Efficiency of correct nucleotide insertion governs DNA polymerase fidelity

DNA polymerase fidelity or specificity expresses the ability of a polymerase to select a correct nucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) from a pool of structurally similar molecules. Fidelity is quantified from the ratio of specificity constants (catalytic efficiencies) for alternate substrates (i.e. correct and incorrect dNTPs). An analysis of the efficiency of dNTP (correct and incorrect) insertion for a low fidelity mutant of DNA polymerase beta (R283A) and exonuclease-deficient DNA polymerases from five families derived from a variety of biological sources reveals that a strong correlation exists between the ability to synthesize DNA and the probability that the polymerase will make a mistake (i.e. base substitution error). Unexpectedly, this analysis indicates that the difference between low and high fidelity DNA polymerases is related to the efficiency of correct, but not incorrect, nucleotide insertion. In contrast to the loss of fidelity observed with the catalytically inefficient R283A mutant, the fidelity of another inefficient mutant of DNA polymerase beta (G274P) is not altered. Thus, although all natural low fidelity DNA polymerases are inefficient, not every inefficient DNA polymerase has low fidelity. Low fidelity polymerases appear to be an evolutionary solution to how to replicate damaged DNA or DNA repair intermediates without burdening the genome with excessive polymerase-initiated errors.     

DNA Polymerase β Ribonucleotide Discrimination: INSERTION,MISINSERTION, EXTENSION,AND CODING*

DNA polymerases must select nucleotides that preserve Watson-Crick base pairing rules and choose substrates with the correct (deoxyribose) sugar. Sugar discrimination represents a great challenge because ribonucleotide triphosphates are present at much higher cellular concentrations than their deoxy-counterparts. Although DNA polymerases discriminate against ribonucleotides, many therapeutic nucleotide analogs that target polymerases have sugar modifications, and their efficacy depends on their ability to be incorporated into DNA. Here, we investigate the ability of DNA polymerase β to utilize nucleotides with modified sugars. DNA polymerase β readily inserts dideoxynucleoside triphosphates but inserts ribonucleotides nearly 4 orders of magnitude less efficiently than natural deoxynucleotides. The efficiency of ribonucleotide insertion is similar to that reported for other DNA polymerases. The poor polymerase-dependent insertion represents a key step in discriminating against ribonucleotides because, once inserted, a ribonucleotide is easily extended. Likewise, a templating ribonucleotide has little effect on insertion efficiency or fidelity. In contrast to insertion and extension of a ribonucleotide, the chemotherapeutic drug arabinofuranosylcytosine triphosphate is efficiently inserted but poorly extended. These results suggest that the sugar pucker at the primer terminus plays a crucial role in DNA synthesis; a 3′-endo sugar pucker facilitates nucleotide insertion, whereas a 2′-endo conformation inhibits insertion.     

Kinetic analysis of base substitution mutagenesis by transient misalignment of DNA and by miscoding

We measured the insertion fidelity of DNA polymerases alpha and beta and yeast DNA polymerase I at a template site that was previously observed to yield a high frequency of T----G transversions when copied by DNA polymerase beta but not by the other two polymerases. The results provide direct biochemical evidence that base substitution errors by DNA polymerase beta can result from a dislocation mechanism governed by DNA template-primer misalignment. In contrast to DNA polymerase beta, neither Drosophila DNA polymerase alpha nor yeast DNA polymerase I appear to misinsert nucleotides by a dislocation mechanism in either the genetic or kinetic fidelity assays. Dislocation errors by DNA polymerase beta are characterized primarily by a substantial reduction in the apparent Km for inserting a "correct," but ultimately errant, nucleotide compared to the apparent Km governing direct misinsertion. For synthesis by DNA polymerase beta, dislocation results in a 35-fold increase in dCMP incorporation opposite template T (T----G transversion) and a 20-35-fold increase in dTMP incorporation opposite T (T----A transversion); these results are consistent with parallel genetic fidelity measurements. DNA polymerase beta also produces base substitution errors by direct misinsertion. Here nucleotide insertion fidelity results from substantial differences in both Km and Vmax for correct versus incorrect substrates and is influenced strongly by local base sequence.     

