Hypoxia induced non-apoptotic cellular changes during aerenchyma formation in rice (Oryza sativa L.) roots

The stress of low oxygen concentrations in a waterlogged environment is minimized in some plants that produce aerenchyma, a tissue characterized by prominent intercellular spaces. It is produced by the predictable collapse of root cortex cells, indicating a programmed cell death (PCD) and facilitates gas diffusion between root and the aerial environment. The objective of this study was to characterize the cellular changes take place during aerenchyma formation in root of rice that accompany PCD. Scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy were used for cellular analysis of roots. Aerenchyma development was observed in both aerobic and flooded conditions. Structural changes in membranes and organelles were examined during development of root cortex cells to compare with previous examples of PCD. There was an initial collapse which started at a specific position in the mid cortex, indicating loss of turgor, and the cytoplasm became more electron dense. These cells were distinct in shape from those located towards the periphery. Mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum appeared normal at this early stage though the tonoplast lost its integrity. Subsequently it underwent further degeneration while the plasmalemma retracted from the cell wall followed by death of neighboring cells followed a radial path. However, pycnosis of the nucleus, blebbing of plasma membrane and production of apoptotic bodies were not found which in turn indicated nonapoptotic PCD during aerenchyma formation in rice.     

Lysigenous aerenchyma formation involves non-apoptotic programmed cell death in rice (Oryza sativa L.) roots

In waterlogged soil, deficiency of oxygen triggers development of aerenchyma in roots which facilitates gas diffusion between roots and the aerial environment. However, in contrast to other monocots, roots of rice (Oryza sativa L.) constitutively form aerenchyma even in aerobic conditions. The formation of cortical aerenchyma in roots is thought to occur by either lysigeny or schizogeny. Schizogenous aerenchyma is developed without cortical cell death. However, lysigenous gas-spaces are formed as a consequence of senescence of specific cells in primary cortex followed by their death due to autolysis. In the last stage of aerenchyma formation, a ‘spoked wheel’ arrangement is observed in the cortical region of root. Ultrastructural studies show that cell death is constitutive and no characteristic cell structural differentiation takes place in the dying cells with respect to surrounding cells. Cell collapse initiation occurs in the center of the cortical tissues which are characterized by shorter with radically enlarged diameter. Then, cell death proceeds by acidification of cytoplasm followed by rupturing of plasma membrane, loss of cellular contents and cell wall degradation, while cells nuclei remain intact. Dying cells releases a signal through symplast which initiates cell death in neighboring cells. During early stages, middle lamella-degenerating enzymes are synthesized in the rough endoplasmic reticulum which are transported through dictyosome and discharged through plasmalemma beneath the cell wall. In rice several features of root aerenchyma formation are analogous to a gene regulated developmental process called programmed cell death (PCD), for instance, specific cortical cell death, obligate production of aerenchyma under environmental stresses and early changes in nuclear structure which includes clumping of chromatin, fragmentation, disruption of nuclear membrane and apparent engulfment by the vacuole. These processes are followed by crenulation of plasma membrane, formation of electron-lucent regions in the cytoplasm, tonoplast disintegration, organellar swelling and disruption, loss of cytoplasmic contents, and collapse of cell. Many processes in lysing cells are structural features of apoptosis, but certain characteristics of apoptosis i.e., pycnosis of the nucleus, plasma membrane blebbing, and apoptotic bodies formation are still lacking and thus classified as non-apoptotic PCD. This review article, describes most recent observations alike to PCD involved in aerenchyma formation and their systematic distributions in rice roots.     

Electron microscopy of gas space (aerenchyma) formation in adventitious roots of Zea mays L. subjected to oxygen shortage

This paper examines the ultrastructure of cortical cells in maize root tips during the early stages in lysigenous aerenchyma formation, promoted by oxygen-deficient nutrient solution. The aim was to determine whether changes in fine structure were compatible with oxygen starvation as the primary cause of cell degeneration and death. There was an initial collapse of some cortical cells, indicating loss of turgor, and the cytoplasm became more electron dense. Mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum appeared normal at this early stage though the tonoplast lost its integrity. Subsequently the cytoplasm became less electron dense than surrounding healthy cells, and underwent further degeneration while the plasmalemma retracted from the cell wall. Cell walls remained unaltered until this stage, but some then became thin and electron transparent. No cells of the stele were found to degenerate. These observations, which do not readily accord with the hypothesis that oxygen starvation was the cause of cell death, are compared with detailed studies of cell degeration in other cell types. An alternative mechanism for the stimulation of cortical cell lysis in poorly oxygenated roots involving the hormone ethylene, is discussed.     

