Chloroplast Biogenesis: XX. Accumulation of Porphyrin and Phorbin Pigments in Cucumber Cotyledons during Photoperiodic Greening

A study of greening in cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) cotyledons grown under a light (14-hour) dark (10-hour) photoperiodic regime was undertaken. The pools of protoporphyrin IX, Mg-protoporphyrin IX monoester, protochlorophyllide, and protochlorophyllide ester were determined spectrofluorometrically. Chlorophyll a and b were monitored spectrophotometrically. Pigments were extracted during the 3rd hour of each light period and at the end of each subsequent dark period during the first seven growth cycles. Protoporphyrin IX did not accumulate during greening. Mg-protoporphyrin IX monoester and longer wavelength metalloporphyrins accumulated during the light cycles and disappeared in the dark. Their disappearance was accompanied by the accumulation of protochlorophyll. Higher levels of protochlorophyll were observed in the dark than in the light, and the greatest accumulation occurred during the third and fourth dark cycles. Protochlorophyllide was present in 3- to 10-fold excess over protochlorophyllide ester; it was detectable during the period of net chlorophyll accumulation as well as afterward. In contrast, protochlorophyllide ester was observable only during the first four photoperiodic cycles, suggesting that it was a metabolic intermediate only during the early stages of chlorophyll accumulation. Between the third and fourth growth cycles, a rapid increase in area and fresh weight per cotyledon began. This was accompanied by a 250-fold increase in the level of chlorophyll a + b during the three subsequent growth cycles. No lag period in the accumulation of chlorophyll b was observed, and at all stages of greening, the chlorophyll a/b ratio was approximately 3.     

Photoconversion of protochlorophyll to chlorophyll a in a mutant of Chlorella regularis

Dark-grown cells of a mutant strain of Chlorella regularis containedchlorophyll a and protochlorophyll, phytyl ester of protochlorophyllide.Under illumination, protochlorophyll was quantitatively anddirectly converted into chlorophyll a. The photoconversion wasdependent on light intensity and temperature and proceeded ina cell-free preparation. The pathway of chlorophyll formation found in the mutant cellsis entirely different from that from protochlorophyllide byway of chlorophyllide a, which is generally observed in greenplants. ¹Present address: Division of Biology, Medical College of Miyazaki,Miyazaki 889-16, Japan. ²Present address: Division of Environmental Biology, The NationalInstitute for Environmental Studies, Ibaragi 300-21, Japan. (Received October 24, 1975; )     

Identification of the chlB Gene and the Gene Product Essential for the Light-Independent Chlorophyll Biosynthesis in the Cyanobacterium Plectonema boryanum

We cloned a 6.0-kb HindIII fragment from the cyanobacteriumPlectonema boryanum using the chloroplast chlB (ORF513) geneof the liverwort (Marchantia polymorpha) as a probe. An openreading frame (ORF508) encoding a polypeptide of 508 amino acidresidues was found within the nucleotide sequence of the 4,437-bpHindIII-EcoRV subfragment. The deduced amino acid sequence ofORF508 shows very high similarity to that encoded by the liverwortchlB gene (72.7%). A mutant, YFB14, in which ORF508 was inactivatedby the insertion of a kanamycin-resistance cartridge, was unableto synthesize chlorophyll, accumulating protochlorophyllidein darkness while synthesizing chlorophyll normally in the light.Thus, the chlB gene is the third gene that is essential forthe light-independent reduction of protochlorophyllide. Theother two genes are chlL and chlN, and the results suggest thatthe light-independent protochlorophyllide reductase consistsof at least three subunits, which are encoded by chlL, chlNand chlB. Using an antiserum prepared against a ChlB-6xHis fusionprotein expressed in Escherichia coli, we detected a proteinwith an apparent molecular weight of 58,000 in the membranefraction of the cyanobacterium. These results indicate thateither the cytoplasmic or thylakoid membranes could be the siteof the light-independent reduction of protochlorophyllide. (Received November 16, 1995; Accepted February 7, 1996)     

Influence of Calcium on Formation and Reduction of Protochlorophyllide in the Pigment Mutant C-2A' of Scenedesmus obliquus

