Quantification and identification of sperm subpopulations using computer-aided sperm analysis and species-specific cut-off values for swimming speed

Abstract

Motility is an essential characteristic of all flagellated spermatozoa and assessment of this parameter is one criterion for most semen or sperm evaluations. Computer-aided sperm analysis (CASA) can be used to measure sperm motility more objectively and accurately than manual methods, provided that analysis techniques are standardized. Previous studies have shown that evaluation of sperm subpopulations is more important than analyzing the total motile sperm population alone. We developed a quantitative method to determine cut-off values for swimming speed to identify three sperm subpopulations. We used the Sperm Class Analyzer^® (SCA) CASA system to assess the total percentage of motile spermatozoa in a sperm preparation as well as the percentages of rapid, medium and slow swimming spermatozoa for six mammalian species. Curvilinear velocity (VCL) cut-off values were adjusted manually for each species to include 80% rapid, 15% medium and 5% slow swimming spermatozoa. Our results indicate that the same VCL intervals cannot be used for all species to classify spermatozoa according to swimming speed. After VCL intervals were adjusted for each species, three unique sperm subpopulations could be identified. The effects of medical treatments on sperm motility become apparent in changes in the distribution of spermatozoa among the three swimming speed classes.     

Identification of sperm subpopulations with defined motility characteristics in ejaculates from Florida goats

The aims of this study were to test the presence of discrete sperm subpopulations in Florida goat ejaculates using a computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) system and to establish the relationship between the distribution of the subpopulations found and individual buck, total motility, and sperm concentration. Clustering methods and discriminant analysis were applied to identify motile sperm subpopulations within the semen samples. Principal component analysis revealed that three principal components represented more than the 88% of the variance. After the cluster analysis was performed four motile sperm subpopulations were identified. Subpopulation 1 consisted of rapid and linear sperm (39.84%), Subpopulation 2 consisted of slow but linear spermatozoa (33.23%), Subpopulation 3 consisted of rapid, high ALH but non-linear spermatozoa (14.63%), and Subpopulation 4 consisted of slow and non-linear spermatozoa (12.31%). There were significant differences in the distribution of the four subpopulations (P < 0.001) as well as in the percentage of total motility and the overall sperm concentration (P < 0.05) in fresh ejaculates among the four bucks tested. In conclusion, four well-defined motile sperm subpopulations were identified in Florida goat ejaculates. The relationship between the distribution of the sperm subpopulations and individual buck, total motility, and sperm concentration shows that the spermatozoa of each have different motility patterns. Therefore, the study of discrete subpopulations of motile spermatozoa could lead to a substantial increase in information acquired during caprine semen analysis.     

Sperm quality evaluation in Solea senegalensis during the reproductive season at cellular level

Sperm quality seems to be one of the reasons for the reproduction constraints faced by Senegalese sole (Solea senegalensis) aquaculturists. Previous studies in this species indicated that the sperm quality of individuals kept in culture varies throughout the year and that different sperm subpopulations can be identified in ejaculates according to the motility pattern of spermatozoa. Aiming to better understand factors affecting sole sperm quality in captivity, sperm of 11 males was assessed during the reproductive season using different parameters: motility characteristics using CASA analysis; cell plasma membrane resistance to seawater hyperosmolarity; DNA fragmentation with single-cell gel electrophoresis; and early apoptosis, labeled with Annexin-V FITC. Computer-assisted sperm analyses motility data were treated using multivariate analysis to identify the presence of different spermatozoa subpopulations according to their motility pattern. Four distinct sperm subpopulations were obtained: Subpop1, which includes fast linear spermatozoa; Subpop2, made up of fast nonlinear spermatozoa; Subpop3, which includes slow linear spermatozoa; and Subpop4, which contains slow nonlinear spermatozoa. The sperm subpopulation structure varied with time after activation and with male. Low cell resistance to the seawater hyperosmotic conditions was noticed. The Annexin-V assay allowed the identification of an apoptotic population ranging from 6% to 20%. A high percentage of cells (64.1%) showed a DNA fragmentation level below 30%, but these values varied significantly between males. DNA fragmentation appears to be related to cell membrane resistance to hyperosmotic conditions faced by the cells when in contact with seawater. This condition seems to modulate the composition of the motile sperm population and performance after activation. This phenomenon could be related to the spermatozoa maturation process.     

