Evidence for catalytic cooperativity during ATP hydrolysis by beef heart F1-ATPase. Kinetics and binding studies with the photoaffinity label BzATP

The photoaffinity analog of ATP, 3'-O-(4-benzoyl) benzoyl ATP (BzATP), was used to covalently modify the catalytic sites on the beef heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase. In the absence of actinic illumination, BzATP was a slow substrate for the enzyme (Vmax = 0.19 mumol min-1 mg-1; kcat/Km = 2.2 X 10(6) M-1s-1) and behaved as a classical competitive inhibitor versus ATP (Ki = 0.85 microM). Under photolytic conditions, BzATP inactivated F1 with pseudo first-order kinetics, and the photoinactivation reaction showed rate saturation suggesting specific, reversible binding of BzATP to F1 prior to covalent bond formation. ATP protected against F1 photoinactivation (Kprotect = 0.3 microM) and partially covalently modified F1 yielded the same Km for ATP as unmodified enzyme. These results strongly suggested that BzATP was bound to catalytic sites on the enzyme. In the absence of photolysis, BzATP saturated two binding sites on the F1 (KD = 1.6 microM), and under photolytic conditions, 1 mol of BzATP was shown to be covalently liganded to the beta subunit of the enzyme coincident with 100% loss in ATPase activity. Previous studies with the mitochondrial F1-ATPase have suggested a mechanism involving catalytic cooperativity during ATP hydrolysis. Our demonstration of a molar stoichiometry of 1 for photoinactivation is in accord with this mechanism. It is suggested that either F1 is unable to hydrolyze covalently bound BzATP, or that subsequent to hydrolysis, the BzADP product can not be released from the catalytic site. It is therefore inferred that F1 hydrolytic activity requires cooperativity between multiple, viable catalytic sites and that covalent modification of a single catalytic site is sufficient for complete enzyme inactivation.     

The use of 8-azido-ATP and 8-azido-ADP as photoaffinity labels of the ATP synthase in submitochondrial particles: evidence for a mechanism of ATP hydrolysis involving two independent catalytic sites?

8-Azido-ATP is a substrate for the ATP synthase in submitochondrial particles with a Vmax equal to 6% of the Vmax with ATP. The Km values for 8-azido-ATP are similar to those for ATP. ATP synthase in submitochondrial particles can bind maximally 2 mol 8-N-ATP or 8-N-ADP per mole and the inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by covalently bound N-ATP or N-ADP is proportional to the saturation of the enzyme with inhibitor, similar to the results obtained with isolated F1. Both 8-N-ATP and 8-N-ADP are bound mainly to the beta subunits and at all levels of saturation the distribution of the label is 77% to the beta and 23% to the alpha subunits. It is proposed that the binding of 8-azido-AXP itself is mainly to the beta subunit, but that part of the nitreno radicals formed during excitation with light reacts with an amino acid of the alpha subunit, due to the location of the binding site at an interface between a beta and an alpha subunit. Partial saturation with 8-N-ATP, under conditions that the concentration of 8-azido-ATP during the incubation is intermediate between the low and high Km values, does not abolish the apparent negative cooperativity of ATP hydrolysis. It is concluded that this apparent cooperativity is not due to the presence of two different catalytic sites, nor to a cooperativity between the two catalytic sites, but to interaction between the catalytic sites and regulatory sites.     

The defective proton-ATPase of uncD mutants of Escherichia coli. Two mutations which affect the catalytic mechanism

