A nonuniform distribution of excision repair synthesis in nucleosome core DNA

We have investigated the distribution in nucleosome core DNA of nucleotides incorporated by excision repair synthesis occurring immediately after UV irradiation in human cells. We show that the differences previously observed for whole nuclei between the DNase I digestion profiles of repaired DNA (following its refolding into a nucleosome structure) and bulk DNA are obtained for isolated nucleosome core particles. Analysis of the differences obtained indicates that they could reflect a significant difference in the level of repair-incorporated nucleotides at different sites within the core DNA region. To test this possibility directly, we have used exonuclease III digestion of very homogeneous sized core particle DNA to "map" the distribution of repair synthesis in these regions. Our results indicate that in a significant fraction of the nucleosomes the 5' and 3' ends of the core DNA are markedly enhanced in repair-incorporated nucleotides relative to the central region of the core particle. A best fit analysis indicates that a good approximation of the data is obtained for a distribution where the core DNA is uniformly labeled from the 5' end to position 62 and from position 114 to the 3' end, with the 52-base central region being devoid of repair-incorporated nucleotides. This distribution accounts for all of the quantitative differences observed previously between repaired DNA and bulk DNA following the rapid phase of nucleosome rearrangement when it is assumed that linker DNA and the core DNA ends are repaired with equal efficiency and the nucleosome structure of newly repaired DNA is identical with that of bulk chromatin. Furthermore, the 52-base central region that is devoid of repair synthesis contains the lowest frequency cutting sites for DNase I in vitro, as well as the only "internal" locations where two (rather than one) histones interact with a 10-base segment of each DNA strand.     

Completion of excision repair in human cells. Relationship between ligation and nucleosome formation

The completion of excision repair patches in human cells, following UV irradiation, was compared to the refolding of these regions into nucleosomes. Incomplete repair patches were detected by their enhanced sensitivity to exonuclease III. This enhanced sensitivity was due to the presence of gaps (or displaced parental strands) at the 3' end rather than unligated nicks, indicating that ligation occurs rapidly after repair synthesis is completed. Different rates of completion were achieved by treatment with the inhibitors hydroxyurea and sodium butyrate, as well as by using a (partially) ligase-deficient human cell strain. Hydroxyurea caused a marked decrease in both the rate of completion and the level of repair incorporation in all three cell types studied, while sodium butyrate yielded different effects in each cell type. In each case, however, a decrease in the rate of repair patch completion resulted in a concomitant decrease in the level of nucleosome formation. To determine the temporal relationship of these two events, the levels of repair-incorporated nucleotides in isolated 146-base pair nucleosome core DNA were compared on native and denaturing gels. The data indicate that little (or no) nucleosome formation occurred in the nascent DNA regions prior to ligation regardless of the cell type or treatment used. Furthermore, comparison of the fraction of unligated repair patches and the fraction of repair patches in a nonnucleosomal state indicated that in the absence of inhibitors there was a significant time lag between ligation and nucleosome formation. This lag time, however, decreased when cells were treated with hydroxyurea. Thus, the formation of nucleosomes in newly repaired regions of DNA occurred after the ligation step in all cases and these two features of the excision repair process are not "tightly coupled" events.     

Distribution of DNA damage in chromatin and its relation to repair in human cells treated with 7-bromomethylbenz(a) anthracene.

We have examined the relationship between the distribution of DNA damage and repair in chromatin from confluent human fibroblasts treated with the carcinogen 7-bromomethylbenz (a) anthracene. Analysis of staphylococcal nuclease (SN)4 digestion kinetics and gel electrophoresis revealed that more total damage occurs in nucleosome core DNA (approximately 80-85% of chromatin DNA) than in SN sensitive DNA (APPROXIMATELY15-20%). Furthermore, over a 24 hr period, damage is removed at about the same rate from these two regions. In contrast, virtually all of the nucleotides incorporated during repair synthesis are initially SN sensitive even when measured at 12 hr after damage. With time many repair-incorporated nucleotides become SN resistant and coelectrophorese with nucleosome core DNA. To explain these data we propose a model whereby excision repair occurs in both linker and core DNA; however, in core DNA the repair process induces conformational changes resulting in temporarily increased SN sensitivity; subsequently, rearrangement occurs and results in the re-establishment of native or near-native nucleosome conformation and SN resistance.     

