Membrane fluidity changes in goat sperm induced by cholesterol depletion using beta-cyclodextrin

Cholesterol efflux from membranes promotes acrosome reaction in goat spermatozoa. In 1 h of incubation of sperm in the presence of beta-cyclodextrin (βCD), all the interchangeable cholesterol is desorbed from sperm membranes, although acrosome reaction is fully accomplished only after 3-4 h of incubation, as previously published. In the present paper we investigate the effect of cholesterol removal from mature goat spermatozoa on the overall membrane “fluidity” of live cell membranes and of liposomes from sperm lipid extracts. Using steady state fluorescence anisotropy of 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH), we studied the average thermotropic behaviour of membrane lipids, after incubation of live sperm for 1 h in BSA-free medium with the presence/absence of 8 mM β-cyclodextrin, as a cholesterol acceptor. Unimodal and bimodal theoretical sigmoids fitted best to the experimental thermotropic profiles of liposomes and whole cells, respectively. In the case of whole sperm, two phase transitions, attributable to different lipid domains, were clearly separated by using the fitting parameters. After cholesterol removal, important changes in the relative anisotropy range of the two transitions were found, indicating an increase in the “fluidity” of some of the lipid microdomains of sperm membranes. These changes in sperm lipid dynamics are produced before the onset of sperm acrosome reaction.     

Comparison of two commercial extenders for cryopreservation of goat semen without sperm washing

The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of two commercially available semen extenders on the motility of cryopreserved goat sperm and to simplify the cryopreservation protocol. Individual goat ejaculates were split and processed in parallel for freezing in either commercially available soy-based extender (Bioxcell®) or egg yolk-based extender (Irvine TYB). Sperm quality was assessed using total and progressive sperm motility, measured by computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA). Total motility was higher for samples processed in soy-based extender, both at pre-freeze (P = 0.002) and at post-thaw (P < 0.0001). Progressive motility was higher for semen processed in soy extender at post-thaw (P < 0.0001). Approximately 10% of samples processed in egg yolk-based extender had a large (> 50%) reduction in total motility prior to freezing. However, this type of extreme reduction in pre-freeze motility did not occur in semen samples processed in soy extender. In addition, the use of soy-based extender eliminated the need for a time-consuming sperm washing protocol. We concluded that a commercially available soy-based extender was superior to an egg yolk-based extender in preserving motility of cryopreserved goat sperm, using a two-step method.     

Quantitative phosphoproteomics reveals GSK3A substrate network is involved in the cryodamage of sperm motility

During sperm cryopreservation, the most significant phenotype of cryodamage is the decrease in sperm motility. Several proteomics studies have already been performed to search for key regulators at the protein level. However, sperm functions are known to be highly regulated by phosphorylation signaling. Here, we constructed a quantitative phosphoproteome to investigate the expression change of phosphorylated sites during sperm cryopreservation. A total of 3107 phosphorylated sites are identified and 848 of them are found to be significantly differentially expressed (DE). Bioinformatics analysis showed that the corresponding genes of these regulated sites are highly associated with sperm motility, providing a connection between the molecular basis and the phenotype of cryodamage. We then performed kinase enrichment analysis and successfully identified glycogen synthase kinase-3α (GSK3A) as the key kinase that may play an important role in the regulation of sperm motility. We further constructed a GSK3A centric network that could help us better understand the molecular mechanism of cryodamage in sperm motility. Finally, we also verified that GSK3A was abnormally activated during this process. The presented phosphoproteome and functional associations provide abundant research resources for us to learn the regulation of sperm functions, as well as to optimize the cryoprotectant for sperm cryopreservation.     

Effect of incubation temperature after devitrification on quality parameters in human sperm cells

Sperm cryopreservation is common in assisted reproduction laboratories, providing a therapeutic option for several clinical conditions. This process has been optimized; however, the effect of post-thaw incubation temperature has been poorly studied. This work analyzed the effect of incubation temperature after devitrification on human sperm quality. Spermatozoa from normozoospermic donors were cryopreserved by vitrification. After devitrification, the spermatozoa were separated into two aliquots: (i) incubated at room temperature (RT, 22-25 °C) and (ii) incubated at 37 °C. Reactive oxygen species (ROS), viability, mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨM), phosphatidylserine externalization and motility were analyzed immediately after devitrification (control) and after 2, 4 and 6 h. Spermatozoa incubated at RT showed a conserved viability and ΔΨM compared to the control, while the incubation at 37 °C promoted a decrease in these parameters. The ROS levels were increased at both incubation conditions. The progressive motility was decreased in all experimental groups and the decrease was more pronounced under incubation at RT. No increase in phosphatidylserine externalization was observed. In conclusion, prior to use in assisted reproduction procedures, devitrified spermatozoa at RT conserve a better viability and ΔΨM than at 37 °C.     