The catalytic characteristics of F1-ATPases from uncD412 and uncD484 mutant strains of Escherichia coli were studied in order to understand how these beta-subunit mutations cause defective catalysis. Both mutant enzymes showed reduced affinity for ATP at the first catalytic site. While uncD412 F1 was similar to normal in other aspects of single site catalysis, uncD484 F1 showed a Keq of bound reactants greatly biased toward bound substrate ATP and an abnormally fast rate of Pi release. Impairment of productive catalytic cooperativity was the major cause of the reduced steady state ("multisite") catalytic rate in both mutant enzymes. Addition of excess ATP to saturate second and/or third catalytic sites did promote ATP hydrolysis and product release at the first catalytic site of uncD412 F1, but the multisite turnover rate was significantly slower than normal. In contrast, with uncD484 F1, addition of excess ATP induced rapid release of ATP from the first catalytic site and so productive catalytic cooperativity was almost completely absent. The results show that both mutations affect properties of the catalytic site and catalytic site cooperativity and further that the relatively more severe uncD484 mutation affects a residue which acts as a determinant of the fate of bound substrate ATP during promotion of catalysis. Taken together with previous studies of uncA mutant F1-ATPases (Wise, J. G., Latchney, L. R., Ferguson, A. M., and Senior, A. E. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1426-1432) the results indicate that catalytic site cooperativity in F1-ATPases involves concerted beta-alpha-beta intersubunit communication between catalytic sites on the beta-subunits.     

Catalytic site forms and controls in ATP synthase catalysis

A suggested minimal scheme for substrate binding by and interconversion of three forms of the catalytic sites of the ATP synthase is presented. Each binding change, that drives simultaneous interchange of the three catalytic site forms, requires a 120 degrees rotation of the gamma with respect to the beta subunits. The binding of substrate(s) at two catalytic sites is regarded as sufficing for near maximal catalytic rates to be attained. Although three sites do not need to be filled for rapid catalysis, during rapid bisite catalysis some enzyme may be transiently present with three sites filled. Forms with preferential binding for ADP and P(i) or for ATP are considered to arise from the transition state and participate in other steps of the catalysis. Intermediate forms and steps that may be involved are evaluated. Experimental evidence for energy-dependent steps and for control of coupling to proton translocation and transition state forms are reviewed. Impact of relevant past data on present understanding of catalytic events is considered. In synthesis a key step is suggested in which proton translocation begins to deform an open site so as to increase the affinity for ADP and P(i), that then bind and pass through the transition state, and yield tightly bound ATP in one binding change. ADP binding appears to be a key parameter controlling rotation during synthesis. In hydrolysis ATP binding to a loose site likely precedes any proton translocation, with proton movement occurring as the tight site form develops. Aspects needing further study are noted. Characteristics of the related MgADP inhibition of the F(1) ATPases that have undermined many observations are summarized, and relations of three-site filling to catalysis are assessed.     

The role of tightly bound ADP on chloroplast ATPase

Isolated chloroplast coupling factor 1 ATPase is known to retain about 1 mol of tightly bound ADP/mol of enzyme. Some experimental results have given evidence that the bound ADP is at catalytic sites, but this view has not been supported by observations of a slow replacement of the bound ADP when CaATP or MgATP is added. The experiments reported in this paper show why a slow replacement of ADP bound at a catalytic site can occur. When coupling factor 1, labeled with tightly bound [3H]ADP, is exposed to Mg2+ or Ca2+ prior to the addition of MgATP or CaATP, a pronounced lag in the onset of ATP hydrolysis is observed, and only slow replacement of the [3H]ADP occurs. Mg2+ or Ca2+ can induce inhibition very rapidly, as if an inhibited form of the enzyme results whenever the enzyme with tightly bound ADP encounters Mg2+ or Ca2+ prior to ATP. The inhibited form can be slowly reactivated by incubation with EDTA, although some irreversible loss in activity is encountered. In contrast, when MgATP or CaATP is added to enzyme depleted of Mg2+ and Ca2+ by incubation with EDTA, a rapid onset of ATP hydrolysis occurs and most of the tightly bound [3H]ADP is released within a few seconds, as expected for binding at a catalytic site. The Mg2+-induced inhibition of both the ATPase activity and the lack of replacement of tightly bound [3H] ADP can be largely prevented by incubation with Pi under conditions favoring Pi addition to the site containing the tightly bound ADP. Our and other results can be explained if enzyme catalysis is greatly hindered when MgADP or CaADP without accompanying Pi is tightly bound at one of the three catalytic sites on the enzyme in a high affinity conformation.     