Multiple conformational states of repair patches in chromatin during DNA excision repair

In mammalian cells, newly synthesized DNA repair patches are highly sensitive to digestion by staphylococcal nuclease (SN), but with time, they acquire approximately the same nuclease resistance as the DNA in bulk chromatin. We refer to the process which restores native SN sensitivity to repaired DNA as chromatin rearrangement. We find that during repair of ultraviolet damage in human fibroblasts, repair patch synthesis and ligation occur at approximately the same rate, with ligation delayed by about 4 min, but that chromatin rearrangement is only 75% as rapid. Thus, repair-incorporated nucleotides can exist in at least three distinct states: unligated/unrearranged, ligated/unrearranged, and ligated/rearranged. Inhibition of repair patch synthesis by aphidicolin or hydroxyurea results in inhibition of both patch ligation and chromatin rearrangement, confirming that repair patch completion and/or ligation are prerequisites for rearrangement. We also analyze the kinetics of SN digestion of repair-incorporated nucleotides at various extents of rearrangement and find the data to be consistent with the existence of two or more forms of unrearranged repair patch which have different sensitivities to digestion by SN. These data indicate that the chromatin rearrangement which restores native SN sensitivity to repaired DNA is a multistep process. The multiple forms of unrearranged chromatin with different SN sensitivities may include the unligated/unrearranged and ligated/unrearranged states. If so, the differences in SN sensitivity must arise from differences in chromatin structure, because SN does not differentiate between ligated and unligated repair patches in naked DNA.     

Enhanced DNA repair synthesis in hyperacetylated nucleosomes

We have investigated the level of "early" DNA repair synthesis in nucleosome subpopulations, varying in histone acetylation, from normal human fibroblasts treated with sodium butyrate. We find that repair synthesis occurring during the first 30 min after UV irradiation is significantly enhanced in hyperacetylated mononucleosomes. Nucleosomes with an average of 2.3 acetyl residues/H4 molecule contained approximately 1.8-fold more repair synthesis than nucleosomes with an average of 1.5 or 1.0 acetyl residues/H4 molecule. Fractionation of highly acetylated nucleosomes by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis yielded an additional 2.0-fold enrichment of repair synthesis in nucleosomes containing 2.7 acetyl residues/H4 molecule as compared to nucleosomes containing 1.9 acetyl residues/H4 molecule. This enhanced repair synthesis is associated primarily with nucleosome core regions and does not appear to result from increased UV damage in hyperacetylated chromatin. In addition, the distribution of repair synthesis within nucleosome core DNA from hyperacetylated chromatin is nonrandom, showing a bias toward the 5' end which is similar to that obtained for bulk (unfractionated) chromatin. These results provide strong evidence that enhanced repair occurs within nucleosome cores of hyperacetylated chromatin in butyrate-treated human cells. Finally, pulse-chase experiments demonstrate that the association of enhanced repair synthesis with hyperacetylated nucleosomes is transient, lasting only about 12 h after UV damage.     

Exchange of histones H1, H2A, and H2B in vivo

We have asked whether histones synthesized in the absence of DNA synthesis can exchange into nucleosomal structures. DNA synthesis was inhibited by incubating hepatoma tissue culture cells in medium containing 5.0 mM hydroxyurea for 40 min. During the final 20 min, the cells were pulsed with [3H]lysine to radiolabel the histones (all five histones are substantially labeled under these conditions). By two electrophoretic techniques, we demonstrate that histones H1, H2A, and H2B synthesized in the presence of hydroxyurea do not merely associate with the surface of the chromatin but instead exchange with preexisting histones so that for the latter two histones there is incorporation into nucleosome structures. On the other hand, H3 and H4 synthesized during this same time period appear to be only weakly bound, if at all, to chromatin. These two histones have been isolated from postnuclear washes and purified. Some possible implications of in vivo exchange are discussed.     

Formation of hybrid nucleosomes cantaining new and old histones.