Aerenchyma develops by cell lysis in roots AND CELL SEPARATION IN LEAF PETIOLES IN Sagittaria lancifolia (Alismataceae)

Aerenchyma gas spaces are important for plants that survive flooding because these spaces provide an internal pathway for oxygen transport to the root zone. The objective of this study was to characterize the development of aerenchyma gas spaces in Sagittaria lancifolia L., a dominant species in freshwater wetlands adjacent to the Gulf of Mexico. Tissue at different developmental stages was collected from hydroponically grown plants, embedded in plastic, and sections were observed with a light microscope. In S. lancifolia roots, lysigeny (cell lysis) produced gas spaces that increased in volume from the root meristem to the most mature root tissue. Shoot aerenchyma occurred in the large petioles of S. lancifolia and through the blade midrib, but not in the laminar portion of the blade. In contrast to the roots, gas spaces in the petiole were formed by schizogeny (cell separation during development). Shoot initials produced cells that formed interlocking cylinders in the cortex and diaphragm cells that bridged the central portion of the cylinders. Division and expansion of both these cell types increased the diameter of the cylinders and created schizogenous gaps between diaphragm layers that produced large gas spaces in mature tissue. Therefore, aerenchyma development occurs by two different processes in S. lancifolia.     

Ultrastructural aspects and programmed cell death in the tapetal cells of Lathyrus undulatus Boiss

Programmed cell death (PCD) in the tapetum of Lathyrus undulatus L. was analyzed based on light, fluorescence and electron microscopy to characterize its spatial and temporal occurrence. Development and processes of PCD in secretory tapetal cells of Lathyrus undulatus L. were correlated with the sporogenous cells and pollen grains. At early stages of development the tapetal cells appeared similar to pollen mother cells, structurally. Concurrent with meiosis, tapetum expanded both tangentially and radially as vacuoles increased in size. Tapetal cells most fully developed at young microspore stage. However, tapetum underwent substantial changes in cell organization including nucleus morphology monitored by DAPI. The TUNEL staining confirmed the occurrence of intra-nucleosomal DNA cleavage. In addition to nuclear degeneration which is the first hallmark of PCD other diagnostic features were observed at vacuolated microspore stage intensely; such as chromatin condensation at the periphery of the nucleus, nuclear membrane degeneration, chromatin release to the cytoplasm, vacuole collapse according to tonoplast rupture, shrinkage of the cytoplasm, the increase and enlargement of the endoplasmic reticulum cisternae and disruption of the plasma membrane. After vacuole collapse due to possible release of hydrolytic enzymes the cell components degraded. Tapetal cells completely degenerated at bicellular pollen stage.     

Lysigenous aerenchyma formation in maize root is confined to cortical cells by regulation of genes related to generation and scavenging of reactive oxygen species

To adapt to waterlogging, maize (Zea mays) forms lysigenous aerenchyma in root cortex as a result of ethylene-promoted programmed cell death (PCD). Respiratory burst oxidase homolog (RBOH) gene encodes a homolog of gp91^phox in NADPH oxidase, and has a role in the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Recently, we found that during aerenchyma formation, RBOH was upregulated in all maize root tissues examined, whereas an ROS scavengingrelated metallothionein (MT) gene was downregulated specifically in cortical cells. Together these changes should lead to high accumulations of ROS in root cortex, thereby inducing PCD for aerenchyma formation. As further evidence of the involvement of ROS in root aerenchyma formation, the PCD was inhibited by diphenyleneiodonium (DPI), an NADPH oxidase inhibitor. Based on these results, we propose a model of cortical cell-specific PCD for root aerenchyma formation.Key words: aerenchyma, ethylene, laser microdissection, maize (Zea mays), metallothionein, programmed cell death, reactive oxygen species, respiratory burst oxidase homologIn both wetland and non-wetland plants, lysigenous aerenchyma is formed in roots by creating gas spaces as a result of death and subsequent lysis of some cortical cells, and allows internal transport of oxygen from shoots to roots under waterlogged soil conditions.^1–3 In rice (Oryza sativa) and some other wetland plant species, lysigenous aerenchyma is constitutively formed under aerobic conditions, and is further enhanced under waterlogged conditions.⁴ On the other hand, in non-wetland plants, including maize (Zea mays), lysigenous aerenchyma does not normally form under well-drained soil conditions, but is induced by waterlogging.⁵ Ethylene is involved in lysigenous aerenchyma formation,^1–3,6,7 but the molecular mechanisms are unclear.We recently identified two reactive oxygen species (ROS)-related genes that were specifically regulated in maize root cortex by waterlogged conditions, but not in the presence of an ethylene perception inhibitor 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP).⁵ One was respiratory burst oxidase homolog (RBOH), which has a role in ROS generation and the other was metallothionein (MT), which has a role in ROS scavenging. These results suggest that ROS has a role in ethylene signaling in the PCD that occurs during lysigenous aerenchyma formation.     