The levels of protochlorophyllide and protochlorophyll of pigmentmutant C-2A' of Scenedesmus obliquus grown in darkness dependupon the calcium concentration in the growth medium. In thepresence of calcium both the protochlorophyllide and protochlorophylllevels decrease upon irradiation whereas the amount of photoreducedchlorophyllide increases. In contrast to light-dependent protochlorophyllide reduction,the activity of light-independent protochlorophyllide reductionis higher in calcium free cultures compared to those grown inthe presence of calcium. It is discussed whether calcium actsdirectly on the activity of the protochlorophyllide oxidoreductaseor stabilizes the newly formed chlorophyllide. (Received September 1, 1989; Accepted February 19, 1990)     

Leaf Developmental Age Controls Expression of Genes Encoding Enzymes of Chlorophyll and Heme Biosynthesis in Pea (Pisum sativum L.)

The effects of leaf developmental age on the expression of three nuclear gene families in pea (Pisum sativum L.) coding for enzymes of chlorophyll and heme biosynthesis have been examined. The steady-state levels of mRNAs encoding aminolevulinic acid (ALA) dehydratase, porphobilinogen (PBG) deaminase, and NADPH:protochlorophyllide reductase were measured by RNA gel blot and quantitative slot-blot analyses in the foliar leaves of embryos that had imbibed for 12 to 18 h and leaves of developing seedlings grown either in total darkness or under continuous white light for up to 14 d after imbibition. Both ALA dehydratase and PBG deaminase mRNAs were detectable in embryonic leaves, whereas mRNA encoding the NADPH:protochlorophyllide reductase was not observed at this early developmental stage. All three gene products were found to increase to approximately the same extent in the primary leaves of pea seedlings during the first 6 to 8 d after imbibition (postgermination) regardless of whether the plants were grown in darkness or under continuous white-light illumination. In the leaves of dark-grown seedlings, the highest levels of message accumulation were observed at approximately 8 to 10 d postgermination, and, thereafter, a steady decline in mRNA levels was observed. In the leaves of light-grown seedlings, steady-state levels of mRNA encoding the three chlorophyll biosynthetic enzymes were inversely correlated with leaf age, with youngest, rapidly expanding leaves containing the highest message levels. A corresponding increase in the three enzyme protein levels was also found during the early stages of development in the light or darkness; however, maximal accumulation of protein was delayed relative to peak levels of mRNA accumulation. We also found that although protochlorophyllide was detectable in the leaves immediately after imbibition, the time course of accumulation of the phototransformable form of the molecule coincided with NADPH:protochlorophyllide reductase expression. In studies in which dark-grown seedlings of various ages were subsequently transferred to light for 24 and 48 h, the effect of light on changes in steady-state mRNA levels was found to be more pronounced at later developmental stages. These results suggest that the expression of these three genes and likely those genes encoding other chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway enzymes are under the control of a common regulatory mechanism. Furthermore, it appears that not light, but rather as yet unidentified endogenous factors, are the primary regulatory factors controlling gene expression early in leaf development.     

Regulation by light of chlorophyll synthesis in the cotyledons of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) seedlings

Seedlings of gymnosperms, unlike angiosperms, synthesize chlorophyll(ide) (Chl) in darkness (D). In Scots pine cotyledons ( Pinus sylvestris L.) Chl accumulation ceases in D at a low level but Chl accumulation is strongly increased by light, red light (R) being more effective than blue light (B), whereas in Pinus maritima Chi synthesis is almost light-independent. In Scots pine the capacity to form Chl can be increased by R pulses, fully reversible by far-red light, demonstrating the involvement of phytochrome. However, when B- or R–grown seedlings were transferred to D, Chl accumulation stopped immediately irrespective of the level of P_fr (far-red light absorbing form of phytochrome), indicating that the conversion of protochlorophyllide (PChl) is light-dependent. Dose response curves in R and B and simultaneous irradiation with R and B show that R and B are perceived by separate photoreceptors. The immunodetected NADPH-dependent protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (POR, EC 1.6.99.1), assumed to regulate light-dependent Chl synthesis in angiosperms, is not correlated with the capacity of gymnosperm Chi accumulation in darkness. While two FOR bands could be separated in extracts from dark grown material (38 and 36 kDa) of Pinus sylvestris and P. maritima , only the 38 kDa band disappeared consistently in the light. However. the significance of the more light resistant 36 kDa band for chlorophyll synthesis remains unclear as well.     

