Correcting confocal acquisition to optimize imaging of fluorescence resonance energy transfer by sensitized emission

Imaging of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between suitable fluorophores is increasingly being used to study cellular processes with high spatiotemporal resolution. The genetically encoded Cyan (CFP) and Yellow (YFP) variants of Green Fluorescent Protein have become the most popular donor and acceptor pair in cell biology. FRET between these fluorophores can be imaged by detecting sensitized emission. This technique, for which CFP is excited and transfer is detected as emission of YFP, is sensitive, fast, and straightforward, provided that proper corrections are made. In this study, the detection of sensitized emission between CFP and YFP by confocal microscopy is optimized. It is shown that this FRET pair is best excited at 430 nm. We identify major sources of error and variability in confocal FRET acquisition including chromatic aberrations and instability of the excitation sources. We demonstrate that a novel correction algorithm that employs online corrective measurements yields reliable estimates of FRET efficiency, and it is also shown how the effect of other error sources can be minimized.     

Probing complexes with single fluorophores: factors contributing to dispersion of FRET in DNA/RNA duplexes

Single molecule fluorescent microscopy is a method for the analysis of the dynamics of biological macromolecules by detecting the fluorescence signal produced by fluorophores associated with the macromolecule. Two fluorophores located in a close proximity may result in Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), which can be detected at the single molecule level and the efficiency of energy transfer calculated. In most cases, the experimentally observed distribution of FRET efficiency exhibits a significant width corresponding to 0.07–0.2 (on a scale of 0–1). Here, we present a general approach describing the analysis of experimental data for a DNA/RNA duplex. We have found that for a 15 bp duplex with Cy3 and Cy5 fluorophores attached to the opposite ends of the helix, the width of the energy transfer distribution is mainly determined by the photon shot noise and the orientation factor, whereas the variation of inter-dye distances plays a minor role.     

An ion-insensitive cAMP biosensor for long term quantitative ratiometric fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements under variable physiological conditions

Ratiometric measurements with FRET-based biosensors in living cells using a single fluorescence excitation wavelength are often affected by a significant ion sensitivity and the aggregation behavior of the FRET pair. This is an important problem for quantitative approaches. Here we report on the influence of physiological ion concentration changes on quantitative ratiometric measurements by comparing different FRET pairs for a cAMP-detecting biosensor. We exchanged the enhanced CFP/enhanced YFP FRET pair of an established Epac1-based biosensor by the fluorophores mCerulean/mCitrine. In the case of enhanced CFP/enhanced YFP, we showed that changes in proton, and (to a lesser extent) chloride ion concentrations result in incorrect ratiometric FRET signals, which may exceed the dynamic range of the biosensor. Calcium ions have no direct, but an indirect pH-driven effect by mobilizing protons. These ion dependences were greatly eliminated when mCerulean/mCitrine fluorophores were used. For such advanced FRET pairs the biosensor is less sensitive to changes in ion concentration and allows consistent cAMP concentration measurements under different physiological conditions, as occur in metabolically active cells. In addition, we verified that the described FRET pair exchange increased the dynamic range of the FRET efficiency response. The time window for stable experimental conditions was also prolonged by a faster biosensor expression rate in transfected cells and a greatly reduced tendency to aggregate, which reduces cytotoxicity. These properties were verified in functional tests in single cells co-expressing the biosensor and the 5-HT(1A) receptor.     

Photobleaching fluorescence resonance energy transfer reveals ligand-induced oligomer formation of human somatostatin receptor subtypes

The existence of dimers and higher oligomers of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) has been frequently reported using strategies based on coimmunoprecipitation or Western blot assays. These methods rely on highly artificial systems with overexpressed receptors, resulting in conflicting observations on the question of whether GPCR dimers are preformed or are formed in response to agonist treatment. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy is a superior and less perturbing technique which can be performed on selected cell regions, e.g., plasma membrane of intact cells with a sensitivity high enough to allow study under physiological levels of receptor expression. Here we describe the application of photobleaching (pb) FRET microscopy for investigating ligand-dependent oligomerization of somatostatin receptors. Procedures for the introduction of suitable donor-acceptor fluorophores in a given GPCR are described. The competitive nature of FRET and photobleaching is exploited to enable the indirect measurement of FRET via its effect on donor photobleaching lifetimes on a pixel-by-pixel basis. The method allows enhanced resolution between 10 and 100A and represents a sensitive and specific biophysical tool for characterizing the assembly and regulation of GPCR oligomers on the cell surface.     

