Impact of winemaking practices on arginine and citrulline metabolism during and after malolactic fermentation

AIMS: To study arginine degradation and carcinogenic ethyl carbamate precursor citrulline formation during and after malolactic fermentation (MLF). METHODS AND RESULTS: MLF was induced in white wine with two commercial Oenococcus oeni strains under different winemaking conditions regarding the type of alcoholic fermentation (spontaneous, induced) and the lees management (racked, on lees). Arginine degradation and citrulline formation did not occur during malic acid degradation in any treatment. In five of the six treatments in which arginine degradation took place, it occurred 3 weeks after malic acid depletion and significant amounts of citrulline were formed. Presence of yeast lees in wines led to increased citrulline formation. Conclusions: This study suggests that arginine metabolism is inhibited in oenococci at low pH values (< 3.5) and that in the postalcoholic fermentation phase, citrulline formation from arginine degradation can be avoided if MLF is induced by pure cultures of O. oeni with inhibition of the bacterial biomass after malic acid depletion. Residual yeast lees in the wine have been identified as a significant risk factor for increased citrulline formation. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Conclusions drawn from this study allow reducing the risk of carcinogenic ethyl carbamate formation from citrulline excretion by wine lactic acid bacteria.     

Which lactic acid bacteria are responsible for histamine production in wine?

AIMS: To quantify the ability of 136 lactic acid bacteria (LAB), isolated from wine, to produce histamine and to identify the bacteria responsible for histamine production in wine. METHODS AND RESULTS: A qualitative method based on pH changes in a plate assay was used to detect wine strains capable of producing high levels of histamine. Two quantitative, highly sensitive methods were used, an enzymatic method and HPLC, to quantify the histamine produced by LAB. Finally, an improved PCR test was carried out to detect the presence of histidine decarboxylase gene in these bacteria. The species exhibiting the highest frequency of histamine production is Oenococcus oeni. However, the concentration of histamine produced by this species is lower than that produced by strains belonging to species of Lactobacillus and Pediococcus. A correlation of 100% between presence of histidine decarboxylase gene and histamine production was observed. Wines containing histamine were analysed to isolate and characterize the LAB responsible for spoilage. CONCLUSIONS: Oenococcus was able to synthesize low concentrations of histamine in wines, while Pediococcus parvulus and Lactobacillus hilgardii have been detected as spoilage, high histamine-producing bacteria in wines. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Information regarding histamine-producing LAB isolated from wines can contribute to prevent histamine formation during winemaking and storage.     

A pre-spoilage marker for bacterial activity in fortified wine, conversion of L-malic acid to L-lactic acid

Sixty-one different fortified wines, from the Douro valley, inoculated with Lactobacillus hilgardii previously isolated from a spoiled fortified wine, were sampled progressively for 280 d. Samples were analysed for volatile acidity (acetic acid) and frozen for subsequent analysis where appropriate. After 280 d, 7/61 wines showed increases in volatile acidity of >0.5 g l^-1 and were considered spoiled. Retrospective analysis of frozen samples of spoilage-positive wines showed that all had apparently undergone a malolactic conversion before the onset of heterolactic activity (acetate production). It is suggested that the monitoring of L-lactic acid might be a method of detecting activity of spoilage lactobacilli before the onset of spoilage.     

Evolution of malolactic bacteria and biogenic amines during spontaneous malolactic fermentations in a Greek winery

AIMS: To study the population dynamics of indigenous malolactic bacteria in a Greek winery and to examine their potential to produce detrimental levels of biogenic amines (BA) under winemaking conditions. METHODS AND RESULTS: Although the wines studied were of different vintage, grape variety and enological characteristics, molecular typing of malolactic bacteria revealed only a low number of strains within the single-species populations of Oenococcus oeni that developed during spontaneous fermentations. Strain MF1, originating primarily from the vineyards surrounding the winery invariably predominated in almost all samples. HPLC analysis showed a slight increase in the BA, putrescine, tyramine and phenylethylamine after malolactic conversion, while histamine, methylamine and ethylamine remained unaffected. No correlation could be established between the BA profiles and the bacterial compositions or the amino acid concentrations in wine samples studied. CONCLUSIONS: A certain regional bacterial flora is established in the winery that prevails in spontaneous malolactic fermentations (MLF) irrespective of the wine characteristics. In all cases, the BA content of the wines after malolactic conversion was within enologically acceptable levels. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This is the first report on the malolactic bacteria occurring naturally in spontaneous MLF in Greek red wines and a preliminary assessment of their impact on wine safety in relation to BA.     