Chloroplast biogenesis 51 : modulation of monovinyl and divinyl protochlorophyllide biosynthesis by light and darkness in vitro

It is shown that the monovinyl and divinyl protochlorophyllide biosynthetic patterns of etiolated maize (Zea mays L.), and cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) seedlings and of their isolated etiochloroplasts can be modulated by light and darkness as was shown for green photoperiodically grown plants (E. E. Carey, C. A. Rebeiz 1985 Plant Physiol. 79: 1-6). In etiolated corn and cucumber seedlings and isolated etiochloroplasts poised in the divinyl protochlorophyllide biosynthetic mode by a 2 hour light pretreatment, darkness induced predominantly the biosynthesis of monovinyl protochlorophyllide in maize and of divinyl protochlorophyllide in cucumber. When etiolated seedlings and their isolated etiochloroplasts were poised in the monovinyl protochlorophyllide biosynthetic mode by a prolonged dark-pretreatment, light induced mainly the biosynthesis of divinyl protochlorophyllide in both maize and cucumber.     

Comparative analysis of the low molecular weight and enzymatic antioxidants in response to the phototoxicity of accumulating uroporphyrin and protochlorophyllide in barley leaves treated with cesium chloride

Cesium chloride treatment of illuminated barley leaves leads to accumulation of uroporphyrinogen which is subsequently either oxidised to uroporphyrin in continuous light or converted to protochlorophyllide in darkness [Shalygo et al. (1998) J Photochem Photobiol 42: 151–158]. We were interested to elucidate the differences in the phototoxicity of uroporphyrin and protochlorophyllide in the CsCI-treated leaves. Photosensitization and the induction of oxidative stress responses in the barley leaves occurred much faster upon protochlorophyllide than upon uroporphyrin accumulation. We compared the time resolved changes in the pool sizes of low molecular weight antioxidants, such as ascorbate, glutathione and tocopherol, as well as of the enzymatic activities of catalase, ascorbate peroxidase, glutathione reductase and superoxide dismutase in illuminated barley leaves which accumulated uroporphyrin or protochlorophyllide. A rapid loss of the antioxidant levels correlated with the accumulation of reactive oxygen species. The contents of low molecular weight antioxidants and the activities of most of the antioxidative enzymes declined more rapidly in the presence of protochlorophyllide than of uroporphyrin. Due to its high lipophilicity, free protochlorophyllide is associated with biomembranes. Therefore, it is assumed that it exerts its phototoxic effects to membranes more rapidly than uroporphyrin. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The photostability of different chlorophyll forms in dark grown leaves of wheat

Formulae were developed for calculation of the relative amount of different pigment forms of dark grown leaves of wheat, present before and after photoreduction of the protochlorophyllide. Three pigment forms were calculated from in vivo absorption spectra: the photoreducible protochlorophyllide with absorption maximum at 650 nm and the two chlorophyll(ide) forms with absorption maximum at 684 nm and 673 nm, respectively. The formulae were used to study the changes of the pigment forms at repeated photoreduction of the protochlorophyllide, and at a repeated treatment involving photoreduction of the protochlorophyllide followed by partial photo-decomposition of the chlorophyllide formed. Five consecutive photoreductions and reaccumulations of protochlorophyllide were carried out by high intensity irradiations of one second (red light, 700 W m^-2) given at intervals of 3 h. The results show that the pool size of reaccumulated protochlorophyllide decreased sharply with the number of photoreductions performed. The absorption spectrum of the chlorophyllide formed at each photoreduction proceeded through the Shibata shift (transformation of the 684-form to the 673-form) and the late red-shift (transformation of the 673-form to other pigment form(s) in the dark). High intensity irradiation for ten minutes (red light, 700 W m^-2) immediately after each phototransformation caused a photodecomposition of about three quarters of the newly formed chlorophyllide (which was in the 684-form) while the earlier formed chlorophyll(ide) (in the 673-form) appeared not to be decomposed. This partial photodecomposition of the chlorophyllide had no effect on further accumulation of protochlorophyllide in the dark, and the absorption spectrum of the remaining chlorophyllide proceeded through the Shibata shift. The partial photodecomposition caused an inhibition of the late red-shift, and the accumulated chlorophyll(ide) remained in the 673-form.     