Stepping rotation of F(1)-ATPase with one, two, or three altered catalytic sites that bind ATP only slowly

F(1)-ATPase is an ATP hydrolysis-driven motor in which the gamma subunit rotates in the stator cylinder alpha(3)beta(3). To know the coordination of three catalytic beta subunits during catalysis, hybrid F(1)-ATPases, each containing one, two, or three "slow" mutant beta subunits that bind ATP very slowly, were prepared, and the rotations were observed with a single molecule level. Each hybrid made one, two, or three steps per 360 degrees revolution, respectively, at 5 microm ATP where the wild-type enzyme rotated continuously without step under the same observing conditions. The observed dwell times of the steps are explained by the slow binding rate of ATP. Except for the steps, properties of rotation, such as the torque forces exerted during rotary movement, were not significantly changed from those of the wild-type enzyme. Thus, it appears that the presence of the slow beta subunit(s) does not seriously affect other normal beta subunit(s) in the same F(1)-ATPase molecule and that the order of sequential catalytic events is faithfully maintained even when ATP binding to one or two of the catalytic sites is retarded.     

The use of 8-azido-ATP and 8-azido-ADP as photoaffinity labels of the ATP synthase in submitochondrial particles: Evidence for a mechanism of ATP hydrolysis involving two independent catalytic sites?

8-Azido-ATP is a substrate for the ATP synthase in submitochondrial particles with a V_max equal to 6% of the V_max with ATP. The K_m values for 8-azido-ATP are similar to those for ATP. ATP synthase in submitochondrial particles can bind maximally 2 mol 8-N-ATP or 8-N-ADP per mole and the inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by covalently bound N-ATP or N-ADP is proportional to the saturation of the enzyme with inhibitor, similar to the results obtained with isolated F₁. Both 8-N-ATP and 8-N-ADP are bound mainly to the β subunits and at all levels of saturation the distribution of the label is 77% to the β and 23% to the α subunits. It is proposed that the binding of 8-azido-AXP itself is mainly to the β subunit, but that part of the nitreno radicals formed during excitation with light reacts with an amino acid of the α subunit, due to the location of the binding site at an interface between a β and an α subunit. Partial saturation with 8-N-ATP, under conditions that the concentration of 8-azido-ATP during the incubation is intermediate between the low and high K_m values, does not abolish the apparent negative cooperativity of ATP hydrolysis. It is concluded that this apparent cooperativity is not due to the presence of two different catalytic sites, nor to a cooperativity between the two catalytic sites, but to interaction between the catalytic sites and regulatory sites.     

The properties of hybrid F1-ATPase enzymes suggest that a cyclical catalytic mechanism involving three catalytic sites occurs

Maximal rates of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by F1-ATPase enzymes are known to involve strong positive catalytic site cooperativity. There are three potential catalytic nucleotide-binding sites on F1. Two important and unanswered questions are (i) whether all three potential catalytic sites must interact cooperatively to yield maximal rates of ATP hydrolysis and (ii) whether a cyclical three-site mechanism operates as suggested by several authors. We have studied these two questions here by measuring the ATPase activities of hybrid enzymes containing normal beta-, gamma-, delta-, and epsilon-subunits together with different combinations of mutant and normal alpha-subunits. The mutant alpha-subunits were derived from uncA401, uncA447, and uncA453 mutant E. coli F1-ATPase, in which positive cooperativity between catalytic sites is strongly attenuated by defined mis-sense mutations. Our data show that three normal catalytic sites are required to interact in order to achieve maximal ATPase rates and suggest that a cyclical mechanism does operate. Hybrid enzyme containing one-third mutant alpha-subunit and two-thirds normal alpha-subunits had substantial but submaximal activity, showing that cooperativity between three sites in a noncyclical fashion, or between pairs of sites, can achieve effective catalysis.     