Root Cell Ultrastructure in Developing Aerenchyma Tissue of Three Wetland Species

Patterns of root cortex cell development and ultrastructurewere analysed in Sagittaria lancifolia L., Thalia geniculataL. and Pontederia cordata L. using scanning and transmissionelectron microscopy (SEM, TEM). In all three species, cortexcells were arranged in radial columns extending from the endodermisto the hypodermis/epidermis. During gas space formation, thecortex cells elongated parallel to the root radius and shrankin the plane perpendicular to the radius leaving long and thinrows of cortex cells extending from the endodermis to the epidermis.Although the cortex cells appeared collapsed in tissue withwell-developed gas spaces, TEM revealed that the cortical cellsas well as the epidermal cells maintained intact membranes andmany normal organelles. Formation of root cortex tissue withwell-developed gas spaces does not require cell death in thesespecies. Living cortex cells in root tissue with mature gasspaces could provide a symplastic pathway for transport betweenthe root stele and the living epidermal cells. Copyright 2000Annals of Botany Company Sagittaria lancifolia, Thalia geniculata, Pontederia cordata, aerenchyma, root, wetland, development     

银杏贮粉室发生部位的珠心细胞程序性死亡的形态学观察

银杏（Ginkgo bilobaL)贮粉室的发生涉及位于珠孔端的珠心细胞的程序性死亡（PCD）,本研究观察了贮粉室发生过程中发生PCD的珠心细胞的形态学变化。这些珠心细胞在PCD过程中形态变化显著,细胞组分有序地降解,液泡在此起关键作用。在液泡化过程中,细胞质基质和一些细胞器被液泡所吞噬,此时的细胞器结构完整。当液泡膜破裂,细胞质基质消失之后。细胞器才逐步解体。最终,这些珠心细胞仅具有残留的细胞壁,随着胚珠的生长,细胞壁也被破坏,在整个PCD过程中,内膜系统发生明显改变;细胞质膜出泡,产生多泡体;形成多环膜结构;出现由膜包围的小体,其中含有细胞质基质和一些细胞器;液泡膜破裂;细胞器解体;细胞中出现大量的小膜泡。珠孔端的珠心表皮开裂形成贮粉室的开口有两种方式：一种为专一细胞的自溶,而另一种是在两个邻接细胞的中胶层处分离,没有发生细胞的自溶破裂。贮粉室开口位置的特定表皮细胞在开裂发生前就死亡,从而提前标示出表皮开裂的发生位置。这些细胞形态的变化反映出银杏珠心细胞的死亡是受发育调控的PCD过程。     

银杏贮粉室发生部位的珠心细胞程序性死亡的形态学观察

银杏(Ginkgo biloba L.)贮粉室的发生涉及位于珠孔端的珠心细胞的程序性死亡(PCD).本研究观察了贮粉室发生过程中发生PCD的珠心细胞的形态学变化.这些珠心细胞在PCD过程中形态变化显著,细胞组分有序地降解,液泡在此起关键作用.在液泡化过程中,细胞质基质和一些细胞器被液泡所吞噬,此时的细胞器结构完整.当液泡膜破裂、细胞质基质消失之后,细胞器才逐步解体.最终,这些珠心细胞仅具有残留的细胞壁.随着胚珠的生长,细胞壁也被破坏.在整个PCD过程中,内膜系统发生明显改变:细胞质膜出泡,产生多泡体;形成多环膜结构;出现由膜包围的小体,其中含有细胞质基质和一些细胞器;液泡膜破裂;细胞器解体;细胞中出现大量的小膜泡.珠孔端的珠心表皮开裂形成贮粉室的开口有两种方式:一种为专一细胞的自溶,而另一种是在两个邻接细胞的中胶层处分离,没有发生细胞的自溶破裂.贮粉室开口位置的特定表皮细胞在开裂发生前就死亡,从而提前标示出表皮开裂的发生位置.这些细胞形态的变化反映出银杏珠心细胞的死亡是受发育调控的PCD过程.     