生物大分子相互作用检测技术新进展———三色荧光级联荧光共振能量转移技术

荧光共振能量转移(fluorescenceresonanceenergytransfer,FRET),是指能量从一种受激发的荧光基团(fluorophore)以非辐射的方式转移到另一种荧光基团的物理现象.FRET的能量转移效率是两个荧光基团间距离的函数,并对此距离十分敏感,它的有效响应距离一般在1～10nm之间,因而可被用于测定原子间及分子间的距离.这一特点使FRET技术在大分子构象变化、大分子之间相互作用、细胞信号通路等研究中发挥重要作用,成为生物医学研究中的重要方法.但细胞内的生物学过程常常涉及多于两个的大分子间相互作用,二色荧光基团的FRET技术不能满足这种生物学研究的需求.最近,两个研究小组在这方面取得突破,建立了分别基于共聚焦显微镜和流式细胞仪的三色荧光级联FRET技术.这一技术的出现将会极大地促进生物学及相关研究领域的发展.     

Fluorescence-based glucose sensors

There is an urgent need to develop technology for continuous in vivo glucose monitoring in subjects with diabetes mellitus. Problems with existing devices based on electrochemistry have encouraged alternative approaches to glucose sensing in recent years, and those based on fluorescence intensity and lifetime have special advantages, including sensitivity and the potential for non-invasive measurement when near-infrared light is used. Several receptors have been employed to detect glucose in fluorescence sensors, and these include the lectin concanavalin A (Con A), enzymes such as glucose oxidase, glucose dehydrogenase and hexokinase/glucokinase, bacterial glucose-binding protein, and boronic acid derivatives (which bind the diols of sugars). Techniques include measuring changes in fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between a fluorescent donor and an acceptor either within a protein which undergoes glucose-induced changes in conformation or because of competitive displacement; measurement of glucose-induced changes in intrinsic fluorescence of enzymes (e.g. due to tryptophan residues in hexokinase) or extrinsic fluorophores (e.g. using environmentally sensitive fluorophores to signal protein conformation). Non-invasive glucose monitoring can be accomplished by measurement of cell autofluorescence due to NAD(P)H, and fluorescent markers of mitochondrial metabolism can signal changes in extracellular glucose concentration. Here we review the principles of operation, context and current status of the various approaches to fluorescence-based glucose sensing.     

Quantitative time domain analysis of lifetime‐based Förster resonant energy transfer measurements with fluorescent proteins: Static random isotropic fluorophore orientation distributions

Förster resonant energy transfer (FRET) measurements are widely used to obtain information about molecular interactions and conformations through the dependence of FRET efficiency on the proximity of donor and acceptor fluorophores. Fluorescence lifetime measurements can provide quantitative analysis of FRET efficiency and interacting population fraction. Many FRET experiments exploit the highly specific labelling of genetically expressed fluorescent proteins, applicable in live cells and organisms. Unfortunately, the typical assumption of fast randomization of fluorophore orientations in the analysis of fluorescence lifetime‐based FRET readouts is not valid for fluorescent proteins due to their slow rotational mobility compared to their upper state lifetime. Here, previous analysis of effectively static isotropic distributions of fluorophore dipoles on FRET measurements is incorporated into new software for fitting donor emission decay profiles. Calculated FRET parameters, including molar population fractions, are compared for the analysis of simulated and experimental FRET data under the assumption of static and dynamic fluorophores and the intermediate regimes between fully dynamic and static fluorophores, and mixtures within FRET pairs, is explored. Finally, a method to correct the artefact resulting from fitting the emission from static FRET pairs with isotropic angular distributions to the (incorrect) typically assumed dynamic FRET decay model is presented.      

Real-time Monitoring of Ligand-receptor Interactions with Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer

FRET is a process whereby energy is non-radiatively transferred from an excited donor molecule to a ground-state acceptor molecule through long-range dipole-dipole interactions¹. In the present sensing assay, we utilize an interesting property of PDA: blue-shift in the UV-Vis electronic absorption spectrum of PDA (Figure 1) after an analyte interacts with receptors attached to PDA^2,3,4,7. This shift in the PDA absorption spectrum provides changes in the spectral overlap (J) between PDA (acceptor) and rhodamine (donor) that leads to changes in the FRET efficiency. Thus, the interactions between analyte (ligand) and receptors are detected through FRET between donor fluorophores and PDA. In particular, we show the sensing of a model protein molecule streptavidin. We also demonstrate the covalent-binding of bovine serum albumin (BSA) to the liposome surface with FRET mechanism. These interactions between the bilayer liposomes and protein molecules can be sensed in real-time. The proposed method is a general method for sensing small chemical and large biochemical molecules. Since fluorescence is intrinsically more sensitive than colorimetry, the detection limit of the assay can be in sub-nanomolar range or lower⁸. Further, PDA can act as a universal acceptor in FRET, which means that multiple sensors can be developed with PDA (acceptor) functionalized with donors and different receptors attached on the surface of PDA liposomes.     