Influence of wine-like conditions on arginine utilization by lactic acid bacteria

Wine can contain trace amounts of ethyl carbamate (EC), a carcinogen formed when ethanol reacts with carbamyl compounds such as citrulline. EC is produced from arginine by lactic acid bacteria (LAB), e.g., Lactobacillus and Pediococcus. Although the amounts of EC in wine are usually negligible, over the last few years there has been a slight but steady increase, as climate change has increased temperatures and alcohol levels have become proportionately higher, both of which favor EC formation. In this study, resting cells of LAB were used to evaluate the effects of ethanol, glucose, malic acid, and low pH on the ability of non-oenococcal strains of these bacteria to degrade arginine and excrete citrulline. Malic acid was found to clearly inhibit arginine consumption in all strains. The relation between citrulline produced and arginine consumed was clearly higher in the presence of ethanol (10-12%) and at low pH (3.0), which is consistent with both the decreased amount of ornithine produced from arginine and the reduction in arginine degradation. In L. brevis and L. buchneri strains isolated from wine and beer, respectively, the synthesis of citrulline from arginine was highest.     

Diversity of ethanol-tolerant lactobacilli isolated from Douro fortified wine: clustering and identification by numerical analysis of electrophoretic protein profiles

Eighty-two ethanol-tolerant (≥ 15% v/v) isolates of Lactobacillus were obtained from Douro fortified wines and associated winery equipment. The diversity and specific identity of these isolates was studied with computer-assisted comparison of the whole-cell, SDS-solubilized protein profiles (as generated by SDS-PAGE); with this method four species were identified. The majority of isolates (89%) were identified as Lact. hilgardii , and three differentiable electrophoretic groups of this species were evident. The identification was confirmed by DNA-DNA dot-blot hybridization studies. Also identified were one strain each of Lact. fructivorans, Lact. collinoides and Lact. mali.     

Degradation of free and sulfur-dioxide-bound acetaldehyde by malolactic lactic acid bacteria in white wine

AIMS: Acetaldehyde is the major carbonyl compound formed during winemaking and has implications for sensory and colour qualities of wines as well as for the use of the wine preservative SO(2). The current work investigated the degradation of acetaldehyde and SO(2)-bound acetaldehyde by two commercial Oenococcus oeni starters in white wine. METHODS AND RESULTS: Wines were produced by alcoholic fermentation with commercial yeast and adjusted to pH 3.3 and 3.6. While acetaldehyde was degraded rapidly and concurrently with malic acid at both pH values, SO(2)-bound acetaldehyde caused sluggish bacterial growth. Strain differences were small. CONCLUSIONS: Efficient degradation of acetaldehyde can be achieved by commercial starters of O. oeni. According to the results, the degradation of acetaldehyde could not be separated from malolactic conversion by oenococci. While this may be desirable in white winemaking, it may be necessary to delay malolactic fermentation (MLF) in order to allow for colour development in red wines. SO(2)-bound acetaldehyde itself maybe responsible for the sluggish or stuck MLF, and thus bound SO(2) should be considered next to free SO(2) in order to evaluate malolactic fermentability. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The current study provides new results regarding the metabolism of acetaldehyde and SO(2)-bound acetaldehyde during the MLF in white wine. The information is of significance to the wine industry and may contribute to reducing the concentration of wine preservative SO(2).     

