The strong dimerization of the transmembrane domain of the fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR) is modulated by C‐terminal juxtamembrane residues

The fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) is a member of the FGFR subfamily of the receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) involved in signaling across the plasma membrane. Generally, ligand binding leads to receptor dimerization and activation. Dimerization involves the transmembrane (TM) domain, where mutations can lead to constitutive activation in certain cancer types and also in skeletal malformations. Thus, it has been postulated that FGFR homodimerization must be inherently weak to allow regulation, a feature reminiscent of α and β integrin TM interactions. However, we show herein that in FGFR3‐TM, four C‐terminal residues, CRLR, have a profound destabilizing effect in an otherwise strongly dimerizing TM peptide. In the absence of these four residues, the dimerizing propensity of FGFR3‐TM is comparable to glycophorin, as shown using various detergents. In addition, the expected enhanced dimerization induced by the mutation associated to the Crouzon syndrome A391E, was observed only when these four C‐terminal residues were present. In the absence of these four residues, A391E was dimer‐destabilizing. Finally, using site specific infrared dichroism and convergence with evolutionary conservation data, we have determined the backbone model of the FGFR3‐TM homodimer in model lipid bilayers. This model is consistent with, and correlates with the effects of, most known pathological mutations found in FGFR‐TM.     

Synthesis and initial characterization of FGFR3 transmembrane domain: consequences of sequence modifications

Receptor Tyrosine Kinases (RTKs) conduct biochemical signals via lateral dimerization in the plasma membrane, and defects in their dimerization lead to unregulated signaling and disease. RTK transmembrane (TM) domains are proposed to play an important role in the process, underscored by the finding that single amino acids mutations in the TM domains can induce pathological phenotypes. Therefore, many important questions pertaining to the mode of signal transduction and the mechanism of pathology induction could be answered by studying the chemical-physical basis behind RTK TM domain dimerization and the interactions of RTK TM domains with lipids in model bilayer systems. As a first step towards this goal, here we report the synthesis of the TM domain of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3), an RTK that is crucial for skeletal development. We have used solid phase peptide synthesis to produce two peptides: one corresponding to the membrane embedded segment and the naturally occurring flanking residues at the N- and C-termini (TMwt), and a second one in which the flanking residues have been substituted with diLysines at the termini (TMKK). We have demonstrated that the hydrophobic FGFR3 TM domain can be synthesized for biophysical studies with high yield. The protocol presented in the paper can be applied to the synthesis of other RTK TM domains. As expected, the Lys flanks decrease the hydrophobicity of the TM domain, such that TMKK elutes much earlier than TMwt during reverse phase HPLC purification. The Lysines have no effect on peptide solubility in SDS and on peptide secondary structure, but they abolish peptide dimerization on SDS gels. These results suggest that caution should be exercised when modifying RTK TM domains to render them more manageable for biophysical studies.     

Synthesis and initial characterization of FGFR3 transmembrane domain: consequences of sequence modifications

Receptor Tyrosine Kinases (RTKs) conduct biochemical signals via lateral dimerization in the plasma membrane, and defects in their dimerization lead to unregulated signaling and disease. RTK transmembrane (TM) domains are proposed to play an important role in the process, underscored by the finding that single amino acids mutations in the TM domains can induce pathological phenotypes. Therefore, many important questions pertaining to the mode of signal transduction and the mechanism of pathology induction could be answered by studying the chemical-physical basis behind RTK TM domain dimerization and the interactions of RTK TM domains with lipids in model bilayer systems. As a first step towards this goal, here we report the synthesis of the TM domain of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3), an RTK that is crucial for skeletal development. We have used solid phase peptide synthesis to produce two peptides: one corresponding to the membrane embedded segment and the naturally occurring flanking residues at the N- and C-termini (TM_wt), and a second one in which the flanking residues have been substituted with diLysines at the termini (TM_KK). We have demonstrated that the hydrophobic FGFR3 TM domain can be synthesized for biophysical studies with high yield. The protocol presented in the paper can be applied to the synthesis of other RTK TM domains. As expected, the Lys flanks decrease the hydrophobicity of the TM domain, such that TM_KK elutes much earlier than TM_wt during reverse phase HPLC purification. The Lysines have no effect on peptide solubility in SDS and on peptide secondary structure, but they abolish peptide dimerization on SDS gels. These results suggest that caution should be exercised when modifying RTK TM domains to render them more manageable for biophysical studies.     

