COLONY FORMATION IN AGAR: IN VITRO ASSAY FOR HAEMOPOIETIC STEM CELLS

Using a method in which embryo fibroblasts were used as feeder layers, the colony forming capacity in agar of a variety of mouse haemopoietic suspensions was compared with their CFU s content. A striking parallelism between the results of the two assays was found. In addition, under certain conditions higher numbers of CFU s could be retrieved from 5-day-old agar colonies than were originally plated, indicating that the CFC a (Colony Forming Cell agar) may fulfil the requirements of pluripotency as well as of self-renewal, both prerequisites for any haemopoietic stem cell candidate. Although our data by no means provide direct proof that the CFC s and the CFC a are identical, they certainly support such a concept. the contradictory findings by others that CFU s and CFU c (Colony Forming Unit culture) can be separated on a velocity gradient is attributed to different culture conditions, in other words, that their CFU cè are not identical with our CFU a .
Our findings also indicate that for mouse cells our soft agar colony assay meets the criteria of a quantitative assay for haemopoietic stem cells and that extension of this technique to bone marrow of primates including humans seems to be justified.     

ANALYSIS OF PROLIFERATION AND DIFFERENTIATION OF FOETAL GRANULOCYTE-MACROPHAGE PROGENITOR CELLS IN HAEMOPOIETIC TISSUE*

Analysis of in vitro colony formation in agar cultures of foetal haemopoietic tissues of eight mammalian species has shown that granulocyte-macrophage progenitor cells are present in foetal liver, yolk sac, marrow and spleen in numbers approaching the incidence in adult marrow. Such characteristics as buoyant density, growth rate and differentiation served to distinguish foetal from adult colony forming cells (CFCs). Cell cycle analysis performed by exposing haemopoietic cells to high doses of tritiated thymidine in vitro showed that foetal CFC proliferation in species of short gestation (rabbit, rat, mouse) approached or exceeded that observed in adult marrow. In contrast, in species of long gestation (human, monkey, calf, lamb, guinea-pig) a period of variable duration was observed when foetal liver CFCs entered a non-cycling G₀ or blocked G₁ phase. In these species foetal liver CFCs were found to be proliferating actively early in gestation and following the non-cycling phase again re-entered a proliferative state associated with onset of active granulopoiesis in foetal marrow and possible migration of CFC from liver to marrow. These results indicate the existence of granulocyte-macrophage progenitor populations displaying foetal characteristics and adapted to particular stages of haemopoietic development, a situation which closely parallels that reported for erythropoiesis.     

THE EFFECT OF CYTOSINE ARABINOSIDE IN VITRO ON AGAR COLONY FORMING CELLS AND SPLEEN COLONY FORMING CELLS OF C57BL MOUSE BONE MARROW

This study reports the effect of cytosine arabinoside in culture on two classes of bone marrow progenitor cells in C57BL mice, agar colony forming cells (ACU) and spleen colony forming cells (CFU). Both normal cells and rapidly proliferating cells were studied. The results show that in normal mice, 23 % of ACU but only 7 % of CFU are killed following 1 hr incubation with the drug. With longer periods of incubation, the survival of ACU in the controls is poor, and the results for the drug-treated cultures suggest that the cells are held up in cycle. In continuously irradiated mice, the proportion of ACU and CFU killed after 1 hr incubation with drug is increased to 43–54%, confirming previous results that these cells are proliferating more rapidly than in normal mice. In mice treated with myerlan, 54 % of ACU are killed by 1 hr in vitro exposure to cytosine arabinoside, again confirming that ACU are rapidly proliferating. However, the proportion of CFU killed is lower (23 %). These results are compared with other studies of the effect of cytosine arabinoside in vivo and also with thymidine suicide in the same strain of mice. The results show that cytosine arabinoside has the same effect as tritiated thymidine, and also that the proportion of CFU killed by these agents in vitro is lower than when the agents are injected in vivo. It is suggested that the conditions in culture have an adverse effect on CFU, which cease DNA synthesis, and are protected from the killing effect of cytosine arabinoside and tritiated thymidine. Since cytosine arabinoside in vitro has an effect similar to tritiated thymidine in vitro on bone marrow progenitor cells in C57BL mice, in vitro incubation with cytosine arabinoside could be an alternative method to thymidine suicide for measuring differences in cell proliferation rate.     

