 additional purified OLF variants by using a fluorescence stability assay and investigate the secondary structure of the most stable variants by circular dichroism. Variants with lower melting temperatures are correlated with earlier glaucoma diagnoses. The chemical chaperone trimethylamine N-oxide is capable of restoring the stability of most, but not all, variants to wild-type (WT) levels. Interestingly, three reported OLF disease variants, A427T, G246R, and A445V, exhibited properties indistinguishable from those of WT OLF, but an increased apparent aggregation propensity in vitro relative to that of WT OLF suggests that biophysical factors other than thermal stability, such as kinetics and unfolding pathways, may also be involved in myocilin glaucoma pathogenesis. Similarly, no changes from WT OLF stability and secondary structure were detected for three annotated single-nucleotide polymorphism variants. Our work provides the first quantitative demonstration of compromised stability among many identified OLF variants and places myocilin glaucoma in the context of other diseases of protein misfolding.     

The stability and aggregation of ovine prion protein associated with classical and atypical scrapie correlates with the ease of unwinding of helix-2

Susceptibility to scrapie disease in sheep, the archetypal prion disease, correlates with polymorphisms within the ovine PrP (prion-related protein) gene. The VRQ (Val136Arg154Gln171) and AL141RQ (Ala136Leu141Arg154Gln171) allelic variants are associated with classical scrapie, whereas the ARR (Ala136Arg154Arg171), AF141RQ (Ala136Phe141Arg154Gln171) and AHQ (Ala136His154Gln171) allelic variants are associated with atypical scrapie. Recent studies have suggested that there are differences in the stability of PrPSc (abnormal disease-specific conformation of PrP) associated with these different forms of scrapie. To address which structural features of ovine PrP may contribute to this difference, in the present study we have investigated the conformational stability and susceptibility to aggregation of allelic variants of ovine PrP associated with classical or atypical scrapie. We find that the melting temperature of ovine recombinant VRQ and AL141RQ PrP is higher than that of AF141RQ, AHQ and ARR. In addition, monoclonal-antibody studies show that the region around helix-1 of VRQ and AL141RQ is less accessible compared with other ovine PrP allelic variants. Furthermore, the extent of both the structural change to copper-ion-treatment and denaturant-induced aggregation was reduced in PrP associated with atypical scrapie compared with PrP associated with classical scrapie. Through the use of molecular dynamics simulations we have found that these biochemical and biophysical properties of ovine PrP correlate with the ease of unwinding of helix-2 and a concurrent conformational change of the helix-2-helix-3 loop. These results reveal significant differences in the overall stability and potential for aggregation of different allelic variants of ovine PrP and consequently have implications for the differences in stability of PrPSc associated with classical and atypical scrapie.     

Variable Mutations at the p53-R273 Oncogenic Hotspot Position Leads to Altered Properties

Mutations in p53 protein, especially in the DNA-binding domain, is one of the major hallmarks of cancer. The R273 position is a DNA-contact position and has several oncogenic variants. Surprisingly, cancer patients carrying different mutant variants of R273 in p53 have different survival rates, indicating that the DNA-contact inhibition may not be the sole reason for reduced survival with R273 variants. Here, we probed the properties of three major oncogenic variants of the wild-type (WT) p53: [R273H]p53, [R273C]p53, and [R273L]p53. Using a series of biophysical, biochemical, and theoretical simulation studies, we observe that these oncogenic variants of the p53 not only suffer a loss in DNA binding, but they also show distinct structural stability, aggregation, and toxicity profiles. The WTp53 and the [R273H]p53 show the least destabilization and aggregation propensity. [R273C]p53 aggregation is disulfide mediated, leading to cross-β, thioflavin-T-positive aggregates, whereas hydrophobic interactions dominate self-assembly in [R273L]p53, leading to a mixture of amyloid and amorphous aggregates. Molecular dynamics simulations indicate different contact maps and secondary structures for the different variants along the course of the simulations. Our study indicates that each of the R273 variants has its own distinct property of stability and self-assembly, the molecular basis of which may lead to different types of cancer pathogenesis in vivo. These studies will aid the design of therapeutic strategies for cancer using residue-specific or process-specific protein aggregation as a target.     