The heterologous expression of polysaccharidase-encoding genes with oenological relevance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

AIMS: The main objective of this study was to develop polysaccharide-degrading wine strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which are able to improve aspects of wine processing and clarification, as well as colour extraction and stabilization during winemaking. METHODS AND RESULTS: Two yeast expression/secretion gene cassettes were constructed, namely (i) a pectinase gene cassette (pPPK) consisting of the endo-polygalacturonase gene (pelE) from Erwinia chrysanthemi and the pectate lyase gene (peh1) from Erwinia carotovora and (ii) a glucanase/xylanase gene cassette (pEXS) containing the endo-beta-1,4-glucanase gene (end1) from Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens and the endo-beta-1,4-xylanase gene (xynC) from Aspergillus niger. The commercial wine yeast strain, VIN13, was transformed separately with these two gene cassettes and checked for the production of pectinase, glucanase and xylanase activities. Pinot Noir, Cinsaut and Muscat d'Alexandria grape juices were fermented using the VIN13[pPPK] pectinase- and the VIN13[pEXS] glucanase/xylanase-producing transformants. Chemical analyses of the resultant wines indicated that (i) the pectinase-producing strain caused a decrease in the concentration of phenolic compounds in Pinot Noir whereas the glucanase/xylanase-producing strain caused an increase in phenolic compounds presumably because of the degradation of the grape skins; (ii) the glucanase/xylanase-producing strain caused a decrease in wine turbidity, especially in Pinot Noir wine, as well as a clear increase in colour intensity and (iii) in the Muscat d'Alexandria and Cinsaut wines, the differences between the control wines (fermented with the untransformed VIN3 strain) and the wines produced by the two transformed strains were less prominent showing that the effect of these polysaccharide-degrading enzymes is cultivar-dependent. CONCLUSIONS: The recombinant wine yeasts producing pectinase, glucanase and xylanase activities during the fermentation of Pinot Noir, Cinsaut and Muscat d'Alexandria grape juice altered the chemical composition of the resultant wines in a way that such yeasts could potentially be used to improve the clarity, colour intensity and stability and aroma of wine. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Aspects of commercial-scale wine processing and clarification, colour extraction and stabilization, and aroma enhancement could potentially be improved by the use of polysaccharide-degrading wine yeasts without the addition of expensive commercial enzyme preparations. This offers the potential to further improve the price:quality ratio of wine according to consumer expectations.     

Oxidase-peroxidase method for determination of ethanol in fermented musts and wine products

A new alcohol oxidase-peroxidase method of determination of ethanol content in fermented musts and wine products is described and compared to conventional methods routinely used in winemaking. The sensitivity, accuracy, and reliability of this method were determined. The results of ethanol determination in fermented musts and wines correlated well with the data obtained by refractometry (correlation coefficient R = 0.9595, p < 0.0001) and densitometry (correlation coefficient R = 0.9384, p < 0.0001). This method is less time- and labor-consuming and allows simultaneous testing a series of wine samples.     

Screening and typing of Patagonian wine yeasts for glycosidase activities

AIMS: The purpose of this study was to select autochthonous glycosidase producer yeasts with potential use in industrial production of Patagonian red wines. METHODS AND RESULTS: The study was carried out in oenological autochthonous yeasts from Comahue region (Argentinean North Patagonia). A set of screenable yeast phenotypic characteristics indicative of their potential usefulness in more aromatic red wine production was defined and tested in both, Saccharomyces and non-Saccharomyces populations. Twelve isolates showing six different glycosidase phenotypes were selected and they were characterized at species and strain levels using molecular methods. A close correlation between molecular and phenotypic characteristics was observed. Five strains belonging to Candida guilliermondii, C. pulcherrima and Kloeckera apiculata with highest constitutive beta-glucosidase activity levels without anthocyanase activity were discriminated. Some of them also showed constitutive beta-xylosidase and inductive alpha-rhamnosidase activities. CONCLUSIONS: The extension of the selection of oenological yeast to non-Saccharomyces species provided strains possessing novel and interesting oenological characteristics which could have significant implications in the production of more aromatic young red wine. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: As these non-Saccharomyces are indigenous to wine, they can be used in mixed starters at the beginning or as pure cultures at the end fermentation to contribute in enhancing the wine nuance that is typical of this specific area.     

