Chiral beta-particles interact differentially with enantiomers--theory to solve a long-existing debate.

The crucial organic molecules associated with life are chiral. Beta irradiation on the causal origin for the great preference of biomolecules in life over their corresponding enantiomers has been extensively studied. The left helical beta electrons, with spin and momentum antiparallel, should propagate with different velocities in the two enantiomers. Much effort has been done to investigate possible mechanism of inducing asymmetry, using longitudinally polarized beta rays to decompose asymmetrically racemic mixtures of biomolecules, but the results were inconclusive and contradictory. In this paper we present our viewpoint that the direct inelastic scattering between polarized electrons and chiral molecules is the dominant one in producing the asymmetry of cross sections for both beta+ and beta- irradiation. The inelastic cross section sigma (0 --> n) is dependent on the dipole strength Dn, rotatory strength Rn of the molecule. According to the theoretical study, the asymmetry of cross section F is approximately 10(-6) and it depends on the sign of Rn+(L type). When Rn+ > 0, sigma D > sigma L, it favors L-amino acid surviving. When Rn+ < 0, sigma D < sigma L, it favours D-amino acid surviving. Our results show that helical electrons do distinguish between molecules of opposite chirality, and the disputation and suspicion about the controversial experimental results between Garay and Darge & Thiemann can be explained.     

Neutral currents in weak interactions and molecular asymmetry

Weak interactions are parity violating forces, i.e. they differentiate between mirror images. Therefore it is a very attractive hypothesis to invoke weak interactions in explaining the origin of molecular asymmetry. It is, however, not clear whether weak interactions may operate between electrons and/or between electrons and protons? For these types of interactions so called neutral currents are needed. Recent experiments with muon neutrinos at CERN gave some evidence for the existence of neutral currents. Thus we may suppose that parity violating forces are active in molecules. In the first part of this paper a very elementary theory of weak interactions is outlined with special reference to the discovery of neutral currents. In the second part we show how weak interactions may differentiate between mirror image molecules. The asymmetrically distributed static charges in chiral molecules represent a helical potential field. This potential field may exert an effect on the orbital electrons and therefore coupling of spins and momenta occurs. Thus the enantiomers are parity transformed images not only as geometrical bodies, but their orbital electrons are parity transformed too as "a helical electron gas". Weak interactions will differentiate between L and D forms because their orbital electrons have a nonzero spin polarization with respect to their velocity.     

Chirality-dependent interactions between molecular propeller structures in solution. Chiral recognition and discrimination processes modulated by temperature and incremental changes in structural chirality

Time-resolved chiroptical luminescence (TR-CL) measurements are used to study chirality-dependent intermolecular interactions in dynamic excited-state quenching processes. The measurements are carried out on solution samples that contain a racemic mixture of chiral luminophore molecules (with enantiomeric structures denoted by LambdaL and DeltaL) and a small, optically resolved concentration of chiral quencher (CQ) molecules. The luminophores are excited with a pulse of linearly polarized laser radiation to produce an initially racemic excited-state population of LambdaL* and DeltaL* enantiomers, and TR-CL measurements are then used to monitor the differential decay kinetics of the LambdaL* and DeltaL* subpopulations. Observed differences between the LambdaL* and DeltaL* decay kinetics reflect differential rate processes and efficiencies for LambdaL*-CQ vs. DeltaL*-CQ quenching actions, and they are diagnostic of chiral discriminatory interactions between the luminophore and quencher molecules. Twelve different luminophore-quencher systems are examined, in both H(2)O and D(2)O solutions, and in each case the quenching kinetics are measured over the 273-308 K temperature range. In all of the systems examined here, quenching occurs via electronic energy-transfer processes in transient (LambdaL*-CQ) and (DeltaL*-CQ) encounter complexes, and the chiral discriminatory rate parameters reflect the relative stabilities and lifetimes of these complexes as well as their structures and internal (electronic and nuclear) dynamics. All of the luminophore and quencher molecules examined in this study have three-bladed propeller-like structures that are very similar in overall shape and size. However, they exhibit small differences in the structural details of their propeller blades, and it is found that these small differences in structure can produce both qualitative and very substantial quantitative differences in their chiral recognition and discrimination properties.     