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE REPOPULATING POTENTIAL OF GRAFTS FROM VARIOUS HAEMOPOIETIC SOURCES: CFU REPOPULATION

The growth rate of the CFU populations in spleens and femora has been studied in irradiated mice injected with cell suspensions, containing equivalent number of CFU, from various sources. The doubling times are shown to be dependent upon the source of the cells. Grafts of bone marrow, spleen and foetal liver cells produced doubling times in the spleen of approximately 25, 19 and 16 hr respectively. Grafts of marrow-derived and spleen-derived spleen colony cells both gave rise to CFU doubling times lower than those of the corresponding primary grafts (approx. 33 and 26 hr respectively in the spleen). In the case of both bone marrow and spleen grafts the CFU population growth was shown to be independent of the size of the graft. A hypothesis is advanced which invokes at least a dual population of CFU, having different doubling times, different seeding capacities in the haemopoietic tissues following i.v. injection and present in different proportions in the various haemopoietic tissues.     

The effect of carnosine on hematopoietic stem cell activity in irradiated animals]

Carnosine given to adult animals together with potable water one day prior to gamma-irradiation or injected in a single intraperitoneal dose one hour after irradiation enhances colony formation by haemopoietic stem cells migrating from the bone marrow to the spleen. In young animals with a high colony-forming activity carnosine either decreases or does not influence at all the efficiency of colony production.     

Effects of human leukocyte conditioned medium on mouse haemopoietic progenitor cells.

Medium conditioned by human peripheral blood leukocytes (HLCM) was studied for its in vitro effects on haemopoietic progenitor cells (CFU-s and CFU-c) present in mouse bone marrow. HLCM has poor colony stimulating activity in semi-solid cultures of mouse bone marrow cells, but invariably increases the number of colonies obtained in the presence of plateau levels of semi-purified colony stimulating factor (CSF). In liquid cultures, HLCM appears to contain a potent initiator of DNA synthesis in CFU-s, an activity which coincides with an increased CFU-s maintenance and causes a three- to four-fold increase in CFU-c number. It is apparent from this study that HLCM, in addition to stimulating colony formation in cultures of human bone marrow cells, has a profound in vitro effect on primitive haemopoietic progenitor cells of the mouse, which cannot be attributed to CSF.     

Potentiation of bone marrow colony growth in vitro by the addition of lymphoid or bone marrow cells

Colony formation and growth in vitro by C57B1 mouse bone marrow cells were analysed following stimulation by a standard dose of serum colony stimulating factor. Under restricted conditions, colony crowding was observed to potentiate colony growth rates. The addition of thymic or lymph node lymphoid cells or nonviable bone marrow cells also potentiated colony growth. Extensive reutilisation of nuclear material by bone marrow colony cells was observed when labeled lymphoid and bone marrow cells were added to the culture system. The results provide evidence that lymphocytes can exert trephocytic effects on proliferating hematopoietic cells.     

MOBILIZATION OF HAEMOPOIETIC STEM CELLS (CFU) INTO THE PERIPHERAL BLOOD OF THE MOUSE; EFFECTS OF ENDOTOXIN AND OTHER COMPOUNDS

Factors affecting the circulation of haemopoietic stem cells (CFU) in the peripheral blood of mice were investigated. I.v. injection of sublethal doses of endotoxin, trypsin and proteinase appeared to raise the number of CFU per ml blood from about 30–40 to about 300–400 or more within 10 min. The effect was smaller when smaller doses of the substances were injected. After this initial rise the number of circulating cells returned to normal in a few hours. Following endotoxin there was a second rise which started 2–3 days after injection and attained a peak on the 6th–7th day. The first rise is explained as a mobilization of stem cells from their normal microenvironments into the blood stream; the second rise is considered to reflect proliferation of CFUs in the haemopoietic tissues. The spleen seems to be acting as an organ capturing CFUs from the blood and not as a source adding stem cells to the blood.
The early mobilization of CFU after endotoxin injection did not coincide with a mobilization of neutrophils. The number of circulating band cells was increased during the first hours.
The importance of 'open sites'in the haemopoietic tissue for capturing CFUs was studied by emptying these sites through a lethal X-irradiation and injecting normal bone marrow cells. When a greater number of syngeneic bone marrow cells was injected intravenously, the level of circulating CFU in irradiated mice was slightly lower than the level in unirradiated mice during the first hours.     

