Effects of elevated CO2 and temperature on the leaf chemistry of birch Betula pendula (Roth) and the feeding behaviour of the weevil Phyllobius maculicornis

Abstract 1 The effect of elevated CO₂ and temperature on the foliar chemistry Betula pendula Roth and the feeding performance of polyphagous weevils Phyllobius maculicornis Germ. was studied. Birch seedlings were grown during one growing season in chamber‐less field conditions and in closed‐top chambers exposed to four different treatments: ambient CO₂ (350 p.p.m) and temperature, elevated atmospheric CO₂ (700 p.p.m) and ambient temperature, elevated temperature +3 °C above ambient) and ambient CO₂, and a combination of elevated CO₂ and temperature. 2 In leaves under CO₂ enrichment, the concentration of nitrogen and some flavonol glycosides significantly decreased, whereas the concentration of total phenolics, condensed tannins and (+)‐catechin significantly increased. The total concentration of cinnamoylquinic acids was significantly increased by CO₂ and decreased by temperature. The concentration of salidroside increased under elevated temperature. 3 Weevil‐feeding experiments were carried out in a five‐choice arrangement, one leaf from each of the five treatments (chamber‐less field controls and four different treatments in chambers) being placed in random order in a plastic box. The weevils preferred the leaves grown under elevated CO₂, which had low nitrogen, high phenolics and the highest condensed tannin concentrations. Whether the reason for this trend is due to the stimulating effect of condensed tannins and/or a change in other secondary compounds, remains unknown. The weevils did not show any obviously different response in feeding performance to temperature and the combination of elevated CO₂ and temperature.     

Effects of elevated carbon dioxide concentration on photosynthesis and growth of small birch plants (Betula pendula Roth.) at optimal nutrition

Small birch plants (Betula pendula Roth.) were grown from seed for periods of up to 70d in a climate chamber at optimal nutrition and at present (350 μmol mol^?1) or elevated (700 μmol mol^?1) concentrations of atmospheric CO₂. Nutrients were sprayed over the roots in Ingestad-type units. Relative growth rate and net assimilation rate were slightly higher at elevated CO₂, whereas leaf area ratio was slightly lower. Smaller leaf area ratio was associated with lower values of specific leaf area. Leaves grown at elevated CO₂ had higher starch concentrations (dry weight basis) than leaves grown at present levels of CO₂. Biomass allocation showed no change with CO₂, and no large effects on stem height, number of side shoots and number of leaves were found. However, the specific root length of fine roots was higher at elevated CO₂. No large difference in the response of carbon assimilation to intercellular CO₂ concentration (A/C_i curves) were found between CO₂ treatments. When measured at the growth environments, the rates of photosynthesis were higher in plants grown at elevated CO₂ than in plants grown at present CO₂. Water use efficiency of single leaves was higher in the elevated treatment. This was mainly attributable to higher carbon assimilation rate at elevated CO₂. The difference in water use efficiency diminished with leaf age. The small treatment difference in relative growth rate was maintained throughout the experiment, which meant that the difference in plant size became progressively greater. Thus, where plant nutrition is sufficient to maintain maximum growth, small birch plants may potentially increase in size more rapidly at elevated CO₂.     

Soil CO2 efflux of two silver birch clones exposed to elevated CO2 and O3 levels during three growing seasons

In the present open‐top chamber experiment, two silver birch clones (Betula pendula Roth, clone 4 and clone 80) were exposed to elevated levels of carbon dioxide (CO₂) and ozone (O₃), singly and in combination, and soil CO₂ efflux was measured 14 times during three consecutive growing seasons (1999–2001). In the beginning of the experiment, all experimental trees were 7 years old and during the experiment the trees were growing in sandy field soil and fertilized regularly. In general, elevated O₃ caused soil CO₂ efflux stimulation during most measurement days and this stimulation enhanced towards the end of the experiment. The overall soil respiration response to CO₂ was dependent on the genotype, as the soil CO₂ efflux below clone 80 trees was enhanced and below clone 4 trees was decreased under elevated CO₂ treatments. Like the O₃ impact, this clonal difference in soil respiration response to CO₂ increased as the experiment progressed. Although the O₃ impact did not differ significantly between clones, a significant time × clone × CO₂× O₃ interaction revealed that the O₃‐induced stimulation of soil respiration was counteracted by elevated CO₂ in clone 4 on most measurement days, whereas in clone 80, the effect of elevated CO₂ and O₃ in combination was almost constantly additive during the 3‐year experiment. Altogether, the root or above‐ground biomass results were only partly parallel with the observed soil CO₂ efflux responses. In conclusion, our data show that O₃ impacts may appear first in the below‐ground processes and that relatively long‐term O₃ exposure had a cumulative effect on soil CO₂ efflux. Although the soil respiration response to elevated CO₂ depended on the tree genotype as a result of which the O₃ stress response might vary considerably within a single tree species under elevated CO₂, the present experiment nonetheless indicates that O₃ stress is a significant factor affecting the carbon cycling in northern forest ecosystems.     