FGFR3 dimer stabilization due to a single amino acid pathogenic mutation

Mutations in the transmembrane (TM) domains of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) have been implicated in the induction of pathological phenotypes. These mutations are believed to stabilize the RTK dimers, and thus promote unregulated signaling. However, the energetics behind the pathology induction has not been determined. An example of a TM domain pathogenic mutation is the Ala391-->Glu mutation in fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3), linked to Crouzon syndrome with acanthosis nigricans, as well as to bladder cancer. Here, we determine the free energy of dimerization of wild-type and mutant FGFR3 TM domain in lipid bilayers using F?rster resonance energy transfer, and we show that hydrogen bonding between Glu391 and the adjacent helix in the dimer is a feasible mechanism for dimer stabilization. The measured change in the free energy of dimerization due to the Ala391-->Glu pathogenic mutation is -1.3 kcal/mol, consistent with previous reports of hydrogen bond strengths in proteins. This is the first quantitative measurement of mutant RTK stabilization in a membrane environment. We show that this seemingly modest value can lead to a large increase in dimer fraction and thus profoundly affect RTK-mediated signal transduction.     

Receptor tyrosine kinase transmembrane domains

The transmembrane (TM) domains of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) play an active role in signaling. They contribute to the stability of full-length receptor dimers and to maintaining a signaling-competent dimeric receptor conformation. In an exciting new development, two structures of RTK TM domains have been solved, a break-through achievement in the field. Here we review these structures, and we discuss recent studies of RTK TM domain dimerization energetics, possible synergies between domains, and the effects of pathogenic RTK TM mutations on structure and dimerization.     

The achondroplasia mutation does not alter the dimerization energetics of the fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 transmembrane domain

The Gly380 --> Arg mutation in the TM domain of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) of the RTK family is linked to achondroplasia, the most common form of human dwarfism. The molecular mechanism of pathology induction is under debate, and two different mechanisms have been proposed to contribute to pathogenesis: (1) Arg380-mediated FGFR3 dimer stabilization and (2) slow downregulation of the activated mutant receptors. Here we show that the Gly380 --> Arg mutation does not alter the dimerization energetics of the FGFR3 transmembrane domain in detergent micelles or in lipid bilayers. This result indicates that pathogenesis in achondroplasia cannot be explained simply by a higher dimerization propensity of the mutant FGFR3 TM domain, thus highlighting the importance of the observed slow downregulation in phenotype induction.     

Receptor tyrosine kinase transmembrane domains: Function,dimer structure and dimerization energetics

The transmembrane (TM) domains of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) play an active role in signaling. They contribute to the stability of full-length receptor dimers and to maintaining a signaling-competent dimeric receptor conformation. In an exciting new development, two structures of RTK TM domains have been solved, a break-through achievement in the field. Here we review these structures, and we discuss recent studies of RTK TM domain dimerization energetics, possible synergies between domains, and the effects of pathogenic RTK TM mutations on structure and dimerization.Key words: transmembrane domain, dimerization thermodynamics, receptor tyrosine kinases, pathogenic mutations, dimer structure     

Effect of pathogenic cysteine mutations on FGFR3 transmembrane domain dimerization in detergents and lipid bilayers

Mutations in fibroblast growth factor receptors are known as the genetic basis of skeletal growth disorders. The mechanism of pathogenesis, as determined by mutation-induced changes in receptor structure, interactions, and function, is elusive. Here we study three pathogenic Cys mutations, associated with either thanatophoric dysplasia or achondroplasia, in the TM domain of fibroblast growth factor receptors 3 (FGFR3). We characterize the dimerization propensities of the mutant TM domains in detergents and in lipid bilayers, in the presence and absence of reducing agents, and compare them to previous measurements of wild-type. We find that the Cys mutations increase the propensity for dimerization in detergent, with the Cys370 mutant exhibiting the highest propensity for disulfide bond formation, the Cys371 mutant having an intermediate propensity, and Cys375 the lowest. Thus, disulfide bonds readily form in detergents, with efficiency that correlates with the severity of the phenotype. In lipid bilayers, however, the Cys370 mutant, which dimerizes strongly in detergent, behaves as the wild-type, suggesting that Cys370-mediated disulfide bonds do not form between the isolated TM domains in bilayers. Thus, the nature of the hydrophobic environment plays an important role in defining the structure and flexibility of transmembrane dimers. These results and previous findings from cellular studies lead us to propose a conformational flexibility mechanism of receptor stabilization as a basis for disregulated FGFR3 signaling in thanatophoric dysplasia and achondroplasia.     

