Unilamellar-Vesicle Systems as Model for Studying Membrane Permeabilization by Polyene Antibiotics

Abstract

Permeabilization of phospholipid/sterol unilamellar vesicles by polyene antibiotics (amphotericin B and lucensomycin) was studied by measuring proton leakage with a pH-stat method. The percentage of proton release was directly related to the antibiotic concentration. Using ergosterol-containing vesicles, a relevant proton efflux was induced by micromolar concentrations of amphotericin B, whereas lucensomycin caused membrane permeabilization at higher concentrations (0.1 mM). Cholesterol-containing vesicles were less sensible to the lytic action of polyenes. When amphotericin B was carried in cholesterol-containing liposomes, the selectivity towards ergosterol-containing vesicles was enhanced. An increase in drug selectivity was also observed by dissolving amphotericin B in fresh human plasma. At concentrations one order of magnitude lower than those necessary to induce a detectable proton efflux, lucensomycin seemed to protect the vesicles from the subsequent permeabilizing action of amphotericin B.     

A selective cholesterol-dependent induction of H+/OH- currents in phospholipid vesicles by amphotericin B

The effect of amphotericin B on the proton/hydroxide permeability of small unilamellar vesicles has been investigated by using potential-dependent paramagnetic probes. Amphotericin B at 1-10 molecules/vesicle causes a modest 4-8-fold increase in the background H+/OH- permeability of egg phosphatidylcholine (egg PC) vesicles. However, in the presence of cholesterol, amphotericin B promotes a dramatic increase in the H+/OH- permeability of more than 2 orders of magnitude. Surprisingly, this is not observed in vesicle membranes containing ergosterol. In membranes composed of 5-15 mol% ergosterol, amphotericin B is even less effective at promoting H+/OH- currents than in pure egg PC vesicles. The K+ current promoted by amphotericin B in vesicles formed from egg PC and from egg PC plus cholesterol or ergosterol was measured. No significant sterol dependence was found for the K+ current. These results strongly suggest that different mechanisms, or amphotericin B/sterol complexes, are responsible for the induction of H+/OH- and K+ currents. These results have important implications for understanding the therapeutic and toxic effects of amphotericin B.     

Interaction of the polyene antibiotics with lipid bilayer vesicles containing cholesterol.

The interaction of the polyene antibiotics, amphotericin B, nystatin and filipin with cholesterol-containing single bilayer lipid vesicles has been characterized using gel permeation chromatography and proton magnetic resonance. All three antibiotics bind to vesicles at low concentrations without causing a large amount of vesicle destruction. The strength of binding as determined by gel permeation studies is greater for filipin and amphotericin than for nystatin. Nystatin and amphotericin B at these low concentrations induce a rapid loss of internal vesicle contents consistents consistent with pore formation. Filipin induces no leakage beyond that expected from partial vesicle destruction or general detergent action. At antibiotic levels above 1:1 antibiotic: cholesterol ratios the NMR results show all three antibiotics to cause extensive vesicle destruction. The onset of this behavior, which appears to be independent of the total antibiotic concentraion, indicates a well defined antibiotic : cholesterol interaction stoichiometry. Despite the fact that cholesterol is required for antibiotic activity, the NMR spectra prior to vesicle destruction show no changes indicative of an antibiotic-induced reversal of cholesterol restriction of phosphatidylcholine mobility. The contrast with polyene antibiotic behavior in more extended bilayers is discussed.     

Interaction of the polyene antibiotics with lipid bilayer vesicles containing cholesterol

The interaction of the polyene antibiotics, amphotericin B, nystatin and filipin with cholesterol-containing single bilayer lipid vesicles has been characterized using gel permeation chromatography and proton magnetic resonance. All three antibiotics bind to vesicles at low concentrations without causing a large amount of vesicle destruction. The strength of binding as determined by gel permeation studies is greater for filipin and amphotericin than for nystatin. Nystatin and amphotericin B at these low concentrations induce a rapid loss of internal vesicle contents consistent with pore formation. Filipin induces no leakage beyond that expected from partial vesicle destruction or general detergent action.At antibiotic levels above 1 : 1 antibiotic : cholesterol ratios the NMR results show all three antibiotics to cause extensive vesicle destruction. The onset of this behavior, which appears to be independent of the total antibiotic concentration, indicates a well defined antibiotic : cholesterol interaction stoichiometry. Despite the fact that cholesterol is required for antibiotic activity, the NMR spectra prior to vesicle destruction show no changes indicative of an antibiotic-induced reversal of cholesterol restriction of phosphatidylcholine mobility. The contrast with polyene antibiotic behavior in more extended bilayers is discussed.     

