A duplex vibriocidal assay to simultaneously measure bactericidal antibody titers against Vibrio cholerae O1 Inaba and Ogawa serotypes

Currently available cholera vaccines are formulated with killed-whole cells of Vibrio cholerae O1 Inaba and Ogawa serotypes. A serum vibriocidal assay has been widely used to evaluate the immunogenicity of cholera vaccines in clinical trials. In this study, we developed a duplex vibriocidal assay to obtain vibriocidal antibody titers against both serotypes simultaneously. Initially, serial dilutions of serum from vaccinees were incubated with guinea pig complements along with both streptomycin-resistant Inaba and ampicillin-resistant Ogawa strains for 1 h. The mixture was then inoculated on separate agar plates containing each antibiotic to selectively culture each corresponding serotype and incubated at 37 °C for 16 to 20 h. Bacterial colonies were enumerated using an automated colony counting system to obtain the vibriocidal antibody titers defined by the reciprocal of serum dilution inhibiting bacterial growth by 50%. Performance of the duplex vibriocidal assay was examined by comparison with a single serotype vibriocidal assay using 20 clinical sera consisting of ten-paired sera prepared at pre- and post-vaccination. Both assays showed a good correlation for vibriocidal titers against the two serotypes, respectively, as determined by Pearson correlation coefficient (r) and regression coefficient (β) analyses; r = 0.998, β = 1.003 for Inaba and r = 0.997, β = 0.999 for Ogawa, respectively. The duplex vibriocidal assay can diminish the amount of sera required for the assay and enhance assay efficiency in terms of time, labor intensity, and expenditure.     

小鼠血清中杀O139霍乱弧菌抗体检测方法的初步建立

目的研究探索O139霍乱弧菌杀弧菌抗体的检测方法。方法用微孔板培养和琼脂平板克隆计数相结合的杀弧菌抗体检测方法,对实验菌株及稀释度、补体浓度等关键参数进行筛选;对50份小鼠免疫血清进行杀弧菌抗体滴度检测,并与O139群霍乱弧菌LPS Ig G抗体滴度进行相关分析;对该方法的特异性、线性和精密性进行了验证。结果筛选出最佳菌株为20100603菌株,最佳稀释度倍数为2 000倍,补体最佳稀释倍数为16倍。O139群霍乱弧菌小鼠免疫血清检测到较高的杀弧菌抗体滴度而PBS小鼠免疫血清未检测到杀弧菌抗体滴度。小鼠免疫血清杀弧菌抗体滴度与O139群霍乱弧菌LPS Ig G抗体滴度之间存在正相关关系。验证结果显示,在抑制剂浓度达到1.0~2.0 A600时,抑制率100%;线性回归方程为y=-1.093x+5.058,其相关系数为-0.999,P0.05;方法批内CV值为15.72%,批间CV值为23.47%。结论初步建立了O139霍乱弧菌杀弧菌抗体的检测方法,该方法具有较高的特异性、线性和精密度。     

Systemic immunity of experimental animals immunized with cholera vaccines

The levels of antitoxic and vibriocidal antibodies in the sera of suckling rabbits after their parenteral immunization with cholera vaccine, cholera toxoid and a combination of cholera vaccine and toxoid were examined. Cholera vaccine induces intensive production of vibriocidal antibodies, and cholera toxoid, of antitoxic antibodies. The parenteral administration of the serum of rabbits immunized with cholera toxoid neutralized the action of cholera toxin in the small intestine of suckling rabbits. The complex preparation combines the properties of the corpuscular vaccine and the toxoid, inducing the production of both vibriocidal and antitoxic antibodies.     