Evolution of mirror images by sexually asymmetric mating behavior in hermaphroditic snails

Abstract Directionally asymmetric animals generally exhibit no variation in handedness of whole-body architecture. In contrast, reversed chirality in both coil and entire anatomy has frequently evolved in snails. We demonstrate a nonrandom pattern and deterministic process of chiral evolution, as predicted by the following hypothesis. Bimodal shell shapes are associated with discrete mating behaviors in hermaphroditic pulmonates. Flat-shelled species mate reciprocally, face-to-face. This sexual symmetry prevents interchiral mating because genitalia exposed by a sinistral on its left side cannot be joined with those exposed by a dextral on its right. Thus, selection against the chiral minority, resulting from mating disadvantage, stabilizes chiral monomorphism. Tall-shelled species mate nonreciprocally: the 'male' copulates by mounting the 'female's' shell, mutually aligned in the same direction. This sexual asymmetry permits interchiral copulation with small behavioral adjustments. Therefore, the positive frequency-dependent selection is relaxed, and reversal alleles persist longer in populations of tall-shelled species. We verified both the assumption and the prediction of this hypothesis: significantly lower interchiral mating success in a low-spired species and higher chiral evolution rate in high-spired taxa. Sexual asymmetry is the key to understanding the accelerated chiral evolution in high-spired pulmonates.     

Space Asymmetry as a Possible Global Feature

A series of reports in the literature indicated symmetry breaking in assemblies of chiral molecules of opposite handedness. These unexpected observations could be accounted for as being generated by the “parity violation” of the nuclear weak force, combined with an autocatalytic amplification process. However, in many such cases, in particular of chiral fluids, this putative mechanism is far from providing a reasonable explanation for such discrimination. In this article it is suggested that space may have deviated a priori from absolute symmetry, a possibility which complies with observations in atoms and molecules and may even be implicated in the asymmetrical configuration of spiral galaxies. Space asymmetry can be extrapolated to a difference between the relative statistical weights of the “right” versus the “left” directions with respect to Euclidian coordinates or, analogously, to a difference between the clockwise and anticlockwise orientations in polar coordinates. The difference in weights of these directions in space is estimated to be around 1%, based on the differences observed in density values of chiral fluids and chiral crystals of NaClO₃. The implied asymmetry of time, as the conjugated fourth dimension, suggests a similar difference in magnitude of the time coordinate in a right‐handed versus left‐handed space, which is feasible for experimental verification. Chirality 25:308–311, 2013. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

A Relativistic Neutron Fireball from a Supernova Explosion as a Possible Source of Chiral Influence

We elaborate on a previously proposed idea that polarized electrons produced from neutrons, released in a supernova (SN) explosion, can cause chiral dissymmetry of molecules in interstellar gas-dust clouds. A specific physical mechanism of a relativistic neutron fireball with Lorentz factor of the order of 100 is assumed for propelling a great number of free neutrons outside the dense SN shell. A relativistic chiral electron–proton plasma, produced from neutron decays, is slowed down owing to collective effects in the interstellar plasma. As collective effects do not involve the particle spin, the electrons can carry their helicities to the cloud. The estimates show high chiral efficiency of such electrons. In addition to this mechanism, production of circularly polarized ultraviolet photons through polarized-electron bremsstrahlung at an early stage of the fireball evolution is considered. It is shown that these photons can escape from the fireball plasma. However, for an average density of neutrals in the interstellar medium of the order of 0.2 cm⁻³ and at distances of the order of 10 pc from the SN, these photons will be absorbed with a factor of about 10⁻⁷ due to the photoeffect. In this case, their chiral efficiency will be about five orders of magnitude less than that for polarized electrons.     