KINETIC PROPERTIES OF HAEMOPOIETIC STEM CELLS

A comparison of the exocolonizing and autorepopulating tests for haemopoietic stem-cell assay indicate that the ‘overshoot’in splenic colony formation, observed 12–14 days after 150 rad total-body radiation (TBR), only occurs with the auto-repopulation assay. The explanation is that the priming dose of 150 rad increases the absolute seeding rate of stem cells from the marrow. A seeding rate significantly greater than normal can ‘take’only if the spleen is available—it can expand and accommodate stem cells while the bone marrow cannot. If, however, the absolute number of colony-forming cells are decreased in the femur, a relative increase in seeding rate can take place even in the splenectomized animal. Evidence is presented concerning the different turnover states of exo- and autorepopulating stem cells (CFU) and those responsible for erythropoietic response (ERC), and the precursors of agar colony-formers.     

EFFECTS OF HUMAN LEUKOCYTE CONDITIONED MEDIUM ON MOUSE HAEMOPOIETIC PROGENITOR CELLS

Medium conditioned by human peripheral blood leukocytes (HLCM) was studied for its in vitro effects on haemopoietic progenitor cells (CFU-s and CFU-c) present in mouse bone marrow. HLCM has poor colony stimulating activity in semi-solid cultures of mouse bone marrow cells. but invariably increases the number of colonies obtained in the presence of plateau levels of semi-purified colony stimulating factor (CSF). In liquid cultures, HLCM appears to contain a potent initiator of DNA synthesis in CFU-s. an activity which coincides with an increased CFU-s maintenance and causes a three- to four-fold increase in CFU-c number. It is apparent from this study that HLCM, in addition to stimulating colony formation in cultures of human bone marrow cells, has a profound in vitro effect on primitive haemopoietic progenitor cells of the mouse, which cannot be attributed to CSF.     

Age dependence of the number of the stem cells in haemopoietic tissues of rats.

The number and concentration of haemopoietic stem cells in the femoral bone marrow and spleen of Wistar rats of different ages were investigated. Stem cells were assayed by the spleen colony technique in irradiated rat recipients. The ability of the recipient spleen to harvest transplanted tissue as a macroscopic colony was found to be dependent on the recipient's age. Changes with senescence were observed also in the concentration and the size of the stem cell compartment both in the marrow and spleen. No differences were demonstrated in the seeding of transplanted colony-forming units into the spleen of recipients of 1 and 4 months of age. A rats-mice strain difference in the effect of senescence on the haemopoietic stem cells is discussed.     

UV survival of human mycoplasmas: evidence of dark reactivation in Mycoplasma buccale.

The inactivation by ultraviolet (UV) light irradiation of mycoplasma cells of five human strains was monitored by investigating the colony-forming ability. The survival curves of five strains tested indicated that the cells of Mycoplasma buccale only are single and homogenously susceptible to UV light. The effect of the repair inhibitor, caffeine, on the colony-forming ability of UV-irradiated cells was investigated with M. buccale because of its homogenous susceptibility to UV light. The colony formation of irradiated cells was markedly depressed by post-irradiation treatment with caffeine at concentrations that had little or no effect on the colony formation of unirradiated cells. The colony-forming units (CFU) of UV-irradiated cells which were kept in broth without caffeine in the dark increased without a lag as the time in the dark increased. The colony-forming ability of the irradiated cells completely recovered after 3 hr in the dark. However, when irradiated cells were kept in the presence of caffeine, no increase in their CFU was observed. The mode of action of caffeine on UV-irradiated cells closely resembles that described for other organisms which possess dark reactivation systems for UV-induced damage in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). Thus, the results obtained provide evidence for the existence of a dark repair function in M. buccale.     

AGE DEPENDENCE OF THE NUMBER OF THE STEM CELLS IN HAEMOPOIETIC TISSUES OF RATS

The number and concentration of haemopoietic stem cells in the femoral bone marrow and spleen of Wistar rats of different ages were investigated. Stem cells were assayed by the spleen colony technique in irradiated rat recipients. The ability of the recipient spleen to harvest transplanted tissue as a macroscopic colony was found to be dependent on the recipient's age. Changes with senescence were observed also in the concentration and the size of the stem cell compartment both in the marrow and spleen. No differences were demonstrated in the seeding of transplanted colony-forming units into the spleen of recipients of 1 and 4 months of age. A rats-mice strain difference in the effect of senescence on the haemopoietic stem cells is discussed.     

