DNase I digestion reveals alternating asymmetrical protection of the nucleosome by the higher order chromatin structure

DNase I was used to probe the higher order chromatin structure in whole nuclei. The digestion profiles obtained were the result of single-stranded cuts and were independent of pH, type of divalent ion and chromatin repeat length. Furthermore, the protection from digestion of the DNA at the entry/exit points on the nucleosome was found to be caused not by the H1/H5 histone tails, but by the compact structure that these proteins support. In order to resolve symmetry ambiguities, DNase I digestion fragments over several nucleosome repeat lengths were analysed quantitatively and compared with computer simulations using combinations of the experimentally obtained rate constants (some of which were converted to 0 to simulate steric protection from DNase I digestion). A clear picture of precisely defined, alternating, asymmetrically protected nucleosomes emerged. The linker DNA is inside the fibre, while the nucleosomes are positioned above and below a helical path and/or with alternating orientation towards the dyad axis. The dinucleosomal modulation of the digestion patterns comes from alternate protection of cutting sites inside the nucleosome and not from alternating exposure to the enzyme of the linker DNA.     

On the occurrence of nucleosome phasing in chromatin.

We have found that DNAase I digestion of yeast, HeLa and chicken erythrocyte nuclei produces a pattern of DNA fragments spaced 10 bases apart and extending to at least 300 bases. This "extended ladder" of DNA fragments is most clearly seen with yeast, and least clearly with chicken erythrocytes. The appearance of regular and discrete bands at sizes much larger than the repeat size shows that the core particles (140 bp of DNA + H2A, H2B, H3 H4) in at least some fraction of chromatin are spaced in a particular fashion, by discrete lengths of spacer DNA, and not randomly. Based on the abundance of small repeats in yeast and from experiments with nucleosome oligomers, we conclude that the extended ladder and nucleosomal phasing probably arise mainly from regions in the chromatin in which nucleosome cores are closely packed or closely spaced (140-160 bp X n). Contributions from less closely packed but still accurately phased nucleosomes, however, cannot be entirely excluded.     

Organization of internucleosomal DNA in rat liver chromatin

A detailed analysis of the length distribution of DNA in nucleosome dimers trimmed with exonuclease III and S1 nuclease suggests that the previously described variation of internucleosomal distance in rat liver occurs, at least for a subset of the nucleosomes, by integral multiples of the helical repeat of the DNA. Results obtained upon digestion of chromatin with DNase II further suggest that lengths of internucleosomal DNA are integral multiples of the helical repeat of the DNA plus approximately 5 bp. Restraints imposed by these features on the arrangement of nucleosomes along the fiber are discussed.     

Regular arrangement of nucleosomes on 5S rRNA genes in Xenopus laevis.

The chromatin structure of the oocyte-type 5S RNA genes in Xenopus laevis was investigated. Blot hybridization analysis of DNA from micrococcal nuclease digests of erythrocyte nuclei showed that 5S DNA has the same average nucleosome repeat length, 192 +/- 4 base pairs, as two Xenopus satellite DNAs and bulk erythrocyte chromatin. The positions of nuclease-sensitive regions in the 5S DNA repeats of purified DNA and chromatin from erythrocytes were mapped by using an indirect end-labeling technique. Although most of the sites cleaved in purified DNA were also cleaved in chromatin, the patterns of intensities were strikingly different in the two cases. In 5S chromatin, three nuclease-sensitive regions were spaced approximately a nucleosome length apart, suggesting a single, regular arrangement of nucleosomes on most of the 5S DNA repeats. The observed nucleosome locations are discussed with respect to nucleotide sequences known to be important for expression of 5S RNA. Because the preferred locations appear to be reestablished in each repeating unit, despite spacer length heterogeneity, we suggest that the regular chromatin structure reflects the presence of a sequence-specific DNA-binding component on inactive 5S RNA genes.     

