Substrate shape specificity of E coli RNase P ribozyme is dependent on the concentration of magnesium ion

The bacterial RNase P ribozyme can accept a hairpin RNA with CCA-3' tag sequence as well as a cloverleaf pre-tRNA as substrate in vitro, but the details are not known. By switching tRNA structure using an antisense guide DNA technique, we examined the Escherichia coli RNase P ribozyme specificity for substrate RNA of a given shape. Analysis of the RNase P reaction with various concentrations of magnesium ion revealed that the ribozyme cleaved only the cloverleaf RNA at below 10 mM magnesium ion. At 10 mM magnesium ion or more, the ribozyme also cleaved a hairpin RNA with a CCA-3' tag sequence. At above 20 mM magnesium ion, cleavage site wobbling by the enzyme in tRNA-derived hairpin occurred, and the substrate specificity of the enzyme became broader. Additional studies using another hairpin substrate demonstrated the same tendency. Our data strongly suggest that raising the concentration of metal ion induces a conformational change in the RNA enzyme.     

The mechanism of group I self-splicing: an internal guide sequence can be provided in trans.

We have reconstituted a group I self-splicing reaction between two RNA molecules with different functional RNA parts: a substrate molecule containing the 5' splice site and a functional internal guide sequence (IGS), and a ribozyme molecule with core structure elements and splice sites but a mutated IGS. The 5' exon of the substrate molecule is ligated in trans to the 3' exon of the ribozyme molecule, suggesting that the deficient IGS in the ribozyme can be replaced by an externally added IGS present on the substrate molecule. This result is different from catalysis mediated by proteins where it is not possible to dissect the specificity of an enzyme from its catalytic activity.     

Substrate Shape Preference of Escherichia coli Ribonuclease P Ribozyme and Holo Enzyme Using Bottom-Half Part-Shifting Variants of Pre-tRNA

We showed previously that the bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) ribozyme has substrate shape preference depending on the concentrations of catalytically important magnesium ions. The ribozyme discriminates a canonical cloverleaf precursor tRNA from a hairpin RNA with a CCA-tag sequence at low concentrations of magnesium ions. By detailed analysis of the shape preference using the bottom-half part-shifting variants of a tRNA precursor, we showed that the RNAs in a T-shape structure can be substrates for the ribozyme reactions even at low concentrations of magnesium ions, and that the RNA in a natural L-shape is the best substrate for both the ribozyme and the holo enzyme. The results also showed that the position of the bottom-half part did not affect the cleavage site selection of a substrate by the enzyme. Our results are the first kinetic evidence to show the importance of the bottom-half part of tRNA molecule, and our result also showed that the holo enzyme can discriminate substrate shape as well as the ribozyme at low concentrations of metal ions.     

Substrate shape preference of Escherichia coli ribonuclease P ribozyme and holo enzyme using bottom-half part-shifting variants of pre-tRNA

We showed previously that the bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) ribozyme has substrate shape preference depending on the concentrations of catalytically important magnesium ions. The ribozyme discriminates a canonical cloverleaf precursor tRNA from a hairpin RNA with a CCA-tag sequence at low concentrations of magnesium ions. By detailed analysis of the shape preference using the bottom-half part-shifting variants of a tRNA precursor, we showed that the RNAs in a T-shape structure can be substrates for the ribozyme reactions even at low concentrations of magnesium ions, and that the RNA in a natural L-shape is the best substrate for both the ribozyme and the holo enzyme. The results also showed that the position of the bottom-half part did not affect the cleavage site selection of a substrate by the enzyme. Our results are the first kinetic evidence to show the importance of the bottom-half part of tRNA molecule, and our result also showed that the holo enzyme can discriminate substrate shape as well as the ribozyme at low concentrations of metal ions.     

Rapid kinetic characterization of hammerhead ribozymes by real-time monitoring of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)

In established methods for analyzing ribozyme kinetics, radiolabeled RNA substrates are primarily used. Each data point requires the cumbersome sampling, gel electrophoretic separation, and quantitation of reaction products, apart from the continuous loss of substrate by radioactive decay. We have used stable, double fluorescent end-labeled RNA substrates. Fluorescence of one fluorophore is quenched by intramolecular energy transfer (FRET). Upon substrate cleavage, both dyes become separated in two RNA products and fluorescence is restored. This can be followed in real time and ribozyme reactions can be analyzed under multiple (substrate excess) and under single (ribozyme excess) turnover conditions. A detailed comparison of unlabeled, single, and double fluorescent-labeled RNAs revealed moderate kinetic differences. Results with two systems, hammerhead ribozymes in I/II (small ribozyme, large substrate) and in I/III format (large ribozyme, small substrate), are reported.     