Single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer techniques on rotary ATP synthases

Conformational changes of proteins can be monitored in real time by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). Two different fluorophores have to be attached to those protein domains which move during function. Distance fluctuations between the fluorophores are measured by relative fluorescence intensity changes or fluorescence lifetime changes. The rotary mechanics of the two motors of F(o)F(1)-ATP synthase have been studied in vitro by single-molecule FRET. The results are summarized and perspectives for other transport ATPases are discussed.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer in single enzyme molecules with a quantum dot as donor

H(+)-ATPsynthases couple a transmembrane proton transport with ATP synthesis and ATP hydrolysis. Previously, the relative subunit movement during this process has been measured by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between two organic fluorophores covalently bound to different subunits. To improve the photophysical stability, a luminescent CdSe/ZnS nanocrystal (quantum dot) was bound to the enzyme and an organic fluorophore, Alexa568, was used as fluorescence acceptor. Single-molecule spectroscopy with the membrane integrated labeled H(+)-ATPsynthase was carried out. Single-pair FRET indicates three different conformations of the enzyme. During ATP hydrolysis relative intramolecular subunit movements are observed in real time.     

Development of an open sandwich fluoroimmunoassay based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer

We have developed a sensitive, one-step, homogeneous open sandwich fluoroimmunoassay (OsFIA) based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and luminescent semiconductor quantum dots (QDs). In this FRET assay, estrogen receptor beta (ER-beta) antigen was incubated with QD-labeled anti-ER-beta monoclonal antibody and Alexa Fluor (AF)-labeled anti-ER polyclonal antibody for 30 min, followed by FRET measurement. The dye separation distance was estimated between 80 and 90 A. The current method is rapid, simple, and highly sensitive, and it did not require the bound/free reagent separation steps and solid-phase carriers. A concentration as low as 0.05 nM (2.65 ng/ml) receptor was detected with linearity. In addition, the assay was performed with commercial antibodies. This assay provides a convenient alternative to conventional, laborious sandwich immunoassays.     

Development of new hCaM-Alexa Fluor biosensors for a wide range of ligands

Eight new fluorescent biosensors of human calmodulin (hCaM) using Alexa Fluor^® 350, 488, 532, and 555 dyes were constructed. These biosensors are thermodynamically stable, functional, and highly sensitive to ligands of the CaM. They resolve the problem of CaM ligands with similar spectroscopic properties to the intrinsic and extrinsic fluorophores of other biosensors previously reported. Additionally, they can be used in studies of protein-protein interaction through Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). The variation in T_m (range 78.07–81.47 °C; 79.05 to WT) is no larger than two degrees in all cases in regards to CaM WT. The K_ds calculated with all biosensors for CPZ and BIMI (a new inhibitor of CaM) are in the range of 0.45–1.86 and 0.69–1.54 μm respectively. All biosensors retain their ability to activate Calcineurin about 70%. Structural models built “in silico” show their possible conformation taking the fluorophores in protein thus we can predict system stability. Finally, these new biosensors represent a biotechnological development applied to an analytical problem, which aims to determine accurately the affinity of inhibitors of CaM without possible interference, to be put forward as possible drugs related to CaM.     

Development of dual receptor biosensors: an analysis of FRET pairs

The development of a dual receptor detection method for enhanced biosensor monitoring was investigated by analyzing potential fluorescent resonance energy transfer (FRET) pairs. The dual receptor scheme requires the integration of a chemical transducer system with two unique protein receptors that bind to a single biological agent. The two receptors are tagged with special molecular groups (donors and acceptors fluorophores) while the chemical transduction system relies on the well-known mechanisms of FRET. During the binding event, the two FRET labeled receptors dock at the binding sites on the surface of the biological agent. The resulting close proximity of the two fluorophores upon binding will initiate the energy transfer resulting in fluorescence. The paper focuses on the analysis and optimization of the chemical transduction system. A variety of FRET fluorophore pairs were tested in a spectrofluorimeter and promising FRET pairs were then tagged to the protein, avidin and its ligand, biotin. Due to their affinities, the FRET-tagged biomolecules combine in solution, resulting in a stable, fluorescent signal from the acceptor FRET dye with a simultaneous decrease in fluorescent signal from the donor FRET dye. The results indicate that the selected FRET pairs can be utilized in the development of dual receptor sensors.     