Mechanism of Root Contraction in Gladiolus

A mechanism for root contraction in Gladiolus is proposed, basedon an ultrastructural study of the cortical parenchyma. Thedriving force of the process is presumed to be the differentialcompressive stress between atmospheric pressure and the negativepressure within the xylem. Early lysis of the middle lamellain the region of maturity, especially marked towards the innercortex, permits the inner cortical cells to respond to thispressure mainly by gliding among their neighbours while theouter cortical cells may glide somewhat but are mostly compressedlongitudinally and expanded radially. The outer cells becomemoribund, with dehydrated cytoplasm and loss of structure inthe cell organelles. Senescence and death take a centripetalcourse through outer and middle cortex, during which the dyingcells are progressively further compressed longitudinally, balloonedradially, and finally collapsed radially. As cell separationceases, the living cells of the inner cortex are also compressedsomewhat. However, they remain turgid, develop thick cell walls,and eventually resist further compression, bringing root contractionto an end.     

Trade-off between root porosity and mechanical strength in species with different types of aerenchyma

The objective of this work was to study the existence of a trade-off between aerenchyma formation and root mechanical strength. To this end, relationships among root anatomical traits and mechanical properties were analysed in plant species with contrasting root structural types: Paspalidium geminatum (graminaceous type), Cyperus eragrostis (cyperaceous type), Rumex crispus (Rumex type) and Plantago lanceolata (Apium type). Variations in anatomical traits and mechanical strength were assessed as a function of root diameter by exposing plants to 0, 7, 15 and 30 d of control and flooded conditions. For each species, the proportion of root cortex was positively associated with the increment of root diameter, contributing to the increase in root porosity under both control and flooded conditions. Moreover, cell lysis produced an additional increase in root porosity in most species under flooded conditions (except R. crispus). Both structural types that presented a uniseriate layer (epidermis) to cope with compression (Rumex and Apium types) were progressively weakened as root porosity increased. This effect was significant even when the increment of root porosity was solely because of increased root diameter (R. crispus), as when both processes (root diameter and cell lysis) added porosity to the roots (P. lanceolata). Conversely, structural types that presented a multiseriate ring of cells in the outer cortex (graminaceous and cyperaceous types) maintained mechanical strength over the whole range of porosity, in spite of lysogenic processes registered in the inner cortex. In conclusion, our study demonstrates a strong trade-off between aerenchyma formation and mechanical strength in root structural types that lacked a multiseriate ring of tissue for mechanical protection in the outer cortex. The results suggest that this ring of tissue plays a significant role in maintaining the mechanical strength of roots when flooding induces the generation of additional aerenchyma tissue in the root cortex.     

Leaf‐shape remodeling: programmed cell death in fistular leaves of Allium fistulosum

Some species of Allium in Liliaceae have fistular leaves. The fistular lamina of Allium fistulosum undergoes a process from solid to hollow during development. The aims were to reveal the process of fistular leaf formation involved in programmed cell death (PCD) and to compare the cytological events in the execution of cell death to those in the unusual leaf perforations or plant aerenchyma formation. In this study, light and transmission electron microscopy were used to characterize the development of fistular leaves and cytological events. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase‐mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) assays and gel electrophoresis were used to determine nuclear DNA cleavage during the PCD. The cavity arises in the leaf blade by degradation of specialized cells, the designated pre‐cavity cells, in the center of the leaves. Nuclei of cells within the pre‐cavity site become TUNEL‐positive, indicating that DNA cleavage is an early event. Gel electrophoresis revealed that DNA internucleosomal cleavage occurred resulting in a characteristic DNA ladder. Ultrastructural analysis of cells at the different stages showed disrupted vacuoles, misshapen nuclei with condensed chromatin, degraded cytoplasm and organelles and emergence of secondary vacuoles. The cell walls degraded last, and residue of degraded cell walls aggregated together. These results revealed that PCD plays a critical role in the development of A. fistulosum fistular leaves. The continuous cavity in A. fistulosum leaves resemble the aerenchyma in the pith of some gramineous plants to improve gas exchange.     