5 mM hydroxyurea (HU) inhibits DNA synthesis in mouse P815 cells by 94-97% in less than 1 hr. Nevertheless, histone synthesis continues and newly-synthesised histones are incorporated into non-replicating chromatin at a rate of about 20% of that in control exponentially-growing cells. To study the organization of these histones in chromatin P815 cells were treated with 5 mM HU in medium containing dense (15N, 13C, 2H) - substituted amino acids. After inhibition of DNA synthesis, newly-synthesised histones were labelled with (3H)-arginine. The cells were harvested 90 min later, and mono- and oligonucleosomes were prepared and analysed on metrizamide-triethanolamine (MA-TEA density gradients. Analysis of the distribution of 3H-labelled histones in these gradients shows that they are incorporated into hybrid mononucleosomes containing both new and old histones. It is also shown that these hybrid nucleosomes are not randomly distributed, but show a certain tendency to be clustered in certain chromatin regions.     

Nucleosome rearrangement in human cells following short patch repair of DNA damaged by bleomycin.

We have examined the structure of newly repaired regions of chromatin in intact and permeabilized human cells following exposure to bleomycin (BLM). The average repair patch size (in permeabilized cells) was six to nine bases, following doses of 1-25 micrograms/mL BLM, and greater than 80% of the total repair synthesis was resistant to aphidicolin. In both intact and permeabilized cells, nascent repair patches were initially very sensitive to staphylococcal nuclease, analogous to repair induced by "long patch" agents, and are nearly absent from isolated nucleosome core DNA. Unlike long patch repair, however, the loss of nuclease sensitivity during subsequent chase periods was very slow in intact cells, or in permeabilized cells treated with a low dose of BLM (1 microgram/mL), and was abolished by treatment with hydroxyurea (HU) or aphidicolin (APC). The rate of repair patch ligation did not correlate with this slow rate of chromatin rearrangement since greater than 95% of the patches were ligated within 6 h after incorporation (even in the presence of HU or APC). In permeabilized cells, repair patches induced by either 5 or 25 micrograms/mL BLM, where significant levels of strand breaks occur in compact regions of chromatin, lost the enhanced nuclease sensitivity at a rate similar to that observed following long patch repair. This rapid rate of rearrangement was not affected by APC. These results indicate that short patch repair in linker regions of nucleosomes, and/or "open" regions of chromatin, involves much less nucleosome rearrangement than long patch repair or short patch repair in condensed chromatin domains.     

Nucleosome rearrangement in vitro. 2. Formation of nucleosomes in newly repaired regions of DNA

We have reported previously that immediately following nucleotide excision repair in human cells the newly repaired DNA lacks a nucleosome conformation [Smerdon, M. J., & Lieberman, M. W. (1980) Biochemistry 19, 2992-3000]. In this study, we have examined the ability of these nascent DNA regions to acquire a nucleosome structure in vitro by incubating intact or H1-depleted nuclei in buffers containing different salt concentrations (0.025-0.625 M KCl) at 0 or 37 degrees C. Nucleosomes were detected in these regions by an increase in the level of repair-incorporated nucleotides associated with isolated nucleosome core particle DNA. Our results indicate that the nascent DNA is resistant to nucleosome formation during the low-salt transition where the limiting repeat length decreases from approximately 190 to 168 base pairs (bp) [Watkins, J. F., & Smerdon, M. J. (1985) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)]. This result provides further evidence that the nascent DNA is indeed in a nonnucleosomal state. At higher salt concentrations (greater than 0.4 M), where the nucleosome repeat length decreases to a limiting value of approximately 146 bp, there was an increase in nucleosome formation in nascent DNA that correlated with the decrease in limiting repeat length. However, we did not observe a complete randomization of the repair-incorporated nucleotides. Indeed, even at the highest salt concentration used (0.625 M), we never observed more than 50% of the nascent DNA associated with the isolated core particles. This was the case even though a major portion of the nucleosomes had a limiting value repeat length following the high-salt incubation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Nonrandom assembly of chromatin during hydroxyurea inhibition of DNA synthesis