Changes in the structures of motile sperm subpopulations in dog spermatozoa after both cryopreservation and centrifugation on PureSperm(®) gradient

The aims of the present study were to: (1) determine if discrete motile sperm subpopulations exist and their incidence in fresh dog ejaculates, (2) evaluate the effects of cryopreservation on the distribution of spermatozoa within the different subpopulations, and (3) determine the effect of the discontinuous PureSperm(?) gradient on the sperm subpopulation structure of frozen-thawed dog spermatozoa. Semen from 5 dogs were collected and cryopreserved following a standard protocol. After thawing, semen samples were selected by centrifugation on PureSperm(?). Sperm motility (assessed by computerized-assisted semen analysis, CASA) was assessed before freezing, just after thawing and after preparation on the PureSperm(?) gradients. Cryopreservation had a significant (P<0.001) effect on CASA-derived parameters. PureSperm(?) centrifugation yielded sperm suspensions with improved motility (P<0.01). A multivariate clustering procedure separated 19414 motile spermatozoa into four subpopulations: Subpopulation 1 consisting of poorly active and non-progressive spermatozoa (20.97%), Subpopulation 2 consisting of slow and low-linear spermatozoa (18.24%), Subpopulation 3 consisting of highly active but non-progressive spermatozoa (20.75%), and Subpopulation 4 consisting of high speed and progressive spermatozoa (40.03%). Although, cryopreservation had a significant (P<0.001) effect on both the frequency distribution of spermatozoa within subpopulations and the motion characteristics of each subpopulation, the sperm subpopulation structure was perfectly maintained after freezing and thawing. The selected sperm samples was enrich in Subpopulation 4, reaching a proportion of 31.9% of the present spermatozoa, in contrast with the unselected sperm samples, where this sperm subpopulation accounted for 24.9% of the total. From these results, we concluded that four well-defined motile sperm subpopulations were present either in fresh semen, in unselected sperm samples or in selected preparations from dogs. The discontinuous PureSperm(?) gradient is a simple method to improve the quality of canine frozen-thawed semen samples, since Subpopulation 4 (high-speed and progressive spermatozoa) was more frequently observed after preparation on the gradient. Finally, this study also demonstrated that the general motile sperm structure present in dog remains constant despite the effect caused by either cryopreservation or separation on PureSperm(?) gradient.     

Effect of cryopreservation on fish sperm subpopulations

The evaluation of the motility data obtained with a CASA system, applying a Two-Step Cluster analysis, identified in seabream sperm 3 different sperm subpopulations that correlated differently with embryo hatching rates. Hence, we designed an experiment to understand the effect of the application of different cryopreservation protocols in these sperm motility-based subpopulations. We analyzed Sparus aurata frozen/thawed semen motility 15, 30, 45 and 60 s after activation, using CASA software. Different protocols were applied for cryopreservation: three different cryoprotectants (Dimethyl Sulfoxide (Me₂SO), Ethylene Glycol (EG) and Propylene Glycol (PG)) each at two different concentrations and two packaging volumes (0.5 ml straws, and 1.8 ml cryovials) were tested. Different freezing rates were evaluated corresponding to 1, 2, 3, 4 and 8 cm above the liquid nitrogen surface for the straws and 1, 2 and 4 cm for the cryovials. Motility parameters rendered by CASA were treated with a Two-Step Cluster analysis. Three different subpopulations were obtained: SP1 – slow non-linear spermatozoa, SP2 – slow linear spermatozoa and SP3 – fast linear spermatozoa. We considered SP3 as the subpopulation of interest and focused further analyses on it. Generally, SP3 was the best represented subpopulation 15 s after activation and was also the one showing a greater decrease in time, being the least represented after 60 s. According to the applied univariate general linear model, samples frozen in straws with 5% Me₂SO and in cryovials with 10% Me₂SO at 2 and 1 cm from the LN_2, respectively, produced the best results (closer to the control). Clustering analysis allowed the detection of fish sperm subpopulations according to their motility pattern and showed that sperm composition in terms of subpopulations was differentially affected by the cryopreservation protocol depending on the cryoprotectant used, freezing rates and packaging systems.     