FRET or no FRET: a quantitative comparison

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a technique used to measure the interaction between two molecules labeled with two different fluorophores (the donor and the acceptor) by the transfer of energy from the excited donor to the acceptor. In biological applications, this technique has become popular to qualitatively map protein-protein interactions, and in biophysical projects it is used as a quantitative measure for distances between a single donor and acceptor molecule. Numerous approaches can be found in the literature to quantify and map FRET, but the measures they provide are often difficult to interpret. We propose here a quantitative comparison of these methods by using a surface FRET system with controlled amounts of donor and acceptor fluorophores and controlled distances between them. We support the system with a Monte Carlo simulation of FRET, which provides reference values for the FRET efficiency under various experimental conditions. We validate a representative set of FRET efficiencies and indices calculated from the different methods with different experimental settings. Finally, we test their sensitivity and draw conclusions for the preparation of FRET experiments in more complex and less-controlled systems.     

VenusA206 Dimers Behave Coherently at Room Temperature

Fluorescent proteins (FPs) have revolutionized cell biology by allowing genetic tagging of specific proteins inside living cells. In conjunction with Förster’s resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements, FP-tagged proteins can be used to study protein-protein interactions and estimate distances between tagged proteins. FRET is mediated by weak Coulombic dipole-dipole coupling of donor and acceptor fluorophores that behave independently, with energy hopping discretely and incoherently between fluorophores. Stronger dipole-dipole coupling can mediate excitonic coupling in which excitation energy is distributed near instantaneously between coherently interacting excited states that behave as a single quantum entity. The interpretation of FP energy transfer measurements to estimate separation often assumes that donors and acceptors are very weakly coupled and therefore use a FRET mechanism. This assumption is considered reasonable as close fluorophore proximity, typically associated with strong excitonic coupling, is limited by the FP β-barrel structure. Furthermore, physiological temperatures promote rapid vibrational dephasing associated with a rapid decoherence of fluorophore-excited states. Recently, FP dephasing times that are 50 times slower than traditional organic fluorophores have been measured, raising the possibility that evolution has shaped FPs to allow stronger than expected coupling under physiological conditions. In this study, we test if excitonic coupling between FPs is possible at physiological temperatures. FRET and excitonic coupling can be distinguished by monitoring spectral changes associated with fluorophore dimerization. The weak coupling mediating FRET should not cause a change in fluorophore absorption, whereas strong excitonic coupling causes Davydov splitting. Circular dichroism spectroscopy revealed Davydov splitting when the yellow FP Venus_A206 dimerizes, and a novel approach combining photon antibunching and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy was used to confirm that the two fluorophores in a Venus_A206 homodimer behave as a single-photon emitter. We conclude that excitonic coupling between Venus_A206 fluorophores is possible at physiological temperatures.     

Bidirectional fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) in mutated and chemically modified yellow fluorescent protein (YFP)

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) using fluorescent protein variants are used for studying the associations and biomolecular motions of macromolecules inside the cell. Intramolecular FRET utilizing fluorescent chemical labels has been applied in nucleic acid chemistry for detection of specific sequence. However, the biotechnological applications of intramolecular FRET in fluorescent proteins have not been exploited. This study demonstrates the intramolecular FRET between fluorescent protein and conjugated chemical label whereby FRET occurs from inside to outside and vice versa for fluorescent protein. The fluorescent protein is modified for the attachment of chemical fluorophores and the novel FRET pairs created by conjugation are MDCC (435/475)-Citrine (516/529) and Citrine-Alexa fluor (568/603). These protein-label pairs exhibited strong intramolecular FRET and the energy transfer efficiency was determined based on the time evolution of the ratio of emission intensities of labeled and unlabeled proteins. The efficiency was found to be 0.79 and 0.89 for MDCC-Citrine and 0.24 and 0.65 for Citrine-Alexa Fluor pairs when the label is conjugated at different sites in the protein. Fo?rster distance and the average distance between the fluorophores were also determined. The bidirectional approach described here can provide new insights into designing FRET-based sensors.     