Strategies for the suppression of peroxidase gene expression in tobacco. I. Designing efficient ribozymes

Five short hammerhead ribozymes (Rzs) were constructed and tested, using a range ofin vitro reaction conditions, for catalytic activity against the mRNA encoding the lignin-forming peroxidase (TPX) of tobacco. Although all 5 Rzs were shown to be able to cleave the RNA substrate, percentage cleavage varied with pre-denaturation of Rz and substrate, incubation temperature, length of incubation and ribozyme (Rz)-to-substrate ratio. One Rz with two catalytic units and 60 nucleotides of complementary sequence in 3 regions was shown to most efficiently cleave the substrate under allin vitro conditions tested. This ribozyme cleaved better than the two single ribozymes from which it was made. The superior cleaving ability of this Rz was shown to be due to the accessibility of the chosen target site and to the increased length of the hybridizing arms spanning this accessible region of the RNA.     

Addition of an Extra Substrate Binding Site and Partial Destabilization of Stem Structures in HDV Ribozyme Give Rise to High Sequence-Specificity for its Target RNA

Because the substrate binding site (P1) of HDV ribozyme consists of only seven nucleotides, cleavage of undesired RNA is likely to occur when applied for a specific long RNA target such as mRNA. To overcome this problem, we designed modified trans-acting HDV ribozymes with an extra substrate-binding site (P5) in addition to the original binding site (P1). By inserting an additional seven base-pair stem (P5 stem) into the J1/2 single-stranded region of the ribozyme core system and partial destabilization of the P2 or P4 stem, we succeeded in preparation of new HDV ribozymes that can cleave the target RNA depending on the formation of P5 stem. Moreover, the ribozyme with a six-nucleotide P1 site was able to distinguish the substrate RNA with a complete match from that with a single mismatch in the P1 region. These results suggest that the HDV ribozyme system is useful for the application in vivo.     

NMR analysis of tertiary interactions in HDV ribozymes.

Three variants of minimized hepatitis delta virus (HDV) RNA ribozyme systems designed on the basis of the "pseudoknot" model were synthesized and their tertiary interactions were analyzed by NMR spectroscopy. Rz-1 is a cis-acting ribozyme system (the cleaved form, 56-mer) in which stem IV is deleted from the active domain of genomic HDV RNA. Rz-1 was uniformly labeled with stable isotopes, 13C and 15N. Rz-2 is a trans-acting ribozyme system (substrate: 8-mer, the cytidine residue at the cleavage site is replaced by 2'-O-methylcytidine; enzyme: 16-mer plus 35-mer). Rz-2 was partially labeled with stable isotopes in guanosine residues of enzyme 35mer. Rz-4 is a trans-acting ribozyme system (substrate: 8mer, the cytidine residue at the cleavage site is replaced by 2'-O-methylcytidine; enzyme 53mer) which was designed by Perrotta and Been. Rz-4 has the same sequence and an extra loop closing stem IV. From 2D-NOESY and 2D-HSQC (except for Rz-4) spectra, it was suggested each ribozyme forms "pseudoknot" type structure in solution. Additionally, it was found that G38 of Rz-1, G28 and G29 of Rz-2 and Rz-4 form base-pairs. These novel base-pairs are observed in the crystal structure of a modified genomic HDV RNA. From temperature change experiment of Rz-2, the imino proton signal of G28 disappeared at 50 degrees C earlier than the other corresponding signals. Upon MgCl2 titration of Rz-2, this signal showed the largest shift.     