Aib residues in peptaibiotics and synthetic sequences: analysis of nonhelical conformations

The alpha-aminoisobutyric (Aib) residue has generally been considered to be a strongly helicogenic residue as evidenced by its ability to promote helical folding in synthetic and natural sequences. Crystal structures of several peptide natural products, peptaibols, have revealed predominantly helical conformations, despite the presence of multiple helix-breaking Pro or Hyp residues. Survey of synthetic Aib-containing peptides shows a preponderance of 3(10)-, alpha-, and mixed 3(10)/alpha-helical structures. This review highlights the examples of Aib residues observed in nonhelical conformations, which fall 'primarily' into the polyproline II (P(II)) and fully extended regions of conformational space. The achiral Aib residue can adopt both left (alpha(L))- and right (alpha(R))-handed helical conformations. In sequences containing chiral amino acids, helix termination can occur by means of chiral reversal at an Aib residue, resulting in formation of a Schellman motif. Examples of Aib residues in unusual conformations are illustrated by surveying a database of Aib-containing crystal structures.     

Beta decay and the origin of biological chirality: New experimental results

The proposed connection between the parity-violating handedness of beta particles in radioactive decay and the sign (L) of biological chirality (the Vester-Ulbricht [V-U] hypothesis) is being investigated by measuring the theoretically predicted asymmetry in the formation of triplet positronium in amino acid enantiomers by low energy positrons under reversal of the helicity of the positrons. We find the asymmetry in leucine to be (0.8±1.0)×10^–4, i.e. consistent with the theoretical, prediction of 10^–6 to 10^–7. The apparatus is now sensitive enough to test the predicted asymmetry in optically active molecules which have heavy atoms at their chiral centers. The connection between these results and asymmetry in radiolysis by beta-decay electrons is made, and the implications of our limits for the V-U hypothesis discussed. Although the above limits are 10⁶ times lower than direct measurements of radiolysis, they are still not small enough to allow us to rule out the V-U hypothesis.     

Molecular chirality and the origin of life

In the living systems L-amino acids and D-sugars are found with almost no exceptions. Although all the molecular chirality must have been established prior to the emergence of life, the origin of the asymmetry of molecules is still an unsolved problem. The time of appearance of the asymmetry of molecules, therefore, was quite problematic during chemical evolution.Since Pasteur's discovery in 1848, a large number of works for solving this problem have been carried out on the basis of mathematics, physics or chemistry. All the proposals which put forth for breaking the symmetry are still considered to be too weak to explain the cause of obtaining the chiral purity as a result of the symmetry breaking of molecules. In order to expand our scope, new sources of the symmetry breaking of molecules should be considered.In this article, some approaches to the achiral-chiral transition are reviewed, which will give an idea for the origin of asymmetry of molecules.     

Left-handed cardiac looping by cell chirality is mediated by position-specific convergent extensions

In the embryonic heart development of mammals and birds, a straight initial heart tube undergoes left-handed helical looping, which is a remarkable and puzzling event. We are interested in the mechanism of this chiral helical looping. Recently, observations were reported that myocardial cells in the embryonic chick heart show intrinsic chirality of rotation. The chirality of myocardial cells, via anisotropic polarization of Golgi inside the cells, leads to a left-right (LR) asymmetry of cell shape. On cell boundaries of LR asymmetric cells, phosphorylated myosin and N-cadherin are enriched. Such LR asymmetric cellular circumstances lead to a large-scale three-dimensional chiral structure, the left-handed helical loop. However, the physical mechanism of this looping is unclear. Computer simulations were performed using a cell-based three-dimensional mathematical model assuming an anterior-rightward-biased contractile force of the cell boundaries on the ventral surface of the heart (orientation of a clock hand pointing to 10 to 11 o’clock). An initially straight heart tube was successfully remodeled to the left-handed helical tube via frequent convergent extension (CE) of collective cells, which corresponds to the previously reported observations of chick heart development. Although we assumed that the biased boundary contractile force was uniform all over the ventral side, orientations of the CEs became position specific on the anterior, posterior, right, and left regions on the ventral tube. Such position-specific CEs produced the left-handed helical loop. In addition, our results suggest the loop formation process consists of two distinct phases of preparation and explicit looping. Intrinsic cell properties of chirality in this investigation were discussed relating to extrinsic factors investigated by other researches. Finally, because CE is generally exerted in the axial developmental process across different animal species, we discussed the contribution of CE to the chiral heart structure across species of chick, mouse, Xenopus, and zebrafish.     