Poliovirus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (3Dpol): kinetic, thermodynamic, and structural analysis of ribonucleotide selection

We have performed a kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of 3D(pol) derivatives containing substitutions in the ribose-binding pocket with ATP analogues containing correct and incorrect sugar configurations. We find that Asp-238, a residue in structural motif A that is conserved in all RNA-dependent RNA polymerases, is a key determinant of polymerase fidelity. Alterations in the position of the Asp-238 side chain destabilize the catalytically competent 3D(pol)-primer/template-NTP complex and reduce the efficiency of phosphoryl transfer. The reduction in phosphoryl transfer may be a reflection of increased mobility of other residues in motif A that are required for stabilizing the triphosphate moiety of the nucleotide substrate in the active conformation. We present a structural model to explain how Asp-238 functions to select nucleotides with a correct sugar configuration and a correct base. We propose that this mechanism is employed by all RNA-dependent RNA polymerases. We discuss the possibility that all nucleic acid polymerases with the canonical "palm"-based active site employ a similar mechanism to maximize fidelity.     

Pre-steady-state kinetic studies of the fidelity of Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 DNA polymerase IV

Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 DNA polymerase IV (Dpo4) is a thermostable archaeal enzyme and a member of the error-prone and lesion-bypass Y-family. In this paper, for the first time, the fidelity of a Y-family polymerase, Dpo4, was determined using pre-steady-state kinetic analysis of the incorporation of a single nucleotide into an undamaged DNA substrate 21/41-mer at 37 degrees C. We assessed single-turnover (with Dpo4 in molar excess over DNA) saturation kinetics for all 16 possible nucleotide incorporations. The fidelity of Dpo4 was estimated to be in the range of 10(-3)-10(-4). Interestingly, the ground-state binding affinity of correct nucleotides (70-230 microM) is 10-50-fold weaker than those of replicative DNA polymerases. Such a low affinity is consistent with the lack of interactions between Dpo4 and the bound nucleotides as revealed in the crystal structure of Dpo4, DNA, and a matched nucleotide. The affinity of incorrect nucleotides for Dpo4 is approximately 2-10-fold weaker than that of correct nucleotides. Intriguingly, the mismatched dCTP has an affinity similar to that of the matched nucleotides when it is incorporated against a pyrimidine template base flanked by a 5'-template guanine. The incoming dCTP likely skips the first available template base and base pairs with the 5'-template guanine, as observed in the crystal structure of Dpo4, DNA, and a mismatched nucleotide. The mismatch incorporation rates, regardless of the 5'-template base, were approximately 2-3 orders of magnitude slower than the incorporation rates for matched nucleotides, which is the predominant contribution to the fidelity of Dpo4.     

phi 29 DNA polymerase residue Leu384, highly conserved in motif B of eukaryotic type DNA replicases,is involved in nucleotide insertion fidelity

Replicative DNA polymerases achieve insertion fidelity by geometric selection of a complementary nucleotide followed by induced fit: movement of the fingers subdomain toward the active site to enclose the incoming and templating nucleotides generating a binding pocket for the nascent base pair. Several residues of motif B of DNA polymerases from families A and B, localized in the fingers subdomain, have been described to be involved in template/primer binding and dNTP selection. Here we complete the analysis of this motif, which has the consensus "KLX2NSXYG" in DNA polymerases from family B, characterized by mutational analysis of conserved leucine, Leu384 of phi 29 DNA polymerase. Mutation of Leu384 into Arg resulted in a phi 29 DNA polymerase with reduced nucleotide insertion fidelity during DNA-primed polymerization and protein-primed initiation reactions. However, the mutation did not alter the intrinsic affinity for the different dNTPs, as shown in the template-independent terminal protein-deoxynucleotidylation reaction. We conclude that Leu384 of phi 29 DNA polymerase plays an important role in positioning the templating nucleotide at the polymerization active site and in controlling nucleotide insertion fidelity. This agrees with the localization of the corresponding residue in the closed ternary complexes of family A and family B DNA polymerases, contributing to form the binding pocket for the nascent base pair. As an additional effect, mutant polymerase L384R was strongly reduced in DNA binding, resulting in reduced processivity during polymerization.     