Concomitant Raman spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering for characterization of therapeutic proteins at high concentrations

A Raman spectrometer and dynamic light scattering system were combined in a single platform (Raman–DLS) to provide concomitant higher order structural and hydrodynamic size data for therapeutic proteins at high concentration. As model therapeutic proteins, we studied human serum albumin (HSA) and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG). HSA concentration and temperature interval during heating did not affect the onset temperatures for conformation perturbation or aggregation. The impact of pH on thermal stability of HSA was tested at pHs 3, 5, and 8. Stability was the greatest at pH 8, but distinct unfolding and aggregation behaviors were observed at the different pHs. HSA structural transitions and aggregation kinetics were also studied in real time during isothermal incubations at pH 7. In a forced oxidation study, it was found that hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) treatment reduced the thermal stability of HSA. Finally, the structure and thermal stability of IVIG were studied, and a comprehensive characterization of heating-induced structural perturbations and aggregation was obtained. In conclusion, by providing comprehensive data on protein tertiary and secondary structures and hydrodynamic size during real-time heating or isothermal incubation experiments, the Raman–DLS system offers unique physical insights into the properties of high-concentration protein samples.     

An approach to quality management in structural biology: biophysical selection of proteins for successful crystallization

Aggregation, incorrect folding and low stability are common obstacles for protein structure determination, and are often discovered at a very late state of protein production. In many cases, however, the reasons for failure to obtain diffracting crystals remain entirely unknown. We report on the contribution of systematic biophysical characterization to the success in structural determination of human proteins of unknown fold. Routine analysis using dynamic light scattering (DLS), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) was employed to evaluate fold and stability of 263 purified protein samples (98 different human proteins). We found that FTIR-monitored temperature scanning may be used to detect incorrect folding and discovered a positive correlation between unfolding enthalpy measured with DSC and the size of small, globular proteins that may be used to estimate the quality of protein preparations. Furthermore, our work establishes that the risk of aggregation during concentration of proteins may be reduced through DLS monitoring. In summary, our study demonstrates that biophysical characterization provides an ideal tool to facilitate quality management for structural biology and many other areas of biological research.     

Phosphorylation at Ser-129 but not the phosphomimics S129E/D inhibits the fibrillation of alpha-synuclein

alpha-Synuclein (alpha-syn) phosphorylation at serine 129 is characteristic of Parkinson disease (PD) and related alpha-synulceinopathies. However, whether phosphorylation promotes or inhibits alpha-syn aggregation and neurotoxicity in vivo remains unknown. This understanding is critical for elucidating the role of alpha-syn in the pathogenesis of PD and for development of therapeutic strategies for PD. To better understand the structural and molecular consequences of Ser-129 phosphorylation, we compared the biochemical, structural, and membrane binding properties of wild type alpha-syn to those of the phosphorylation mimics (S129E, S129D) as well as of in vitro phosphorylated alpha-syn using a battery of biophysical techniques. Our results demonstrate that phosphorylation at Ser-129 increases the conformational flexibility of alpha-syn and inhibits its fibrillogenesis in vitro but does not perturb its membrane-bound conformation. In addition, we show that the phosphorylation mimics (S129E/D) do not reproduce the effect of phosphorylation on the structural and aggregation properties of alpha-syn in vitro. Our findings have significant implications for current strategies to elucidate the role of phosphorylation in modulating protein structure and function in health and disease and provide novel insight into the underlying mechanisms that govern alpha-syn aggregation and toxicity in PD and related alpha-synulceinopathies.     

Analysis of the Native Structure,Stability and Aggregation of Biotinylated Human Lysozyme

Fibril formation by mutational variants of human lysozyme is associated with a fatal form of hereditary non-neuropathic systemic amyloidosis. Defining the mechanistic details of lysozyme aggregation is of crucial importance for understanding the origin and progression of this disease and related misfolding conditions. In this study, we show that a biotin moiety can be introduced site-specifically at Lys33 of human lysozyme. We demonstrate, using biophysical techniques, that the structure and stability of the native-state of the protein are not detectably altered by this modification, and that the ability to form amyloid fibrils is unchanged. By taking advantage of biotin-avidin interactions, we show that super-resolution fluorescence microscopy can generate detailed images of the mature fibrils. This methodology can readily enable the introduction of additional probes into the protein, thereby providing the means through which to understand, in detail, the nature of the aggregation process of lysozyme and its variants under a variety of conditions.     