Titration of Cholera Antitoxin in Human Sera by Microhemagglutination with Formalinized Erythrocytes

Microtiter hemagglutination tests employing formalinized sheep erythrocytes sensitized with either crude or purified cholera toxin were used to assay the cholera antitoxin content of human sera. Comparable results were obtained with either crude or purified toxin-sensitized cells with the exception of two sera that gave unusually high hemagglutination titers with the crude toxin. Sera from 13 convalescent cholera patients showed a high degree of correlation between antitoxin levels as determined in vitro by the hemagglutination test and in vivo by the skin permeability factor neutralization test. Fourfold or greater rises in antitoxin levels between acute and convalescent sera were detected in 9 of 15 patients with bacteriologically proven cholera. No significant increases in titer were observed in 14 cases of noncholera diarrhea. Cholera antitoxin was detected by hemagglutination in only 1 of 33 sera, obtained from eight countries, containing vibriocidal antibodies. Formalinized sheep erythrocytes sensitized with toxin and stored at 4 C in the presence of 1:10,000 thimerosal were stable and sensitive for at least 6 months (the longest time tested).     

Longitudinal neutralization activities on authentic Omicron variant provided by three doses of BBIBP-CorV vaccination during one year

The majority of people in China have been immunized with the inactivated viral vaccine BBIBP-CorV. The emergence of the Omicron variant raised the concerns about protection efficacy of the inactivated viral vaccine in China. However, longitudinal neutralization data describing protection efficacy against Omicron variant is still lacking. Here we present one-year longitudinal neutralization data of BBIBP-CorV on authentic Omicron, Delta, and wild-type strains using 224 sera collected from 14 volunteers who have finished three doses BBIBP-CorV. The sera were also subjected for monitoring the SARS-CoV-2 specific IgG, IgA, and IgM responses on protein and peptide microarrays. The neutralization titers showed different protection efficacies against the three strains. By incorporating IgG and IgA signals of proteins and Spike protein derived peptide on microarray, panels as potential surrogate biomarkers for rapid estimation of neutralization titers were established. These data support the necessity of the 3^rd dose of BBIBP-CorV vaccination. After further validation and assay development, the panels could be used for reliable, convenient and fast evaluation of the efficacy of vaccination.     

Guinea pig complement potently measures vibriocidal activity of human antibodies in response to cholera vaccines

The vibriocidal assay using guinea pig complement is widely used for the evaluation of immune responses to cholera vaccines in human clinical trials. However, it is unclear why guinea pig complement has been used over human complement in the measurement of vibriocidal activity of human sera and there have not been comparison studies for the use of guinea pig complement over those from other species. Therefore, we comparatively investigated the effects of complements derived from human, guinea pig, rabbit, and sheep on vibriocidal activity. Complements from guinea pig, rabbit, and human showed concentration-dependent vibriocidal activity in the presence of quality control serum antibodies. Of these complements, guinea pig complement was the most sensitive and effective over a wide concentration range. When the vibriocidal activity of complements was measured in the absence of serum antibodies, human, sheep, and guinea pig complements showed vibriocidal activity up to 40-fold, 20-fold, and 1-fold dilution, respectively. For human pre- and post-vaccination sera, the most potent vibriocidal activity was observed when guinea pig complement was used. In addition, the highest fold-increases between pre- and post- vaccinated sera were obtained with guinea pig complement. Furthermore, human complement contained a higher amount of V. cholerae- and its lipopolysaccharide-specific antibodies than guinea pig complement. Collectively, these results suggest that guinea pig complements are suitable for vibriocidal assays due to their high sensitivity and effectiveness to human sera.     

The characteristics of the reactogenicity and immunological activity of a new cholera bivalent chemical vaccine based on the results of controlled trials]

The reactogenic properties and immunological potency of modified cholera chemical vaccine (choleragen-toxoid + O-antigens Inaba and Ogawa) were tested in 278 volunteers aged 18 years and over in comparison with those of a commercial batch of monovalent cholera vaccine (choleragen-toxoid + O-antigen Inaba). The cholera vaccine, enriched with O-antigen Ogawa, was found to be safe; vaccination with this vaccine was not accompanied by the development of systemic and local reactions whose frequency and intensity met the requirements for the reactogenic properties of commercial cholera vaccine. The immunological potency of the bivalent vaccine with respect to strain Inaba was not inferior to that of the commercial vaccine; at the same time in persons immunized with the new preparation the titers of vibriocidal antibodies to strain of serovar Inaba were five-fold higher. The conclusion on the expediency of using cholera chemical vaccine enriched with O-antigen Ogawa was made.     