Structural characteristics and chemical composition of birch (Betula pendula) leaves are modified by increasing CO2 and ozone

Impacts of ozone and CO₂ enrichment, alone and in combination, on leaf anatomical and ultrastructural characteristics, nutrient status and cell wall chemistry in two European silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) clones were studied. The young soil‐growing trees were exposed in open‐top chambers over three growing seasons to 2 × ambient CO₂ and/or ozone concentrations in central Finland. The trees were measured for changes in altogether 35 variables of leaf structure, nutrients and cell wall chemistry of green leaves, and 20 of the measured variables were affected by CO₂ and/or O₃. Elevated CO₂ increased the size of chloroplasts and starch grains, number of mitochondria, P : N ratio, and contents of cell wall hemicellulose. Elevated CO₂ decreased the total leaf thickness, specific leaf area, concentrations of N, K, Cu, S and Fe, and contents of cell wall α‐cellulose, uronic acids, acid‐soluble lignin and acetone‐soluble extractives. Elevated ozone led to thinner leaves, higher palisade to spongy ratio, increased number of peroxisomes and mitochondria, reduced content of Mn, Zn, Cu, hemicellulose and uronic acids, and lower Mn : N and Zn : N ratios. In the combined exposure, interactions were antagonistic. Ultrastructural changes became more evident towards the end of the exposure. Young leaves were tolerant against ozone‐caused oxidative stress, whereas oxidative H₂O₂ accumulation was found in older leaves. CO₂ enrichment improved ozone tolerance not only through increased photosynthesis rates, but also through changes in cell wall chemistry (hemicellulose, in particular). However, nutrient imbalances due to ozone and/or CO₂ may predispose the trees to other biotic and abiotic stresses. Down‐regulation and up‐regulation of photosynthesis under elevated CO₂ through anatomical changes is discussed.     

Growth response to step-decrease in nutrient availability in small birch (Betula pendula Roth)

Abstract Changes in the uptake and allocation of carbon and nitrogen, after a step-decrease in nutrient availability, were investigated in small birch (Betula pendula Roth). By demonstrating stable nutrition, before and after the decrease in nutrient supply, it was possible to eliminate the effects of plant size and age. Immediately following the step-decrease in nutrient availability, net nitrogen uptake to leaves and the relative rate of increase in shoot area tended to zero. Although photosynthetic rate per shoot area decreased, carbon uptake remained in excess of that used in structural growth and respiration. More of the excess carbon was accumulated as starch in leaves than in roots. After a lag phase, the relative rates of increase in plant dry matter, starch amount, net nitrogen uptake to leaves and shoot area development equalled that of the reduced rate of nutrient supply. It is concluded that the reduction in plant relative growth rate was much more attributable to the reduced allocation of photosynthate to leaf area growth than to the reduction in photosynthesis per shoot area.     

The effects of elevated CO2 and temperature on the resistance of winter-dormant birch seedlings (Betula pendula) to hares and voles