The water and ionic permeability induced by polyene antibiotics across plasma membrane vesicles from Leishmania sp

An osmotic method has been used to study the effect of the polyene antibiotics amphotericin B, nystatin and candicidin on the water permeability of plasma membranes prepared from Leishmania sp. The effect of amphotericin B on the permeability of Leishmania membranes to a salt such as potassium nitrate was also investigated. A non-linear and saturable enhancement of water and salt permeability was measured with increasing polyene concentrations, which could be adjusted to Hill cooperativity equation. The antibiotic concentrations that induce at 30 degrees C half-maximal effects on the water permeability of Leishmania vesicles were 0.021 microM for candicidin, 0.21 microM for amphotericin B and 1.4 microM for nystatin. At 30 degrees C, the concentration of amphotericin B required to induce half of the maximal effect on the permeability of Leishmania vesicles to potassium nitrate was 1.8 microM. The temperature dependence for amphotericin B, nystatin and candicidin enhancement of the water permeability of Leishmania vesicles was determined by using Q10 data at 20 and 30 degrees C. The estimated activation energies at increasing polyene concentrations display the same general pattern for all three polyene antibiotics investigated, that is, a maximal positive value at about the polyene concentrations required for half-maximal effect. The significance of these results for understanding the mechanisms of action of polyene antibiotics on natural membranes is discussed.     

Cation permeability induced by valinomycin,gramicidin D and amphotericin B in large lipidic unilamellar vesicles studied by 31P-NMR

Permeability induced by mobile carriers and channel-forming compounds in large unilamellar lipidic vesicles (LUV) has been studied by the proteon-cation exchange method. Proton movement has been monitored by pH-stat and ³¹P-NMR techniques. pH-stat measurements indicate that, in the presence of valinomycin, the proton efflux develops with a rate dependent upon valinomycin concentration, until equilibrium is reached. ³¹P-NMR spectra, monitoring pH-dependent intravesicular phosphate ionization, show that after addition of valinomycin the initial pH peak (pH 5.5; =0.25) shifts progressively to the position corresponding to the pH at equilibrium (pH 7.4; =2.20).In the presence of the channel-forming compounds, gramicidin D or amphotericin B, permeability developed in a few minutes whatever the concentration used. The percentage of total titratable proton released depends upon the antibiotic concentration. ³¹P-NMR spectra shows two signals from internal phosphate: one signal corresponding to the initial pH and a second signal corresponding to the pH at equilibrium indicating an all-or-none mode of action; just after addition of the antibiotic, two populations of vesicles coexist in proportions that depend on ionophore concentration; after longer incubation times all vesicles are permeabilized.The results obtained primarily reflect the differences in the mode of interaction with the membrane, of valinomycin as compared to the channel-forming reagents, gramicidin D or amphotericin B.     

Acetobacter aceti possesses a proton motive force-dependent efflux system for acetic acid

Acetic acid bacteria are obligate aerobes able to oxidize ethanol, sugar alcohols, and sugars into their corresponding acids. Among them, Acetobacter and Gluconacetobacter species have very high ethanol oxidation capacity, leading to accumulation of vast amounts of acetic acid outside the cell. Since these bacteria are able to grow in media with high concentrations of acetic acid, they must possess a specific mechanism such as an efflux pump by which they can resist the toxic effects of acetic acid. In this study, the efflux pump of Acetobacter aceti IFO 3283 was examined using intact cells and membrane vesicles. The accumulation of acetic acid/acetate in intact cells was increased by the addition of a proton uncoupler and/or cyanide, suggesting the presence of an energy-dependent efflux system. To confirm this, right-side-out and inside-out membrane vesicles were prepared from A. aceti IFO 3283, and the accumulation of acetic acid/acetate in the vesicles was examined. Upon the addition of a respiratory substrate, the accumulation of acetic acid/acetate in the right-side-out vesicles was largely decreased, while its accumulation was very much increased in the inside-out vesicles. These respiration-dependent phenomena observed in both types of membrane vesicles were all sensitive to a proton uncoupler. Acetic acid/acetate uptake in the inside-out membrane vesicles was dependent not on ATP but on the proton motive force. Furthermore, uptake was shown to be rather specific for acetic acid and to be pH dependent, because higher uptake was observed at lower pH. Thus, A. aceti IFO 3283 possesses a proton motive force-dependent efflux pump for acetic acid.     