Incubation of MSB-1 chicken lymphoblastoid cells with hydroxyurea leads to a rapid 25-fold decrease in the incorporation of [3H]thymidine into DNA and a 5-fold decrease [3H]lysine into the nucleosome core histones. I have investigated whether the distortion in the normal proportion of histone-DNA synthesis results in alterations in the nucleosome assembly process and find that neither the stoichiometry of new histone synthesis nor the deposition is appreciably changed during hydroxyurea incubation. Protein cross-linking and micrococcal nuclease digestion show that the histones synthesized during hydroxyurea treatment form octamer structures and are assembled into typical nucleosome particles. Minor nucleosome subpopulations are found which exhibit altered sensitivity to nuclease digestion and which are depleted in new histones H3 and H4. When MSB-1 cells incubated in hydroxyurea are pulsed briefly with density-labeled amino acids and [3H]lysine, the radiolabeled core histone octamers formed are as dense as individual monomer histones. These results suggest that the newly synthesized histone octamers are uniformly dense and do not contain mixtures of new and old histones. Thus, histones synthesized during hydroxyurea incubation are deposited nonrandomly and do not exchange with preexisting histones.     

Stimulation of deoxyribonucleic acid excision repair in human fibroblasts pretreated with sodium butyrate

The effect of pretreatment with sodium butyrate on DNA excision repair was studied in intact and permeable confluent (i.e., growth-inhibited) diploid human fibroblasts. Exposure to 20 mM sodium butyrate for 48 h increased subsequent ultraviolet (UV)-induced [methyl-3H]thymidine incorporation by intact AG1518 fibroblasts by 1.8-fold and by intact IMR-90 fibroblasts by 1.2-1.3-fold. UV-induced incorporation of deoxy[5-3H]cytidine, deoxy[6-3H]cytidine, and deoxy[6-3H]uridine, however, showed lesser degrees of either stimulation or inhibition in butyrate-pretreated cells. This result suggested that measurements of butyrate's effect on DNA repair synthesis in intact cells are confounded by simultaneous changes in nucleotide metabolism. The effect of butyrate on excision repair was also studied in permeable human fibroblasts in which excision repair is dependent on exogenous nucleotides. Butyrate pretreatment stimulated UV-induced repair synthesis by 1.3-1.7-fold in permeable AG1518 cells and by 1.5-2-fold in permeable IMR-90 cells. This stimulation of repair synthesis was not due to changes in repair patch size or composition or in the efficiency of DNA damage production but rather resulted from a butyrate-induced increase in the rate of damage-specific incision of DNA. The increased rate of incision in butyrate-pretreated cells could be due either to increased levels of enzymes mediating steps in excision repair at or before incision or to alterations in chromatin structure making damage sites in DNA more accessible to repair enzymes.     

Stability of nucleosome placement in newly repaired regions of DNA

Rearrangements of chromatin structure during excision repair of UV-damaged DNA appear to involve unfolding of nucleosomal DNA while repair is taking place, followed by refolding of this DNA into a native nucleosome structure. Recently, we found that repair patches are not distributed uniformly along the DNA in nucleosome core particles immediately following their refolding into nucleosomes (Lan, S. Y., and Smerdon, M. J. (1985) Biochemistry, 24,7771). Therefore, the distribution of repair patches in nucleosome core DNA was used to monitor the stability of nucleosome placement in these regions. Our results indicate that in nondividing human cells undergoing excision repair there is a slow change in the positioning of nucleosomes in newly repaired regions of chromatin, resulting in the eventual randomization of repair patches in nucleosome core DNA. Furthermore, the nonrandom placement of nucleosomes observed just after the refolding event is not re-established during DNA replication. Possible mechanisms for this change in nucleosome placement along the DNA are discussed.     

Influence of histone acetylation on the solubility, H1 content and DNase I sensitivity of newly assembled chromatin.

In a previous report [Annunziato, A.T. and Seale, R.L. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258:12675] a novel intermediate in chromatin assembly was described (detected by labeling new DNA in the presence of the deacetylase inhibitor sodium butyrate), which retained approximately 50% of the heightened sensitivity of newly replicated chromatin to DNaseI. It is now reported that nucleosomes replicated in butyrate are considerably more soluble in the presence of magnesium, relative to chromatin replicated under control conditions, and that this heightened magnesium-solubility is reflected in a concomitant increase in the preferential solubility of nucleosomes containing newly synthesized core histones. This differential solubility was accompanied by a 5- to 6-fold depletion of histone H1, and was completely abolished by the selective removal of H1 from isolated nuclei. The removal of H1 also markedly reduced the preferential DNaseI sensitivity of chromatin replicated in butyrate. Further, when mononucleosomes of control and (acetylated) nascent chromatin were compared, no differences in DNaseI sensitivity were detected. These results provide evidence that the interactions between newly assembled nucleosomes and histone H1 are altered when histone deacetylation is inhibited during chromatin replication, and suggest a mechanism for the control of H1 deposition during nucleosome assembly in vivo.     