The effects of elevated CO₂ and temperature on the resource allocation pattern and resistance against mammalian herbivores of silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) were studied. Birch seedlings were grown through two growing seasons in closed‐top chambers exposed to four different treatments: ambient CO₂ and temperature, elevated atmospheric CO₂ (700 ppm) and ambient temperature, elevated temperature (+3°C above ambient) and ambient CO₂, and a combination of elevated CO₂ and temperature. After winter hardening of the seedlings, the growth of the seedlings was measured and the concentration of secondary compounds such as phenolics and papyriferic acid determined. The top parts of the stem were fed to hares, and the basal parts of the same stems were offered to voles. Elevated CO₂ increased the height and basal diameter of the shoots, shoot biomass and total biomass of the seedlings but did not have any effect on secondary chemistry. Elevated temperature increased the height and shoot biomass, but did not have a significant effect on the total biomass of the seedlings. Elevated temperature decreased the concentration of condensed tannins and their precursor, (+)‐catechin, in the top part of the stems, but only the concentration of (+)‐catechin in the basal part of the stems. There were no significant interactive effects between CO₂ and temperature on phenolics in the stems, while the concentration of papyriferic acid showed significant interaction in the top part of the stems. This indicates high accumulation of papyriferic acid in ambient CO₂ under increased temperature. Consequently, elevated temperature increased the resistance of birch against hares, but did not affect the resistance of the basal parts of the same birches to voles. Our results indicate that the predicted climatic change will not necessarily lead to increased browsing damage by the mountain hare and the field vole to silver birch.     

Dependence of starch storage on nutrient availability and photon flux density in small birch Betula pendula Roth)

Abstract Small birch plants (Betula pendula Roth) were grown in a climate chamber at different levels of nutrient availability and at two photon flux densities. The extent to which starch storage was dependent upon nutrient availability and photon flux density was investigated. Acclimated values of starch concentration in leaves were highest at low nutrient availability and high photon flux density. Starch storage in roots was only found at the lowest nutrient availability. However, the relative rate of starch storage (starch stored per unit plant dry weight and time) was higher in plants with good nutrition. The data suggest that, at sub-optimal nutrient availability, the momentary rate of net shoot photosynthesis is unlikely to limit the structural (as opposed to carbon storage) growth of the plant. Although photosynthetic rate per unit leaf area (as measured at the growth climate) was slightly lower in plants with poor nutrient availability, photosynthetic rate per unit leaf nitrogen was higher. These data suggest a priority of leaf nitrogen usage in photosynthesis, with limiting amounts of leaf nitrogen (and possibly other nutrients) for subsequent growth processes. This argument is consistent with the higher concentrations of starch found in plants with poor nutrient availability.     

Physiological, stomatal and ultrastructural ozone responses in birch (Betula pendula Roth.) are modified by water stress

The physiological, stomatal and ultrastructural responses to ozone and drought of ozone-sensitive and more ozone-tolerant birch ( Betula pendula Roth.) clones were studied singly and in combination, in a high-stress chamber experiment and in a low-stress open-field experiment. In the chamber experiment, well watered (WW), moderately watered (MW) or drought-stressed (DS) saplings were exposed for 36 d to 0 or 130 nmol mol^∠1 ozone. In the open-field experiment, well watered or drought-stressed saplings were grown for one growing season in ambient air or exposed to 1·8 × ambient ozone. Drought stress reduced growth rate, stomatal conductance, stomatal density and the proportion of starch and thylakoids in chloroplasts, but stimulated net photosynthesis, Rubisco and chlorophyll quantity at the end of the growing season, and increased the size and density of plastoglobuli. Ozone fumigations caused more variable, clone- and exposure-dependent responses in growth, decreased stomatal conductance and net photosynthesis, an increased number of stomata, visible and ultrastructural chloroplast injuries, and enhanced autumn yellowing of the leaves. Ozone-induced changes in plastoglobuli, starch and thylakoids resembled drought responses. The two experiments revealed that, depending on the experimental conditions and the variable, the response to drought and ozone stress can be independent, additive or interactive. Drought protected the plants from ozone injuries under high-stress conditions in the chamber experiment. In the low-stress, open-field experiment, however, enhanced ozone damage was observed in birch saplings grown under restricted water supply.     

Effects of source-sink relations on photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO2

Abstract. While photosynthesis of C₃ plants is stimulated by an increase in the atmospheric CO₂ concentration, photosynthetic capacity is often reduced after long-term exposure to elevated CO₂. This reduction appears to be brought about by end product inhibition, resulting from an imbalance in the supply and demand of carbohydrates. A review of the literature revealed that the reduction of photosynthetic capacity in elevated CO₂ was most pronounced when the increased supply of carbohydrates was combined with small sink size. The volume of pots in which plants were grown affected the sink size by restricting root growth. While plants grown in small pots had a reduced photosynthetic capacity, plants grown in the field showed no reduction or an increase in this capacity. Pot volume also determined the effect of elevated CO₂ on the root/shoot ratio: the root/shoot ratio increased when root growth was not restricted and decreased in plants grown in small pots. The data presented in this paper suggest that plants growing in the field will maintain a high photosynthetic capacity as the atmospheric CO₂ level continues to rise.     