Yeast DNA polymerase eta utilizes an induced-fit mechanism of nucleotide incorporation.

DNA polymerase eta (Poleta) is unique among eukaryotic DNA polymerases in its proficient ability to replicate through distorting DNA lesions, and Poleta synthesizes DNA with a low fidelity. Here, we use pre-steady-state kinetics to investigate the mechanism of nucleotide incorporation by Poleta and show that it utilizes an induced-fit mechanism to selectively incorporate the correct nucleotide. Poleta discriminates poorly between the correct and incorrect nucleotide at both the initial nucleotide binding step and at the subsequent induced-fit conformational change step, which precedes the chemical step of phosphodiester bond formation. This property enables Poleta to bypass lesions with distorted DNA geometries, and it bestows upon the enzyme a low fidelity.     

Bumps in the road: how replicative DNA polymerases see DNA damage

Significant advances have been made recently in the study of polymerases. First came the realization that there are many more DNA polymerases than originally thought; indeed, no fewer than 14 template-dependent DNA polymerases are found in mammals. Concurrent structural studies of DNA polymerases bound to DNA and incoming nucleotide have revealed how these remarkable copying machines select the correct deoxynucleoside triphosphate among a sea of nucleotides. A whole new level of insight into DNA replication fidelity has been reached as a result of recently determined crystal structures of DNA lesions in the context of the active sites of repair, replicative and specialized DNA polymerases. These structures illustrate why some lesions can be bypassed readily, whereas others are strong blocks to DNA replication.     

DNA合成的忠实性机制

DNA的忠实性合成对于基因组稳定和物种延续至关重要,否则可能会产生严重的后果。DNA合成具有极高的忠实性,这主要基于3个步骤:(1)基于氢键、碱基对构象或其他因素的核苷酸选择;(2)基于3′→5′外切酶活性的校对,方式有顺式校对和反式校对,可以去除错误掺入的核苷酸;(3)基于错配修复、切除修复、同源重组修复和跨损伤DNA合成的修复过程,可以纠正逃过校对的错误核苷酸。由于DNA聚合酶不仅可以作为抗病毒或抗癌药物的靶标,而且其忠实性还与抗药性或药物副作用有关,所以深入研究DNA合成的忠实性具有非常重要的意义。文章主要论述了DNA合成的忠实性机制,并对DNA聚合酶的应用前景做了展望。     

Human DNA polymerase iota utilizes different nucleotide incorporation mechanisms dependent upon the template base

Human DNA polymerase ι (Polι) is a member of the Y family of DNA polymerases involved in translesion DNA synthesis. Polι is highly unusual in that it possesses a high fidelity on template A, but has an unprecedented low fidelity on template T, preferring to misincorporate a G instead of an A. To understand the mechanisms of nucleotide incorporation opposite different template bases by Polι, we have carried out pre-steady-state kinetic analyses of nucleotide incorporation opposite templates A and T. These analyses have revealed that opposite template A, the correct nucleotide is preferred because it is bound tighter and is incorporated faster than the incorrect nucleotides. Opposite template T, however, the correct and incorrect nucleotides are incorporated at very similar rates, and interestingly, the greater efficiency of G misincorporation relative to A incorporation opposite T arises predominantly from the tighter binding of G. Based on these results, we propose that the incipient base pair is accommodated differently in the active site of Polι dependent upon the template base and that when T is the templating base, Polι accommodates the wobble base pair better than the Watson-Crick base pair.     