SELF-MAINTENANCE ABILITY AND KINETICS OF HAEMOPOIETIC STROMA PRECURSORS

The use of repeated femoral curettages and repeated passages of ectopic haemopoietic foci has demonstrated the capacity of stromal precursor cells for repeated formation of haemopoietic microenvironment. During this process the stromal precursors undergo no less than ten to twelve mitoses. Precursors of bone marrow stroma proliferating slowly, if at all, in normal mice are triggered into cell cycle, as revealed by suicide methods, during formation of the ectopic haemopoietic focus.     

Mechanisms of haemopoietic stem cell proliferation control

The control of stem cell (CFU-S) proliferation is mediated by short-range acting factors which can be detected by the proliferation modifying activities present in media conditioned by haemopoietic cells. A specific inhibitor of stem cell proliferation is obtained from haemopoietic tissue containing minimally proliferating CFU-S, whilst stimulatory material is obtained from cell suspensions containing rapidly proliferating CFU-S. Used competitively, these factors, which are detected in different molecular weight range fractions, manipulate the rate of CFU-S proliferation in a manner compatible with a physiological control mechanism. In addition, a long-term bone marrow culture system has been shown to provide an in vitro model of stem cell control. Fractionation of cell populations from haemopoietic tissues reveals marked concentration differences of the CFU-S proliferation modifying activities depending on the proliferative state of the CFU-S. However, irrespective of whether the tissue contains stem cells that are actively or minimally proliferating, both stimulatory and inhibitory activities are detected. From dose-response studies it is concluded that stem cell proliferation is controlled by an appropriate balance of stimulatory and inhibitory factors which, however, are not produced by the stem cells themselves.     

Chemical radioprotection of hemopoietic colony-forming cells: comparative effect of AET, anoxia, and urethan

The bone marrow colony-forming unit (CFU) technique of Till and McCulloch was employed to test the radioprotective effect of AET, anoxia, urethan on marrow cells irradiated in vivo. For AET and anoxia, a dose-reduction factor of 1.9 to 2.1 was found. Since the marrow cells were assayed for CFU content immediately after irradiation of the donor, the observed effect can be interpreted as a "true" radiation dose reduction. By contrast, urethan injection did not increase the survival of marrow CFU assayed immediately after whole-body x-irradiation. However, both urethan and AET afforded radioprotection of endogenous CFU content of spleen and bone marrow, but not of endogenous spleen colony count. It is concluded that the mechanism of radioprotection by urethan is fundamentally different from that of AET or anoxia.     

Blast colony-forming cell binding from CML bone marrow, or blood, on stromal layers pretreated with G-CSF or SCF

Blast colony-forming cells (CFU-BL) represent a specific subpopulation of special primitive progenitors characterized by colony formation only in close contact with a preformed stromal layer. CFU-BL derived from bone marrow of chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) patients have been proved to adhere poorly to bone marrow derived stromal layers suggesting that the appearance of progenitors and precursors in the circulation is due to a defective adhesion of these cells to the bone marrow microenvironment. In the present experiments the effect of short-term incubation of preformed normal bone marrow stroma on the adherence of CML derived CFU-BL was studied. For stroma cultures bone marrow cells were cultured in microplates in the presence of hydrocortisone. Cultures were used when stromal layers became confluent and no sign of haemopoiesis could be observed. CFU-BL were studied by panning plastic non-adherent mononuclear (PNAMNC) bone marrow or blood cells. 8.9 +/- 2.4 colonies/103 PNAMNC (six experiments) were formed from normal bone marrow on stromal layers and 4.8 +/- 2.1 colonies/103 PNAMNC (five experiments) from CML bone marrow. Colony formation from normal bone marrow was not increased if stromal layers were incubated with 100 ng/mL granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF) or stem cell factor (SCF). Incubation of stroma with G-CSF or SCF, however, increased the colony formation of PNAMNC from CML bone marrow or blood significantly. These findings suggest that local concentration of haemopoietic growth factors at the time of panning may influence the attachment of CML progenitors to the stroma.     