Shedding off specific lipid constituents from sperm cell membrane during cryopreservation

Membrane damage is one of the main reasons for reduced motility and fertility of sperm cells during cryopreservation. Using a model system of sperm cryopreservation developed in our laboratory, we have investigated the detailed changes due to cryopreservation in the plasma membrane lipid composition of the goat epididymal sperm cells. Total lipid and its components, i.e., neutral lipids, glycolipids and phospholipids decreased significantly after cryopreservation. Among neutral lipids sterols, steryl esters and 1-O-alkyl-2,3-diacyl glycerols decreased appreciably, while among phospholipids, major loss was observed for phosphatidyl choline and phosphatidyl ethanolamine. Unsaturated fatty acids bound to the phospholipids diminished while the percentage of saturated acids increased. The cholesterol:phospholipid ratio enhanced and the amount of hydrocarbon, which was unusually high, increased further on cryopreservation. The data indicates that profound increase of the hydrophobicity of the cell membrane is one of the major mechanisms by which spermatozoa acquire potential to resist or combat stress factors like cryodamage. The results are compatible with the view that for survival against cryodamage, sperm cells modulate the structure of their outer membrane by shedding off preferentially some hydrophilic lipid constituents of the cell membrane.     

Cryopreservation of Plagiognathops microlepis sperm

Sperm was collected from cultured male fish and cryopreserved in 0.25 ml straws for the study of sperm cryopreservation. Different parameters were evaluated, including extender, dilution ratio, cryoprotectant type and concentration, equilibrium time, cooling height (in a two-step cooling protocol), and thawing temperature. The optimum result was obtained when the sperm was diluted at a 1:7 ratio in D-16 with 5% DMSO as a cryoprotectant, equilibrated for 20 min, held at 3 cm above liquid nitrogen for 10 min, and then stored in liquid nitrogen. After thawing in a water bath at 40 °C, the percentage of motile cells and fertilization rates of frozen-thawed sperm were 35.33 ± 2.52% and 39.00 ± 4.58%, respectively, while the corresponding rates for fresh sperm were 87.67 ± 3.06% and 88.67 ± 4.62%. We also used a programmed cooling protocol in which temperature was decreased from 4 °C to −80 °C by a rate of 30 °C/min, and then straws (0.25 ml) were placed above the surface of liquid nitrogen for 2 min before being stored in liquid nitrogen. This protocol provided a post-thaw activation rate of 36.67 ± 4.77%. Further parametric optimization is required to improve the quality of frozen-thawed sperm.     

Supplementation of sperm cryopreservation media with cell permeable superoxide dismutase mimetic agent (MnTE) improves goat blastocyst formation

The aim of this study was to assess whether a cell permeable superoxide dismutase agent such as MnTE, can further improve the quality of frozen/thawed semen sample using a commercially optimized sperm cryopreservation media (Bioxcell). Bioxcell was supplemented with different concentration of MnTE. Sperm membrane integrity, motility, viability and acrosomal status were assessed after freezing. Optimized concentration of MnTE was defined and used to assess fertilization and developmental potential. 0.1 μM MnTE significantly improved membrane integrity while 0.01 μM MnTE significantly improved acrosomal integrity post thawing. Addition of 0.01 μM MnTE also improved blastocyst formation rate. Supplementation of commercially optimized cryopreservation media with MnTE further improves the quality of goat frozen semen sample and may have important consequence of future embryo development. This effect may be attributed to cell permeable behavior of this antioxidant which may protect sperm genome from ROS-induced DNA damage.     