Pyrene-perylene as a FRET pair coupled to the N2'-functionality of 2'-amino-LNA

Detection of nucleic acid hybridization via fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) using pyren-1-ylmethyl and perylen-3-ylmethyl N2'-functionalized 2'-amino-LNA nucleosides incorporated into oligonucleotides exhibited a clear distance dependence of the FRET efficiency, ranging from below 10% when the fluorophores were approximately 40A apart to approximately 90% when the fluorophores were in close proximity.     

Caspase-3 sensitive signaling in vivo in apoptotic HeLa cells by chemically engineered intramolecular fluorescence resonance energy transfer mutants of green fluorescent protein

Green fluorescent protein (UV5) was re-engineered to remove native cysteine residues, and a new cysteine was introduced near the C-terminus, approximately 20 A from the native fluorophore, for site-specific attachment of chemical fluorophores. The resultant efficient intramolecular FRET quenched GFP emission and gave a new emission band from the conjugated fluorophore. Caspase-3 cleavage of constructs with a caspase-3 sequence near the C-terminus in the sequence between the native fluorophore and the new cysteine, located C-terminal to the caspase site, destroyed the FRET, the emitted color reverting to that of unmodified GFP. This process was demonstrated in vitro with caspase-3 and lysates from cells undergoing apoptosis. Real-time emission changes for the Alexa Fluor 532 conjugate of this GFP, studied quantitatively in vivo for single HeLa cells using the ratios of fluorescence at the red and green maxima by confocal microscopy, showed that caspase-3 action in the cytosol preceded that in the nucleus.     

FRET analyses of the U2AF complex localize the U2AF35/U2AF65 interaction in vivo and reveal a novel self-interaction of U2AF35

We have analyzed the interaction between the U2AF subunits U2AF35 and U2AF65 in vivo using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy. U2 snRNP Auxiliary Factor (U2AF) is an essential pre-mRNA splicing factor complex, comprising 35-kDa (U2AF35) and 65-kDa (U2AF65) subunits. U2AF65 interacts directly with the polypyrimidine tract and promotes binding of U2 snRNP to the pre-mRNA branchpoint, while U2AF35 associates with the conserved AG dinucleotide at the 3' end of the intron and has multiple functions in the splicing process. Using two different approaches for measuring FRET, we have identified and spatially localized sites of direct interaction between U2AF35 and U2AF65 in vivo in live cell nuclei. While U2AF is thought to function as a heterodimeric complex, the FRET data have also revealed a novel U2AF35 self-interaction in vivo, which is confirmed in vitro using biochemical assays. These results suggest that the stoichiometry of the U2AF complex may, at least in part, differ in vivo from the expected heterodimeric complex. The data show that FRET studies offer a valuable approach for probing interactions between pre-mRNA splicing factors in vivo.     

Modelling Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) using anisotropy resolved multi-dimensional emission spectroscopy (ARMES)

BackgroundFörster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) is widely used to study the structure and dynamics of biomolecular systems and also causes the non-linear fluorescence response observed in multi-fluorophore proteins. Accurate FRET analysis, in terms of measuring changes in donor and acceptor spectra and energy transfer efficiency is therefore critical.MethodsWe demonstrate a novel quantitative FRET analysis using anisotropy resolved multidimensional emission spectroscopy (ARMES) in a Human Serum Albumin (HSA) and 1,8-anilinonaphathalene sulfonate (ANS) model. ARMES combines 4D measurement of polarized excitation emission matrices (pEEM) with multivariate data analysis to spectrally resolve contributing fluorophores. Multivariate analysis (Parallel Factor, PARAFAC and restricted Tucker3) was used to resolve fluorophore contributions and for modelling the quenching of HSA emission and the HSA-ANS interactions.ResultspEEM spectra were modelled using Tucker3 which accommodates non-linearities introduced by FRET and a priori chemical knowledge was used to optimise the solution, thus resolving three components: HSA emission, ANS emission from indirect FRET excitation, and ANS emission from direct excitation. Perpendicular emission measurements were more sensitive to indirectly excited acceptor emission. PARAFAC modelling of HSA, donor emission, separated ANS FRET interacting (Tryptophan) and non-interacting (Tyrosine) components. This enabled a new way of calculating quenching constants using the multi-dimensional emission of individual donor fluorophores.ConclusionsFRET efficiency could be calculated using the multi-dimensional, resolved emission of the interacting donor fluorophores only which yielded higher ET efficiencies compared to conventional methods.General significanceShows the potential of multidimensional fluorescence measurements and data analysis for more accurate FRET modelling in proteins.