Sequence-specific endoribonuclease activity of the Tetrahymena ribozyme: enhanced cleavage of certain oligonucleotide substrates that form mismatched ribozyme-substrate complexes

A shortened form of the self-splicing intervening sequence RNA of Tetrahymena acts as a sequence-specific endoribonuclease. Specificity of cleavage is determined by Watson-Crick base pairing between the active site of the RNA enzyme (ribozyme) and its RNA substrate [Zaug, A. J., Been, M. D., & Cech, T. R. (1986) Nature (London) 324, 429-433]. Surprisingly, single-base changes in the substrate RNA 3 nucleotides preceding the cleavage site, giving a mismatched substrate-ribozyme complex, enhance the rate of cleavage. Mismatched substrates show up to a 100-fold increase in kcat and, in some cases, in kcat/Km. A mismatch introduced by changing a nucleotide in the active site of the ribozyme has a similar effect. Addition of 2.5 M urea or 3.8 M formamide or decreasing the divalent metal ion concentration from 10 to 2 mM reverses the substrate specificity, allowing the ribozyme to discriminate against the mismatched substrate. The effect of urea is to decrease kcat and kcat/Km for cleavage of the mismatched substrate; Km is not significantly affected at 0-2.5 M urea. Thus, progressive destabilization of ribozyme-substrate pairing by mismatches or by addition of a denaturant such as urea first increases the rate of cleavage to an optimum value and then decreases the rate.     

Twin ribozyme mediated removal of nucleotides from an internal RNA site

Over the past two decades, the structure and mechanism of catalytic RNA have been extensively studied; now ribozymes are understood well enough to turn them into useful tools. After we have demonstrated the twin ribozyme mediated insertion of additional nucleotides into a predefined position of a suitable substrate RNA, we here show that a similar type of twin ribozyme is also capable of mediating the opposite reaction: the site-specific removal of nucleotides. In particular, we have designed a twin ribozyme that supports the deletion of four uridine residues from a given RNA substrate. This reaction is a kind of RNA recombination that in the specific context of gene therapy mimics, at the level of RNA, the correction of insertion mutations. As a result of the twin ribozyme driven reaction, 17% of substrate are converted into the four nucleotides shorter product RNA.     

Determination of hammerhead ribozyme kinetic constants at high molar ratio ribozyme-substrate

 Hammerhead ribozymes provide valuable tools in the field of gene therapy due to their cleavage specificity and the broad range of RNA targets. A major prerequisite for the selection of suitable ribozymes for in vivo application is represented by in vitro determination of ribozyme cleavage kinetic constants. From the experimental cleavage data, kinetic constants are usually calculated under the assumption of rapid conversion of the substrate into the ribozyme-substrate complex. However, this condition is often not satisfied for ribozymes carrying additional RNA stretches, due to cloning strategies or necessary for ribozyme expression in the cell. To overcome this problem, we propose a mathematical model which is able to calculate ribozyme kinetic constants in the case of non-rapid conversion of substrate into ribozyme-substrate complex. In addition, our system gives the opportunity to evaluate the nature of the S conversion into ES through the determination of a model parameter. The validity of the proposed model is restricted to the hypothesis of a ribozyme excess over the substrate at the beginning of the cleavage reaction and to the absence of any mass exchange with the external environment. Received: 1 February 2001 / Revised version: 1 September 2001 / Published online: 23 August 2002     

Ribozymes

The ability to alter genes in order to regulate their expression has become an undeniable reality. This can be performedin vitro and in cells, and the possibility of treating diseases and even preventing them now exists through such gene manipulation. A particularly intriguing form of manipulation that has been investigated for just over a decade is one that involves the use of ribozymes. These are short segments of RNA that form complementary base-pairing with mRNA. However, it is their enzymatic properties that set them apart from other antisense RNA molecules and allow them to cleave and destroy mRNA in a very specific manner. The ribozyme then dissociates from the cleaved substrate RNA, and repeatedly hybridizes to and cleaves additional substrate RNA molecules. Problems being addressed as this technology evolves involve optimization of ribozyme: substrate binding efficiencies and their effective transmission into cells. This article points out the origin of ribozymes, analyzes and summarizes the current strategies for designing ribozymes, and outlines a basic procedure for ribozyme development.     

Tailoring RNA modular units on a common scaffold: A modular ribozyme with a catalytic unit for β-nicotinamide mononucleotide-activated RNA ligation

A novel ribozyme that accelerates the ligation of β-nicotinamide mononucleotide (β-NMN)-activated RNA fragments was isolated and characterized. This artificial ligase ribozyme (YFL ribozyme) was isolated by a “design and selection” strategy, in which a modular catalytic unit was generated on a rationally designed modular scaffold RNA. Biochemical analyses of the YFL ribozyme revealed that it catalyzes RNA ligation in a template-dependent manner, and its activity is highly dependent on its architecture, which consists of a modular scaffold and a catalytic unit. As the design and selection strategy was used for generation of DSL ribozyme, isolation of the YFL ribozyme indicated the versatility of this strategy for generation of functional RNAs with modular architectures. The catalytic unit of the YFL ribozyme accepts not only β-NMN but also inorganic pyrophosphate and adenosine monophosphate as leaving groups for RNA ligation. This versatility of the YFL ribozyme provides novel insight into the possible roles of β-NMN (or NADH) in the RNA world.     