Dissociation kinetics and equilibrium binding properties of polyene antibiotic complexes with phosphatidylcholine/sterol vesicles

The interactions of sonicated vesicles with the polyene antibiotics amphotericin B, candicidin, mediocidin , and a water-soluble, guanidine derivative of amphotericin B were examined by UV-visible spectroscopy at concentrations below which the polyenes become self-associated. The association constants, Kapp, and the numbers of binding sites per sterol or phospholipid molecule (n) were determined at 30 degrees C and pH 7.4. A single class of binding sites was found, with no evidence of cooperativity. For the binding of mediocidin , amphotericin B, and the guanidine derivative with phosphatidylcholine (PC), PC/cholesterol, and PC/ergosterol vesicles, Kapp was in the range of (1.0-3.0) X 10(6) M-1; Kapp was higher for candicidin-vesicle interaction, reaching 9.0 X 10(6) M-1 with PC/ergosterol vesicles. Binding of the guanidine derivative of amphotericin B to PC vesicles lacking sterol was extensive (n = 0.46); since the other polyenes, which have low aqueous solubilities, had n less than 0.05, positive charges in the mycosamine moiety appear to enhance the extent of polyene antibiotic interaction with the glycerophospholipid head group. Higher values of n (and, therefore, of nKapp ) were found with sterol-containing than with sterol-free vesicles, suggestive of penetration of the polyenes toward the interior of the bilayer when sterol is present. For binding to PC/sterol vesicles, nKapp followed the order of candicidin greater than guanidine derivative of amphotericin B greater than amphotericin B much greater than mediocidin . The values of n and nKapp were appreciably higher for amphotericin B-ergosterol than for amphotericin B-cholesterol interaction in vesicles.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Effect of amphotericin B on cholesterol-containing liposomes of egg phosphatidylcholine and didocosenoyl phosphatidylcholine. A refinement of the model for the formation of pores by amphotericin B in membranes

(1) Binding and K+-permeability measurements were performed on egg and 22 : 1c/22 : 1c-phosphatidylcholine liposomes with or without cholesterol. (2) Amphotericin B binds specifically to cholesterol in both types of liposome despite the difference in bilayer thickness. (3) Addition of amphotericin B to one side of the cholesterol-containing egg phosphatidylcholine bilayers induces a fast K+ efflux from the outermost compartment of the liposomes. In contrast, the total K+ content of sonicated unilamellar cholesterol-containing egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles is released by amphotericin B. (4) Amphotericin B addition to one side of the cholesterol-containing 22 : 1c/22 : 1c-phosphatidylcholine liposomes does not cause a change in K+ permeability. The presence of amphotericin B on both sides of the bilayer, however, induces an increase in K+ permeability. (5) A model is proposed which accounts for the effect of bilayer thickness on the amphotericin B-induced permeability changes in membranes.     

Lactate efflux-induced electrical potential in membrane vesicles of Streptococcus cremoris.

We developed a procedure for isolating membrane vesicles from the homolactic fermentative bacterium Streptococcus cremoris. The membrane vesicles were shown to have a right-side-out orientation by freeze-etch electron microscopy and to be free of cytoplasmic constituents. The membrane vesicles retained their functional properties and accumulated the amino acids L-leucine, L-histidine, and L-alanine in response to a valinomycin-induced potassium diffusion gradient. Studies with these membrane vesicles strongly supported the possibility that there was a proton motive force-generating mechanism by end product efflux (Michels et al., FEMS Lett. 5:357-364, 1979). Lactate efflux from membrane vesicles which were loaded with L-lactate and diluted in a lactate-free medium led to the generation of an electrical potential across the membrane. The results indicate that lactate efflux is an electrogenic process by which L-lactate is translocated with more than one proton.     