A one dose experimental cholera vaccine

The number of cholera vaccine doses required for immunity is a constraint during epidemic cholera. Protective immunity following one dose of multiple Vibrio cholerae (Vc) colonization factors (Inaba LPS El Tor, TcpA, TcpF, and CBP-A) has not been directly tested even though individual Vc colonization factors are the protective antigens. Inaba LPS consistently induced vibriocidal and protective antibodies at low doses. A LPS booster, regardless of dose, induced highly protective secondary sera. Vc protein immunogens emulsified in adjuvant were variably immunogenic. CBP-A was proficient at inducing high IgG serum titers compared with TcpA or TcpF. After one immunization, TcpA or TcpF antisera protected only when the toxin co-regulated pilus operon of the challenge Vc was induced by AKI culture conditions. CBP-A was not consistently able to induce protection independent of the challenge Vc culture conditions. These results reveal the need to understand how best to leverage the 'right' Vc immunogens to obtain durable immunity after one dose of a cholera subunit vaccine. The dominance of the protective anti-LPS antibody response over other Vc antigen antibody response needs to be controlled to find other protective antigens that can add to anti-LPS antibody-based immunity.     

Seroepidemiology of cholera in Gulf coastal Texas

Single serum samples from 559 volunteers from a Texas Gulf Coast area were examined for vibriocidal antibody to Vibrio cholerae O1 (biotype El Tor, serotype Inaba) by a microtiter method. Elevated levels of vibriocidal antibody were present in 14% of the subjects. Also, 6.8% of the subjects had elevated levels of antibody to the enterotoxin of V. cholerae O1 by the immunoglobulin G enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Recent infection, defined on the basis of elevations in both vibriocidal and antitoxin antibodies, had occurred in 1.3% of the subjects. When subjects who reported Brucella infection, travel to a cholera-endemic area, and/or cholera vaccination within a year of the study were removed from the analysis, a prevalence of recent infection of 0.89% was obtained. Significantly higher titers of vibriocidal antibody were found in those with exposure to seawater (fishermen, shrimpers, merchant marines, and dock workers) than in those without such exposure (P less than 0.005). Furthermore, titers of antitoxin antibody were significantly higher in those who consumed shellfish than in nonconsumers. Finally, titers of vibriocidal antibody were significantly higher in Vietnamese subjects than in non-Vietnamese subjects. The results of this study indicate that an endemic focus of infection with V. cholerae occurs in this area.     

Seroepidemiology of cholera in Gulf coastal Texas.

Single serum samples from 559 volunteers from a Texas Gulf Coast area were examined for vibriocidal antibody to Vibrio cholerae O1 (biotype El Tor, serotype Inaba) by a microtiter method. Elevated levels of vibriocidal antibody were present in 14% of the subjects. Also, 6.8% of the subjects had elevated levels of antibody to the enterotoxin of V. cholerae O1 by the immunoglobulin G enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Recent infection, defined on the basis of elevations in both vibriocidal and antitoxin antibodies, had occurred in 1.3% of the subjects. When subjects who reported Brucella infection, travel to a cholera-endemic area, and/or cholera vaccination within a year of the study were removed from the analysis, a prevalence of recent infection of 0.89% was obtained. Significantly higher titers of vibriocidal antibody were found in those with exposure to seawater (fishermen, shrimpers, merchant marines, and dock workers) than in those without such exposure (P less than 0.005). Furthermore, titers of antitoxin antibody were significantly higher in those who consumed shellfish than in nonconsumers. Finally, titers of vibriocidal antibody were significantly higher in Vietnamese subjects than in non-Vietnamese subjects. The results of this study indicate that an endemic focus of infection with V. cholerae occurs in this area.     

Vibriocidal Antibody Responses to a Bivalent Killed Whole-Cell Oral Cholera Vaccine in a Phase III Trial in Kolkata,India

Background

During the development of a vaccine, identification of the correlates of protection is of paramount importance for establishing an objective criterion for the protective performance of the vaccine. However, the ascertainment of correlates of immunity conferred by any vaccine is a difficult task.