Microtubules in epidermal and cortical root cells of Brassica rapa during clinorotation

Using confocal microscopy the organization of tubulin cytoskeleton including endoplasmic and cortical microtubules (CMTs) has been studied in epidermal and cortical cells of the different growth zones of main root of Brassica rapa L. 6-days-old seedlings in control conditions and under clinorotation. It was shown that changes in CMTs orientation occured only in the distal elongation zone (DEZ). In the control, CMT arrays oriented transversely to the root long axis. Under clinorotation appearance of the shorter randomly organized CMTs was observed. Simultaneously, a significant decrease in the cell length in the central elongation zone (CEZ) under clinorotation was detected. It is suggested that the decline of anisotropic growth typical for CEZ cells is connected with CMTs disorientation under clinorotation.     

Aerenchyma formation in maize roots

Maize (Zea mays L.) is generally considered to be a plant with aerenchyma formation inducible by environmental conditions. In our study, young maize plants, cultivated in various ways in order to minimise the stressing effect of hypoxia, flooding, mechanical impedance or nutrient starvation, were examined for the presence of aerenchyma in their primary roots. The area of aerenchyma in the root cortex was correlated with the root length. Although 12 different maize accessions were used, no plants without aerenchyma were acquired until an ethylene synthesis inhibitor was employed. Using an ACC-synthase inhibitor, it was confirmed that the aerenchyma formation is ethylene-regulated and dependent on irradiance. The presence of TUNEL-positive nuclei and ultrastructural changes in cortical cells suggest a connection between ethylene-dependent aerenchyma formation and programmed cell death. Position of cells with TUNEL-positive nuclei in relation to aerenchyma-channels was described.     

Katanin's severing activity favors bundling of cortical microtubules in plants

Higher plant cells exhibit interphase microtubule arrays specific to plants, which are essential for their developmental program. These cortical microtubules (CMT) consist of a population of highly dynamic microtubules that are usually organized into bundles in the cortex of the cells. The organization of CMT is intimately linked to the acquisition of specialized functions, and subsequentchanges in their distribution affect their properties. The mechanisms underlying the formation and the distribution of CMT are still unclear, and little is known about the proteins that are involved in this phenomenon. Here we investigated the putative role of katanin, the only known plant microtubule-severing protein, in the organization of CMT. We generated transgenic Arabidopsis lines that overexpress katanin under the control of an ethanol-inducible promoter. In response to an induced overexpression of katanin, CMT organized into numerous and thick bundles, which ultimately depolymerized. From the analyses of CMT patterns together with recent data on CMT dynamics, we propose that, in interphase cells, katanin's main activity is to free CMT, generating motile microtubules that incorporate into bundles.     

Process of aerenchyma formation and reactive oxygen species induced by waterlogging in wheat seminal roots

The development and regulation of aerenchyma in waterlogged conditions were studied in the seminal roots of wheat. Evans blue staining and the first cell death position indicated that the cortical cell death began at the root mid-cortex cells in flooding conditions. Continuous waterlogging treatment caused the spread of cell death from the mid-cortex to the neighboring cells and well-developed aerenchyma was formed after 72 h. Meanwhile, the formation of radial oxygen loss barrier was observed in the exodermis owing to the induction of Casparian bands and lignin deposition. Analysis of aerenchyma along the wheat root revealed that aerenchyma formed at 10 mm from the root tip, significantly increased toward the center of the roots, and decreased toward the basal region of the root. In situ detection of radial oxygen species (ROS) showed that ROS accumulation started in the mid-cortex cells, where cell death began indicating that cell death was probably accompanied by ROS production. Further waterlogging treatments resulted in the accumulation of ROS in the cortical cells, which were the zone for aerenchyma development. Accumulation and distribution of H₂O₂ at the subcellular level were revealed by ultracytochemical localization, which further verified the involvement of ROS in the cortical cell death process (i.e., aerenchyma formation). Furthermore, gene expression analysis indicated that ROS production might be the result of up-regulation of genes encoding for ROS-producing enzymes and the down-regulation of genes encoding for ROS-detoxifying enzymes. These results suggest that aerenchyma development in wheat roots starts in the mid-cortex cells and its formation is regulated by ROS.     