Biologically active amphotericin B-calix[4]arene conjugates

In order to provide tools for investigations of amphotericin B ion channels, new conjugates bearing a calix[4]arene scaffold covalently linked to four amphotericin B molecules were synthesized. These macromolecules adopt a cone conformation that mimics the structure of a transmembrane pore. The antifungal activity of the conjugates 3 and 4 was superior or similar to that of native amphotericin B, with minimal inhibitory concentration values of 0.10 and 0.25 microM, respectively. Furthermore, the hemotoxicity of the new conjugates was considerably lower (at least 10 times) than the hemotoxicity of monomeric amphotericin B. Finally, the formation of ion channels in the lipid bilayer by the amphotericin B tetramer was monitored by measuring the K+ efflux from various liposomes.     

Proton decay kinetics for vesicles containing buffers—an analytical solution

The problem of predicting the kinetics of proton efflux and the decay of the internal proton concentration for vesicles containing one or more buffers for which the internal proton concentration is initially higher than that of the surrounding medium is examined. An analytical solution is derived that describes the time course of the proton efflux from vesicles and the decay of the internal proton concentration under conditions of zero transmembrane electric potential. The effect of the internal buffers is to increase the time required for the proton concentration gradient to equilibrate across the membrane. To simplify the analysis we assume that the equilibration of the internal and external proton activity is due primarily to proton diffusion through the membrane, and not to hydroxyl ion flux. For a vesicle containing a single buffer the solution requires six independent physical parameters: the initial internal proton concentration, the external proton concentration, the ratio of the vesicle surface area to the internal volume, the permeability coefficient of the membrane for protons, the total concentration of the internal buffer, and the equilibrium constant for the dissociation of the internal buffer. Determination of these physical values is sufficient to predict the time dependence of the internal proton concentration and of the proton efflux. Over a pH range that is below or near the pK of the internal buffer the solution is complex. However, if the initial pH is one unit or more higher than the pK of the internal buffer the kinetics of the internal proton concentration and proton efflux can be described by a pseudo first order reaction. In this case the apparent rate constant depends linearly on the permeability coefficient and is dominated by the total internal buffer concentration and its pK. For example, increasing the internal buffer concentration inside a vesicle by 10-fold results in an approximately 10-fold increase in the half-time of the proton efflux kinetics. The theoretical analysis is applied to thylakiod vesicles using experimentally determined values for the physical parameters. The predictions of the analysis are compared to experimentally observed kinetics.     

Transfer of the polyene antibiotic amphotericin B between single-walled vesicles of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and egg-yolk phosphatidylcholine

Amphotericin B transfer between single-walled vesicles of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and of egg phosphatidylcholine, both containing 10 mol% cholesterol, has been studied concurrently by circular dichroism spectroscopy and permeability measurements. At 22°C amphotericin B is rapidly transferred from DPPC to DPPC vesicles as well as from egg phosphatidylcholine to egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles. On the other hand, although amphotericin B is rapidly transferred from egg phosphatidylcholine to DPPC vesicles, it is not transferred from DPPC to egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles. At 48°C, above the transition temperature of DPPC, transfer occurs rapidly both ways. These results are interpreted in terms of difference of association constant of amphotericin B with vesicle membranes in the gel and liquid-crystalline state.     

ATP-dependent cadmium transport by the cadA cadmium resistance determinant in everted membrane vesicles of Bacillus subtilis.

Resistance to cadmium conferred by the staphylococcal plasmid pI258 occurs by means of energy-dependent efflux, resulting in decreased intracellular accumulation of cadmium. Recent sequence information suggested that efflux is mediated by a P-type ATPase. The cadA gene was previously expressed in Bacillus subtilis, conferring resistance to cadmium. Everted membrane vesicles were prepared from B. subtilis cells harboring either a plasmid containing the cadA system or the vector plasmid alone. 109Cd2+ transport into the everted membranes was measured in the presence of various energy sources. Cadmium transport was detected only in the presence of ATP as an energy source. The production of an electrochemical proton gradient (delta mu H+) by using NADH or phenazine methosulfate plus ascorbate was not able to drive transport. Reagents which dissipate delta pH abolished calcium transport due to the Ca2+/H+ antiporter but only partially inhibited cadmium transport. Inhibition of transport by the antibiotic bafilomycin A1 occurred at concentrations comparable to those which inhibit P-type ATPases. A band corresponding to the cadA gene product was identified on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and antibodies to the protein were prepared.     