Supplementation of sperm cryopreservation media with cell permeable superoxide dismutase mimetic agent (MnTE) improves goat blastocyst formation

The aim of this study was to assess whether a cell permeable superoxide dismutase agent such as MnTE, can further improve the quality of frozen/thawed semen sample using a commercially optimized sperm cryopreservation media (Bioxcell). Bioxcell was supplemented with different concentration of MnTE. Sperm membrane integrity, motility, viability and acrosomal status were assessed after freezing. Optimized concentration of MnTE was defined and used to assess fertilization and developmental potential. 0.1 μM MnTE significantly improved membrane integrity while 0.01 μM MnTE significantly improved acrosomal integrity post thawing. Addition of 0.01 μM MnTE also improved blastocyst formation rate. Supplementation of commercially optimized cryopreservation media with MnTE further improves the quality of goat frozen semen sample and may have important consequence of future embryo development. This effect may be attributed to cell permeable behavior of this antioxidant which may protect sperm genome from ROS-induced DNA damage.     

Evaluation of oxidative DNA damage promoted by storage in sperm from sex-reversed rainbow trout

Short-term storage and cryopreservation of sperm are two common procedures in aquaculture, used for routine practices in artificial insemination reproduction and gene banking, respectively. Nevertheless, both procedures cause injuries affecting sperm motility, viability, cell structure and DNA stability, which diminish reproductive success. DNA modification is considered extremely important, especially when sperm storage is carried out with gene banking purposes. DNA damage caused by sperm storage is not well characterized and previous studies have reported simple and double strand breaks that have been attributed to oxidative events promoted by the generation of free radicals during storage.The objective of this study was to reveal DNA fragmentation and to explore the presence of oxidized bases that could be produced by oxidative events during short-term storage and cryopreservation in sex-reversed rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) spermatozoa. Sperm from six males was analyzed separately. Different aliquots of the samples were stored 2 h (fresh) or 5 days at 4 °C or were cryopreserved. Then spermatozoa were analyzed using the Comet assay, as well as combining this method with digestion with two endonucleases from Escherichia coli (Endonuclease III, that cut in oxidized cytosines, and FPG, cutting in oxidized guanosines). Both storage procedures yielded DNA fragmentation, but only short-term storage oxidative events were clearly detected, showing that oxidative processes affect guanosines rather than cytosines. Cryopreservation increases DNA fragmentation but the presence of oxidized bases was not noticed, suggesting that mechanisms other than oxidative stress could be involved in DNA fragmentation promoted by freezing.     

Effect of testicle postmortem storage on goat frozen-thawed epididymal sperm quality as a tool to improve genebanking in local breeds

The interest to develop assisted reproductive technologies and cryobanking for farm animal genetic resource conservation has recently increased. However, cryopreservation for ex-situ management of genetic diversity sometimes is not routinely feasible, owing to the lack of facilities (AI centres, laboratories) and expertise near the local breed farming area. In these cases, epididymal sperm obtained from slaughtered or castrated animals, associated with the possibility of managing rather long periods between animal death, sperm recovery and freezing, would increase the opportunities to create semen storages. This investigation addresses the pre-freeze/post-thaw quality of goat epididymal sperm as a function of testicle storage temperature (environment or +5°C) and time elapsed between animal’s death and sperm recovery (0, 24, 48, 72 h) to establish the optimal protocols for the recovery and cryopreservation of epididymal sperm in this species. Testicles of 50 mature bucks collected at the abattoir were divided in two groups: half of the testicles (n=50) were transported to the laboratory at environment temperature (E), whereas the remaining half (n=50) at a refrigeration temperature (R) of +5°C. In the two groups (E) and (R), one testicle from each pair was processed after slaughter forming the time 0 groups (0E and 0R). The contralateral testicle was processed after 24, 48 or 72 h of storage, at the corresponding temperature. Sperm motility and kinetic parameters, viability and morphology were assessed in pre-freeze and post-thaw samples. Until 48 h postmortem, both E and R temperatures are able to maintain good pre-freeze epididymal sperm quality. After 48 h postmortem, R temperature is fundamental to reduce epididymal sperm quality decay in pre-freeze samples. Moreover, testicle refrigeration also has a positive impact on post-thaw samples, allowing a lower decline through time considering total motility, kinetics parameters, sperm viability and sperm abnormalities. Therefore, when sperm cryopreservation is not immediately practicable, goat testicles should be transported and stored at 5°C up to a maximum of 48 h postmortem to ensure an acceptable sperm quality.     