RNA-RNA and RNA-DNA ligation with the sTobRV(+) hammerhead ribozyme.

The sTobRV(+) ribozyme consists of a small catalytic domain and two wing sequences(1). By changing its wing sequences, the ribozyme can cleave many different RNAs in a site-specific manner, functioning as an RNA restriction enzyme(1). Although relatively strong ligase activity is known to be associated with sTobRV(+) RNA(2,3), the sTobRV(+) ribozyme itself has been claimed to have no ligase activity. Here, we show the evidence that the sTobRV(+) ribozyme has the ability to rejoin its digestion products at low temperatures such as 4 degrees C. In contrast, little or no ligation product can be produced at 50 degrees C, the temperature giving the maximum digestion activity. The ligation reaction requires Mg++ ion. The first substrate (P1, see Fig.1), possessing 2',3' cyclic phosphate, must be RNA, but the second substrate (P2), required to have 5'OH, can be replaced by DNA counterparts, equal to or longer than dimer, thus making it possible to generate RNA-DNA chimeric molecules. We also show the resultant RNA-DNA chimera to be digestable by the sTobRV(+) ribozyme. RNase digestion indicates the phosphodiester linkage thus generated to be exclusively 3'-5'.     

Efficient RNA ligation by reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes and engineering of twin ribozymes consisting of conventional and reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme units

In recent years major progress has been made in elucidating the mechanism and structure of catalytic RNA molecules, and we are now beginning to understand ribozymes well enough to turn them into useful tools. Work in our laboratory has focused on the development of twin ribozymes for site-specific RNA sequence alteration. To this end, we followed a strategy that relies on the combination of two ribozyme units into one molecule (hence dubbed twin ribozyme). Here, we present reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes that are structurally optimized and which, in addition to cleavage, catalyse efficient RNA ligation. The most efficient variant ligated its appropriate RNA substrate with a single turnover rate constant of 1.1 min(-1) and a final yield of 70%. We combined a reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme with a conventional hairpin ribozyme to create a twin ribozyme that mediates the insertion of four additional nucleotides into a predetermined position of a substrate RNA, and thus mimics, at the RNA level, the repair of a short deletion mutation; 17% of the initial substrate was converted to the insertion product.     

Design and NMR analysis of HDV ribozymes for structural investigation.

Three variants of minimized hepatitis delta virus (HDV) RNA ribozyme systems (Rz-1 to approximately Rz-3) (Fig. 1) were designed on the basis of the "pseudoknot" structure model and synthesized. Rz-1 is a cis-acting ribozyme system (a cleaved form, 56-mer) in which stem IV is deleted from the active domain of genomic HDV RNA. Rz-1 was uniformly labeled with stable isotopes, 13C and 15N. The 2D-NOESY and 2D-HSQC data for Rz-1 suggest that Rz-1 forms the pseudoknot structure and G38 which is opposite to the cleavage site makes a base-pair. Rz-2 is a trans-acting ribozyme system which consists of three RNA oligomer strands (substrate: 8-mer, the cytidine residue at the cleavage site is replaced by 2'-O-methylcytidine; enzyme: 16-mer plus 35-mer). Rz-3 is a ribozyme in which the three RNA strands of Rz-2 are connected. It turns out that Rz-3 forms an inactive structure with low cleavage activity (k(obs) = 0.009) and final cleavage yield (6%). Rz-3 has the highest cleavage activity at pH 5.5. The optimal activity at acidic pH is similar to that of the wild type ribozyme. We also synthesized and examined the activity and structure of Rz-4 (designed by Perrotta and Been) which consists of two RNA strands (1).     