Role of receptor tyrosine kinase transmembrane domains in cell signaling and human pathologies

Receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) conduct biochemical signals via lateral dimerization in the plasma membrane, and their transmembrane (TM) domains play an important role in the dimerization process. Here we present two models of RTK-mediated signaling, and we discuss the role of the TM domains within the framework of these two models. We summarize findings of single-amino acid mutations in RTK TM domains that induce unregulated signaling and, as a consequence, pathological phenotypes. We review the current knowledge of pathology induction mechanisms due to these mutations, focusing on the structural and thermodynamic basis of pathogenic dimer stabilization.     

Studies of Receptor Tyrosine Kinase Transmembrane Domain Interactions: The EmEx-FRET Method

The energetics of transmembrane (TM) helix dimerization in membranes and the thermodynamic principles behind receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) TM domain interactions during signal transduction can be studied using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). For instance, FRET studies have yielded the stabilities of wild-type fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) TM domains and two FGFR3 pathogenic mutants, Ala391Glu and Gly380Arg, in the native bilayer environment. To further our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of deregulated FGFR3 signaling underlying different pathologies, we determined the effect of the Gly382Asp FGFR3 mutation, identified in a multiple myeloma cell line, on the energetics of FGFR3 TM domain dimerization. We measured dimerization energetics using a novel FRET acquisition and processing method, termed “emission-excitation FRET (EmEx-FRET),” which improves the precision of thermodynamic measurements of TM helix association. The EmEx-FRET method, verified here by analyzing previously published data for wild-type FGFR3 TM domain, should have broad utility in studies of protein interactions, particularly in cases when the concentrations of fluorophore-tagged molecules cannot be controlled.     

Rotational coupling of the transmembrane and kinase domains of the Neu receptor tyrosine kinase

Ligand binding to receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) regulates receptor dimerization and activation of the kinase domain. To examine the role of the transmembrane domain in regulation of RTK activation, we have exploited a simplified transmembrane motif, [VVVEVVV](n), previously shown to activate the Neu receptor. Here we demonstrate rotational linkage of the transmembrane domain with the kinase domain, as evidenced by a periodic activation of Neu as the dimerization motif is shifted across the transmembrane domain. These results indicate that activation requires a specific orientation of the kinase domains with respect to each other. Results obtained with platelet-derived growth factor receptor-beta suggest that this rotational linkage of the transmembrane domain to the kinase domain may be a general feature of RTKs. These observations suggest that activating mutations in RTK transmembrane and juxtamembrane domains will be limited to those residues that position the kinase domains in an allowed rotational conformation.     

High-Throughput Selection of Transmembrane Sequences That Enhance Receptor Tyrosine Kinase Activation

Dimerization is a critical requirement for the activation of the intracellular kinase domains of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs). The single transmembrane (TM) helices of RTKs contribute to dimerization, but the details are not well understood. Work with TM helices in various model systems has revealed a small number of specific dimerization sequence motifs, and it has been suggested that RTK dimerization is modulated by such motifs. Yet questions remain about the universality of these sequence motifs for RTK dimerization and about how TM domain dimerization in model systems relates to RTK activation in mammalian membranes. To investigate these questions, we designed a 3888-member combinatorial peptide library based on the TM domain of Neu (ErbB2) as a model RTK. The library contains many closely related, Neu-like sequences, including thousands of sequences with known dimerization motifs. We used an SDS-PAGE-based screen to select peptides that dimerize better than the native Neu sequence, and we assayed the activation of chimeric Neu receptors in mammalian cells with TM sequences selected in the screen. Despite the very high abundance of known dimerization motifs in the library, only a very few dimerizing sequences were identified by SDS-PAGE. About half of those sequences activated the Neu kinase significantly more than did the wild-type TM sequence. This work furthers our knowledge about the requirements for membrane protein interactions and the requirements for RTK activation in cells.     

The single transmembrane domains of ErbB receptors self-associate in cell membranes.

Members of the epidermal growth factor receptor, or ErbB, family of receptor tyrosine kinases have a single transmembrane (TM) alpha-helix that is usually assumed to play a passive role in ligand-induced dimerization and activation of the receptor. However, recent studies with the epidermal growth factor receptor (ErbB1) and the erythropoietin receptor have indicated that interactions between TM alpha-helices do contribute to stabilization of ligand-independent and/or ligand-induced receptor dimers. In addition, not all of the expected ErbB receptor ligand-induced dimerization events can be recapitulated using isolated extracellular domains, suggesting that other regions of the receptor, such as the TM domain, may contribute to dimerization in vivo. Using an approach for analyzing TM domain interactions in Escherichia coli cell membranes, named TOXCAT, we find that the TM domains of ErbB receptors self-associate strongly in the absence of their extracellular domains, with the rank order ErbB4-TM > ErbB1-TM equivalent to ErbB2-TM > ErbB3-TM. A limited mutational analysis suggests that dimerization of these TM domains involves one or more GXXXG motifs, which occur frequently in the TM domains of receptor tyrosine kinases and are critical for stabilizing the glycophorin A TM domain dimer. We also analyzed the effect of the valine to glutamic acid mutation in ErbB2 that constitutively activates this receptor. Contrary to our expectations, this mutation reduced rather than increased ErbB2-TM dimerization. Our findings suggest a role for TM domain interactions in ErbB receptor function, possibly in stabilizing inactive ligand-independent receptor dimers that have been observed by several groups.     