Identification of sperm subpopulations with defined motility characteristics in ejaculates from Holstein bulls: effects of cryopreservation and between-bull variation

The aims of the present study were: (1) to determine the existence of sperm subpopulations with specific motility characteristics in fresh ejaculates from Holstein bulls, (2) to investigate the effects of semen cryopreservation and post-thaw incubation on the distribution of spermatozoa within the different subpopulations, and (3) to evaluate the existence of between-bull variation in the sperm subpopulations structure of fresh and frozen-thawed semen. Six ejaculates were collected from each of 9 Holstein bulls and cryopreserved following a standard protocol. Overall sperm motility and the individual kinematic parameters of motile spermatozoa, determined using a CASA system, were evaluated before freezing and after 0, 2 and 4h of post-thaw incubation at 37 degrees C. Data from 16,740 motile spermatozoa, defined by VCL, VSL, VAP, LIN, STR, WOB, ALH and BCF, were analysed using a multivariate clustering procedure to identify and quantify specific subpopulations within the semen samples. The statistical analysis clustered all the motile spermatozoa into four separate subpopulations with defined patters of movement: Subpopulation (Subp. 1) moderately slow but progressive spermatozoa (23.2%), (Subp. 2) highly active but non-progressive spermatozoa (16.0%), (Subp. 3) poorly motile non-progressive sperm (35.5%), and (Subp. 4) highly active and progressive sperm (25.3%). Subpopulations 2 and 4 significantly (P<0.01) decreased during cryopreservation and post-thaw incubation (Subp. 2: 21.1%, 18.1%, 8.7% and 5.9%; and Subp. 4: 34.1%, 20.6%, 15.2% and 7.3%, respectively, for fresh, 0, 2 and 4h post-thaw) whereas Subp. 3 significantly (P<0.01) increased (10.7%, 27.2%, 27.2% and 30.7%, respectively, for fresh, 0, 2 and 4h post-thaw). The frequency distribution of spermatozoa within subpopulations was quite similar for the 9 bulls, either in fresh or frozen-thawed semen, and differences among bulls were mainly due to differences in the Subp. 4. Significant correlations (P<0.01) were found between the proportions of spermatozoa assigned to Subp. 4 in the fresh ejaculates and those in frozen-thawed semen after 0 (r=0.473), 2 (r=0.513) and 4h post-thaw (r=0.450). This indicated that the ejaculates with the highest subpopulations of rapid and progressive sperm were also the most resistant to cryopreservation and showed the best post-thaw sperm longevity.     

Identification of sperm subpopulations with defined motility characteristics in ejaculates from Ile de France rams