Expression of a reporter gene is reduced by a ribozyme in transgenic plants

A chimeric gene encoding a ribozyme under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter was introduced into transgenic tobacco plants. In vivo activity of this ribozyme, which was designed to cleave npt mRNA, was previously demonstrated by transient expression assays in plant protoplasts. The ribozyme gene was transferred into transgenic tobacco plants expressing an rbcS-npt chimeric gene as an indicator. Five double transformants out of sixteen exhibited a reduction in the amount of active NPT enzyme. To measure the amount of ribozyme produced, in the absence of its target, the ribozyme and target genes were separated by genetic segregation. The steady-state concentrations of ribozyme and target RNA were shown to be similar in the resulting single transformants. Direct evidence for a correlation between reduced npt gene expression and ribozyme expression was provided by crossing a plant containing only the ribozyme gene with a transgenic plant expressing the npt gene under control of the 35S promoter, i.e. the same promoter used to direct ribozyme expression. The expression of npt was reduced in all progeny containing both transgenes. Both steady-state levels of npt mRNA and amounts of active NPT enzyme are decreased. In addition, our data indicate that, at least in stable transformants, a large excess of ribozyme over target is not a prerequisite for achieving a significant reduction in target gene expression.     

A ribozyme with DNA in the hybridising arms displays enhanced cleavage ability.

Hammerhead ribozymes cleave RNA substrates containing the UX sequence, where X = U, C or A, embedded within sequences which are complementary to the hybridising 'arms' of the ribozyme. In this study we have replaced the RNA in the hybridising arms of the ribozyme with DNA, and the resulting ribozyme is many times more active than its precursor. In turnover-kinetics experiments with a 13-mer RNA substrate, the kcat/Km ratios are 10 and 150 microM-1min-1 for the RNA- and DNA-armed ribozymes, respectively. The effect is due mainly to differences in kcat. In independent experiments where the cleavage step is rate-limiting, the DNA-armed ribozyme cleaves the substrate with a rate constant more than 3 times greater than the all-RNA ribozyme. DNA substrates containing a ribocytidine at the cleavage site have been shown to be cleaved less efficiently than their all-RNA analogues; again however, the DNA-armed ribozyme is more effective than the all-RNA ribozyme against such DNA substrates. These results demonstrate that there are no 2'-hydroxyl groups in the arms of the ribozyme that are required for cleavage; and that the structure of the complex formed by the DNA-armed ribozyme with its substrate is more favourable for cleavage than that formed by the all-RNA ribozyme and its substrate.     

Recent insights into the structure and function of the ribonucleoprotein enzyme ribonuclease P

In bacteria, the tRNA-processing endonuclease ribonuclease P is composed of a large ( approximately 400 nucleotide) catalytic RNA and a smaller ( approximately 100 amino acid) protein subunit that is essential for substrate recognition. Current biochemical and biophysical investigations are providing fresh insights into the modular architecture of the ribozyme, the mechanisms of substrate specificity and the role of essential metal ions in catalysis. Together with recent high-resolution structures of portions of the ribozyme, these findings are beginning to reveal how the functions of RNA and protein are coordinated in this ribonucleoprotein enzyme.     

Selective cleavage of bcr-abl chimeric RNAs by a ribozyme targeted to non-contiguous sequences.

Conventionally designed ribozymes may be unable to cleave RNA at sites which are inaccessible due to secondary structure. In addition, it may also be difficult to specifically target a conventionally designed ribozyme to some chimeric RNA molecules. Novel approaches for ribozyme targeting were developed by using the L6 bcr-abl fusion RNA as a model. Using one approach, we successfully directed ribozyme nucleation to a site on the bcr-abl RNA that is distant from the GUA cleavage site. These ribozymes bound to the L6 substrate RNA via an anchor sequence that was complementary to bcr sequences. The anchor was necessary for efficient cleavage as the anchor minus ribozyme, a conventionally designed ribozyme, was inefficient at catalyzing cleavage at this same site. The effect of anchor sequences on catalytic rates was determined for two of these ribozymes. Ribozymes generated by a second approach were designed to cleave at a CUU site in proximity to the bcr-abl junction. Both approaches have led to the development of a series of ribozymes specific for both the L6 and K28 bcr-abl chimeric RNAs, but not normal abl or bcr RNAs. The specificity of the ribozyme correlated in part with the ability of the ribozyme to bind substrate as demonstrated by gel shift analyses. Secondary structure predictions for the RNA substrate support the experimental results and may prove useful as a theoretical basis for the design of ribozymes.