Transmembrane domain of EphA1 receptor forms dimers in membrane-like environment

Eph receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) are activated by a ligand-mediated dimerization in the plasma membrane and subjected to clusterization at a high local density of receptors and their membrane-anchored ligands. Interactions between transmembrane domains (TMDs) were recognized to assist to the ligand-binding extracellular domains in the dimerization of some RTKs, whereas a functional role of Eph-receptor TMDs remains unknown. We have studied a propensity of EphA1-receptor TMDs (TMA1) to self-association in membrane-mimetic environment. Dimerization of TMA1 in SDS environment was revealed by SDS-PAGE and confirmed by FRET analysis of the fluorescently labeled peptide (K_d = 7.2 ± 0.4 μM at 1.5 mM SDS). TMA1 dimerization was also found in 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine liposomes (ΔG = −15.4 ± 0.5 kJ/mol). Stability of TMA1 dimers is comparable to the reported earlier stability of TMD dimers of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 and tenfold weaker than the stability of TMD dimers of glycophorin A possessing high propensity to dimerization. Our results suggest that EphA1-receptor TMD contribute to the dimerization-mediated receptor activation. An assumed role of the TMD interactions is the efficient signal transduction due to TMD-driving mutual orientation of kinase domains in dimers, while a relatively low force of the TMD interactions does not prevent a ligand-controlled regulation of the receptor dimerization.     

The role of individual amino acids in the dimerization of CR4 and ACR4 transmembrane domains

CRINKLY4 is a growth factor-like plant receptor kinase designated as CR4 in Zea mays and ACR4 in Arabidopsis. Using the TOXCAT system, a genetic assay that measures helix interactions in a natural membrane environment, we have previously demonstrated that the dimerization potential of the ACR4 transmembrane (TM) domain is significantly weaker than that of CR4 TM domain, even though 13 of the 24 residues are identical. Neither of the TM domains contain the GxxxG motif that has been shown to be important for the dimerization of the TM segments of several receptors. To further investigate the relationship between protein sequence and dimerization potential, we (a) mutated each of the 11 differing residues in the CR4 TM domain to the corresponding residue of ACR4 (b) made reciprocal mutations in ACR4 and (c) made hybrids consisting of half CR4 and half ACR4 TM domains. Our results suggest that most mutations in ACR4 or CR4 TM domains have low to moderate effects on the dimerization potential and that residues in the N-terminal half of the CR4 TM domain are important for dimerization.     

Dimerization properties of the transmembrane domains of Arabidopsis CRINKLY4 receptor-like kinase and homologs

CRINKLY4 (CR4) is a plant serine–threonine receptor kinase. In Zea mays, CR4 functions in the differentiation of the leaf epidermis and the aleurone cell layer and, in Arabidopsis thaliana, the ortholog ACR4 is involved in the development of the integument and seed coat. The Arabidopsis genome also encodes four CR4-related proteins (CRR) whose functions are not known. Based on studies of animal receptor kinase proteins it is likely that the molecular basis of function of CR4 and related proteins is mediated by receptor dimerization. The importance of the transmembrane (TM) domain in the dimerization of several receptor kinases has been demonstrated by the TOXCAT system, a genetic assay that measures helix interactions in a natural membrane environment. In this study, we have used the TOXCAT assay to investigate the potential of the CR4 and CR4-related TM domains to homo-dimerize. Our investigation indicates that the CR4 TM domain and the CRR TM domains have higher propensities for homo-dimerization than the ACR4 TM domain. Interestingly, the dimerization potential of the ACR4 TM domain is significantly weaker even though 13 of 24 amino acids are identical to that of the CR4 TM domain. In order to determine the contributions of specific amino acids to the higher dimerization potential of CR4 compared to ACR4, mutations were made at specific sites in ACR4 TM domain and the strength of the dimer assessed by the TOXCAT assay. One mutation restored the activity to the CR4 level, while other mutations produced either no change or significantly increased the dimerization potential of the ACR4 TM domain. Our results indicate that the TM domains of CR4, ACR4 and the CRR receptor family of proteins have the intrinsic capacity to homo-dimerize, albeit with varying degrees of affinity.     