A Transmission and Cryo-Scanning Electron Microscopy Study of the Formation of Aerenchyma (Cortical Gas-Filled Space) in Adventitious Roots of Rice (Oryza sativa)

The initiation and development ofaerenchyma in adventitiousroots of rice (Oryza sativa) was studied in tissuc up to approximately36-h-old using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and cryoscanningelectron microscopy (cryo-SEM). Aerenchyma resulting from selective cortical cell collapse isa naturally occurring feature of rice roots. Evidence of somecortical cell disruption was noticeable by TEM in cells thatwere approximately 6-h-old; it became more advanced as the cellsaged. At 12 h, early stages of cell wall breakdown and lossof cell turgidity were seen. Complete collapse of columns ofcells had occurred by 24 h. In tissue that was 36-h-old, thesenescent cytoplasm of many remaining cells began to disperse.The visual evidence suggests that cell collapse was the resultof autolysis. This pattern of cortical degeneration in ricewas dissimilar to that reported elsewhere for Zea roots grownin an oxygen depleted environment. Cryo-SEM revealed the occurrence of small structures withinthe cortex with the external appearance of miniature, intactcells which are not preserved during conventional SEM preparativeprocedures. Key words: Rice (Oryza sativa L.), roots, aerenchyma, ultrastructure     

Cytoskeletal arrays in the cells of soybean root nodules: The role of actin microfilaments in the organisation of symbiosomes

Summary Within the infected cells of root nodules there is evidence of stratification and organisation of symbiosomes and other organelles. This organisation is likely to be important for the efficient exchange of nutrients and metabolites during functioning of the nodules. Using immunocytochemical labelling and confocal microscopy we have determined the organisation of cytoskeletal elements, micro tubules and actin microfilaments in soybean nodule cells, with a view to assessing their possible role in organelle distribution. Most microtubule arrays occurred in the cell cortex where they formed disorganised arrays in both uninfected and infected cells from mature nodules. In infected cells from developing nodules, parallel arrays of microtubules, transverse to the long axis of the cell, were observed. In incipient nodules, before release of rhizobia into the plant cells, the cells also had an array of microtubules which radiated from the nucleus into the cytoplasm. Three actin arrays were identified in the infected cells of mature nodules: an aster-like array which emanated from the surface of the nucleus, a cortical array which had an arrangement similar to that of the cortical microtubules, and, throughout the cytoplasm, an array of fine filaments which had a honeycomb arrangement consistent with a distribution between adjacent symbiosomes. Uninfected cells from mature nodules had only a random cortical array of actin filaments. In incipient nodules, the density of actin microfilaments associated with the nucleus and radiating through the cytoplasm was much less than that seen in mature infected cells. The cortical array of actin also differed, being composed of swirling configurations of filaments. After invasion of nodule cells by the rhizobia, the number of actin filaments emanating from the nucleus increased markedly and formed a network through the cytoplasm. Conversely, the cytoplasmic array in uninfected cells of developing nodules was identical to that in the cells of incipient nodules. The cytoplasmic network in infected cells of developing nodules is likely to be the precursor of the honeycomb array seen in mature nodule cells. We propose that this actin array plays a role in the spatial organisation of symbiosomes and that the microtubules are involved in the localisation of mitochondria and plastids at the cell periphery in the infected cells of root nodules.     

Aerenchyma formation in roots of maize during sulphate starvation

Young maize ( Zea mays L., Poaceae) plants were grown in a complete, well-oxygenated nutrient solution and then deprived of their external source of sulphate. This treatment induced the formation of aerenchyma in roots. In addition to the effect of sulphate starvation on root anatomy, the presence and location of superoxide anions and hydrogen peroxide, and changes in calcium and pH were examined. By day 6 of sulphate deprivation, aerenchyma started to form in the roots of plants and the first aerenchymatous spaces were apparent in the middle of the cortex. S-starvation also induced thickening of the cell walls of the endodermis. Active oxygen species appeared in groups of intact mid-cortex cells. Formation of superoxide anion and hydrogen peroxide was found in degenerating cells of the mid-cortex. Very few nuclei in the cortex of S-starved roots fluoresced, being shrunken and near to the cell wall. By day 12 of S-deprivation, a fully developed aerenchyma was apparent and there were only a few 'chains' of cells bridging hypodermis to endodermis and stele of roots. Cell walls of endodermis of S-starved roots increased 68% in thickness. Intensive fluorescence in the cell walls of the endodermal, hypodermal and to a lesser extent of epidermal cells was observed due to the formation of active oxygen species, while there was no fluorescence in the cortical cells. There was a higher Ca concentration in the cells walls of the endodermis and epidermis, compared to the rest of the S-starved root tissues. A higher pH was observed, mainly in the cell walls of the hypodermis and to a lesser extent in the cell walls of the endodermis. Superoxide anion and hydrogen peroxide was found in degenerating cells of the root cortex. There was no fluorescence of nuclei in the cortex of S-starved roots.