Transformation of Protochlorophyllide, Formed from Exogenous δ-Aminolevulinic Acid, in Continuous Light and in Flashlight

δ-Aminolevulinic acid supplied to dark grown isolated leaves or wheat causes an accumulation of protochlorophyllide which is only partly transformed to chlorophyllide α in continuous light At the same time a considerable photodestruction of both pigments takes place. By a suitable combinations of short lights flashes and dark periods it is possible, however, to obtain at least double the amount of the protochlorophyllide transformed without photodestruction. The transformation isshown to be dependent on the dark interval between the light flashes. Possible connections with the formation of the protein part of the protochlorophyllide holochrome are discussed.     

Chloroplast biogenesis. Biosynthesis and accumulation of protochlorophyll by isolated etioplasts and developing chloroplasts.

Etioplasts and developing chloroplasts were isolated from etiolated Cucumis cotyledons that were irradiated with white fluorescent light for various periods of time. The endogenous porphyrins and phorbins of the isolated plastids were partitioned between hexane, hexane-extracted aqueous acetone and a lipoprotein precipitate. Spectrofluorometric determinations were performed on these fractions without further fractionation. For quantitative determinations, the fluorescence amplitudes of the various fluorescent components were corrected for fluorescence emission overlap by sets of simultaneous equations. Developing chloroplasts contained endogenous amounts of the following metabolites: Protochlorophyllide, protochlorophyllide ester, Mg-protoporphyrin monoester + longer-wavelength metalloporphyrins and protoporphyrin. The protochlorophyll pool consisted mainly of protochlorophyllide. The latter was heterogeneous and consisted of at least two chemically related protochlorophyllides. In contrast to developing chloroplasts, irradiated etioplasts contained mostly protochlorophyllide ester and smaller amounts of protochlorophyllide. Upon incubation of developing chloroplasts and irradiated etioplasts with δ-aminolevulinic acid and cofactors (coenzyme A, glutathione, adenosine triphosphate, nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide, methyl alcohol, magnesium, potassium and phosphate), a net synthesis and accumulation of protochlorophyllide, Mg-protoporphyrin monoester + longer-wavelength metalloporphyrins, protoporphyrin, coproporphyrin and uroporphyrin were observed. Small amounts of zinc-coproporphyrin and zinc-uroporphyrin were also formed. In some experiments a net synthesis of protochlorophyllide ester was also observed. This report represents the first account of the unambiguous net synthesis of protochlorophyll in vitro.     

Formation of Chlorophyll-Protein Complexes during Greening 1. Distribution of Newly Synthesized Chlorophyll among Apoproteins

The relationship between the accumulation of Chl and the apoproteinsof the light-harvesting Chl a/b-protein complex of PS II (LHCII)during the greening of cucumber cotyledons was studied. LHCIIapoproteins were not detected in etiolated cotyledons. Uponillumination, Chl a was formed as a result of photoconversionof protochlorophyllide (Pchlide) which had accumulated in thedark. During the lag period that preceded the accumulation ofChl, a small amount of LHCII apoproteins appeared. The amountof LHCII apoproteins increased with increases in levels of Chlb, though somewhat more rapidly during the first 10 h of greening.Treatment with benzyladenine (BA) or levulinic acid (LA) wasused to vary the supply of Chl a for apoproteins by promotingor inhibiting the synthesis of Chl a, respectively. LA decreasedbut BA increased the rate of accumulation of Chl b and LHCIIapoproteins. Only small amounts of Chl b and LHCII apoproteinswere formed under intermittent illumination. However, in thepresence of chloramphenicol (CAP), which inhibits the synthesisof plastome-coded proteins including apoproteins of the P700-Chla-protein complex (CP1) and a Chl a-protein complex of PS II(CPa), we observed the accumulation of Chl b and LHCII apoproteins,both of which are of nuclear origin. During incubation in thedark after intermittent exposure to light, CAP alone allowedneither destruction nor accumulation of Chl b and LHCII apoproteins,but it did enhance the effect of CaCl₂ in inducing both Chlb and these apoproteins. These results can be explained by assumingthat apoproteins of CP1 and CPa have a higher affinity for Chla than do LHCII apoproteins. When the availability of Chl ais limited, these apoproteins compete with one another for Chla, with the resultant preferential formation of CP1 and CPa.However, when the supply of Chl a becomes large enough for saturationof apoproteins of CP1 and CPa, some of the Chl a is incorporatedinto LHCII apoproteins either directly or after conversion toChl b. Thus, the formation of different Chl-protein complexes(CPs) is regulated by the relative rates of synthesis of Chla and apoproteins and by differential affinities of the apoproteinsfor Chl a. ⁴Present address: Kyowa Hakko Co., Ltd., 4041, Ami-machi, Inashiki,Ibaraki, 300-03 Japan (Received September 14, 1989; Accepted April 26, 1990)     