Lipid phase transition in the plasma membrane of the goat epididymal maturing spermatozoa

Microviscosity of the highly purified plasma membranes isolated from the maturing goat caput, corpus and cauda epididymal sperm, was measured using l,6-diphenyl-l,3,5-hexatriene as the lipophilic probe at varying temperatures (12–42°C). As shown by the Arrhenius plot of the data each of the maturing sperm membranes had two distinct lipid phase transitions in the temperature zones 19–25°C and 34–37°C. The low-temperature transitions for the immature caput- and mature cauda-sperm membranes were noted at 19–20°C, and 24–25°C, respectively, whereas both these membranes showed high temperature transition at 36–37°C. The maturing corpus-sperm membrane had phase transitions at 21–22°C and 35–36°C that were significantly different from those of the immature/mature sperm membranes. The data implicate significant alteration of the sperm membrane structure during epididymal maturation. The phase transition of the mature male gametes at 36–37°C may have a great impact on the subsequent events of the sperm life cycle since the mature spermatozoa that are stored in the epididymis a few degrees below the body temperature, experience higher temperature when ejaculated into the female reproductive tract.     

Specific features of in vivo and in vitro sperm storage in birds

This review focuses on some of the main features of sperm selection and storage in birds mainly on the basis of studies performed in poultry species, with emphasis on the initial selection of sperm at the female vagina level prior to migration towards the sperm storage tubules. Sperm originating from low-quality males or subjected to inappropriate in vitro storage conditions are rapidly discarded, resulting in impaired fertility in corresponding flocks. In the absence of accessible and appropriate technology for matching the 'storing' potential of sperm in the oviduct, conditions for prolonged sperm storage under a liquid (through the use of semen extenders) or a solid state (cryopreservation) have received only limited attention, despite their potential interest to facilitate male and female management in poultry flocks. Despite this, technology for short-term liquid storage is currently used in turkeys, guinea fowl and muscovy ducks and also in progress in chickens. In addition, technology for cryopreservation of avian semen has become available for some species (chicken, goose) to facilitate the management of genetic resources, including the preservation of rare and economically important breeds.     

Application of sperm sorting and associated reproductive technology for wildlife management and conservation

Efforts toward the conservation and captive breeding of wildlife can be enhanced by sperm sorting and associated reproductive technologies such as sperm cryopreservation and artificial insemination (AI). Sex ratio management is of particular significance to species which naturally exist in female-dominated social groups. A bias of the sex ratio towards females of these species will greatly assist in maintaining socially cohesive groups and minimizing male-male aggression. Another application of this technology potentially exists for endangered species, as the preferential production of females can enable propagation of those species at a faster rate. The particular assisted reproductive technology (ART) used in conjunction with sperm sorting for the production of offspring is largely determined by the quality and quantity of spermatozoa following sorting and preservation processes. Regardless of the ART selected, breeding decisions involving sex-sorted spermatozoa should be made in conjunction with appropriate genetic management. Zoological-based research on reproductive physiology and assisted reproduction, including sperm sorting, is being conducted on numerous terrestrial and marine mammals. The wildlife species for which the technology has undergone the most advance is the bottlenose dolphin. AI using sex-sorted fresh or frozen-thawed spermatozoa has become a valuable tool for the genetic and reproductive management of captive bottlenose dolphins with six pre-sexed calves, all of the predetermined sex born to date.     

Mouse ICSI with frozen-thawed sperm: the impact of sperm freezing procedure and sperm donor strain

Normal mouse offspring can be obtained from oocytes injected with frozen-thawed spermatozoa without cryoprotection, however, embryo development can be affected by sperm freezing procedure and sperm donor strain. In this study we observed that direct contact of mouse spermatozoa with liquid nitrogen did not affect their ability to activate injected oocytes but severely restricted subsequent in vitro embryo development to blastocyst stage. Tris-EDTA buffer and M2 were also shown to be better sperm freezing extenders than DPBS, allowing higher developmental potential. In addition, differences in embryo development obtained by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) with frozen-thawed spermatozoa were observed between hybrid sperm donor strains. Frozen-thawed B6D2F1 spermatozoa provided higher embryo development than sperm cells from C57CBAF1.     