Polymerase beta simulations suggest that Arg258 rotation is a slow step rather than large subdomain motions per se

The large-scale opening motion of mammalian DNA polymerase beta is followed at atomic resolution by dynamic simulations that link crystal "closed" and "open" conformations. The closing/opening conformational change is thought to be key to the ability of polymerases to choose a correct nucleotide (through "induced fit") and hence maintain DNA repair synthesis fidelity. Corroborating available structural and kinetic measurements, our studies bridge static microscopic crystal structures with macroscopic kinetic data by delineating a specific sequence, Phe272 ring flip, large thumb movement, Arg258 rotation with release of catalytic Mg2+, together with estimated time-scales, that suggest the Arg258 rearrangement as a limiting factor of large subdomain motions. If similarly slow in the closing motion, this conformational change might be restricted further when an incorrect nucleotide binds and thus play a role in pol beta's selectivity for the correct nucleotide. These results suggest new lines of experimentation in the study of polymerase mechanisms (e.g. enzyme mutants), which should provide further insights into mechanisms of error discrimination and DNA synthesis fidelity.     

Consecutive incorporation of fluorophore-labeled nucleotides by mammalian DNA polymerase β

In the present study, we investigated mammalian polymerases that consecutively incorporate various fluorophore-labeled nucleotides. We found that rat DNA polymerase β (pol β) consecutively incorporated fluorophore-labeled nucleotides to a greater extent than four bacterial polymerases, Sequenase Version 2.0, Vent_R (exo-), DNA polymerase IIIα and the Klenow fragment, and the mammalian polymerases DNA polymerase α and human DNA polymerase δ, under mesophilic conditions. Furthermore, we investigated the kinetics of correct or mismatched incorporation with labeled nucleotides during synthesis by rat pol β. The kinetic parameters K_m and k_cat were measured and used for evaluating: (i) the discrimination against correct pair incorporation of labeled nucleotides relative to unlabeled nucleotides; and (ii) the fidelity for all nucleotide combinations of mismatched pairs in the presence of labeled or unlabeled nucleotides. We also investigated the effect of fluorophore-labeled nucleotides on terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase activity of rat pol β. We have demonstrated for the first time that mammalian pol β can consecutively incorporate various fluorophore-labeled dNTPs. These findings suggest that pol β is useful for high-density labeling of DNA probes and single-molecule sequencing for high-speed genome analysis.     

Pre-steady-state kinetic studies of the fidelity and mechanism of polymerization catalyzed by truncated human DNA polymerase lambda

DNA polymerase lambda (Pollambda), a member of the X-family DNA polymerases, possesses an N-terminal BRCT domain, a proline-rich domain, and a C-terminal polymerase beta-like domain (tPollambda). In this paper, we determined a minimal kinetic mechanism and the fidelity of tPollambda using pre-steady-state kinetic analysis of the incorporation of a single nucleotide into a one-nucleotide gapped DNA substrate, 21-19/41-mer (primer-primer/template). Our kinetic studies revealed an incoming nucleotide bound to the enzyme.DNA binary complex at a rate constant of 1.55 x 10(8) M(-1) s(-1) to form a ground-state ternary complex while the nucleotide dissociated from this complex at a rate constant of 300 s(-1). Since DNA dissociation from tPollambda (0.8 s(-1)) was less than 3-fold slower than polymerization, we measured saturation kinetics for all 16 possible nucleotide incorporations under single turnover conditions to eliminate the complication resulting from multiple turnovers. The fidelity of tPollambda was estimated to be in the range of 10(-2)-10(-4) and was sequence-dependent. Surprisingly, the ground-state binding affinity of correct (1.1-2.4 microM) and incorrect nucleotides (1.4-8.4 microM) was very similar while correct nucleotides (3-6 s(-1)) were incorporated much faster than incorrect nucleotides (0.001-0.2 s(-1)). Interestingly, the misincorporation of dGTP opposite a template base thymine (0.2 s(-1)) was more rapid than all other misincorporations, leading to the lowest fidelity (3.2 x 10(-2)) among all mismatched base pairs. Additionally, tPollambda was found to possess weak strand-displacement activity during polymerization. These biochemical properties suggest that Pollambda likely fills short-patched DNA gaps in base excision repair pathways and participates in mammalian nonhomologous end-joining pathways to repair double-stranded DNA breaks.     