The aims of this study were to identify different motile sperm subpopulations in fresh ejaculates from six Ile de France rams, by using a computer-assisted sperm motility analysis (CASA) system, and to evaluate the effects of individual ram and season on population distribution. Overall sperm motility and individual kinematic parameters of motile spermatozoa were evaluated for 125,312 spermatozoa, defined by curvilinear velocity (VCL), linear velocity (VSL), average path velocity (VAP), linearity coefficient (LIN), straightness coefficient (STR), wobble coefficient (WOB), mean amplitude of lateral head displacement (ALH) and frequency of head displacement (BCF). A multivariate cluster analysis was carried out to classify these spermatozoa into a reduced number of subpopulations according to their movement patterns. The statistical analysis clustered the whole motile sperm population into five separate groups: subpopulation 1, constituted by rapid, progressive and non sinuous spermatozoa (VCL=126.41 μm/s, STR=92.87% and LIN=86.47%); subpopulation 2, characterized by progressive spermatozoa with moderate velocity (VCL=74.74 μm/s and STR=84.03%); subpopulation 3, represented by rapid, progressive and sinuous spermatozoa (VCL=130.45 μm/s, STR=76.02% and LIN=47.68%); subpopulation 4 represents rapid nonprogressive spermatozoa (VCL=128.69 μm/s and STR=44.09%); subpopulation 5 includes poorly motile, nonprogressive spermatozoa with a very irregular trajectory (VCL=36.81 μm/s and STR=47.04%). Our results show the existence of five subpopulations of motile spermatozoa in ram ejaculates. The frequency distribution of spermatozoa within subpopulations was quite similar for the six rams, and the five subpopulations turned out to be very stable along seasons.     

Changes in the motility patterns of spermatozoa from the rabbit epididymis as assessed by computer-aided sperm motion analysis

Sperm maturation in the epididymis includes changes in their potential for motility that enables spermatozoa to reach the egg and penetrate its investments. The motility characteristics of spermatozoa from the testis, the epididymis, and vas deferens of the rabbit were investigated by computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA). Various forms of motility were displayed by sperm from different regions of the epididymis released into incubation medium Testicular sperm were motile, although nonprogressive. The maximum percentage motility was expressed by sperm in the proximal cauda epididymidis, and forward progression was developed by spermatozoa from the distal caput. Once forward progression was established, the curvilinear velocity was about the same for sperm from all regions of the tract, whereas straight-line velocity increased between the mid-corpus and cauda and paralleled the decline in lateral displacement of the head. The maintenance of motility in vitro was best maintained by sperm from the distal regions of the tract although sperm from the distal caput maintained motility better than sperm from the proximal and midcorpus regions. Analysis of the motile sperm cells revealed several types of trajectories (“irregular,” “small circular,” “large circular and arcs,” “jagged” and “straight-line”) that were analyzed by discriminant analysis using the variables generated by CASA. Accuracy of classification varied from 70% to 96%, depending on the type of track. The classification function was then applied to the changes that occurred during incubation and showed that irregular trajectories gave way to small and then large circular tracks and progressive forms as sperm matured. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Taking advantage of the use of supervised learning methods for characterization of sperm population structure related with freezability in the Iberian red deer

Using Iberian red deer as a model, this study presents a supervised learning method, the Support Vector Machines (SVM), to characterize sperm population structure related with freezability. Male freezability was assessed by evaluating motility, membrane status and mitochondrial membrane potential of sperm after a freezing-thawing procedure. The SVM model was generated using sperm motility information captured by computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) from thawed semen, belonging to six stags with marked differences on their freezability. A total of 1369 sperm tracks were recorded for seven kinematic parameters and assigned to four motility patterns based on them: weak motile, progressive, transitional and hyperactivated-like. Then, these data were split in two sets: the training set, used to train the SVM model, and the testing set, used to examine how the SVM method and three other unsupervised methods, a non-hierarchical, a hierarchical and a multistep clustering procedures, performed the sperm classification into subpopulations. The SVM was revealed as the most accurate method in the characterization of sperm subpopulations, showing all the sperm subpopulations obtained in this way high significant correlations with those sperm parameters used to characterize freezability of males. Given its superiority, the SVM method was used to characterize the sperm motile subpopulations in Iberian red deer. Sperm motile data from frozen-thawed semen belonging to 25 stags were recorded and loaded into the SVM model. The sperm population structure revealed that those males showing poor freezability were characterized by high percentages of sperm with a weak motility pattern. In opposite, males showing good freezability were characterized by higher percentages of sperm with a progressive and hyperactivated-like motility pattern and lower percentages of sperm with a weak motile pattern. We also identified a sperm subpopulation with a transitional motility pattern. This subpopulation increased as the freezability of males improved, and may be used as indicative of overall sperm motility.     