Identification and physiological characteristics of heterofermentative strains of Lactobacillus from South African red wines

Nineteen atypical heterofermentative strains of Lactobacillus spp. isolated from South African red wines were identified with the API 50 CHL system and by computerized comparison of their total soluble cell protein patterns. Eleven strains were identified as Lactobacillus hilgardii and eight strains as L. brevis . Three strains of L. hilgardii and three strains of L. brevis produced small amounts of H₂S in peptone water supplemented with 001% l -cysteine. All strains produced mannitol from fructose. Proteolytic activity was detected in all except two strains of L. hilgardii . Strains capable of digesting gelatine, hydrolized casein, but not vice versa . The excessive production of sulphur-containing compounds, mannitol and acetaldehyde by lactic acid bacteria could have serious quality implications for the wine industry. Three strains of L. hilgardii and all strains of L. brevis decarboxylated l -malic acid to l -lactic acid.     

The occurrence of malolactic fermentation in brandy base wine and its influence on brandy quality

AIMS: In this study we determined the extent to which lactic acid bacteria (LAB) occurred in brandy base wines, their ability to catalyse the malolactic fermentation (MLF) and the effect of MLF on the quality of the base wine and the brandy distillate. METHODS AND RESULTS: Lactic acid bacteria were isolated and enumerated from grape juice, experimental and commercially produced brandy base wines. Spontaneous MLF occurred in approximately 50% of the commercial base wines. The occurrence of MLF had an influence on the quality of the base wines and the resulting distillates. In samples where MLF occurred there was a loss of fruitiness and in the intensity of aroma. Volatile compounds like iso-amyl acetate, ethyl acetate, ethyl caproate, 2-phenethyl acetate and hexyl acetate decreased in samples having undergone MLF, while ethyl lactate, acetic acid and diethyl succinate increased in the same samples. CONCLUSIONS: Spontaneous malolactic fermentation does occur in commercial brandy base wines and it has an influence on base wine and brandy quality. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study showed that MLF influences the quality of the base wine and the resulting distillate and with this in mind commercial base wine producers should be able to produce brandy of higher quality.     

Use of a PGU1 recombinant Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain in oenological fermentations

AIM: The aim of this work was the construction of an oenological Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain able to overexpress the PGU1 gene in order to be used in trial fermentations. METHODS AND RESULTS: The recombinant strain is able to secrete an active endopolygalacturonase into the medium leaving its fermentation ability essentially unchanged. Wines obtained with the recombinant strain and the untransformed counterpart did not differ in their physicochemical parameters or major sensory characteristics. The time needed for wine filtration was dramatically reduced in wines elaborated with the PGU1 recombinant strain, and was comparable to the filtration time shown by wines elaborated from must supplemented with fungal pectolytic enzymes. CONCLUSIONS: The oenological strain constructed in this work secretes an endopolygalacturonase into the wine in an efficient manner, resulting in an improvement in wine filtration but preserving wine typicality and keeping the methanol levels unchanged. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The PGU1 recombinant strains could be used in oenological fermentations as an alternative to commercial pectolytic enzymes of fungal origin.     

Inactivation of oenological lactic acid bacteria (Lactobacillus hilgardii and Pediococcus pentosaceus) by wine phenolic compounds

Aims:  To investigate the inactivation properties of different classes of phenolic compounds present in wine against two wine isolates of Lactobacillus hilgardii and Pediococcus pentosaceus , and to explore their inactivation mechanism.
Methods and Results:  After a first screening of the inactivation potency of 21 phenolic compounds (hydroxybenzoic and hydroxycinnamic acids, phenolic alcohols, stilbenes, flavan-3-ols and flavonols) at specific concentrations, the survival parameters (MIC and MBC) of the most active compounds were determined. For the L. hilgardii strain, the flavonols morin and kaempferol showed the strongest inactivation (MIC values of one and 5 mg l⁻¹, and MBC values of 7·5 and 50 mg l⁻¹, respectively). For the P. pentosaceus strain, flavonols also showed the strongest inactivation effects, with MIC values between one and 10 mg l⁻¹ and MBC values between 7·5 and 300 mg l⁻¹. Observations by epifluorescence and scanning electron microscopy revealed that the phenolics damaged the cell membrane and promoted the subsequent release of the cytoplasm material into the medium.
Conclusions:  The antibacterial activity of wine phenolics against L. hilgardii and P. pentosaceus was dependent on the phenolic compound tested, and led not only to bacteria inactivation, but also to the cell death.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  New information about the inactivation properties of wine lactic acid bacteria by phenolic compounds is presented. It opens up a new area of study for selecting/obtaining wine phenolic preparations with potential applications as a natural alternative to SO₂ in winemaking.     