Effect of Light on Alkaloid Accumulation in Cell Cultures of Nicotiana Species

The effect of light on alkaloid accumulation in a range of cellcultures of tobacco was determined. Cell suspension culturesof Nicoriana rabacwn L. cv. Wisconsin-38 with differing degreesof photosynthetic activity, callus cultures of N. glauca Graham,root cultures of N. rustica L. and shoot cultures of N. tabacumwere used. The alkaloid content of green illuminated cultureswas greatly reduced compared with non-green cultures grown inthe dark, but decreased accumulation did not correlate withincreasing photosynthetic activity. The accumulation of allof the major alkaloids was affected, regardless of the speciesof tobacco used. Transfer of N. glauca callus from the darkinto the light caused a decrease in alkaloid accumulation, whilemoving cultures from the light into the dark resulted in anincrease in alkaloid content. In root cultures light causeda reduction in growth, which affected alkaloid synthesis. Inshoot cultures there were only traces of alkaloid detectable,regardless of whether or not cultures were illuminated. Lightappeared to cause a non-photosynthetic suppression of alkaloidaccumulation in visibly undifferentiated cultures, and thiseffect was modified in visibly differentiated cultures. Key words: Nicoriana spp, tobacco, alkaloid accumulation, cell culture     

The Accumulation of Protochlorophyllide in Cells of Synechocystis PCC 6714 with a Low PSI/PSII Stoichiometry

Changes in intracellular levels of Chl a precursors were examinedin relation to changes in the PSI/PSII stoichiometry in thecyanophyte Synechocystis PCC 6714. Protochlorophyllide (Pchlide)accumulated markedly in cells with a low PSI/PSII stoichiometrygrown under light that is absorbed by Chl a (PSI light) whereasno accumulation occurred in cells with a high PSI/PSII stoichiometrygrown under light absorbed by phycobilisomes (PSII light). Levelsof Pchlide in cells grown under PSI light decreased rapidlyupon a shift to PSII light. The rapid decrease in Pchlide accompanieda transient increase in chlorophyllide a, indicating that reductionof Pchlide was enhanced by shift to PSII light. The action spectrumindicated that the Pchlide decrease upon the shift to PSII lightdepended on excitation of Pchlide, suggesting that the accumulationof Pchllide was due to limited excitation of Pchlide, so thatPchlide photoreduction, under PSI light. However, comparisonof levels of Pchlide and the photosystem complexes in wild-typePlectonema boryanum with those in a mutant that lacked the darkPchlide reductase (YFC 1004) indicated that dark reduction compensatedfor the limited photoreduction under PSI light. Similar compensationby dark reduction was confirmed with Synechocystis PCC 6714.In cultures of Synechocystis under conditions where Pchlidecould not be photoreduced, accumulation of Pchlide and low PSI/PSIIstoichiometry occurred only when cells were illuminated withlight that preferentially excited PSI. The results indicatethat the low PSI/PSII stoichiometry in cells grown under PSIlight is not a result of inefficient synthesis of Chl a witha reduced rate of Pchlide photoreduction. They suggest furtherthat accumulation of Pchlide under PSI light results from retardationof the Chl a synthesis due to suppression of PSI synthesis. ¹Present address: Tsurukawa 5-15-11, Machida, Tokyo, 195 Japan.     

Inhibition of chlorophyll biosynthesis at the protochlorophyllide reduction step results in the parallel depletion of Photosystem I and Photosystem II in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC 6803

In most oxygenic phototrophs, including cyanobacteria, two independent enzymes catalyze the reduction of protochlorophyllide to chlorophyllide, which is the penultimate step in chlorophyll (Chl) biosynthesis. One is light-dependent NADPH:protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (LPOR) and the second type is dark-operative protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (DPOR). To clarify the roles of both enzymes, we assessed synthesis and accumulation of Chl-binding proteins in mutants of cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC 6803 that either completely lack LPOR or possess low levels of the active enzyme due to its ectopic regulatable expression. The LPOR-less mutant grew photoautotrophically in moderate light and contained a maximum of 20 % of the wild-type (WT) Chl level. Both Photosystem II (PSII) and Photosystem I (PSI) were reduced to the same degree. Accumulation of PSII was mostly limited by the synthesis of antennae CP43 and especially CP47 as indicated by the accumulation of reaction center assembly complexes. The phenotype of the LPOR-less mutant was comparable to the strain lacking DPOR that also contained <25 % of the wild-type level of PSII and PSI when cultivated under light-activated heterotrophic growth conditions. However, in the latter case, we detected no reaction center assembly complexes, indicating that synthesis was almost completely inhibited for all Chl-proteins, including the D1 and D2 proteins.     