Evolutionary protein stabilization in comparison with computational design

Two major strategies are currently used for stabilizing proteins: in vitro evolution and computational design. Here, we used gene libraries of the beta1 domain of the streptococcal protein G (Gbeta1) and Proside, an in vitro selection method, to identify stabilized variants of this protein. In the Gbeta1 libraries, the codons for the four boundary positions 16, 18, 25, and 29 were randomized. Many Gbeta1 variants with strongly increased thermal stabilities were found in 11 selections performed with five independent libraries. Previously, Mayo and co-workers used computational design to stabilize Gbeta1 by sequence optimization at the same positions. Their best variant ranked third within the panel of the selected variants. None of the ten computed sequences was found in the Proside selections, because several computed residues for positions 18 and 29 were not optimal for stability.     

Investigating the effects of mutations on protein aggregation in the cell

The conversion of peptides and proteins into highly ordered and intractable aggregates is associated with a range of debilitating human diseases and represents a widespread problem in biotechnology. Protein engineering studies carried out in vitro have shown that mutations promote aggregation when they either destabilize the native state of a globular protein or accelerate the conversion of unfolded or partially folded conformations into oligomeric structures. We have extended such studies to investigate protein aggregation in vivo where a number of additional factors able to modify dramatically the aggregation behavior of proteins are present. We have expressed, in Escherichia coli cells, an E. coli protein domain, HypF-N. The results for a range of mutational variants indicate that although mutants with a conformational stability similar to that of the wild-type protein are soluble in the E. coli cytosol, variants with single point mutations predicted to destabilize the protein invariably aggregate after expression. We show, however, that aggregation of destabilized variants can be prevented by incorporating multiple mutations designed to reduce the intrinsic propensity of the polypeptide chain to aggregate; in the cases discussed here, this is achieved by an increase in the net charge of the protein. These results suggest that the principles being established to rationalize aggregation behavior in vitro have general validity for situations in vivo where aggregation has both biotechnological and medical relevance.     

Interrelationships of glycosylation and aggregation kinetics for Peniophora lycii phytase

The kinetics of thermally induced aggregation of the glycoprotein Peniophora lycii phytase (Phy) and a deglycosylated form (dgPhy) was studied by dynamic (DLS) and static (SLS) light scattering. This provided a detailed insight into the time course of the formation of small aggregates ( approximately 10-100 molecules) of the enzyme. The thermodynamic stability of the two forms was also investigated using scanning calorimetry (DSC). It was found that the glycans strongly promoted kinetic stability (i.e., reduced the rate of irreversible denaturation) while leaving the equilibrium denaturation temperature, T(d), defined by DSC, largely unaltered. At pH 4.5-5.0, for example, dgPhy aggregated approximately 200 times faster than Phy, even though the difference in T(d) was only 1-3 degrees C. To elucidate the mechanism by which the glycans promote kinetic stability, we measured the effect of ionic strength and temperature on the aggregation rate. Also, the second virial coefficients (B(22)) for the two forms were measured by SLS. These results showed that the aggregation rate of Phy scaled with the concentration of thermally denatured protein. This suggested first-order kinetics with respect to the concentration of the thermally denatured state. A similar but less pronounced correlation was found for dgPhy, and it was suggested that while the aggregation process for the deglycosylated form is dominated by denatured protein, it also involves a smaller contribution from associating molecules in the native state. The measurements of B(22) revealed that dgPhy had slightly higher values than Phy. This suggests that dgPhy interacts more favorably with the buffer than Phy and hence rules out strong hydration of the glycans as the origin of their effect on the kinetic stability. On the basis of this and the effects of pH and ionic strength, we suggest that the inhibition of aggregation is more likely to depend on steric hindrance of the glycans in the aggregated form of the protein.     

Effects of arginine on kinetics of protein aggregation studied by dynamic laser light scattering and tubidimetry techniques

Prevention of undesirable protein aggregation is an extremely important strategy in protein science, medicine, and biotechnology. Arginine is one of the most widely used low molecular weight solution additives effective in suppressing aggregation, assisting refolding of aggregated proteins, and enhancing the solubility of aggregation-prone unfolded molecules in vitro. However, the mechanism of suppression of protein aggregation by arginine is not well understood. To address the mechanism, two model systems have been investigated: protection of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) and insulin from heat- and dithiothreitol-induced aggregation, respectively, in the presence of arginine. Using dynamic light scattering (DLS) technique, we have demonstrated the concentration-dependent suppression of light scattering intensity of both ADH and insulin aggregates upon addition of arginine to the incubation medium, a significant effect being revealed in the physiological concentration range of arginine (1-10 mM). DLS studies showed that arginine shifted the populations of nanoparticles with higher hydrodynamic radii to the lower ones, suggesting that the preventive effect of arginine on the protein aggregation process arises because it suppresses intermolecular interactions among aggregation-prone molecules. The results of turbidity measurements were also shown to be consistent with these findings.     