Comparative analysis of the nucleosomal structure of rye,wheat and their relatives

Analysis of the structure of chromatin in cereal species using micrococcal nuclease (MNase) cleavage showed nucleosomal organization and a ladder with typical nucleosomal spacing of 175–185 bp. Probing with a set of DNA probes localized in the authentic telomeres, subtelomeric regions and bulk chromatin revealed that these chromosomal regions have nucleosomal organization but differ in size of nucleosomes and rate of cleavage between both species and regions. Chromatin from Secale and Dasypyrum cleaved more quickly than that from wheat and barley, perhaps because of their higher content of repetitive sequences with hairpin structures accessible to MNase cleavage. In all species, the telomeric chromatin showed more rapid cleavage kinetics and a shorter nucleosome length (160 bp spacing) than bulk chromatin. Rye telomeric repeat arrays were shortest, ranging from 8 kb to 50 kb while those of wheat ranged from 15 kb up to 175 kb. A gradient of sensitivity to MNase was detected along rye chromosomes. The rye-specific subtelomeric sequences pSc200 and pSc250 have nucleosomes of two lengths, those of the telomeric and of bulk nucleosomes, indicating that the telomeric structure may extended into the chromosomes. More proximal sequences common to rye and wheat, the short tandem-repeat pSc119.2 and rDNA sequence pTa71, showed longer nucleosomal sizes characteristic of bulk chromatin in both species. A strictly defined spacing arrangement (phasing) of nucleosomes was demonstrated along arrays of tandem repeats with different monomer lengths (118, 350 and 550 bp) by combining MNase and restriction enzyme digestion.     

The small chromatin fragments released by micrococcal nuclease from hepatoma tissue cultured cell nuclei are strongly enriched in coding DNA sequences and are related to an actively transcribed single-stranded DNA fraction

It was shown with the use of specific probes that mild micrococcal nuclease digestion releases from chromatin actively-transcribed genes as small nucleosome oligomers. In the present work we demonstrate that most if not all of the active genes are accessible to the nuclease. It was found that the short released fragments are greatly enriched in transcribed DNA sequences, the most enriched being the dimers of nucleosomes since 35% of their DNA could be hybridized to cytoplasmic RNA. The results of cDNA-DNA hybridizations indicate that the monomers and dimers of nucleosomes contain most of the DNA sequences which encode poly(A⁺) RNAs, however larger released fragments include some transcribed sequences, while the nuclease-resistant chromatin is considerably impoverished in coding sites. These evidences and the finding that about 25% of the DNA from the dimers of nucleosomes are exclusively located in this class of fragments, tend to prove that the active chromatin regions are attacked in a non-random way by micrococcal nuclease. We have previously isolated, without using exogenous nuclease, an actively transcribed genomic fraction amounting to 1.5–2% of the total nuclear DNA, formed of single-stranded DNA. In the present study we show that all or nearly all the single-stranded DNA sequences could be reassociated with the DNA fragments present in the released monomers and dimers of nucleosomes. Our observations confirmed our previous finding that the greatest part of single-stranded DNA selectively originates from the coding strand of genomic DNA.     

The subunit structure of chromatin from Physarum polycephalum.

Nucleosome DNA repeat lengths in Physarum chromatin, determined by nuclease digestion experiments, are shorter than those observed in most mammalian chromatin and longer than those reported for chromatin of certain other lower eukaryotes. After digestion with staphylococcal nuclease for short periods of time an average repeat length of 190 base pairs is measured. After more extensive digestion an average repeat length of 172 base pairs is measured. Upon prolonged digestion DNA is degraded to an average monomer subunit length of 160 base pairs, with only a small amount of DNA found in lengths of 130 base pairs or smaller. Mathematical analysis of the data suggests that the Physarum nucleosome DNA repeat comprises a protected DNA segment of about 159 base pairs with a nuclease-accessible interconnecting segment which ranges from 13 to 31 base pairs. The spacing data are compatible with measurements from electron micrographs of Physarum chromatin.     