Computer assisted sperm analysis of motility patterns of postthawed epididymal spermatozoa of springbok (Antidorcas marsupialis), impala (Aepyceros melampus), and blesbok (Damaliscus dorcus phillipsi) incubated under conditions supporting domestic cattle in vitro fertilization

The need for information on the reproductive physiology of different wildlife species is important for ex situ conservation using such methods as in vitro fertilization (IVF). Information on species reproductive physiology and evaluation of sperm quality using accurate, objective, repeatable methods, such as computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) for ex situ conservation has become a priority. The aim of this study was to evaluate motility patterns of antelope epididymal spermatozoa incubated for 4 h under conditions that support bovine IVF using CASA. Cauda epididymal spermatozoa were collected postmortem from testicles of springbok (N = 38), impala (N = 26), and blesbok (N = 42), and cryopreserved in biladyl containing 7% glycerol. Spermatozoa were thawed and incubated in Capacitation media and modified Tyrode lactate (m-TL) IVF media using a protocol developed for domestic cattle IVF. The study evaluates 14 motility characteristics of the antelope epididymal sperm at six time points using CASA. Species differences in CASA parameters evaluated under similar conditions were observed. Several differences in individual motility parameters at the time points were reported for each species. Epididymal sperm of the different antelope species responded differently to capacitation agents exhibiting variations in hyperactivity. Motility parameters that describe the vigor of sperm decreased over time. Spermatozoa from the different antelope species have different physiological and optimal capacitation and in vitro culture requirements. The interspecies comparison of kinematic parameters of spermatozoa between the antelopes over several end points contributes to comparative sperm physiology which forms an important step in the development of species specific assisted reproductive techniques (ARTs) for ex situ conservation of these species.     

Post mortem time and season alter subpopulation characteristics of Iberian red deer epididymal sperm

We have studied the effect of post mortem time and season on sperm subpopulation pattern and characteristics. We used epididymal samples from free-ranging Iberian red deers harvested during the hunting season. We studied samples at different moments of the year (rut, transition period and post-rut), and at different times post mortem (up to 4 days). Sperm were extracted from the cauda epididymis and their motility was evaluated by means of a CASA system. A principal component and clustering analysis were carried out to identify subpopulations. Post mortem time caused a significant decrease in motility quality, and a general deterioration in subpopulation characteristics. We found three subpopulations the first day, and the one indicating good sperm quality decreased with post mortem time until it disappeared on the fourth day. This may indicate considerable impairment of the samples after 72 h post mortem, which could compromise their use in AI programs. With regard to season, subpopulation pattern and characteristics were better in the transition and post-rut periods. Moreover, we found one subpopulation formed by mature spermatozoa, which increased from rut to post-rut. This might be a negative fact, because samples collected after the rut may undergo hypermaturation, which possibly impairs fertility. Our results are of interest for the management of wildlife germplasm banks based on post mortem sperm recovery.     

Comparison of two methods for obtaining spermatozoa from the cauda epididymis of Iberian red deer

We have compared two methods for salvaging epididymal sperm from post-mortem samples from Iberian red deer. Of each pair of testicles (29 samples), one cauda epididymis was processed by means of cuts (sperm was immediately diluted with extender) and the other was detached from the corpus and flushed from the vas deferens with 1 mL of extender. Sperm was processed for cryopreservation, and analyzed just after recovery, pre-freezing and post-thawing. Total spermatozoa recovered, contamination (concentration of epididymal cells and red blood cells (RBCs)) and quality (motility by CASA, and acrosomal status, viability and mitochondrial status by flow cytometry) were used to compare both methods. The number of recovered spermatozoa was similar for both methods. Contamination was higher for the cuts method, but when considering the final dilution before freezing, only RBCs concentration was significantly higher. Motility was similar just after extraction, but higher for both pre-frozen and post-thawed flushed sperm. Pre-freezing acrosomal status (P < 0.05) and viability (P < 0.1) were better for flushing; however post-thawing results were similar for the two methods. A clustering analysis using CASA data showed that the subpopulation pattern of motile sperm was different depending on the method, being better for flushing. With regard to yield, lower contamination (especially RBCs) and, in general, better quality results, flushing seems to be a more recommendable method for post-mortem sperm recovery. The cuts method may be more practical on certain occasions, but care must be taken in order to achieve rapid extension of the sample and to avoid contamination in order to improve sample condition.     