Effect of cryopreservation on the frequency of chromosomal abnormalities and sex ratio in human sperm

The effects of cryopreservation on the frequency and type of chromosomal abnormalities in human sperm were investigated. Employing a technique that enables direct visualization of human sperm chromosomes following in vitro penetration of hamster oocytes, sperm samples from 10 normal men were examined before and after freezing in liquid nitrogen. A total of 1,960 sperm karyotypes were analyzed, 1,132 before freezing and 828 after freezing. There was no significant difference in the frequency of structural chromosomal anomalies (10.5% prefreeze vs. 8.5% postfreeze), but there was a significant decrease in the frequency of numerical abnormalities (5.2% prefreeze vs. 3.0% postfreeze). However, there was a large excess of hypohaploid complements compared with hyperhaploid complements, suggesting that the hypohaploid complements were caused by technical artefact. A conservative estimate of aneuploidy, derived by doubling the hyperhaploid frequencies, did not differ before (0.4%) and after (0.4%) freezing. There was no evidence for interdonor variability in response to sperm cryopreservation for total chromosomal abnormalities, structural abnormalities, and sex ratios. The sex ratios were also not affected by cryopreservation and did not differ significantly from the theoretical 50%. It is concluded that cryopreservation does not affect the frequencies of chromosomal abnormalities or alter the sex ratio in human sperm, provided that an adequate cryoprotective buffer and freezing system is employed.     

Comparison of two different cryopreservation protocols for freezing goat semen

In this study, two different semen cryopreservation protocols were compared to freeze goat semen. The ejaculates (n = 12) were collected by using electro-ejaculator from six mature bucks (two ejaculates per each buck). Each ejaculate was divided into two groups as Protocol 1 (P1) and Protocol 2 (P2). In P1, semen was diluted directly in an extender containing 15% egg yolk, 300 mM Tris, 28 mM glucose, 95 mM citric acid 5% glycerol to a concentration of 200 × 10⁶ sperm/mL. In P2, after the removal of seminal plasma by centrifugation, the semen sample was diluted with the first portion of milk extender consist of 100 mg/mL skimmed milk powder and 27.75 mM glucose (without glycerol) to a concentration of 400 × 10⁶ sperm/mL. The second portion of the milk extender containing 14% glycerol was added to semen gradually in order to achieve sperm concentration 200 × 10⁶ sperm/mL and 7% glycerol level in the final volume. Extended semen was loaded in 0.25 mL straws, held for 2 h at 4 °C, frozen in nitrogen vapor and stored in liquid nitrogen. Post-thaw motility and live sperm rate (mean ± SEM) were significantly lower (P < 0.05) in P1 as compared to P2 (47.50 ± 1.23% vs. 55.63 ± 1.72%; 80.04 ± 1.29% vs. 84.04 ± 1.08%, respectively). However, live intact, total intact, abnormal, reacted acrosome and DNA damaged sperm rates were similar (P > 0.05) in both protocols. It was concluded that both protocols used in this study provided reasonable post-thaw parameters; however, P2 yielded better motility and live sperm rate compared to P1.     

Proteomic characteristics of human sperm cryopreservation

Human sperm cryopreservation in assisted reproductive technology is the only proven method that enables infertile men to father their own children. However, freezing and thawing reduces spermatozoon motility, viability, and fertilizing ability. An association between dysfunctional spermatozoa due to cryoinjury and protein changes has not been established. We investigated through proteomic analysis the differential protein characteristics between freeze‐thawed and fresh sperm samples obtained from nine normozoospermic donors. Twenty‐seven proteins differed in abundance between the two groups, and results were verified for four proteins via Western blot and immunofluorescent staining. These proteins are putatively involved in sperm motility, viability, acrosomal integrity, ATP and isocitrate content, mitochondrial membrane potential, capacitation, acrosome reaction, and intracellular calcium concentration. These marked differences suggest that dysfunctional spermatozoon after cryopreservation may be due to protein degradation and protein phosphorylation.     