Derivatization of the catalytic subunits of the chloroplast ATPase by 2-azido-ATP and dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. Evidence for catalytically induced interchange of the subunits

Modifications of the catalytic beta subunits of the chloroplast ATPase (CF1-ATPase) are reported which support the proposal that all three subunits participate sequentially during catalysis. The beta subunits of the CF1-ATPase are sufficiently homogeneous to allow detection of their derivatization with dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) or the substrate analog 2-azido-ATP by two-dimensional isoelectric focusing. Whether the DCCD reacts with the same beta subunit that tightly binds ATP has not been known. Our results show that when CF1-ATPase is covalently labeled with 2-azido-ATP followed by reaction with DCCD, different beta subunits are labeled. The DCCD labeling does not stop catalytic cooperativity of the CF1-ATPase and allows slow enzyme turnover. When the DCCD-modified enzyme catalyzes 2-azido-ATP cleavage and the enzyme with tightly bound nucleotide is photolyzed, both DCCD-modified and unmodified subunits are randomly labeled by the azido nucleotide. This result is as expected if during the catalytic cycle one beta subunit with unique properties is replaced by another subunit that gains these properties. The participation of all three subunits in the catalytic cycle is suggested by the apparent retention of catalytic cooperativity by the two remaining subunits after one subunit has already catalyzed 2-azido-ATP cleavage and been labeled.     

Ordered ATP hydrolysis in the gamma complex clamp loader AAA+ machine

The gamma complex couples ATP hydrolysis to the loading of beta sliding clamps onto DNA for processive replication. The gamma complex structure shows that the clamp loader subunits are arranged as a circular heteropentamer. The three gamma motor subunits bind ATP, the delta wrench opens the beta ring, and the delta' stator modulates the delta-beta interaction. Neither delta nor delta' bind ATP. This report demonstrates that the delta' stator contributes a catalytic arginine for hydrolysis of ATP bound to the adjacent gamma(1) subunit. Thus, the delta' stator contributes to the motor function of the gamma trimer. Mutation of arginine 169 of gamma, which removes the catalytic arginines from only the gamma(2) and gamma(3) ATP sites, abolishes ATPase activity even though ATP site 1 is intact and all three sites are filled. This result implies that hydrolysis of the three ATP molecules occurs in a particular order, the reverse of ATP binding, where ATP in site 1 is not hydrolyzed until ATP in sites 2 and/or 3 is hydrolyzed. Implications of these results to clamp loaders of other systems are discussed.     

Mechanical modulation of catalytic power on F1-ATPase

The conformational fluctuation of enzymes has a crucial role in reaction acceleration. However, the contribution to catalysis enhancement of individual substates with conformations far from the average conformation remains unclear. We studied the catalytic power of the rotary molecular motor F(1)-ATPase from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 as it was stalled in transient conformations far from a stable pausing angle. The rate constants of ATP binding and hydrolysis were determined as functions of the rotary angle. Both rates exponentially increase with rotation, revealing the molecular basis of positive cooperativity among three catalytic sites: elementary reaction steps are accelerated via the mechanical rotation driven by other reactions on neighboring catalytic sites. The rate enhancement induced by ATP binding upon rotation was greater than that brought about by hydrolysis, suggesting that the ATP binding step contributes more to torque generation than does the hydrolysis step. Additionally, 9% of the ATP-driven rotary step was supported by thermal diffusion, suggesting that acceleration of the ATP docking process occurs via thermally agitated conformational fluctuations.     