Energetics of ErbB1 Transmembrane Domain Dimerization in Lipid Bilayers

One of the most extensively studied receptor tyrosine kinases is EGFR/ErbB1. Although our knowledge of the role of the extracellular domains and ligands in ErbB1 activation has increased dramatically based on solved domain structures, the exact mechanism of signal transduction across the membrane remains unknown. The transmembrane domains are expected to play an important role in the dimerization process, but the contribution of ErbB1 TM domain to dimer stability is not known, with published results contradicting one another. We address this controversy by showing that ErbB1 TM domain dimerizes in lipid bilayers and by calculating its contribution to stability as −2.5 kcal/mol. The stability calculations use two different methods based on Förster resonance energy transfer, which give the same result. The ErbB1 TM domain contribution to stability exceeds the change in receptor tyrosine kinases dimerization propensities that can convert normal signaling processes into pathogenic processes, and is thus likely important for biological function.     

Identifying interactions between transmembrane helices from the adenosine A2A receptor

The human adenosine A(2A) receptor (A(2A)R) is an integral membrane protein and a member of the G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) superfamily, characterized by seven transmembrane (TM) helices. Although helix-helix association in the lipid bilayer is known to be an essential step in the folding of GPCRs, the determinants of their structures, folding, and assembly in the cell membrane are poorly understood. Previous studies in our group showed that while peptides corresponding to all seven TM domains of A(2A)R form stable helical structures in detergent micelles and lipid vesicles, they display significant variability in their helical propensity. This finding suggested to us that some TM domains might need to interact with other domains to properly insert and fold in hydrophobic environments. In this study, we assessed the ability of TM peptides to interact in pairwise combinations. We analyzed peptide interactions in hydrophobic milieus using circular dichroism spectroscopy and F?rster resonance energy transfer. We find that specific interactions between TM helices occur, leading to additional helical content, especially in weakly helical TM domains, suggesting that some TM domains need a partner for proper folding in the membrane. The approach developed in this study will enable complete analysis of the TM domain interactions and the modeling of a folding pathway for A(2A)R.     

The Pathogenic A391E Mutation in FGFR3 Induces a Structural Change in the Transmembrane Domain Dimer

Fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) is a single-pass membrane protein and a member of the receptor tyrosine kinase family of proteins that is involved in the regulation of skeletal growth and development. FGFR3 has three distinct domains: the ligand binding extracellular domain, the cytosolic kinase domain and the transmembrane domain (TMD). Previous work with the isolated FGFR3 TMD has shown that it has the ability to dimerize. Clinical and genetic studies have also correlated mutations in the TMD with a variety of skeletal and cranial dysplasias and cancer. Although the structures of the extracellular and cytosolic domains of FGFR3 have been solved, the structure of the TMD dimer is still unknown. Furthermore, very little is known regarding the effects of pathogenic mutations on the TMD dimer structure. We, therefore, carried out ToxR activity assays to determine the role of the SmXXXSm motif in the dimerization of the FGFR3 TMD. This motif has been shown to drive the association of many transmembrane proteins. Our results indicate that the interaction between wild-type FGFR3 TMDs is not mediated by two adjacent SmXXXSm motifs. In contrast, studies using the TMD carrying the pathogenic A391E mutation suggest that the motifs play a role in the dimerization of the mutant TMD. Based on these observations, here we report a new mechanistic model in which the pathogenic A391E mutation induces a structural change that leads to the formation of a more stable dimer.     

Atomistic mechanism of the constitutive activation of PDGFRA via its transmembrane domain

Single-point mutations in the transmembrane (TM) region of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) can lead to abnormal ligand-independent activation. We use a combination of computational modeling, NMR spectroscopy and cell experiments to analyze in detail the mechanism of how TM domains contribute to the activation of wild-type (WT) PDGFRA and its oncogenic V536E mutant. Using a computational framework, we scan all positions in PDGFRA TM helix for identification of potential functional mutations for the WT and the mutant and reveal the relationship between the receptor activity and TM dimerization via different interfaces. This strategy also allows us design a novel activating mutation in the WT (I537D) and a compensatory mutation in the V536E background eliminating its constitutive activity (S541G). We show both computationally and experimentally that single-point mutations in the TM region reshape the TM dimer ensemble and delineate the structural and dynamic determinants of spontaneous activation of PDGFRA via its TM domain. Our atomistic picture of the coupling between TM dimerization and PDGFRA activation corroborates the data obtained for other RTKs and provides a foundation for developing novel modulators of the pathological activity of PDGFRA.