Below-ground responses of silver birch trees exposed to elevated CO2 and O3 levels during three growing seasons

Field‐growing silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) clones (clone 4 and 80) were exposed to elevated CO₂ and O₃ in open‐top chambers for three consecutive growing seasons (1999–2001). At the beginning of the OTC experiment, all trees were 7 years old. We studied the single and interaction effects of CO₂ and O₃ on silver birch below‐ground carbon pools (i.e. effects on fine roots and mycorrhizas, soil microbial communities and sporocarp production) and also assessed whether there are any clonal differences in these below‐ground CO₂ and O₃ responses. The total mycorrhizal infection level of both clones was stimulated by elevated CO₂ alone and elevated O₃ alone, but not when elevated CO₂ was used in fumigation in combination with elevated O₃. In both clones, elevated CO₂ affected negatively light brown/orange mycorrhizas, while its effect on other mycorrhizal morphotypes was negligible. Elevated O₃, instead, clearly decreased the proportions of black and liver‐brown mycorrhizas and increased that of light brown/orange mycorrhizas. Elevated O₃ had a tendency to decrease standing fine root mass and sporocarp production as well, both of these O₃ effects mainly manifesting in clone 4 trees. CO₂ and O₃ treatment effects on soil microbial community composition (PLFA, 2‐ and 3‐OH‐FA profiles) were negligible, but quantitative PLFA data showed that in 2001 the PLFA fungi : bacteria‐ratio of clone 80 trees was marginally increased because of elevated CO₂ treatments. This study shows that O₃ effects were most clearly visible at the mycorrhizal root level and that some clonal differences in CO₂ and O₃ responses were observable in the below‐ground carbon pools. In conclusion, the present data suggests that CO₂ effects were minor, whereas increasing tropospheric O₃ levels can be an important stress factor in northern birch forests, as they might alter mycorrhizal morphotype assemblages, mycorrhizal infection rates and sporocarp production.     

Seasonal changes in the effects of elevated CO2 on rice at three levels of nitrogen supply: a free air CO2 enrichment (FACE) experiment

Over time, the stimulative effect of elevated CO₂ on the photosynthesis of rice crops is likely to be reduced with increasing duration of CO₂ exposure, but the resultant effects on crop productivity remain unclear. To investigate seasonal changes in the effect of elevated CO₂ on the growth of rice (Oryza sativa L.) crops, a free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment was conducted at Shizukuishi, Iwate, Japan in 1998–2000. The target CO₂ concentration of the FACE plots was 200 µmol mol^?1 above that of ambient. Three levels of nitrogen (N) were supplied: low (LN, 4 g N m^?2), medium [MN, 8 (1998) and 9 (1999, 2000) g N m^?2] and high N (HN, 12 and 15 g N m^?2). For MN and HN but not for LN, elevated CO₂ increased tiller number at panicle initiation (PI) but this positive response decreased with crop development. As a result, the response of green leaf area index (GLAI) to elevated CO₂ greatly varied with development, showing positive responses during vegetative stages and negative responses after PI. Elevated CO₂ decreased leaf N concentration over the season, except during early stage of development. For MN crops, total biomass increased with elevated CO₂, but the response declined linearly with development, with average increases of 32, 28, 21, 15 and 12% at tillering, PI, anthesis, mid‐ripening and grain maturity, respectively. This decline is likely to be due to decreases in the positive effects of elevated CO₂ on canopy photosynthesis because of reductions in both GLAI and leaf N. Up to PI, LN‐crops tended to have a lower response to elevated CO₂ than MN‐ and HN‐crops, though by final harvest the total biomass response was similar for all N levels. For MN‐ and HN‐crops, the positive response of grain yield (ca. 15%) to elevated CO₂ was slightly greater than the response of final total biomass while for LN‐crops it was less. We conclude that most of the seasonal changes in crop response to elevated CO₂ are directly or indirectly associated with N uptake.     