Reversible association of proteins into sub-visible amorphous aggregates using short solubility controlling peptide tags

Careful analysis of sub-visible amorphous aggregates, where proteins associate non-covalently in either native or denatured states without forming a specific quaternary structure, may shed insight into the mechanisms of protein aggregation and solubility. Here we report a biophysical and biochemical analysis of our model protein, a bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor variant (BPTI-19A), whose oligomerization were controlled by attaching solubility controlling peptide tags (SCP tags) to its C terminus, which are short peptides composed of a single type of amino acid that modulate protein solubility. The dynamic light scattering and static light scattering at 25 °C indicated that 11 out of 15 SCP tags merely affected the hydrodynamic radius and light scattering intensity of our reference variants BPTI-19A and BPTI-C2G. On the other hand, hydrophobic SCP tags composed of 5 Ile (C5I) or 5 Leu (C5L) were associated into sub-visible aggregates. Circular dichroism indicated that all tagged BPTI variants had the same secondary structure contents as the reference BPTI-19A at 25 °C, suggesting that BPTI-C5I and C5L kept their native structure upon association. Furthermore, the thermal denaturation of all of the BPTI variants was fully reversible and typical of natively folded small globular proteins, as monitored by CD at 222 nm. However, the thermal stability of BPTI-19A tagged with hydrophobic residues decreased with increasing protein concentration and tag's hydrophobicity, and BPTI-C5I and C5L were partially denatured at 37 °C. Biochemical stability assessed by limited proteolysis with pepsin correlated with the extent of the variants' aggregation, and the large sub-visible aggregates formed by BPTI-C5I and C5L significantly increased their resistance to pepsin proteolysis. Altogether, these observations indicated that hydrophobic SCP tags led to the reversible association of native-like proteins into sub-visible soluble amorphous aggregates resistant to pepsin digestion.     

Suppressing mutation-induced protein aggregation in mammalian cells by mutating residues significantly displaced upon the original mutation

Mutations introduced to wild-type proteins naturally, or intentionally via protein engineering, often lead to protein aggregation. In particular, protein aggregation within mammalian cells has significant implications in the disease pathology and biologics production; making protein aggregation modulation within mammalian cells a very important engineering topic. Previously, we showed that the semi-rational design approach can be used to reduce the intracellular aggregation of a protein by recovering the conformational stability that was lowered by the mutation. However, this approach has limited utility when no rational design approach to enhance conformational stability is readily available. In order to overcome this limitation, we investigated whether the modification of residues significantly displaced upon the original mutation is an effective way to reduce protein aggregation in mammalian cells. As a model system, human copper, zinc superoxide dismutase mutant containing glycine to alanine mutation at position 93 (SOD1^G93A) was used. A panel of mutations was introduced into residues substantially displaced upon the G93A mutation. By using cell-based aggregation assays, we identified several novel variants of SOD1^G93A with reduced aggregation propensity within mammalian cells. Our findings successfully demonstrate that the aggregation of a mutant protein can be suppressed by mutating the residues significantly displaced upon the original mutation.     

Separating instability from aggregation propensity in γS-crystallin variants

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, circular dichroism (CD), and dynamic light scattering (DLS) measurements were used to investigate the aggregation propensity of the eye-lens protein γS-crystallin. The wild-type protein was investigated along with the cataract-related G18V variant and the symmetry-related G106V variant. The MD simulations suggest that local sequence differences result in dramatic differences in dynamics and hydration between these two apparently similar point mutations. This finding is supported by the experimental measurements, which show that although both variants appear to be mostly folded at room temperature, both display increased aggregation propensity. Although the disease-related G18V variant is not the most strongly destabilized, it aggregates more readily than either the wild-type or the G106V variant. These results indicate that γS-crystallin provides an excellent model system for investigating the role of dynamics and hydration in aggregation by locally unfolded proteins.     