UV Damage in DNA Promotes Nucleosome Unwrapping

The association of DNA with histones in chromatin impedes DNA repair enzymes from accessing DNA lesions. Nucleosomes exist in a dynamic equilibrium in which portions of the DNA molecule spontaneously unwrap, transiently exposing buried DNA sites. Thus, nucleosome dynamics in certain regions of chromatin may provide the exposure time and space needed for efficient repair of buried DNA lesions. We have used FRET and restriction enzyme accessibility to study nucleosome dynamics following DNA damage by UV radiation. We find that FRET efficiency is reduced in a dose-dependent manner, showing that the presence of UV photoproducts enhances spontaneous unwrapping of DNA from histones. Furthermore, this UV-induced shift in unwrapping dynamics is associated with increased restriction enzyme accessibility of histone-bound DNA after UV treatment. Surprisingly, the increased unwrapping dynamics is even observed in nucleosome core particles containing a single UV lesion at a specific site. These results highlight the potential for increased “intrinsic exposure” of nucleosome-associated DNA lesions in chromatin to repair proteins.     

Histones of terminally differentiated cells undergo continuous turnover

In contrast to the widely accepted idea of the nearly absolute metabolic stability of histones, our experiments support the view that the histones of nonproliferating, terminally differentiated cells undergo continuous replacement. This conclusion is based on the incorporation of labeled amino acids into the histones of mouse kidney and liver cells after their intraperitoneal introduction. We have found that the intranuclear uptake of the histones made in the absence of replicative synthesis and their integration into chromatin proceed with striking delay. The metabolic rates of individual histones measured by calculating their half-lives suggest that each histone turns over at a specific rate. With regard to the basic chromatin structure, the nucleosome, such unequal turnover should mean that the histone core does not participate in this process as a single unit but rather as a protein mosaic in which each partner follows its own rate of removal. Additional experiments suggested that intact nucleosomes take part in the replacement, but the relative proportion of the nucleosomes involved should be limited. The nonnucleosomal H1A and H1 degree histones have been found to undergo faster replacement than the core histones. Moreover, in comparison to each other, these two histone subfractions are also replaced at a different rate. The results of autoradiography of isolated kidney and liver nuclei after continuous labeling with [3H]-thymidine suggest that the histone replacement is not associated with the repair of DNA.     

Nucleosome structure and repair of N-methylpurines in the GAL1-10 genes of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Nucleosome structure and repair of N-methylpurines were analyzed at nucleotide resolution in the divergent GAL1-10 genes of intact yeast cells, encompassing their common upstream-activating sequence. In glucose cultures where genes are repressed, nucleosomes with fixed positions exist in regions adjacent to the upstream-activating sequence, and the variability of nucleosome positioning sharply increases with increasing distance from this sequence. Galactose induction causes nucleosome disruption throughout the region analyzed, with those nucleosomes close to the upstream-activating sequence being most striking. In glucose cultures, a strong correlation between N-methylpurine repair and nucleosome positioning was seen in nucleosomes with fixed positions, where slow and fast repair occurred in nucleosome core and linker DNA, respectively. Galactose induction enhanced N-methylpurine repair in both strands of nucleosome core DNA, being most dramatic in the clearly disrupted, fixed nucleosomes. Furthermore, N-methylpurines are repaired primarily by the Mag1-initiated base excision repair pathway, and nucleotide excision repair contributes little to repair of these lesions. Finally, N-methylpurine repair is significantly affected by nearest-neighbor nucleotides, where fast and slow repair occurred in sites between pyrimidines and purines, respectively. These results indicate that nucleosome positioning and DNA sequence significantly modulate Mag1-initiated base excision repair in intact yeast cells.