Photosynthetic parameters of birch (Betula pendula Roth) leaves growing in normal and in CO2- and O3- enriched atmospheres

Two silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) clones K1659 and V5952 were grown in open‐top chambers over 3 years (age 7–9 years). The treatments were increased CO₂ concentration (+CO₂, 72 Pa), increased O₃ concentration (+O₃, 2 × ambient O₃ with seasonal AOT40 up to 28 p.p.m. h) and in combination (+CO₂ + O₃). Thirty‐seven photosynthetic parameters were measured in the laboratory immediately after excising leaves using a computer‐operated routine of gas exchange and optical measurements. In control leaves the photosynthetic parameters were close to the values widely used in a model (Farquhar, von Caemmerer and Berry, Planta 149, 78–90, 1980). The distribution of chlorophyll between photosystem II and photosystem I, intrinsic quantum yield of electron transport, uncoupled turnover rate of Cyt b₆f, Rubisco specificity and K_m (CO₂) were not influenced by treatments. Net photosynthetic rate responded to +CO₂ with a mean increase of 17% in both clones. Dry weight of leaves increased, whereas protein, especially Rubisco content and the related photosynthetic parameters decreased. Averaged over 3 years, eight and 17 mechanistically independent parameters were significantly influenced by the elevated CO₂ in clones K1659 and V5952, respectively. The elevated O₃ caused a significant decrease in the average photosynthetic rate of clone V5952, but not of clone K1659. The treatment caused changes in one parameter of clone K1659 and in 11 parameters of clone V5952. Results of the combined treatment indicated that +O₃ had less effect in the presence of +CO₂ than alone. Interestingly, changes in the same photosynthetic parameters were observed in chamberless grown trees of clone V5952 as under +O₃ treatment in chambers, but this was not observed for clone K1659. These results suggest that during chronic fumigation, at concentrations below the threshold of visible leaf injuries, ozone influenced the photosynthetic parameters as a general stress factor, in a similar manner to weather conditions that were more stressful outside the chambers. According to this hypothesis, the sensitivity of a species or a clone to ozone is expected to depend on the growth conditions: the plant is less sensitive to ozone if the conditions are close to optimal and it is more sensitive to ozone under conditions of stress.     

Decomposition of Betula papyrifera leaf litter under the independent and interactive effects of elevated CO2 and O3

Litter decay dynamics of paper birch (Betula papyrifera) were assessed at the Aspen free‐air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) facility in northern Wisconsin, USA. Leaf litter was decomposed for 12 months under factorial combinations of 360 vs. 560 μL CO₂ L^?1, crossed with 36 vs. 55 nL O₃ L^?1. To differentiate between substrate quality and environment effects, litterbags were placed in their Native Plots of origin or transplanted into the other treatments. CO₂ enrichment, regardless of O₃ concentration, produced poorer quality litter (high C/N, lignin/N and condensed tannins) than did ambient CO₂ (low C/N, lignin/N and condensed tannins). Substrate quality differences were reflected in the mass loss rates (k‐values), which were high for litter generated under ambient CO₂ (0.887 year^?1) and low for litter generated under elevated CO₂ (0.674 year^?1). The rate‐retarding effects of CO₂ enrichment were neither alleviated nor exacerbated by O₃ exposure. Decay rates varied, however, depending on whether litter was placed back into its plot of origin or transplanted to Common Gardens. The results of this study are species specific, but they have important implications for understanding the processes regulating storage of fixed C and the release of CO₂ from northern forest ecosystems.     

Carbon gains by desiccation-tolerant plants at elevated CO2

1. There have been no reports of the long-term responses of the desiccation-tolerant (DT) plants to elevated CO₂. Xerophyta scabrida is a DT woody shrub, which loses chlorophylls and thylakoids during desiccation: a so-called poikilochlorophyllous desiccation-tolerant species (PDT). When the leaves of X. scabria are allowed to desiccate, the species shows many of the normal features of (P)DT plants.
2. However, the duration of photosynthesis in X. scabria is prolonged by 300% when the measurements are made at 700 as opposed to 350p.p.m. CO₂. The implication is that the carboxylating enzymes must still have been active at this time to enable appreciable photosynthetic activity. This response could have far-reaching implications for the success of such species in a future climate.
3. Lichens and mosses, representing the homoiochlorophyllous DTs (HDT), retain their chlorophyll content and photosynthetic apparatus during desiccation. We show the desiccation responses of two common HDT species ( Cladonia convoluta and Tortula ruralis ) to elevated CO₂ for comparison. Both HDT species showed increased net CO₂ uptake in the material grown at high CO₂ by more than 30% in moss and by more than 50% in lichen. It is concluded that desiccation-tolerant plants will be among the main beneficiaries of a high CO₂ future.     