Enhanced ribonucleotide incorporation by an O-helix mutant of Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I

The O-helix of DNA polymerases has been implicated in substrate discrimination and replication fidelity. In this study, wild-type Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I (Taq pol I) and an O-helix mutant A661E was examined for their ability to discriminate between ribonucleotides and deoxyribonucleotides. Steady-state nucleotide extension kinetics were carried out using a template cytidine and each nucleotide dNTP and rGTP. Wild-type Taq pol I and A661E demonstrated similar Vmax and Km values for the correct nucleotide dGTP. However, A661E discriminated between incorrect and correct nucleotide less well than wild-type; discrimination was reduced by factors of 9.5-, 5.6- and 15-fold for dATP, dTTP and rGTP, respectively. These data suggest that A661E is efficient polymerases in the presence of the correct deoxynucleotide, dGTP, but it is impaired in ability to discriminate between correct and incorrect deoxyribonucleotides or between ribo- and deoxyribonucleotides. A structural model of Taq pol I is described in which the mutation A661E alters the interactions between the O-helix and the terminal two phosphate groups in the primer strand.     

Low fidelity DNA synthesis by a y family DNA polymerase due to misalignment in the active site

Sulfolobus solfataricus DNA polymerase IV (Dpo4) is a member of the Y family of DNA polymerases whose crystal structure has recently been solved. As a model for other evolutionarily conserved Y family members that perform translesion DNA synthesis and have low fidelity, we describe here the base substitution and frameshift fidelity of DNA synthesis by Dpo4. Dpo4 generates all 12 base-base mismatches at high rates, 11 of which are similar to those of its human homolog, DNA polymerase kappa. This result is consistent with the Dpo4 structure, implying lower geometric selection for correct base pairs. Surprisingly, Dpo4 generates C.dCMP mismatches at an unusually high average rate and preferentially at cytosine flanked by 5'-template guanine. Dpo4 also has very low frameshift fidelity and frequently generates deletions of even noniterated nucleotides, especially cytosine flanked by a 5'-template guanine. Both unusual features of error specificity suggest that Dpo4 can incorporate dNTP precursors when two template nucleotides are present in the active site binding pocket. These results have implications for mutagenesis resulting from DNA synthesis by Y family polymerases.     

Regulation of DNA repair fidelity by molecular checkpoints: "gates" in DNA polymerase beta's substrate selection

With an increasing number of structural, kinetic, and modeling studies of diverse DNA polymerases in various contexts, a complex dynamical view of how atomic motions might define molecular "gates" or checkpoints that contribute to polymerase specificity and efficiency is emerging. Such atomic-level information can offer insights into rate-limiting conformational and chemical steps to help piece together mechanistic views of polymerases in action. With recent advances, modeling and dynamics simulations, subject to the well-appreciated limitations, can access transition states and transient intermediates along a reaction pathway, both conformational and chemical, and such information can help bridge the gap between experimentally determined equilibrium structures and mechanistic enzymology data. Focusing on DNA polymerase beta (pol beta), we present an emerging view of the geometric, energetic, and dynamic selection criteria governing insertion rate and fidelity mechanisms of DNA polymerases, as gleaned from various computational studies and based on the large body of existing kinetic and structural data. The landscape of nucleotide insertion for pol beta includes conformational changes, prechemistry, and chemistry "avenues", each with a unique deterministic or stochastic pathway that includes checkpoints for selective control of nucleotide insertion efficiency. For both correct and incorrect incoming nucleotides, pol beta's conformational rearrangements before chemistry include a cascade of slow and subtle side chain rearrangements, followed by active site adjustments to overcome higher chemical barriers, which include critical ion-polymerase geometries; this latter notion of a prechemistry avenue fits well with recent structural and NMR data. The chemical step involves an associative mechanism with several possibilities for the initial proton transfer and for the interaction among the active site residues and bridging water molecules. The conformational and chemical events and associated barriers define checkpoints that control enzymatic efficiency and fidelity. Understanding the nature of such active site rearrangements can facilitate interpretation of existing data and stimulate new experiments that aim to probe enzyme features that contribute to fidelity discrimination across various polymerases via such geometric, dynamic, and energetic selection criteria.     