Temperature-dependent modes for the binding of the polyene antibiotic amphotericin B to human erythrocyte membranes. A circular dichroism study

The interaction of amphotericin B with isolated human erythrocyte ghosts was monitored by circular dichroism at 37 degrees C and 15 degrees C. Although different, these spectra were not concentration dependent over a concentration range covering the inducement of K+ leakage and hemolysis, which suggests the existence of only one bound amphotericin B species. At 15 degrees C, the spectra indicate that amphotericin B is complexed with membrane cholesterol; the complex formation is saturable but not cooperative. At 37 degrees C new spectra are observed, and their existence is conditioned by the presence of membrane proteins. The binding is cooperative but not saturable. The amphotericin B right side-out vesicles complexation is temperature as well as ionic strength dependent: at high ionic strength it is the same as with ghosts, with the same temperature dependence. At low ionic strength it is characteristic of an interaction with cholesterol, regardless of temperature. In the large unilamellar vesicles reconstituted from the total lipid extracts of erythrocyte membranes, amphotericin B is complexed with cholesterol, regardless of temperature and ionic strength. These results indicate that there are two different modes of amphotericin B complexation with erythrocyte membranes, reversible one in the other, depending on the molecular organization of the membrane and the presence of membrane proteins.     

The bacteriocin lactococcin A specifically increases permeability of lactococcal cytoplasmic membranes in a voltage-independent, protein-mediated manner.

Lactococcin A is a bacteriocin produced by Lactococcus lactis. Its structural gene has recently been cloned and sequenced (M. J. van Belkum, B. J. Hayema, R. E. Jeeninga, J. Kok, and G. Venema, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 57:492-498, 1991). Purified lactococcin A increased the permeability of the cytoplasmic membrane of L. lactis and dissipated the membrane potential. A significantly higher concentration of lactococcin A was needed to dissipate the membrane potential in an immune strain of L. lactis. Lactococcin A at low concentrations (0.029 microgram/mg of protein) inhibited secondary and phosphate-bond driven transport of amino acids in sensitive cells and caused efflux of preaccumulated amino acids. Accumulation of amino acids by immune cells was not affected by this concentration of lactococcin A. Lactococcin A also inhibited proton motive force-driven leucine uptake and leucine counterflow in membrane vesicles of the sensitive strain but not in membrane vesicles of the immune strain. These observations indicate that lactococcin A makes the membrane permeable for leucine in the presence or absence of a proton motive force and that the immunity factor(s) is membrane linked. Membrane vesicles of Clostridium acetobutylicum, Bacillus subtilis, and Escherichia coli were not affected by lactococcin A, nor were liposomes derived from phospholipids of L. lactis. These results indicate that lactococcin A acts on the cytoplasmic membrane and is very specific towards lactococci. The combined results obtained with cells, vesicles, and liposomes suggest that the specificity of lactococcin A may be mediated by a receptor protein associated with the cytoplasmic membrane.     

Amphotericin B-induced changes in K+ content, viability, and ultrastructure of yeast-phase Histoplasma capsulatum.

Yeast-phase cells of Histoplasma capsulatum were challenged with amphotericin B, and membrane perturbation was monitored by K+ efflux. Suspensions of washed cells readily absorbed about 1.12 microgram of amphotericin B per mg (dry weight) and further nonspecific sites were also apparent. The dose-response curve for initial rate of K+ efflux was sigmoidal within the range 0.1 to 1.0 microgram of amphotericin B per ml. A fungistatic concentration of amphotericin B (0.3 microgram/ml) evoked an efflux of 85 to 90% K+ from the cells within 15 min, but cell viability decreased only 13% (yeast phase) or 33% (transformed to mycelial units). Ultrastructural changes in treated cells were detected within 5 min, and the hallmark was expansion of vacuoles during the 1-h monitoring period. In contradistinction to a previous report, the appearance of the protoplasmic membrane was not altered by fungistatic concentration. When treated cells were returned to a fresh growth medium, there was a pronounced lag (20 h). During this apparent recovery phase, the large vacuoles fragmented and returned to normal size. It is proposed that vacuoles of H. capsulatum act as a spatial buffer of considerable survival value to stressed cells.     