Terrestrial and extraterrestrial sources of molecular homochirality

The unique chirality of biomolecules is reviewed, and the prebiotic requirement for the absolute chiral homogeneity of such molecules prior to their capability of self-replication is emphasized. Biotic and abiotic theories embracing both chance and determinate mechanisms which have been proposed for the origin of terrestrial chiral molecules are briefly summarized and evaluated, as are abiotic mechanisms for the subsequent amplification of the small enantiomeric excesses (e.e.s) in the chiral molecules which might be formed by such processes. While amplification mechanisms are readily validated experimentally and are potentially viable on the primitive Earth, it is concluded that all terrestrial mechanisms proposed for the origin of chirality have one or more limitations which make them either intrinsically invalid or highly improbable in the chaotic and turbulent environment of the prebiotic Earth. To circumvent these difficulties we have proposed an extraterrestrial scenario for the production of terrestrial chirality in which circularly polarized synchrotron radiation from the neutron star remnant of a supernova interacts with the organic mantles on interstellar grains, producing chiral molecules by the partial asymmetric photolysis of racemic constituent in the mantles, after which the interstellar grains with their enantiomerically enriched mantles are transported to Earth either by direct accretion or through cometary impact. At this point one of the known terrestrial e.e. enrichment mechanisms could promote the small extraterrestrially produced e.e.s. into the state of chiral homogeneity required for self-replicating biomolecules.     

Interaction of diverse voltage sensor homologs with lipid bilayers revealed by self-assembly simulations

Homologous pairing and braiding (supercoiling) have crucial effects on genome organization, maintenance, and evolution. Generally, the pairing and braiding processes are discussed in different contexts, independently of each other. However, analysis of electrostatic interactions between DNA double helices suggests that in some situations these processes may be related. Here we present a theory of DNA braiding that accounts for the elastic energy of DNA double helices as well as for the chiral nature of the discrete helical patterns of DNA charges. This theory shows that DNA braiding may be affected, stabilized, or even driven by chiral electrostatic interactions. For example, electrostatically driven braiding may explain the surprising recent observation of stable pairing of homologous double-stranded DNA in solutions containing only monovalent salt. Electrostatic stabilization of left-handed braids may stand behind the chiral selectivity of type II topoisomerases and positive plasmid supercoiling in hyperthermophilic bacteria and archea.     

The possible role of soluble salts in chemical evolution

Summary A model is proposed for a prebiotic environment in which concentration, condensation, and chemical evolution of biomolecules could have taken place. The main reactions expected of proteins, nucleic acids, lipids, and some of their precursors in this environment are examined.The model is based on our previously developed concept of a fluctuating system in which hydration and dehydration processes take place in a cyclic manner. In the present model, however, high concentrations of soluble salts, such as chlorides and sulfates, are taken into account, whereas previously a more or less salt-free system had been assumed. Thus the preponderance of surfaces of soluble salts is implied, even though sparingly soluble minerals, such as clay minerals or quartz, are also present.During the dehydration stage biomolecules tend to leave the solution and concentrate at certain microenvironments, such as in micelles and aggregates, at the liquid-gas surface and, possibly, at the emerging solid surfaces. Moreover, in these brines, and especially during the last stages of dehydration, high temperatures are attainable, which may enhance certain reactions between the organic molecules, and result in a net increase of condensation over degradation.In the dehydrated state, solid-state condensation and synthesis reactions are possible in which the surface of soluble salts may serve as a catalyst. Several reports in the literature support this hypothesis. Hydration brings about dissolution of the minerals and redistribution of the biomolecules. In such a system, evolutionary processes like those postulated by White (1980) and by Lahav and White (1980) are possible. Moreover, since several soluble salts of known geological occurrence are optically active in their crystalline state, the involvement of the model system in the selection and evolution of chiral organic compounds should also be considered. In addition, organic molecules in the above microenvironments are also expected to undergo selective interactions based on factors such as molecular pattern and chiral recognition and hydrophobicity. The proposed system emphasizes the need to develop the theoretical background and experimental methods for the study of interactions among biomolecules in the presence of high salt concentrations and solid surfaces of soluble salts, as well as interactions between the biomolecules and these surfaces.     

Interstellar dust,chirality, comets and the origins of life: Life from dead stars?