The effects of cryopreservation on the acrosome structure,enzyme activity,motility, and fertility of bovine,ovine, and goat sperm

The study was designed to investigate the effects of cryopreservation on bovine, ovine, and goat sperm motility, acrosome structure, enzyme activity, and fertilization ability. Percentage of sperm with hyaluronidase enzyme (HYD) activity was detected by a modified sodium hyaluronate-gelatin membrane. The N-α-benzoyl-DL-arginine-p-nitroanilide (BNPNA) method was used to assess the sperm acrosome enzyme (ACE). The mean percentage of sperm acrosome integrity dropped significantly (P < 0.01) after cryopreservation. The ACE activity of bovine sperm (100.48) was higher (P < 0.01) than that of ovine (57.88) or goat sperm (50.30), while the percentage of sperm with HYD activity of bovine (71.10%) and ovine (67.60%) sperm was higher than that of goat sperm (58.52%) after cryopreservation (P < 0.01). Sperm motility was positively correlated with the activity of the two acrosome enzymes before and after cryopreservation (P < 0.01). Cryopreservation had a negative effect on acrosomal morphology, motility, and acrosomal enzyme activity in their sperm. The fertilization ability of ovine and goat sperm decreased significantly after cryopreservation, but that of frozen bovine sperm did not differ significantly when compared with fresh sperm. There was no significant difference between ovine and goat sperm indices, except for percentage of sperm with HYD activity.     

Numbers and size of sperm storage tubules and the duration of sperm storage in birds: a comparative study

Estimates of the numbers of sperm storage tubules (SSTs) in the utero-vaginal junction of 11 bird species are presented. Numbers of SSTs varied by a factor of 40 between species, and ranged from 500 to 20000. Body mass accounted for over 50% of the variation in SST mumbers. SST length was positively correlated with the length of spermatozoa across species. The duration of sperm storage was not correlated with the number of SSTs or the volume of sperm storage tissue. However, the number of 'active' SSTs appears to vary between species and it was not possible to make allowance for this. Sperm storage duration was weakly, positively correlated wth clutch size, but showed a significant positive relationship with the number of days over which laying occurred. The number of SSTs was also positively correlated with the number of sperm per ejaculate. The best predictor of sperm storage duration was a multiple regression equation using the spread of laying and the length of sperm storage tubules. The duration of sperm storage in birds which remain together during the pre-laying period is such that a single insemination immediately before the start of laying could fertilize the entire clutch.     

Production of channel catfish with sperm cryopreserved by rapid non-equilibrium cooling

This report describes the feasibility of using vitrification for fish sperm. Vitrification can be used to preserve samples in the field and offers an alternative to conventional cryopreservation, although it has not been systematically studied for sperm of aquatic species. The overall goal of the project was to develop streamlined protocols that could be integrated into a standardized approach for vitrification of aquatic species germplasm. The objectives of the present study in channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) were to: (1) evaluate the acute toxicity of 5%, 10%, 20% and 30% methanol, N,N-dimethyl acetamide, dimethyl sulfoxide, 1,2-propanediol, and methyl glycol; (2) evaluate a range of devices commonly used for cryopreservation and vitrification of mammalian sperm; (3) compare vitrification with and without cryoprotectants; (4) evaluate the post-thaw membrane integrity of sperm vitrified in different cryoprotectant solutions, and (5) evaluate the ability of vitrified sperm to fertilize eggs. Cryoprotectant concentrations of higher than 20% were found to be toxic to sperm. Methanol and methyl glycol were the least toxic at a concentration of 20% with an exposure time of less than 5 min. We evaluated a method reported for human sperm, using small volumes in loops (15 μl) or cut standard straws (20 μl) with and without cryoprotectants plunged into liquid nitrogen. Cryoprotectant-free vitrification using loops did not yield fertilization (assessed by neurulation), and the fertilization rates observed in two trials using the cut standard straws were low (∼2%). In general, fertilization values for vitrification experiments were low and the use of low concentrations of cryoprotectants yielded lower fertilization (<10%) than the use of vitrification solutions containing high cryoprotectant concentrations (as high as 25%). The highest neurulation obtained was from a mixture of three cryoprotectants (20% methanol + 10% methyl glycol + 10% propanediol) with a single-step addition. This was reflected in the flow cytometry data from which the highest membrane integrity using loops was for 20% methanol + 10% methyl glycol + 10% propanediol (∼50%). We report the first successful sperm vitrification in fish and production of offspring from vitrified sperm in channel catfish. Although the fertilization values were low, at present this technique could nevertheless be used to reconstitute lines (especially in small aquarium fishes), but it would require improvement and scaling up before being useful as a production method for large-bodied fishes such as catfish.