Topological analysis of plasmid chromatin from yeast and mammalian cells

Yeast has proven to be a powerful system for investigation of chromatin structure. However, the extent to which yeast chromatin can serve as a model for mammalian chromatin is limited by the significant number of differences that have been reported. To further investigate the structural relationship between the two chromatins, we have performed a DNA topological analysis of pRSSVO, a 5889 base-pair plasmid that can replicate in either yeast or mammalian cells. When grown in mammalian cells, pRSSVO contains an average of 33 negative supercoils, consistent with one nucleosome per 181 bp. This is close to the measured nucleosome repeat length of 190 bp. However, when grown in yeast cells, pRSSVO contains an average of only 23 negative supercoils, which is indicative of only one nucleosome per 256 bp. This is dramatically different from the measured nucleosome repeat length of 165 bp. To account for these observations, we suggest that yeast chromatin is composed of relatively short ordered arrays of nucleosomes with a repeat of 165 bp, separated by substantial gaps, possibly corresponding to regulatory regions.     

Deoxyribonuclease II as a probe for chromatin structure. I. Location of cleavage sites

DNAase II has been shown to cleave condensed mouse liver chromatin at 100-bp² intervals while chromatin in the extended form is cleaved at 200-bp intervals (Altenburger et al., 1976). Evidence is presented here that DNA digestion patterns of a half-nucleosomal periodicity are also obtained upon DNAase II digestion of chicken erythrocyte nuclei and yeast nuclei, both of which differ in their repeat lengths (210 and 165 bp) from mouse liver chromatin. In the digestion of mouse liver nuclei a shift from the 100-bp to the 200-bp cleavage mode takes place when the concentration of monovalent cations present during digestion is decreased below 1 mM. When soluble chromatin prepared by micrococcal nuclease is digested with DNAase II the same type of shift occurs, albeit at higher ionic strength.In order to map the positions of the DNAase II cleavage sites on the DNA relative to the positions of the nucleosome cores, the susceptibility of DNAase II-derived DNA termini to exonuclease III was investigated. In addition, oligonucleosome fractions from HaeIII and micrococcal nuclease digests were end-labelled with polynucleotide kinase and digested with DNAase II under conditions leading to 100 and 200-bp digestion patterns. Analysis of the chain lengths of the resulting radioactively labelled fragments together with the results of the exonuclease assay allow the following conclusions. In the 200-bp digestion mode, DNAase II cleaves exclusively in the internucleosomal linker region. Also in the 100-bp mode cleavage occurs initially in the linker region. Subsequently, DNAase II cleaves at intranucleosomal locations, which are not, however, in the centre of the nucleosome but instead around positions 20 and 125 of the DNA associated with the nucleosome core. At late stages of digestion intranucleosomal cuts predominate and linkers that are still intact are largely resistant to DNAase II due to interactions between adjacent nucleosomes. These findings offer an explanation for the sensitivity of DNAase II to the higher-order structure of chromatin.     

Nucleotide sequence-directed mapping of the nucleosomes

The concept of sequence-dependent deformational anisotropy of DNA proposed earlier is further elaborated and a computational procedure is developed for the sequence-directed mapping of the nucleosomes along chromatin DNA nucleotide sequences. The deformational anisotropy is found to be nonuniform along the molecule of the nucleosomal DNA, suggesting that the DNA superhelix in the nucleosome is slightly oval rather than circular in projection. The number of superhelical turns in the nucleosome core particle is estimated to be 2.0 +/- 0.2. Preliminary mapping of the nucleosomes in various chromatin DNA sequences yields the distribution of linker lengths which shows several minima separated by about 10 base-pairs. This is explained by sterical exclusion effects due to overlapping of the nucleosomes in space when some specific linker lengths are chosen. The mapping procedure described is tested by comparing its results with all the most accurate experimental mapping data reported so far. The comparison demonstrates that the exact positions of all the nucleosomes appear to be determined exclusively by the nucleotide sequences.     