Cationic surfactant mediated fibrillogenesis in bovine liver catalase: a biophysical approach

Protein aggregation into oligomers and mature fibrils are associated with more than 20 diseases in humans. The interactions between cationic surfactants dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (DTAB) and tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide (TTAB) with varying alkyl chain lengths and bovine liver catalase (BLC) were examined by various biophysical approaches. The delicate coordination of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions with protein, play imperative role in aggregation. In this article, we have reconnoitered the relation between charge, hydrophobicity and cationic surfactants DTAB and TTAB on BLC at pH 7.4 and 9.4 which are two and four units above pI, respectively. We have used techniques like turbidity, Rayleigh light scattering, far-UV CD, ThT, ANS, Congo red binding assay, DLS, and transmission electron microscopy. The low concentration ranges of DTAB (0–600 μM) and TTAB (0–250 μM) were observed to increase aggregation at pH 9.4. Nevertheless, at pH 7.4 only TTAB was capable of inducing aggregate. DTAB did not produce any significant change in secondary structure at pH 7.4 suggestive of the role of respective charges on surfactants and protein according to the pI and alkyl chain length. The morphology of aggregates was further determined by TEM, which proved the existence of a fibrillar structure. The surfactants interaction with BLC was primarily electrostatic as examined by ITC. Our work demystifies the critical role of charge as well as hydrophobicity in amyloid formation.     

Protein aggregates as depots for the release of biologically active compounds

Protein misfolding and aggregation is one of the most serious problems in cell biology, molecular medicine, and biotechnology. Misfolded proteins interact with each other or with other proteins in non-productive or damaging ways. However, a new paradigm arises that protein aggregation may be exploited by nature to perform specific functions in different biological contexts. From this consideration, acceleration of stress-induced protein aggregation triggered by any factor resulting in the formation of soluble aggregates may have paradoxical positive consequences. Here, we suggest that amorphous aggregates can act as a source for the release of biologically active proteins after removal of stress conditions. To address this concept, we investigated the kinetics of thermal aggregation in vitro of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) as a model substrate in the presence of two amphiphilic peptides: Arg-Phe or Ala-Phe-Lys. Using dynamic light scattering (DLS) and turbidimetry, we have demonstrated that under mild stress conditions the concentration-dependent acceleration of ADH aggregation by these peptides results in formation of large but soluble complexes of proteins prone to refolding.     

Differential Thermal Stability and Oxidative Vulnerability of the Hemoglobin Variants,HbA2 and HbE

Apart from few early biophysical studies, the relative thermal instability of HbE has been only shown by clinical investigations. We have compared in vitro thermal stability of HbE with HbA₂ and HbA using optical spectroscopy. From absorption measurements in the soret region, synchronous fluorescence spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering experiments, we have found thermal stability of the three hemoglobin variants following the order HbE<HbA<HbA₂ in terms of structural unfolding and aggregation pattern. We have found formation of intermolecular dityrosine fluorophores with characteristic fluorescence signature, at pH >11.0 in all the three variants. Under oxidative stress conditions in presence of hydrogen peroxide, HbE has been found to be more vulnerable to aggregation compared to HbA and HbA₂. Taken together, these studies have shown thermal and oxidative instability of HbE and points towards the role of HbE in the upregulation of redox regulators and chaperone proteins in erythrocyte proteome of patients suffering from HbEbeta thalassemia.     

Temperature-dependent oligomerization in M-crystallin: lead or lag toward cataract, an NMR perspective

The oligomerization and/or aggregation of proteins is of critical importance in a wide variety of biomedical situations, ranging from abnormal disease states like Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease to the production of inclusion bodies, stability, and delivery of protein drugs. In the case of eye-lens proteins, oligomerization is implicated in cataract formation. In the present study, we have investigated the temperature driven oligomerization of M-crystallin, a close homologue of eye-lens proteins, using NMR spectroscopy and dynamic-light scattering (DLS). The NMR data primarily included R(1), R(2) relaxation rates and nOes of the backbone amide groups recorded at three different temperatures, 25, 20, and 15° C. The major outcome of the study is the two fold increase in the overall tumbling time (τ(c)) of M-crystallin on lowering the temperature from 25 to 15° C. An extrapolation of τ(c) to a further lower temperature (5° C) may lead to a τ(c) of ～19 ns that would correspond to a τ(c) value of a tetrameric M-crystallin. These results also validate the observed changes in the hydrodynamic radius of M-crystallin, determined using DLS data. Further, the temperature-dependent protein dynamics of M-crystallin reveal considerable variation at/near the Ca(2+)-binding sites. A concerted analysis of the temperature dependent relaxation parameters and DLS data reveals that the self-association of the protein is not only a monomer-dimer equilibrium, but also goes to tetramers or other multimeric states. These higher states may co-exist in fast exchange with the monomeric and dimeric M-crystallin at milli-molar to sub-millimolar concentrations and at lower temperature.