The physical, chemical and astrophysical processes by which chiral prebiotic molecules can be produced in interstellar dust and later delivered safely to the earth are considered. A laboratory analog experiment on the irradiation by circularly polarized UV light of mirror image molecules at the low temperatures of interstellar dust demonstrates that a substantial degree of chirality can be produced by irradiation of the dust by circularly polarized light from pulsars whose mean brightness and distribution in the Milky Way provide the energetic photons. The chirality is then preserved by cold aggregation of the dust into low density fragile nuclei. The thermal evolution of comets following them from birth through billions of years in the Oort cloud and back to the inner solar system results in preservation of dust organics in largely pristine form — even including effects of radiogenic heating. Physical justification for the cushioned transfer of fragments of the fluffy comets impacting the earth's atmosphere provides a conceptual basis for depositing significant concentrations of interstellar prebiotic molecules. Chiral amplification in water on the earth is presumed to be enhanced by this local concentration. If chiral molecules are discovered in comet nucleus material which will some day be returned to the laboratory, we may have in our hands the same building blocks from which we evolved.     

Front Cover

This review highlights the scientific advances concerning the origins of human right‐handedness and language (speech and gestures). The comparative approach we adopted provides evidence that research on human and non‐human animals’ behavioural asymmetries helps understand the processes that lead to the strong human left‐hemisphere specialisation. We review four major non‐mutually exclusive environmental factors that are likely to have shaped the evolution of human and non‐human primates’ manual asymmetry: socioecological lifestyle, postural characteristics, task‐level complexity and tool use. We hypothesise the following scenario for the evolutionary origins of human right‐handedness: the right‐direction of modern humans’ manual laterality would have emerged from our ecological (terrestrial) and social (multilevel system) lifestyle; then, it would have been strengthened by the gradual adoption of the bipedal stance associated with bipedal locomotion, and the increasing level of complexity of our daily tasks including bimanual coordinated actions and tool use. Although hemispheric functional lateralisation has been shaped through evolution, reports indicate that many factors and their mutual intertwinement can modulate human and non‐human primates’ manual laterality throughout their life cycle: genetic and environmental factors, mainly individual sociodemographic characteristics (e.g., age, sex and rank), behavioural characteristics (e.g., gesture per se and gestural sensory modality) and context‐related characteristics (e.g., emotional context and position of target). These environmental (evolutionary and life cycle) factors could also have influenced primates’ manual asymmetry indirectly through epigenetic modifications. All these findings led us to propose the hypothesis of a multicausal origin of human right‐handedness.     

Fluorescence decay and spectral evolution in intact photosystem I of higher plants

A photosystem I preparation from maize, containing its full antenna complement (PSI-200) and in which detergent effects on chlorophyll coupling are almost completely absent, has been studied by time-resolved fluorescence techniques with approximately 5 ps resolution at 280 and 170 K in the wavelength interval of 690-780 nm. The data have been analyzed in terms of both the decay-associated spectra (DAS) and the time-resolved emission spectra (TRES). As in a previous room temperature study [Turconi, S., Weber, N., Schweitzer, D., Strotmann, H., and Holzwarth, A. R. (1994) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1187, 324-334], the 280 K decay is well described by three DAS components in the 11-130 ps time range, the fastest of which displays both positive and negative amplitudes characteristic of excitation transfer from the bulk to the red antenna forms. Both the 57 and 130 ps components have all positive amplitudes and describe complex decay and equilibration processes involving the red forms. At 170 K, four major components in the 10-715 ps time range are required to describe the decay. The fastest represents bulk to red form transfer processes, while the 55, 216, and 715 ps decays, with all positive amplitudes, have maxima near 720, 730, and 740 nm, respectively, in accord with previous steady-state fluorescence measurements. The width and asymmetry of these DAS indicate that they are spectrally complex and represent decay and equilibration processes involving the red forms. Spectral evolution during the fluorescence decay process was analyzed in terms of the TRES. The red shifting of the TRES was analyzed in terms of the first central spectral moment (mean spectral energy) which is biexponential at both temperatures. The slower component, which describes equilibration between the red forms, leads to spectral red shifting during the entire fluorescence decay process, and the mean lifetimes of the spectral moments at 280 and 170 K (86 and 291 ps, respectively) are similar to the mean lifetimes of the fluorescence decays (119 and 384 ps, respectively). Thus, both spectral evolution and the trapping-associated fluorescence decay occur on a similar time scale, and both processes display a very similar temperature sensitivity. On the basis of these data, it is concluded that trapping in PSI-200 is to a large extent rate-limited by excitation diffusion in the antenna and in particular by the slow "uphill" transfer from the low-energy forms to the bulk and/or inner core chlorophyll molecules.     