Acrosome staining and motility characteristics of sterlet spermatozoa after cryopreservation with use of methanol and DMSO

In this study we describe acrosome staining and motility characteristics of fresh and cryopreserved sterlet (Acipenser ruthenus L.) spermatozoa using soybean trypsin inhibitor-Alexa conjugate fluorescent staining and computer-aided sperm analysis (CASA), respectively. Methanol or dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) were used as cryoprotectants. After cryopreservation a decline in sperm motility characteristics occurred, but no differential effect between cryoprotectant was observed. Cryopreservation caused a significant increase in the percentage of spermatozoa with acrosome stained by SBTI-Alexa for samples cryopreserved using DMSO compared to methanol. These data suggest that the low usefulness of DMSO for cryopreservation of sturgeon spermatozoa is related to its harmful specific effect towards the acrosome, probably by causing its precocious triggering, much before any egg contact.     

Quality characteristics and fertilizing ability of ram sperm subpopulations separated by partition in an aqueous two-phase system

Centrifugal countercurrent distribution (CCCD) in an aqueous two-phase system (TPS) is a resolute technique revealing sperm heterogeneity and for the estimation of the fertilizing potential of a given semen sample. However, separated sperm subpopulations have never been tested for their fertilizing ability yet. Here, we have compared sperm quality parameters and the fertilizing ability of sperm subpopulations separated by the CCCD process from ram semen samples maintained at 20°C or cooled down to 5°C. Total and progressive sperm motility was evaluated by computer-assisted analysis using a CASA system and membrane integrity was evaluated by flow cytometry by staining with CFDA/PI. The capacitation state, staining with chlortetracycline, and apoptosis-related markers, such as phosphatidylserine (PS) translocation detected with Annexin V, and DNA damage detected by the TUNEL assay, were determined by fluorescence microscopy. Additionally, the fertilizing ability of the fractionated subpopulations was comparative assessed by zona binding assay (ZBA). CCCD analysis revealed that the number of spermatozoa displaying membrane and DNA alterations was higher in samples chilled at 5°C than at 20°C, which can be reflected in the displacement to the left of the CCCD profiles. The spermatozoa located in the central and right chambers (more hydrophobic) presented higher values (P<0.01) of membrane integrity, lower PS translocation (P<0.05) and DNA damage (P<0.001) than those in the left part of the profile, where apoptotic markers were significantly increased and the proportion of viable non-capacitated sperm was reduced. We have developed a new protocol to recover spermatozoa from the CCCD fractions and we proved that these differences were related with the fertilizing ability determined by ZBA, because we found that the number of spermatozoa attached per oocyte was significantly higher for spermatozoa recovered from the central and right chambers, in both types of samples. This is the first time, to our knowledge that sperm recovered from a two-phase partition procedure are used for fertilization assays. These results open up new possibilities for using specific subpopulations of sperm for artificial insemination or in vitro fertilization, not only regarding better sperm quality but also certain characteristics such as subpopulations enriched in spermatozoa bearing X or Y chromosome that we have already isolated or any other feature.     