Effect of simultaneous inoculation with yeast and bacteria on fermentation kinetics and key wine parameters of cool-climate chardonnay

Inoculating grape musts with wine yeast and lactic acid bacteria (LAB) concurrently in order to induce simultaneous alcoholic fermentation (AF) and malolactic fermentation (MLF) can be an efficient alternative to overcome potential inhibition of LAB in wines because of high ethanol concentrations and reduced nutrient content. In this study, the simultaneous inoculation of yeast and LAB into must was compared with a traditional vinification protocol, where MLF was induced after completion of AF. For this, two suitable commercial yeast-bacterium combinations were tested in cool-climate Chardonnay must. The time courses of glucose and fructose, acetaldehyde, several organic acids, and nitrogenous compounds were measured along with the final values of other key wine parameters. Sensory evaluation was done after 12 months of storage. The current study could not confirm a negative impact of simultaneous AF/MLF on fermentation success and kinetics or on final wine parameters. While acetic acid concentrations were slightly increased in wines after simultaneous AF/MLF, the differences were of neither practical nor legal significance. No statistically significant differences were found with regard to the final values of pH or total acidity and the concentrations of ethanol, acetaldehyde, glycerol, citric and lactic acids, and the nitrogen compounds arginine, ammonia, urea, citrulline, and ornithine. Sensory evaluation by a semiexpert panel confirmed the similarity of the wines. However, simultaneous inoculation led to considerable reductions in overall fermentation durations. Furthermore, differences of physiological and microbiological relevance were found. Specifically, we report the vinification of "super-dry" wines devoid of glucose and fructose after simultaneous inoculation of yeast and bacteria.     

Effect of Simultaneous Inoculation with Yeast and Bacteria on Fermentation Kinetics and Key Wine Parameters of Cool-Climate Chardonnay

Inoculating grape musts with wine yeast and lactic acid bacteria (LAB) concurrently in order to induce simultaneous alcoholic fermentation (AF) and malolactic fermentation (MLF) can be an efficient alternative to overcome potential inhibition of LAB in wines because of high ethanol concentrations and reduced nutrient content. In this study, the simultaneous inoculation of yeast and LAB into must was compared with a traditional vinification protocol, where MLF was induced after completion of AF. For this, two suitable commercial yeast-bacterium combinations were tested in cool-climate Chardonnay must. The time courses of glucose and fructose, acetaldehyde, several organic acids, and nitrogenous compounds were measured along with the final values of other key wine parameters. Sensory evaluation was done after 12 months of storage. The current study could not confirm a negative impact of simultaneous AF/MLF on fermentation success and kinetics or on final wine parameters. While acetic acid concentrations were slightly increased in wines after simultaneous AF/MLF, the differences were of neither practical nor legal significance. No statistically significant differences were found with regard to the final values of pH or total acidity and the concentrations of ethanol, acetaldehyde, glycerol, citric and lactic acids, and the nitrogen compounds arginine, ammonia, urea, citrulline, and ornithine. Sensory evaluation by a semiexpert panel confirmed the similarity of the wines. However, simultaneous inoculation led to considerable reductions in overall fermentation durations. Furthermore, differences of physiological and microbiological relevance were found. Specifically, we report the vinification of “super-dry” wines devoid of glucose and fructose after simultaneous inoculation of yeast and bacteria.     