Discovery of the first light‐dependent protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase in anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria

In all photosynthetic organisms, chlorophylls function as light‐absorbing photopigments allowing the efficient harvesting of light energy. Chlorophyll biosynthesis recurs in similar ways in anoxygenic phototrophic proteobacteria as well as oxygenic phototrophic cyanobacteria and plants. Here, the biocatalytic conversion of protochlorophyllide to chlorophyllide is catalysed by evolutionary and structurally distinct protochlorophyllide reductases (PORs) in anoxygenic and oxygenic phototrophs. It is commonly assumed that anoxygenic phototrophs only contain oxygen‐sensitive dark‐operative PORs (DPORs), which catalyse protochlorophyllide reduction independent of the presence of light. In contrast, oxygenic phototrophs additionally (or exclusively) possess oxygen‐insensitive but light‐dependent PORs (LPORs). Based on this observation it was suggested that light‐dependent protochlorophyllide reduction first emerged as a consequence of increased atmospheric oxygen levels caused by oxygenic photosynthesis in cyanobacteria. Here, we provide experimental evidence for the presence of an LPOR in the anoxygenic phototrophic α‐proteobacterium Dinoroseobacter shibae DFL12^T. In vitro and in vivo functional assays unequivocally prove light‐dependent protochlorophyllide reduction by this enzyme and reveal that LPORs are not restricted to cyanobacteria and plants. Sequence‐based phylogenetic analyses reconcile our findings with current hypotheses about the evolution of LPORs by suggesting that the light‐dependent enzyme of D. shibae DFL12^T might have been obtained from cyanobacteria by horizontal gene transfer.     

Temperature inducible protochlorophyllide reduction in darkness in a pigment mutant of Scenedesmus obliquus

Accumulation of chlorophyll and protochlorophyllide (PChlide) was followed during beterotrophic growth of the pigment mutant C-2A' of Scenedesmus obliquus L. in the darkness at 30 and 20°C. At 30°C the cells remained yellow with accumulation of protochlorophyllide, whereas they became green at 20°C with only traces of protochlorophyllide. The capacity of mutant cells to reduce PChlide to chlorophyllide (Chlide) in the dark with or without addition of 5-aminolevulinic acid as measured in isolated membranes, was high in cells grown at 20°C but negligible at 30°C. The high capacity to reduce PChlide created in cells growing at 20°C was only slightly diminished by exposure of cells to 38°C for 3 h. Mechanisms of temperature-sensitive chlorosis in algae and higher plants are discussed in relation to the results with pigment mutant C-2A' of Scenedesmus obliquus . It is assumed that either an activator of NADPH protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (EC 1.6.99.1) or a different enzyme system can be activated by lower temperature as by light.     

Protochlorophyllide b does not occur in barley etioplasts

Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) etioplasts were isolated, and the pigments were extracted with acetone. The extract was analyzed by HPLC. Only protochlorophyllide a and no protochlorophyllide b was detected (limit of detection < 1% of protochlorophyllide a). Protochlorophyllide b was synthesized starting from chlorophyll b and incubated with etioplast membranes and NADPH. In the light, photoconversion to chlorophyllide b was observed, apparently catalyzed by NADPH :protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase. In darkness, reduction of the analogue zinc protopheophorbide b to zinc 7-hydroxy-protopheophorbide a was observed, apparently catalyzed by chlorophyll b reductase. We conclude that protochlorophyllide b does not occur in detectable amounts in etioplasts, and even traces of it as the free pigment are metabolically unstable. Thus the direct experimental evidence contradicts the idea by Reinbothe et al. (Nature 397 (1999) 80-84) of a protochlorophyllide b-containing light-harvesting complex in barley etioplasts.