Methods

While conducting a phase three double-blind, cluster-randomized, placebo-controlled trial of a bivalent killed whole-cell oral cholera vaccine in Kolkata, we evaluated the immunogenicity of the vaccine in a subset of participants. Randomly chosen participants (recipients of vaccine or placebo) were invited to provide blood samples at baseline, 14 days after the second dose and one year after the first dose. At these time points, serum geometric mean titers (GMT) of vibriocidal antibodies and seroconversion rates for vaccine and placebo arms were calculated and compared across the age strata (1 to 5 years, 5 to 15 years and more than 15 years) as well as for all age groups.

Results

Out of 137 subjects included in analysis, 69 were vaccinees and 68 received placebo. There were 5•7 and 5•8 geometric mean fold (GMF) rises in titers to Vibrio cholerae Inaba and Ogawa, respectively at 14 days after the second dose, with 57% and 61% of vaccinees showing a four-fold or greater titer rise, respectively. After one year, the titers to Inaba and Ogawa remained 1•7 and 2•8 fold higher, respectively, compared to baseline. Serum vibriocidal antibody response to V. cholerae O139 was much lower than that to Inaba or Ogawa. No significant differences in the GMF-rises were observed among the age groups.

Conclusions

The reformulated oral cholera vaccine induced a statistically significant anti-O1 Inaba and O1 Ogawa vibriocidal antibody response 14 days after vaccination, which although declined after one year remained significantly higher than baseline. Despite this decline, the vaccine remained protective five years after vaccination.     

A simple and convenient microtiter plate assay for the detection of bactericidal antibodies to Vibrio cholerae O1 and Vibrio cholerae O139

It is believed that the correlate of protection for cholera can be determined by the serum vibriocidal assay. The currently available vibriocidal assays, based on the conventional agar plating technique, are labor intensive. We developed a simple and convenient microtiter plate assay for the detection of vibriocidal antibodies that is equally as efficient for Vibrio cholerae O1 and for V. cholerae O139. The addition of succinate and neotetrazolium made it possible to measure the growth of surviving bacterial target cells by monitoring a color change. We evaluated assay parameters (target strains, growth of target cells, complement source and concentration) that may affect the reproducibility of the method for V. cholerae O139. The results obtained with the microtiter plate assay were uniformly similar to those obtained with the conventional agar plating assay, when testing both the Inaba and Ogawa serotypes of V. cholerae O1. The microtiter plate assay was also convenient for measuring the activity of animal sera and mouse monoclonal antibodies.     

The evaluation of the vibriocidal antibody test in establishing a diagnosis of cholera or Vibrio carriage]

On the basis of the serological survey of cholera patients, vibrio carriers and persons having had contacts with the source or reservoir of Vibrio cholerae the conclusion has been made that the test for the presence of vibriocidal antibodies, together with the bacteriological study of the patient, is of diagnostic importance in the diagnosis of cholera or vibrio carriership. The detection of vibriocidal antibodies, especially in the study of paired sera, permits the detection of cholera cases which have not been bacteriologically confirmed due to various reasons; besides, it makes it possible to exclude the diagnosis of cholera made only on the basis of clinical data. Like bacteriological study, the determination of vibriocidal antibodies must be obligatory for persons hospitalized in a provisory hospital or an isolation ward; it will undoubtedly improve the quality of cholera diagnosis and permit taking timely antiepidemic measures in the focus of infection.     

Immunogenicity of a Killed Bivalent (O1 and O139) Whole Cell Oral Cholera Vaccine,Shanchol, in Haiti

Background

Studies of the immunogenicity of the killed bivalent whole cell oral cholera vaccine, Shanchol, have been performed in historically cholera-endemic areas of Asia. There is a need to assess the immunogenicity of the vaccine in Haiti and other populations without historical exposure to Vibrio cholerae.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We measured immune responses after administration of Shanchol, in 25 adults, 51 older children (6–17 years), and 47 younger children (1–5 years) in Haiti, where cholera was introduced in 2010. A≥4-fold increase in vibriocidal antibody titer against V. cholerae O1 Ogawa was observed in 91% of adults, 74% of older children, and 73% of younger children after two doses of Shanchol; similar responses were observed against the Inaba serotype. A≥2-fold increase in serum O-antigen specific polysaccharide IgA antibody levels against V. cholerae O1 Ogawa was observed in 59% of adults, 45% of older children, and 61% of younger children; similar responses were observed against the Inaba serotype. We compared immune responses in Haitian individuals with age- and blood group-matched individuals from Bangladesh, a historically cholera-endemic area. The geometric mean vibriocidal titers after the first dose of vaccine were lower in Haitian than in Bangladeshi vaccinees. However, the mean vibriocidal titers did not differ between the two groups after the second dose of the vaccine.