Mechanism of efficient and accurate nucleotide incorporation opposite 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine by Saccharomyces cerevisiae DNA polymerase eta

Most DNA polymerases incorporate nucleotides opposite template 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) lesions with reduced efficiency and accuracy. DNA polymerase (Pol) eta, which catalyzes the error-free replication of template thymine-thymine (TT) dimers, has the unique ability to accurately and efficiently incorporate nucleotides opposite 8-oxoG templates. Here we have used pre-steady-state kinetics to examine the mechanisms of correct and incorrect nucleotide incorporation opposite G and 8-oxoG by Saccharomyces cerevisiae Pol eta. We found that Pol eta binds the incoming correct dCTP opposite both G and 8-oxoG with similar affinities, and it incorporates the correct nucleotide bound opposite both G and 8-oxoG with similar rates. While Pol eta incorporates an incorrect A opposite 8-oxoG with lower efficiency than it incorporates a correct C, it does incorporate A more efficiently opposite 8-oxoG than opposite G. This is mainly due to greater binding affinity for the incorrect incoming dATP opposite 8-oxoG. Overall, these results show that Pol eta replicates through 8-oxoG without any barriers introduced by the presence of the lesion.     

Amino acid substitutions at conserved tyrosine 52 alter fidelity and bypass efficiency of human DNA polymerase eta

DNA polymerase eta (Pol eta) is a member of a new class of DNA polymerases that is able to copy DNA containing damaged nucleotides. These polymerases are highly error-prone during copying of unaltered DNA templates. We analyzed the relationship between bypass efficiency and fidelity of DNA synthesis by introducing substitutions for Tyr-52, a highly conserved amino acid, within the human DNA polymerase eta (hPol eta) finger domain. Most substitutions for Tyr-52 caused reduction in bypass of UV-associated damage, measured by the ability to rescue the viability of UV-sensitive yeast cells at a high UV dose. For most mutants, the reduction in bypass ability paralleled the reduction in polymerization activity. Interestingly, the hPol eta Y52E mutant exhibited a greater reduction in bypass efficiency than polymerization activity. The reduction in bypass efficiency was accompanied by an up to 11-fold increase in the incorporation of complementary nucleotides relative to non-complementary nucleotides. The fidelity of DNA synthesis, measured by copying a gapped M13 DNA template in vitro, was also enhanced as much as 15-fold; the enhancement resulted from a decrease in transitions, which were relatively frequent, and a large decrease in transversions. Our demonstration that an amino acid substitution within the active site enhances the fidelity of DNA synthesis by hPol eta, one of the most inaccurate of DNA polymerases, supports the hypothesis that even error-prone DNA polymerases function in base selection.     

Distinctive properties of mammalian DNA polymerases.

DNA polymerase-alpha and -beta can be distinguished from one another by the differential effects of N-ethylmaleimide, KCl, ara-CTP and temperature, as well as on the basis of sedimentation. The sensitivity of DNA polymerase-beta to elevated temperatures as compared to DNA polymerase-alpha provides a new means of distinguishing between these two enzymes even in crude extracts and a possible probe for determining their function. DNA polymerase-alpha and -beta share several properties in common, including the ability to readily incorporate dUTP in place of dTTP. The Km for dUTP varies from 10 to 30 micron with different preparations of DNA polymerase-alpha and -beta. Thus, in mammalian cells, dUMP could be incorporated into DNA, and if excised by an endonuclease, would lead to discontinuities. Initial analyses of fidelity in direct comparative studies indicate that beta-class DNA polymerases are highly accurate in base selection when copying poly[d(A-T)]. Less than one molecule of dGMP is incorporated for every 12 000-45 000 molecules of dAMP and dTMP polymerized. DNA polymerase-alpha is somewhat less accurate, making one mistake for every 4000-10 000 correct nucleotides incorporated. Since both polymerases lack an exonucleolytic activity, this accuracy must be the result of selectivity for the complementary nucleotide by the polymerase.