Biogenic amine production by Lactobacillus

AIMS: The aim of this work was to demonstrate that strains of Lactobacillus may be able to produce putrescine and agmatine from one of the major amino acids present in fruit juices and wine, arginine, and from amino acid-derived ornithine. METHODS AND RESULTS: Biogenic amines were determined by HPLC. Their production in the culture medium was similar under both microaerophilic and anaerobic conditions. The presence of Mn2+ had a minimal influence on the results, whereas the addition of pyridoxal phosphate increased amine production 10-fold. Lactobacillus hilgardii X1B, isolated from wine, was able to degrade arginine by two pathways: arginine deiminase and arginine decarboxylase. The isolate was able to produce putrescine from ornithine and from agmatine. Lactobacillus plantarum strains N4 and N8, isolated from orange, utilized arginine via the arginine deiminase system. Only the N4 strain was able to produce putrescine from ornithine. CONCLUSION: It has been demonstrated that Lact. hilgardii X1B is able to produce the most important biogenic amine found in wine, putrescine, and also agmatine from arginine and ornithine, and that Lactobacillus plantarum, considered to be an innocuous spoilage micro-organism in fruit juices, is able to produce amines. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The results have significance in relation to food poisoning caused by beverages that have been contaminated with biogenic amines.     

Yeast population dynamics during the fermentation and biological aging of sherry wines

Molecular and physiological analyses were used to study the evolution of the yeast population, from alcoholic fermentation to biological aging in the process of "fino" sherry wine making. The four races of "flor" Saccharomyces cerevisiae (beticus, cheresiensis, montuliensis, and rouxii) exhibited identical restriction patterns for the region spanning the internal transcribed spacers 1 and 2 (ITS-1 and ITS-2) and the 5.8S rRNA gene, but this pattern was different, from those exhibited by non-flor S. cerevisiae strains. This flor-specific pattern was detected only after wines were fortified, never during alcoholic fermentation, and all the strains isolated from the velum exhibited the typical flor yeast pattern. By restriction fragment length polymorphism of mitochondrial DNA and karyotyping, we showed that (i) the native strain is better adapted to fermentation conditions than commercial strains; (ii) two different populations of S. cerevisiae strains are involved in the process of elaboration, of fino sherry wine, one of which is responsible for must fermentation and the other, for wine aging; and (iii) one strain was dominant in the flor population integrating the velum from sherry wines produced in González Byass wineries, although other authors have described a succession of races of flor S. cerevisiae during wine aging. Analyzing all these results together, we conclude that yeast population dynamics during biological aging is a complex phenomenon and differences between yeast populations from different wineries can be observed.     

Expression analysis of putative arcA, arcB and arcC genes partially cloned from Lactobacillus plantarum isolated from wine

AIMS: The aim of this paper was to study if homofermentative strains (Lacobacillus plantarum) capable of malolactic fermentation in wine can degrade arginine via the ADI pathway. METHODS AND RESULTS: Homofermentative lactic acid bacteria (LAB) isolated from a typical red wine were investigated for their ability to produce citrulline. Citrulline was formed suggesting that the arginine metabolism takes place via the arginine deiminase (ADI) pathway and not via the arginase/urease pathway. Ammonia was also detected with Nessler's reagent, and all the strains examined were able to produce ammonia. Identification of homofermentative LAB was performed using 16S ribosomal sequence analysis. The strains were further classified as belonging to L. plantarum species. Furthermore, the genes encoding for the three pathway enzymes (ADI, ornithine transcarbamylase, carbamate kinase) were partially cloned and gene expression was performed at two different pH values (3.6 and 4.5). CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that citrulline production in wine, could be performed by homofermentative LAB. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Homofermentative malolactic bacteria (L. plantarum) may degrade arginine through the ADI pathway.     

Increased resveratrol production in wines using engineered wine strains Saccharomyces cerevisiae EC1118 and relaxed antibiotic or auxotrophic selection

Resveratrol is a polyphenolic compound with diverse beneficial effects on human health. Red wine is the major dietary source of resveratrol but the amount that people can obtain from wines is limited. To increase the resveratrol production in wines, two expression vectors carrying 4‐coumarate: coenzyme A ligase gene (4CL) from Arabidopsis thaliana and resveratrol synthase gene (RS) from Vitis vinifera were transformed into industrial wine strain Saccharomyces cerevisiae EC1118. When cultured with 1 mM p‐coumaric acid, the engineered strains grown with and without the addition of antibiotics produced 8.249 and 3.317 mg/L of trans‐resveratrol in the culture broth, respectively. Resveratrol content of the wine fermented with engineered strains was twice higher than that of the control, indicating that our engineered strains could increase the production of resveratrol during wine fermentation. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 31:650–655, 2015