Incorporation of amphotericin B into large unilamellar vesicles composed of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylglycerol

The spontaneous incorporation of the polyene antibiotic amphotericin B from a micellar solution into phospholipid vesicles was examined as a function of the lipid composition of the vesicles and their physical state. Virtually no insertion of the antibiotic into egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles was observed even when cholesterol was also present in the bilayer. In contrast, rapid incorporation occurred into systems containing an anionic phospholipid such as phosphatidylglycerol or phosphatidylserine with the fastest rates observed for lipids containing the saturated dimyristoyl fatty acyl species. Insertion of amphotericin B into vesicles composed of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine and dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol (7:3 mole ratio) was rapid either above, below or within the gel-to-liquid-crystalline phase transition temperature (23 degrees C). The ability of amphotericin B to intercalate into lipid vesicles is discussed in relation to their relative bilayer stabilities.     

Spin-labeled amphotericin B: synthesis, characterization, biological and spectroscopic properties

A biologically active spin-labeled derivative of amphotericin B has been synthesized by the nucleophilic addition of amphotericin B to 4-(2-iodoacetamido)-2,2',6,6'-tetramethylpiperadine-N-oxyl in dimethyl-sulphoxide at 40 degrees C. The derivative is a moderately water-soluble compound which displays the same biological activity of the parental compound against the sensitive organism Leishmania mexicana; also, the rates of proton-cation exchange induced by the two compounds in large unilamellar liposomes are indistinguishable. The ESR spectra of spin-labeled amphotericin B in lipid vesicles indicate a high degree of motion, very similar to that encountered for the compound in aqueous solutions at neutral pH and in deoxycholate micelles, and suggest that the structures formed by the antibiotic in membranes are composed by a small number of molecules. In contrast, the spectra of the labeled antibiotic in ethanol, diethyl ether and dimethylformamide indicate restricted motion and exchange interactions, probably resulting from the micellar aggregation induced in these media. Ascorbate at 10 mM is able to reduce completely the nitroxide group of the labeled antibiotic in lipid vesicles in less than 30 s, indicating that an asymmetric disposition of the antibiotic molecules across the membrane is capable of inducing its biological and ionophoric properties. Ni2+ and Cu2+ produce moderate exchange broadening of the ESR signal of spin-labeled amphotericin B in lipid vesicles; the comparison of this phenomenom with the exchange broadening produced by the same ions in the ESR spectrum of 2,2',6,6'-tetramethylpiperidine-N-oxyl in water solution suggests an specific Cu2+-amphotericin B interaction in membranes.     

Is agonist self-inhibition at the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor a nonspecific action?

Agonist concentration-response relationships at nicotinic postsynaptic receptors were established by measuring 86Rb+ efflux from acetylcholine receptor rich native Torpedo membrane vesicles under three different conditions: integrated net ion efflux (in 10 s) from untreated vesicles, integrated net efflux from vesicles in which most acetylcholine sites were irreversibly blocked with alpha-bungarotoxin, and initial rates of efflux (5-100 ms) from vesicles that were partially blocked with alpha-bungarotoxin. Exposure to acetylcholine, carbamylcholine, suberyldicholine, phenyltrimethylammonium, or (-)-nicotine over 10(8)-fold concentration ranges results in bell-shaped ion flux response curves due to stimulation of acetylcholine receptor channel opening at low concentrations and inhibition of channel function at 60-2000 times higher concentrations. Concentrations of agonists that inhibit their own maximum 86Rb+ efflux by 50% (KB values) are 110, 211, 3.0, 39, and 8.9 mM, respectively, for the agonists listed above. For acetylcholine and carbamylcholine, KB values determined from both 10-s and 15-ms efflux measurements are the same, indicating that the rate of agonist-induced desensitization increases to maximum at concentrations lower than those causing self-inhibition. For all partial and full agonists studied, Hill coefficients for self-inhibition are close to 1.0. Concentrations of agonists up to 8 times KB did not change the order parameter reported by a spin-labeled fatty acid incorporated in Torpedo membranes. We conclude that agonist self-inhibition cannot be attributed to a general nonspecific membrane perturbation. Instead, these results are consistent with a saturable site of action either at the lipid-protein interface or on the acetylcholine receptor protein itself.