Conclusions/Significance

A killed bivalent whole cell oral cholera vaccine, Shanchol, is highly immunogenic in Haitian adults and children. A two-dose regimen may be important in Haiti, and other populations lacking previous repeated exposures to V. cholerae.     

The use of immunoenzyme analysis and the vibriocidal antibody reaction in the serological examination of persons who have had cholera and of those in contact with them

The preparation of cholera toxin obtained from Vibrio cholerae strain 1310 has been used for producing solid-phase immunosorbent intended for the enzyme immunoassay (EIA). The use of EIA and the vibriocidal antibody test (VAT) in the serological study of former cholera patients and persons having contacts with them has made it possible to show the excess of the antitoxic activity of sera over their vibriocidal activity in all subjects covered by the dynamic study (from 5-14 days to 8-10 months). EIA and VAT can be used as auxiliary methods in epidemiological survey and analysis.     

Heterologous Prime-Boost Vaccination with MF59-Adjuvanted H5 Vaccines Promotes Antibody Affinity Maturation towards the Hemagglutinin HA1 Domain and Broad H5N1 Cross-Clade Neutralization

In an open label clinical study (2007), MF59-adjuvanted hemagglutinin (HA) vaccine from H5N1-A/Vietnam/1194/2004 (clade 1) was administered to subjects previously vaccinated (primed) with clade 0 H5N3 (A/duck/Singapore/97) vaccine at least 6 years earlier (in 1999 or 2001). The primed individuals responded rapidly and generated high neutralizing antibody titers against the H5N1-Vietnam strain within 7 days of a single booster vaccination. Furthermore, significant cross-neutralization titers were measured against H5N1 clade 0, 1, and 2 viruses. In the current study, the impact of MF59 adjuvant during heterologous priming on the quality of humoral polyclonal immune response in different vaccine arms were further evaluated using real time kinetics assay by surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Total anti-H5N1 HA1 polyclonal sera antibody binding from the heterologous prime-boost groups after a single MF59-H5N1 boost was significantly higher compared with sera from unprimed individuals that received two MF59-H5N1 vaccinations. The antigen-antibody complex dissociation rates (surrogate for antibody affinity) of the polyclonal sera against HA1 of H5N1-A/Vietnam/1194/2004 from the MF59-H5N3 primed groups were significantly higher compared to sera from unadjuvanted primed groups or unprimed individuals that received two MF59-H5N1 vaccines. Furthermore, strong inverse correlations were observed between the antibody dissociation off-rates of the immune sera against HA1 (but not HA2) and the virus neutralization titers against H5 vaccine strains and heterologous H5N1 strains. These findings supports the use of oil-in-water-adjuvanted pandemic influenza vaccines to elicit long term memory B cells with high affinity BCR capable of responding to potential variant pandemic viruses likely to emerge and adapt to human transmissions.     

Correlation of Clostridium botulinum type C antitoxin titers in mink and guinea pigs to protection against type C intoxication in mink

In USA, the potency of commercial vaccines containing Clostridium botulinum type C toxoid is determined by a mink vaccination-challenge assay outlined in the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 9, Part 113.110. A more humane potency test is desired, and this study provides preliminary data in support of a serological assay that correlates post-vaccination antitoxin titers of guinea pigs to vaccine efficacy in mink. Mink and guinea pigs were injected with varying dilutions of a vaccine containing C. botulinum type C toxoid. Blood samples were collected from each animal prior to challenging the mink with type C toxin. Serum antitoxin titers of mink and guinea pigs were measured by a mouse protection test, and the results were compared to the outcome of the toxin challenge in mink. A dose-dependent antitoxin response was observed in guinea pigs vaccinated with the critical dilutions of vaccine bracketing the minimum protective dose in mink. These preliminary data suggest that it may be possible to correlate post-vaccination antitoxin titers in guinea pigs to vaccine efficacy in mink. This correlation could be used as the basis for a more humane potency test for C. botulinum type C toxoids.     