Cross-linking of two beta subunits in the closed conformation in F1-ATPase

In the crystal structure of mitochondrial F1-ATPase, two beta subunits with a bound Mg-nucleotide are in "closed" conformations, whereas the third beta subunit without bound nucleotide is in an "open" conformation. In this "CCO" (beta-closed beta-closed beta-open) conformational state, Ile-390s of the two closed beta subunits, even though they are separated by an intervening alpha subunit, have a direct contact. We replaced the equivalent Ile of the alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex of thermophilic F1-ATPase with Cys and observed the formation of the beta-beta cross-link through a disulfide bond. The analysis of conditions required for the cross-link formation indicates that: (i) F1-ATPase takes the CCO conformation when two catalytic sites are filled with Mg-nucleotide, (ii) intermediate(s) with the CCO conformation are generated during catalytic cycle, (iii) the Mg-ADP inhibited form is in the CCO conformation, and (iv) F1-ATPase dwells in conformational state(s) other than CCO when only one (or none) of catalytic sites is filled by Mg-nucleotide or when catalytic sites are filled by Mg2+-free nucleotide. The alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex containing the beta-beta cross-link retained the activity of uni-site catalysis but lost that of multiple catalytic turnover, suggesting that open-closed transition of beta subunits is required for the rotation of gamma subunit but not for hydrolysis of a single ATP.     

A perspective of the binding change mechanism for ATP synthesis

An overview of research in the field of bioenergetics that led to the development of the binding change mechanism for ATP synthesis is presented, with emphasis on research from the author's laboratory. The text follows closely the Rose Award Lecture given at the 1989 meeting of the American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology. Remarkable advances have revealed that the ubiquitous membrane-bound ATP synthase has unusual composition and properties. The enzyme complex has 1, 2, 3, or 9-12 copies of eight or more protein subunits. The catalytic sites are located on three copies of an approximately 55-kDa subunit. It has the strongest positive catalytic cooperativity known for any enzyme. Examples are given of selected experimental results that have provided insights into its mechanism. These include demonstration of the characteristics, location, and function of catalytic and noncatalytic adenine nucleotide binding sites and the incisive information provided by measurement of phosphate oxygen exchanges and distribution of 18(O) in ATP or Pi formed by catalysis. Research from various laboratories gives support to the binding change mechanism in which energy from proton translocation serves principally to promote release of tightly bound ATP, with sequential participation of three catalytic sites. Some speculative suggestions about a rotational catalysis and about the different forms assumed by the ATPase are included.     

Adenine nucleotide-binding sites on beef heart F1-ATPase. Conditions that affect occupancy of catalytic and noncatalytic sites

Beef heart mitochondrial F1 contains a total of six adenine nucleotide-binding sites including at least two different types of sites. Three "exchangeable" sites exchange rapidly during hydrolysis of MgATP, whereas three "nonexchangeable" sites do not (Cross, R. L. and Nalin, C. M. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 2874-2881). When F1 that has been stored as a suspension in (NH4)2SO4/ATP/EDTA/sucrose/Tris, pH 8.0, is pelleted, rinsed with (NH4)2SO4, dissolved, and desalted, it retains three bound adenine nucleotides. We find that two of these endogenous nucleotides are bound at nonexchangeable sites and one at an exchangeable site. The vacant nonexchangeable site is highly specific for adenine nucleotide and is rapidly filled by ADP upon addition of ADP or during ATP hydrolysis. ADP bound at this site can be removed by reprecipitating the enzyme with (NH4)2SO4. The single nucleotide retained by desalted F1 at an exchangeable site is displaced during hydrolysis of ATP, GTP, or ITP. The binding of PPi at two sites on the enzyme also promotes its dissociation. Neither procedure affects retention of nucleotide at the nonexchangeable sites. These observations, combined with the finding that PPi is much more easily removed from exchangeable sites than ADP, have led to the development of a procedure for preparing F1 with uniform and well-defined nucleotide site occupancy. This involves sequential exposure to MgATP, PPi, and high concentrations of Pi. Unbound ligand is removed between each step. The resulting enzyme, F1[3,0], has three occupied nonexchangeable sites and three vacant exchangeable sites. Evidence that nonexchangeable and exchangeable sites represent noncatalytic and catalytic sites, respectively, suggest that this form of the enzyme will prove useful in numerous applications, including transient kinetic measurements and affinity labeling of active site residues.