Influence of elevated CO2 and O3 on Betula pendula Roth crown structure

Elevated CO(2) and ozone effects were studied singly and in combination on the crown structure of two Betula pendula clones. Measurements were made at the end of the second fumigation period in an open-top-chamber experiment with 9-year-old trees. Shoot ramification (number of long and short daughter shoots), shoot length, and number of metamers, leaves and buds were measured at four positions in every tree. As a result of increased temperature, trees in chambers had longer shoots and more frequent shoot ramification than control trees not enclosed in chambers. Ozone treatment decreased shoot ramification significantly. Additionally, ozone treatment resulted in an increased number of metamers in one clone. There was no statistically significant interaction between ozone effect and crown position; however, there was a slight tendency for the lower crown to be more affected by ozone. Elevated CO(2) caused a significant increase in the number of long-shoot metamers. Therefore, 2x ambient CO(2) concentration partly ameliorated the negative effect of ozone because the increased number of leaves per shoot counteracted the decreased branching. Although the main effects of elevated ozone and CO(2) were similar in the two clones, slight, statistically insignificant, differences appeared in their responses when interactions with crown position were considered.     

The effect of nitrogen source on photosynthesis of carob at high CO2 concentrations

Carob seedlings ( Ceratonia siliqua L. cv. Mulata), fed with nitrate or ammonium, were grown in growth chambers containing two levels of CO₂ (360 or 800 μl l⁻¹), three root temperatures (15, 20 or 25°C), and the same shoot temperature (20/24°C, night/day temperature). The response of the plants to CO₂ enrichment was affected by environmental factors such as the type of inorganic nitrogen in the medium and root temperature. Increasing root temperature enhanced photosynthesis rate more in the presence of nitrate than in the presence of ammonium. Differences in photosynthetic products were also observed between nitrate- and ammonium-fed carob seedlings. Nitrate-grown plants showed an enhanced content of sucrose, while ammonium led to enhanced storage of starch. Increase in root temperature caused an increase in dry mass of the plants of similar proportions in both nitrogen sources. The enhancement of the rates of photosynthesis by CO₂ enrichment was proportionally much larger than the resulting increases in dry mass production when nitrate was the nitrogen source. Ammonium was the preferred nitrogen source for carob at both ambient and high CO₂ concentrations. The level of photosynthesis of a plant is limited not only by atmospheric CO₂ concentration but also by the nutritional and environmental conditions of the root.     

N2 fixation by Acacia species increases under elevated atmospheric CO2

In the present study the effect of elevated CO₂ on growth and nitrogen fixation of seven Australian Acacia species was investigated. Two species from semi‐arid environments in central Australia (Acacia aneura and A. tetragonophylla) and five species from temperate south‐eastern Australia (Acacia irrorata, A. mearnsii, A. dealbata, A. implexa and A. melanoxylon) were grown for up to 148 d in controlled greenhouse conditions at either ambient (350 µmol mol^?1) or elevated (700 µmol mol^?1) CO₂ concentrations. After establishment of nodules, the plants were completely dependent on symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Six out of seven species had greater relative growth rates and lower whole plant nitrogen concentrations under elevated versus normal CO₂. Enhanced growth resulted in an increase in the amount of nitrogen fixed symbiotically for five of the species. In general, this was the consequence of lower whole‐plant nitrogen concentrations, which equate to a larger plant and greater nodule mass for a given amount of nitrogen. Since the average amount of nitrogen fixed per unit nodule mass was unaltered by atmospheric CO₂, more nitrogen could be fixed for a given amount of plant nitrogen. For three of the species, elevated CO₂ increased the rate of nitrogen fixation per unit nodule mass and time, but this was completely offset by a reduction in nodule mass per unit plant mass.