Effects of different surfactants on motility and DNA integrity of brown trout (Salmo trutta fario) and common carp (Cyprinus carpio) spermatozoa

In this study we evaluated effects of surfactants on motility parameters and DNA integrity of spermatozoa of freshwater teleost fish. Common carp (Cyprinus carpio) and brown trout (Salmo trutta fario) spermatozoa were exposed to either sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS, anionic surfactant) or octoxynol 9 ( Triton X-100, nonionic surfactant). Both surfactants added at activation caused a decrease in sperm motility characteristics measured by computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA). Intraspecific differences in speed and trajectory of movement were detected. Triton X-100 and SDS when added to non activated sperm were also effective in the decrease of sperm motility and caused an increase of DNA fragmentation. Our results suggest that not only sperm motility apparatus but also DNA are targets for surfactant action. Therefore any exposure of spermatozoa to surfactants, in aquaculture conditions or natural environment, would have a negative impact on fish reproduction.     

Assessment of motility of ejaculated, liquid-stored boar spermatozoa using computerized instruments

Visual-motility assessment is a tool used to determine the quality of boar ejaculates. This method is subjective by nature, and consequently, computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA), with different software designs, has been developed for more objective assessment using conventional image analysis or particle counting. In the present study, we compared the results of sperm analysis using a conventional CASA system (Cell Motion Analyzer, SM-CMA™), with those using a novel software (QualiSperm™) and those of visual assessment performed by two operators. Ejaculates were collected weekly from four Swedish Landrace boars for 4 weeks. Each ejaculate was divided into three aliquots of different sperm concentration (300, 125, and 40 million spermatozoa/mL) and stored at 17 °C for 96 h. Only samples at 40 million spermatozoa/mL concentration were analyzed using both automated systems; for the remaining concentrations, the SM-CMA™ was not used due to its inability to examine higher sperm concentrations. The number of spermatozoa analyzed was highest for the QualiSperm™ (300–5000 spermatozoa), followed by the SM-CMA™ (200 spermatozoa), and lastly, by subjective motility evaluation (100 spermatozoa). There was a time-course decrease in motility of the liquid-stored semen, detectable by either computerized method. Although the percentage of motile spermatozoa measured by the two automated systems correlated well (r ≥ 0.75), there was disagreement between operators. In conclusion, because of the lower degree of variation, the numbers of spermatozoa analyzed, and the speed of analysis (1 min per sample), QualiSperm™ appears to be a suitable instrument for routine work, provided it maintains stability and is available at an affordable price.     

Different computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) systems highly influence sperm motility parameters

In this study, we examined different computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) systems (CRISMAS, Hobson Sperm Tracker, and Image J CASA) on the exact same video recordings to evaluate the differences in sperm motility parameters related to the specific CASA used. To cover a wide range of sperm motility parameters, we chose 12-second video recordings at 25 and 50 Hz frame rates after sperm motility activation using three taxonomically distinct fish species (sterlet: Acipenser ruthenus L.; common carp: Cyprinus carpio L.; and rainbow trout: Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum) that are characterized by essential differences in sperm behavior during motility. Systematically higher values of velocity and beat cross frequency (BCF) were observed in video recordings obtained at 50 Hz frame frequency compared with 25 Hz for all three systems. Motility parameters were affected by the CASA and species used for analyses. Image J and CRISMAS calculated higher curvilinear velocity (VCL) values for rainbow trout and common carp at 25 Hz frequency compared with the Hobson Sperm Tracker, whereas at 50 Hz, a significant difference was observed only for rainbow trout sperm recordings. No significant difference was observed between the CASA systems for sterlet sperm motility at 25 and 50 Hz. Additional analysis of 1-second segments taken at three time points (1, 6, and 12 seconds of the recording) revealed a dramatic decrease in common carp and rainbow trout sperm speed. The motility parameters of sterlet spermatozoa did not change significantly during the 12-second motility period and should be considered as a suitable model for longer motility analyses. Our results indicated that the CASA used can affect motility results even when the same motility recordings are used. These results could be critically altered by the recording quality, time of analysis, and frame rate of camera, and could result in erroneous conclusions.