Agglutinating and Bactericidal Properties of Fractions of Rabbit Anti-Vibrio cholerae Serum

The major portion of the agglutinating and bactericidal activity of the sera of rabbits immunized with live Vibrio cholerae or with cholera vaccine was found in the gammaM fractions during the early stages of immunization. After 5 weeks or more, gammaG fractions accounted for more than half of the agglutinating activity. When late antibody was measured as the amount of protein precipitated by somatic antigens, nearly 3 times as much gammaG as gammaM was required for agglutination, and about 30 times as much gammaG as gammaM was required to kill 50% of a standard inoculum in the presence of complement. The ratio of vibriocidal to agglutinin titer of gammaG fractions at different stages of immunization was more variable than that of gammaM fractions. More complement was required for a vibriocidal effect by gammaG than by gammaM. Increasing the amount of complement decreased the amount of both gammaG and gammaM required to kill, but smaller amounts of gammaM required disproportionately larger amounts of complement. Less time was required by gammaM than by gammaG to kill 50% of the inoculum. Removal of the group-reactive antibody from anti-Ogawa serum and serum fractions by absorption with Inaba reduced the vibriocidal titer by more than one-half.     

吸附霍乱菌苗免疫后人群血清杀弧菌抗体观察

本文介绍了用霍乱杀弧菌抗体微量法,检测经Ｏ１型吸附霍乱菌苗免疫前后人群的Ｏ１型霍乱和Ｏ１３９型霍乱的血清杀弧菌抗体。结果表明,免前人群的Ｉｎａｂａ、Ｏｇａｗａ、Ｏ１３９型三种自然杀弧菌抗体很低（ＧＭＴ在５．４９以下）,免后Ｉｎａｂａ和Ｏｇａｗａ型杀弧菌抗体大幅度增加,ＧＭＴ分别达到７８２和５９２、Ｏ１３９型霍乱杀弧菌抗体免疫前后无变化     

A Cholera Conjugate Vaccine Containing O-specific Polysaccharide (OSP) of V. cholerae O1 Inaba and Recombinant Fragment of Tetanus Toxin Heavy Chain (OSP:rTTHc) Induces Serum,Memory and Lamina Proprial Responses against OSP and Is Protective in Mice

Background

Vibrio cholerae is the cause of cholera, a severe watery diarrhea. Protection against cholera is serogroup specific. Serogroup specificity is defined by the O-specific polysaccharide (OSP) component of lipopolysaccharide (LPS).

Methodology

Here we describe a conjugate vaccine for cholera prepared via squaric acid chemistry from the OSP of V. cholerae O1 Inaba strain PIC018 and a recombinant heavy chain fragment of tetanus toxin (OSP:rTTHc). We assessed a range of vaccine doses based on the OSP content of the vaccine (10-50 μg), vaccine compositions varying by molar loading ratio of OSP to rTTHc (3:1, 5:1, 10:1), effect of an adjuvant, and route of immunization.

Principle Findings

Immunized mice developed prominent anti-OSP and anti-TT serum IgG responses, as well as vibriocidal antibody and memory B cell responses following intramuscular or intradermal vaccination. Mice did not develop anti-squarate responses. Intestinal lamina proprial IgA responses targeting OSP occurred following intradermal vaccination. In general, we found comparable immune responses in mice immunized with these variations, although memory B cell and vibriocidal responses were blunted in mice receiving the highest dose of vaccine (50 μg). We found no appreciable change in immune responses when the conjugate vaccine was administered in the presence or absence of immunoadjuvant alum. Administration of OSP:rTTHc resulted in 55% protective efficacy in a mouse survival cholera challenge model.

Conclusion

We report development of an Inaba OSP:rTTHc conjugate vaccine that induces memory responses and protection against cholera in mice. Development of an effective cholera conjugate vaccine that induces high level and long-term immune responses against OSP would be beneficial, especially in young children who respond poorly to polysaccharide antigens.