A Method For Measuring the Generation Time and Length of Dna Synthesizing Phase of Clonogenic Cells In A Heterogenous Population

Information on the cell cycle of progenitor cells in haemopoietic tissue is useful for understanding population control under physiological and abnormal conditions. Unfortunately, methods that have been developed for measuring cell cycle parameters are applicable only to cells of homogenous populations and not to morphologically non-recognizable progenitor cells such as colony forming units (CFU) that are present at low frequency in a heterogenous population. to circumvent this difficulty, a method was developed to measure CFU cell cycle parameters based on specific killing of cells in S phase by [³H]thymidine ([³H]TdR). This was done by estimating the number of CFU killed following exposure of the cell suspension to [³H]TdR for various time periods. Since cycling CFU are continuously entering S phase, a linear curve relating the percentage CFU-kill to the length of exposure of the cells to [³H]TdR in culture can be obtained. the slope of the curve (percentage kill/hr) indicates the rate that CFU enter the S phase and travel through the cell cycle. the inverse of this value will then represent a time period for CFU to move through a complete cell cycle (generation time). the length of S phase can then be obtained by multiplying generation time by the fraction of cells in S phase at time zero. This method has been used to measure generation time and length of S phase of three kinds of haemopoietic progenitor cells: mouse granulocyte-macrophage CFU, human T lymphocyte CFU and CFU from regenerating mouse spleens. This method should be applicable to any normal or neoplastic clonogenic cell populations and the latter could be either of haematological or of solid tumour origin.     

Haemopoiesis in mice genetically lacking granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor during chronic infection with Mycobacterium avium

In order to test the role of granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) in haemopoiesis during chronic infection, mice with a targeted disruption of the gene for GM-CSF were infected intraperitoneally with the facultative intracellular pathogen, Mycobacterium avium. The bacteria spread to lungs, liver and spleen and persisted for more than 10 weeks at levels between 105 and 106 CFU. Bacterial numbers did not differ significantly between infected GM-CSF-/- and wild-type mice, making this an excellent model in which to study the effects of GM-CSF deficiency on haemopoietic cells without complications of interpretation relating to differences in bacterial load. Haemopoietic colony forming cells (CFC) in the bone marrow of GM-CSF-/- mice before infection were not different from wild-type. However, whereas CFC in wild-type mice increased 1.5-fold with infection, GM-CSF-/- mice were unable to increase their CFC and numbers were significantly lower than in infected wild-type mice. Cells attracted to the peritoneal cavity of the GM-CSF-/- mice following i.p. injection of bacteria were notably lacking in the large, granular macrophages of activated appearance, which were a feature in wild-type mice. Nitric oxide production by peritoneal cells from GM-CSF-/- mice was deficient. Thus, GM-CSF is not critical for haemopoiesis during chronic infection, but in its absence the mice are unable to increase their output of haemopoietic cells and there are deficiencies in macrophage activation.     

REGULATION OF HUMAN MYELOPOIESIS BY PROSTAGLANDIN E AND LACTOFERRIN

Studies on human myeloid stem cell proliferation indicate that progenitor cell populations committed to monocytoid differentiation are preferentially inhibited by prostaglandin E (PGE). the addition of PGE but not PGF to day 7 CFU_GM cultures upon initiation results in the dose-dependent inhibition of total colony and cluster formation. Morpholigical analysis of proliferating clones demonstrates that the effect of PGE on total colony and cluster formation results from the selective inhibition of monocyte-macrophage colony forming cells. Mixed monocytoid/neutrophil colony formation was markedly less sensitive and neutrophil and eosinophil colony formation essentially insensitive to the inhibitory effects of PGE. the inhibition of monocytoid colony formation by PGE₁ extends equally well to day 13 CFU_GM, but not to CFU_GM in suspension culture. the observed effects of PGE₁ on monocytoid committed pre-CFU_GM and day 7 and day 14 CFU_GM indicate that sensitivity to inhibition by PGE increases with progenitor cell maturity. Specificity analysis indicates that prostaglandins of the E series (PGE₁, PGE₂) are by far the most active naturally occurring prostanoate compounds inhibiting CFU_GM proliferation. The addition of iron saturated lactoferrin to liquid cultures of human peripheral blood monocytes, inclusion into mononuclear cell feeder layers or addition to agar cultures proliferating in response to endogenously produced CSFs, results in the equivalent inhibition of CSFs necessary for day 7 and day 14 monocytoid and/or neutrophil and eosinophil colony and cluster formation. These results indicate roles for PGE and lactoferrin in myeloid stem cell regulation in vitro and suggest that they may serve as physiological regulators of granulocyte and monocyte proliferation.