Somatic kinetics or paroral membrane: which came first in ciliate evolution?

The ciliate species which lack a distinctive oral ciliature are considered to represent an ancestral state in ciliate evolution. Consequently, the somatic kineties composed of kinetids (kinetosomes plus cilia and associated fibrillar systems) are thought to be the ancestral ciliature. Results on stomatogenesis in 'gymnostomial ciliates' have shown that these ciliates probably have evolved from ancestors already equipped with an oral ciliature. Thus instead of the somatic, the oral ciliature may be regarded an ancestral. Based on these ideas a hypothesis on the evolution of the ciliate kinetome (assembly of all kinetids covering the body of a given ciliate) is presented. The first step in the evolution of the kinetome was the formation of a paroral membrane, a compound ciliary organelle lying along the right side of the oral area which historically but falsely is termed membrane. It was composed of kinetosomal dyads (dikinetids), derived from the kinetid of a dinoflagellate-like ancestor. From the beginning the paroral membrane was responsible for locomotion, ingestion and for the formation of a cytopharyngeal tube which the first ciliate probably had inherited from its flagellate ancestor. In the second step a first somatic kinety was formed from the right row of kinetosomes of the paroral membrane as a result of a longitudinal splitting of the paroral membrane and a subsequent migration of the forming kinety to the right into the somatic cortex. To increase the number of somatic kineties this process was repeated until the kinety produced first reached the left border of the oral area. By this step the locomotive and the nutritional functions were differentiated between somatic and oral structures. In a third step the adoral organelles were formed from somatic kinetids left of the oral area. The primitive type of stomatogenesis was a buccokinetal one derived from the mode the flagellate ancestor used to distribute its replicated kinetosomes to the offspring cells (buccokinetal means that at least parts of the oral anlage for the posterior offspring cell has its origin in the parental oral apparatus). This hypothesis, based on comparative studies on ciliate morphogenesis, is corroborated by molecular data from other laboratories.     

Racemization and the origin of optically active organic compounds in living organisms

The organic compounds synthesized in prebiotic experiments are racemic mixtures. A number of proposals have been offered to explain how asymmetric organic compounds formed on the Earth before life arose, with the influence of chiral weak nuclear interactions being the most frequent proposal. This and other proposed asymmetric syntheses give only slight enantiomeric excess and any slight excess will be degraded by racemization. This applies particularly to amino acids where half-lives of 10(5)-10(6) years are to be expected at temperatures characteristic of the Earth's surface. Since the generation of chiral molecules could not have been a significant process under geological conditions, the origins of this asymmetry must have occurred at the time of the origin of life or shortly thereafter. It is possible that the compounds in the first living organisms were prochiral rather than chiral; this is unlikely for amino acids, but it is possible for the monomers of RNA-like molecules.     

早期地球的环境变化和生命的化学进化

生命起源是当代最大的科学疑谜之一,也是历来人类普遍关注的一个焦点。在地球上最早的生物出现之前,有机物经历了漫长而复杂的化学进化过程,称为生命的化学进化。地球上生命的化学进化与非生物部分的早期演化过程,是密切地相互关联、相互作用并相互制约的。文章着重阐述与生命的化学关系最为密切的冥古宙和太古宙的地球演化历史,指出这两个阶段所形成的还原性原始大气和古海洋条件在生命的化学进行中起了极其重要的作用,并且从宇宙形成、太阳系演化和地球环境早期演化的角度,探讨地球生命的化学进化历程;以地球形成初期发生了一系列复杂的有机化学反应过程,由无机分子生成生物小分子,再进一步生成生物大分子,直至最后产生原始细胞。此外,文章评述当前国际上最流行的生命化学进化学说,对早期地球的化学进化是发生在地球表面的原始海洋、粘土矿物、火山喷发等,或是来源于地球之外的宇宙空间进行了综合的阐述。