Telomeric repeats act as nucleosome-disfavouring sequences in vivo

Telomeric DNAs consist of tandem repeats of G-clusters such as TTAGGG and TG_1-3, which are the human and yeast repeat sequences, respectively. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the telomeric repeats are non-nucleosomal, whereas in humans, they are organized in tightly packaged nucleosomes. However, previous in vitro studies revealed that the binding affinities of human and yeast telomeric repeat sequences to histone octamers in vitro were similar, which is apparently inconsistent with the differences in the human and yeast telomeric chromatin structures. To further investigate the relationship between telomeric sequences and chromatin structure, we examined the effect of telomeric repeats on the formation of positioned nucleosomes in vivo by indirect end-label mapping, primer extension mapping and nucleosome repeat analyses, using a defined minichromosome in yeast cells. We found that the human and yeast telomeric repeat sequences both disfavour nucleosome assembly and alter nucleosome positioning in the yeast minichromosome. We further demonstrated that the G-clusters in the telomeric repeats are required for the nucleosome-disfavouring properties. Thus, our results suggest that this inherent structural feature of the telomeric repeat sequences is involved in the functional dynamics of the telomeric chromatin structure.     

Signals in chicken beta-globin DNA influence chromatin assembly in vitro.

We have confirmed the result that chicken beta-globin gene chromatin, which possesses the characteristics of active chromatin in erythroid cells, has shortened internucleosome spacings compared with bulk chromatin or that of the ovalbumin gene, which is inactive. To understand how the short (approximately 180-bp) nucleosome repeat arises specifically on beta-globin DNA, we have studied chromatin assembly of cloned chicken beta-globin DNA in a defined in vitro system. With chicken erythrocyte core histones and linker histone H5 as the only cellular components, a cloned 6.2-kb chicken beta-globin DNA fragment assembled into chromatin possessing a regular 180 +/- 5-bp repeat, very similar to what is observed in erythroid cells. A 2-kb DNA subfragment containing the beta A gene and promoter region, but lacking the downstream intergenic region between the beta A and epsilon genes, failed to generate a regular nucleosome array in vitro, suggesting that the intergenic region facilitates linker histone-induced nucleosome alignment. When the beta A gene was placed on a plasmid that contained a known chromatin-organizing signal, nucleosome alignment with a 180-bp periodicity was restored, whereas nucleosomes on flanking plasmid sequences possessed a 210-bp spacing periodicity. Our results suggest that the shortened 180-bp nucleosome spacing periodicity observed in erythroid cells is encoded in the beta-globin DNA sequence and that nucleosome alignment by linker histones is facilitated by sequences in the beta A-epsilon intergenic region.     

Chromatin reconstituted from tandemly repeated cloned DNA fragments and core histones: a model system for study of higher order structure

We describe a model system for study of chromatin structure at levels above that of the nucleosome. A series of fragments with lengths ranging from 172 to 207 bp tandemly repeated three to greater than 50 times was prepared; each repeat contains the region important in forming a positioned core particle on a sea urchin 5S rRNA gene upon in vitro association with histones. The tandemly repeated sequences can be studied as linear DNA fragments or as relaxed or supercoiled circular molecules. A number of criteria indicate that nucleosomes position correctly on all the tandemly repeated elements. Measurement of the change in linking number per core particle led to a value of -1.0. Both length and repeat number dependent changes in conformation of the nucleoproteins are observed. We discuss the possibility that some ordered higher level chromatin structure can form with DNA and core histones alone.     

Comparison of the active and inactive chromatin structures of genes transcribed by RNA polymerases I and II

The coding sequences of the yeast 35S rDNA gene and of the yeast galactokinase gene both show clear staphylococcal nuclease nucleosome profiles under conditions in which the gene is inactive (galactokinase) or less active (rDNA). Under conditions of more active expression, the galactokinase gene shows marked smearing in the digestion profiles. The rDNA gene shows a qualitatively similar change in digestion patterns. There is a typical nucleosomal DNase I ladder on the coding sequences of both genes, regardless of the state of activity. In contrast to the coding sequences, the rDNA upstream region chromatin shows a nonnucleosomal profile. The nonnucleosomal character is more pronounced when the gene is more active. On the galactokinase upstream region chromatin, there is a nucleosomal structure, with some minor modifications, when the gene is inactive and a clear nonnucleosomal structure when the gene is expressed.